8 ms·
EV shipping is set to blow internal combustion engines out of the water
- rkagerer 4y agoAny downsides?
- slt2021 4y agoimagine how many batteries are needed to move huge container ship. now imagine these batteries catching fire, just like Teslas routinely do. I dont want to be on that container ship
- askvictor 4y agoimagine how much fuel oil is needed to move huge container ship. now imagine this fuel catching fire, just like ICE cars routinely do. I dont want to be on that container ship
- bpodgursky 4y agoI mean, oil tankers also routinely catch fire, it's not exactly headline news.
- midoridensha 4y agoYes, but it's not a big deal if an oil tanker, or any other oil-powered ship catches fire. However, it's possible that a battery-powered ship could catch fire, so we need to avoid this technology and stick with oil. /s
- kcplate 4y agoLet’s just agree that being on any container ship that is on fire isn’t an optimal situation.
- askvictor 4y agoIndeed. Energy sometimes escapes its confines. This usually results in fire. The failure modes of EV batteries are probably quite different to those on ships (ships don't collide with other things nearly as often as cars collide with other things, for one). I'm sure ships have their own issues (e.g. falling into disrepair due to lax regulation requirements at the lowest-priced-ports-of-convenience), but you can't really compare an EV ship with an EV car.
- p1necone 4y ago> Teslas routinely do Isn't this just FUD? A quick google tells me that ICE cars catch fire much more often than electric vehicles do. Although I have no idea how often container ships catch fire.
- slt2021 4y agothe danger of EV is spontaneous fire. It needs only one faulty battery cell to short due to abuse/overcharge and lead to runaway reaction and burning of the whole thing down. Imagine you are sleeping at your house, parked your EV in garage and it catches fire and burns your whole house down. https://www.businessinsider.com/couples-tesla-caught-fire-charging-overnight-caused-a-house-fire-2021-8 https://www.businessinsider.com/couples-tesla-caught-fire-ch...
- morepork 4y agoYou mean just like can happen in an ICE car? https://edition.cnn.com/2022/02/08/business/hyundai-kia-fire-recall/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2022/02/08/business/hyundai-kia-fire...
- slt2021 4y agoelectric short is applicable to any electronics, not ICE specifically. ICE engine itself is old and proven tech
- lelanthran 4y agoThat's an electrical fire. ICE engines rarely spontaneously combust when parked in your garage. In fact, I cannot think of it ever happening. The most recent thing that matches your perception was a Ford model that was know for catching fire when overheating. It made news precisely because it is so rare.
- lelanthran 4y ago> Isn't this just FUD? A quick google tells me that ICE cars catch fire much more often than electric vehicles do. Although I have no idea how often container ships catch fire. No, the FUD is actually the other way around - fires in ICE models are always found to be electrical faults. The only exception I can think of is the Ford Kuga from 2019 or so; and even then, it was down to manufacturing/design defect in the turbo, not the engine itself.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoHow often do LiFePO4 cars catch fire?
- carapace 4y agoThis went by last week: "High-end magnets contain illegal rare earths from ravaged Myanmar valleys" (globalwitness.org) https://www.globalwitness.org/en/campaigns/natural-resource-governance/myanmars-poisoned-mountains/ https://www.globalwitness.org/en/campaigns/natural-resource-... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32489998 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32489998
- swader999 4y agoLot of copper
- m3kw9 4y agoProb need huge infrastructure changes because you need to charge the thing or swap batteries
- fy20 4y agoI imagine these being charged by a bunch of diesel generators at the port, as it is cheaper than upgrading power infrastructure to supply that much power...
- ReactiveJelly 4y agoImagine putting the batteries in shipping containers and just using the existing cranes to swap them around Edit: Probably wouldn't happen though. I feel like if swapping was gonna work, it would be done in smaller vehicles already
- XorNot 4y agoIts not really analogous though: smaller vehicles are dominated by aerodynamic concerns, and otherwise a cargo profile that's totally different (people). Whereas ships are dominated by the cargo profile: shipping containers.
- chrjxnandns 4y ago
- geenew 4y agoYour first point is a good one, these ships base at locations specifically designed for transferring heavy loads. Adding battery swapping to the to-do list at container ports does not seem unreasonable at all. To your second point, let it always be remembered that the first electric busses, from the early 20th century, used a battery swap system. It can be done, especially on industrial vehicles. Personally I don’t understand why it isn’t being done today for electrified bus networks. https://historicengland.org.uk/listing/the-list/list-entry/1423929?section=official-list-entry https://historicengland.org.uk/listing/the-list/list-entry/1...
- 4y ago
- elevaet 4y ago> The average cost of lithium-ion batteries has plummeted 89% since 2010, and is expected to reach $50 per kWh in the near future. Assuming a battery cost of $100 per kWh, the TCP for a battery-electric containership is already lower than that of an ICE equivalent, for routes less than 1,000km. And when battery prices reach $50 per kWh, which is predicted for the near future, electrified ships will be cost-effective on routes as long as 5,000km. This was the nugget for me. Big if true, as they say.
- akira2501 4y agoCost of maintenance and expected depletion as a function of vessel lifetime is most relevant, an ICE engine itself lasts for a very long time and marine engines have special maintenance features that allow you to repair and run them simultaneously. It's also not entirely clear if these figures consider "utility power" which is a major function of any container ship that's going to haul refrigerated or frozen cargo. The main engine is a major source of electrical power on board, but there are also usually several large electrical generators on board to satisfy the demand of these types of containers.
- nazgulnarsil 4y agoit's not binary. We'll likely start seeing hybrids that follow the cost curve down while scaling up battery capacity.
- tablespoon 4y ago> it's not binary. We'll likely start seeing hybrids that follow the cost curve down while scaling up battery capacity. Do hybrids make any sense at all if you're mostly operating at a constant load, like I imagine container-ships do? It's not like they're stuck in stop and start traffic across the Pacific.
- kthejoker2 4y agoThey (well, oil tankers at least) actually do spend a significant time lightering, idling, "in traffic" in canals, ports, some key "merge lanes" like Azores, Singapore straits, etc.
- akamaka 4y agoOriginal paper was posted to HN last month. Here’s the thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32159891 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32159891
- Incipient 4y agoWith the amount of lithium required in batteries for ships, and the issues with recycling them, is green hydrogen/synthetic fuel not a better option overall? Or are these options too expensive?
- radium3d 4y agoMaybe we need smaller hydrofoil container ships
- nradov 4y agoWell Boundary Layer Technologies (a Y Combinator portfolio company) is working on that. But it will never be more than a small niche market for high-value, time-sensitive cargoes. https://www.boundarylayer.tech/ https://www.boundarylayer.tech/
- antisthenes 4y ago> small niche market for high-value, time-sensitive cargoes. You mean air freight, right?
- nradov 4y agoThey're aiming for the niche market that's slower than air freight but faster than displacement hull cargo ships. Not sure if that market is really large enough for a viable business, but we'll see.
- stephen_g 4y agoYeah, shipping does seem to be one of the main applications where green hydrogen actually makes sense. Battery chemistry should improve to the point where basically no road transport should need anything else over the next 20 years (we're basically already there for most car applications, still some improvement needed for trucking etc., although maybe battery swaps is a better model there anyway). Ships need huge amounts of energy, but have the space to deal with hydrogen's poor volumetric density, unlike aviation, where I think synthetic fuel is a better option.
- imwillofficial 4y agoUntil they get lithium production pollution under control, I just can’t get behind it.
- danielheath 4y agoWait until you find out about bunker oil pollution!
- imwillofficial 4y agoNot even close
- knownjorbist 4y agoYeah, lithium mining is not even in the same ballpark as bunker fuel used to power large cargo vessels.
- imwillofficial 4y agoYou’re right, but not the way you think. 10 oil spills from massive tankers don’t even begin to match one lithium mine for one week. It’s insaneX and disastrous, and largely ignored.
- goldforever 4y ago
- panick21_ 4y agoWhat are you talking about? Most lithium either comes from conventional mining in Australia or from underground salt water in deserts that is evaporated. The first is no more polluting then any other type of mining. The second can cause some problems but I would call it polluting. So what are you actually referring to?
- imwillofficial 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- evilos 4y agoThe 5000km range barge needs a 6.5 GWhr battery, which is the equivalent of 130,000 base range model 3s. That's a lot of batteries. Not sure if that much industrial capacity will be available soon enough. Also, I'd really really hate to be the person that has to fight a marine fire on board the 6.5 GWhr battery barge.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jl6 4y agoWould it be a lot worse than a ship storing the equivalent energy in combustible liquid fuel?
- isatty 4y agoYes, lithium fires are a LOT worse.
- rootusrootus 4y agoLithium ion, sure. There are other chemistries, such as LFP, where thermal events aren't nearly as exciting.
- chickenuggies69 4y agoA container ship would use the equivalent of 641825 BMW 3 series of fuel for that trip. Though one would use premium and the other bunker fuel. Math based on 2500 gallons per mile for a 3106 mile trip, converted to km and liters, then divided by a 55 liter tank.
- a9h74j 4y agoVideo of single passenger bus lithium battery fire: http://www.jimstoneindia.com/pagesq22022/page2v.html http://www.jimstoneindia.com/pagesq22022/page2v.html
- sandos 4y ago
- janef0421 4y agoThis seems to be quite a shallow analysis. Evaluating a technology for use at scale requires a whole-system analysis of the core material factors; Resource use, energy use, and labour. Price is insufficient and often irrelevant. Also, when trying to solve urgent problems like climate change, it is a bad idea to rely on projected technological developments and cost reductions that may materialise too late or never.
- jonnycomputer 4y agoConsidering how dirty the fuel used to power such ships is, this would be a boon indeed (discounting from whatever effects it might have on the cost and availability of resources required to electrify other parts of transportation, of course).
- sbaiddn 4y ago"But since even the most efficient internal combustion ship engines are no more than 50% efficient, a [...]" But how efficient are the coal, nuclear, or natural gas needed to charge the batteries? At best 60%? Was it mid 20s or mid 30s for PWR nukes? 50% thermal efficiency is insanely good. And the battery ship? To the 90% battery efficiency, knock a few trips through a transformer (95%) and power converter. So 0.6 * 0.95 * 0.95 * 0.9 - = 0.48% thermal efficiency By contrast shipping fuel is a waste product that is going to get made whether or not the ships sail (i.e. largely free to produce energetically). Talk to me about cleaning ships S emissions and Ill get excited. In the meantime put all those Li ion batteries into hybrid versions of Ford F350 and heavy trucks used by contractors. That will make a much larger dent in CO2 emissions.
- jamal-kumar 4y agoI think what is making these companies move towards other options is their bottom line - if they don't have to spend on fuel, why should they? (By the way a lot of what I've seen for the generation so far is in stuff like power-generating "sails" which are really interesting, so maybe not even relying on land sources)
- sbaiddn 4y agoThis isn't good for their bottom line. The efficiency of batteries is comparable to shipping oil at best, and electricity is rather expensive while shipping oil is almost free. Shipping oil is filthy, dirty, hard to use. To a good approximation one wants it. To a better approximation no one on land can use it because if its high S content precludes it from being used on land (illegal and you need something that can deal with high Sulphuric acid) Its a byproduct of the refinery that only shipping can use (they can and do burn straight diesel too). It is really very cheap. [1] Ban it, if you must. But without market shenanigans itll never be cheaper to use a massive battery. [1] without looking at the price, I wouldn't be surprised if its currently gone up in price. In Europe right now anyone who can burn it on shore is eyeing it and the EU has suspended many environment regulation. But thats a blip; once Germany's economy collapses the EU's energy needs will be much smaller
- 4y ago
- pengaru 4y agoIn a slow-moving ginormous long-distance vehicle the size of a modern container ship wouldn't redox flow batteries be an attractive option, which are already substantially cheaper by requiring less of those costly electrode materials?
- Gibbon1 4y agoI looked at that, the energy density seems too low. 10-20Wh/kg vs 260 for lithium ion batteries. For as the internet told me cargo ships carry 30 days worth of fuel. I think I figured flow batteries could power a cargo ship for a couple of days. Which isn't enough. Interesting idea though in that you could pump the two chemical solutions into the ship. Sail it to it's destination and then pump the used fluids out and replace them with fresh. And it's not a bomb like lithium ion batteries.
- pengaru 4y agoThere are some >20Wh/kg chemistries listed @ [0]. Zinc-bromine apparently is 60-85Wh/kg... [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flow_battery#Chemistries https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flow_battery#Chemistries
- kortex 4y agoI bet we are nowhere near the engineering limit of flow battery energy density. It is fairly limited in research compared to the various conventional battery technologies. I think a 5x increase in energy density over Vanadium redox (to 100-200 Wh/kg, 75 Wh/kg is achievable by some chemistries already) would put it in striking distance.
- dimtion 4y agoOn the flip side, the amount of materials, metals, and energy necessary to produce enough batteries to replace current fossil fuel usages, are order of magnitude larger than the current world production and known reserves. This presentation does ballpark analysis of the problem: https://youtu.be/MBVmnKuBocc https://youtu.be/MBVmnKuBocc Even if the numbers are off by an order of magnitude, them problem remains worrisome and difficult to solve at scale.
- a9h74j 4y ago+++ anything by Simon Michaux So far we have scaled to a few percent of what would need to be rebuilt every 20 years indefinitely.
- BlueTankEngine 4y agoThank you so much for linking this; this video is incredible.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoReplacing the entire fossil fuel system is a big job. But, the fact that this guy mentios the gold standard, criticizes the EU, the WEF, and talks about EROEI means he's mostly a conspiracy theorist. It's a repeated pattern to say "big numbers mean this is impossible!". Solar PV was impossible, Wind Power was impossible, EVs were impossible, on and on and on. His numbers aren't wrong as far as I can tell, but he's just repeating the same things that people who think it's a good idea are saying, then adding on the lie that "they never considered this, the fools, they'll doom us all". About 25 minutes in he reveals that we'll need to double our electricity production. Except we know that, we also know that it means we'd need half as much primary power, since we wouldn't be wasting so much of it as heat. Here's a 2018 government report looking at this phenomenon in electrifying the US. This is entirely typical of real work in this area, despite his attempts to imply that clueless beaurocrats are just making things up. https://www.nrel.gov/news/program/2018/analysis-demand-side-electrification-futures.html https://www.nrel.gov/news/program/2018/analysis-demand-side-... edit: I particularly enjoy his "The ERoEI for renewable energy systems is much lower than fossil fuel energy systems. Renewable energy systems may not be strong enough to replace fossil fuels". Oh, it's not strong enough. That weak, puny renewable electricity. Followed up with "energy is becoming more expensive". Wow, no wonder he's so pessimistic.
- hedora 4y agoI was wondering about usng solar panels to offset batteries. These ships travel at 43 kph. A 5000 km range ship needs 6.5 GWh of storage for a roughly 100 hour trip, or 33 hours of near-peak solar production (assuming no clouds). So, it would need about 200 megawatts of solar to completely avoid charging while docked. 20 watt/sqft is pretty good these dats, so it would need 10M sq ft of solar panels on its deck. Cargo ship decks max out at about 265K sqft. So, there's no point in putting a solar array on the deck of one of these things.
- derefr 4y agoGiven the centuries of (mostly) effective use of sailing ships, maybe wind power would be the better candidate here?
- atwood22 4y agoMany ships already use wind power. I don't think you'd be able to harness the wind, convert it to electricity, and use the electricity more efficiently than a sail.
- derefr 4y agoInstantaneous efficiency is well and good, but a sail only redirects power; it doesn’t capture it. To me, the goal of adding wind power to a cargo ship would be the same as adding solar power: to recharge the batteries asynchronously to demand, to then later use that power when there is demand but no active supply. Wind→electric gives you the ability to “save up” power in a tailwind, and then later “spend” that power against a headwind. (You’d think pure wind power would do this as well—the engines can in theory work less hard if the sails are full—but wind is too precarious to match the slow ramp-up/ramp-down times of the giant motors used to power boat propellers. Those things are what power plant designers would call “base load” — mostly you don’t even turn them off, you just engage a giant clutch to put the boat into neutral when you don’t want to be moving. The master “transmission” of a boat is essentially a cylindrical steel flywheel; and you don’t want to lose its momentum. This is why boats a good match for bunker-fuel furnaces — or, on subs, nuclear — which are power sources that also ramp up/down slowly.)
- danielheath 4y agoI was curious and did some math based on numbers plucked from the web. A panamax cargo ship burns ~250 tons of bunker fuel a day and carries ~15k containers. Cruising speed is a little over 1000 km / day. The energy density of bunker fuel is approx 12500 wh / kg. Lead-acid batteries hold 50 wh / kg while high-end li-ion cells hold 500 wh / kg. By those numbers it sounds like you'd need approx 6000 tons of high-end lithium cells per day of operation - you can put 40 tons in a shipping container (much more and many ports will refuse to unload), so 150 containers of batteries per day of travel. A 5000km trip is going to use 5% of your cargo space for fuel (where previously it would be closer to 0.1%). That adds up to real money (you could have moved 750 containers at approx $5000 each, so you lost ~3.75 million, but the fuel would have only cost approx 0.3 to 1.5 million USD depending on where you fill up). For short trips (sub 1000km) I suspect they'd probably use cheaper, less-energy-dense ni-mh batteries as they are safer and cost less than half as much for a comparable charge.
- tonyarkles 4y agoI don’t have paper handy to check but in your bunker->electric conversion are you factoring in the (generally much higher) conversion loss from hydrocarbon to useful energy? Edit: looks like they’re more efficient than most ICE at around 50%. That at least cuts down the cost spread a fair bit.
- ghouse 4y agoCheck the conversion of the energy content to usable energy. More of the Wh of the batteries become motive force than the Wh of the bunker fuel. Your conclusion isn't wrong; the density of the energy storage (be it bunker fuel as chemical energy storage, or batteries as chemical energy storage) matters.
- morepork 4y agoFor a fair comparison, you'd have to know how big the engine and fuel tanks are in relation to the batteries and electric motors.
- dymk 4y agoThat holds given today's pricing of fuel, but I expect that will change in the next couple of decades as the world decides to tax carbon emissions.
- rektide 4y agoMinistry for the Future is a book chock full of optimistic can-do idealism. One of the ideas floated is container ships with (on-ship) wind and solar renewables that just move really really slow. Personally I think for many transportation needs that would be find. And they start chopping up bug ships to make smaller more regional ones. Which jives with the analysis here. But given that bigger boats afaik almost always are more efficient moving through the water (short of hydrofoiled or wing-in-groumd craft), I didnt totally get this notion.
- justinator 4y agoHonest question, where are we getting all the lithium for all these electric-powered vehicles? How many mines is this?
- 2000UltraDeluxe 4y agoMostly from Australia and Chile. I assume more large producers will pop up as demand increases.
- ephbit 4y agoMaybe the answer will be sodium batteries: https://www.altris.se/ https://www.altris.se/ Sodium is pretty abundant and much more easily accessible than lithium.
- timbit42 4y agoUse sodium batteries in large vehicles like semis and cargo ships and in stationary applications such as buildings. Keep lithium for applications where weight is critical such as electric airplanes and cars.
- lazyjones 4y agoSomeone should build stackable, pluggable shipping containers with a battery in the floor, to power both container ships and trucks. Tesla?
- allanrbo 4y agoSomewhat related: using the good old technology of sails is another way of reducing emissions from shipping: https://www.fastcompany.com/90567832/this-cargo-ship-cuts-emissions-90-using-an-old-fashioned-trick-sails https://www.fastcompany.com/90567832/this-cargo-ship-cuts-em...
- hooloovoo_zoo 4y agoI wonder if a ship could tow a big solar array rather than have a big battery.
- timbit42 4y agoThey can also have masts to generate electricity from the wind. Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MdI191-vNlc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MdI191-vNlc
- ephbit 4y agoIf you want to replace the 80 MW of a big engine [1] you'll need quite some square meters. Let's assume the solar array operates at some medium yield of 4,5 kWh / (sqm * day) [2]. Assuming you have some big enough battery on board to evenly supply the solar harvest of the sunny hours over 24h this results in a contant power output of: ~ 0,18 kW / sqm So to replace the 80 MW engine you'd need a solar array of more than 400000 sqm. If you tow several floating arrays that are 100 m wide and 200 m long, you'd need 20 of those. Sounds like a challenge at least for the huge vessels. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/W%C3%A4rtsil%C3%A4-Sulzer_RTA96-C https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/W%C3%A4rtsil%C3%A4-Sulzer_RTA9... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_irradiance#Solar_potential_maps https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_irradiance#Solar_potenti...
- trhway 4y agoIf there is an application for hydrogen, i'd say the container ships are it. The fuel cell gives great efficiency and hydrogen storage has higher kwh/kg than batteries.
- timbit42 4y agoHow will the hydrogen be generated? It's only green if generated from solar, wind or hydro power. Generating it from natural gas produces more pollution than burning natural gas directly.