16 ms·
Hollywood’s visual effects crisis
- bobsmooth 4y ago"Marvel allowed the back half of Multiverse of Madness to showcase far more of Raimi’s hallmark directing style, but by then it was too late for the entire film to play out as a cohesive whole. It still grossed nearly a billion dollars worldwide." Why change when it's working so well?
- gambiting 4y agoMultiverse of Madness has to be one of my favourite marvel films of late, I get that the author doesn't like it but saying that it's not a "cohesive whole" is just not true.
- bobsmooth 4y agoRead the comment from the VFX artists that worked on it. The whole article is well researched.
- gambiting 4y agoI would if it wasn't paywalled.
- rawling 4y ago> Perhaps the apex of this creative fatigue was Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness, which underwent extensive reshoots but didn’t have enough of an effects budget to cover that new footage adequately. As a result, the effects in the opening sequence of the film are about as convincing as a Windows 98 screensaver. One supervisor expressed to Defector their exasperation not only with the process on that film, but with the startlingly inert creative choices that went into it. > “When you see something like the first third of Doctor Strange, you’re like, Why not do something more interesting, where you’re not straining your budget and 1,000 artists to try and make something that you know is going to look substandard? Why not try something else when you have a good director like Sam Raimi?“ ... followed by the original paragraph. There's no big shocking revelation that backs up the "not a cohesive whole" point imo.
- gambiting 4y agoI think it's hard to accurately judge something you have worked on. I'm a video game developer and I struggle to enjoy the games I work on - all I can see is the bugs and the areas we didn't deliver or where we changed the artistic vision or where yes, we had to re-do certain systems a hundred times. And yet, people seem to enjoy them. They review well. So maybe my opinion as a developer isn't really worth that much. I feel the same about the opinion you copied here - having watched Multiverse of Madness 3 times now I don't see any issue with the opening sequence. It looks pretty good from visual standpoint in fact. But I'm sure a trained VFX artist can point out the areas where it fell short and how many times they had to change it. The only visual effect in this entire film that stood out to me as "bad" was the sequence with illuminati right after they killed their thanos - that just looks like a poor Photoshop.
- sammalloy 4y ago> Multiverse of Madness has to be one of my favourite marvel films of late I’m curious why you think that. I thought it was one of the most boring Marvel films in the franchise, and I’m surprised I was able to stay awake for the entire thing. On the other hand, its twin, "Everything Everywhere All at Once", had me deeply engrossed and interested.
- gambiting 4y agoIt was crazy and out there, like the comics are - which is what I love in Marvel. The scene where Dr Strange commands the dead in another universe is like absolute peak enjoyment for me. The worst marvel film for me is Civil War since it's so.....grounded(closely followed by Ragnarok, but that's purely because I can't stand Waititi's humour) I've watched it 3 times now and I still love it - it's their best film since Infinity War, everything else after that was very much meh.
- danjac 4y agoI felt completely left out, because although I had seen the last Spiderman movie, I hadn't watched Wandavision or half of the TV shows. It was like trying to follow a game in a sport you only have a casual interest in: you kind of know the rules but have no idea who the main teams or players are or who is up or down in the league, so your enjoyment is limited to the occasional good goal or pass (or VFX shot in this case). In contrast to DC movies - very hit and miss in quality, but you can at least watch a movie without having to follow a dozen other TV shows and other films in the franchise.
- gambiting 4y agoSo I personally enjoy this style of storytelling - it rewards you for knowing the backstory of all the characters, it allows for a richer universe, and you don't feel like the film treats you like an idiot for explaining everything you might already know. But - I can also see why this is a problem - you're right that people who haven't seen Wandavision would be very confused by this film. Wanda went from being a hero in Infinity War/Endgame, to suddenly being a villain.
- SSLy 4y agomind you that you still can't legally watch WV in a lot of the countries the movie is running in.
- gambiting 4y agoI know, and I agree it's a problem. I don't know what the right answer is. I think building a big universe requires some background knowledge of the events and characters, but maybe in this specific case Wanda could have used like one more scene just to explain what happened in Westview.
- onion2k 4y agoIt might gross 2 billion if it was done better.
- classichasclass 4y agoJust watched the 3D Blu-ray this evening and the introductory sequence was indeed of appallingly bad CGI quality ("Windows 98 screensaver" indeed), as was the bus-wrecking beast which came off like a rejected design from Monsters Inc., and really the entire first act as a whole was just really rickety. In that sense the poor CGI was the symptom of a more systemic disease. Fortunately Earth-838 has lots of welcome character surprises and the ending redeemed a lot. Not Raimi's best, but hardly his worst.
- XorNot 4y ago3D has been garbage since it's inception in cinema though: the guy who pushed it on us (James Cameron) couldn't even constrain himself to the rules of the new tech in the movie which was meant to showcase it (I.e focus pulling will hurt the eyes of the viewer, you have to essentially construct the whole scene in focus so the viewer can look around it). No one else has really cared about it since then.
- classichasclass 4y agoIt wasn't the 3D that was the problem, though, even though the 3D was obviously not native and the digital mattes were fairly flat. It just wasn't good visuals even in 2D. That said, Dredd 3D was a high mark in 3D because it was almost all native, especially the component effects photography (the Slo-Mo scenes in particular blew me away). The few upconverted shots stick out like sore thumbs. Upconversion can be done well - see T2 3D, which was mesmerizing - but nowadays 3D conversion is now just another VFX workflow with the same drawbacks.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cm2187 4y agoIt's just grain for the pigs.
- Joeboy 4y agoI definitely wouldn't say no to a "fully Raimi" movie, but I quite liked the way it started off as typical Marvel cheese and pulled off a surprising change of tack somewhere in the middle. In fact that might be my favourite aspect of the movie.
- jiggawatts 4y agoThis is a “solved problem” now with technologies like this: https://youtu.be/bErPsq5kPzE https://youtu.be/bErPsq5kPzE The backgrounds are “real” and can be captured in-camera, so there is no need for special effects to blend hair. Similarly, reflective surfaces aren’t a problem either. This was used to good effect for the Mandalorian series where the protagonist wears shiny metal armour.
- buildartefact 4y agoYeah just because they say “you just shoot it and you’re done” doesn’t mean that’s what actually happens.
- objclxt 4y agoIt’s nowhere near a solved problem, there’s a large number of camera moves you can’t do with that tech, and it doesn’t help you if you have any sort of virtual or CG augmented character or prop in the shot (because you’d still have to do the compositing). If you want to talk about The Mandalorian, IMDB credits over 380 compositors on that series. In-camera effects are fantastic, but they’re not reducing the visual effects burden.
- sammalloy 4y agoI can’t say enough good things about The Mandalorian. Seriously first rate all around.
- glandium 4y ago> there’s a large number of camera moves you can’t do with that tech Even when the background is updated in real time according to the camera position?
- Groxx 4y agoTry that while pointing two cameras at the scene.
- 4y ago
- dcow 4y agoSounds like “hollywood” is finally fully corporate, devoid of any soul it once had. I just finished the ILM docu-series and wow what an amazing and incredible story. It’s sad that, for the industry, it’s all culminated in abusive studios, disconnected directors and fuck it someone else will fix my mess mentality. And the disrespect for VFX workers, my god, they should come join an ops team they’d get more respect. I guess it’s kinda to be expected when you’re just perpetually milking cash cow IP to death (hardly the innovation it once was). And since when do lasers arc in space?? I don’t watch super hero movies on principle at this point. It’s the least I can do.
- leeoniya 4y ago> And since when do lasers arc in space?? Webb would like a word...
- dcow 4y agoCan you explain? I’m genuinely curious what phenomenon you’re referring to.
- rz2k 4y agoI think they're alluding to phenomena this[1], a description of gravitational lensing from the Webb Space Telescope team. [1] https://webbtelescope.org/contents/media/images/2019/20/4377-Image?Tag=Gravitational%20Lensing https://webbtelescope.org/contents/media/images/2019/20/4377...
- dcow 4y agoOkay yes, we can see distant light from slightly behind stars because it follows curved spacetime. The energy projectiles in question in Star Wars VIII arc in a parabolic trajectory through flat spacetime over much shorter distances.
- ozzythecat 4y ago> it’s all culminated in abusive studios, disconnected directors and fuck it someone else will fix my mess mentality. > And the disrespect for VFX workers, my god, they should come join an ops team they’d get more respect. > I guess it’s kinda to be expected when you’re just perpetually milking cash cow IP to death (hardly the innovation it once was) I can’t help but smile reading this. Replace “studios” with “organization at big tech company”. Replace “vfx workers” with “software development engineers” Replace “cash cow IP” with “legacy systems that still bring in $$$”, although yeah there’s IP there too from a while ago. Sorry, I don’t mean to take this completely on a tangent, but I can’t help but think there are similarities here.
- muglug 4y ago> You saw Taika Waititi savaging his effects team in the clip at the beginning of this story Waititi's comments are blown out of all proportion in this article (and also on Twitter). He points at a CGI character and says "does that look real?" but then similarly points at human characters and says "does he look real?". It seemed like the monitor they used using in the Vanity Fair video had its brightness set too high, making the scene look more fake than it did in cinemas.
- karaterobot 4y agoI just watched it for the first time, and it seemed like it was pretty innocent. Right after the moment in question, they point out a continuity error, and then go on to list several examples of the challenges of a complex production like that. It did not seem like they were blaming the VFX artists, just acknowledging that those movies are made at an insane scale. They didn't say it, but it seemed to me like they were both a little detached from the process due to its size, despite being nominally so crucial to it.
- leeoniya 4y ago> Some actors have digital fixes to their hair, among many of their other physical features, written into their contracts. TIL
- jbverschoor 4y agoig /tiktok/ snap should just release a feature film creation tool
- KaiserPro 4y agoIn harry potter, the actors were chosen at age ~8 (ish, young what ever it was) This meant that in the middle movies, they went through puberty. My generation of VFX people cut their teeth doing puberty based acne removal. Both harry and ron had pretty bad zits, and because continuity is kind, the needed to be removed. Meryl Streep in MamaMia had "digital makeup" applied by one bloke working the night shift.
- vertexmachina 4y agoA lot of what this article talks about rings true in a presentation I watched recently by the team at Weta Digital which did the VFX for The Batman They talked about, among other things, how they had to: - digitally replace the stunt man's face in many of the action shots because his jawline was too dissimilar to Robert Pattinson's. - digitally modify a hand because a prop gun misfired in a shot - enhance the fight scenes to look more visceral and violent - add rain and rain spatter to the car chase (the parts that weren't already fully digital) I'm no filmmaker but I felt many of those things could have been done without VFX. Hire a stunt man that looks more like RP, reshoot the scene with the broken prop, forget about rain and/or tone down the epic action set piece, etc. Instead it seemed like it all just came to rest on the shoulders of the VFX artists.
- jbverschoor 4y agoVFX artists are cogs.. I guess they're like cloud servers. Cheap for some things, but misused for too many things
- ygra 4y agoIt's probably also everything that is accidentally overlooked during the shoot. Previously you would hat a different take, perhaps, or live with the goof. Now you can just offload that to post-production. But probably also a question if how expensive filming days are with the whole crew vs. how expensive VFX artists are. The latter work is also highly parallelizable.
- ip26 4y agoIt’s probably a good ol perfectly rational slippery slope. Fixing a minor mistake or two in post is absolutely the best choice for everyone. Each additional fix is not worth a reshoot either. But slip too far and the product suffers.
- berkut 4y agoAs someone in the VFX industry myself (but as a software dev writing the tools the artists use), I'd argue those examples are generally useful work being done on the movie to make things "more real". Whether it's worth it, is going to be very opinionated. However, I would say: I re-watched GoldenEye recently, and - maybe it was because I'm in the industry and notice these things more - but the blatantly different stunt men (especially landing the Cessna in Cuba: the man looked totally different compared to the actor who should have been flying!) compared to the actors did make me personally go "hang on a moment, who's that?" Some of this stuff can now also be automated to a degree (not completely, it still requires artist input, and sometimes a lot), but it's not often Rotoing every frame like it used to be ten years or so ago. Things I'd personally argue aren't worth artists having to work on, but I know they do, are things like skin wrinkle removal on leading actresses, removing mustaches on actors, etc. And the biggest issue is clients changing their mind at the last minute, often having previously signed off on lookdev or anim at the earlier stages, or just generally having to deal with bad set preparation because the 'talent''s time on set is 1000x times more important than the unseen artists, who then have to do loads of work to compensate for badly lit (very un-evenly lit) greenscreens or lighting on set, because the on-set VFX supe was likely ignore when he complained ("Oh, they can just fix it in post").
- dsign 4y agoI get that there is some suffering involved, and some broken egos. But people are having jobs and getting paid, aren't they? That's important; specially for artists and technical artists who don't have many well-paying opportunities otherwise. What worries me is that I watch these productions because they are the lowest common denominator, the kind of thing attractive to my friends and partners who didn't finish high school. These movies, to justify their budgets and make the money back, have to be appealing to the widest possible audience. Therefore, they can not afford to hurt any sensibilities, and their plots need to happen in worlds as disconnected as possible from our reality. They can't be neither "political" nor "well-educated" in any obvious way. So when anybody watches a Marvel movie, they are maximizing their social futility, the amount of brain-bleaching they get. Worse, they are not using their time to assess/judge the work of a smaller studio who wants to bring public attention to something more concrete. It is like social media.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- raverbashing 4y agoHolywood's self inflicted visual effects crisis It seems the special effects industry got the short-end of both cut-throat industries (tech and cinema) without the benefits of any of them Then they will go broke, and wonder what happened. Again Taika Waititi sounds like a great guy but that jab was better left unsaid. I think a lot of people (yes, all around us) think that it's easy just because "it's done in the computer" and they have a menu item to merge somebody's wig into the background just like that. But that's "the business fault" because they don't surface the cost of that upfront
- anigbrowl 4y agoA lot of the best VFX work is what you don't even notice. Sound is the same. Producers and directors want to keep their options open as long as possible and then everyone wants to touch the final product so they feel they really earned their credit Being a technician is pretty exhausting and unglamorous, plus if you're too good at what you do it becomes a prison because you're a known quantity and nobody wants to take a risk on giving you upward mobility, but you don't necessarily get paid enough to have any economic autonomy. Now I work in an adjacent area where I have editorial/creative control, which is great, but also a lot more fraught financially (much like any other startup). I do get annoyed when I hear people criticize the media/entertainment industry; there's a lot of celebs and jerks that deserve criticism, but people outside it mostly assume everyone's on easy street and have no appreciation of the workloads and craft involved.
- ur-whale 4y agoNone of what this article talks about is new, except perhaps for the WFH bit. The "we'll fix it in post" attitude in particular has been around for as long as computers have been used in VFX.
- wodenokoto 4y agoMy impression is that the advancements in cgi has let producers and directors get sloppy in planning. “We’ll fix it in post” feels evident in the final product to a very high degree. But worse, it lets producers “work around” actors schedules by having them film at different times and locations for the same scene.
- smat 4y agoI am also curious how this period in movies will hold over time. Older movies with more practical effects (such as Star Wars) still have a very crisp look to them while newer movies look blurry and bloomy due to the heavy post processing.
- WalterBright 4y agoOnce I learned how optical printing worked, Return of the Jedi was ruined for me. I could see the flickering black line around the flying craft. I never noticed that when I watched RotJ in the theater.
- zerocrates 4y agoStar Wars is a tricky one, since the versions that are generally available and that lots of people have seen have all had various levels of after-the-fact VFX applied to them.
- goto11 4y agoIf you take a classic which have stood the test of time and compare it to the current average, the classic will probably look better. But that is just survivorship bias because we have forgotten all the forgettable movies. If you look at the average sci-fi movie from the 1970's, the special effects are not usually very impressive.
- Joeboy 4y ago> newer movies look blurry and bloomy due to the heavy post processing If newer movies look blurry and bloomy, it's probably because they're trying to look like old movies.
- 4y ago
- Scandiravian 4y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20220814070946/https://defector.com/inside-hollywoods-visual-effects-crisis/ https://web.archive.org/web/20220814070946/https://defector.... For those who do not want to sign up to continue reading
- abbadadda 4y agoYou should get 2-3 free articles without signing up (not affiliated, just a subscriber).
- Barrin92 4y agoI honestly could do with way simpler VFX if the end result at least had something like style or a vision to it. One result of this highly sophisticated and expensive pipeline seems to be that everything looks sort of generic. The superhero productions in particular, don't know how to describe it but visually they all basically look like the equivalent of what Material design is for apps. i want something like Sin City or Hannibal (the tv show) again, I wouldn't really care if it's not the most technically sophisticated thing ever made.
- deebosong 4y agoI am absolutely of this school of thought. So many forms of art don't need to be hi-fi, latest & greatest, "realistic," or only conform to the "acceptable" trends of the times. I think even as a kid, some videogame cut scenes in 2D pixel art got me so hyped/ engaged/ moved. Same goes for comic books, that were nothing more than black and white line art (granted the line art was executed superbly – what up Akira Toriyama & Bill Watterson!). One can hope that studios would be more willing to try new things, but they don't even pretend it's about anything other than the bottom line.
- moomin 4y agoThe elephant in the room here is that VFX, unlike many other film professions, isn’t properly unionised. Half of the practices that make VFX a hell-scape to work in and produce so many poor results are due to the simple fact that the workers are not treated the same as other parts of the crew. As long as it’s cheaper to fix it in post than retake the shot you can look forward to much more of this.
- agileAlligator 4y agoThing is, unions usually proliferate in industries where you are more or less replaceable. That isn't the case in industries that can't be easily automated.
- 0xRusty 4y agoOr creative industries where 20% of the people do 80% of the heavy lifiting work. As a vfx and cg supervisor at a large vfx company myself I work extremely long hours, picking up the slack for the 80%'ers who can barely simulate a piece of cloth or match a plate's key light direction. Why on earth would I choose to unionize and equalize my pay and benefits to those that are objectively poor at their job in an industry where successful results to tasks are so subjectively measured.
- BeFlatXIII 4y ago> so subjectively measured There's your answer. Equalize pay and benefits because there's no telling whether those in charge of assigning pay have any good sense at all for quality. It's the argument of salary vs. hourly vs. per-item all over again.
- agileAlligator 4y ago> because there's no telling whether those in charge of assigning pay have any good sense at all for quality They'll pay what they think you are worth, and you are free to leave if you think they aren't paying you enough. It's not like there are only two software companies in the entire world and you gotta work for one of them.
- amelius 4y agoIf this is a crisis then imagine what it would be if movies were all multi-angle or interactive.
- fedeb95 4y agoMovies have become something absurd. It's wasted effort in my opinion. All this money doesn't lead to an improvement artistically. Some movies are just trash piles made for advertising products
- JKCalhoun 4y agoYour'e being downvoted, but I for one agree wholly with the point you make. I don't doubt filmmaking has always, in the end, been about business or they wouldn't be made. But the captains of the film industry, perhaps in optimizing profit, seem to be all circling the same kind of flashy, effects-laden action film. I've heard people suggest it's a result of the "globalization of the industry", that action films with "effects > dialog" sells to a Chinese audience, for example. Perhaps there is some truth to it (if so, it suggests again studios optimizing for profit). I've been on a "1001 Films To See Before You Die" tear for a few years now and it is hard not to see many of these old films and sigh, "When would Hollywood ever make a film like this today?" Please, can we have another, another "new wave"? More indie cinema please. This market has been ripe for disruption since the Pirates of the Caribbean franchise took root.
- true_religion 4y agoDoes anyone remember Karate Kid 7? The movie market has always been repetitive. Arnold Schwarzenegger played a tough guy in a dozen derisive movies. Heck, even Ronald Reagan’s later movies felt like they were all the same character in different clothes and a pastiche plot.
- Joeboy 4y agoThe Wizard of Oz (1939) was the fourth Wizard of Oz film.
- boppo1 4y agoHey, POTC 1 is a truly great swashbuckler/adventure film. The sequels are all truly garbage though, I agree.
- 4y ago
- XorNot 4y agoI wonder where something like DALL-E fits into the digital touch up pipeline in the near future. Taking existing footage and in words accepting instructions like "remove the facial hair on X"
- H8crilA 4y agoIt's not a crisis unless the workers start quitting.
- not_the_fda 4y agoSpecial effects do nothing for me in movies. Movies that take the [Dogme 95](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dogme_95 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dogme_95) approach are more my style.
- karaterobot 4y agoThat was a reaction to the direction of movies which eventually evolved into this, but sort of an overreaction in my opinion. Rules like "the camera must be handheld" and "the director must not be credited" seem unnecessary. It felt like that manifesto was meant to make an ideological point rather than to help make better movies. In practice, even most of its adherents broke those rules, because they were bad rules. That said, while reading this article I did think about Dogme 95, and started wondering what a similar manifesto specifically related to the use of VFX would look like, if it were maybe a little bit less reactionary, and more tailored to "how do we make VFX an integrated, manageable, sustainable part of movies?". Has anybody done this already?
- Joeboy 4y agoIf you google "vfx workflow" or "vfx pipeline" you'll find lots of stuff. As I understand it the reason things get out of control on big movies is that there's no incentive to plan shots properly or be decisive, because VFX houses are expected to sign stupid contracts. There are smaller movies where people are more disciplined, eg. Monsters, where I believe director Gareth Edwards did all the VFX himself.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoA lot of resonance with software. I worked for hardware manufacturers for all my career. It involved a brazen disdain for software, yet also an assumption that hardware defects could be "spackled over," using "magic" software. I really enjoyed the VFX in Miss Marvel. They obviously really enjoyed their job, and they had the advantage of not having to look "real."
- DoneWithAllThat 4y ago> Visual effects departments didn’t even exist, particularly in television, until roughly a decade ago. …what? To pick a random example Star Trek: The Next Generation debuted in 1987 with ILM doing the effects. Is the author really claiming visual effects departments sprung into existence in 2012? That’s ridiculous.
- SSLy 4y agoEverything is 10 years ago if you're a 45 y.o. white dude who thinks they're 25.
- DoneWithAllThat 4y agoThat’s a really impolite thing to say. It also tends to be more frequently younger people who think history started when they were born.
- winternett 4y agoI make music for film, and I edit video in relation to that work often. I can recall several years of having to learn how to do things in so many different applications that dictated the end product because the applications were very complex to use, and quite time consuming. I couldn't understand how friends were paid less than application developers (Around 60k annually) to do some of the most impressive VFX things I've observed in commercials and movies, and it was very hard for them to find work even when they had great portfolios. Fast forward to now, there are mobile apps that can edit videos, and add effects, color grading, etc to videos. I can literally run a video editing session in my car that outputs better product far more quickly than I used to be able to do with $2k software... Even mobile software that can work with object files... Making the process of creation easier will likely be the best field for innovation moving forward. Making things more simple will also save studios and VFX editors tons of money, time and grief. TikTok formats are dominating the entertainment world right now, VFX movies are beginning to look disingenuous because they either overdo effects, or they cut corners and make things low quality, relying too much on the power of celebrity to push the movie forward... Viewers are also worn out by actors trying to take cues on green screen sets, it comes across often as far too staged, or far too busy visually. Movies where the VFX trump everything else end up being weak on writing and emotional composition in my opinion. Movies that rely on celebrity become very weak on VFX... I think good movies come from a great script that can be used to plan everything that comes thereafter, and then the quality of the final product depends on the vision of the director and execution of the team involved. Movies like Blade, Hancock, Ant Man, and even more recent work like "The Boys" are some of my personal favorites because VFX are not the primary hitch to the stories... Avatar completely lost me, even though far more money was spent to make it. VFX is a support tool to great films, when it becomes the primary aspect, the script suffers and budgets balloon, and the worst part is that movies take 5 years to make instead of just taking one.
- Tiktaalik 4y ago> Once the time comes to do that post-production work, the crunching begins. These are workers who, similar to video game developers This comparison is increasingly out of date. From my experience and what I've heard, the notion of video game developers crunching is getting rarer and rarer, while I haven't heard of any such trend in visual effects.
- olivertaylor 4y agoI work in the VFX business, formerly managing a VFX house and now negotiating contracts with studios and production companies. A few random thoughts… There is a massive industry-wide labor shortage and a massive surplus of work to be done. Artist rates are way up, there are more junior artists than ever, there are more shows with more VFX than ever, VFX shops are turning away tons of work, new shops are springing up, investment groups are buying and consolidating VFX houses to try and become big players, etc. This is a boom time for VFX. This is absolutely a (labor) seller’s market. Individuals and companies that are not taking advantage of this to create a better environment for themselves are missing a huge opportunity. There’s never been a better time to quit a job you don’t like and find a better one. Or to start a company! It’s not actually true that the contracts allow studios like Marvel to make whatever changes they want at any time. I’m sure it can feel like that to artists at times but that’s not how it works. Contracts are negotiated at a fixed price for a certain scope of work, with the tacit understanding that both parties will be flexible. If requests for changes push that scope of work outside the original deal VFX studios can negotiate overages and schedule changes (and they’re free to attempt this at any time). It is totally within their power to be firm and demand livable contracts. But… it’s a subtle art. Like any human endeavor or any contract worth tens of millions of dollars trade offs and accommodations are made. No vendor wants to leave a client high and dry or totally screw them over, and no client wants to ruin their relationship with a vendor they rely on. I can’t imagine there’s anything about this that is specific to either the visual effects industry or the movie industry. There are a lot of people running VFX companies that are simply bad at this part of the job and get themselves into hot water. When that happens it’s the front line workers (as always) who have to work the extra hours. That said, there are a number of (very large) companies where it is absolutely normal to work 6 days a week 10 to 12 hours a day. This is not a secret, it’s been very common for a very long time. Personally, I wouldn’t work for a company like that. What we’re experiencing is a huge shift in how movies are made and an industry that is struggling to keep up. Workflows, infrastructures, and tool chains designed for how movies were made for decades are being pushed to the limit, both because of the volume of work and the way in which people want to work. We’re moving from a world where everything had to be planned way in advance (because of how massively expensive and slow everything was) to one where we’re expected to be more improvisational (because of how much much cheaper and faster it is to do the work). You can’t characterize that as a change from a good way of working to a bad one, it’s simply change. One with countless industries have also faced. And keep in mind that just like any other industry, many of the changes to the film/tv business are technology driven, and VFX is at the forefront of that. So producers looking to totally reinvent how movies are made end up using the VFX industry to do it. If you take VFX out of the conversation there is little that’s changed (technologically) about how movies are made in the last 20 years. So VFX is baring the brunt of the changes that are happening in the larger industry.
- crazygringo 4y agoEverything about how much life sucks for visual effects artists may be true, but I'm not convinced it's any worse than everything that comes beforehand: > In today’s Hollywood, compositors, along with all of their colleagues, are often left to clean up all of the messes left by writers, actors, directors, producers, and all of the other name-brand talent. "Clean up all of the messes" sounds awfully derogatory. How about the fact that on-set you might have 50-200 people working at any given time, so doing anything that will delay the next shot by even just 10 minutes can be astonishingly expensive, and not every problem can be predicted in advance. Not to mention things like the sun setting. If something can be fixed in post, it's because it's the better more efficient option, not because people meant to leave a "mess". > is being left to a post-production workforce that is disparate, overworked, confused, and exploited. News flash: the production workforce is just as disparate, overworked, confused, and exploited. 16 hour days and 6 day weeks are standard for everyone involved. Not saying this is good either, but setup for each day and shoot takes so long (just think the hours spent in daily hair, makeup and wardrobe for actors) that days need to be 16 hours long just to get in a reasonable amount of shooting. Visual effects may be difficult and suck, but everything in production is like that. I just don't like how this article seems to frame it that the regular production side of things somehow has things easier.
- joenot443 4y agoWell said. I also think it's worth remembering that everyone involved in the production of Hollywood movies are likely doing so at least partially because there's an immense amount of worldwide prestige in working on them. Similarly to how I feel about Tesla employees working 16h days, I don't imagine the thousands of people behind every big budget movie were under any delusion they'd be working a comfy 9-5.
- f1refly 4y ago> It can come in the form of changing frame rates on an entire TV show from 24 frames per second to 60 because a network is, rationally or not, dedicated to that second number. I don't understand why 60fps is the default for all nrw productions. Lots of movies today cut the action into tiny pieces, make the camera shake a lot and the set itself may shake as well. With 24 frames per second one can hardly see anything but blurred colors. Slow camera pans also tend to become choppy and unpleasant to lool at.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoRead this recently. Truth is most vfx left Hollywood long ago for greener tax subsidies overseas. Industry is too small or too democrat-adjacent? for government to notice. Oh well, was always a sweatshop so perhaps a good riddance to those abusive jobs.
- TaylorAlexander 4y agoI don't think either political party really cares about labor anymore.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lotsofpulp 4y agoDemocrat led states and cities have paid sick leave, paid parental leave, longer leave periods for new moms, higher minimum wages, daily overtime laws, laws requiring sitting, pay transparency laws, laws requiring employee to be able to sit, higher unemployment insurance benefits, same minimum wage regardless of tips, etc. Republicans led states do not. That seems to be clear evidence indicating one cares more about labor than the other.
- TaylorAlexander 4y agoThat’s fair. I guess at the state level things are better. Maybe even at the federal level democrats care more than republicans. I do however feel disillusioned with how little it feels like the democrats in congress are willing to do to fight for labor.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoDemocrats passed Affordable Care Act in 2009 during the only 6 months where they had a tenuous 60 seats in the US Senate required to pass non budgetary laws. Democrats also almost passed significant child care benefits and tax credits in the original build back better bill in 2021, which of course was voted against by every Republican. Even a single Republican voting with the Democrats would have enabled millions of poorer families with children. In my entire adult lift (since 2000) I cannot recall a single bill proposed by Republics to benefit lower income/poorer people. I do know they pushed through two wars and a bunch of tax cuts. I know Democrats tried to reform healthcare as early as mid 1990s (which then culminated in Affordable Care Act). Seems like pretty conclusive evidence that the parties are not the same at the federal level too, and the voting rules at the Senate level do not leave any options other than severe compromise.