7 ms·
> ...could yield more vibrant computer displays, TVs, printed materials, textiles and more I'm sorry, how exactly? From the paper's abstract: > Consequences o
by crazygringo 4y ago
> ...could yield more vibrant computer displays, TVs, printed materials, textiles and more
I'm sorry, how exactly? From the paper's abstract:
> Consequences of this apply to color metrics that are currently used in image and video processing, color mapping, and the paint and textile industries.
At best, I could imagine how computer-selected colors might be chosen differently, i.e. adding to the many ways in which gradients between two colors are computed.
But I can't for the life of me imagine how computer displays might become more vibrant -- this isn't going to affect the spectrum of backlights or LCD color filters or OLED phosphors or anything as far as I can tell? E.g. in the way that Macs shifted from sRGB screens to P3 screens for their color gamuts?
Similarly with paints and textiles -- this isn't going to lead to new paints or dyes.
At the end of the day, colors -- whether in a movie scene or a paint chip -- are ultimately chosen by eye, not by math. So seems like the headline is making claims that can't be substantiated?
Would love to know if I'm missing something here.
- robbrown451 4y agoAgree that they haven't offered much in terms of how it could make displays more vibrant. > At the end of the day, colors -- whether in a movie scene or a paint chip -- are ultimately chosen by eye, not by math Well.... math is involved if you want to do even simple stuff like blending two colors in a paint program. There is subjective stuff, sure, but you aren't going to get very far in computer graphics, display manufacture or camera chip manufacture, if you just conclude that it is 100% subjective and there is no mathematical logic behind it.
- refulgentis 4y agoIt inherently doesn't make any sense because the limits, the "bounds of space" of displays is physical. Changing your indexing system doesn't sprout new colors
- orbital-decay 4y agoIt very much does, as color is not a physical phenomenon. It's just perception - essentially a bunch of weights in your neural network that makes some internal conceptual sense. You can trivially go outside of those "physical limits" e.g. by exploiting temporal perception quirks to get impossible colors (not represented by any spectral combination in typical conditions). The same can be said about all human perception in general, not just colors. Artists exploit this for centuries, and are trying to formalize this. Newer color appearance models try to precisely quantify perception effects to make better color appearance possible.
- jcims 4y agoIs there any example of using color chirps(?) in mainstream use? Interesting concept.
- refulgentis 4y agoThis doesn't have any effect on my claim, that displays have a gamut that's bounded by how they physically create lights. I'm not sure how to explain why further than that, it's not even wrong, something I've definitely seen is the more people know about color, the more complex it seems when usually it's more simple when you start thinking across reference frames / viewing conditions Source: builds color spaces using color appearance models
- pbazarnik 4y agoIt is about rendering colors of the scene within the bounds of physical limits of display device color space. Rendering to the display device screen uses perceptual intent: a conversion of color space of the display under some assumptions about screen viewing environment etc. [1] With better models we can improve this conversion. Article mentions that large color differences are not perceived as acute as the current models (Riemman etc) suggested so new model could boost the color difference to achieve that higher acuity. [1] https://blog.colorgate.com/en/rendering-intent-explained https://blog.colorgate.com/en/rendering-intent-explained
- refulgentis 4y agoThis does not create more colors or mean displays or fabrics could have more colors or anything like that Mental model for color space that keeps things on track is it's just like any 3D space. Here, we could say "distance space" like "color space" and two "distance spaces" are miles and kilometers, (two color spaces are RGB and $ONE_FOLLOWING_FROM_PAPER) If we found the distance equation in distance space differed from expectations, due to interesting things about physical geometry, that wouldn't create new places. Why? The map is not the territory. The physical space still exists as it did. Moving from distance to color: the physical display gamut is the territory. The map is the color space. If we discover our distance metric in the space is flawed, we'd measure distance between colors as different than before. That wouldn't create new colors in color space. Source: I create color spaces
- toiletfuneral 4y ago
- hilbert42 4y ago"But I can't for the life of me imagine how computer displays might become more vibrant..." You're most likely correct, that is for current display technologies. For years, I've hypothesized that we cannot solve the problem with tricolor displays and I've postulated that we need a 7-color system to do proper justice to our eyes/perception and even then it'd still be an approximation albeit a pretty good one. Obviously, I can't argue this out here or we'd be at it for weeks. Suffice to say I'm far from being alone in thinking this way. Keep your ears to the ground and no doubt you'll soon hear from better minds than mine on the subject.
- newaccount74 4y agoWhy 7? Our eyes have 4 different cells, so any system with more than 4 colors will lead to a system where we just have redundant colors that the eye can't tell apart
- OscarCunningham 4y agoThe possible colours form a sort of semi-circle known as a chromaticity diagram (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chromaticity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chromaticity). If you pick 3 points in the diagram then the triangle they form won't cover the entire shape. In fact since it has curved sides no finite amount of colours will allow you to fully cover the perimeter. But having more colours lets you more completely approach the perimeter.
- hilbert42 4y agoThat's one solution. Seven wide points on the CIE would cover it pretty well. Another is to have fewer points and dedicate extra channels to specular reflections, extra-spectral colors: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spectral_color#Extra-spectral_colors https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spectral_color#Extra-spectra... and imaginary, impossible and chimerical colors: en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impossible_color and 'matrix' them with the color channels. The challenges however for any new color system are formable and it would require new developments in technology before being practical. The human eye is quite remarkable, it adapts dynamically to the situation in both its luminance and chrominance channels and has an effective dynamic luminance range of around 10^6 : 1. To give you a sense of how truly adaptable the eye is here's an example: the now defunct Kodachrome - which was once the gold standard in film emulsions and in some limited ways still is - only had a luminance dynamic range of between about 250 and 500 : 1 (depending on how you measure it, 250 being more the norm), and its chromaticity was pretty limited especially in reproducing violet (violet being the least objectionable tradeoff) and yet it was capable of producing some quite wonderful photographs (and I've still many thousands of slides to prove the fact). Now if you compare Kodachrome with what the eye is actually capable of then there's essentially no comparison, Kodachrome falls so far short you'd wonder why we'd bother using it at all. The fact is the eye adapts to that limited situation and does a remarkable job of fooling you into believing that the Kodachrome image is the 'true and real thing'. This example also illustrates the very real difficulties in getting to the bottom of color theory. Keep in mind the issues here: real light consists of an almost continuous electromagnetic spectrum, the eye resolves this by matrixing RGB primaries to produce an 'imaginary' spectrum and it also has to deal with extra-spectral colors such as magenta, and there are other issues as well. As I hinted I'm reticent about entering a heavy debate about this subject here as I can only do so superficially - just one word out of place and it'll be mistaken as wrong and it'd only derail the debate. Look, it's a huge subject: (a) our existing color technologies - video/television, printing and color film - are already very sophisticated and are full engineering professions in their own right - and as we're discussing all have quite severe limitations in their ability to faithfully reproduce the luminance channel let alone the chrominance one, and (b) the theory of color vision is not only complex and quite difficult to understand - and now it's become even more complex. I will however finish with an idea I've had for years that could overcome many of the limitations of the tricolor (or any multicolor system). It's completely theoretical as the tech still doesn't exist. The idea would work like wideband superhetrodyne radio receiver. A UV laser as the local oscillator would beat with incoming light in a mixer to produce an IF (intermediate frequencies). The more manageable IF would be bandwidth compressed and eventually reconverted up-band to visible light so the viewer is actually seeing a spectrum of visible light. Simply, a TV camera of such system would capture say light at 555nm and that's what the viewer would eventually see - and not some mixture of RGB primaries. Picking coordinates on the CIE would be a thing of the past. Now, I know the objections will be many and all sorts of issues both technical and theoretical arise but there's little point in debating them here. I've raised this for one reason. The whole problem we have with color reproduction starts with the fact that we cannot reproduce the eye's CIE with true accuracy and using any number of CIE coordinates will never completely solve the problem. Eventually, we need to find a better way. Finding a way to accurately record the incoming wavelength of light in recorded images would also provide us with many other scientific and engineering advantages.
- a-dub 4y agoi wonder if choices amongst metamers might have secondary effects we don't know about... like given two renders of the same image with different metamer selections, are there possibly subconscious impacts to mood or feeling between them. do different spectral envelopes that produce the same percept result in different demands or representations in the ventral stream which then could (or may not) manifest in nonobvious ways?
- OscarCunningham 4y agoI can't think of a mechanism by which this could happen, since the cone pigments will have the same absorption rates in either case. There's no signal that the brain could use to behave differently.
- a-dub 4y agoi just reread about the retina and i think you are correct. i was under the false impression that the transfer function for each group of cones was a function of some processing in higher layers of the ventral stream.
- sam0x17 4y agoFor example, I would imagine you could come up with a more perfect list of what the "pastel" color is for any given hue. Another example I remember from my early 00s UX days -- if you take a gradient-based glass/glossy bar that is blue and try to hue shift it to red, it won't look properly glossy without tweaking the relationships between the colors in the gradient. Having a perfect understanding of how our eyes perceive these types of color differences I would think could yield a perfect approach for transposing visual phenomenona between different hues. I have no idea though I'm by no means an expert on this.
- sam0x17 4y agoSide note: if our eyes did perceive color in a euclidean way, for example, the normal process of hue shifting something would actually work without needing to do any saturation/brightness/darkness adjustments afterwards.
- Taniwha 4y agoBack in the early 90s I worked for a Mac company that made graphics cards for the publishing industry - color correction was a big deal (print magazines have/had 'white rooms' rooms with known color temperature where they looked at photos). Marketing really wanted a game winning solution. One thing I learned - no two sets of eyes are the same - at an extreme 10% of the male population are red-green color blind but in reality we're just not all the same - there is just no perfect color matching solution
- guenthert 4y agoI wonder how important relatively speaking the individual differences (outside the extremes of color-blindness) are, compared to the fact that the customers are simply not sitting in such 'white rooms'.
- Taniwha 4y agowell the whole point of trying to produce color corrected monitors was to avoid the whole process of printing things out and looking at them in white rooms as desktop publishing started to become a thing - high end publishers were (are?) very sensitive to their color fidelity, compelling color is very much part of what draws in their readers
- strogonoff 4y agoNo two sets of eyes (which includes retinas plus all the processing that converts the input into internal scene representation) are the same. This is especially frustrating with photography. No two people see a single scene the same way; the best you can do is take raw data and interpret it into the tiny, tiny display space the way you think best describes the scene. Yet do many think that the blandest possible JPEG render is the reference truth of what reality is actually like.
- WithinReason 4y ago>But I can't for the life of me imagine how computer displays might become more vibrant The perceived vibrancy of a display is not only dependent on the spectrum of light emitted but also on the way the colors of an image are mapped to the colors of the display. Better understanding of color would help with the latter.