18 ms·
Lex Fridman Podcast #309 – John Carmack
- ebbflowgo 4y agoJohn is such a legend
- f0e4c2f7 4y ago5 hours long! I'm so excited to listen to this. Video version here: https://youtube.com/watch?v=I845O57ZSy4 https://youtube.com/watch?v=I845O57ZSy4
- affgrff2 4y agoLex Fridman's Podcast is what I listen to when doing sports, will take me weeks to get through it but I am really looking forward for this episode.
- starik36 4y agoI am gonna have to get a job with a commute. Podcast is over 5 hours.
- s1k3s 4y agoI'm out of the loop on game development, is John Carmack a "big brain" as presented on grugbrain.dev?
- fredrikholm 4y agoThat would be recursivedoubts, the author of HTMX.
- sgt 4y agoOn that note, htmx is really cool.
- Centigonal 4y agoJohn Carmack BIG brain. make Doom. make rockets too. work for oculus too, but then leave
- mandeepj 4y ago> work for oculus too, but then leave Not sure about his current work status with Oculus, but he did not leave immediately; turned into a consultant or something like that - from CTO
- TremendousJudge 4y agoNot so sure. On a technical level at least, everything that I have read from him has been very concise and pragmatic. His programming advice is always to be as simple as possible because simple is fast. For example, the one I always remember is that in order to optimize that you should try to remove as many "edge case optimizations" as possible, so that everything runs always the same way, and then optimize _that_.
- exitb 4y agoI do value simplicity very much, but this doesn’t seem true. There’s a reason why musl is slower than glibc, st is slower than xterm, OpenBSD is slower than Linux etc. It’s great if the optimization via simplification works out like that, but usually it doesn’t.
- atlasunshrugged 4y agoHaven't listened to this one yet but for people with sticker shock over the time commitment, Lex consistently does amazing podcasts with really sharp people over the course of a few hours and imo (being an avid podcast listener) it's one of the best out there. Edit to add: His recent episode with Jack Barsky (former KGB spy) was exceptional and worth a listen if 5hrs is too long of a test case
- 1980phipsi 4y agoI listen to Lex on 1.5X and usually have no problem understanding anyone.
- sph 4y agoI'd have a hard time following Carmack's train of thought at 1.5x. It is impressive how dense and fast-paced his conversations are.
- dexterdog 4y agoI default to 2.3x plus silence skipping and I know people who go faster. Most conversational podcasts run effectively at 3x with the silence skipping. It sounds like gibberish for a second or two and then once the focus comes in it's normal. I can't listen to things are normal speed. I started out at 1.5 and then went up in .1 increments over time until it was too much. I still tune some faster speakers back to 2 or 1.1, but that is the minimum. I was always a piss-slow reader so I prefer to listen to things, but anything close to 1x just takes forever.
- kepler1 4y agoAre we listening to the same person? I find Lex Fridman to be wooden, robotic, non-sequitur, not smooth or charismatic, and (I admit, shallowly) not a pleasing speaking voice to listen to, and not that articulate actually. The main reason he gets famous guests is that he has a reputation for getting famous guests. He's like a Kardashian. I actively have to tune him out and suppress my wish that someone, anyone else were asking the questions. But it is what it is. We don't have voting rights on who random walks their way to being famous in this world.
- fezfight 4y agoFacebook is dying, so it seems less important now, but I'd have liked to hear in his own words how he felt supporting a company with such questionable ethics.
- HellDunkel 4y agoThis would have been interesting but does not appear to be something Carmack would get into.
- fezfight 4y agoYeah. C'est la vie. Glad for his contributions over the years to open source.
- fdgsdfogijq 4y agoHe can meaningfully retire on facebook money. Good for him and I have no requirement for him to publicly criticize them. Also, facebook is the main company plowing money and top engineers into AR/VR. They also created react and pytorch. Facebook has had a massive impact on software.
- fezfight 4y agoSure but the question isnt how did he decide to fortify a successful company with his reputstion, but an unethical one. Successful does not mean ethical. They're so unrelated as to be orthogonal.
- fdgsdfogijq 4y agoPioneering technology that pushes society forwards often comes from unsavory industries. Its a reality of life and a critical piece of capitalism
- fezfight 4y agoAnd thus it always should? No. Carmack could apply his genius elsewhere, but he chose not to. I'd like to hear him explain why.
- naillo 4y agoCarmack is awesome. Rarely does an interview anymore but when he does he really delivers and gives us friggin 5 hours. Look forward to it.
- modeless 4y agoCan't wait to find out what the heck he's been working on in AI! Seems to me like he would be best at scaling to extreme model size and making efficient use of available hardware, but it would be too expensive to keep up with the corporate labs as an independent researcher. And from what I've seen before it seems like his opinion is that scale might not be required.
- gwern 4y agoFWIW, Lex is good about including a ToC, and when you have that, you can use the dropdown menu to open up YouTube's neural-net-generated transcripts (which are surprisingly good but also deliberately extremely literal and badly formatted) to read that instead of spending 5 hours listening to it. (This is what I did to quickly check out his comments on Gato etc.)
- modeless 4y agoOh, I'm going to listen to the whole thing for sure. John Carmack's interests line up very well with mine.
- ge96 4y agoNice, I think he did one with him in the past, that was also good
- ge96 4y agoOh no I was thinking of Jim Keller
- timcavel 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- HellDunkel 4y agoI listened to a few episodes but can’t help sensing some form of shallowness. The oliver stone episode was particularly disappointing. He basically talks to all celebrities within his reach about whatever he feels the want to talk about.
- dubsman 4y ago
- yardie 4y agoLex Fridman's interviews are the only reason I'd put up with a longer commute. They are super dense and super long. Like listening to an audiobook every few days. The Tony Fadell interview was also interesting. A great review on the history of iPod and iPhone and what he was up to at Nest.
- sva_ 4y agoI just discovered this when I went to the store, and will probably take a nice long walk in the evening/night heat to devour at least part of this delicious release. What a nice gem to randomly receive. I'm curious to know what Carmack has been doing especially in regard to AI.
- phendrenad2 4y agoJohn Carmack is a programming god, and every time I hear him talk I wish I could be that smart. If you haven't seen Carmack's Reverse yet, you should: https://www.gamedev.net/forums/topic/210276-carmacks-reverse/ https://www.gamedev.net/forums/topic/210276-carmacks-reverse... Lex Friedman is also my favorite podcaster. His podcasts are the highlight of my week.
- mikewarot 4y agoCarmack says he wasn't the first to find it[1], and the other person had "done that somewhat before" [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I845O57ZSy4&t=2861s
- seattle_spring 4y ago[flagged]
- md2020 4y agoTake this comment back to Reddit.
- seattle_spring 4y agoWhat exactly do you mean? I strongly feel that Lex Fridman is a canonical anti-intellectual (or pseudo-intellectual, "in a sense" :P ), and I don't think that's unreasonable to point out on HN.
- kingTug 4y agoLex Fridman misrepresents his role at MIT to make himself sound more accomplished than he really is, and the way he went about putting out his self driving car research directly to the press instead of going through peer review is shady. The guy is a cringeworthy grifter. He’s trying to be viewed as some AI expert but he’s totally full of shit. Elon made him famous and he got the Joe Rogan push. Absolutely droning interviewer in need of media training.
- briga 4y agoSeems to me like he’s gotten along just fine without any ‘media training’, whatever that is. Calling him a grifter seems a little unwarranted
- redmen 4y ago
- infamouscow 4y agoDo you have any evidence to back that up -- or a counter-argument to the undeniable fact the podcast is a success?
- redmen 4y ago
- LewisVerstappen 4y ago
- kodah 4y ago> And very naive man boy > You sound triggered. > You know what else has had undeniable success? Cigarettes and Facebook. Terrible argument. Just a note, I think you've violated the guidelines in a multitude of ways here. Since you're new, definitely have a read: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- tambourine_man 4y agoLike many here, I have mixed feelings regarding Lex. Last time I heard him, he started the podcast saying that he “fears nothing and no one”, which of course means he's either extremely immature or a psychopath. I'm betting in the former. For whatever reason, he manages to get great guests, so I keep listening. I wouldn't say I tolerate him because he mostly doesn't get in the way of the interview much. Which is good, but the bare minimum for a good host. I used to listen to Rogan a few years ago, but it has become unbearable to me and the Spotify exclusivity deal was the push that I needed to stop completely. With Lex, I keep coming back, reluctantly, so I guess he's got something going with his show. Edit: oh, and Carmack is a legend, I'll listen to him with almost any interviewer.
- spfzero 4y agoThe fact that he's opening a podcast with that, lets you know that he's talking about "fear" in a very narrow sense: of how he questions conversationally, and how he chooses podcast guests. It doesn't mean he's a psychopath.
- tambourine_man 4y agoThere’s no such thing as no fear, no matter how narrow you constrain its scope. It’s ignorance, hubris, naïveté, dishonesty, etc. Anything but bravery.
- jimkleiber 4y agoI've thought about hosting a podcast with a similar format to Lex's and yet I don't listen to podcasts much so I don't know what's missing from the scene. If there were another one like Lex's, how would you want it to be? What would you want to be the same, what different?
- markus_zhang 4y agoJohn Carmack is and will always be one of the greatest programmers for me. His drive, motivation and work ethics are also very inspiring. Whenever I feel low the first thing I tried (sometimes failed) to pull me out is reading a few chapters of "Masters of Doom". I'll probably never be as productive as he has been, but I appreciate the games and impact he made. I also enjoy this podcast because this is one interview of Carmack that I can almost fully understand :P
- nickjj 4y agoAs someone who grew up playing Doom II along with Quake I/II/III I can't thank you enough for name dropping that book. I've always followed id software's games but never really knew their origin story or the full history of how it all came together. I'm about 2/3rds of the way done with the book which I've read in 1 sitting so far. I felt compelled to stop to make this reply. This is one of the best books I've ever read in my entire life.
- markus_zhang 4y agoNo problem and I'm glad you enjoy the book. If you are into programming plz also check out Fabien Sanglard's game engine books.
- nickjj 4y agoThanks. I am into programming but it's more focused on web development. Gaming is how I got introduced to web development tho, specifically making Quake clan sites and being a part of a Quake III ladder site.
- Cub3 4y agoI finished "masters of doom" a month ago from a HN recommendation, was fantastic and I see a lot of their organisational patterns repeat in the startup space
- markus_zhang 4y ago
- debug-desperado 4y agoHere' the flamewar money quote: (in reference to the pain of using multiple languages on a project) "At Meta we have a lot of projects that use React frameworks, you've got javascript here, and then you have C++ for real work, and you may have Java interfacing with some other part of the Android system, and those are all kinda horrible things." Of course just a few minutes later Carmack says that garbage collection is unequivocally a good thing for most programs, so C++ pros shouldn't puff up their chests too much!
- bch 4y agoAre you sure it wasn’t Carmac referring to using vi (versus a modern IDE like Visual Studio) as something like “civil war reeanactment LARPing”?
- parineum 4y agoI think you're misinterpreting that and/or quoting it out of context. He was going on about how many different languages were in use. The "horrible thing" he's referring to is the variety, not that they aren't all C++. The "real work" he's referring to is performance intensive work and I think his phrasing makes it clear that he like C++ but he gives a lot of credit to modern languages for their ease of use as well.
- debug-desperado 4y agoAgreed - I hoped my parenthetical would get that across but it's worth making it clear that Carmack isn't against different programming languages. He rather feels that being forced to use multiple languages on the same project brings extra pain. The thing is, he also complains about a time at Oculus where he needed C++ experts to right the ship but Facebook didn't have the talent base for it. Since he says 99% of code should be written in GC'ed languages, it shouldn't be surprising there's a talent vacuum in C++ among modern programmers.
- jstx1 4y ago5 hours?! I'm diving in (I try to fastforward when Lex talks). Carmack is one of the few people that actually inspires me a bit - like I listen to him and think "okay, I should be writing way more code than I do".
- JonChesterfield 4y agoIs there a transcript? Looked around the posted link unsuccessfully
- gabrielsroka 4y agoYouTube has one. There are also timestamps.
- JonChesterfield 4y agoAh, yes it does. Can toggle the timestamps off and copy it into an editor to fix the sporadic newlines to get something broadly legible, thanks!
- Nimitz14 4y agoI dont like lex but this and the one with demis hassabis were very good (i think bcz lex managed to avoid saying much).
- slt2021 4y agogosh did they just sit for 5 straight hours and talk??? Impressive
- abhaynayar 4y agoIt's not about being a wall, or being uninteresting that gets me. Unlike most boring interviewers, he also positively makes me cringe. Like, I just can't. I believe he is trying to emulate Prince Myshkin from The Idiot, but he has a profound misunderstanding of what it means to be an Idiot in the way of the Prince, and so, he is only able to emulate the surface level behaviours but not the underlying identity. I was watching his episode with Jaron Lanier, and because I loved what his guest had to say, I really had to push through all the cringe and force myself to watch it. The same thing has happened multiple times. Whenever I see an amazing guest on his podcast, I feel sad that I'll either have to skip it, or go through a painful experience. It would be amazing if there was an alternate edited form of his podcast, where Lex is replaced with someone else who fills in whatever Lex is talking about in a concise way, just to keep the flow going. I would definitely watch something like that, solely because of his guest lineup. Edit: I feel like this comment might be interpreted as too harsh, but just to clarify, I am not attacking his person. Interviewing is a skill, and I'm only criticizing his skills. If I tried interviewing, I might suck as well, but I wouldn't expect the kind of guests he gets.
- xnx 4y agoDoes anyone have a version of this with Lex edited out?
- jacklizhui 4y agoThere is a lot of -ve feedback on Lex. I dont want to dwell on it, instead, provide another end of the spectrum. Stephen wolfram. The wolf man. completely insane. So much arrogance, hubris and self promotion makes me stop watching instantly.
- Exendroinient00 4y agoI've never understood sense of those talking heads type of podcast. You won't get anything useful out of it and it's not even entertaining. Listening to smart people talk doesn't make you smarter.
- isitmadeofglass 4y ago> Listening to smart people talk doesn't make you smarter. I don’t listen to standups thinking it will make me smarter, I don’t watch football thinking it’ll make me more athletic. Why would you assume people listen to smart people to become smarter and not just for the entertainment and informational reasons that are straight forwards reasons?
- antholeole 4y agoWhy would it not make you smarter? Having a hard time following this logic. Perhaps not significantly, but if they say something you don’t know, then by definition you just got a little smarter, if only by one fact about one topic. Also, I think a lot of ideas are presented black and white but podcasts like these show the intricacies of the gray area
- mikewarot 4y agoLikely they will say something that happens to make contact with some other thought you picked up somewhere else, and you'll make a new mental connection between concepts and that expands your mental map of the world. It's always good to understand the world a bit better.
- bitwize 4y agoI really love one of the points Carmack makes: You are leaving productivity on the table by not using an IDE. IDEs bring you closer to the Lisp/Smalltalk ideal of live-coding a running system, but with programming languages people are likely to use. Text editor based edit/compile/run workflows are pointless grognardism by sticking with "stone knives and bearskins" tooling. Use a goddamn IDE, you filthy barbarians.
- igouy 4y agoBack in the day, from the people who brought you commercial Smalltalk: July 10, 1989 "ParcPlace Systems Inc, of Mountain View California, has launched its Objectworks software development system for AT&T’s C++ Release 2.0: the integrated set of object-oriented tools include an incremental compiler and linker, source level debugger and source code browsing, and will be available in late August for Sun Microsystems’s Sun-3 workstation, selling for $2,500." https://techmonitor.ai/technology/parcplace_launches_objectworks https://techmonitor.ai/technology/parcplace_launches_objectw...
- kilroy123 4y agoWho doesn't use an IDE? I've known developers who used only VIM back in the day. I don't know of any dev that doesn't use one, nowadays.
- bitwize 4y agoDo they use a debugger as a tool of first resort? Do they step through their code line by line? One of Carmack's points was that gdb's terrible interface has made debuggers a tool of last resort in the Linux/open source world, when they should be a tool of first resort, and code should be stepped through even before it's run normally because that's how you get a clear picture of how it runs. Visual Studio's excellent debugger integration alone has made the open source development experience truly "stone knives and bearskins" by comparison until relatively recently.
- mehphp 4y agoI've seen it at most places I've worked. A lot of people still use just VIM and the command line only.
- grandpoobah 4y agoWith so much negativity in the comments I'm simply going to save myself the trouble and assume Lex is a white supremacist.
- tzekid 4y agoYeah, you're right. He's pretty much up there with Michael Malice, Eric Weinstein and Ben Shapiro. \s Offtopic: Comments like this is why I love this site.
- sidcool 4y agoMy Programming gods: - Jef Dean - John Carmack
- thorin 4y agoI thought this was a fantastic podcast. I'm not sure how so many people can hate Lex and his (free!) work. I've been waiting for some of these interviews (with a technical interview for years/decades). I'm a bit confused why you'd want to speed then up or skip them, surely this is missing the point of settling into a thought provoking conversation? I happened to have a longish drive yesterday for a day of walking in the hills and listened to the whole thing in 2 sections. Never felt bored and had quite a few interesting thoughts come up during the conversation. Thanks Lex!
- dexterdog 4y agoI never get that argument about not listening faster. Do you slow things down to .75x when you want to focus even more? I will get far more out of the conversation by listening to it 2 times at 3x speed than I will listening to it once at 1x.