12 ms·
Quaise Energy is working to create geothermal wells
- donatj 4y agoI’m generally curious after reading this, what effect does our molten core have on our ambient surface temperature? I can’t imagine much, but it can’t be nil, and I genuinely have no idea.
- icegreentea2 4y agoWiki says it's basically nil: > The flow of heat from Earth's interior to the surface is estimated at 47±2 terawatts And > Despite its geological significance, Earth's interior heat contributes only 0.03% of Earth's total energy budget at the surface, which is dominated by 173,000 TW of incoming solar radiation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earth%27s_internal_heat_budget https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earth%27s_internal_heat_budget
- donatj 4y agoThank you so much for the link, there is a lot in here that is genuinely fascinating! For instance heat from the surface “thus penetrates only several tens of centimeters on the daily cycle and only several tens of meters on the annual cycle”
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoThis is why ground source heat pumps are suprisingly effective. You're drawing on the yearly solar inflow to the ground, at a depth where the temperature is quite stable, due to accumulating and averaging over years.
- DLTADragonHawk 4y agoMy curiosity in using things like heat pumps is that what happens when you move too much of that heat energy away. The heat might be doing nothing but, it has been there for a long time. At what point is too much heat displaced to the surface and what is the outcome of that?
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoFor them to actually work the energy needs to be replaced, flowing from the hot areas to the (relatively) cold areas, mostly coming from the sun. If you have a small area and continually pump the heat out then you end up with the inside of a freezer, which uses the same tech for exactly that purpose, but also intentionally insulates to prevent the heat getting back in.
- antisthenes 4y agoYou can read about what happened to the London underground over the years. Except the process has been sort of reversed: there was heat being introduced into the deep layers of clay and rock. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/London_Underground_cooling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/London_Underground_cooling
- aronhegedus 4y agoIt's probably similar to the fact that wind turbines don't stop wind around the world :D
- soco 4y agoThey actually do, a bit: https://www.popsci.com/science/article/2013-05/fyi-do-wind-farms-make-it-less-windy/ https://www.popsci.com/science/article/2013-05/fyi-do-wind-f...
- pantulis 4y agoThats for sure but, where does that energy come from? I would say it comes from the earths own rotation, would this infinitesimally slow the earth rotation? Anyway this is fascinating stuff!
- pantulis 4y agoI also read that Quaise value proposal is drilling a 20km deep hole but once you reach there, how do you transform that into usable energy? Push water to extract vapor?
- u320 4y agoYes pump water down, extract supercritical steam coming out and then just use a regular turbine.
- pantulis 4y agoJust curious, is this process performed in alternate phases (pump water, wait for the vapor ) or is it done at the same time with different pipes in the same hole?
- bshipp 4y agoI'm also curious how they would deal with rock deformation as it reaches the point of becoming less solid and more squishy. There would need to be a mechanism to maintain hole integrity post-drilling. To your question, I'm wondering if they simply pump down water and extract resulting steam once it reaches the point of vaporization? The steam condensers and everything else are already built on-site for coal generation. One difficulty would be handling any accumulated minerals that got into the steam loop from interaction with the rock in the hole. Unlike traditional closed-loop steam generator, an open system would pick up contaminants and eventually cause scaling.
- MrsPeaches 4y agoAs another spin-off of this, I’ve always wondered how much tidal energy we can extract before we start messing up the moon’s orbit.
- treeman79 4y agoWe lose energy from gravitational waves being emitted from the earth spinning around the sun. Causing earth to move toward the sun. The amount lost is sufficient to power a small toaster oven.
- smilespray 4y agoWhere can you buy one of these toaster ovens?
- Scoundreller 4y agoDoes it have a USB port?
- revolvingocelot 4y agoCan't you read?! There's just one! ...and it's kept in the basement of the BIPM, right next to the International Prototype of the Pop-Tart®.
- ufmace 4y agoI've worked in oil and gas for years. It's possible the article is missing a bunch of details, but I'm extremely dubious of their idea. First, how do they plan to address well control? As you drill down through the Earth, you drill through many layers of rock, some of which contain oil and gas in various quantities. Since the thousands of feet of rock above is heavy, they are under a lot of pressure, and will be happy to flow out through your borehole and up to the surface if you don't take measures to keep the formation under control. If they are allowed to do that, those flammable materials can easily ignite and cause a fire big enough to destroy your entire drilling apparatus and be very difficult to put out. Note that you don't necessarily need enough oil and gas to be commercially produceable to generate a disastrously bad blowout. Oil wells address this by filling the borehole with drilling fluid at a specific density, which produces enough pressure at the bottom of the hole to counter formation pressure. Every well is also fitted with multiple blowout preventers to seal off the well in case of a sudden pressure increase from the formation, and also allow heaver weight fluid to be circulated in to get back under control. The wells are also drilled and cased in sections, so that there is never too large of an amount of borehole uncovered that needs to be kept under control. So given all that, exactly where is this Gyrotron going to be? If it's at the surface, how are they planning to microwave through miles of drilling fluid and have enough energy at the bottom to cut more rock? If it's at depth, how is this Gyrotron going to survive the high temperatures there? High-end electronics are much more sensitive to extreme heat than drill bits are. Especially if you're pumping ~megawatts of energy through them to actually cut rock. Speaking of, how would we even get that much electric power down there? Oil and gas has spent many billions of dollars on this and has yet to find a good solution. Also, how are they planning to keep this whole straight and judge depth? Holes thousands of feet down don't just stay straight, you have to actively keep them straight. The oilfield has plenty of ways to do this with conventional drilling hardware, how will their Gyrotron system manage it? And we also need to transport rock cuttings / fumes to the surface fast enough to support the drilling rate, how will they do that? I'm also wondering about fluid flowrates. If they manage to drill down far enough to get to rock hot enough, how much fluid do they need to flow in order to get enough heat energy to the surface to operate these steam turbines? How big pipes do they need up and down to flow that rate? They also need to flow slow enough at depth to pick up lots of heat, and also fast enough through the mid and shallow depths to not lose all that heat to the local formation before it gets to the surface. For that matter, what's the heat flow rate from the magma into the rock at the depth they were drilling out - how much heat power can we really extract long-term with their setup? (I see jjk166 has addressed that, and that it is another serious issue). Don't get me wrong, geothermal is a really nice solution, and I wish all the luck in the world to anyone working on using it more. I just don't see any technology here that address the real issues with getting large-scale energy from geothermal.
- pseudolus 4y agoInterview with Carlos Araque, the founder of Quaise Energy, on the podcast "How I Built This" with Guy Raz: https://wondery.com/shows/how-i-built-this/episode/10386-hibt-lab-quaise-energy-carlos-araque/ https://wondery.com/shows/how-i-built-this/episode/10386-hib...
- alfiedotwtf 4y agoAnyone else find it weird that there have been a flood of MIT links on the front page the past few days?
- 3pt14159 4y agoThey've always been around and fairly frequent. Pretty high quality source for hacker related stuff. Check out this, for example: https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=news.mit.edu&next=22099182 https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=news.mit.edu&next=220...
- alexpotato 4y agoIs there a guide to how to use some of the features of HN like the search in the link above?
- 3pt14159 4y agoThere is, but I can't remember the link, haha. You just kinda learn things over the years. This one can be reached by clicking on the domain name of a linked article, so it's easy to remember how to get there.
- Agamus 4y agoThere is a guide to the API here: https://github.com/HackerNews/API https://github.com/HackerNews/API
- BbzzbB 4y agoSpecifically for search, might as well use hn.algolia.com than figure out how to use HN's hidden(ish) API.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI suspect it's a chain reaction. Someone (from here) follows one link, then starts clicking around, and finds more interesting stuff, and so on.
- 4y ago
- TomGullen 4y agoA great video on this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g8sjdOjNxIE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g8sjdOjNxIE
- giantg2 4y agoMy biggest question is whether this will be the next climate crisis. There have been recent articles about how the earth's geology is cooling faster than expected. There are questions around if our planet will become a dead planet as it cools. It seems like speeding this up could be an issue, especially given how little we know.
- idontwantthis 4y agoCan you link an article?
- doikor 4y agoGeothermal heat provides less than 0.1% of the total heat of our planet. It is pretty much all just the sun. So as long as the output of the sun does not change much it won't be a problem (so will have to wait billions of years and even then sun will actually get bigger and hotter first before getting colder)
- lrem 4y agoWon't Earth be engulfed in the first phase? If that's the case, Solar gasses will also drag down our orbital velocity and Earth will fall towards the core. So it won't be around for the second phase.
- NineStarPoint 4y agoThe issue is that when the core cools too much it will cease to be magnetic, and then solar radiation strips the atmosphere. But it’s not a major concern, in this case faster still means billion year time scales.
- u320 4y agoThe planet is expected to still be mostly molten by the time the sun swallows it, so there is a huge margin. I think people underestimate just how much energy there is down there.
- 4y ago
- hereme888 4y agoIdk why this sounds like another business scientist with a lofty idea that will never materialize.
- pseudolus 4y agoThe potential upside is incredibly high and the investment required to determine if the technology is so low that it's well worth pursuing.
- hereme888 4y agoTotally agree.
- pqdbr 4y agoI actually got really excited after reading the article, and the entire piece is about how "down to earth" (pun intended) the technology being developed here really is. They are going to great lengths to make it compatible with the existing power grid (just replacing the heat source for current generators), re-utilizing abandoned mines and all. So, would you care to elaborate why you think it would never materialize?
- jffry 4y agoThe article puts a lot of weight on the use of pre-existing technology in a new mode for making deep bore holes, and glosses over the engineering challenges that have yet to be solved ("transmitting a clean beam and having it operate at a high energy density without breakdown"). I'm not equipped to judge how difficult those problems will be to overcome in practice. Obviously this would be very cool if it bears out, but it's hard to tell if it will.
- hereme888 4y agoI agree the technology does seem down to earth, and they're trying to make it quite practical. I'm also excited. I just think of so many hurdles...I hope they make it. I originally wrote a huge reply explaining my thinking, but sounded like a rant. If it works, maybe it can also be used to quickly bore the underground tunnels Musk has been working on. Could be life-changing tech.
- V__ 4y ago> This will happen quickly once we solve the immediate engineering problems of transmitting a clean beam and having it operate at a high energy density without breakdown > [...] In five or six years, I think we’ll have a plant running if we solve these engineering problems. I’m very optimistic. If only a few engineering problems have to be solved to make it work, then it will be ready in no time. It's not like those engineering problems are hard to solve or anything. That's why fusion works so great, cheap batteries are wide-spread and everyone has 100% effective solar-panels.
- bshipp 4y agoWhile your sarcasm is noted, it's important to also note that engineering problems would never be solved until someone is allocating the necessary resources to solve them. I'm not a huge fan of gross theoretical speculation as being a savior for humanity, but I very much appreciate an innovator's optimism that redirecting known technologies to a novel application will result in benefits to humanity. Optimism is difficult to generate and easy to snuff out. We should be less inclined, as a society, to default to apathy.
- falcolas 4y agoI read this as skepticism about the timeline - which is 100% valid. Nobody's downplaying the validity of the research. But perhaps being optimistic about timelines is how you secure funding? Couldn't say.
- bshipp 4y agoThat is fair. I recently watched "We Were Apollo" and was struck by how incredibly audacious a manned moon landing really was in 1960. That sort of positive thinking is what we really need for fixing the climate crisis and elevating humanity beyond constant resource conflicts.
- falcolas 4y agoIt's worth remembering that national pride (and the beating that pride took when the Soviet Union beat us to space) is what drove the US to make such fast progress. That national pride does not exist as a driving force for addressing climate change. We, in many ways, don't even have a national consensus on the need to address climate change.
- ovi256 4y agoThe well drilling using microwave lasers, generated using those gyrotrons, certainly sounds novel enough. It will need a R&D program to bring it up to a mature tech level. The concept of reusing existing coal plants sounds clever.
- Communitivity 4y agoTANSTAAFL... If we tap the energy from the molten core, part of the system that both drives/stabilizes the rotation of the planet, and provides the magnet generating our solar radiation shield (van allen belts), then I think we can expect eventually to face rotation/stabilization degradation. Of course, eventually might be a million years from now. I remember climate change deniers saying that climate change might produce a visible effect by 2400, and by then we could fix it. Now look where we are with that. There's also fracking. To tap the core we probably need to do deep drilling, with a lot of the problems that drilling for oil or fracking cause, except possibly magnified because of the depths we're talking about. It is much easier, and safer, to tap solar energy. If we pour research into solar efficiency and house-scale batteries, we could provide all of the electricity needed for U.S. homes and have enough to sell to Canada and Mexico with only 16k sq miles (the size of Nellis AFB). "A square mile, 5,280 feet times 5,280 feet equals 27,878,400 square feet. Divided by 15 sq.ft. per module, we can fit 1,858,560 modules per square mile. At 0.6266 kilowatt-hours per module per day, our square mile will deliver 1,164,574 kWh per day on average, or 425,069,510 kWh per year. Back to our goal of 4,000,000,000,000 kWh, divided by 425,069,510 kWh per year per square mile, it looks like we need about 9,410 square miles of surface to meet the electrical needs of the U.S. That’s a square area a bit less than 100 miles on a side. This is a bit over half of the approximate 16,000 square miles currently occupied by the Nevada Test Site and the surrounding Nellis Air Force Range." [1] [1] https://www.terrawatts.com/PV-production.html https://www.terrawatts.com/PV-production.html
- sophacles 4y agoJust a nit: fracking problems aren't from the depth of the drilling. In fracking (hydraulic fracturing) they drill a hole then push high pressure fluid into the hole in such a way as to cause large volumes of rock to break apart. For something like this, you'd want the hole to be stable and not tear apart all the rock around it, like in a traditional well.
- u320 4y agoAFAIK they aren't planning to do any fracking, and it's not obvious that it is even possible at these depths. And the drilling is far less disruptive as it is given that it is done at atmospheric pressure (no drilling fluid). As for your second point, batteries are not cheap. Nowhere near cheap. We need solutions not pipe dreams.
- jmyeet 4y agoIf I read this right, this is still the basic geothermal structure and idea but is really an improvement in drilling? Geothermal seems to be limited by finding suitable places for it, which is generally where you only need to build fairly shallow wells. Building deep wells is expensive. If you can build deeper wells faster and cheaper then it opens it up to move areas. Is that correct? Better and cheaper drilling has way more applications thatn building geothermal wells. I mean we need to build tunnels all the time. Cheaper drilling probably has significant applications for the oil and gas industry too. So if that's true, why the focus on geothermal? I mean I support research into renewables but it's a whole lot easier if, say, you can get the oil and gas industry to pay for your R&D, effectively. My understanding is that geothermal energy production is still pretty low. It's also worth noting that boiling water to steam and turning a turbine has inbuilt costs that you can't escape. There's only one power source that directly creates energy and that's solar. Additionally, solar has no moving parts (other than facing PV pannels towards the Sun, optionally).
- danans 4y ago> So if that's true, why the focus on geothermal? I mean I support research into renewables but it's a whole lot easier if, say, you can get the oil and gas industry to pay for your R&D, effectively. I believe that is what they are doing, with initial projects being related to gas exploration, and using that to refine the technology.
- u320 4y agoI've been following Quaise for a while and I have never seen any mention of such a plan. Oil and gas is into vertical drilling and fracking, which these people have little use for so the applications aren't that similar really. There are other geothermal startups doing more O&G-like drilling though.
- danans 4y agoThe CEO mentioned it during a recent interview, I think this one: https://www.woodmac.com/news/opinion/the-interchange-recharged-podcast-quaise-energy-digs-deep--into-the-world-of-geothermal/ https://www.woodmac.com/news/opinion/the-interchange-recharg...
- azinman2 4y agoWhat the article doesn’t address is the potential for earthquakes. I thought that was the limiting factor in a lot of deep geothermal drilling? Didn’t Iceland run into this?
- giarc 4y agoPerhaps you are thinking of fracking? In fracking they dig deep, horizontal wells and inject a water/sand mix into the well to fracture the rock. This method has resulted in measurable earthquakes.
- azinman2 4y agoThis is one example of a geothermal system leading to earthquakes: https://grapevine.is/news/2020/11/16/earthquakes-linked-to-power-plant-activity/ https://grapevine.is/news/2020/11/16/earthquakes-linked-to-p...
- skagenpilot 4y agoIt depends on the rock formation the project is targeting. If one targets a steam reservoir or a sedimentary rock formation, generaly things are ok (save for this one case in Germany where Earth started to rise [0]). In case you target hot (dry) rock that you need to fracture to increase the heat exchange surface, then more often than not you are going to induce seismicity. It's been well studied in Alsace and some small induced earthquake was felt in Strasbourg and attributed to nearby geothermal developments [1]. [0] https://m.dw.com/en/green-good-intentions-cause-chaos-in-two-german-towns/a-4473382 https://m.dw.com/en/green-good-intentions-cause-chaos-in-two... [1] https://comptes-rendus.academie-sciences.fr/geoscience/articles/10.5802/crgeos.71/ https://comptes-rendus.academie-sciences.fr/geoscience/artic...
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoRe-using coal plant grid infrastructure is a good idea. So good that it's regularly done today, with big energy consumers like data centres setting up in those areas to save money. Battery systems and solar are other initiatives that are currently re-using the existing lines. However, while it makes a nice hook for a story, I'm dubious of any energy system that relies on that minor cost saving in established grids to be viable.
- u320 4y agoGrid connections, turbines and BoP equipment reused from a coal plant is not a minor cost saving.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoWell, minor is a relative term, but regardless, my point is stronger the more the business case relies on this re-use. Solar can win on price with entirely new builds against already depreciated Coal plants. If you can't beat that price, then you are at best a complement to solar, and sticking solar, battery or synchronous condensors in the old coal plants might make more sense instead. See: Cost–benefit analysis of coal plant repurposing in developing countries https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3646443 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3646443
- mgoetzke 4y agoAlways fascinated by all of these approaches. Though I still am fascinated, that all energy available to us is derived from gravity in one way or another.
- boomboomsubban 4y ago>that all energy available to us is derived from gravity in one way or another. How so? Our major energy source is oil, where the energy comes from sunlight. And light's energy is from the electromagnetic fundamental force, not gravity.
- washbrain 4y agoWhere is the light generated? The sun. How did the sun form and why does it produce light? Gravity pulled some hydrogen into a ball, enough of it was there that gravity forced it to fuse.
- boomboomsubban 4y agoSure. Our energy is still derived from the photons released by the sun, even if the sun needed gravity to form. Gravity is necessary, but isn't the source of the energy.
- washbrain 4y agoI mean, I guess. The fusion that causes photons doesn't happen without gravity though.
- boomboomsubban 4y agoAnd fusion happens through an interaction of the weak nuclear force. Finally, without the strong nuclear force there wouldn't even be hydrogen atoms for any of this to happen. All four are necessary, the energy we use comes from electromagnetism.
- 4y ago
- 4ggr0 4y agoI have absolutely zero knowledge which would qualify me to talk about this topic. But based on what I know about our world and its ecosystems, I just can't imagine that drilling holes into earth and extracting it's heat can be a good idea when done in large scales. I could imagine that this seems reasonably safe right now, only for us to find out that it's actually a horrible thing to do. As has happened lots of times before. This is just a gut feeling and I'm not anti or whatever, it just feels...weird to me. No idea what the bad effects could be. Loss of internal heat, destabilization, sinkholes, loss of pressure, volcano eruptions back-firing through these holes. Admittedly, these examples sound like apocalypse movie scenarios. Which just validates my initial statement about me actually not knowing very much.
- sparsely 4y agoI haven't done any maths but I bet the order's of magnitude in terms of energy flows are wildly different for human usage vs solar + geothermal flows.
- cassianoleal 4y agoWouldn't the availability of energy at this scale drive people and organisations to use it?
- 4ggr0 4y agoThat could very well be, yes. Could also be like deforestation. Trees do die just like that, without our intervention. This benefits the forest. A couple of humans can chop wood in said forest and it will not affect it too much. But if whole cities and countries suddenly have to get their wood from this forest, it will disappear very fast. So maybe geothermal energy is not a risk when a couple of plants exist. But if humanity starts to rely on it too much and starts building geothermal plants like crazy, the damage could show. Maybe the damage only appears locally in the vicinity of these plants, which would still be worrying. I just want to disclose again that I am just spit-balling here.
- tresqotheq 4y ago> it just feels...weird to me. You are one person, and is sensible. Humanity as a whole, not so much so, sadly.
- RosanaAnaDana 4y agoMan MIT press and marketing is good.
- russfink 4y agoCan someone clarify the geochemistry for me? What happens to the rock vapor? Does it resolidify along the existing wall, or does it recondense into fine particulates, and are those particulates easier to remove than pieces of the solid rock itself? Then, can somebody clarify the physics for me- how far away can the target be from the energy source of the gyro-tron?
- Maximus9000 4y agoIt's discussed a little bit in this video (starting at 8:37). It sounds like it creates a glassy coating on the drill hole wall https://youtu.be/g8sjdOjNxIE?t=519 https://youtu.be/g8sjdOjNxIE?t=519
- daltont 4y agoI remember seeing bits of an old movie when I was young that used this has a plot device: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0059065/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0059065/
- Offsite_camp 4y agoFascinating. In the most basic of philosophies, extracting conserved energy from our planet doesn't really fix the problem. Even in the best case the unintended and unknown consequences will destroy any predictions as to how something like this plays out. But as far as band-aids go this one sounds like it could us a whole lot more time...
- f6v 4y agoIt’s just for a little while till we get fusion reactors up and running. /s
- h2odragon 4y agoMore geothermal: https://austinvernon.site/blog/geothermalnextsteps.html https://austinvernon.site/blog/geothermalnextsteps.html
- nsm 4y agoThe article is quite skeptical of Quaise: "While it is exciting to see the interest in geothermal, much of the effort leaves me skeptical. Quaise is staffed heavily by former Schlumberger employees. Schlumberger is known for being too expensive and impractical in many of its business units for shale. It is on-brand that they are building a laser-like drilling technology! Quaise deserves credit for correctly identifying the challenges in geothermal economics and pursuing a path with a greater than zero chance of success. But many of their assumptions are off base. The large, bureaucratic companies you work with at Schlumberger often do things like limit trip speed to 500'/hr. One time tripping fast caused a blowout by swabbing the hole, so no rig contracted by the company can trip fast even if the blowout risk is low. Smaller companies are ripping out of the hole at 4000'/hr. Tripping in granite is like tripping in a cased hole. Most companies will push the speed to the physical limits of the crew and rig. And even at 50,000' depths, on-bottom drilling will dominate total time (assuming a high-temperature motor is available). Both PDC bits and motors suffer from the vibration drilling in hard rock causes. There is a decent chance that PDC and elastomer-free motor assemblies will see longer runs at deep depths because the rock is more ductile." I have no background in energy at all, so I'm not qualified to comment on this at all. Just leaving it here as a counterpoint to the original article.
- ivan_gammel 4y agoI was looking for the reference to The Garin Death Ray book in comments, didn't found, so here it is: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Garin_Death_Ray https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Garin_Death_Ray The writer Aleksey Tolstoy came up with the idea of the laser-like machine that melts the rock in 1920s (maybe also influenced by H.G.Walls), when his science fiction book was first published. In this book a genial engineer Garin creates a beam that can be used both in mining (he wants to get the gold from the mantle, so uses American VC funding to set up a mining operation in Pacific) and as a weapon (he also wants to rule the world, so he uses his machine to destroy German and American competitors).
- ge96 4y agoThe Core movie had a gatling laser miner to get to the core of the Earth.
- jjk166 4y agoThe big issue with geothermal energy is that rock doesn't conduct heat very well. When you first bore a hole and pump some water down, it's easy to use the hot rocks to generate steam which can in turn drive a turbine, but doing so cools down the rock the water comes in contact with. Digging deeper, the rock starts out hotter, maybe it takes twice as long to exhaust the initial heat, but it's still going to happen in a matter of hours. Long term, a geothermal well can't extract heat faster than heat flows into the well from lower in the Earth. This heat flow rate is in the milliwatts per square meter range. Now with horizontal boring technology, a single drilling rig might be able to plumb a large area, but even if they got all the energy in a 10km radius, which is about 3 times what current technology is capable of, you're still looking at around 30 MW of thermal heat flux, which would at best produce about 20 MW of electricity. That's like 8 on shore windmills or a 100 acre solar plant. It's a little better given that the heat flow is continuous rather than intermittent, and multiple borehole locations can be connected by pipeline to a single generator station to keep capital costs down, but still this is not a lot of power. For context, to provide the electricity demand for kansas would require about 35% of the total geothermal flux into kansas. New Jersey's electricity demand is 7 times higher than what its geothermal heat flux could provide. For the whole US, electricity consumption is about 75% of geothermal heat flux if you ignore variations like the yellowstone hotspot. Geothermal certainly makes sense in certain locations where the heat flux is high and other power sources are problematic - for example iceland is probably the most ideal spot on earth. The technology for extracting geothermal power may also be useful for future efforts to control volcanism (though at this point such plans are highly speculative), so research is warranted. But it is unlikely to ever be more than a minor slice of the world's energy supply, and certainly anyone claiming to solve the issue by just digging deeper is selling snake oil.
- yayr 4y ago> For context, to provide the electricity demand for kansas would require about 35% of the total geothermal flux into kansas. New Jersey's electricity demand is 7 times higher than what its geothermal heat flux could provide. For the whole US, electricity consumption is about 75% of geothermal heat flux if you ignore variations like the yellowstone hotspot. It would be great if you can provide a bit more details on those assumptions. Thanks
- engineer_22 4y agoHow do they propose to remove the vaporized material from the bore hole?
- digdugdirk 4y agoThe best part about vaporization is that there's nothing left to remove.
- engineer_22 4y agoI can't tell if you're serious or not. If that's true, they're proposing to convert mass to energy?
- rexreed 4y agoMy understanding of the term vaporization means turning a solid into a vapor... so that implies there's nothing substantial left after vaporization that can't be otherwise removed simply through ventilation.
- engineer_22 4y agoMy understanding is they propose to excite the material with electromagnetic waves until it undergoes a phase shift, solid to liquid to gas. So then they have superheated gaseous rock in the bottom of the bore hole, how do they get it out? Conservation of mass: it must go somewhere. Ventilation isn't so simple. The gaseous rock will condense, then harden on the walls of the ventilation tube. Or, maybe it reacts with the materials of your down-hole equipment.
- yetihehe 4y agoIf they put enough high pressure chilled air or water to cool that gas, it may change into lots of ash before it condenses on the tube.
- psadri 4y agoShould we be concerned about cooling down the earth's core over the long term? I'd rather if we focus our efforts on renewables (basically anything that gets energy from sunlight - solar, wind, biomass)
- dan353hehe 4y agoA similar question was asked in a another geothermal post. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32134418 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32134418 The tldr being that there is sufficient heat and we don’t need to worry about running out even if we tapped into a significant portion of it.
- jillesvangurp 4y agoShort answer: no. There's not enough time until our sun goes super nova in a few billion years to trickle cool the planet's core in any appreciable way by siphoning of really tiny amounts of energy.
- Ken_At_EM 4y agoI really don't love being negative all the time, but this project is going nowhere. Boring rock in this way is a permanent "we're 5-10 years away research project." They've coupled a never ending research project with the idea of "hey there's already some power lines here" which is the smallest of efficiency gains in the big picture.
- benevol 4y agoThat's nice. But there's an even easier, cleaner and even mobile source of "free" energy - plus, it's fully open-sourced (no patents, fees, limitations, etc.): https://www.KryonEngine.org https://www.KryonEngine.org
- dang 4y agoPlease stop posting these links. You've done it a ton lately and I'm afraid it's crossing into a kind of spamming.
- benevol 4y agoThe idea is this: 1. The invention works, it WILL be built and sold, and you know how much revenue potential this means. 2. HN readers (even YCombinator as a VC) should be given a shot at "the next big thing". 3. If you guys really insist in not wanting to be part of this, then so be it. Don't be too hard on yourself in a few months, though.
- brianwawok 4y agoYou argue with the mod about are we really sure we don’t want your spam?
- dang 4y agoEven if you're right, it's clearly impossible for the point to get an interesting discussion on HN. It immediately turns into an off topic flamewar. Therefore, please stop.
- theptip 4y agoPaging u/Animats, who had some interesting thoughts on a previous write-up of Quaise which had less info. I think he mentioned that gyrotrons had not been deployed for this use-case and that should make us skeptical because sticking one on the end of a multi-km long drill bit sounds Hard(tm). An adviser of Quaise (an MIT research engineer) claims: > “This will happen quickly once we solve the immediate engineering problems of transmitting a clean beam and having it operate at a high energy density without breakdown,” explains Woskov, who is not formally affiliated with Quaise but serves as an advisor. “It’ll go fast because the underlying technology, gyrotrons, are commercially available. You could place an order with a company and have a system delivered right now — granted, these beam sources have never been used 24/7, but they are engineered to be operational for long time periods. In five or six years, I think we’ll have a plant running if we solve these engineering problems. I’m very optimistic.” Interested in what others think here. Seems overly optimistic to me. It's a really elegant solution though if it works; the idea of boring a hole in an existing coal plant and repurposing the old steam turbine & transmission equipment sounds like it could really lower the cost.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Ope_Welp 4y agoFantastic. Geothermal power has such potential. "The amount of heat within 10 000 meters of the earth's surface is estimated to contain 50 000 times more energy than all oil and gas resources worldwide." - The International Renewable Energy Agency