6 ms·
Sounds similar to Boeing. You begin to wonder when these kind of lessons start entering management textbooks.
by amelius 4y ago
Sounds similar to Boeing. You begin to wonder when these kind of lessons start entering management textbooks.
- jimkleiber 4y agoI was just gonna say that the Intel case may fit well in this book called Obliquity[0], which ironically discusses Boeing. I believe it said that Boeing was less profitable when it focused on increasing profits and more profitable when it focused on improving engineering. [0]: https://www.johnkay.com/product/obliquity/ https://www.johnkay.com/product/obliquity/
- spamizbad 4y agoI've noticed a pattern of how executives approach this: 1) When looking for more profits/revenue at a technology company, they'll often either try to push an R&D "big bet" to market half-baked, in hopes of it pulling in new revenue OR put the screws to product and engineering to churn out some "quick wins" to give them some momentum. 2) When focusing more on engineering, it's often because they're either distracted by other challenges faced by the organization outside of engineering OR they are up against an existential threat that mandates engineering investment and letting them steer the strategy somewhat.
- alexashka 4y agoThey can't. It'd undermine the very existence of the ruling elite class that doesn't know how to do anything, besides 'managing' by following a magic formula taught at Harvard, Stanford, etc. The problem is the existence of a business management layer as an idea - it's an attempt to get back to the good old days of feudalism, whose chief characteristics are nepotism, stagnation, corruption and nihilism, now that we've gotten rid of the mental pacifier of 'heaven' for the oppressed and hell for the ruling elites (religion).
- jjtheblunt 4y agothis is the most resonant comment I've seen in months, as it entirely fits my experiences in engineering inside Apple, and later Amazon and Facebook. the inner sanctum of very flat Apple was as far from feudalism as could be, for my several years, and it functioned like a very performant ecosystem of engineering. This diametrically contrasts precisely with Amazon engineering, where I saw all the horrors of feudalism and generalized nepotism (racism for example, sexism promoting incapable people to fit quotas, and flagrant corruption). Facebook was somewhere more like Apple but not in its DNA...just in the imitation is flattery sense.
- recyclelater 4y agoYes but I would argue Amazon has better software than apple by a long shot. Ignoring how you felt as a worker out what you read Amazon employees feel like, Amazon has better results.
- adamc 4y agoWhy do you think that is?
- recyclelater 4y agoAs in can I justify my claim, or what are the reasons that Amazon produces better software? I would say the former is a qualitative statement and I am going to have a hard time backing it up with facts, and the latter I have no idea. I run into non stop issues when interacting with apple software as an app producer, from Xcode to iOS to App Store to App Store connect. Their apis are pretty horrible, both the reliability and the design. As an end user of apple products, I regularly run into odd software problems with my MacBook and iPhone. Every CarPlay experience I have had is buggy, both from the actual CarPlay connectivity as well as apples own CarPlay enabled apps. Apple Watch is a horrible nightmare to make anything more complicated than a simple remote display. I could go on and on. However on the Amazon side of things I have never experienced a significant bug, aside from the audible app freezing on occasion when interacting with CarPlay. I blame apple though based off how their own apps work. I say this as an extensive consumer of Amazon products both as a business owner, developer, and SRE, as well as an extensive user of Amazon consumer products. All this being said I don’t like amazon as a business, I can find flaws in their decisions, but they are business decision flaws not just straight buggy products.
- roflyear 4y agoThe nepotism is unreal in every company. Where I work the CEO hired a family member who makes more than me as a senior engineer and works 2-3 hours a day. Amazing.
- cjbgkagh 4y agoI read a lot of creative accounting case studies and am repeatedly surprised when others fall for the same simple tricks over and over again. At some point I have to assume willful ignorance. I’m sure there are plenty of case studies in text books that management could read. Either they don’t read them or they take away the wrong message. Don’t forget the execs at these companies probably cashed in some big bonuses.
- throwaway4good 4y agoThe accountants took over the company, and the good engineers left. I have witnessed this with other companies; and I am sorry they are never going to return to what they once were. It is kind of obvious when you chat with all the sad employees: Why didn't you leave? And then you realise that the ones, who are left, are the ones who couldn't get a job elsewhere.
- formerkrogemp 4y ago> The accountants took over the company, and the good engineers left. As an accountant, I would quibble with this aspersion and lay the blame with management and other, broader issues. > It is kind of obvious when you chat with all the sad employees: Why didn't you leave? And then you realise that the ones, who are left, are the ones who couldn't get a job elsewhere. This seems true of many companies. Many of us are just playing musical chairs with our careers and jobs trying to find that job that doesn't suck.
- throwaway4good 4y agoI am sorry for insulting accountants and I realise what wrote is too harsh (but hey this is the internet so ...). And you cannot have engineers running everything because then you will have a half-built Concorde and a bankrupt company. But there is a balance. And if that balance tips for too long, you end up with the whole organisation content with just doing maintenance. And when that happens there is just no going back.
- formerkrogemp 4y ago> I am sorry for insulting accountants and I realise what wrote is too harsh (but hey this is the internet so ...). No worries. I didn't mean to sound angry. I appreciate the apology, didn't think it was necessary, and understand where you're coming from. I think you have valid points. I am very bad at reading and writing tone in quick comments online. I agree that having accountants and mba types in charge isn't a great idea most of the time or that accountants are necessarily the best people on average, but I am wee bit biased here against such blanket statements regarding my profession, as an accountant anyways.
- georgeecollins 4y agoI went to business school. The management textbooks used to tell you that steady profits were the most important thing. When I think about the things I was taught, particularly this incredible reverence for GE, I laugh.
- pyuser583 4y agoInteresting. The introductory business courses I took said revenue was far more important than profit. Is that not true?
- cdf 4y agoI suppose the business courses you took are tech startup oriented. For tech companies until recently, the business is valued at roughly 10x revenue, so revenue is the all important metric. Profit is not important. This is why the barely profitable Salesforce and the non profit enterprise named Uber is worth so much in the stock market. For traditional businesses, the metrics are profit and in particular profit margin (profit/revenue), so more revenue at same profit is bad. And other metrics like ROCE (Return on Capital Employed) and FCF (Free Cash Flow)... which incentivise lots of debt if you can borrow cheap but discourage capital investment. This is obviously antithesis of tech startups.
- georgeecollins 4y agoI guess the point is that you can make both cases. They would argue that a company with dominant sales and no profits could be bought by bought by a smaller competitor with profits. But they had never seen VCs like today and could never conceive companies that could go for years with no profits and maintain high stock valuation. The world changes. So there's your answer: sometimes!
- Throwawayaerlei 4y ago"The management textbooks [at my business school] used to tell you that steady profits were the most important thing." That's stark raving mad. It is for example one of the clearest signs someone is running a Ponzi scheme. Which would seem to transfer over to this not quite as dishonest domain. Reverence for GE, a company doing technical things that started stack ranking and firing their employees.... Plus eventually got first their fingers and then last time I checked their whole body burned by going into financial businesses, very much not a core competence.