11 ms·
> As CEO, I approved and took responsibility for our ambitious staffing trajectory—this is on me Reminder that Vlad Tenev received $800M in compensation in 202
by paxys 4y ago
> As CEO, I approved and took responsibility for our ambitious staffing trajectory—this is on me
Reminder that Vlad Tenev received $800M in compensation in 2021. In the same year the company made terrible bets on crypto and banking, took an irreversible reputation hit among its core user base because of the GME fiasco, had multiple user data breaches, was subject to several investigations and was fined hundreds of millions by the SEC and other regulatory bodies, and saw its share price drop by 90%.
At this point "taking responsibility" would mean resigning and letting someone more competent fix his messes.
- sn_master 4y agohow much of that $800M was in stock vs cash?
- arcticbull 4y agoThe only thing that matters is how much he sold vs held. Cash is cash no matter how derived.
- mikeyouse 4y agoHe's sold ~$55M worth: https://finance.yahoo.com/screener/insider/TENEV%20VLADIMIR https://finance.yahoo.com/screener/insider/TENEV%20VLADIMIR
- adrr 4y agoIt's all stock from a 2019 agreement that vested on a liquidty event. His cash comp is $250k for that year.
- pcurve 4y agoYep, talk is cheap. Of course he's responsible, whether he admits it or not. If not willing to step down, then give up pay.
- Spivak 4y agoGood lord, if I resigned every time I caused a production issue my resume length would triple. You are allowed to admit you made a mistake without publicly self flagellating. This is some straight puritanical shit.
- paxys 4y agoDoes your company also do mass layoffs whenever you cause a production issue?
- Spivak 4y agoThe impact doesn’t matter, the magnitude of the mistake does. * If I take all reasonable precautions and bad thing still happens — not a fuckup. * If try my best but make an honest mistake like being forgetful — minor fuckup. * If I try my best but don’t know something crucial — minor fuckup. If I am paid to be an expert on that thing — major fuckup. * If I deliberately choose to forego necessary precautions because that’s effort it’ll be fine — major fuckup or legal trouble depending on the field. * If I purposely cause bad thing to happen — legal trouble. * If I choose to take a calculated risk in good faith after getting the advice of my board and my advisors and bad thing happens — not even a fuckup. How bad the bad thing is doesn’t matter except at the margins “no harm done” or actual injury. Downsizing a company does not meet that bar. Being in a leadership position shouldn’t be a job of calling coins in the air and betting your job you get it right.
- lopatin 4y ago“crypto up plz” being the calculated, good faith, board approved risk? I’m not saying it was illegal. All I’m saying is the people who paid for the bad bets (with their livelihoods) were not the same ones who made the bets in the first place.
- Spivak 4y agoNot my company not my bets. I’m paid to staff a post at a company, the CEO laying people off has no more impact on or responsibility to my livelihood than I do to the workers of food truck I frequent. As a worker I take literally no risk except “one day they might stop paying me.” I am not impacted at all by how the company is doing. And if you’re a stock holder then you should love this move since it’s in your best interest.
- V__ 4y agoIf you crash a company against the wall resulting in such a disaster and having to cut so much staff, resigning isn't enough. CEO's should have to pay back big parts of their compensation.
- a-dub 4y agoexecutives should be compensated for the performance of the company in the future, not the current quarter or year. this is the board's fault for failing to set effective incentives.
- lupire 4y agoDid the board members pay the CEO with their own money? Or some bag holders? Will the board return their board fees?
- gruez 4y agoIsn't that what a vesting period is supposed to enforce?
- a-dub 4y agoyeah it needs to be stretched more. people talk about ESG... imagine what the world would look like if energy company executives were compensated based on the health of the company (and by proxy the health of the economy) ten years in the future... also maybe more tax rules along the lines of long/short cap gains that reduce the short term time value of money.
- gruez 4y ago>people talk about ESG What you described is supposed to be part of the "G" in "ESG".
- guntars 4y agoExactly, there should be a multi-year lockout period where the CEOs cannot sell their stock. If the potential hires don't like it, well, cry me a river. Plenty of people would still take the job, especially if they are interested in building a long-term company.
- cjrp 4y agoTaking responsibility would mean returning a significant portion of that compensation.
- systemvoltage 4y agoWait, shouldn't this be returned back to whom the money belonged (investors)?
- munk-a 4y agoInvestment comes with risk - that's why you can make money at it. I think it's fair to say if this business is struggling it'd be more equitable to share the excess compensation with rank and file employees that are being deprived of their livelihood but unfortunately they likely have no "right" to that compensation with how various employee contracts are structured. It's usually the case in situations like this that the CEO getting a golden parachute is less expensive to the company than trying to get out of paying them. Companies, of course, would prefer a world in which no one had to be paid so all this thread is sort of a socialist pipedream where the havenots might actually get treated fairly since if the money wasn't going to the CEO it'd likely end up straight back in the pockets of investors.
- systemvoltage 4y agoAll these people had salaries in excess of $180k I presume + stock compensation. Sorry, but they do not fall in the category of people that were exploited. I firmly believe in at will employment. In this case, the CEO exploited the investors, whether it is VC firms, institutional or private investors by making an error in the judgement of hiring needs. Of course there is a risk in investment, but when CEO's make major mistakes while paying themselves $800M in compensation; investors should seek relief.
- closewith 4y ago> All these people had salaries in excess of $180k I presume + stock compensation. Sorry, but they do not fall in the category of people that were exploited. The gilded cage is freedom argument?
- munk-a 4y agoThere are talks of "late stage capitalism" all over the place - I think CEO compensation is one of the biggest hallmarks of it. Capitalism is supposed to naturally reward value creation to incentivize further value creation - somehow we've found ourselves in a situation where folks on the bottom of the pyramid aren't going to get incentivized for efficient labour no matter how much value they create - while folks at the top will be gloriously celebrated for even the most abject failures. Most people are doing their best to be productive and most of their managers are trying to reward these efforts with recognition beyond a "thanks" but it becomes more difficult to do when we have an insane wealth sink at the top of our economy.
- tomrod 4y agoEhhhh.. Economic rents and scarcity of talent with solid networks still apply to execs as much as pro sports. You don't buy an exec because they are brilliant or hard working, you buy them for their network and how much they can grow the the business relative to compensation. At least in theory.
- elihu 4y agoMy own theory is that executive compensation serves a purpose that generally isn't said out loud. Usually compensation comes mostly in the form of stock, and the real reason for the large amounts is to reassure investors that if the executive finds him or herself in a situation where they have to make a choice between what's good for employees or what's good for shareholders, they'll be strongly incentivized to choose the latter. It follows that if a CEO were to refuse stock compensation they'd be at risk of being fired by the board of directors, because owning stock is an unspoken qualification for the job.
- jrochkind1 4y agoI realize it's not something that happens, but I would say "taking responsibility" would mean taking, oh, I dunno, $50M of that $800M in compensation in 2021, and distributing it to those laid off? (How the hell is your life different with $750M instead of $800M anyway?)
- eatonphil 4y agoLots of execs take "only" $100ks of compensation in salary and the rest in stock.
- sianemo 4y agoHe's perfectly capable of giving stock to these employees as well.
- 88913527 4y agoIt's simple to say we'd be more charitable if we had incomes 1,000x or more our current annual compensation, but I do genuinely wonder if I'd be different. Would I be greedy, would I care about doing right to the laid off employees-- it's hard to imagine how crossing that bridge might change people.
- sianemo 4y agoI'm not going to try to justify how I would act, or how anyone else should act, were I to have a compensation package putting me easily in the top 0.1% of society, but we can collectively dispense with the notion that certain types of compensation (i.e. stocks) must necessarily be prohibitively harder for a CEO to give up than just money.
- selectodude 4y agoThe CEO of Robinhood would need to file a public form with the SEC if he wanted to sell any of his shares. People watch that and say "hmmm, why is the CEO of Robinhood wanting to sell shares? I wonder what he knows that we don't" and the stock goes down on that information. Stock is absolutely more difficult to liquidate for a CEO.
- akomtu 4y ago"With big money comes big responsibility, so I took that responsibility and I'm going to take more of it next year. As a result of my increased responsibility, 25% of our staff will be given new opportunities this year and 25% more will see even more opportunities next year. Stay tuned."
- BurningFrog 4y agoI read this as saying "This is not happening because you did a bad job, it's because I did a bad job". An important thing to mention at a layoff.
- lupire 4y agoThat's what a layoff is. Otherwise it's a firing for cause
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kaczordon 4y agoNo one’s forcing those employees to stay working there. If he’s that bad people can just leave and work for a company that they like.
- VoodooJuJu 4y agoThe beauty of corporatism - unlimited upside and no downside.
- somehnacct3757 4y agoThe Shopify layoff also contained this phrasing. Shows how tone-deaf these CEOs are. Shopify's version: > Ultimately, placing this bet was my call to make and I got this wrong. Now, we have to adjust. As a consequence, we have to say goodbye to some of you today.
- prh8 4y agoI commented about this when it happened and was met with vitriol. Nice to see people here have some sense.
- fipar 4y agoThis is basically the Lord Farquaad line: "some of you may die, but it is a price I am willing to pay" I don't think they're tone-deaf as much as they don't care. Which reminds me of another line, this time from Kids in the Hall (from the Girl Drink Drunk sketch): (from memory, so may not be exact) "I can't help to feel responsible for this, but then again, I can't help not to care: that's just who I am")
- edouard-harris 4y agoNote that the complete, non-truncated quote [1] says: "Ultimately, placing this bet was my call to make and I got this wrong. Now, we have to adjust. As a consequence, we have to say goodbye to some of you today and I’m deeply sorry for that." Emphasis added, but perhaps some part of this apparent tone-deafness might be attributed to the omission? [1] https://news.shopify.com/changes-to-shopifys-team https://news.shopify.com/changes-to-shopifys-team
- interpol_p 4y agoI question "we have to say goodbye" I worked for a small business. The CEO and other executives were generally ethical people. When revenue went down, the C-level executives took a pay cut to ensure others could stay. They knew they could weather it better than their employees. Their salaries were always some of the lowest even before that, because they had a stake in the business that the employees did not have. Given how much money this person makes, how much of a safety net they likely have compared to their employees, it doesn't make much sense that they do not redistribute their personal wealth to help the people they are "deeply sorry" to "say goodbye to"
- memish 4y agoReminder that Vlad Tenev founded Robinhood, an incredibly successful app that disrupted an industry and is still best in class. There really is no replacement for a founder CEO.
- adambyrtek 4y agoWould you say the same about Travis Kalanick or Adam Neumann?
- Phlarp 4y agoAnd Elizabeth Holmes
- adambyrtek 4y agoNot the best example since she wasn't replaced.
- SpicyLemonZest 4y agoI would say that Kalanick and Neumann's mistakes were quite a bit worse than overhiring.
- adambyrtek 4y agoSure, what I meant is that founder CEOs are not as irreplaceable as it might seem.
- spullara 4y agoTo be fair, Travis was not the founding CEO of Uber. That was Ryan Graves.
- truejamesbond 4y ago
- bdcravens 4y agoNot true that there's no replacement for a founder CEO. Creating a company and growing it to viability is a much different skillset than running a company of a given size. Many startups have actually eventually suffered because they didn't transition.
- adam_arthur 4y agoBrokerage is such a competitive space, their valuation never made any sense. And big money players would never use Robinhood over Schwab et all
- ramesh31 4y ago> And big money players would never use Robinhood over schwab et all Their entire business model is PFOF [0]. That is, a huge fucking scam against retail. [0] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/paymentoforderflow.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/paymentoforderflow.asp
- fullshark 4y agoWhy would a typical retail investor prefer commissions to PFOF? Seems like a much better deal.
- ramesh31 4y ago>Why would a typical retail investor prefer commissions to PFOF? It's about incentives. I am more than happy to pay $0.65 to Fidelity for my options trades, because I know that Fidelity's incentive is to get me the best possible price. Commission fees are absolutely negligible compared to price improvement with a real broker.
- fullshark 4y agoI don't remember exactly but i thought Robinhood was first about how it had "free" trades and then they basically forced all their competitors to race to the bottom and lower fees in response. For some retail traders it was like pay $10 to get a few shares of some stock you want to buy. Pretty terrible deal in comparison to PFOF. You don't sound like a typical investor so I get why you might care deeply about pennies at price execution. But I think most retail investors really don't care about PFOF and prefer it to commissions. And some of these retail firms are basically about just getting your stock trading business so they can funnel you towards professional portfolio managers who will just take a cut of your savings for no real value...that is probably even worse than the PFOF business model imo.
- jmyeet 4y ago> ... took an irreversible reputation hit among its core user base because of the GME fiasco God I'm so sick of hearing this. It comes from people who seriously don't know what happened. let me explain: RH had (and still has) a service that you can trade immediately on signing up and sending funds rather than waiting for them to clear. This mostly works out fine because people buy different things and you have the underlying assets as security so it tends to work out, meaning it's not a risk of a huge loss. Put another way: the convenience of RH lending you money (because that's actually what's happening) is counterbalanced by the additional business they get. When GME popped off, they got a ton of sign ups to buy GME. This wasn't people using their own money to buy GME. This was RH lending you money to buy GME. And suddenly it didn't balance out. RH actually had a huge long GME position effectively. They actually borrowed a billion dollars to cover that and that was insufficient. So they stopped lending money to buy GME to avoid insolvency. Remember too that they are lending you money on the promise you would fund the account. If people bought GME at $100 and it dropped to $30, RH would be left holding the bag as a significant percentage of people would simply avoid the loss by not funding their accounts. RH may have recourse to pursue that in court but that's going to get expensive and is a losing option all around. That's literally all it was. Some people were so delusional about what was going to happen with GME. They thought that since the open short interest exceeded the stock actively traded, the shares were going to go to infinity or something like that. That was never going to happen.
- prh8 4y agoThey also prevented trading by people who had long running, funded accounts. It was a mess and it wasn't only GME.
- 88913527 4y agoThe fact that other brokerages could handle the counterparty risk with stronger financials than Robinhood (eg: by continuing to permit securities purchases) does highlight reputational risk in that you're clearly running an inferior brokerage compared to the competition. Ordinary market conditions wouldn't add visibility to this fact, but unfortunately there was always the risk and the situation had occurred.
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoRobinhood's executive compensation clawback policy just FYI: In March 2021, our board of directors adopted a clawback policy effective upon the closing of this offering. Under our clawback policy, our board of directors may recover incentive compensation from an executive officer in the event of (i) a restatement of our financial statements or a material error in the calculation of one or more performance-based measures used to determine the amount of such compensation or (ii) the executive officer’s “detrimental conduct” (as defined in our clawback policy) that results in an excess performance payout, results in legal proceedings or causes us material financial or reputational harm ref. https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1783879/000162828021013318/robinhoods-1.htm https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1783879/000162828021...
- gnu8 4y agoI'm wondering how much of that language is common to all publicly traded companies and how often the clawback policy is actually activated. Maybe the board sees enforcing the clause to be detrimental because it would impair their ability to hire another CEO, or it would have a chilling effect on the performance of CEOs in general. The board members are all wealthy themselves so this isn't a decision that affects their lives in any material way, except for their likelihood of being appointed to other company boards in the future. They basically meet in a fancy conference room once every six weeks to eat an expensive lunch and play-act at running a company.
- remflight 4y agoI said the same thing. Taking responsibility doesn’t mean “I acknowledge that this is on me.” Of course it is. How about some accountability? How about getting your pay clawed back etc? Just “taking responsibility” is lip service.
- jonas21 4y agoAre you talking about the ~$800M in stock-based compensation described here [1]? Nearly all of that only vests if Robinhood stock hits price targets between $120 and $300 per share. The remainder requires a price of $50.75 to be sustained for 60 days. Since none of these goals have been met, Vlad has not received any of it. And unless the company turns around dramatically - it's currently around $9/share - it's likely he never will. [1] https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1783879/000178387922000090/fscmix-robinhood2022proxy.htm https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1783879/000178387922...
- BeetleB 4y agoExactly - all these articles about CEO compensation are misleading. Case in point: Intel's CEO's 2021 salary was reported as almost $180M. In reality, he got only about $10M. He hit literally none of the targets that would allow him to get the rest of the compensation (although in theory he has a few years to hit those targets).
- groby_b 4y agoTo be fair, if I could get paid $10M for not hitting any of my goals, I sure wouldn't complain.
- dylan604 4y agoTo be fair, I don't think the CEO is complaining either
- drunkpotato 4y agoHe doesn't even pay people to complain for him, they're so deluded they do it for free.
- kemitchell 4y agoIt’s case by case. I have seen some accurate CEO comp headlines. Some publications certainly bat better than others. As for Intel: $10m a year is still a lot of money. I have also heard that targets are occasionally hit. ;-D
- quickthrower2 4y agoAn article I read on HN talked about the difference between being nice (saying something to appease someone) vs. kind (doing something that benefits another person). It mentioned on the NYC Subway you will see a guy help with a mother's pram but not say a word. No small talk. No smile. They are kind but not nice. Assuming the above definition, I would say this CEO is "nice" but not "kind".
- Closi 4y agoSince when did giving millions to some bankers being laid off become the signal of being kind? They are getting severance packages with two months of further employment, and while that is not ideal for them at the individual level, I don't see why they need charity any more than anyone else. Being kind would actually be donating the money for truly charitable purposes to help the poorest.
- quickthrower2 4y agoI agree. Being kind is not keeping it for yourself. Also the "some bankers" classification. I remember in the 2008 crash people getting angry at their tellers because they are "bankers". Yes they are, but they probably don't earn that much, dude.
- kevinpet 4y agoHis job is to make big ambitious bets. These didn't pay off. CEOs are not hired (or retained) for the benefit of employees or customers, they are hired by boards for the benefit of shareholders, and shareholders in Robinhood were not buying for stable reliable dividends.
- oldgradstudent 4y agoShareholders have a residual interest. Debts, taxes, regulations, suppliers, and other liabilities and requirements come first. The CEOs making ambitious bets should take those into account.
- throwfh80h82 4y agoAt this point, unfortunately, "take responsibility" it just a PR phrase. It doesn't come with any consequences, responsibility, or costs to the individual in the corporate class.
- somewhereoutth 4y agoThis is why we need wealth taxes. Confiscate the lot.
- misiti3780 4y agoYa, the board and the VCs didnt care about that at the time.
- happyopossum 4y ago> Reminder that Vlad Tenev received $800M in compensation in 2021 No he did not in fact receive $800m. You seem to know a lot about the performance of RH stock, but you’ve completely missed the fact that the poor performance means he won’t be seeing that $800m worth of stock - almost none in fact. He got a comp plan that could get him up to that much in stock if certain goals were met, but none of those have been met so he hasn’t gotten any of that $$. Suffice it to say, if he had met those goals, they wouldn’t be laying off anyone, as their stock price would be sky high.
- kaidon 4y ago> laying off anyone Laying off 23% of staff is _literally_ how he will make the stock go up enough to get a good % of his compensation, if not 100%.
- ikeboy 4y ago>For Tenev to actually receive the full compensation, Robinhood stock would need to trade up to $300 per share over the next seven years, the company said in the filing. It closed today at $9.23, so it's a fair guess that he's not getting anywhere near 800M value.
- mylons 4y agoi’m positive vlad feels like he did something hard by “taking responsibility.” but he loses nothing and some former employees are now in a precarious financial situation. his skin in the game is nothing compared to theirs.
- UncleMeat 4y agoIt is worth repeating this. 800M is more money in a single day than a very large number of people make in an entire lifetime.
- fuckstick 4y agoWat? What does the timescale of a single day have to do with anything?
- adrr 4y agoVlad Tenev received $800m for taking the company public per an RSU agreement the board gave him in 2019 and $800m was when the stock price was $50+. Nows its only worth $130m. Banking is standard with discount brokers, you have a sweep account that is probably on an FDIC insured bank. GME issue was a lack of capital to settle GME trades. They owed $3 billion to NSCC. Robinhood was insolvent but people always flock to conspiracy theories on why Robinhood pulled GME trades. I am curious what would be the better decision for robinhood with the GME issue? I don't use Robinhood but do benefit that my trades at other discount brokers are now free.
- colechristensen 4y agoDidn't etrade and/or other frims do the same halting of GME because they couldn't cover the overnight options capital requirements? Ultimately RH and others didn't have the ability to raise the crazy amount of capital they needed to cover trades over a very short time and instead of breaking these requirements and receiving the consequences (getting taken over by SIPC? or whatever, I don't actually know) they halted trading. Failure to predict an unprecedented future, I suppose.
- tjr225 4y agoAnd giving a million bux to every one of the saps that got laid off. He's a crook.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- throwaway27727 4y agoHow much of that compensation was in Robinhood stock, which dropped 90%? How much of it vested? These aren't rhetorical questions, I'd like to actually know these details.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- x86x87 4y agoWhen I was a young boy in Bulgaria people would be laid off left and right and nobody complained.
- fairity 4y ago> At this point "taking responsibility" would mean resigning and letting someone more competent fix his messes. Your derision is probably blinding you from the solution that's most likely to produce the best outcome -- him learning from his mistakes & cleaning up his own mess. Resigning won't be a magical fix-all. It's actually ironic that your definition of "taking responsibility" is him quitting and having someone else clean up his mess. Paying back a portion of his stock based compensation from 2021 or forfeiting his comp going forward would make sense though.
- honkycat 4y agoAt first I was like "jesus christ this is going to be a bloodbath" and then I read your post and thought "huh yeah i guess it makes sense they are firing people."
- ulfw 4y agoI hate this BS lately with CEOs claiming it's "on them" and "their bad decisions" as if that somehow makes it all okay. There is NEVER any repercussions for CEOs when they fire/lay off no matter how many people. So if it's on you, how about YOU lose your job? No? Oh well then.