5 ms·
Climate endgame: exploring catastrophic climate change scenarios
- felixmeziere 4y agoAmazing. I wish there were more discussions about this most important topic on HN, and more generally on describing how we are depleting earth’s resources and dispersing them everywhere, transforming it into a giant pile of garbage (gaseous garbage in the case of GHG). Sadly, climate change is not even the only imminent threat, when 60% of vertebrae have disappeared in 50 years for example, among many others… We need to invent a new storytelling for society to have an organized energetic and material de-growth, so that we don’t have to undergo a disorganized one, forced upon us by nature, that would be orders of magnitude worse. Technology can be a huge help in organizing this de-growth, so I guess HN could be a great forum for collectively imagining how to do it!
- logifail 4y ago> Technology can be a huge help in organizing this de-growth[..] Errm, what? Apologies for appearing to be negative, but isn't technology one of the main contributors to the mess we're in?
- solardev 4y ago
- felixmeziere 4y agoAbsolutely agree, I didn’t want people to fixate on this fact so I preferred focusing on the positive and not mention it, but technology alone without deciding collectively how to repurpose it (this is a huge philosophical/cultural change where we need to decide together that black Friday and going to space for fun are lame, for example) is not going to be the solution. As you said so far we have observed it has only made the problem worse, year after year after year! And with the little margin we have left, it’s irrational to take the bet it’ll change by itself and just “improving”.
- eej71 4y agoI think one of the challenges that the movement faces is that since the 1960's, there have been many disaster claims - sometimes bordering on the fantastical - and they simply don't come to pass. Not sure why this go-around should be given more credibility.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoyou know how in the boy who cried wolf, there is a wolf.
- pc86 4y agoIf that's your takeaway I don't think you're getting from the story what you're supposed to.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoI mean if we're going for snarky takedowns how about "if you identify most strongly with the attention-seeking liar in the story I don't think I need your advice." But more seriously you can take more than one lesson from a tale. "A threat may be real even if the one relaying it lacks credibility" is not a neat or satisfying morality lesson to feed to children, but it remains true in my experience.
- Sharlin 4y agoFor the past 20 to 30 years, the climate science community has been consistently nothing but EXTREMELY conservative in all their predictions in order to not being labeled as alarmist. Newsflash: they were STILL labeled alarmist AND also ignored because whatever happens in 50 years is Someone Else's Problem, can't be bothered to think beyond the next quartal or election cycle. Look! A shiny new thing! Consume! Consume! Now it's becoming clear that almost everything is happening way faster than the conservative models estimated. Humanity just. can't. win. against itself.
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago
- deepdriver 4y agoDe-growth means lowering humanity's total energy output. Lowering our total energy output means lowering humanity's average life expectancy, quality of life, and the size of our overall economic pie. These are all negative side-effects with comparable potential for societal destabilization as the effects of rising sea levels or increasing global temperatures. There are solutions to climate change that avoid de-growth and its many negative consequences, such as increasing our investment in nuclear energy. Some states already see things this way, such as China, where the government has announced plans to build 150 new reactors by 2050: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2021-11-02/china-climate-goals-hinge-on-440-billion-nuclear-power-plan-to-rival-u-s https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2021-11-02/china-cli...
- badtension 4y agoYour reasoning is flawed, technically if we make things last longer, be repairable, skip vacations on the other side of the planet and stop buying so much cheap plastic crap we would most definitely "degrow" but the quality of life would at least remain unchanged. Capitalism is a beast that needs constant feeding, it doesn't do much good in many cases, it's just growth for the sake of it.
- bwestergard 4y agoKate Soper makes the case that quality of life would improve significantly if we took these steps. The carbon-intensive "good life" leaves us time poor and stressed.
- felixmeziere 4y agoPreach
- cortesoft 4y agoYou can argue how much a change in quality of life it is, but not being able to travel or buy cheap plastic things is certainly a reduction in quality of life.
- 4y ago
- nradov 4y agoYou aren't going to get anyone to embrace de-growth by telling stories. Instead, find ways that technology can enable continued growth while simultaneously decreasing environmental impact. If you force people to pick between global warming versus a major step down in living standards, a lot of them are just going to say screw it and pick global warming.
- felixmeziere 4y agoEveryone tells themselves stories. Like « what’s cool in life is to try and be a billionaire so I can get a private jet and everybody treat me like a king », or, at the level of a country « we should build entire new cities and airports and stimulate growth to increase GDP which is the main metric measuring our success » or, if you are an economist: “what nature has concentrated for us for free for millions of years, like oil, clean air, water, sand for construction etc, is free”. I’m not talking about telling stories to people but about changing theses stories they already tell themselves that have been implanted into them by a system
- anonymousiam 4y agoHow can one not be skeptical when every existing model fails to even come close to predicting future temperature patterns, and every publicized prediction about climate catastrophe over the past 50 years has been wrong? Where is the science?
- Kaibeezy 4y ago“every”
- YellowStuDregg 4y agoA quick google search gives us plenty of past published projections and how they fared: https://www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-how-well-have-climate-models-projected-global-warming/ https://www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-how-well-have-climate-m... You can also watch Carl Sagan break it down in front of congress back in 1985 for just 15 minutes of your time https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wp-WiNXH6hI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wp-WiNXH6hI
- PheonixPharts 4y agoDo you mean because the impacts of climate change continue to happening faster and more severe than expected?
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoDon't feed the troll
- acdha 4y agoYour ignorance doesn’t mean the science didn’t happen. The predictive models from decades ago have held up quite well, while deniers have moved from one wrong excuse to another. https://climate.nasa.gov/news/2943/study-confirms-climate-models-are-getting-future-warming-projections-right/ https://climate.nasa.gov/news/2943/study-confirms-climate-mo... https://arstechnica.com/science/2012/12/ipccs-climate-projections-on-target-so-far/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2012/12/ipccs-climate-projec...
- Kaibeezy 4y agoNo matter how bad it gets, Earth will always be more habitable than anywhere else. But even if humans survive for millions of years, we’ll never get back what we have now.
- ben_w 4y agoOther than the easily available fossil fuels, this planet will be essentially back to the wild state a few tens of millennia after a hypothetical catastrophic collapse in technology.
- wizofaus 4y agoIf humans survive for millions of years we'll almost certainly transform the planet vastly further than anything even conceived of so far (except perhaps in SciFi). And I wouldn't assume that even within a few 1000 years Earth will be more habitable than elsewhere (but yes, it's almost guaranteed for the next century or so at least). OTOH, if we really did somehow totally self-destruct as a species, there's good reason to suppose the climate would settle back to something similar to what it has been the last 10k years, though it certainly won't last forever, or even much more than a dozen or so more thousand years.
- maybelsyrup 4y ago> there's good reason to suppose the climate would settle back to something similar to what it has been the last 10k years What's that good reason?
- wizofaus 4y agoMy understanding is that the natural CO2 cycle would gradually remove the excess concentration currently in the atmosphere. I don't know how long it might take, several centuries at least I suppose.
- orwin 4y agoNo, it's too late, we won't ever get back to last century climate, Oxydes are some of the most stable molecules on earth, so the only way to get them out of the mid to high troposphere (where it actually have an impact) is to lower their concentration in the low troposphere. At the moment, the CO2 you emit will take roughly 20 year before it has an impact on climate (the time to reach the altitude necessary for the re-emission to cause real harm). When we start planting trees and let the ocean capture the Co2 (they will acidify, but fuck the plankton and corals at that point, we can't do anything about that), then it will start to get better. It will take roughly five hundreds years to eliminate half of our past an current emission (if we stop in 2050) and ten thousand to get back to 1850 climate. So, yeah, it will settle back, but in a long, long time.
- _9xrb 4y agoI'm surprised that this paper doesn't mention hydrogen sulfide, a poisonous gas emitted into the atmosphere during anoxic ocean events, which is thought to be responsible for several known periods of mass extinction: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permian%E2%80%93Triassic_extinction_event#Hydrogen_sulfide_emissions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permian%E2%80%93Triassic_extin... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anoxic_event#Atmospheric_effects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anoxic_event#Atmospheric_effec... >The trigger for these mass extinctions appears to be a warming of the ocean caused by a rise of carbon dioxide levels to about 1000 parts per million To me, this is the most concerning potential result of climate change. Short of hermetically-sealed self-sustaining biodomes, which must run smoothly for up a million years before the atmosphere naturally clears of H2S, an event like this could wipe out all human life on Earth. Our political or ideological alignment would be of no consequence. Even communist utopian societies can't survive a poisoned atmosphere. We'll hit 1000ppm in a few centuries if current trends hold, or much sooner than that if certain positive feedback loops kick in. Last I checked, the methane clathrate gun hypothesis wasn't as bad as previously thought, but we simply don't know what we don't know in this area: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clathrate_gun_hypothesis#Current_outlook https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clathrate_gun_hypothesis#Curre...
- AftHurrahWinch 4y ago> Last-resort emergency measures like solar radiation management (SRM), the injection of aerosols into the stratosphere to reflect sunlight (35). Whether to resort to such measures depends on the risk profiles of both climate change and SRM scenarios. One recent analysis of the potential catastrophic risk of stratospheric aerosol injection (SAI) found that the direct and systemic impacts are under-studied (36). The largest danger appears to come from “termination shock”: abrupt and rapid warming if the SAI system is disrupted. Hence, SAI shifts the risk distribution: The median outcome may be better than the climate change it is offsetting, but the tail risk could be worse than warming (36). > There are other interventions that a better understanding of catastrophic climate change could facilitate. For example, at the international level, there is the potential for a “tail risk treaty”: an agreement or protocol that activates stronger commitments and mechanisms when early-warning indicators of potential abrupt change are triggered. I like the idea of a "tail risk treaty" as a way for skeptical nations to hedge their bets and prepare for unilateral geoengineering. > An existential risk is usually defined as a risk that cause an enduring and significant loss of long-term human potential (51, 52). This existing definition is deeply ambiguous and requires societal discussion and specification of long-term human values (52). While a democratic exploration of values is welcome, it is not required to understand pathways to human catastrophe or extinction (52). For now, the existing definition is not a solid foundation for a scientific inquiry. Dark comedy.
- wlindley 4y agoIn all Earth's history, has there ever been Climate Stasis?