10 ms·
Lava Tubes on the Moon Maintain Comfortable Room Temperatures Inside
- sjatkins 4y agoInteresting. Much like the temperature underground on earth.
- georgeoliver 4y ago> “Because the Tranquillitatis pit is the closest to the lunar equator, the illuminated floor at noon is probably the hottest place on the entire moon,” said Horvath. With the daily big temperature swings, is this a viable source of power?
- chiph 4y agoI wanted to know how anyone could know this without having actually measured it. They have modeled it using known regolith/rock insulation values (presumably from the Apollo samples). > The researchers used computer modeling to analyze the thermal properties of the rock and lunar dust and to chart the pit’s temperatures over a period of time. I'm not sure I'd trust a lining applied to a naturally-formed tube wall to retain air. But if we were to build our own tunnels with a lunar TBM¹, where we could control what the tunnel wall is like, yeah, that'd be fine. ¹ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tunnel_boring_machine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tunnel_boring_machine
- nickff 4y agoThe tunnels have been structurally stable for a long time, sealing them seems much easier and more reliable than boring a new tunnel, sealing it, and hoping it remains stable. What kind of control do you think you'd have that would make the 'artificial' tunnel better?
- vorpalhex 4y agoPreventing it from collapsing by increasing structural durability seems wise.
- nickff 4y agoThe grandparent didn't say anything about reinforcing the TBM-made tunnel, it just asserted that it would be controlled. What techniques would be used for "increasing structural durability" that are only applicable to TBM-made tunnels?
- aurizon 4y agoI would expect a lava tube from a drained lava flow to vary greatly. We see many have collapsed over the ages. It would provide an insulated underground tube miles in potential extent. That said, the danger of a roof fall would be low in some spots and ready to fall anytime in others. This is still rock, about 6 tonnes earth mass per cubic meter (one tonne on the moon). That means a very strong tunnel liner is needed. It also needs to be air tight. Research into the use of regolith as an ingredient of a concrete needs to be done. One traditional concreted mass is baking bricks of regolith. More research into brick baking from various lunar materials is also needed. A blown up fabric habitat would work inside this sealed brick tunnel.
- dylan604 4y agoCan you do that without water? That would be the ultimate so the little that is available doesn't have to be used in construction materials
- hutzlibu 4y agoWith enough energy, one can sinter the regolith together. Using water would be ridiciously expensive, unless some meaningful water reservoirs on the moon are found or an easy way to extract the very little existing water.
- aurizon 4y agoYes, ground regolith and other local minerals might be available to mine - grind to powder, press into a shape(s) that can be Lego'd into the tunnel you want. Sintered blocks are very strong in compression and 1-2 layers will allow long buildings to be made in the lava tubes or on the surface. crushed regolith will serve as insulating berms that embed structures.
- margalabargala 4y agoThey've been structurally stable under a specific, unchanging load for a very long time. If suddenly they are pressurized to 1 atm, that may very well change.
- hutzlibu 4y agoIt may, but usually it would mean they are even more durable, since the air pressure works against the gravital pressure from above. But lots of experiments are definitely needed.
- chiph 4y agoIt'd have several desirable properties: 1. You'd have a flat smooth surface that you could apply a liner to, instead of a surface that undulates and (probably) has fissures. 2. The diameter would also be constant, so that you could design your liner to fit based on known dimensions. Curves would also be of a known radius. 3. Also, our tunnel would go exactly where we want, and not wander around based on some ancient flow pattern. Or form oxbows where it loops back on itself. 4. So far as a structural liner, if you look at some of the tunnels under rivers where there is the danger of water intrusion, to my knowledge none of them have ever used a natural formation. Brunel used a brick structural liner under the Thames, and modern TBMs use interlocking concrete panels with rubber gaskets.
- nickff 4y agoYou seem to be assuming that the whole tunnel should be one continuous structure, and that the pressure vessel must occupy the whole volume. A segmented structure, possibly with pressure vessels that are either flexible or of a smaller diameter than the outer walls may be more practical. I'm also not sure whether luncrete is really a practical option, and you certainly won't have clay for bricks. I think you're making a lot of assumptions, and don't have a comprehensive view of how the structure(s) would be designed and built.
- Kye 4y agoA space station in a bottle. Except the bottle is a lava tube.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- edm0nd 4y agoTIL the moon has lava tubes whoa https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_lava_tube https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_lava_tube
- adastra22 4y agoI mean we visited a collapsed lava tube on one of the Apollo missions (15 I think?).
- jrussino 4y agoThere was recently a proposal to send rovers to explore them: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moon_Diver_(spacecraft) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moon_Diver_(spacecraft) Check out the video on this page for a ton of details: https://www.kiss.caltech.edu/lectures/2018_Moon_Diver.html https://www.kiss.caltech.edu/lectures/2018_Moon_Diver.html That particular mission concept was not funded, unfortunately, but I'm hopeful that we'll do something like this soon. As others in this thread have said, aside from just being really cool these lava tubes on the moon (and Mars! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martian_lava_tube https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martian_lava_tube) are an interesting candidate for human habitats.
- bell-cot 4y agoIssues: Discovery - Other than spots where part of a lava tube's roof has already collapsed, how quick & cheap is it to discover and map the lava tubes under some non-trivial part of the lunar surface? Scale - Let's say there's a lovely lava tube, X meters in diameter and Y meters below the surface, in a location where we'd like to build a moonbase. For a give size of moonbase, there will be fairly narrow ranges of X and Y values where the lava tube is actually suitable for housing the moonbase. Cut & Fill Competition - Lava tubes aren't magical. If an area on the moon has deep, stable "soil" (vs. near-surface bedrock) containing ~few larger pieces of rock, then "dig a trench, install tubular habitat, fill trench back in" may give a far lower cost and/or higher predictability than "starting looking for the perfect lava tube...". Stability - If you're not familiar with the things that often go wrong when humans start digging and building structures, Practical Engineering ( https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCMOqf8ab-42UUQIdVoKwjlQ https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCMOqf8ab-42UUQIdVoKwjlQ ) is a pretty good intro. Note that we have a lot of experience with and data on how to do such things on the Earth. On the moon...not so much. Some very painful and expensive lessons seem inevitable.
- DennisP 4y ago> If the scientists' gravity analyses are correct, the lava tube near Marius Hills could easily house a large U.S. city such as Philadelphia https://www.nbcnews.com/mach/science/gigantic-lava-tube-could-be-home-moon-colonists-ncna813396 https://www.nbcnews.com/mach/science/gigantic-lava-tube-coul...
- wolfram74 4y agowhich would be a bit excessive for a 10 person base, yes?
- bell-cot 4y agoLooking at that article...it appears to show Philadelphia being a mere 1km or so wide. Vs. Wikipedia says that Philadelphia is >350 sq. km. Even if that's not horribly wrong (maybe they figure that New Philly, on the moon, will be a ~1km x ~350km strip?), they still show the bottom of the lava tube being 3km or so below the lunar surface. The moon's gravity may be weak...but just building a few 3km-tall freight elevators, to provide minimal transport to/from the surface, would be a huge infrastructure project. Vs. "Philadelphia" suggests that you'd have ~1.6 million people living down there. And are they figuring that the city will have it's own pressure dome(s), totaling ~350 sq. km., to hold the air in? At some point, the ideas start to sound like "wouldn't it be great to build a thousand-square-mile tropical island, in this spot where the ocean is only 3 miles deep?" Sure, if you know somebody who'll give you ~5,000 cubic miles of good rock, delivers cheap, and there's no "asteroid impact" in the fine print.
- dr_dshiv 4y agoI can’t wait until we set up base, blow up a large sporting arena and get the moonball games televised! If everyone on earth wants to watch something, then it can make money. And then, finally, we have a financial incentive for moon infrastructure. Moon sports ftw!
- api 4y agoThe moon is in general a better place than Mars for a first attempt at a space settlement in part because there's more options for monetization. It might not pay for the whole thing but it would at least offset it a bit. There are other big reasons too, like help being only days away instead of months away in the event of a catastrophe. Once we figure out how to do a space settlement on the moon, then we could try Mars. Mars is likely a better long term home for humans but it's about 60X as far away in terms of travel time.
- TomSwirly 4y agoBefore any of these things, it would be better to make sure that we survive here, on Earth - and right now, this looks like it's seriously in doubt.
- uncertainrhymes 4y agoIf only we had some other long term home closer at hand.
- yrgulation 4y agoOne that we keep digging in instead of digging asteroids, the moon or mars. It’s like taking a poo in your living room because you already have the space available. We should offload all destructive resource gathering off this planet, precisely so we keep our home clean.
- TomSwirly 4y agoThe idea that we will move heavy industry off the planet sounded entertaining in the 1970s. Now it's just sad. No, space won't save us. We have to stabilize the planet first.
- kemiller 4y agoWait… so does this mean the moon really IS made of Swiss cheese?
- stephc_int13 4y agoWait, is there volcanic activity on the moon?
- wincy 4y agoNot anymore. But there used to be!
- shadowgovt 4y agoThe moon was formed by a massive impact that calved a piece off of Earth. The resulting body formed from accreted material, much of it still very hot from the impact. Since thermal energy has nowhere to go in a closed system like a planetoid except, eventually, radiation, it stayed partially melted for a long time and cooled from the outside in. Earth is actually undergoing a similar process... IIUC, our planet isn't big enough to generate internal heat, and eventually the core heat should radiate away. I don't know if the time scale for it exceeds lifetime of the sun though.
- lutorm 4y agoWikipedia puts the radioactive decay of isotopes at half of the heat flux from the core. So yes, eventually it will cool down, but it is absolutely generating internal heat.
- shadowgovt 4y agoOh, that is awesome. I swear, every time I learn a new thing about Earth's internal structure it gets weirder and cooler.
- jmyeet 4y agoOnce again it seems necessary to remind people just how unsuitable Mars is for human colonization while the Moon is significantly better: 1. Lava tubes will be a cheap form of initial habitable space. Additionally, the Moon is geologically stable; 2. Gravity is too low in both places so you'll probably have to still live in spin gravity; 3. Mars has an atmosphere but it's basically a vacuum. It's just enough to cover all your stuff in dust; 4. Mars is poisonous. The surface is covered in many toxic substances (eg perchlorates); 5. People have a vision of living on the surface of Mars. That'll basically never happen. Radiation is still a problem. Living underground just makes way more sense. And any above ground structure (eg domes) can just as easily be built on the Moon; 6. Distance from Earth is a significant downside to Mars and a significant advantage for the Moon. You can still maintain real-time communication with Earth. And supplies are days not months away. Mars really only has 2 advantages: 1. Day length. Mars day is almost Earth normal. The Moon is tidally locked so its day is ~28 Earth days long; and 2. Day-night temperature differential on the surface. It's really large on the Moon. Why this matters is that even though you'd be living underground you still need power and solar power is really the best option. On the Moon this means your best options are the poles. The standard retort is "terraforming". People who say this don't seem to comprehend what a massive undertaking this is. Example: the Earth loses (IIRC) ~1 million tons of atmosphere every year due to Jeans Escape Energy. That doesn't matter on Earth because the atmosphere is so much more massive. So at actual atmosphere on Mars would have to be so large such that a similar loss would be insigifnicant.
- marsven_422 4y ago
- JohnJamesRambo 4y agoReally good post thank you.
- ewjt 4y agoMars advantages continued: 3. Available water, required for any human/plant/animal life 4. 2.3 times the gravity of the moon 5. CO2 in atmosphere could be converted to O2 for breathing or methane for rocket fuel