12 ms·
Why Punish?
- tomohawk 4y agoThe state must punish, or the citizenry will resort to revenge, or just realize that the state isn't worth supporting. The more the state allows people to infringe on others rights, the less reason for it to exist.
- superchroma 4y agoPresently in America, the state punishes and the citizenry isn't too enamored with the state. It punishes the poor and poorly connected savagely and the well-off inconsistently. Generally, I disagree with the assertion, and I would not be seeking to refine how we punish to be more effective and consistent. The goal ought to be to remove a person from their situation, show them a better way to live and slowly and patiently attempt to re-form them as people through real growth (skills, character, etc.) so that they can go back into the world better and don't need to reoffend. Obviously there's a long way to go to get there, but I think many countries have tried the other path and I'm not convinced it works.
- ryan93 4y agoLike half the murders in Chicago go unsolved.
- superchroma 4y agothat is a separate problem to punishment, in fairness.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sonofhans 4y agoThis is mostly a history of punishment in western society. There’s nothing wrong with that; it’s interesting. It answers the question in the title mostly by asking what, from today’s perspective, are the rational uses of punishment? But it doesn’t get much at why we do this in the first place. Why do adults punish children? Why do so many people belong to religions with strict and explicit punishment dogmas (e.g., going to hell for offending a higher power). It doesn’t provide a rhetorical or moral framework for differentiating punishment from abuse or torture. I think these are more interesting questions, although perhaps not fair to expect from a historian. Clearly punishment is satisfying to us. Revenge stories are as old as literature, and widely celebrated. I think that in a large society it’s an obsolete and harmful impulse. The article references Plato’s views: “Plato discussed punishment in terms of learning virtue and deterring future acts rather than just in terms of taking vengeance for the past, which he dismissed as a primitive, animalistic motive.” It’s interesting to me how long it takes for views like this to take hold and create a more just society, and how easy it is for cultures to backslide. Revenge is a powerful impulse.
- kodah 4y agoMoralism is a powerful thing and American moralism is far from dead. I think a lot of folks in America probably fancy themselves as being free from these chains, but subconsciously I think the chains of moralism are fairly deep and strong.
- mantas 4y agoToday’s anti-moralist stance is very moralist itself. It’s funny how cultural colonialism is going at full speed today. Yet many people think this brings post-colonial justice.
- kodah 4y agoI don't really see amoralists creating laws to punish moral people. Generally people who don't like morals prefer ethical frameworks. But, I do agree that a lot of speech today has moral overtones, and that itself is wrong.
- WalterBright 4y agoThe recent trend towards decriminalization of various crimes like shoplifting have resulted in a crime wave.
- Simon_O_Rourke 4y agoArguments put forward without evidence can be dismissed without evidence.
- actually_a_dog 4y agoYou have proof of causality in that direction, right?
- 57457802 4y agoI don't think that's true at all. People say that crime increased in San Francisco because of the more progressive DA, but ignore that crime increased less in San Francisco than nationwide.
- DiggyJohnson 4y agoDo you have any numbers that shows this? To discuss the disproportionate rise in crime in progressive DAs’ cities isn’t to ignore the rise in crime across the board.
- 57457802 4y agoSome relevant links: https://www.ppic.org/publication/crime-trends-in-california/ https://www.ppic.org/publication/crime-trends-in-california/ https://citycrimestats.com/statistics/ https://citycrimestats.com/statistics/ https://applieddivinitystudies.com/sf-crime-2/ https://applieddivinitystudies.com/sf-crime-2/
- gruez 4y agoExcept for property crimes, there are reason to believe that the official statistics are totally unrepresentative of actual number of crimes committed. For instance: https://www.sfchronicle.com/sf/article/shoplifting-data-Target-Walgreens-16647769.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/sf/article/shoplifting-data-Targ...
- WaitWaitWha 4y agoI care not about if some individual gets a speeding ticket on the other side of town. I have zero revenge ideas. I do care that I am (and others are) aware there are consequences to speeding. That is a direct, and explicit deterrent to me. It is also a social contract that I or others who break this contract will be punished. That is a comforting thought. Why is it that I am comfortable crossing the intersection when I have a green light? Because I have confidence that those who would break the social contract of following agreed upon laws will be punished, so they are deterred from breaking them. I cross without hesitation. We think of others as having near-similar ethics (following social rules) as we do. When such contract is broken and punished I am appalled not because I want vengeance, but because I am relying for my life to keep such contract. Punishment is a deterrent, not vengeance. Ethics and morals must not die. I am really trying not to be cynical about the article's framing.
- Gordonjcp 4y ago> Why is it that I am comfortable crossing the intersection when I have a green light? Because I have confidence that those who would break the social contract of following agreed upon laws will be punished, so they are deterred from breaking them. It's really quite telling that in countries where religious strictures are held to be more important than individual freedom, like the US, the prevailing attitude is that "people will only do the right thing if they are afraid of being punished if they don't". Whereas, in a country like the UK, with considerably more rights and freedoms and less reliance on Judeo-Christian religion, the idea is that "people will do the right thing, because they expect others to do the right thing in return".
- superb-owl 4y agoThe idea of punishment as a deterrent is hopefully dead and buried at this point. The U.S. has one of the harshest prison systems in the developed world, and an outrageous recidivism rate - 76% of prisoners are arrested again within 5 years of release [1]. Norway, on the other hand, has some of the most humane prisons [2], and a recidivism rate of only 20% [1] [1] https://harvardpolitics.com/recidivism-american-progress/ https://harvardpolitics.com/recidivism-american-progress/ [2] https://norwaytoday.info/culture/what-are-prisons-in-norway-like-really/ https://norwaytoday.info/culture/what-are-prisons-in-norway-...
- shakow 4y agoAnd Singapore has a very punitive legal system, while featuring a recidivism rate around 20-25%. You can't just take two cherry-picked examples and proclaim the ‶idea of punishment as [...] dead and buried″.
- SiempreViernes 4y agoYou argue against cherry-picking, and then you think you can prove something with one single example? My dude, the other guy provided 100% more data than you!
- mrex 4y ago>You argue against cherry-picking, and then you think you can prove something with one single example? Well... he can! He can prove, with one example, that the other person's thesis doesn't fit the facts. And he did that. So, yeah.
- SiempreViernes 4y agoCan you please explain your understanding of the word correlation? I'm very curios to hear how your reasoning for how statements about these can be proven by a single data point.
- 4y ago
- Cupertino95014 4y agoIf you think a more just society requires rehabilitation & showing the criminals a better way, you just got schooled by the far-left voters of San Francisco. They found out the hard way that there are some very, very bad people out there, and they got sick of them. A very small number of sociopathic folks are not deterred by anything but the certainty of punishment. In the worst case, all you can do is ensure that they can't prey on everyone else. Lacking capital punishment for most crimes, we're left with imprisonment, or Clockwork Orange.
- vaidhy 4y agoWhat got shown was that ignoring bad behavior does not make it go away. I do not see any effort towards rehabilitation or education in SFO, just no prosecution.
- Cupertino95014 4y agoThat's right as far as it goes. What's missing is any realization that our society can't do "rehabilitation or education" effectively and if it could, just replacing the DA won't make it happen. Secondly, as I said, there is a non-negligible criminal population that's already been raised, so all the talk about raising your kids or your dogs properly is kinda irrelevant. For a really sociopathic person, therapy is just finishing school: it teaches them how to fake normal human emotions more effectively.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Cupertino95014 4y ago
- mihaic 4y agoI know it's almost always taboo whenever I bring it up, but in recent years I've become convinced that a moderate level of retaliatory violence could lead to a better society. There seems to no longer be any negative consequences for many minor antisocial acts (types of bullying, shoplifting in some parts, even reckless driving/endangerment). It's impossible in practice to legislate being an asshole, so until recently we relied on group shaming or the thread of a minor beating from someone wronged to keep this sort of behaviour in check. Because of past cruelties, we've determined that all amount of verbal and psychological abuse is milder that a single slap, and I'm honestly wondering if we're leaving too many usable options to better society on the table. That, combined with shaming and some amount of indoctrination of morals and ethics in our youth seem to have been abandoned completely, instead of being mostly toned down.
- Ekaros 4y agoHonestly, maybe spending a day at stocks on public square might be effective tool. And probably relatively cheap punishment. We could even stream it online. Show advertisements and have it pay itself.
- mihaic 4y agoYeah, or imagine what effect adding 50 lashed to the CEO on those $100 million fines that get easily paid.
- d0mine 4y agoImagine the current cancel culture is even more widespread (it is a nightmare). [My personal point of view is that] the society should not punish, it should try to prevent future crimes. For example, capital punishment: according to studies I've read, it is not a real deterrent, and false positives are likely (innocent people are killed) -- therefore I'm against capital punishment (if the capital punishment were effective to prevent murders, I'd reconsider it).
- mihaic 4y agoSure, that's exactly my point: capital punishment is over the top, and prevention would have been achieved with much less. If light corporal punishment were shown to be just as efficient at prevention as a 1-year in jail sentence, would you consider it?
- scythe 4y agoThere's a lot of difficulty in actually measuring the long-term effects of punishment and policy on society that gets breezed over when we are faced with a brute contrast between retribution and deterrence. It's fine to point out that branding criminals on the face created more repeat offenders, but most other effects are more subtle. I wish I could hear less ethics and more epistemology when the philosophers come to talk about justice.
- scombridae 4y agotl;dr Because punishment deters and because it feels good ("desert"). Article raised insignificant, pathological counter-arguments: If robbery is punishable by death, then thieves are more likely to kill their victims to squelch witnesses. Since suicide was religiously verboten, suicidal mothers engaged in capital crimes to enlist the authorities to off them.
- thunderrabbit 4y agoUntil reading this article, I thought "just desserts" etymology was the final 'treat' one deserved.
- m463 4y agoI can't help but think of this other article -- only loosely related How Inuit Parents Teach Kids To Control Their Anger https://www.kqed.org/mindshift/53283/how-inuit-parents-teach-kids-to-control-their-anger https://www.kqed.org/mindshift/53283/how-inuit-parents-teach... however I don't know how this translates to the whole of society vs a small community
- brainzap 4y ago"Our parents told us that if we went out without a hat, the northern lights are going to take your head off and use it as a soccer ball"
- pessimizer 4y agoThis seems to really dance around the fact (getting very close a number of times) that the primary reason for punishment is that if you don't punish the perpetrator, the victim, their family, and their loved ones will consider the matter unresolved, and attempt to carry out what they think would be an adequate punishment themselves. Then the perpetrator and their family would retaliate, and society eventually dissolves in the tit-for-tat. The justice system is something that you use to prevent a civil war. A secondary reason is touched upon here, but if the perpetrator of crime is not punished, only isolated comfortably, committing crime becomes attractive in and of itself to the portion of people who are currently less comfortable than prisoners. That's why the treatment of prisoners is a great metric for the quality of a society: it sets a baseline for the way non-prisoners are treated. You can't give prisoners free, high-quality education, no matter how helpful it would be to prevent crime after they're released, if you're not giving it to the general public, or else the general public would commit crimes to be educated.
- nine_k 4y agoPunishment is a form of compensation of the damage inflicted. The perpetrator of a,crime must compensate the damage to the victim(s), at a somehow excessive rate to prevent crime from being a viable business model. This is relatively simple (though not easy) for property-related crimes. It's much harder for crimes like battery or rape. That said, staying in a prison is about the least productive way to compensate, or to repent. Prisons, as seen in USA, should be abolished and replaced with other institutions. Property crimes can be paid for with labor, with less limitations of freedoms than in a prison. Education should be provided not just for rehabilitation (which is a worthy aim), but to also produce the compensation faster, while earning the basic upkeep. Non-property crimes should likely be paid for in repentance work, on top of material compensation work: by working at places that expose the perpetrator to the woes of people who suffered through consequences relevant to the crime. Maybe something like menial work at a hospice.
- pessimizer 4y agoPunishment isn't any sort of compensation. Victims receive compensation. Compensation replaces a portion of the loss represented by crime. Perpetrators receive punishment, and it doesn't replace anything. It actually represents even more loss (in the US to the tune of something like $40K a year per prisoner.) edit: Punishment for the victim is like a gift-wrapped empty box. It doesn't fix anything that the crime did, and the system pretends like they're doing it for the victim. The system punishes perpetrators in order to stop the victims from doing it themselves. It's not a favor.
- andrewstuart 4y agoThe article is about society in general, but on a personal level I have a "no punishment" policy with my son. I never punish him and never have. Whenever he behaves in a way that's not OK with me I first ask myself "does he understand my expectations here, have I already explained my expectations to him?". Usually not, so I explain that his behavior isn't acceptable and why. I very rarely need to do this. The one time he behaved in a way that made me really angry I dealt with it at the time by speaking to him about it and also with the other people involved and there was still no punishment.
- 1270018080 4y agoHow old is he?
- reidjs 4y agoI don’t know your relationship with your kid, but I’m confused when you say you don’t punish your kids. Maybe you use the word “discipline” them or think that because you don’t physically hit them you never punish them. Talking to/lecturing can be seen as a form of punishment. Refusing to punish a child for their poor behavior could be interpreted as neglect.
- psyc 4y agoLecturing being a punishment is too flimsy a proposition to build a credible argument on top of. Hardly anyone could see it that way for more than a few seconds without pulling a muscle. At worst it's simply asserting your status as the parent.
- reidjs 4y agoMaybe I’m weird, but I hate being lectured, to the point where I’d much prefer physical pain towards me (within reason of course). I would rather get punched in the face than be forced to listen to the average person speak for more than 5 minutes, my father, maybe I’d give him 3 minutes of lecturing before I’d prefer the punch, we don’t have a great relationship. Many children probably feel the same way.
- Pakdef 4y agoSome punishment might be ok but the prison system in many states is more like torture. One example is that some of them design the cells to have maximum echo... When you speak it drives you crazy.
- foogazi 4y agoIncarceration works because those in prison can’t commit crimes against society It’s an adult timeout It’s not so much punishment or revenge as taking the convicted out of society
- pabs3 4y agoOther forms of justice must surely be better in the long term: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transformative_justice https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transformative_justice https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rehabilitative_justice https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rehabilitative_justice https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Restorative_justice https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Restorative_justice
- chiefalchemist 4y ago> Politicians of all stripes encourage such anxiety Encourage? More like enable. That is, those (i.e., politicians) that benefit and leverage the problem have little incentive to solve the problem (i.e., poverty, mental health, etc.) > But in fact, our era is the safest and least violent in human history. We are less likely to killed, assaulted, or otherwise physically harmed today than ever before. Yes. But that's on average. There are areas where danger is real. Perhaps not relative to history, but relative to where Karen lives the marginalized are highly disadvantaged. I live in NJ. I'm able to get the local news from Philadelphia. There are shootings daily / nightly. Those events are not evenly distributed across PHL.
- collimator 4y agoWhy punish? Indeed, why? Human justice - legal, lawful justice, has nothing to do with Justice at all, and is nothing but the visitation of revenge on the wrongdoer. I would hate to punish anyone because it would coarsen me to supervise somebody's pain. On the other hand, no punishment ever helped me to become a better person. The only thing that ever helped me in any case was love. I say "Abolish punishment" It only harms both its new victim and ourselves.
- noelherrick 4y agoThese types of analysis start out the basic proposition that systems are designed for a specific goal from the start and that we should judge them based on those goals. Our justice systems have emergent properties that have arisen after many years and are due to many historical accidents vs. a planned or purposeful approach. They should also be judged on their outcomes, not their professed goals. I will talk about the US, since that's what I have the most experience with and it's where MIT is located. The US does not adopt either of those strategies mentioned in the article, even if it does dress itself in the rhetoric of either moral justice or practical utility (the former is heavily favored). The outcomes of policing, legal system, and prisons is that poor and Black people are heavily oppressed and only the property rights of the weathly are taken seriously. White people's drug crimes are punished less than Black people's drug crimes. Heck, even the criminalization of drugs is oppressive against the already oppressed. What is wild is that we don't see the police and judicial system as an occupying force. Why do police departments need MRAPs, M-16s, and plate carriers? Why do we have to keep gasing, shooting, and beating our own citizens? Why does the NSA and CIA feel the need to monitor our every word? We can do better, but we have to admit that our system is not working for a lot of people. This is a blameless post-mortem, so all I want to do is fix our system, not assign blame. We have to make this better, for the sake of all.
- projektfu 4y agoIt's weird to see this topic discussed historically without mentioning Foucault (Discipline and Punish, English Title), even if just to dismiss him. I have to assume Baldwin read it, and can only assume that he dislikes that book so much he doesn't want people to read it.
- Borrible 4y agoIt's fun. And deeply satisfying.