15 ms·
Huanan Seafood Market in Wuhan was early epicenter of the Covid-19 pandemic
- paulpauper 4y agoDidn't we know this already as early as Feb 2020?
- Khelavaster 4y agoThis was known for two years. Markets are breeding grounds for zoonotic diseases. They often even jump from human to animal and back. The real question is--how did the virus get to the live market? The study accurately says, "While there is insufficient evidence to define upstream events, and exact circumstances remain obscure, our analyses indicate that the emergence of SARS-CoV-2 occurred via the live wildlife trade in China, and show that the Huanan market was the epicenter of the COVID-19 pandemic."
- throwaway4good 4y agoIt says in the last two paragraphs: "The sustained presence of a potential source of virus transmission into the human population in late 2019, plausibly from infected live mammals sold at the Huanan market, offers an explanation of our findings and the origins of SARS-CoV-2. The pattern of COVID-19 cases reported for the Huanan market, with the earliest cases in the same part of the market as the wildlife sales and evidence of at least two introductions (38), resembles the multiple cross-species transmissions of SARS-CoV-2 subsequently observed during the pandemic from animals to humans on mink farms (46), and from infected hamsters to humans in the pet trade (47). There was an extensive network of wildlife farms in western Hubei province, including hundreds of thousands of raccoon dogs on farms in Enshi prefecture, which supplied the Huanan market (48). This region of Hubei contains extensive cave complexes housing Rhinolophus bats, which carry SARSr-CoVs (49). SARS-CoV-1 was recovered from farmed masked palm civets from Hubei in 2003 and 2004 (20). The animals on these farms (nearly 1 million) were rapidly released, sold, or killed in early 2020 (48), apparently without testing for SARS-CoV-2 (7). Live animals sold at the market (Table 1) were apparently not sampled either. By contrast, during the SARS-CoV-1 outbreaks farms and markets remained open for over a year after the first human cases occurred, allowing sampling of viruses from infected animals (20). The live animal trade and live animal markets are a common theme in virus spillover events (21–23, 50), with markets such as the Huanan market selling live mammals being in the highest risk category (51). The events leading up to the COVID-19 pandemic mirror the SARS-CoV-1 outbreaks from 2002-2004, which were traced to infected animals in Guangdong, Jiangxi, Henan, Hunan, and Hubei provinces in China (20). Maximum effort must now be applied to elucidate the upstream events that might have brought SARS-CoV-2 into the Huanan market, culminating in the COVID-19 pandemic. To reduce the risk of future pandemics we must understand, and then limit, the routes and opportunities for virus spillover."
- thakoppno 4y ago> However, the observation that the preponderance of early cases were linked to the Huanan market does not establish that the pandemic originated there.
- mgamache 4y agoSorry this is an unscientific conclusion. The lab leak is more plausible based on the animals required and known and proposed research at that facility. It's simply another polemic. Without information / data from the lab you cannot claim one is more probable.
- WaxProlix 4y ago> The lab leak is more plausible > you cannot claim one is more probable Am I missing something here?
- mikeyouse 4y agoNope - HN is one of the worst 'smart' places on the internet for Covid discussion. Every single thread immediately devolves into completely ascientific conspiracy ranting.
- reglkj45y 4y ago
- ravitation 4y agoThis is also not limited to just COVID discussion either. Most things that aren't somehow related to day-to-day software development devolve into unsubstantiated, or ill-informed, "ranting." It's a source of constant disappointment.
- dwringer 4y ago> Most things that aren't somehow related to day-to-day software development And especially the things that are. That's what makes HN special.
- ravitation 4y agoThese are at least often informed by (overly specific) personal anecdotes.
- rob_c 4y ago> The real question is--how did the virus get to the live market? The chances are we'll never know, it may have spread through here (despite no real action to stop this form of trading from any of the wonderlfully eclectic groups still engaged in it). > While there is insufficient evidence to define upstream events, Also, we're not brave enough to say read the evidence it came from here. We're only brave enough to say it's the 'epicenter' of an early outbreak to keep from annoying those who don't co-operate anyway.
- rr888 4y ago> how did the virus get to the live market? My guess is that someone was selling animals from the lab that were supposed to be destroyed.
- siva7 4y agoThat’s an interesting theory and i suppose not even that far fetched
- sudosysgen 4y agoIt is far fetched. Labs typically engage in destructive testing of their animals.
- noworriesnate 4y agoThis lab was a joint venture of the French and Chinese. The French pulled out and sounded the alarm about how careless the Chinese were. So yeah it’s very plausible that such flagrant violations took place.
- sudosysgen 4y agoIt's not about violations. The animals are killed because the nature of the data taken from them requires them not to be alive.
- tradertef 4y agoCan they sell killed animals (in the live market)?
- sudosysgen 4y agoThe whole point of live markets is that the animals are, well, live. And I would imagine they'd have a hard time selling dissected animals.
- anon23anon 4y agoCan't world leaders put pressure on china to clean up these wild life markets? Like better health practices and what not?
- marcosdumay 4y agoAren't they doing that since 2020? AFAIK those markets are out-right banned already.
- mikeyouse 4y agoYeah, they were meant to be largely banned since SARS1, the presence of raccoon dogs and foxes at the market in Wuhan is deeply problematic -- all of the people skeptical of China can still be skeptical!
- pipeline_peak 4y agoThey grow garlic with sewer water and the air is polluted because they're cranking out everything the world buys in suicide netted factories. China is a developing country, do you think government officials are going to go all around regulating wild life markets along with every other threat? They have the environmental and mental health concern of 1960's America.
- HPsquared 4y ago1960s America led to 1970s America, which had a lot more concern for the environment. It's inevitable that as problems accumulate, people affected by them will want to do something about it.
- pipeline_peak 4y ago1970's America wasn't anywhere near as poverty struck as China. It's really difficult to care about the world around you when you can't even take care at home.
- 4y ago
- throwaways85989 4y agoThe labs janitor sold dead animals for a side hustle, cheaper then cremation and the lower caste is not properly educated about bacterias, viruses and bio hazards. (Wild speculation - may contain novel truth contamination)
- Proven 4y ago
- dtx1 4y agoI don't believe this to be true. I consider the likelyhood that the Wuhan Institute of Virology was the cause of this to be much higher than that the seafood market in wuhan was the cause and there's no reason to trust any media or NGO to be truthful in that regard.
- CWuestefeld 4y agoThe two are not mutually exclusive. For example, some "theories" say that a WIV employee took animals that had been used in experiments, and sold them at the market. I'm not suggesting this is actually what happened, just that there's plenty of room for involvement from both of these entities (or, perhaps, neither).
- MichaelCollins 4y agoMMmmm, medical monkey meat.
- dtx1 4y agoI would categorize such a situation as a lab leak, too. Either way, we will never be able to confirm the truth.
- CaptWillard 4y agoA very good point, which is sadly absent from most of the public discussion. Having said that, a case could be made that this (lab leak via market) is a distinction without a difference.
- mikeyouse 4y agoIt's transparently obvious that the Market was first place where it began to spread in humans - so "neither" isn't an option. The Market was unequivocally involved.
- drak0n1c 4y agoThe reason for the doubt is that it wasn't transparent nor obvious. The Chinese government retroactively censored the institute's publications, Fall 2019 job postings, staff listings, and internal discussion of new symptoms amongst certain researchers [1]. There is a possibility that there were a few earlier cases than the market ones which were covered up to conceal negligence at the institute. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bpQFCcSI0pU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bpQFCcSI0pU
- dangom 4y agoConspiracy theories aside, Worebey's Science paper is not unanimously well received by the scientific community, and the data analysis was shown to be partly flawed. Here's a discussion on inference pointing to references and sources that argue against the results of the paper: https://inference-review.com/article/thunder-out-of-china https://inference-review.com/article/thunder-out-of-china It also raises eyebrows the fact that no animal has ever been found to be positive for COVID, in contrast to all of the previous SARS pandemics. EDIT: thanks everyone for correcting my assertion. No source animal was found.
- gerdesj 4y ago"Animals infected with SARS-CoV-2 have been documented around the world. Most of these animals became infected after contact with people with COVID-19, including owners, caretakers, or others who were in close contact. We don’t yet know all of the animals that can get infected. Animals reported infected worldwide include ..." https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/daily-life-coping/animals.html https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/daily-life-coping/... EDIT: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_animals_that_can_get_SARS-CoV-2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_animals_that_can_get_S... - long list of refs
- mikeyouse 4y agoPlenty of animals have been found to positive for Covid - and the animal cages in the market had numerous environmental positive samples. I think you mean that no source animals have been found -- but if the timeline in this paper is right, the zoonotic jump happened in late November and they didn't shut down the market and start testing until almost a month later -- so a strong case of "absence of evidence isn't evidence of absence"
- phreeza 4y agoAre you sure COVID has never been documented in animals? I seem to remember reading about cases where entire farm populations of minks were being killed. Perhaps you mean infection from an animal host to human?
- 4y ago
- adolph 4y agoThey still don't have anything. Streetlight effect at its finest. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streetlight_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streetlight_effect However, we do not have access to the precise latitude and longitude coordinates of all these cases. Should such data exist, they may be accompanied by additional metadata, some of which we have reconstructed, but some of which, including the date of onset of each case, would be valuable for ongoing studies. We also lack direct evidence of an intermediate animal infected with a SARS-CoV-2 progenitor virus either at the Huanan market or at a location connected to its supply chain, like a farm. Previously: What happened to the lab-leak hypothesis?: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31866601 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31866601 [flagged] More evidence that Covid-19 started in a market, not a laboratory: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30566956 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30566956 Book Review: “Viral” by Alina Chan and Matt Ridley: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29764537 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29764537 US raises ‘deep concerns’ over WHO report on Covid’s Wuhan origins: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26125145 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26125145
- rob_c 4y agoDon't worry adolph we still need to pretend that this is the leading cause of death in the world and that economic recession will not responsible for 10-100x this based on historical evidence. Frankly turning this on it's head, Russia should be applauded for pushing so many people toward green, renewable and truely economically viable energy sources, I nominate putin for the nobel peace prize based on his efforts here.
- dgfitz 4y ago> I nominate putin for the nobel peace prize based on his efforts here. You're implying intent on his part. If any single person in the world would want renewables to never exist, it would be him. I also am aghast that you would feel this way about a man destroying hundreds of thousands of lives. The man is evil.
- rob_c 4y ago
- reglkj45y 4y ago
- reglkj45y 4y ago[dead]
- ejb999 4y agoI wonder how many people who are seemingly willing to believe the self-serving CCP party-line on this, would be just as believing of the owners of a nuclear power plant in their town, once the drinking water became radioactive, claiming "it didn't come from the plant, someone else down the street must have done it" - that is just about as believable as this.
- flybrand 4y agoIt’s painful in that scenario to give complete authority for resolving the nuclear safety issue to (1) the most likely cause of the issue, and (2) a low integrity party that has obscured their role in causation.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoMaybe it was somebody in the flea market selling scrapped smoke detectors. Possible... but not my first guess. But it's worth keeping in mind that sometimes the most obvious answer is not the correct one. In 1984: "During routine monitoring at a Pennsylvania nuclear power plant, a worker was found to be contaminated with radioactivity. A high concentration of radon in his home was subsequently identified as responsible."
- connordoner 4y agoFor anyone who, like me, was curious about this, the worker's name was Stanley Watras. There's more on him on JSTOR if you want to read up: https://www.jstor.org/stable/44534629 https://www.jstor.org/stable/44534629
- hammock 4y agoThat is exactly what pfas manufacturers like 3M and others are doing to gaslight residents of towns all over America, right now
- dylan604 4y agoNot just America. The globe. There was a link posted here a couple of weeks ago about a European 3M plant and its PFAS problems.
- flybrand 4y agoThe same visual analysis, when showing the location of the lab, could lead to other conclusions. Here’s a link to that, if we’re open to differing perspectives. https://igorchudov.substack.com/p/lie-exposed-bbc-says-covid-19-came?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email https://igorchudov.substack.com/p/lie-exposed-bbc-says-covid...
- fakethenews2022 4y agoNo it doesn't lead to different conclusions. The lower right one is where the bat experiments were conducted rather than the one in the middle. That is far from the epicenter. If people would actually read and digest the article before spewing out their own biases, then you would see that the article addressed this very contention. The article pointed out several facts. One was that there were two strains already. Having that come from the virology institute doesn't make sense. It makes more sense if the virus was spreading and mutating amongst the animals in the market. Second, is charting the concentration of early spread. Again, the market was the epicenter. Third is looking more closely at that and seeing this same epicenter pattern in a specific part of the market. This again points to the market being the epicenter. Fourth, there is no such pattern of infection around the virology institute that was conducting the bat virus research.
- AlanYx 4y agoJust to add to this, in the linked paper by Worobey et. al., Fig 2(B) shows something they label as "Centroid of Blue Cases". That centroid appears to be almost squarely on the location of the Wuhan Institute of Infectious Diseases. For some reason, neither the locations of the Wuhan Institute of Infectious Diseases or the Wuhan Institute of Virology are mentioned in the linked paper.
- anigbrowl 4y agoThis is correct, but the paper does observe that these second-stage cases (mostly reported around January and February) occur in an area of high density housing with a preponderance of elderly people.
- buscoquadnary 4y ago
- anewpersonality 4y agoWhat do the logicians among us conclude? Occam's Razor? I am not smart enough to deduce the truth of all this nonsense.
- LatteLazy 4y agoAll conclusions are weak because all theories are at least possible and there is no conclusive evidence. Instead of accepting we will never know, people will now tell you with 1000% (1e4) certainty that it was definitely X. They will queue to die on whatever hill their brains have randomly selected. It's like lemmings only they don't actually do that.
- systemvoltage 4y agoNo one seems to be doing that. Can you tell us where anyone is claiming with 100% certainty?
- LatteLazy 4y agoThe top comment in this thread: >I wonder how many people who are seemingly willing to believe the self-serving CCP party-line on this, would be just as believing of the owners of a nuclear power plant in their town, once the drinking water became radioactive, claiming "it didn't come from the plant, someone else down the street must have done it" - that is just about as believable as this. Absolutely sure the CCP are lying (I don't trust them either but that's not proof they're lying is it?) Another comment here: >I don't believe this to be true. I consider the likelyhood that the Wuhan Institute of Virology was the cause of this to be much higher than that the seafood market in wuhan was the cause and there's no reason to trust any media or NGO to be truthful in that regard. Literally "I don't believe the facts". That's just this thread, on HN. It's really concerning, or it was when I thought people could be self governing. /EdgyBS
- encryptluks2 4y agoTo be fair, if 100 years ago some scientist wrote a paper about how being a certain race made you more prone to violence or how lobotomies are safe and effective.. there would be people saying you don't believe the facts of you don't agree. So, before you judge people maybe reflect on history a little and see that people have reasons to distrust government. A single paper doesn't prove anything. It must be reproducible throughout the scientific community.
- diogenescynic 4y agoI'll never believe that this wasn't leaked from the Wuhan virology lab. There was way too much done to suppress any coverage and the people involved in the investigation had conflicts of interest since they were the ones who funded the lab. All the behavior from China was extremely guilty. It seems naive to believe that this came from a seafood market.
- pid_0 4y ago
- LatteLazy 4y agoIt's been fascinating and terrifying watching people (in general and on here) jump to answers that are nice but wrong (China did it on purpose, You can cure it with X, it's just the flu, etc) over the last few years. We will never know for certain what happened. It's honestly killed me support for democracy. 95% of people seem to be incapable of thinking about uncertainty and living with not knowing. They just jump headlong into whatever looks good. Facts and reason are just justifications for things their prejudices already decided.
- upupandup 4y agoThere's a difference between being informed and feeling informed. The Western civilization have increasing distanced itself from the former because its "offensive and hurts others feelings" in favor of the latter. When emotion triumphs logic and reasoning, that society is nearing end of times. Such was the case for Roman empire, increasingly people's mentality started to shift away from reality and into idealized and complex web of absurdities leading up to its down fall, much of which were spouted by its upper echelon awash with luxury and comforts unaffordable by its masses We see such absurdities being pushed in schools (ex. Math is racist) and in society in general which then antagonizes and gaslights, attacks opposing nuanced views that throws its own narratives into question. While doing business with authoritarian states, we've ended up resembling in some form. It's a damn shame, once again reminded that open societies remain open only as long as its participants believe it to be so. If we close ourselves to one view then we are doomed to repeat the same attrocities that closed socities commit against individuals groups.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoI generally find that, while there are a worrying amount of people with insane takes on things, often reaching 30% in various polls when something becomes "political", that the majority generally gets it right. If only there was a bit more democracy, a lot of bad things could be avoided. Having said that, I looked up the polling on lab leaks and American democracy loses on this one: https://morningconsult.com/2021/06/09/coronavirus-lab-leak-wuhan-china-poll/ https://morningconsult.com/2021/06/09/coronavirus-lab-leak-w...
- thepasswordis 4y ago
- prepend 4y agoIt’s important for COVID reparations.
- mullen 4y agoThe one thing that makes me think the Lab Leak theory is true is that the Chinese government very very strongly denies the story and does anything it can to deflect or redirect the discussion to some other theory. For anyone reading these kinds of stories and reports but is not a regular China follower, there is one thing you really should know. Anytime the Chinese government reacts very negatively to a story (Denial, attacking, undermining, deflecting), it usually means the story is true. The Chinese government is really terrible at information management and addressing anything that might make them look bad or lose face. Just admitting a Chinese lab collected, studied and by accident a lab worker got infected with COVID is just something China can not admit. It is perfectly reasonable that some lab somewhere would collect and study the COVID virus. What is unreasonable is that the lab or a lab worker just got sloppy and accidently released that virus out to the world.
- chimprich 4y ago> The one thing that makes me think the Lab Leak theory is true is that the Chinese government very very strongly denies the story ...well, yes, of course they do. But they would also strongly deny the story if they thought it was untrue. > Anytime the Chinese government reacts very negatively to a story (Denial, attacking, undermining, deflecting), it usually means the story is true. So if they don't react negatively and deny something, then the story is... false? That doesn't make any sense.
- mullen 4y ago> ...well, yes, of course they do. But they would also strongly deny the story if they thought it was untrue. Then why would block any investigation from outside the Chinese government? If anything, if the Lab Leak theory is provable false, they should be inviting outsiders to investigate and waste their political capital/time/energy. If your advisories want to spin their wheels on something that is not true, then let them. > So if they don't react negatively and deny something, then the story is... false? That doesn't make any sense. When it comes to the Chinese government and information, surprisingly as it sounds, yes. If the Lab Leak story was not true, the Chinese government would not even react to it. They might even entertain it as part of their information ops strategy since the Lab Leak theory is a plausible theory. If you think about it, how does the Wet Market theory make China look better than the Lab Leak theory? It really doesn't. If serious pandemics are coming out of Wet Markets, then why does China still allow Wet Markets to exist? At least with lab safety, labs can be improved and managed better while Wet Markets are just ticking pandemic timebombs.
- csours 4y agoWe don't have testable theories here, we have Mad Libs. A virus of (human)/(animal) origin was (un)intentionally (released)/(spread)/(detected) in Wuhan, starting at a (lab)/(market). Narrative 1: Animal origin with extensive spread in a food market Narrative 2: Animal origin with accidental release from lab study Narrative 3: Intentional creation/modification of a virus for purposes of scientific study and subsequent (un)intentional release Narrative 4: Intentional creation/modification of a virus for nefarious purposes with (un)intentional release Narrative 5: Animal origin with slow undetected community spread somewhere and possibly random mutation that lead to more viral fitness in Wuhan. --- What would actually change if you had certainty around one of these theories? Are you certain that there will not be a zoonotic viral pandemic in the future? If you aren't certain that there will never be a zoonotic pandemic again, then we should ramp up vector and disease surveillance. Also, China has had no problem disciplining people that cause trouble and embarrassment. If they thought someone caused this, that person is fucking gone.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoFor theories number 3 4 and 5, increased controls and monitoring viral labs is one possible action.
- csours 4y agoI guess I didn't say all of it - yes, if it is a possibility, we should take it seriously. I think they are all possible, we should take them all seriously. I don't think there is any way to get to a scientific certainty either positively or negatively about any of the origin theories; thus we should take precautions about all of them.
- kansface 4y ago> What would actually change if you had certainty around one of these theories? Widespread political support for ending all public funding of gain-of-function research or outright banning it.
- csours 4y ago
- manv1 4y agoOne problem in these kinds of investigations is that nobody involved really wants the truth to be known. The lab isn't going to let anyone poke around and see what it was doing until the CPP falls. And even then records have probably been wiped already. The problem is that there really isn't any evidence. SARS-COV-2 has never been detected in any Chinese land animals associated with the market. We know that birds can transmit it, but it needs to come from somewhere. There's no reservoir of the stuff found in the wild...unlike viruses like Ebola, Marburg, MERS, etc. There were two variants in the market...but given the speed at which SARS-COV-2 variants have mutated in humans, well, how likely is it that the market was the source? SARS-COV-2 went through millions of humans before the first variant popped out. Is it reasonable to assume that some progenitor virus went though millions of iterations to become SARS-COV-2 in the market, then did it again and again? But however unlikely, this is where we are today. Was it just bad luck that some virus entered an immuno-compromised animal at the market and mutated...twice?
- oasisbob 4y ago> There were two variants in the market... No, there were two distinct lineages in the market. That's different than variants. The lineages are important because although the differences between the sequences are small, they are distinct, and there are no known transitional haplotypes. > given the speed at which SARS-COV-2 variants have mutated in humans, well, how likely is it that the market was the source? See Pekar et al: https://zenodo.org/record/6342616 https://zenodo.org/record/6342616 They deal with this question directly.
- Consultant32452 4y agoIn Dr. Birx's recently released book she claims to have known it came from a lab origin from the start, based on evolutionary reasoning. As she describes: A virus takes years to learn/evolve the ability to infect humans, and does so poorly at the start. But covid was extremely effective at infecting humans "right out of the box." In a lab environment the virus is repeatedly exposed to human cells and gets better at infecting human cells with each iteration. Evolutionary biologist Heather Heying similarly reasoned the origin of the virus through an understanding of evolution. Covid doesn't appear to transmit outside. If covid evolved naturally, it would be capable of spreading outside, where animals live. Instead, it appeared to evolve to spread in lab-like air conditioned conditions only.
- hypersoar 4y agoIf, unlike most of the other top commenters I see, you read the paper and its sibling[0], which isn't very long or difficult to understand, you'll find an interesting and thoughtful analysis. They talk a lot about ascertainment (sampling) bias. They find the data points to the market even after they threw out the 1/3+ of the people who lived closest to it. And the cases not linked to the market lived closer to it than the cases that were: > One of the key findings of our study is that ‘unlinked’ early COVID-19 patients, those who neither worked at the market or knew someone who did, nor had recently visited the market, resided significantly closer to the market than patients with a direct link to the market. The observation that a substantial proportion of early cases had no known epidemiological link had previously been used as an argument against a Huanan market epicenter of the pandemic. However, this group of cases resided significantly closer to the market than those who worked there, indicating that they had been exposed to the virus at, or near, the Huanan market. For market workers, the exposure risk was their place of work not their residential locations, which were significantly further afield than those cases not formally linked to the market. This makes sense, but it's probably not something I'd have thought of myself. I also find figure 4[1] fascinating. Evidence points not just to the market, but to just a handful of stalls within it. The sibling study tracks two lineages in the early spread, both clustered around the market. The first study, citing this sibling, says: > This, along with the lineage A cases we report in close geographical proximity to the market in December, challenges the suggestion that the market was simply a superspreading event, which would be lineage-specific. Rather, it adds to the evidence presented here that lineage A, like lineage B, may have originated at the Huanan market then spread from this epicenter into the neighborhoods surrounding the market and then beyond. They conclude that they are likely the result of separate animal-to-human transmissions and that there were probably more jumps that quickly died off. This suggests that the virus was well-suited to infect humans before it jumped: > Successful transmission of both lineage A and B viruses after independent zoonotic events indicates that evolutionary adaptation within humans was not needed for SARS-CoV-2 to spread (49). We now know that SARS-CoV-2 can readily spread after reverse-zoonosis to Syrian hamsters (Mesocricetus auratus), American mink (Neovison vison), and white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus), indicating its host generalist capacity (50–55). [0] https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abp8337 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abp8337 [1] https://www.science.org/cms/10.1126/science.abp8715/asset/86346dd9-84ab-43de-bfb8-fc8dd159756d/assets/images/large/science.abp8715-f4.jpg https://www.science.org/cms/10.1126/science.abp8715/asset/86...
- Consultant32452 4y ago"I remind us all that an “outbreak at the Wet market” “natural origin” “not designed” “not a bioweapon” and “nothing to do with a virology lab” are all VERY different things that keep, oddly, getting conflated." ~ Eric Weinstein This study seems to potentially shine some light on only the first item in that list, an outbreak at/near the wet market.
- sudden_dystopia 4y agoThis is just a study of the distribution of early cases which was centered around the market. But the WIV is in the same area so I don’t see what this proves. Still doesn’t isolate an animal or explain how they had a bat virus that 95% matched sars cov 2 genome back in 2013 in WIV.
- synergy20 4y agoWuhan Biosafety Lab is only 8 miles away from this seafood market. That lab is the only lab on earth to deal with SARS related study. The link is quite obvious to me which is why China tried to interfere with the investigation so hard.
- jpeloquin 4y agoThe practice of plotting case maps like this started during the 1854 cholera epidemic. The cholera case map helped discredit the theory that cholera was transmitted by miasma, and supported the theory of fecal-oral transmission. Just some related history that you might find interesting. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1854_Broad_Street_cholera_outbreak https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1854_Broad_Street_cholera_outb...
- rafaelturk 4y agoWhere is Wuhan Institute of Virology on the map?
- 99_00 4y agoAt least it won't happen again because the markets are forever shut down or have strict international monitoring.