47 ms·
In defense of the Google chef
- alexwolfe 15y agoWho determines who is actually worthy 20 million or a billion? In every case there is a tremendous amount of good fortune, luck, and incredible timing. Anyone who thinks they deserve that much more money than someone else because they are just a better human being needs to get a reality check. Its really about being fortunate. The Chef certainly has just as much right to his 20 mil as all the other guys that cashed out. Again, its not about just talent or brains, its about luck.
- bad_user 15y agoGreat people make their own luck. The Chef took a risk that may have impacted his career negatively. That's not necessarily luck, that's an investment that payed off. And if you don't want the Chef to get rich, then don't offer him any stock - but then you do need to pay a higher salary. It's funny that Zynga tries to paint this negative picture of Google's IPO, when clearly at Google everybody won tenfold, including founders and investors and being good employers is partly the reason for that. Zynga will never be Google and it starts with their attitude towards their employees.
- alexwolfe 15y agoThere are a million great people people out there that you don't know who aren't lucky. Having money doesn't make you great, being great makes you great. I do think that the harder you work and the the more opportunity you give yourself to get lucky the better your chances are to be successful. But believe me, luck plays a huge part in everyones life no matter how smart or great you think you are.
- bad_user 15y agoYes, but the odds of having 20 million drop from the sky in front of you are zero. Even people winning the lottery have to buy a ticket first and even then, the chances are greater for being hit by a car the next day. So there's a huge difference between that and investing your time and skill in something based on making educated guesses. Which is why I wouldn't call it luck. Also, wealth is relative. Some people simply don't care that much about money if they earn enough to live comfortably, especially since pursuing money is in general painful for everybody.
- lutorm 15y agoSo there's a huge difference between that and investing your time and skill in something based on making educated guesses. Which is why I wouldn't call it luck. That's an absurd definition of luck. What you have to do is look at the distribution of outcomes in the population. If those outcomes are widely distributed, it depends on luck. The characteristics of the underlying population are irrelevant.
- drumdance 15y agoLike Vincent Van Gogh. Only sold one painting in his lifetime.
- damoncali 15y agoHaven't you neen paying attention? Pincus decides. Then he decides again later, differently.
- rhizome 15y agoOoh, I think thinking twice about the Google chef is to accept Zynga's "pray I don't alter your option plan any further," take on things, i.e. the argument's already lost.
- kls 15y agoI'm not usually a get out the E-Pitchfork type guy, but this subject has really gotten under my skin. I got stiffed on an exit so you can take my view as biased if you would like. It most likely is given my irritation at the subject, I generally don't get worked up over stuff so it has certainly hit a nerve. But the part that really gets me is it has absolutely nothing to do with the role these people played and every bit to do with the longer hours, reduced compensation risk and how long a person takes that risk for. If they came in on the ground floor then have been riding the roller-coaster and getting paid dirt for longer then they deserve those early and current options, I just cannot understand the attitude that is being displayed where the CEO feels that later employees that are "now" more strategic to the company (read executives) are more deserving of that equity given their worth to the current goals of the company. That is such a warped perspective, it has nothing to do with the future and everything to do with how much risk and how long those early employes took that risk for.
- earbitscom 15y agoWe are talking about unvested shares to be earned in the future. There is not much risk in working at Zynga from here moving forward - no more than any large company. They're not taking back shares people earned during the risky period. They're saying, now that the company exploded we'd prefer to pay you differently from here on out. You have the choice to stay or go. Nothing that already happened is being rescinded except that 2 years ago we put together a plan to keep you highly motivated for 4 years, and now that we know what the stock is worth, it's not equitable to trade the latter half for 2 more years of your work. We could fire you to preserve this capital, but we're offering you a regular compensation package instead.
- andrewfelix 15y ago"Charlie didn't make $20M for cooking, he made $20M for taking the risk that the company he was joining would fail" This succinct sentence sums it up for me perfectly. His ability and contribution aside, a gamble was made and it paid off.
- tlrobinson 15y agoAlso, if I were Mark Pincus or another Zynga executive I'd probably avoid the Zynga cafeteria for awhile...
- muppetman 15y agoI know it's frowned to post these sort of comments, but I spat my beer (Friday night in New Zealand) on the table laughing your comment.
- raganwald 15y agoI don't soeak for anyone else, but I've always thought that an ocassional witty comment was fine, it's just lazy joking that's reviled. So for example, pun threads amd lowbrow memes are discouraged. The guidelines for submissions speak to piquing intellectual curiousity. If there was such a guideline for cracking a joke, it might be "anythng that uses humour to sneak an insight into the conversation." The post above made me laugh and certainly makes a point about the morale at Zynga. Well done! p.s. There is another kind of wit that is explicitly discouraged, the "witty reply." That is a special case where a comment tries to make fun of another comment. As a general rule, this lowers the tone of the discussion by emphasizing rhetoric over ideas. This isn't the case here, making fun of Pincus is not the same thing as making fun of a comment or making fun of the OP.
- muppetman 15y agoI actually meant my comment, which was essentially pointless :)
- goodside 15y agoIt's ludicrous that it's even necessary to paint the archetypical "Google chef" as someone who daringly sacrifices for their scrappy company for them to be worthy of windfall profits. If you compensate employees with options, they deserve whatever they end up being worth. Period. That's the whole point of options. If there were an asterisk attached that said, "...but only if people agree in retrospect that you deserve the money," nobody would accept them as payment.
- retrogradeorbit 15y agoYeah. I find it humourous that they say they are clawing them back so they "could attract more top talent with the promise of stock." What? By demonstrating how they'll screw them out of that stock when the time comes?
- perfunctory 15y agoThat's exactly right. It's bizarre how people believe they can improve their business by being dicks.
- zem 15y agothere are always people willing to believe that they won't be screwed out of their options because they deserve them more than those lazy early employees.
- lambda 15y agoI loved the local coffee shop that had a sign up by the register: "We cheat the other guy, and pass the savings on to you!" That's exactly the message that Zynga is sending out now.
- Vivtek 15y agoExactly. If they didn't want early people to have disproportionate gains, they should have paid them with money. This just looks like what it is - regret that they didn't keep more, now that Zynga is successful. Cheap bastards.
- oacgnol 15y agoZynga and Groupon just seem to have shot themselves in the foot right before their IPOs for stupid reasons. It's a shame how greed and stupidity in leadership have negatively impacted the payout for the people who toiled to make the dream possible.
- mmaunder 15y agoMy sister's a french trained chef and I've been writing software most of my life. She works probably 3X harder than any geek I know including me. It's brutal. She arrives 8am to prep and leaves 11pm after service, 6 days a week when she was working for someone else. 7 now that she's opening her own place. She's on her feet all day. The job is both time critical and requires constant teamwork. If you or anyone else drops the ball the angry customer is right there, including the angry wait staff and angry team mates. It's very high pressure. She's now busy opening her own restaurant and it's a far cry from writing software once and kicking back while each incremental copy sold costs you zero effort or money. Every incremental product a chef sells is hand-made and has to have its raw ingredients bought without any certainty it'll actually get sold. What's worse is many ingredients have a shelf life of mere days. Every product is hand made to a customer's specifications and delivered in real-time with immediate feedback. If a product is rejected, it's expected to be replaced immediately without interrupting the flow of products heading out to new customers. And of course the tools of the trade are not a keyboard, but sharp knives and open flames. So yeah, the "google chef scenario" comment bugged me too.
- VBprogrammer 15y agoWhat annoyed me is not the suggestion that the chef is in someway less entitled to the money than other employees, or that he didn't work as hard. It is that it is just factually wrong. How many great people joined Google when it was an up and coming start up who loved the emerging culture and the idea of having a great chef.
- sophacles 15y agoTo expand on your point: I remember that pre-IPO articles about Google always mentioned the great working conditions, including the amazing meals in the cafeteria. Recruitment material from Google touted the chef as a major reason for working there. People talked about Google as the de-facto model for treating your employees well "look they even have a good chef". Given how much that chef played a role in Google's name making, he certainly deserved every penny he made.
- scottschulthess 15y ago
- kschua 15y agoAnyone who joins a startup be it a chef or masseuse (Bonnie Brown) who take a risk by joining a startup deserves to be compensated accordingly if the startup succeeds. Just because they are not developers doesn't mean they didn't contribute to Google's success. Glad that I am not alone in thinking that the "Google Chef" deserves what he gets.
- danbmil99 15y agoAll I can say is Ayer's restaurant serves really amazing food at an affordable price. So he's giving something back to the community. He's hiring people and building a business. Is he less of a contributor to Google's success than the worst programmer who made $20M on their IPO? What I don't get is the zero-sum thinking here. They're worried that someone in their organization might get rich, and maybe they didn't deserve to get so rich. So what? They should worry about their company, not be squabbling over percentages. Reminds me of the end of "Treasure of the Sierra Madre." The prospect of real money seems to drive some people insane.
- earbitscom 15y agoThey're not worried about whether someone gets rich who doesn't deserve it. They no longer need to pay someone $10M to keep them working there because the risky part of the journey is over. So, they're saying, you earned X already for the risky portion, you can keep that, and you can keep your job, but we're not going to keep paying you a startup equity share for you to work at a big company with total stability, benefits, vacation, etc. We need to scale it back, and we want you to stick around for what is probably a competitive comp package if you look at it objectively.
- div 15y agoThe deal was x amount of shares for the risk of working for a startup. Renegging that to x/2 amount of shares in hindsight is evil. It's a construct in which an early employee can only lose, if the startup fizzles, he gets nothing, if the startup booms he is screwed out of half of what he and his employer agreed on.
- zem 15y agono, you're missing the point. here's how it works: zynga: want to be an early employee in our risky little venture? emp: um - the salary is kind of low and there's no job security zynga: but we're tossing in 100,000 options. potentially worth $10M if our stock hits $100 in the ipo emp: okay, that sounds better. i'm in zynga: of course, to prevent you from just exercising the options and leaving, they'll vest over four years emp: works for me. so basically the entire chunk of options was the employee's payment for joining the company when there was low salary and job security. the vested part is payment for sticking around to help zynga succeed. and the implicit contract is that the unvested part is an already made promise that his compensation for each year of work will be $x in salary + $y in incrementally vested options. since employers tend to have disproportionate leverage in these matters, there are of course a whole range of clauses stating that he could be fired for any or no reason and lose his unvested stock just as if he'd resigned, but that's harking back to the letter rather than the spirit of the agreement. abusing that leverage is a scummy thing to do, regardless of the technical legality of it all.
- dylangs1030 15y agoJust the fact that Ayers was stylized as a "Google chef" and not by his name is demoralizing. It just gets worse when they speak of his success as something a company should avoid if at all possible. It's manipulative to hire someone, offer them stock options, then decide they're not worth it later on. Just don't offer them in the first place!
- sounds 15y agoFortunately, Pincus' attempt to paint Ayers with this brush _is_ backfiring. Ayers is getting tons of free publicity, while Pincus is utterly failing at what he was trying to accomplish. Zynga is bleeding valuation right now.
- michaelochurch 15y agoJust the fact that Ayers was stylized as a "Google chef" and not by his name is demoralizing. It just gets worse when they speak of his success as something a company should avoid if at all possible. Last time I checked, Google has multiple high-quality products that users love, and it's not hurting because of the "Google chef". Zynga has... what, exactly? A bunch of shitty games that die (and have to be reinvented) as soon as the novelty wears off. Who the fuck is Mark Fucking Pincus to decry the "Google chef"? Zynga will never achieve 1/100 of what Google achieved. Pinky should learn from Google, not trash it on no basis whatsoever.
- brown9-2 15y agoI'm not sure if you should really be demoralized by it - this is one of those textbook actions where how person A treats person B tells you all you need to know about them. I don't think this incident has revealed some ugly aspect of our culture, but it has revealed a ton about the people that run Zynga and the "others in the Valley" that think this way. I'd stay away from these folks at all costs.
- JulianMiller520 15y agoCouldn't agree more. I'd expect a comment/attitude like this from people on wall street but not in the world of tech. It's sad that they could even pervert the phrase "Google Chef" into something negative or something that should be avoided.
- wisty 15y ago"Charlie didn't make $20M for cooking, he made $20M for taking the risk that the company he was joining would fail" Maybe. Or how about this: Charlie didn't make $20M for cooking. He effectively made a normal chef's salary, some of which he effectively invested into Google shares. What's the issue? That a chef (unlike a banker or programmer) helps fund a company, and gets shares for it?
- gmazzotti 15y agoExactly, thats the best way to see it and makes the "Give back our stock" more ridiculous: employees get les money in cash because they decided to invest some part of their salaries in the company shares, so, if the company go to IPO and they get rich they are not geting rich because of how much value they provide to the company, they get rich because they could recognize a great company in the early days and invest on it. Is like saying to an angel you didn´t help me so much in your mentoring so give me your shares back.
- wisty 15y agoI kind of understand why they want to stop giving them shares, as they no longer need funding from little people. But it seems a lot like tearing up a term sheet 5 minutes from signing the final contract, just because you managed to shop for a better deal. It might be legal, but it's just not done.
- davros 15y agoThat's the best way to look at it. All the talk of what is 'fair' misses the point - remuneration is not inherently fair, never has been. You can point to market forces or regulations or whatever, but there's no real and fair basis for most differences in income. What we can be fair about is how we treat people, if we give them shares and later we wish we hadn't we should live with that gracefully. We can give them bonuses for both self-interested (motivate employees) or altruistic reasons (it happens!).
- andywood 15y agoBegrudging the 'Google chef' is taking the effects of market forces that influence the relative pay of chefs and software developers, and trying to apply them by sheer assertion to the stock option lottery. The mechanics that influence pay are completely separate from the mechanics that make early employees rich. If a CEO honestly believed that certain workers should not have any chance of getting rich, the consistent thing would be not to offer them options in the first place. This issue also reeks of the Just-World Fallacy. Individual early employees of wildly successful companies don't get rich because it's fair, even if it sort of works out that way on average. They get rich because someone gave them options, and then the stock skyrocketed. Efforts to explain it in terms of justice are mostly post-hoc rationalization.
- dylangs1030 15y agoRight, and the problem is that everyone wants to be a captain of industry, but no one wants to clean the toilets. So they promise wealth to someone who cleans their particularly promising toilets, but they don't really believe in the worth of that job, otherwise, they'd probably be doing it themselves (I think most programmers would sooner learn a new sector of information technology than give themselves a position as a cook on the side). It becomes "I don't want to do y, I'm much too busy with important x" ----> "Eureka, pay someone for necessary evil y" -------> "Wow, look at all this money, hey wait, my company is selling x, not y!" The fallacy is revealed when it's simplified.
- MaysonL 15y agoAt this point the only question worth asking about this situation is whether anybody on Zynga's board has the balls and integrity to tell Pincus to go fuck himself.
- potatolicious 15y agoThey can't. Pincus isn't an obstacle in the way of the company. Pincus is the reason Zynga is successful. Without the aversion of innovation, the complete disregard for ripping others off, and partnerships with incredibly shady companies, Zynga would not be anywhere close to where they are today. A business in the theme of Zynga needs the unscrupulous head honcho who can't care less about what's right, only what's profitable. Get rid of Pincus and Zynga sinks like a rock. Let's be honest, if you take Zynga's games, strip out the blatantly psychologically manipulative bits, inject some real fun into there, and actually spend some money on innovation... none of it would be profitable.
- nasmorn 15y agoLets not forget, the basis of their business is that they found a way to replicate the economics of a slot machine without falling under gambling regulation and without ever having to pay out real dollars. It is still the same business though. As a former game developer I am shocked by the fact that people buy their image as a gaming company. They have about as much to do with computer games as roulette has to do with Settlers of Catan.
- michaelochurch 15y agoThank you. Zynga is an insult to game developers. I can't for the life of me see the appeal of their garbage games.
- kamaal 15y agoWhat really is a important question to ask now is Would anybody worth their salt really want to work or deal with them anymore? If I know someone is going to rip me off sooner or later. I am not going to do business with him.
- DodgyEggplant 15y agoConduit famously gave options to the cleaning ladies
- kamaal 15y agoIts not about chef or a Janitor or whatever. Why are these people acting as though only a few have the right to be rich? Why can't a Janitor be rich? Why can't a chef be rich? What really is so wrong with it? This attitude is so despicable! So anybody who doesn't go to a big Ivy league, or some one who doesn't have an MBA next to his name or hasn't worked at a investment bank can't be rich? Which in case, what this really turns out to be is alternate form of slavery where a selected few have to resign themselves to a lesser standard of life to serve the remaining self chosen elite and act in every way such that the elite are benefiting. If you want some job to be done and you are ready to pay for it, money/stock or whatever. And you promise and the contract so. You just need to pay up. That's it, it ends there. You don't get the work done, squeeze the juice out of the employees. Then one fine day realize that what you promised is now worth a lot of money. So you suddenly dump them, loot all the money yourself and say that they don't deserve it. You had promised that it was worth paying something for some one from some work. So now when it is time to pay up. Just pay.
- Tichy 15y agoAlso, I think most people are not doing anything useful at all while they rake in the money. That probably irks me the most, or rather, I think it is a pity because of all the wasted productivity.
- TDL 15y agoHey now, not all MBAs think this way;-)
- lancewiggs 15y agoIvy League MBA here. I completely agree. And so far we are missing the two other points - fairness and fun. It's simply the right thing to do to get everyone onto the bus, to let everyone share in the upside of a start-up. Sure the amounts of options can vary between employees, but it's just not fair to be stuck on a salary while everyone else around you gets millions from an exit. The second reason is fun. Isn't it a whole lot more fun to come to work where everyone has a stake in the company? Wouldn't it be wild fun if your company did an exit or IPO and everyone came to work with a huge smile on their face? For the sake of giving up a little bit of founder equity we can create an environment that is not only a lot more fun to be in, but is potentially life-changing for everyone and their families. Thinking anything else can lead to the situation that Wall Street is in now.
- grandalf 15y agoThis is essentially a Trolley problem that people are getting quite indignant about: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolley_problem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolley_problem Here's an oversimplified example that mirrors the classic Trolley problem: Suppose the company consists of three people: The founder, the engineer and the chef. The founder can't raise more money from investors and she realizes that if she fires the chef it'll free up 200K ISOs which can be used to recruit a sysadmin. Without a sysadmin the startup will fail. If the founder gives up her own shares, she loses control of the company to one of the investors, who she knows will sell the company to cash out immediately. If she stays in control, the founder aspires to grow the business to 20x its current size. Should the founder fire the chef? What small detail would have to change in order to quell the ire of all of the people claiming that Pincus is acting unethically?
- blrgeek 15y agoThe fact that in this case the founder alone has 20% of the stock (after multiple investments & dilution), has 40% of the vote share, and is probably talking about < 5% given to early employees. And his investors are gaga about him, and super unlikely to take control away from him. If he gives away 5%, he will still have 15% of the equity, 30% of the voting share, and retain complete control of the company. Or he could issue 5% addn shares and dilute everyone equally by 5%. Now he just looks like as ass.
- OoTheNigerian 15y agoLike I said earlier, how about keeping your own side of the bargain? Remember the 'useless' chef already got you to where you are presently. The place where you need to raise more money. Why then did you hire the chef in the first place? If the chef has started cooking poorly, you sack him/her. Just like your board would fire you for poor performance. That this is even up for debate is baffling. PS: Grandalf, so I suppose the stock people receive in your project 'Dandelion Labs' do not really have any worth because two years down the line the people canget disposed if the founder needs to free some stock without getting diluted
- grandalf 15y ago
- kaze 15y agoBeautiful. There was a chef of similar capabilities at my first company. Ten years later, me and my ex-colleagues still rave about his food and the inspiration it gave us. EVERY employee counts.
- OoTheNigerian 15y agoHow about just keeping agreements? Does it matter if the money allotted to the barber down the road becomes worth $100m? If he kept his part of the deal, you should.
- ck2 15y agoI wouldn't have a problem with a startup janitor taking home $20M in a stock payout. A rising tide should lift all boats, not the boats they specifically select with hindsight.
- damoncali 15y agoNot only is it not a problem, it's a good thing. We sell dreams. In order to do that, some of them have to come true.
- petegrif 15y agoIf the Zynga story is as reported it is beyond despicable.
- suprgeek 15y agoWhat really stinks about "not creating a Google chef" scenario is the implicit belief that the chef should not become rich and should not be able to participate in the success of your company. Why the arrogance? If an employee (Chef, Janitor, Developer or CEO) played a part in the success, exactly why is it that they should not participate in the payoff
- Tichy 15y agoAlso the food comes up pretty high on the list of incentives for working at Google. Who knows how many talented people now work at Google because of their chefs. Also consider opportunity cost. The chef could have opened a restaurant instead and perhaps also earn a lot of money that way.
- jiggy2011 15y agoI thought most restaurants basically hemorrhaged money? A job at a tech startup + stock options might have been quite low risk by comparison.
- Tichy 15y agoSure, but if he is a really good chef? Just saying that chefs can make a lot of money, it is not a given that chefs have to be poor.
- neilk 15y agoAccording to BusinessWeek, new restaurants are not quite as risky as people perceive. Only 60% of new restaurants fail or are sold in three years[1], which is a bit higher but similar rate to any new business.[2] I can't find any good numbers on tech startups with some Googling other than the oft-quoted 90%. This is hard to compare, because you might earn some sort of salary while the startup is in operation, but it closes down because it fails to meet growth targets. But on balance it seems to me the startup is still riskier. [1] http://www.businessweek.com/smallbiz/content/apr2007/sb20070416_296932.htm http://www.businessweek.com/smallbiz/content/apr2007/sb20070... [2] http://www.newventurelab.com/resources/blog.php?id=261 http://www.newventurelab.com/resources/blog.php?id=261
- gwern 15y ago> Also consider opportunity cost. The chef could have opened a restaurant instead and perhaps also earn a lot of money that way. Would he have profited millions, on top of his salary? I read routinely about hugely popular top-rated restaurants going under (eg. https://www.nytimes.com/2011/04/27/dining/27zakarian.html?reddit https://www.nytimes.com/2011/04/27/dining/27zakarian.html?re...) or nearly going bankrupt (http://tmagazine.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/08/16/gordon-ramsay-plays-chicken/?reddit http://tmagazine.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/08/16/gordon-ramsay-...). When we're considering risk, let's remember the upside to an option on a restaurant is small, and the risk is practically startup levels.
- OoTheNigerian 15y agoThis Zynga position is the reason why most Nigerian politicians have second wives. A poor young man finds a woman wo will marry him a starter in life, poor with fair education. 20 years down the line after the woman has bore him kids, supported his career, this man becomes a Governor. Then aha! He realizes his mid aged wife is not really educated, not fit for the position of a first lady. He does not want the situation of a high school educated first lady.
- jackgavigan 15y agoIf these people were underperforming, then why didn't Pincus address the issue before now? Why do it now, when Zynga appears to be preparing to IPO? This strikes me as pure greed. Pincus offered people shares as part of a package to persuade them to come work at his risky startup. He made a deal and now he wants to go back on it. Say what you like about Bill Gates but he was perfectly comfortable with early Microsoft employees like Andrea Lewis growing rich from their share options. PS: Lots of people talk about the greed on Wall Street but it strikes me that the prospect of riches is causing greed to rear its ugly head in the startup scene too. What's more, people seem to turn a blind eye to it if the perpetrator has been successful. It's disappointing and I think it bodes ill for the entire sector.
- michaelochurch 15y agoPS: Lots of people talk about the greed on Wall Street but it strikes me that the prospect of riches is causing greed to rear its ugly head in the startup scene too. What's more, people seem to turn a blind eye to it if the perpetrator has been successful. It's disappointing and I think it bodes ill for the entire sector. Very ill. We'll never know the real numbers, but it wouldn't surprise me if Mark Pincus has done $1+ billion worth of damage to the startup ecosystem. Fewer people will want to work for options/equity because of this story (which has caught on outside of our echo chamber) and the reputation of Silicon Valley's leadership has taken a hit. On the flip side, this is a great opportunity for Facebook and Google+ to repair their reputations. Drop Zynga. Denounce Pincus. I don't know about Facebook, but the vast majority of Google engineers who have to work with Zynga detest that company, so this move would also be beneficial for internal morale at many companies.
- jackgavigan 15y agoDo you really think that Facebook, led by Mark "I'm going to fuck them in the ear!" Zuckerberg is concerned about ethics?
- fauldsh 15y agoAre there no laws in the US protecting employees from this kind of scenario? Something like Unfair Dismissal in the UK. As others have said, the first employees took the risk of working for a startup, any-one who joined later can't possibly deserve more because they "contributed more" because the company wouldn't exist without the original employees.
- smackfu 15y agoI wonder if the chef was hired at typical chef wages, or at "startup" chef wages?
- jfruh 15y agoThe thing that most bugs me about this is that the Google chef somehow needs to have his rights defended. He was made a promise when he was hired and Google cheerfully fulfilled its obligation to follow through with that. Ditto on whoever is being screwed at Zynga. "Unvested" does not mean "maybe you will get this at a later date, who can say."
- alex_c 15y agoMost of the business world has no issue with a "you deserve what you negotiate for yourself" mentality - if it applies to your own high compensation, or to someone else's low compensation. It only becomes an issue if someone you perceive to be lower on the pecking order than you has successfully negotiated a good deal. A contract's a contract, and a deal's a deal. "Deserving" it doesn't come into play beyond the scope of the contract.
- esrauch 15y agoThat is exactly what unvested means, it means "maybe you will get this at a later date, maybe you will be fired, who can say." Zynga could just fire all of these people if they didn't want to give them the stock, and that wouldn't be "taking back stock", that would just be "you never had the stock". The only reason why it's evil is because they think the employees are actually valuable enough that they want to keep them around but not valuable enough to keep good on their stock units. They could easily fire the employees and let them re-interview for their old jobs if they wanted and it would be perfectly legal (companies do this on a regular basis to rehire employees as contractors without benefits). RSUs and stock options like this are pretty interesting to me because it provides a huge incentive for employees to stay at the company, but it also provides a huge incentive for employers to fire their employees after (N-1) time periods where N is when their units vest.
- damoncali 15y agoIf the only reason you're firing someone is to keep their stock, you're a dick and it's wrong. This, unlike options agreemetns, is not complicated. It may be legal. And it may be financially rational. But it's wrong.
- dasil003 15y agoIt's laughable to think Pincus is worried about a "Google Chef" scenario. There will be no Google-anything scenario at Zynga.
- webwright 15y agoI'm not sure I agree with earbitscom (commented a few times here), but I upvoted him because I think he's boiled it down to the important point. But for the people downvoting his "options are future compensation" argument, here's an interesting thought exercise: Say you joined a young/really hot startup that was heading straight up. You negotiate a good options package, but it's lean-- they aren't super eager to part with these (obviously valuable) shares. Then, the world explodes. The company gets sued, the market crashes, the users revolt. But the company manages to emerge from the carnage beaten-but-alive. It's no longer a sure thing. In fact, it looks risky as hell. But you believe in the vision and the management, so you want to stick it out. You're 1.5 years in. New hires are getting packages that reflect the (newfound) risk in the stock. Your stock package looks small in comparison. Given the new information, would it be wrong to negotiate for more stock?
- SourPatch 15y agoIf you didn't have some leverage over the company, it would not be wrong. If you were, say, lead engineer, and knew that training a replacement would take quite some time, then it would be wrong.
- doki_pen 15y agoTo argue that he deserved it is to cede the point. It was what he signed up for and google was right to respect that agreement.
- gwern 15y ago> Feeding a few hundred people in a professional setting is not just taking the process of preparing a home-cooked meal and multiplying. If a software engineer screws up, the site goes down. But if a chef screws up, people get sick. In extreme cases, they die. Wow, hyperbole much? A chef only gets people sick or kills if he epically screws up. A thought experiment: figure how many restaurants and fast-food chains there are in the US; multiply by how many people they serve a day; multiply by 365.25; divide by number of annual deaths. Ponder this upper bound on risk. Ponder whether the base-rate risk is greater or lesser than the risk of walking across the street or driving to work. Finally, ponder on whether this base-rate ought to be adjusted upwards or downwards for a trained corporate chef working in a controlled environment with good facilities (as opposed to a newbie teen or immigrant working for minimum wage in a kitchen somewhere).
- davesims 15y agoThe real problem Zynga has created is summed up nicely is this comment from the OP's blog: "Pincus has violated the basic tenant of start up economics and, thus made start ups vastly more risky for people to join. In short he's just ups the cost of hiring at start ups by 10-15%." I suspect long-term it will be much more than that. Whatever the reality behind the scenes, Zynga has created a new startup narrative to replace the "Google Chef" narrative that was precisely the story that made it possible to hire premium talent willing to risk a few years and hard work on the chance of a big payout. Zynga has quickly and fairly decisively dealt a near death-blow to that idea. Between Zynga and the stories coming out of the Skype acquisition a few months ago, I expect startups will find it increasingly difficult to trade stock options in lieu of compensation early on. Unless and until some legal device is created to re-establish that trust, I expect we'll be looking back on this incident in years to come as the moment when startups lost one of the essential strategies to hiring top talent early. Everyone will be skittish over this for quite some time.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- whacker 15y agoWhy is this even being debated? How is the chef, or any other employee, any different from an early stage investor?
- pg 15y agoIt's not about cooks vs hackers. This is the critical point: Charlie didn't make $20M for cooking, he made $20M for taking the risk The money that founders and early employees make from startups they make as investors. They're getting compensated for risk, not simply for the work they do. Startups are volatile, which is why investors like them. Like other startup investors, early employees sometimes get really lucky. But that is not the same thing as being overpaid. I can't say much for sure about this particular case because I don't know the details, but I don't like the sound of it. It seems so shortsighted. The amounts of stock involved must be small, and the damage done not just to Zynga but the whole startup world could be big.
- codyrobbins 15y agoDisclaimer: Only having read the WSJ article and knowing nothing more, I think it’s more or less a form of blackmail—the employees are unfairly being put in a no-win situation. That being said, my takeaway was that they had thrown around equity so liberally that they’ve exhausted their employee options pool and it’s going to interfere with their ability to recruit going forward. Is that the wrong interpretation? If it’s not, and given such a situation, do you think it’s fair to say that a startup should generally be trying to allocate its options carefully such that a chef doesn’t end up with $20M worth of equity?
- aneth 15y agoGiven that most equity is worth nothing in the end I don't think you're correct. The beautiful thing about equity is that its future value can not be determined and it's not possible to limit the upside fairly. If employers start putting a cap on the upside, it undermines the shoot-for-the-moon lets make this a $100 billion dollar company spirit that equity otherwise engenders. Had Google had a $1B exit, or a $100M exit - both far more likely scenarios when the chef joined - the grant would have seemed perfectly reason. This has nothing to do with risk and all to do with incentive. Whether your grant is on top of a full salary or not is irrelevant.
- blacksmythe 15y ago>> That being said, my takeaway was that they had thrown around equity so liberally that they’ve exhausted their employee options pool and it’s going to interfere with their ability to recruit going forward. They can issue more stock to incentivize new employees, which is fair in that it dilutes everyone equally (preferred and common together). What is unfair is to assume that the preferred stock allocation must be a constant, and that you have to claw back existing stock options in order to pass on stock in the existing options pool to new employees.
- paul 15y agoThis is a good example of why Google became a great company: they understood the big picture. Zynga apparently does not.
- davesims 15y agoFor all of you trying to parse this on a purely business level and justify Zynga on some ethical or legal distinction between 'vested' and 'unvested', etc., understand this: The take-away lesson, from the standpoint of an experienced developer being offered stock options in lieu of compensation is, from now on, a simple story, and it's the one you will have to overcome for the foreseeable future, thanks to Pincus: Once upon a time the "Google Chef" could become a millionare. Now he can't. The End
- martian 15y agoMy startup has an in-house chef. It is the best investment we have made. Employees are happy, morale is high, we eat healthy food, and stay late to have a family-style dinner. When we make it big, I'm going to be stoked to share profits with her. :-) One of my colleagues takes pictures of our food and puts them up here: http://thumbtackfood.tumblr.com/ http://thumbtackfood.tumblr.com/
- justinhj 15y agobeing a chef is a hard job for sure but the real point here is that being on board for a succesful ipo is like a lottery win for all early employees. let them have it and enjoy it. don't make them feel like shit by telling them they don't deserve it. i don't see any win for zynga here
- linuxhansl 15y agoI do not understand this entire discussion. He joined Google, got early stock options that ended up being worth a lot. Good for him. Where is the problem? The system worked.
- code_duck 15y agoThis is a pointless rebuttal, because it's not about who contributed what, or how hard a chef worked, or whether their job was worth it. If you make a deal with someone for x amount of stock, or whatever, they get it. You don't try to strong arm them into giving it back later on - that's dishonest. It doesn't matter if it's worth 20 million or 20 cents.
- HarrietTubgirl 15y agoI interned at Google back in the day, and when I came back to school, I can only remember raving about one thing -- the food. It was absolutely fucking amazing. I gained 10 pounds that summer (starting at 145, this probably wasn't a bad thing). There was a lot I could have raved about. The fact that around my area in ads there was probably a 20% chance that an individual had his own Wikipedia page. The debugging tools I got to work with and the MapReduces I got to write. All of the geeky stuff that makes Google a cool place to work at. But when I got back to school, the food is really what stuck out about the experience. I would argue that those cafeterias are one of Google's most marketable benefits. A bad programmer who is overcompensated just blends in, a great chef gets singled out. No matter what, equity distributions are going to look insane in retrospect. Probably the most glaring ones are not even going to be the under-performers who plodded along or folks in less-important roles that were hired early, but the crappy execs that were hired well after the risk was decreased, but got a huge stock grant anyway. Start with those guys. Let's be honest here -- how hard someone works isn't directly relevant to the discussion, it's how much value they end up adding. But to that point, I'm pretty sure Charlie added a lot more value to the company than many software engineers there had.
- missy 15y agoI know in stocks you can sell futures. So you say, the shares are worth 1$ today as a fresh start up, in 2 years we will buy them back of you for 20 $, if the share is worth over 20$. If your are Zynga and you are confident that they could go above that its a good buy and the worker feels a bit more secure but wont earn these too high returns that Zynga may not like . Sorry if my application of basic futures to Zynga are bit off, hope explains more or less what I mean, my memory is flaky here.
- balsam 15y agoI don't know, man. I would rather give shares to someone who can keep my teammates and I on the brink of starvation. Does nobody remember the motto "stay hungry, stay foolish"?