16 ms·
From August 1: Cash transactions above NIS 6k illegal
- Linda703 4y ago[dead]
- collegeburner 4y agowell uhh fuck that. its only like $1740 and the reasons they list for getting rid of cash is exactly why we need cash.
- _8j50 4y agoAnd why bitcoin is here to stay regardless of price and of course xmr.
- p1necone 4y agoBitcoin specifically is inadequate to act as anything more than a very infrequently traded store of value. Not a currency that is exchanged for goods and services in small amounts by many people. Someone needs to build a better cryptocurrency, but it everyone is preoccupied with building ponzi schemes and pump and dump scams instead.
- _8j50 4y agoThere is eth and btc cash. Lightning payment is also a thing even eith btc. It is really a question of merchants willing to spend time supporting it give lack of significanr consumer demand.
- aaronbrethorst 4y agoAh yes, the notoriously computer-illiterate Israeli government will never think to monitor Bitcoin transactions.
- cube00 4y ago7 transactions a second won't cut it unfortunately[1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bitcoin_scalability_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bitcoin_scalability_problem
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 4y agoBitcoin's layer 2 can do 7000 transactions per second easily.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hristov 4y agoIt is very easy to track crypto spending. All the information is there on the blockchain for anybody to peruse. The blockchain may not have personal identifications, but you only need to catch a person spending bitcoin once in order to match them to a blockchain wallet. So if the Israeli government's goal is to track citizen's spending, they will love crypto.
- jondwillis 4y agoI’ve been considering “laundering” my own crypto through a handful of bespoke smart contracts that I write myself since I doubt anyone on IRS salary would actually read my source code.
- ayende 4y agoAt which point you are probably guilty of "structuring". Which is a crime all on its own. Also, that only holds up until someone actually looks at you.
- reedjosh 4y agoBut XMR is private?
- _8j50 4y agoNot with single use wallets. If you have multiple transactions yes but if you create a new wallet put btc in it and spend it all and each time you spend you create a new wallet it is much like cash.
- hristov 4y agoBut you will have to move BTC from the old wallet to the new one. And that will be visible on the blockchain.
- _8j50 4y agoNo, that's what I am saying you will spend the entire wallet no transfers. If HN was charging me something I will create a new wallet at say paxful, populate it with btc by paying much more than exchange rate in exchange for giftcards or wire (or cash if they are local) and then pay HN, never use that wallet again. Of course the threat to this has been thay american/western services have all become KYC (mandatory ID check) still possible with chinese and other services. Another alternative is to store it all in XMR and populate single use btc wallets with one time XMR transfers all while VPN+Tor'd.
- MerelyMortal 4y agoAll the replies so far seem to focus on Bitcoin and not XMR (Monero). Monero does a better job at solving the problems that have been mentioned about Bitcoin: A blocksize that scales which also leads to reduced fees, transactions and address balances are private. (Disclaimer: I own some XMR, but not much.)
- throwaway290 4y agoProps for the disclaimer. However, it seems doubtful that Monero is 'better' than cash either. The idea is less about chasing after cash money, and more that if e.g. you suggest me to deal in cash I must consider that I will be on the hook forever in case this leaks -- doesn't matter if this is due to your negligence, your disgruntled employee or partner whistleblowing, advances in spying tech, another customer reporting you, etc. It's the same with Monero, possibly worse. With cash, taking all precautions once is enough (ensure there are no cameras around, leave my phone at home, wear gloves, etc.), while the only way to have all the evidence gone from blockchain is only by having Monero itself gone, right?
- anigbrowl 4y agolol imagine still buying this. You have even less privacy with BTC than you do with fiat.
- p1necone 4y agoYeah, the average laypersons idea of crypto seems to be that it's totally anonymous. When I explain that most are pseudonymous not anonymous and that every single transaction being publicly visible forever is a feature, not a bug they seem pretty shocked.
- Double_a_92 4y agoThis seems extreme, but it's actually already common in some European countries (e.g. Italy where the limit is 999€).
- solatic 4y agoSurprised to find this on the front page of HN. Note that the current law already forbids cash transactions higher than 11,000 NIS and that an exception is carved out for automobile purchases. This law is tightening screws that already exist, not implementing new screws.
- kelnos 4y agoI hadn't heard of this before today, and I think the same is probably true for many other people, so I found it interesting and notable.
- noisy_boy 4y agoMaybe it is beneficial for the knowledge of those who didn't know about the original screws in the first place.
- brigandish 4y agoWhy is an insidious erosion of rights and liberties better than a sudden one, and why does that (if that's why, it's unclear) make it surprising to find on the front page?
- solatic 4y agoCulturally, Israelis only value privacy in very narrow contexts that are carved out and afforded protection in law (reputational and medical privacy). This is a country where there are security guards who open your bags before you can enter public places like government offices, malls, and public transit terminals, and airport security at Ben Gurion is world-famous for its invasiveness. Israelis accept this because Ben Franklin's quote about liberty and security falls on deaf ears here. To Israelis, security is a pre-requisite for liberty, not the other way around, and there is wide public support for measures that would be completely DOA in the US, like government identity registries (that now include facial scans and fingerprint databases, with fingerprinting admittedly optional but fingerprinting extends the validity period of issued identification) and extremely strict gun control. Financial security is pretty much the same, for example, most of the Israeli drug trade links back to terrorist organizations and as such a "war on cash" is seen by many as fighting against terrorists as well.
- alfiedotwtf 4y agoIt's almost like we need some kind of cryptography currency
- patates 4y agoWhat does a "cryptography currency" bring to the table in regards to this problem that cash hasn't? The fact that it hasn't been banned... yet? Cash is way less traceable than most cryptocurrencies.
- redox99 4y agoOf course cash is better, but with cash the government is in charge of issuance. What are you going to do if governments decide against issuing any more cash? Bills will eventually break, or the currency itself will lose too much value due to inflation that the bills won't enough. With crypto you don't rely on your government issuing cash.
- t-3 4y agoIf governments ban cash, it's back to barter. Drugs/alcohol/cigarettes, weapons, food, gas, gold and silver...
- tphyahoo2 4y agoAnyone can issue (paper) cash. Cash is just a paper IOU for some other thing. With 100 dollar bill, that thing is 100 USD. You could also issue paper for gold backed IOU, or gold itself, or bitcoin. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wildcat_banking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wildcat_banking Counterfeiting paper is a problem, so you need force against this, and this is why the government is generally involved. But what kind of paper counterfeiting is enforced against, is just a legality. Currently the wost thing to counterfeit is 100 dollar bills. Law could be changed to make it equally bad to counterfeit gold bills, or bitcoin bills. Saying bitcoin is less private than cash is a category error.
- walterbell 4y ago> there are plans afoot to impose additional restrictions on cash in the future, with the Treasury and Tax Authority pushing for a law prohibiting any citizen from holding more than NIS 200,000 in cash in his home. One motivation for CBDCs (Central Bank Digital Currencies) was succinctly stated by BIS (Bank of International Settlements, the central bank for all central banks, including US and UK) Director Carstens at an IMF meeting in 2020, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mVmKN4DSu3g&t=1451s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mVmKN4DSu3g&t=1451s > With cash, we don't know who is using the 100 dollar bill today ... a key difference with CBDC is that the central bank will have absolute control on the rules and regulations that determine the expression of that central bank liability .. also we will have the technology to enforce that ... if an advanced economy issues a CBDC, and someone in a 3rd country wants to use it, it will require the consent of the central bank of the residence of that person, therefore the degree of control will be far bigger. Previous CBDC threads on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30634245 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30634245 (2022), https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27805709 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27805709 (2021). Meanwhile, the US UCC (Uniform Commercial Code) was modified in July 2022 to recognize CERs (controllable electronic records), a flexible definition which could apply to both decentralized cryptocurrencies and centralized CBDCs. It's now up to individual U.S. states to ratify these changes in state legislation, https://www.clearygottlieb.com//news-and-insights/publication-listing/ucc-digital-asset-amendments-finalized https://www.clearygottlieb.com//news-and-insights/publicatio... > Control under Article 12 is designed to be a technology-neutral functional equivalent of “possession.” It generally encompasses circumstances when a party has the “private key” or other mechanism to avail itself of substantially all of the benefits of the record, prevent others from availing themselves of such benefits, and transfer the record and associated benefits.
- influxmoment 4y agoChina will definitely be the leader in CBCDs. This is the kind of control over their population they seek
- lettergram 4y ago> The stated purpose of the law is to force the general public to use digital means of payment rather than cash, so that transactions can be easily monitored. You mean you don’t want the government monitoring you at all times? I mean, the end goal is also to decide what you spend it on… > Digital dollars, on the other hand, would be traceable and programmable. The Federal Reserve (or some other designated entity) would have the ability to create more digital dollars whenever it sees fit, and, depending on how the legislation is written setting up the currency, the dollars could be formulated to have various rules and restrictions built into their design. https://thehill.com/opinion/finance/599768-biden-is-planning-a-new-digital-currency-heres-why-you-should-be-very-worried/ https://thehill.com/opinion/finance/599768-biden-is-planning... (This is the US, but UK, EU, and I’m assuming elsewhere all have the same legislation at the moment. China already has this to a degree with the social credit system) Imagine, I go to get groceries: checkout machine: “sorry, you used all your carbon credits this month” You: “but I need food!” Checkout machine: “if you need food, remember cricket powder is carbon net neutral” You: “guess I’ll eat that this week.. grumble” Yeah, that’s literally and explicitly what is being discussed. Maybe this scenario is exaggerated, but carbon tax credit and restricting purchases inbound.
- kichik 4y agoFor context, under the table transactions are very common in Israel. Tax avoidance is everywhere.
- DSingularity 4y agoAre you surprised that a country built by illegally stealing other peoples land and property would have citizens who don’t respect its laws?
- ls15 4y agoIf the citizens of a democracy don't respect its laws, then it is not a democracy.
- barry-cotter 4y ago> a country built by illegally stealing other peoples land That would be all of them? Even if you ignore illegally I’m not aware of a sovereign state that was settled by people who were there first settlers and has continuity of government.
- quickthrower2 4y agos/Israel/every country/
- walterbell 4y agoThose pesky citizens! Meanwhile, https://wallstreetonparade.com/2020/09/3-count-felon-jpmorgan-chase-caught-laundering-more-dirty-money/ https://wallstreetonparade.com/2020/09/3-count-felon-jpmorga... > ... secret documents leaked from FinCEN, the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, a unit of the U.S. Treasury. The documents “show that five global banks — JPMorgan, HSBC, Standard Chartered Bank, Deutsche Bank and Bank of New York Mellon — kept profiting from powerful and dangerous players even after U.S. authorities fined these financial institutions for earlier failures to stem flows of dirty money.” Trailer for Netflix series, The Laundromat, https://youtube.com/watch?v=wuBRcfe4bSo https://youtube.com/watch?v=wuBRcfe4bSo
- 4y ago
- kragen 4y agoAnother entry in the list of "What is Bitcoin good for, anyway?"
- vxNsr 4y agoBitcoin is actually worse than this. Bitcoin is easily traceable and doesn’t solve the “anonymous money” problem that cold hard cash solves. Not only is Bitcoin easily traceable the record exists forever and is impossible to erase. There are other crypto products that attempt to solve this issue but Bitcoin is definitely not one of them.
- redox99 4y agoBitcoin is much better in that it's pseudonymous (instead of 100% associated to your real identity) and cannot be censored (instead of your government being able to freeze your funds, only allow transferring from/to X, up to Y amount, etc).
- etchalon 4y agoModern forensics techniques make Bitcoin's pseudonymous nature more or less irrelevant. Worse, anti-censorship only extends within Bitcoin itself. The moment Bitcoin has to touch traditional financial networks it becomes more easily censorable.
- MerelyMortal 4y agoBitcoin is censorable, and it has been censored in the past by miners refusing to include transactions that they viewed as spam. Because Bitcoin transactions are public, they can be discriminated against.
- kragen 4y agoIt takes a "51% attack" majority of miners to refuse to include a transaction, and then only if they're willing to reject blocks mined by others that include it, at the risk of their own blocks being rejected by full nodes (like Coinbase's and Binance's) if their 51% majority turns out not to be as solid as they thought it was. As far as I know this has never happened; the only transactions I've seen excluded from the blockchain are unanimous things like the spam transactions you're talking about.
- young_unixer 4y agoPlease, HN, tell me again how cryptocurrencies are useless.
- quickthrower2 4y agoBecause the malware they have backdoored into your phone can track what money you have sent/received?
- ori_b 4y agoYou're right -- the traceable transaction ledger that most cryptocurrencies generate is exactly what this law is intended to force people towards, to ease the burden on law enforcement. Combined with basic know-your-customer laws, they're quite useful for tracking down illegal transactions.
- trinovantes 4y ago"Hmm this person is receiving high value products but we have no record of money being exchanged. Maybe we should send the police to 'interrogate'"
- Double_a_92 4y agoHow would crypto currencies solve this issue? Crypto transactions above that value are also illegal and traceable. If you wanted to break the law it would be easier to just keep using regular cash. OR just use your bank account / card to send money, which is kinda like crypto but easier and legal.
- throwaway290 4y agoMind elaborating how cryptocurrencies are at all helpful here? How's government saying 2k cash transactions are illegal different from it saying 2k Bitcoin or Monero transactions are illegal? The point is not that cops will now chase after conspicuous stacks of colorful paper, but that law-abiding citizens and businesses will refuse dealing with you and/or report you to police if you suggest to commit an offence.
- cperciva 4y agoI'm surprised that this applies to cheques. Can someone from the region explain this? In Canada cash transactions over $10k are possible but require a large amount of extra paperwork for anti-money-laundering reasons, but there's no such restriction on cheques since the government can see all those clearing through the banking system already.
- solatic 4y agoIn Israel, checks are basically legally-enforced IOUs and are thus nearly the same as cash. Once a check is written in a particular amount, that check can be transferred to another party. If the check bounces, that party can take the person who wrote the check to court and begin legal proceedings to enforce a recovery of the funds in the amount listed on the check. Israel has a state institution, Hotza'ah LePo'al, which enforces the collection and payment of debt through means like garnishing wages and cancelling passports. To evade taxes, one merely needs to trade in such IOUs without actually cashing them out.
- ars 4y ago> To evade taxes, one merely needs to trade in such IOUs without actually cashing them out. So because the law about bounced checks is so strict, checks are essentially as good as cash? That's an amazing unintended effect.
- cperciva 4y agoAha, interesting! In Canada it's possible to "countersign" a cheque, allowing it to be cashed by a third party, but in practice it's extremely rare and many banks refuse to cash such cheques. It never occurred to me that this mechanism could be used for money laundering!
- anjel 4y agoEliminate non-fungible revenue and many many forms of corruption are abruptly rendered extinct. It might even repurpose why people enter politics.
- atemerev 4y agoOh, cash is not how you bribe politicians in (relatively) civilized countries. Inside information, bearer shares in offshore projects, and board seats will have to do.
- boomboomsubban 4y agoIt's crazy how they openly admit they're targeting the exception available to PA Arabs yet are fine with the one available to haredi Jews. I realize it's completely in line with Israel's laws, but imagine if there was a change in US law with a loophole that kept Christian churches tax exempt but closed that loophole for Jewish synagogues. The outrage would be immense. Yet in this story the line is a non-issue, seemingly thrown in to show an added "bonus" of making things worse for PA Arabs.
- ars 4y agoThis law applies to the Israeli trading with the PA Arab, not to the PA Arab.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hristov 4y agoThe main reason for this is taxes. It is the same reason why India's government is also trying to ban cash (with very negative results for the economy). You see rich people have to use banks. Because over certain sums, using cash just becomes way too dangerous. So they use banks which means the banks report to the government and the government gets their taxes. But rich people also often influence the government (or even outright run it). And they hate paying taxes. So they want to shift some of the taxation burden on to the middle class and the poor. But poor people often use cash and sometimes skim on taxes. I am sure this happens with some of the more adventurous middle class too. For smaller sums cash is perfectly manageable. Thus, the government becomes very concerned and does everything it can to "help" the poor move to more modern electronic payments.
- idan 4y agoThis is totally unaligned with my experience. Yes, the wealthy can afford to find ways to cheat on everything. But all segments of society are dodging taxes. As a middle-class salaried employee, your income is taxed down to the last decimal place. But if you work in the trades, or anything else where many transactions are handled in cash, then tax evasion is _rampant_. And you know who is usually party to that? The tradespeople AND the relatively wealthier folks giving them envelopes of cash in exchange for a "discount" because the transaction isn't reported. Will those stop? Probably not. But at least in larger sums it should make people afraid of dodging their tax burden.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tpoacher 4y ago> The main reason for this is taxes The reason doesn't really matter. What matters is that it's happening.
- radiKal07 4y ago> they hate paying taxes. So they want to shift some of the taxation burden on to the middle class and the poor. I don't understand how making middle/poor class pay more taxes spares the rich from taxes.
- anonymous344 4y agoIt's almost like we would need a global rise from the consumers (99,9%) against the bank moguls & wef. If we only knew who these ~1000 people were..
- knowaveragejoe 4y agoBeen seeing WEF pop up all over the place in contrarian, mainly right circles lately - what's the deal with that? It was traditionally a bogeyman of the more left-leaning global conspiracies in the 90s and 2000s
- cbg0 4y agoConspiracies are like fads, they come and go.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ajvs 4y agoTheir promotional materials with sinister messages like "you'll own nothing and be happy", "great reset" discussed in Klaus Schwab's book which puts the world under technocrat control, their young leaders tending to support their authoritarian policies, etc. make them a disturbingly powerful antagonistic organisation to be aware of.
- systemvoltage 4y agoKlaus Schwab lol, Charles Schwab is the banking CEO. Very cool guy.
- ajvs 4y ago> Klaus Oops, corrected. Thanks!
- knowaveragejoe 4y agoCan you link some of these promotional materials with sinister messaging, or their young leaders supporting authoritarian policies? I think the reason I'm seeing this all over the place in conspiracy circles this week is some grift podcast brought it up - in a week or two we'll be on to something else.
- eyelidlessness 4y ago> Another exception applies to PA Arabs, although according to attorney Uri Goldman, this situation will be rectified by the end of 2022. To be absolutely clear here, “PA Arabs” refers to those governed by the Palestinian Authority… as agreed to by Israel, so excluding the Gaza Strip… and “rectified” refers to subjecting anyone under that agreed authority to Israeli law rather than any agreement with any party. “Rectified” here means effectively acknowledging that PA governance is effectively squat. Which it has been for some time, but the other consequence is that there’s no denying Israel is a colonial occupier of Palestinian territories.
- ars 4y agoThe law applies to the Israeli not the PA Arab. > no denying Israel is a colonial occupier of Palestinian territories. You are seriously messed up. How can a native to the land also be a colonizer?
- kennywinker 4y ago> the area of ancient Israel was predominantly Jewish until the Jewish–Roman wars of 66–136 CE. During the wars, the Roman Empire expelled most of the Jews from the area and formed the Roman province of Syria Palaestina > 1948, when the Jewish State of Israel was proclaimed in part of the ancient land of Israel. This was made possible by the Zionist movement and its promotion of mass Jewish immigration. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Jews_and_Judaism_in_the_Land_of_Israel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Jews_and_Judais...) > Colonization, constitutes large-scale population movements wherein migrants maintain strong links with their, or their ancestors', former country – by such links, gaining substantial privileges over other inhabitants of the territory. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colonization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colonization) The history of Isreal is poorly summarized by these three quotes - but your "a native to the land" is a worse summary. A wrongful expulsion, or thousands of years away, doesn't give you a right to displace and oppress on your return.
- eyelidlessness 4y ago> The law applies to the Israeli not the PA Arab. “Rectified” is the exact wording I quoted, they plan to apply the law to Palestinians under the PA authority. > How can a native to the land also be a colonizer? By doing the actions colonizers do to other people native to the land. Imposing their national law on those explicitly not subject to it is pretty clear cut, without even considering the other Palestinians they exempt from clear cut designation under their law.
- eftychis 4y agoThis is such a dark future (and present for some apparently).
- ARandomerDude 4y ago> The theory is that this will stifle black market activity Black market activity is already illegal. As usual, this kind of government overreach will only punish law abiding citizens for being law abiding citizens.
- ls15 4y agoSo when there was a black market for banned goods, there now is a black market for banned goods AND banned money. No?
- ayende 4y agoThe idea is that you make holding a lot of cash much harder to work with on day to day life. That means the incentives for that are far lower. It also complicate illegal activities in general. The idea isn't that your typical criminal will say: "I'm okay with dealing drugs, but the law about 6K NIS is where I draw the line". The idea is that once they get the money in cash, they have a problem actually using that. So they have to go into addition hurdles. Basically, it makes illegal activities more expensive.
- imgabe 4y agoCriminals already have means of laundering their illicit cash. They can't just deposit it in their bank account anyway without accounting for how they got it. They have a front business that accepts small cash transactions (which would be under this limit anyway) so they can report it as legitimate income.
- olliej 4y agoThis took me a while to understand, this is targeting physical cash transactions - online transfers/payments were the norm for me growing up in NZ. The absurd difficulty of transferring money online in the US was incredibly frustrating when I first moved here, though not as absurd as when I discovered that in the US having someone's bank account# meant you can take money from their account.
- ibejoeb 4y ago>in the US having someone's bank account# meant you can take money from their account. The account number is written on every check. This is simply not the case.
- olliej 4y agoYes it is. The way you do online payments in the US if not by credit card is by providing the recipient with your account number - they conveniently point to the parts of the cheque to copy - and then they withdraw money from that account. Better yet when I was first trying to set up my online banking so that I could send money to my partner E*trade had me enter their account#, and then confirm the amount that they sent to it. Once I confirmed it they let me pull money out of her account at will. Because they were enforcing the can/cannot withdraw money for my partners account with another bank. A lot of the reason for things like Venmo, etc existing in the US is because you can’t simply send money to a bank account. Everything assumes that having an account# means having something to withdraw money from.
- graderjs 4y agoI don't want people monitoring or controlling what I spend stuff on. I love cash. I hate the idea of a restriction on that. At the same time, if governments fail to efficiently tax their populations they end up having to go to war to plunder the resources they need to maintain their countries instead. Probably another solution tho.
- noduerme 4y agoyeah, I'm going with there's probably something in between plundering your own population and plundering your neighbor's.
- choward 4y ago> At the same time, if governments fail to efficiently tax their populations they end up having to go to war to plunder the resources they need to maintain their countries instead. This is a pretty bold assertion. Do you have an example of this happening? If a country has all the resources it needs then it's not going to have to plunder resources. If it doesn't have to the resources it needs it either has to trade for them, borrow, or plunder as a worst case scenario. It has absolutely nothing to do with taxes. Also, with your logic, how do you afford an army to plunder resources if the reason for plundering is because they didn't "efficiently tax"? To go to war to plunder some resources, you need the resources. You can tax all you want but if you don't have the real resources you can't build an army. Taxes can put resources you already have to work but it can't create them out of thin air.
- graderjs 4y agoTake a read of [this book], it has plenty of examples throughout history (from ancient times to today). From memory, most recent example is I think Japan in WWII, and maybe Germany in both wars tho I can't recall clearly right now. The thesis is: expansionist tendencies arise because states fail to efficiently tax their populations so they seek wealth through plunder. Good question about where the money comes from first, I can't remember what the book said now but I'm sure there's possible solutions. Maybe: seize from the rich people in your own country first (likely by demonizing them ~ I think China did this to elites during the cultural revolution from memory from [another book]); the leaders are savvy enough to go to war before all the funds are gone; bootstrap by using emotive demonization of enemy and fear (I guess the Nazis did this to Jews before and during WWII) so you can be scrappy at first until you plunder some wealth and use it to upgrade and purchase more soliders. [that book]: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9491855-why-the-west-rules-for-now https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9491855-why-the-west-rul... [that other book]: https://www.bookdepository.com/Mao-The-Unknown-Story-Jon-Halliday/9780099507376 https://www.bookdepository.com/Mao-The-Unknown-Story-Jon-Hal...?
- aviramha 4y agoas an Israeli, I really think this is a good thing. I hate the use of cash. I understand digital privacy and liberal concerns, but apart from the theoretical liberty taken, most non-criminals dont use cash and prefer digital payments.
- jesterson 4y ago> I really think this is a good thing. I hate the use of cash Noone forces you to use cash, isn't it? > apart from the theoretical liberty taken why theoretical? It's a liberty taken. > most non-criminals dont use cash and prefer digital payments Do you have evidence supporting this? I am not a criminal, but I have no intentions to share how my money are spent with actual criminals, who constitute government bodies.
- leipert 4y agoMildly related. A lot of countries have limits on physical cash transactions. Germany doesn’t. You can buy a mansion and pay for it in physical cash. Apart from the tax implications, it is an effective way to launder money. Apparently organized crime really likes this and buys real estate en masse.
- Double_a_92 4y agoI still don't understand how those supposed money laundering plots work. E.g. if you buy a house with dirty money, wouldn't the tax agency still ask you why you suddenly own a house and how you could afford to buy it? My tax agency already asks questions if my living costs seem too low...
- bobthepanda 4y agoWell, table stakes are to obfuscate you. A nesting doll of shell companies buys the house on your behalf that you live in. In a lot of cases tax agencies also lack the means or authority to verify the cleanliness of money obtained abroad.
- leipert 4y agoThey pay taxes on it. This is why the state “doesn’t care”. As far as I recall, when you buy a house, the notary is supposed to check where the money is coming from, but this can be more of a handwavey thing. This is a slightly older article, I am on the go and didn’t find anything more in depth in English: https://m.dw.com/en/german-real-estate-market-a-hotbed-of-money-laundering-transparency-reports/a-46637937 https://m.dw.com/en/german-real-estate-market-a-hotbed-of-mo...
- wolongong942 4y agoIn NZ or Aus the house would be taken under civil forfeiture, with you having to show a legit paper trail for the money to get your asset back. I think they're making it so you don't even have to be associated with any crime, and nothing has to be proven beyond reasonable doubt because it's civil.
- logifail 4y agoThe European Central Bank decided to discontinue issuing the €500 note back in 2019[0], "due to concerns of widespread use for illegal purposes"[1]. It wouldn't surprise me if other central banks/governments were to take this approach in a future crackdown on cash, step by step getting rid of the largest denomination. It would get pretty hard to use cash for large payments if there weren't any large banknotes available. (Full disclosure: the largest cash payment I've ever made was in fact made in those very €500 notes, pre-2019...) [0] https://www.ecb.europa.eu/euro/banknotes/html/index.en.html https://www.ecb.europa.eu/euro/banknotes/html/index.en.html [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/500_euro_note https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/500_euro_note
- wsc981 4y agoThe Bank of International Settlements (BIS) wants to have full control of everyone’s money in the future [0]. This is not possible with cash, but with CBDCs it’s possible to exercise full control. ——— [0]: https://m.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=10&v=9FM4Fu2ujDE https://m.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=10&v=9FM4Fu2ujDE
- sjaak 4y agoIf you want to deposit an EUR 200 banknote at some banks in my country the bank will charge you EUR 5. Per note.
- redox99 4y agoHow is that even legal?
- barry-cotter 4y agoIs that a Euro using country?
- sjaak 4y agoYes, The Netherlands See this (in Dutch): https://radar.avrotros.nl/nieuws/item/rabobank-5-euro-betalen-voor-storten-van-200-euro-en-500-euro-vanaf-1-oktober/ https://radar.avrotros.nl/nieuws/item/rabobank-5-euro-betale...
- godmode2019 4y agoNew Zealand is making it illegal to buy Gold with cash. This is not about paying taxes its a global move to make sure the banking systems are well funded, and runs on the bank are pointless during periods of high inflation. Cash is problematic, how is the banking system meant to increase money supply if everyone holds physical cash.
- DocTomoe 4y agoNo, no more buying used cars from private citizens. Got you. Sure, you could do this by the bank, wait for a few days, then constantly wonder if it arrived, and/or if the car seller is scamming you, while the (honest) car seller wonders the same thing, facing a third potential buyer who brings cash. Or you can just, you know, become a criminal and decide to ignore that particular law.
- krab 4y agoI actually prefer to buy and sell used cars with wire transfer. Within EU, they're usually instantaneous within a country and overnight internationally. I don't have to worry about carrying larger amount of money - when I was purchasing my first motorcycle, it was literally almost everything I had at the time. If something goes wrong and I got scammed, the money can be tracked a little bit better than with cash. EDIT: And in this case, there seems to be an exception specifically for cars.
- em500 4y agoOr you could implement a system like in our country where national wire transfers arrive in seconds without any fees.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 4y agoI recently sent a US national wire transfer (known as ACH) from my bank account to my account in another bank. Took two weeks.
- tzs 4y ago> No, no more buying used cars from private citizens. Got you. There is no change when it comes to buying cars. The limit before this change was NIS 50000 for payments between private individuals. That limit is dropping to NIS 15000, but there is an exception keeping it at NIS 50000 for car purchases.
- notme1234 4y agoThere was an exiting legislation for 11K, so this new legislation only reduced the sum to 6K. Not sure how this law is going to be enforced (as many of the laws in Israel are not strictly enforced).
- codedokode 4y agoIt seems like governments around the world want to push people to keep their money in the bank. But this is an awful idea: first, in this case the government can track all your spending (even if the law doesn't allow that, they can ask the bank informally). Second, the government can always limit how much you can spend or withdraw. For example, if there is a financial crisis, the government can limit how much you can withdraw from your account. Those with cash might be able to buy currency or precious metals, but those who trust the bank will be screwed. But to be honest cash is not much better. For example, the government can introduce a cash reform, and also set limits for exchanging old currency to new one.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 4y agoThat's exactly why Bit--in was invented. Electronic money, kept outside of gov control.
- jaza 4y agoA government with little enough concern for its citizens, and enough tech savviness, can effectively ban cryptocurrency too. Case in point: China.
- alkonaut 4y agoSame in many countries where it’s just too inconvenient even if it’s legal. For example in Sweden some Ukrainian refugees who fled without their documents can’t open bank accounts so now can’t be paid despite having worked since may. It’s just not possible for an employer to pay employees any other way than directly trough a bank account. Which is good in most cases (less tax evasion and money laundering) but it gets silly in some edge cases. This (not being able to pass out a check or a few $100 bills every month) must sound absolutely insane to Americans.
- N19PEDL2 4y agoIn Italy the current limit for cash transactions is €2k, but it will be lowered to €1k starting from 2023. [0] (Just for reference, NIS 6k is roughly equal to €1.7k) [0] (Italian) https://bancadiasti.it/senza-categoria/utilizzo-dei-contanti-nuovi-limiti-a-partire-dal-1-marzo-2022/ https://bancadiasti.it/senza-categoria/utilizzo-dei-contanti...
- cantrevealname 4y ago> Around NIS 5 billion have already been collected in fines since the restrictions were voted into law. In 2022 alone, around 6,000 audits have been conducted so far, with 2,189 law-breakers identified, representing a sum of NIS 35 million in illicit transactions. That figure of NIS 5 billion, or US $1.45 billion[1], must be error because it suggests they are fining people $95K when caught doing a $5K cash transaction[2]. It seems very extreme, enough to bankrupt many people and businesses; it can't be right. [1] The exchange rate for the NIS (New Israeli Shekel) to US dollars is about NIS 3.44 = US $1.00. [2] Extrapolating backwards, if 2,189 law-breakers did NIS 35 million in illicit transactions so far this year, then in the last 3.5 years since the law came into effect, 15,323 law-breakers did NIS 245 million in illicit transactions, for an average transaction size of NIS 15,989 or US $4,647. So each law-breaker received an average fine of NIS 326,306 (NIS 5 billion divided by 15,323), or US $94,856, which is 20 times greater that the illicit transaction itself.
- Lapsa 4y agodeath sentence punishment for using money
- orko3310 4y agoanother + is that they can track much better what and when people buy stuff. Cash is at least kind of anonymous
- bjourne 4y agoArutz Sheva/Israel National News is an extremist right-wing rag. A more extreme version of Daily Mail or Fox News. While the claims it makes may be true, they may as well be completely false or severely distorted. If the story hasn't been reported in reliable Israeli press (Haaretz, Times of Israel, ynetnews) INN may be misrepresenting it.