9 ms·
Instagram gets worse with dark patterns lifted from TikTok
- gsatic 4y agoIs the Tucker Carlson story few days back, about the tiktok algo promoting edu and wholesome content within China, but twerking and gender transition in the west true?
- desindol 4y agoYes because they do as they are told.
- abledon 4y agowaiting for my Civilization: VII game to have 'boost twerking signal' when I reach modern age tech trees
- smegsicle 4y agohttps://www.news24.com/news24/xArchive/Archive/Porn-the-new-weapon-of-choice-20020330 https://www.news24.com/news24/xArchive/Archive/Porn-the-new-... psychological warfare
- trowawee 4y ago> Is the Tucker Carlson story [...] true? No
- powerhour 4y agoI dunno, I believe his ranting about M&Ms came from a real place. He sure seemed upset that their recent redesign left him less sexually satisfied.
- trowawee 4y agoVery good point. His stories about his personal sexual kinks, lightly disguised as news, are probably accurate. Disturbing, but accurate.
- falcolas 4y agoI get bird and cat videos; plus some Kronk and Dr. Doofenschmirtz. It gives you more of what you watch and upvote. So the contents of your For You page are on you, after the first 5 or so videos.
- winternett 4y agoYou get bird videos a lot too?! Lol... I used to have a parrot and IG and TikTok think that's all I want to see now every day... It's really not smart... People aren't all one dimensional. Their use cases/journeys need a lot of work. Also, TikTok is not accounting for views properly (Mr Beast reported it on TikTok among many others), they redirect users away from certain accounts when links are shared on web sites, and they even stop certain videos from playing and shadow ban US users if their content talks negatively about the platform... Just like the country it comes from might do.
- nemothekid 4y agoCertain types of content is banned on Douyin but the idea that tiktok promotes "edu and wholesome content within China" is a myth spread by Andrew Tate a couple months ago. TikTok promotes the content that you respond to, no different than the recommendation algos we've gotten from our homegrown social media companies. Their biggest differentiator is that the signals they use are way better. If you see alot of gender transitioning content, then it says more about the content you watch. That said, if you think critically, if Chinese users as a whole preferred educational and wholesome content on tiktok, that says more about Chinese society and what they value not that there is some boogeyman who holds a big level on whether to show you cats or twerking.
- gruez 4y ago>>the tiktok algo promoting edu and wholesome content within China, but twerking and gender transition in the west true? >Certain types of content is banned on Douyin but the idea that tiktok promotes "edu and wholesome content within China" is a myth spread These two comments aren't really contradictory. Tiktok might technically not be "promoting edu and wholesome content" in china, but they might have banned the content that the parent poster thinks is repugnant (ie. "twerking and gender transition"). Indeed, depending on how much stuff is banned and what you consider as "wholesome", it's very possible that the chinese censors banned everything that you don't consider wholesome.
- nemothekid 4y ago>These two comments aren't really contradictory. No, I think the phrasing of the statement is misleading. It implies that TikTok (or some Chinese boogeyman) is the one making the decision to "poison" American Tiktok viewers. That isn't the case; the two cultures are different - China may ban choose to ban twerking videos on social media platforms but the US could not do something like that without infringing on free speech. The people want twerking videos (TikTok did not invent "sex sells"), whether or not tiktok gives it to you is a function of the countries government, not some Chinese mastermind. That said, I don't think the statement is globally true. I opened TikTok just now on "unpaired words"[1], I've never seen a video on transitioning and I get plenty of educationally curious content. This content does exist on US TikTok and is being promoted; you just have to be interested in watching it. [1] https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTRA7HJSv/?k=1 https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZTRA7HJSv/?k=1
- atoav 4y agoYou mean the story by the guy that (successfully!) used this legal defense in court: > The "'general tenor' of the show should then inform a viewer that [Carlson] is not 'stating actual facts' about the topics he discusses and is instead engaging in 'exaggeration' and 'non-literal commentary.' and > Fox persuasively argues, that given Mr. Carlson's reputation, any reasonable viewer 'arrive[s] with an appropriate amount of skepticism' about the statement he makes." So if even the guys lawyers tell you any reasonable person would take him with a grain of salt, I would assume that everything he says is indeed exaggerated and non-literal as they phrase it. Or phrased differently: he will say what he thinks his audience wants to hear. What he says might be completely made up, have some important bits omitted or contain a kernel of truth with a truckload of fantasy. From a European perspective this guy seems so over the top that I thought it was meant to be parody when I first saw a clip from him. source: https://www.npr.org/2020/09/29/917747123/you-literally-cant-believe-the-facts-tucker-carlson-tells-you-so-say-fox-s-lawye https://www.npr.org/2020/09/29/917747123/you-literally-cant-...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- exolymph 4y agoIf we rephrase the question as "Does CCP suppress or ban LGBTQ content?" then I can easily see the answer being yes.
- falcolas 4y agoBummer. I loved the mute feature and had hopes TikTok would pick it up. But the reverse? Serious bummer.
- grishka 4y agoI hated their previous implementation too. This whole "you've unmuted one thing once which means you've unmuted everything for the rest of your session" assumption is just plain stupid. All too often I unmute something, watch it, keep scrolling for a minute or two, and then another video comes up and startles me. That's not okay. But I guess their shitty metrics don't show that? And then, let's be honest, video autoplay in any shape or form in the first place is also a clear dark pattern hoping to grab your attention. Some Instagram builds have a server-side setting to disable video autoplay, which I use (by enabling the debug menu where you get to override all those things manually). Some builds do not. Yes, I got annoyed by Instagram UX so much that I had to decompile it, patch the nastiest parts out, and put it back together.
- longemen3000 4y agofor instagram, i just gave up looking at the feed and just look at the posts that a group chat sends
- lrvick 4y agoAt that point maybe try moving the group chat to a service not actively mining every word you type to feed adtech engines.
- deanCommie 4y agoInstagram didn't out-innovate Snapchat, but they did destroy them. Turns out "Photo stories" wasn't a moat - it was a feature trivial to copy and deliver at a higher quality. And while Snapchat's AR filters were (and still are) state-of-the-art, those are only short-term distractions and don't have long-term stickiness. They'll have a much harder time with TikTok. Tiktok's secret juice isn't the Slightly-Longer-Vines. It's the recommendation algorithm. It's INCREDIBLY addictive. It's also (today) wildly incompatible with Instagram's bread and butter, which is celebrity influencers peddling masked branded content. Tiktok's very brilliance is that it's egalitarian - every video gets 100 views. And if you're a heavy user (say 1 hour a day) you will almost every day discover some amazing new creator or video BEFORE they go viral. (or as viral as they might in this app where you get 15 seconds of fame not 15 minutes) I predict that Instagram will fail to beat Tiktok here, but TikTok will be trying hard to be one of the big boys, and ruin what makes it amazing by attracting and embracing celebrities and brands (already starting to happen). If Instagram can hold on to their celebrities long enough (and i think they will), they'll win out in the end when people get bored of TikTok after they self-sabotage their recommendation algorithm.
- rvz 4y agoEvery social media product eventually gets out of fashion for the current generation and gets taken over and Meta knew that decades ago for Facebook. They have another 10+ years of relevance due to Instagram. > They'll have a much harder time with TikTok. Tiktok's secret juice isn't the Slightly-Longer-Vines. It's the recommendation algorithm. It's INCREDIBLY addictive. As long as the corporations, large advertisers, existing influencers and celebrities and mainstream media, keep paying big money to TikTok to game the algorithm and flood their content, ads on there to reach more users, the ruining of TikTok will happen, just like it did with Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, Reddit, etc and the users will always be in last vs the ones who can pay big money. I predict that TikTok will screw its users over (which it is already doing) due to investor, advertiser pressure to keep it up and this would definitely happen after they IPO to give them a return. The longer they postpone the IPO, it will get worse it for them and especially the users. It doesn't matter if it is Instagram. If they can't do it will be from someone else. It is the same old power law happening again. The early users who got addicted to it will complain that TikTok is ruining the platform and will no longer feel addicted anymore and leave to find the next addictive hit. The late users will follow suit leaving it to the bots to pick up the pieces. Rinse and repeat for 'current trend'.
- jondwillis 4y agoTikTok and Facebook’s antics (existence?) have me seriously considering quitting tech. I feel like no matter what I do, I am feeding one of these societal cancers by implementing tracking for whoever is paying me currently, lifting dark patterns, etc, using the API of Google… I tried to avoid doing these things for awhile but nobody pays me to be ethical. My only marketable skill is software development and I pretty much hate what it has become. 16 years down the drain.
- vorpalhex 4y agoGood, user respectful software exists in many forms. IRC is still around, gemini is pleasant, I like Matrix too. I don't think you'll get the huge audience of these other platforms. That may be a feature.
- astrange 4y agoIs IRC respecting you when it has no encryption, no authentication, and frequently netsplits?
- OmarAssadi 4y agoNot to totally dismiss any concerns, but most IRC servers support TLS. While not end-to-end in the sense that the server can read all of the messages, encryption is available. And in the case of IRC, with the most common use case being channels for particular communities which often need moderation, I don’t think the fact that the server can read the chat is a big issue. I wouldn’t advocate for it as a way to privately and individually communicate with people one-on-one, but I think it’s pretty okay for what it is. The nice thing with IRC, though, is that by not being one massive centralized entity where all channels in existence reside, you’re not depending on one particular network in the same way you might be dependent on services like Discord. You can run your own server for your own community where you can set your own rules and manage everything the way you want to. IRCv3 also has SASL [1]. And more rudimentary forms of authentication have been around for ages on most servers. [1]: https://ircv3.net/specs/extensions/sasl-3.1 https://ircv3.net/specs/extensions/sasl-3.1
- vimy 4y agoNothing in this article about how pictures work. Are they gone? Can I still see my friends pictures? I still have the old UI.
- RyanShook 4y agoYou can still see your friend’s pictures but the feed is a mix of suggested content and people you follow with a heavily tilt towards reels. Instagram has essentially done a copy paste of TikTok’s business model.
- ChrisArchitect 4y agoThis author is describing stuff they are only affected by -- niche whining. "I don't know about you but I'm on vibrate all the time" etc. The pause/unpause vs sound muting has been forever on videos/reels. I'd say this is in line with general OS changes that leave all volume controls to the OS and people are just getting more used to going there to control that (i.e. in Android 13 etc). It's hardly a dark pattern, especially if you're not constantly performing tasks with different audio levels. Many will have already set their audio levels and are ready to go. And then with the Reels 'flipping' mode of browsing. Also been a core facet of the Reels-specific UI area for a long time now. It may not be the most fun for you but it's not new and many who hang out in that area will be comfortable with it. Yes, Instagram's copying of annoying things from TikTok and general decline on quality of content experience etc is a common gripe, but that's it, it's a common gripe and part of an ongoing evolution that ppl have been commenting on for ages. Not new. There's a lot of manual finessing that can be done to help the balance of ads and curation you get in your IG experience and it just takes work, all is not lost to the algorithm. People seem lazy and at odds with IG's business goals but that doesn't mean the whole thing has gone out the window.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- winternett 4y agoIG has announced they're switching focus all to reels... Literally throwing the old focus out the window... Photographers are pissed.
- solarkraft 4y agoI'm a photographer and was always pissed. You couldn't upload stuff from a desktop for the longest time, except for with a stupid UA string tweak. It's not like Instagram suddenly sucks.
- prawn 4y agoInstagram was trending down but has taken a dive in recent months. Just an unbearable proportion of ads and lame suggested content. You end up playing whack-a-mole trying to get it to stop showing you rubbish. It had been a not-insignificant part of my work but now I just resent using it at all.
- dmix 4y agoProbably because what makes TikTok attractive isn't it's dark features that only Instagram would think was important, but how amazing it is at learning your interests with the lowest amount of required input (just swiping down quickly or not after a new video starts). I was one of those people that thought TikTok was a modern garbage machine that only produced low quality dancing videos of young girls for zoomers. But then I read on HN that you just need to commit for a little while and it will learn what you like. I was amazed at how much this is true. I'm now getting Scott Manley-esque space news, tech stuff, hyper local restaurant recommendations, real gameplay of game genres I actually like, etc. Basically what took me years to carefully subscribe to on Youtube was done in a few months on TikTok and it only seems to get more relevant (note: YT always still wins in pure intellectual signal vs noise). The whole addictive thing is obviously an issue, especially for kids, but I'm an adult who grew up with tech and I've learned how to carefully balance internet/life, so it's mostly pure upside for me.
- prawn 4y agoBut I don't want any content recommendations. I don't like the idea of infinite channels and endless content to flood my skull. I use Instagram to keep up with what friends and family are doing. I just want to see the content my friends put up. Not the things they like, not similar accounts, not similar industries, not hot topics. And when I've caught up, I want to see the previous content, not unrelated accounts and promotions. I work in travel content and on my work account I want to see the content of my clients and prospective clients I've chosen to follow (to see the work they're selecting or which videographers they're using), but instead it pushes everything else on me. More than ever, these apps are about consuming content - ever increasing amounts of it. I seriously resent that.
- tomc1985 4y ago
- JohnHaugeland 4y agoPlease consider not using phrases like "Indian giving" That's significantly racist.
- tomc1985 4y agoThat would be the first time I've ever heard anyone say that about that phrase. Please consider not correcting everyone with your wokeness; it is equally if not more intolerant than the people you lord it over. Is the phrase "giving someone a dutch oven" rascist? What about jerry-rigging? What about a Mexican standoff? If you guys are going to indiscriminantly purge "rascist" language, then be thorough about it. And don't weep when there's nothing left but some of the most bland, boring-ass speech available. Come on.
- JohnHaugeland 4y agoDo you even know what "Indian Giving" means? It's a slur that all Native Americans are thieves, who will go back on gifts and agreements, because (as the slur goes, incorrectly) they are too stupid and backwards to understand the concept of property. If that's the first time anyone's ever told you that's racist, it's probably because you're the kind of person who responds to being told by calling someone "woke," then compares it to a fart joke, and tries to talk down to other people from what you imagine is a position of moral superiority, and nobody spends the time on you anymore. It's a criticism, made on the basis of ethnicity. Of course that's racism. How have you gotten to a point in your life where you can't see that?
- beej71 4y agoI had just installed the web app version of Instagram with UBO enabled in Firefox. It was a radically changed experience, for the better. I had stopped using the native app some time before. But it sounds like this is the end of that. So... Bye!
- dreamcompiler 4y agoI did the same with Facebook, which I still use because my extended family uses it. It took some trickery to remove FB from a Samsung phone but it can be done. The web version of FB works fine and it is less able to dig out personal info from my phone. (Which is why FB and everybody else prefers that you use their app, but to hell with that.)
- LeonTheremin 4y agoTo evade the dark pattern use a proxy like ProxiTok/Bibliogram and read them from your feed reader, customized as you prefer.
- pndy 4y agoHaven't seen Bibliogram working at all in last 3 or 4 months. Every instance gives me blocked message - guess Instagram is actively fighting against these "proxies". There's this federated photo sharing service pixelfed [1](of course runs on ActivityPub) but it doesn't seem to be gaining any traction, comparable to mastodon. Perhaps because it doesn't come with a mobile application. [1] - https://github.com/pixelfed/pixelfed https://github.com/pixelfed/pixelfed
- monista 4y agoWeird that Bibliogram doesn't work for you, for me, the main instance never worked, but most of other instances do work (both directly and via PrivacyRedirect addon).
- rumori 4y agoThe top dark pattern Instagram employs is sending you internal notifications that you cannot turn off no matter of your notification settings. If you have multiple accounts it’s guaranteed you will have a little red dot sitting there making you switch to one of the accounts to clear it. I absolutely hate this and it’s going straight against their imaginary goal of being a responsible company that supports mental well being, screen time and other ways of getting a mental break when you might need it.
- alisonatwork 4y agoThis is one of the most trash patterns in software development, because it trains you to ignore in-app notifications altogether, so you end up having a feature that theoretically could've been useful made utterly useless by the fact the real signal is spammed out by a million tedious marketing things. I don't know if these patterns were pioneered by Chinese software companies, but from at least 5 years ago they were already doing this in pretty much every mobile app. Infuriatingly, my online banking app did it too, so you couldn't even just log on to check your account balance without having a half dozen pop-ups and flashing icons and weird mini-apps trying to get you to click on something almost, but not quite entirely unlike a banking product. Nowadays I even see it on ordinary western e-commerce websites like Booking.com, or (most recently, post-redesign) the account management page of my mobile provider. I have no idea what the product managers responsible for this are thinking, because it just makes using the app an exercise in disappointment. If I click on a notification I want to get something that genuinely is important to me, not some kind of alert from a half-assed feature I never wanted in the first place.
- aendruk 4y agoI tried Instagram in 2020 but shortly deleted it for precisely this abuse.
- holler 4y agoBesides the complaints of the author, I noticed recently that: - They stopped displaying the name of the account under the stories circles at the top, so you don't know who's story you're clicking on unless you memorized their profile photo. Since I only want to click on stories of people I know closely, I now choose not to watch any stories at all. - They moved the activity (heart) from the main bottom icon navigation and up to the top right next to the dm icon, signifying they're giving it less relevance than it's new replacement, the shopping icon! - They're pushing shopping in seemingly half the posts showing up in the newsfeed now. The combination of shopping and forced watching of video reels has me ready to cancel my account entirely. I don't use instagram to watch videos or shop, but even if I did decide to do one of those, which I never would, I don't want it forced on me.
- lopis 4y agoTwitter has also been doing this since a few months ago. And there's no way to disable it, no matter how often I tell it to "see this less often". Sometimes half the posts I see on the feed are recommended posts from people I don't follow nor care about. Not to mention the "notifications" bell has been useless for years now because all my notifications are suggested posts from people I follow. It's a total perversion of UX to try to hijack our habits for the sake of engagement. For people with attention deficit that just visit these websites sporadically with specific goals, this trend is really disgusting.
- nicbou 4y ago> For people with attention deficit that just visit these websites sporadically with specific goals An ad blocker can block a lot more than just ads. Mine removes anything that isn't goal-oriented, including most recommendation elements.
- pndy 4y ago> no matter how often I tell it to "see this less often" It's in the wording, innit? It's "don't show me again" but "less often" which implies you'll be nagged again with irrelevant content up until you gave up because the queue never ends as algorithm never sleeps.
- IlPeach 4y agoStarted using a third party client exactly for that reason (twidere)
- gammarator 4y agoAt least currently, switching to “latest posts” sorting still removes most of the cruft.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pragmatick 4y agoThe author complains about dark patterns but has a hugely annoying autoplaying, non-pausable gif in the middle of the article.
- digital_x_ray 4y agoI have moved to a pattern of “install instagram, login in, add a post, and then uninstall” i.e I’m only interested in adding content to it, for the purpose of broadcasting it to my friends. I can’t fight the algorithm, no matter how much I know about it, I know that I would be sucked right in.
- mindracer 4y agoSimilar for me, they recently? added the ability to upload from the desktop web browser so I only upload using this method now
- mateo1 4y agoCoincidentally today I removed Facebook's app from my phone (actually just disabled it since I'm not really allowed to remove it...) because I logged in to check out marketplace and somehow ended up losing a couple hours of my life to the infinite video feed (comprised mostly by Instagram videos). The good thing about this scourge getting out of hand is that we might see regulatory action in the future.
- dreamcompiler 4y agoYou can actually delete the Facebook app from your phone with adb (Android Debug Bridge). Here's an example: https://www.reddit.com/r/samsung/comments/ay39vh/first_things_first_uninstall_facebook_on_your_new/ https://www.reddit.com/r/samsung/comments/ay39vh/first_thing...
- Kukumber 4y agoInstagram is a nest for influencers trying to scam their communities with random products and drops, a cancer, conditioning new generations to consumerism and beauty filters, it should be banned It's the complete opposite on tiktok, you see almost exclusively entertainers and creative people So it's no wonder they are trying to copy this, but copying the UI won't be enough if you keep the same userbase The only one close enough to TikTok is youtube, but their Shorts UI/UX is one of the worst i ever seen
- rvz 4y agoThere is nothing that TikTok is doing differently than Instagram that is a net positive for society. Replacing one digital crack cocaine product with other digital crack cocaine product but with stronger ingredients and someone else copying the worse parts of it is a race to the bottom. There is no difference with these platforms other than one of them (TikTok) having an addictive Orwellian algorithm that dictates what is seen and unseen and can amplify a dangerous reality distortion field to create a deception of reality such that its users cannot tell what is real or not, even as serious as a war [0] all thanks to the algorithm. So when you have something that is even worse than Facebook, Instagram, etc that is hardly 'The best thing to have happened to the Internet.' [1] [0] https://www.nrk.no/osloogviken/xl/tiktok-doesn_t-show-the-war-in-ukraine-to-russian-users-1.15921522 https://www.nrk.no/osloogviken/xl/tiktok-doesn_t-show-the-wa... [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28135484 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28135484
- Traubenfuchs 4y agoOne more dark pattern: The explore screen, or however it‘s called, now always shows at least 3 videos. At least one of them completely. Half a year ago they would show only two. In any case, now there will always be 3 things moving on this screen and that‘s why I can‘t use it anymore.
- JohnHaugeland 4y agoPutting items on screen instead of scroll is not a dark pattern, it's just UI that does not think like the 2010 web