8 ms·
After weight-loss surgery, a year of joys and disappointments (2016)
- boloust 4y agoSemaglutide is a new drug that results in ~20% weight loss. Previously, only surgery could accomplish that kind of reduction in a single intervention. It's going to be an absolute revolution in the fight against obesity.
- PeterStuer 4y agoA person in my direct environment has been on that (Ozempic) for 2 years. While at first the results were very decent, longer term (> 9 months) things seemed to reverse. Now, about 2 years in, weight-wise things seem back to the original starting position. Unfortunately, there literally does not seem to be a free lunch.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bpodgursky 4y agoUnfortunately I'm confident that the FDA will make it hard enough to prescribe (need to get it through a GP, only after you've tried diet and exercise, only for a limited duration) that it's only ever used by a tiny fraction of the target population.
- mysore 4y agothats fucked up. they should just prescribe it to anyone.
- whatshisface 4y agoMedication doesn't work like potions in a role playing game, there are usually side effects.
- throwaway0a5e 4y agoEnough weed turns you into some version of a deadbeat. Alcohol has a hangover and a lot is bad for your liver. Most nicotine delivery mechanisms are expensive and really bad for you. Caffeine creates a dependency. If people are ok with the tradeoffs they should be able to go for it. It's not like this is back alley drug dealing. If people are getting these drugs from their GP or over the counter then they can be informed.
- PeterStuer 4y ago"It's not like this is back alley drug dealing." Honestly, I feel the more you delve into the pharma business, the less it seems to differ from back alley drug dealing, apart from the marketing & lobbying budgets.
- whatshisface 4y agoThe three-party (patient, doctor, drug company) drug selling relationship is fraught with a lot of conflicts of interest that two-party relationships (buyer and seller) are not, unless you have a really good doctor. Too bad there is no way to find them!
- Handytinge 4y agoThere's heaps of ways. For a starter, don't live in a country where doctors can get kickbacks.
- P_I_Staker 4y agoNo, the way it works is they don't prescribe to people that need it. Meanwhile, the weekend party people can get whatever they want. Easy not to look like you're drug seeking when you don't actually need the meds.
- nradov 4y agoDo you have actual evidence that doctors are refusing to prescribe? Usually they're only concerned with drug seeking in the case of controlled substances.
- rswail 4y agoSpeaking as a T2 diabetic that relies on Semaglutide, I'm really pissed that doctors are prescribing it "off label" for weight loss to the point that it is becoming difficult to get for its primary use.
- paulpauper 4y agoweight regain is a huge problem https://www.mayoclinic.org/medical-professionals/endocrinology/news/weight-regain-after-bariatric-surgery/mac-20431467#:~:text=In%20a%20recent%20prospective%2C%20long,weight%20loss%20after%2012%20years https://www.mayoclinic.org/medical-professionals/endocrinolo.... Apparently despite such drastic efforts, the weight finds its way back
- mbrodersen 4y agoWeight-loss surgery is not only dangerous but also (in a lot of cases) ineffective. Before thinking about taking such a dramatic step, I recommend trying a low carb diet. Reduce carbs as much as possible and increase protein/fat an equivalent amount so that your overall calories stay the same. The science behind it: Search for “low carb down under” on YouTube.
- SV_BubbleTime 4y agohttps://archive.ph/W4pxI https://archive.ph/W4pxI Should be updated to reflect (2016)
- oneepic 4y agoI didn't have surgery to lose weight, but I lost >110 lb via diet/some exercise and I feel similar to the people in TFA -- things haven't changed as much as I expected. For me, a big reason is that my overall body shape is the same. I'm overweight, not obese, going by BMI (though pretty close to the borderline). but I still look fat in all the old places I used to look fat. I've gone down a couple clothing sizes, but it's very hard to see the change in a mirror unless other people tell me.
- jackling 4y agoI went through the same thing, lost a bunch of weight, people around me noticed, but I still had my belly and love handles. Ended up gaining the weight back, maybe if I kept up with the healthy diet I would've eventually gotten the physique I wanted.
- P_I_Staker 4y agoI can't say I relate completely, but I do to some extent. 60-100lbs makes an enormous difference for me, even as a tall dude. That said, even bottoming out at 6'2" 155lbs, there were still noticeable pockets of fat in the "bad areas" (chest, belly). This was probably due to low muscle mass, but it can be pretty crushing. All that work and you don't look any better without a shirt on... but cloths fit better and I definitely looked better. That weight makes around a 5-20 year difference in appearance for me. You could argue this should be a part of the fitness conversation. You probably won't achieve perfection and people with long term weight issues may never really get the desired results. This is definitely an area where body positivity is important.
- PeterStuer 4y agoYep, not looking fat is a non-linear function. The good news: you are/have been on the slowest part of the curve. WRT looks&perceptions, things are going to accelerate along the journey.
- andrewstuart 4y ago>> diet/some exercise Can you be specific?
- clumsysmurf 4y ago(Much) more recently, Tirzepatide could be useful in treating obsesity: https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2206038 https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2206038 and for a more gentle read https://medicalxpress.com/news/2022-06-diabetes-drug-patients-never-before-seen-amounts.html https://medicalxpress.com/news/2022-06-diabetes-drug-patient...
- ggm 4y agoI think this is an under-rated side of the entire process. Things like "jenny craig" waitloss work because of the huge psychological investment and support, the managed dieting is in some ways, the side issue that goes with a collossal amount of CBT. Bariatric surgery is fantastic, but I know people who learned how to eat "around" it and the net effect was to undermine the "win" -If the same $ went into the psychology of food, into support, into dietary interventions AND exercise AND mental health, as went into the surgery, I wonder if that would have been true? And then in the end, you have self-ideation, how you look at yourself in the mirror. Maybe others see change you can't see or maybe you see change you do not see in the reaction(s) from others. Its hard.
- Rebelgecko 4y agoWhat does CBT mean in this context?
- ggm 4y agoCognitive Behaviour Therapy: a virtuous circle of ideation, action and mood which is reinforcing.
- miketery 4y ago> Dr. Kaplan reports that surgery immediately alters the activity of more than 5,000 of the 22,000 genes in the human body. What does this mean? How is activity of genes altered? > But surgery only alters the intestinal tract. That tells you, Dr. Kaplan says, that there are whole classes of signals coming from the gut and going to the brain and that they interact to control hunger, satiety, how quickly calories are burned and how much fat is on the body. This makes sense - you're disrupting signaling. But what does altering genes mean?
- rycomb 4y agoI'd imagine that it's referring to their endocrine system changes leading to changes in gene expression (of that many genes).
- mrmincent 4y agoI’ve always struggled with my weight, every 5 or so years I’ll get really motivated and lose 20-30kg, and then slowly gain it back over the next 5 years to hit the same point I’m at right now, about 120kg and a BMI of 40. Reading the article I’m glad I’ve never been tempted by surgery, but at the same time, gosh it’d be nice to have my brain rewired with the stroke of a scalpel. But surgical intervention just feels like it’s too much, especially when I know that calorie counting and putting in some effort to get active achieves the results I’m after.
- ASalazarMX 4y ago20-30 Kg is amazing! Even more if you managed to motivate yourself every 2-3 years instead of 5. It'll probably become progressively harder to lose that amount as you age, though.
- themgt 4y agoI realize this is more of a pop culture, human-framed narrative driven story but words like "insulin", "leptin", "mitochondria", "carb(ohydrate)", "glycemic", "glycogen", "ketones" don't appear a single time in the 5000+ word piece. My take as someone who has some personal anecdata is a) no one really quite knows what is causing the incredible and nationally, geographically, socioeconomic/culturally, etc divergent crisis in weight gain and obesity, however b) there is a lot of interesting and useful information at the intersection of biomechanical, endocrinological, psychological, cultural, etc research and attempt at explanations. What's worked for me is a moderate all-of-the-above approach: eat real unprocessed food, do some lazy IF/low-carb, focus on nutrient and protein-dense plant and animal foods, find enjoyable exercise outdoors in the sun, lift some weights, eat fermented and fiber-rich foods, etc. Basically there's a slippery slope and positive feedback loop, where if you're sedentary and eat processed junk you're going to gain weight and wind up feeling like remaining sedentary and eating processed junk, which will cause you to gain more weight, and so on. "her urge to eat, as powerful as the urge to breathe when holding your breath, defeated her" just seems like learned (taught?) helplessness "misinformation" - you need to breathe every one or few dozen seconds or you die. You certainly don't need to eat every one or few dozen seconds or you die. This isn't to understate the difficulty and I was never hundreds of pounds overweight, but fundamentally you need to commit to turning the dial in the other direction at a pace that feels sustainable, and then sustain it. Nutrition science provides good explanations for why the urge to eat low nutrient crap is going to be very powerful if you're 200lbs overweight, not totally unlike the urge to inject heroin is going be very powerful if you've been injecting heroin for a decade. Your body down to the cellular level has adapted to it and you can't just hit an off switch. At a personal level I'd urge everyone to disregard the learned helplessness narrative and try to make a healthy lifestyle work - at a societal/policy level I think we desperately need to stop greasing the path down the slippery slope. It's as if a syringe full of heroin ready to inject was on sale BOGO for $2 at the supermarket and completely socially accepted while you had to cook up aspirin yourself on the stove for $8/pill with 30 minutes effort. "Why are so many addicted to heroin? Experts have no idea." Please.
- throwaway0a5e 4y ago>I'd urge everyone to disregard the learned helplessness narrative and try to make a healthy lifestyle work That requires a hell of a lot of time and effort investment. Time and effort are a finite resource. It's probably better for society as a whole if we find a way to be healthy that doesn't involve all of us to actively work at it every day. That's like expecting people to grind their own coffee and hand wash their clothes. Sure it's theoretically possible but in aggregate less coffee will be drunk and less clothes will be washed.
- sshine 4y ago> it's very hard to see the change in a mirror unless other people tell me I bet that others can see the difference if they've tracked you. I get told that I look different when I can't see it. Try and have someone honest close to you point out what those differences are by holding two pictures up.