12 ms·
‘Things are going to break’: Texas power plants are running nonstop
- wumpus 4y agoLooking forward to Texas again blaming renewables for their bad planning. Oh, wait, I'm late saying this.
- Gasp0de 4y agoWhy aren't they investing massively into solar power? It's one of the cheapest energy sources currently available, and since a lot of the energy in Texas goes into cooling when the sun is shining, the load should perfectly match the production time.
- kthejoker2 4y agoFirst world version of the resource curse. We're an oil and gas state, 14th largest producer in the world, 2 million jobs, $10 billion economy, owned by oil and gas lobbyists. Lifelong Texan, will never understand it, but fear of any disruption to that world stops any discussion about green energy in its tracks.
- pfdietz 4y agoIf you look at the ERCOT demand/supply graphs, the recently spikes really do perfectly match solar. They start just before noon and tail off in late afternoon. Build the PV to point a bit to the west or use single axis trackers.
- pfdietz 4y agoIf you look at the current Texas demand/supply curves at the ERCOT dashboard, the current squeeze would be very well addressed by adding more solar capacity (and perhaps a few hours of batteries for the period around and just after sundown.)
- ur-whale 4y agohttps://archive.ph/q6bTP https://archive.ph/q6bTP
- chroem- 4y agoDoes the California power grid still need to perform load shedding during peak usage, or have they added additional capacity?
- nativespecies 4y agoTexan resident here. Experienced more blackouts/brownouts when I lived in CA than I have in TX.
- Kye 4y agoThe California grid can pull from outside if needed. Most of Texas can't. That's the issue.
- lkjdsklf 4y agoThis is true in theory, but in practice it makes little difference. When California has increased demand, so do all the states it's connected to. Hence the rolling blackouts a couple years ago and more are expected for this summer.
- khuey 4y agoMost blackouts in California are not driven by electricity shortages but rather by hot and strong wind events that lead electric utilities to shut off certain transmission lines in rural areas to avoid sparking wildfires. This distinction probably doesn't matter much to those who have their power cut but it is important to actually fixing the root cause. There was a particularly nasty heat wave in the western US in 2020 that did lead to load shedding due to a shortage of electricity. That was the first time California had load shedding since 2011 IIRC, and it did not repeat in 2021.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Hence the rolling blackouts the last few years and more are expected for this summer. California has had two days with rolling blackouts since 2001, August 14-15 of 2020. It has had public safety power shutoffs in some areas since 2019 to prevent fire risk during dry, high-wind conditions, but those are a different issue than rolling blackouts and unrelated to energy generating capacity.
- oneplane 4y agoInside the article a nice contrast can be found: >> “Things are going to break,” she said. “We have an aging fleet that’s being run harder than it’s ever been run.” >> Also See: Texas Confident Stressed Grid Will Hold Up Amid Summer Heat Seems to me that one statement is rooted in experience, science and measurable facts, while the other is nonsense.
- djbusby 4y agoAlso, they are running 100% for longer periods - so they skip some maintenance. That's not good for systems like this. The breakage will likely be bigger and more exciting.
- landemva 4y ago>> That's not good for systems like this. Do you have insider maintenance knowledge or is this a hunch? How many fluid samples have you sent to the lab? Big machines are thermally designed to run at 100%. Oil and lube can be stretched for the proper economic incentive.
- djbusby 4y agoWell the article mentions it. My numerous tours of power plants. And 20 years of stories from my uncle (now retired) who was an engineer on power generation (mostly hydroelectric, a little nuclear). And a bit of my own experiences with mechanical systems.
- landemva 4y agoI read that in the article quoting from the trade association person. My experience is big plants can run at 100% for a long time, if during past downtime the PM was completed and not just penciled-in. At this scale, the PM is recorded and signed. I guess most or all of the plants should do okay. Anyway, too late for worry to be useful!
- 4y ago
- lovich 4y agoWell that’s bleak but entirely expected. I don’t remember the Texas government doing anything in response to the last time their grid almost fell over last year other than crow about their independence
- enraged_camel 4y agoNot sure why you got downvoted. As a Texan, that's exactly what happened. Our state government will learn its lesson only when a series of major incidents start making companies reconsider their plans to expand or relocate to the state. Republicans may love their "independence" but money is also a language they understand very well.
- LambdaComplex 4y agoDid that not happen after the last incident?
- random-human 4y agoExactly, If or once the situation gets to a point that requires scheduled load shedding (eg South Africa) I would suspect a lot of things would change pretty quickly. I can not imagine any 'side' in TX putting up with having no power for 2-3 hours, 2-3 times day - forcing a greater divide between the have's (businesses/homes willing to pay for generators) & the have-nots.
- giraffe_lady 4y ago> I can not imagine any 'side' in TX putting up with having no power for 2-3 hours, 2-3 times day If it's the side that you've disenfranchised then you don't really need to worry about it.
- bradleybuda 4y ago
- rybosome 4y ago
- hourago 4y ago> Crypto mining has also taken off in the past year, bringing with it the industry’s power-intensive operations. Risking the real economy and even human lives for this.
- blibble 4y agocan't they just cut them off? call it "load shedding"
- l1n 4y agoYep: https://www.texastribune.org/2022/07/15/crypto-energy-texas-power-grid/ https://www.texastribune.org/2022/07/15/crypto-energy-texas-...
- leeoniya 4y ago> “The bitcoin miners were able to push over 1,000 [megawatts] back into the grid for ten-hour plus periods multiple times during the week.” that's an entire nuclear power plant worth of energy; how noble of them. no words :'(
- civilized 4y agoGood. Texas doesn't get to complain until Texas stops wasting electricity on virtual beanie babies.
- caymanjim 4y agoThey only shut down because the price is so low that margins are slim. Not like it was a benevolent act.
- abathur 4y agoIn theory, though they're presumably cutting slack out of the system (and presumably making the kind of maintenance mentioned here harder to perform unless they're willing to cut them off to do it?)
- landemva 4y ago
- superb-owl 4y agoI'd be curious to see exactly how much of the energy consumption is due to crypto. I can't imagine it's a huge amount given the cost of energy in TX versus elsewhere in the world.
- abathur 4y agoI was seeing something about them having a 2.5c/kwh deal, I think? Edit: I think I was remembering this: https://twitter.com/DigiEconomist/status/1546844815140216835 https://twitter.com/DigiEconomist/status/1546844815140216835
- supernovae 4y ago1,500 megawatt is what i heard, so about 2% of grid and growing.
- galangalalgol 4y agoWhy is it growing? BTC is past the point that even asics get you to breakeven right? Eth2 went to proof of stake. What are people mining?
- obviouslynotme 4y agoSmart miners mine during the slumps in BTC prices when there is less competition. They get more BTC, even if it is currently worth less USD. They then hold the BTC for the next rally. Most large miners are also cash flush early BTC adopters who do it for hobby and ideology.
- postalrat 4y agoSounds smart until it isn't. ... honestly doesn't sound smart at all. Are they also buying or just overpaying by mining?
- pengaru 4y agoCryptocurrency is not at all something I've gone deep in, but don't "miners" always earn something in return for processing transactions? Otherwise how on earth would you incentivize the network existing in the long-term? Nobody is going to acquire/power/maintain/network/operate these hashing machines if there's no return for their efforts.
- Bud 4y ago
- ceejayoz 4y agoTexas voted 46.5% for Biden in 2020, and the outages likely impact the concentrated blue areas disproportionately. A bunch of those Texans suffering have little meaningful political power at the state level.
- sterlind 4y agoit's interesting that 46% of a state can vote blue, but the majority votes red every time. Texas isn't even close to purple; there's little moderating effect on Republican politics in the state, unlike how Manchin's tugged to the right. I'm sure there's arguments that this powerless 46% Democratic minority is balanced out by a 46% Republican minority in a reliably blue state, but still.. it seems messed up that voting works like this.
- Spooky23 4y agoIt’s called gerrymandering and machine politics. Congressional districts get a lot of attention, but state legislatures take this stuff to a whole other level. Strategically, the democratic focus on a few issues that alienate more traditional democrats strongly amplify that effect.
- chrisco255 4y agoAnd how do you feel about the republicans in California?
- lotsofpulp 4y ago
- JamesBarney 4y agoI'm a Democrat in Texas never had any problems voting.
- jhallenworld 4y agoThis is their plan to get more people to install stand-alone PV systems. Grids (electric, gas, etc.) are communal things, and Texans resist communism.
- usrn 4y agoSolar panels are pretty hard on the environment and (in places with poor regulation) the people manufacturing them but once you've got them set up they're pretty fantastic (provided you don't accidentally smash them like I did my first system.) You have truly independent energy this way. Also there are consumer products like the jackery that make moving power easy for normal people so It's not hard to share with your neighbors when they need some extra too.
- chrisco255 4y agoI'm not a fan of giant solar farms cut into forests, but if someone adds panels to their roof or yard seems like an easy enough way to cut energy demand in the sunbelt in particular.
- wumpus 4y ago> I'm not a fan of giant solar farms cut into forests What % of new solar farms are cut into forests? I can't think of a one, I'm sure there is one, but it's hard to imagine it's a high %.
- pfdietz 4y agoSolar panels are not pretty hard on the environment.
- EricE 4y agoLet's check back in five years and see how well recycling of them is going. We are already having issues dealing with used wind turbine blades.
- kyrra 4y agoWSJ (editorial pages) has a theory of that the expanded use wind power in Texas is part of the cause. When 30 to 40% of power for the state can be produced by wind, you have fewer backup natural gas and coal plants, as maintaining backup capacity is expensive. And then there tends to be much less wind when there is a heat wave, such as last week when wind was only producing 6% of the state's power. To me it seems the state needs to enforce x amount of backup not a renewable capacity. https://www.wsj.com/articles/californiapowerproblems-hit-texas-blackouts-electricity-heat-wave-11657919178 https://www.wsj.com/articles/californiapowerproblems-hit-tex... Edit: they have another editorial today postulating the moved to green energy without sufficient backup is leading to problems across the US and Europe. https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-wests-climate-policy-debacle-global-warming-energy-putin-russia-fossil-fuel-power-summer-heat-11658084481 https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-wests-climate-policy-debacl...
- Gasp0de 4y agoThat's why it's wise to build both solar and wind, as they behave antiproportional most of the time. When there's more sun, there is less wind and vice versa.
- salt-thrower 4y agoEven if that’s true (debatable), it’s important to not use it as ammo to slam renewables as a whole - which republicans are keen to do. We need to wean off of fossil fuels asap, and this sentiment is easily manipulated to hurt that cause.
- JADev62096 4y agoSo even if a technology isn't fulfilling our needs and is leading to problems, we should ignore that because it's the "right" thing to do?
- Edman274 4y agoYour unstated assertion here is that we don't actually need to try to mitigate global warming and that it's merely a moral question, or like some culture war tempest-in-a-teapot. We need to mitigate global warming. That's a need we have to fulfill. It's the "right" thing to do for that very reason. Creating a strawman by saying 'haha, you think we should ignore that because it's the "right" thing to do' suggests that it's the "right thing to do" in the same way that it's the "right" thing to put toilet paper with the free end facing the room rather than facing the wall, rather than a slow-moving catastrophe that will kill billions through crop failures.
- chrisco255 4y agoI've been hearing these predictions all summer but here in TX I have yet to see one blackout or brownout. Days starting to get shorter. So how much of this is puff?
- supernovae 4y agowe haven’t even hit our hottest month and yet and this week alone the grid hit an effective 100% utilization rate and was only saved by asking manufacturers and crypto miners to shutdown. Toyota has to close their plants by 2pm. That’s pretty messed up
- chrisco255 4y agoI don't know why Toyota is singled out unless the power supply in their particular region of Texas is particularly strained. They can't be that significant of a percentage of Texas power demand. Reading this article, it doesn't seem clear that the heat wave was at fault: "The plant had scheduled five days of summer shutdown next week, and added two additional days due to a global semiconductor shortage, Toyota said. The seven days of closures are unrelated to the heat wave, the spokesperson added." "General Motors Co has avoided production cuts at its Arlington, Texas, assembly plant, but has scaled back on air conditioning, the company said on Thursday." "Sources familiar with LyondellBasell plant operations said early Thursday the petrochemical firm reduced power usage at its Houston refinery by switching from electric pumps to steam turbines where possible." https://www.channelnewsasia.com/business/toyota-scales-back-texas-plant-output-heatwave-2810596 https://www.channelnewsasia.com/business/toyota-scales-back-... Also, July is the hottest month: https://www.rssweather.com/climate/Texas/Dallas-Fort%20Worth/ https://www.rssweather.com/climate/Texas/Dallas-Fort%20Worth... and days have been getting shorter since the solstice. We'll see slightly reduced energy demand in August and more so if we get more rain (we've had very little this summer so far, so any change in rain patterns will lower temps).
- supernovae 4y agoaugust is by far the hottest month in texas. and yes, i just chose Toyota because it was easy to identify them since they are huge. you should go by their factory sometime. you can get a tour, it’s pretty awesome.
- xoa 4y agoDoes anyone in Texas know if there have been any changes since the 2021 spring freezes to the system in terms of letting people set their own price caps, preferably with some fine grained options to them? My recollection from then is that one issue is a lot of people had signed up for completely dynamic price plans, where they got the absolute lowest grid price at all times, but that the system didn't let them easily and adjustable do caps. Kind of similar to some of the surprise cloud services bills that appear on HN from time to time for that matter, anything of that kind should have some sort of sanity check to "never ever spend more than $X without my explicit say so". Ideally a market system like that would allow entering something automated along the lines of >I will pay up to $0.10/kWh with no limits, $0.10-$0.25/kWh but only for 6 hours per day, or >$0.25 kWh but only for up to $5 worth per day and it should send alerts to my phone/email/app immediately Then there'd be no surprise hundred/thousand dollar bills, and the grid operator could get demand to smoothly drop off based on how much people valued it just by raising the price. Could even make that revenue neutral by having all excess money gathered from emergency demand adjustment pricing be evenly distributed back to all customers at the end of each billing cycle, which would help offset the loss for those less well off. It'd be more transparent to see the value of things like home energy storage or conservation measures. Or maybe those plans just fell out of favor vs more traditional uniform billing where both the best and the worst case are price capped?
- abathur 4y agoAIUI (as someone who as on one of these plans), the primary provider, Griddy, went into bankruptcy (and was scapegoated for making a plan that had regulatory approval...). A lesser provider, Octopus Energy (which is rooted in the UK) disabled new subscriptions for their market-rate plan and has probably phased out all users by now. They have been running a month-to-month plan, though they were giving customers $100 to leave the month-to-month service (in late May? Early June?). I'm not 100% sure what this is about. They framed it as being about having to charge really high rates as the summer went on, but it could since it too is a pre-deposit plan, they might be fearing a similar circumstance (grid goes into crisis, prices once again get pegged at $8.99/kwh, and they get stuck with the choice of either turning people off and letting them potentially die in the heat, or being stuck with a massive shortfall). FWIW, Griddy tried this as well (shedding customers), but the notice came late on a Friday and it wasn't clear who (if anyone) would be taking customers on a Saturday. That aside, a cap would help, though it's not clear to me that the power infrastructure has controls that are fine-grained enough to actually enforce it? Unless maybe you had your own ~smart-breaker?
- taf2 4y agoSeems like Texas could build a few nuclear plants and solve this issue
- no_wizard 4y agoIf Texas could assert itself it should be with nuclear power plants. In all seriousness they could get it rammed through and it would be good for the state
- bequanna 4y agoAmen! Texas even has large open spaces w/ cheap land where they could locate them with minor NIMBY resistance.
- grepfru_it 4y agoWhere do they put the waste?
- EricE 4y agoIf they are smart they will use newer designs that let them burn everyone else's "waste"
- pfdietz 4y agoYou're probably not aware that reprocessing spent fuel to recover plutonium is not economical until uranium reaches something like $700/kg. The advantage of burning waste is very minor; it's cheaper to just squirrel the stuff away in dry casks.
- rswskg 4y agoIn the ground like everyone else.
- pfdietz 4y agoActually almost everyone is putting waste in dry casks, which is cheaper than burying it and just as safe.
- 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- balderdash 4y agoIt’ll be painful, but I suspect Texas will come out of this in the medium term stronger as the they will actually build new generation driven by economic price signals, and not be hampered by excessive regulation with regards to permitting new assets.
- cthalupa 4y ago> they will actually build new generation driven by economic price signals, and not be hampered by excessive regulation with regards to permitting new assets. The problem with this theory is that it has not been born out in reality: Despite lacking excessive regulation, Texas has a large quantity of plants stuck in permit hell, and we've been stuck in this situation for years. Texas likes to sell itself as being small on regulations, but the truth of the matter is the bureaucracy is as bad as anywhere else.
- spoils19 4y agoProgress has never been made without a little blood, sweat and tears. I can see Texas' model expanding across the entire country as a success, as it has proven to be the most stable, reliable and consistent energy delivery system in the world.
- mrguyorama 4y agoYou cannot be serious. Here in Maine, we have a partially deregulated system, and our wind turbines do not shut down in the Winter.
- skellington 4y agoNuclear is the best possible solution to climate change in the short term, but we definitely will not do it. Instead, we will do all of the worse solutions, take 50 years to transition (if ever), and do a bunch of harm on the way. TX is going to be forced to build more natural gas power plants.
- pfdietz 4y agoHow can that be? Nuclear plants take way too long to build; there's nothing "short term" about it.
- mwint 4y agoThey don’t have to take that long to build.
- pfdietz 4y agoYes, we can imagine the Nuclear Fairy waving her magic wand to give us NPPs. Here in the real world, we operate under constraints that we can't just wish away because that would be convenient for the point we're trying to defend. Among those constraints is the lack of organizational and industrial experience and infrastructure for effectively making new NPPs.
- mwint 4y agoIf it was seen as a high priority, we could do it. They put people on the moon in the 60’s in less time than people claim it’d take to build a power plant today. Ingredients for a quick transition to nuclear: 1. Gov’t must be willing to ignore NIMBY/BANANA people 2. Accept slightly more risk than zero 3. Aggressively poach people from countries with healthy nuclear programs and put them in charge of ours.
- azemetre 4y agoWhat does banana stand for? Searching, obviously, yields nothing fruitful.
- nothatscool 4y agoWe’ve been having some extreme load shedding in South Africa for the past few weeks. It has been an ongoing problem since 2007 or 2008 but has been particularly bad this year. We’re just coming out of a stretch of having the power off 3 times a day (either for 2.5 or occasionally 4.5 hours at a time.) I am relieved that the power is only going off once for two and a half hours tonight now that things have calmed down a bit. It has been stressful.
- thefz 4y agoWith a population of one obese person every three, good luck telling them not to use air conditioning.
- schwartzworld 4y agoAlso dangerous heat levels
- dtagames 4y agoAs a Texan, two tiny realities are missing from this convo. First, much of the failures last winter were caused by stuff freezing, not from overuse. The power system in Texas is not built for snow or ice for the same reason the one in Hawaii is not. Secondly, Texas has the only open power market in the US. Companies compete to lower their prices and have lots of free and discount days for consumers. Is that a perfect system? No, but it does contribute to a lower cost of living which people and businesses seem to like. These are not new setups. This arrangement has existed for decades. Finally, it's distressing to read all the as hominem attacks in this thread. Texas is not full of dumb, overweight crypto miners or insensitive eco terrorists. We have lots of smart people, some of whom like it that things are run differently than other states and that's ok. It's what freedom is all about. BTW, Houston, Texas's largest city, gets its power entirely from wind and solar. That's a good goal for any city.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> BTW, Houston, Texas's largest city, gets its power entirely from wind and solar. That's a good goal for any city. This is a bit misleading. It appears the big-C City's own operations do, not the whole city worth of people and private industry. https://www.houstontx.gov/mayor/press/2020/100-percent-renewable-energy.html https://www.houstontx.gov/mayor/press/2020/100-percent-renew... > As part of the contract renewal, the City will power all municipal operations with renewable energy and realize $65 million in savings over the seven-year contract. Through the NRG Renewable Select plan, the City will receive 1,034,399 MWh of renewable electricity annually from a new, third-party utility-scale solar facility in Texas that is dedicated to City operations.
- dtagames 4y agoWasn't meaning to mislead. You found the exact story I was looking for. Thank you.
- timbit42 4y ago> Houston, Texas's largest city, gets its power entirely from wind and solar. What do they do at night when it's simultaneously dark and not windy?