11 ms·
Unity is acquiring a company who made a malware installer
- ummonk 4y agoArticle buries it deep in the article probably because it makes this merger a lot less concerning but apparently Unity is acquiring IronSource rather than vice versa.
- dang 4y agoOk, we've put that in the title above.
- whiteboardr 4y agoSince I worked for a german automotive brand as an interaction designer for 7 years and left with good reasons - having learned that the three pointed star (my ex-employer) and bmw now are turning to using unity as a foundation for the ui layer - how stable is that choice?
- cobertos 4y agoA company I have a friend at built their mobile app in Unity. It has no 3D or 2D "game" in the traditional sense. It's all just UI screens. But it's all Unity UI. Apparently it has some non-native feel issues, but it works better than you'd expect. They had a bunch of custom UI components for recycling views and stuff too.
- shp0ngle 4y agoWait, unity bought WETA? THAT WETA?
- mprovost 4y agoIt's not an acronym but yes. It's hard to believe that an ad company is worth 3x a multiple Academy Award winning VFX studio.
- shp0ngle 4y agoAh, but they spun off the VFX teams to a separate entity. > The VFX teams at Weta Digital aren’t included in the deal; instead, they will be part of a standalone entity called WetaFX that will still be majority owned by Jackson
- mprovost 4y agoInteresting! PJ and his partner still own 60%. And Sean Parker is a director of the company? https://app.companiesoffice.govt.nz/companies/app/ui/pages/companies/8265368/directors https://app.companiesoffice.govt.nz/companies/app/ui/pages/c...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- afterburner 4y agoNot surprising at all considering VFX studios can so easily go bankrupt.
- TechBro8615 4y agoExtreme nitpick: > InstallCore was also behind a fake installer for a Windows version of Snapchat, a program that's only ever been available on mobile. It would instead install Android emulator BlueStacks, as well as the usual injection of adware. This was true in 2015 when the referenced blog post was written. Nowadays Snapchat is not only available on mobile; there is a web client. Additionally, on Mac OS, there is an officially supported emulation (virtualization?) layer that allows you to run iOS apps (at least in theory; I’ve never tried it). EDIT: this comment is almost entirely wrong, sorry! I’ll leave it up since people have replied to it. I don’t know why I thought there was a web client - maybe I was thinking of snap map. And I thought that you could run any iOS app on Apple M1, but apparently this is not true. (While I was searching this, I believe I also encountered articles promoting the same malware described in the OP!)
- l33t2328 4y agoNitpick to your nitpick: > InstallCore was also behind a fake installer for a Windows version of Snapchat, a program that's only ever been available on mobile. It would instead install Android emulator BlueStacks That actually sounds like a _real_ installer for a Windows version of snapchat. Just because they had to use some technical trick to make it work doesn’t mean diddly(if it actually works).
- josephcsible 4y ago> Nowadays Snapchat is not only available on mobile; there is a web client. This isn't true.
- liuliu 4y agoI would be surprised if the iOS emulator can run production Snapchat app. Their policy has been incredibly consistent on where Snapchat should be used (real device, with cameras). Anything else probably will fail the attestation phase.
- richard_mcp 4y agoThis news about not trusting some software is posted on a news website that hijacks your back button for more ad views.
- phkahler 4y agoI've never understood why browsers let web sites hijack any part of the browser UI. I'm not asking for an explanation, I'm sure there were "reasons" but it's still a bad idea.
- placatedmayhem 4y agoThere was an article here a couple months ago about the browser's "danger zone", i.e. the area that can be controlled by the website, and how it's changed over time. The context was around the encryption padlock to indicate valid certificates. What I took away is that nothing in a browser can be trusted now. Indeed, in my experience, hijacking elements like right click, copy, and back/forward buttons is somewhat commonplace. Some browsers are better at avoiding this, but none I've used are immune to hijacking tricks, especially the back button.
- tomcatfish 4y agoThat article: https://textslashplain.com/2017/01/14/the-line-of-death/ https://textslashplain.com/2017/01/14/the-line-of-death/
- marcosdumay 4y agoWhen you make an application, it's often useful to create a static identifier of the application state and push it on the back button, so that if the user doesn't like where he is going, he can simply go back. I don't agree that it's a bad idea. What is bad is the amount of user-hostile sites that get promoted on the web. Those should be silenced, not boosted into mainstream by search engines an social media. Anyway, browsers can improve the feature by grouping the added links and making it easy for users to ignore them. But innovation on the web got it's last and fatal strike when Firefox killed its original extensions API.
- Aeolun 4y agoI don't understand why Unity would feel the need to merge with anything? Aren't they more or less sharing half of the market with UE4 now?
- charonn0 4y agoThey want to offer monetization features to Unity-based games. > Unity already has Unity Ads, "our monetization solution for mobile games that enables game developers to monetize their entire player base", but obviously there are benefits to combining that with IronSource: "Unity and ironSource's complementary data and product capabilities will give creators access to better funding for user acquisition (UA) and monetization to successfully scale their games and accelerate their economic performance."
- tapoxi 4y agoUnreal gets a 5% royalty on every game. Unity is a subscription model, they don't get more money out of wildly successful games like Hearthstone or Pokemon Go. Their solution to this is adding more over-the-top services like analytics and advertising.
- daenz 4y agoOof. In 2017, Hearthstone was bringing in $40M per MONTH[0]. Imagine Unity getting 5% of that. Huge missed revenue. 0. https://venturebeat.com/2017/08/10/pc-gaming-weekly-watch-out-heartstone-here-comes-artifact/ https://venturebeat.com/2017/08/10/pc-gaming-weekly-watch-ou...
- shadowgovt 4y agoThe thing about game tools is that it's always a balancing act because for all the money that flows through the space, there isn't a lot of money to go around. A game engine company cannot ask for much money at all without the people holding the purse strings turning around and asking "Why don't we just use an open source engine or build our own?" So Unity is stuck with a huge foot-in-the-door problem regarding their game engine business: their direct competition is their customers. To their credit, I have been consistently impressed with their approach to addressing that challenge, but that challenge makes the whole space of game development support tooling hard to persevere in.
- netule 4y agoAbout a decade ago, I briefly worked for a company with the same business model. Since most Windows installers require Administrator privileges, the DLLs that they side-load will inherit these elevated privileges and can scan the user's machine for anything they are interested in. The way this software worked (as far as I can recall): The installer bundled a DLL from which only a few minor functions were exposed to display offers within the host process. Usually, the only thing the client portion of this DLL needed was a HWND. During initialization, the DLL stored a copy of itself in the user's temp directory. The host application unknowingly then used rundll32 to load this copy as a separate (also elevated) process. This process would run at least as long as the calling process would. Once in place, the process would scan the user's computer for specific use patterns (geoinformation; MS Office presence; what language; etc.). In order to retrieve the latest advertising "offers", the DLL called home with this information over a secure pipe and checked for updates. This data was stored and referenced if the same user invoked the DLL again at some point. Only at this point would any actual targeted ads be displayed in the client application's window. Things may have changed since then - these were the pre-Windows 10 days - but if it's anything like this, it's wise to avoid the Unity installer.
- None4U 4y agoDoesn't that violate GDPR?
- netule 4y agoIt probably would these days, but in 2012 there were no such regulations.
- structural 4y agoThese sorts of shenanigans a decade ago certainly influenced the creation of GDPR.
- starburst 4y ago> it's wise to avoid the Unity installer What "Unity installer"? Games nowadays are all distributed on steam / epic / app store / etc. If you are talking about the editor, this makes no sense they would bundled it up with malware (their target is the games made with it). I'm not thrill about the announcement at all but there is a lot of unfounded fear.
- UnpossibleJim 4y agoAll of this makes me ask the question of, "How does a company go public without losing themselves? Is that even possible?" This type of going public and chasing shareholder, share selling, cash infusion (sorry for the word salad, I couldn't think of a better way to put it) - which is often needed for growth past a certain point - how does a company not compromise their vision and bow to the shareholders once they go public, when their directive then becomes "Maximize stock value for the shareholders"? NOTE: I'm an engineer who graduated with an art degree, so this is way out of my wheel house. I've always built things, and have not been privy to the business side of the show. It's a bit foreign to me.
- nitwit005 4y agoIf you don't want other people to have a voice in decisions, don't sell them the right to have a that voice.
- georgeecollins 4y agoAnswer: Ethical leadership, which many public companies have. Sometimes you hear people say that public companies have to value shareholder returns above all else. It's usually opinion columnists or maybe popular economists, but not lawyers. That's because it's not really true. Public corporations have always made choice that favor customers or employees over shareholders and always will. Example: Ben and Jerry's. Public corporations can be as ethical as any other type of business. But any business can be ethical or not. CEOs use the excuse of "shareholders" because it sounds better than "I wanted to maximize my bonus." That isn't all bad-- seriously everyone wants to maximize their bonus, including me! As as an aside, I really doubt Unity is planning on installing malware even if they could through the Steam or Apple stores (which they probably can't). They probably just want to do better ad tracking. Is this ethical? I don't know enough to say. But a mom and pop or private company could do the same thing.
- 202206241203 4y agoIsn't effectively punishing customers unwilling to pay for premium games highly ethical though?
- Geee 4y agoI won't touch Unity or their stock with a ten-foot pole now. If they did this to please investors, then they're wrong.
- sithadmin 4y agoYou're not the sort of investor that public companies are generally interested in pleasing. They're mainly concerned with institutional investors and fund managers, not retail investors.
- plorkyeran 4y agoUnity's stock dropped another 20% in response to the announcement and it prompted yet another shareholder lawsuit, so I wouldn't expect those people to be happy either.
- sithadmin 4y agoOne-day valuation changes like that on an already-somewhat-volatile-and-downtrending stock isn't necessarily an indicator of meaningful long-term impact, and nearly any major action a public company takes triggers shareholder lawsuit trolling.
- HFguy 4y agoI think a lot of institutional investors may question this also. It isn't a great look. Did the stock not fall yesterday while the market was flat?
- mattlondon 4y agoObligatory mention: if you are dissatisfied with Unity please consider the open source engine Godot http://godotengine.org http://godotengine.org No relationship to Godot - just an impressed user.
- joewrong 4y ago+1, their documentation has improved so much in the last couple of years https://docs.godotengine.org/en/stable/index.html https://docs.godotengine.org/en/stable/index.html
- didibus 4y agoAlso recommend having a look at Defold: https://defold.com/ https://defold.com/
- seba_dos1 4y agoNote that unlike Godot, Defold isn't open source.
- didibus 4y ago> Q: Why don't you use the term Open Source when talking about the source code? > A: The definition of the term Open Source is heavily debated. The Open Source Initiative has created a definition of the term Open Source where it must be possible to commercialise the source code. The Defold Foundation has made the decision to prevent commercialisation of the game engine and editor (the Game Engine Product). We want Defold to always be free to use! (You can of course still sell your games and plugins and you can modify the engine as much as you like). Depending where your moral compass lies this is either even better than open source or worse.
- seba_dos1 4y agoThat's a very misleading characterization. No, the definition of the term isn't heavily debated; it just became a trendy term over years with enough positive connotations to make some people want to use it for marketing even when their projects don't actually match the definition. When Defold made its source code public, they used the term "open source" across their marketing material and only stopped doing so after community backlash. Their license URL is still "/opensource/". They got a lot of media coverage from people who were mislead into believing that Defold went open source until this got corrected. You should read what they wrote with this context in your head. I find what you quoted to be borderline manipulative. Also, I don't understand the purpose of non-commercial clauses on such projects. All they do is cause PITA. It makes your project non-free, so it cannot be included in distros that distribute FLOSS only or mixed with code on viral licenses. And nobody is going to buy something they can get for free unless you're adding some real value on your own with your fork. Furthermore, what exactly constitutes of "commercial usage" is often arguable. If you really care about your project staying free, use a viral FLOSS license, with a non-viral exception on the runtime part. Those technically don't prevent commercialization, but still require freedom, so everything stays free to use in practice. Stamping a non-commercial clause on a Apache-like license like Defold did is the worst of all worlds.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoThey're really working hard to make godot better. Appreciate it.
- ffhhj 4y agoThey recently had layoffs and are now merging with a company that has 50% as many employees. More layoffs to be expected?
- mike_hock 4y agoGamedevs not baking in malware installers are "fucking idiots."
- Kipters 4y agoFor everyone else's benefit, here is where it comes from: https://mobilegamer.biz/devs-not-baking-monetisation-into-the-creative-process-are-fucking-idiots-says-unitys-john-riccitiello/ https://mobilegamer.biz/devs-not-baking-monetisation-into-th...
- shmerl 4y agoGodot engine is something to look into.
- astlouis44 4y agoSlightly on topic - has anybody here ever used Unity's WebGL export? Was it viable for your game or real-time 3D app? If not, can you provide reasons why?
- NonNefarious 4y agoEpic installs malware with Unreal Engine 5, so why not? https://i.imgur.com/UCjMy0g.png https://i.imgur.com/UCjMy0g.png
- throwawaycuriou 4y agoIt's fair to compare what competitors baseline is here, at the risk of whataboutism. I find it surprising not a peep about the culpability Windows has in the equation.
- NonNefarious 4y agoKind of. To be fair, I just took the opportunity to call Epic out on a very disappointing betrayal.
- navjack27 4y agoSo uh, notifications are malware now huh?
- NonNefarious 4y agoIf you mistook that blatant, irrelevant ADVERTISEMENT for a "notification," you live life as a victim. And Epic took pains to hide where this shit was coming from. Wake up.
- navjack27 4y agoLol. No. I live life as someone who sees something in the corner of my screen that uses a toast and immediately dismisses it.
- tekknik 4y agoHere you go, and this isn’t the same. https://www.epicgames.com/help/en-US/epic-games-store-c73/launcher-support-c82/how-do-i-turn-off-epic-games-launcher-notifications-a3172 https://www.epicgames.com/help/en-US/epic-games-store-c73/la...
- yomkippur 4y agoI have a confession to make. I installed lots of adware back in the 2000s. It was good money, got paid around $4~6 USD per toolbar installs that I bundled with my free software I made. It really felt like I was printing money. Whenever I needed to pay tuition I would just work for like 8~10 hours and the next month a check arrived that paid all of my costs as a student. Looking back it wasn't the best but neither was being forced to pay a few thousand dollars every semester to buy the same textbook but with an updated cover and table of contents so they can call it the 18th edition. For a corporation that is trading publicly to do this, I have to wonder who is running it and whether they have its best interest. I see many indie developers starting to ditch Unity and opting for Godot or other game engines. This is unlikely to impact Unreal Engine, as it very much is aimed at a different demographic (namely studios with at least 5 FTE)
- tgtweak 4y ago"Acquiring" is a stretch, basically they're bringing ironsource public under their stock. The "valuation" of the deal is also a stretch, but honestly shows how little the market cares about ethics. I'm quite surprised that nobody is talking about anti competition - ironsource's rise and unity ads are, together, a very large mobile advertising network. Two that are often vying for the same customer. App developers that depend on those two competing are now shit out of luck. I'm really surprised this deal snuck through anticompetition oversight and it doesn't seem like it would have if google wasn't at the same table. Anyway, ironsource STILL runs this slippery desktop install network - it's not like this was way back in the past and they've moved on. Hit the download button on any streaming/torrent website or keygen installer and you'll find ironsource.
- snird 4y agoApplovin is bigger than both. I think even bigger than them both combined. And there are many other competitors in this field.
- dang 4y agoUnity merges with IronSource - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32081051 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32081051 - July 2022 (315 comments)