18 ms·
People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate academia, data shows
- ArrayBoundCheck 4y ago
- fallingfrog 4y agoMake education expensive enough, and only rich kids can get one. Not hugely surprising. Education used to be a lot cheaper and you got a lot more first generation graduates.
- zamfi 4y agoAnd prior to that, education used to be a lot more expensive, and was only for the rich. Your claim is not just cause-and-effect, it's historical fact too.
- eek2121 4y agoNot in the US it wasn't? Costs for higher education have tripled in the past couple decades, to say NOTHING of costs in the 80s or 90s. Note that I already knew this, having a free ride thanks to the U.S. Pell Grants, however I DID to a basic google search. Among many other sources, this one is eye opening. Curious as to what your thoughts are: https://politicalcalculations.blogspot.com/2014/04/the-ongoing-inflation-of-higher.html https://politicalcalculations.blogspot.com/2014/04/the-ongoi... In case you think I'm shilling a link (I'm not, first i've seen of this), here is another: https://res.cloudinary.com/value-penguin/image/upload/c_limit,dpr_1.0,f_auto,h_1600,q_auto,w_1600/v1/AverageCostofCollegeHist_azhzrx https://res.cloudinary.com/value-penguin/image/upload/c_limi... and one more: https://feelthebern.org/bernie-sanders-on-education/ https://feelthebern.org/bernie-sanders-on-education/ Even being at the edge of a boomer and a millennial, I particularly love that last link.
- frognumber 4y ago"Prior" was before 1920 or 1945 or so. Costs for higher education placed it well into the realm of the super-elite.
- AlexandrB 4y agoWhenever this comes up, I'm always puzzled about where the extra money is going. Is it just pure profit for the University?
- zamfi 4y agoRarely profit. But it goes towards higher salaries, larger administrations, financial aid, and various amenities that today's college-bound kids' parents demand, like comfortable dorms, gyms, etc. College in the 80s didn't look much like college today. For many schools, the actual cost the average student pays has not changed as much as the sticker price. One reason is that some colleges discovered they could price discriminate: by charging $XXk/yr as the sticker price, they could let in some fraction of students who can afford to pay full fare, and use that money to offer financial aid to the students they want to attract but who can't pay full fare. Another reason is that basically no college competes on being less expensive, because that might imply that they're not "worth it".
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoHigher education was only made affordable after WW2 in the western world, and has been rising ever since then (at least in the USA). Before WW2, it was something mostly rich kids did.
- zamfi 4y agoAs siblings note, the "historically" I'm talking about is pre-WW2. Life in the US from 1950-2000 will one day be seen as a historical blip, not a state of being the US can ever return to. In that period, the US reaped massive profits from its position as sole industrial powerhouse for the first 20-30 years of that period (thanks to the destruction of the rest of the world's industrial capacity in WW2), and then as the world's bank for the following 20-30 years. It was a privileged position that--combined with the rise of the automobile and the opening up of cheap hinterlands for suburban development, without accounting for the externalities of course--enabled all sorts of leverage and quality of life for the working and middle classes, including massive subsidies for higher education. Those days are over. Labor has little leverage these days, there's little exploitable land, and the middle class is more or less gone. We could definitely decide to bring back the massive subsidies for higher ed -- after all, they're present in much of the EU. But it's not clear why one would think that heavily subsidized education would have an appreciably better effect here than it does in the EU.
- rayiner 4y agoExcept this isn’t true. A larger fraction of the population than ever before are getting a college education: https://www.statista.com/statistics/184272/educational-attainment-of-college-diploma-or-higher-by-gender https://www.statista.com/statistics/184272/educational-attai.... More Americans get a college degree than in most other developed countries. What you’re seeing is an entirely different effect, which is that academic hiring focuses intensely on pedigree. Professors are drawn from the ranks of a handful of elite schools: Harvard, Yale, etc. Graduates of those schools are much more likely to be elites. For example, the vast majority of law school professors went to Harvard or Yale.
- seibelj 4y agoAlso a lot of lifetime academics are generally insufferable. Hugely important vision of themselves, lack of knowledge of reality, and are totally useless if they had to do a job outside of their hyper-specialized area. I see a lot of value in hard-science / math research. Don’t see a lot of value in yet another 80 page treatise on Proust that only 8 people will ever read. Hopefully everything gets priced so high that the vast amounts of money wasted on universities will be greatly reduced.
- privatdozent 4y agoHaha. Because math research is so widely read
- seibelj 4y ago
- achenet 4y agoWell some of it is used a LOT - for example all of digital technology is basically applied boolean algebra, and calculus is the base of physics. Granted, the original research for those was 200-400 years ago, but the current day applications are everywhere. So while a new research paper on some obscure subset of point-set topology may not appear to be useful today, it is possible that in the future it will be. :) EDIT: misread your comment as "widely used", not "widely read", my bad.
- askafriend 4y agoAccredited education like universities are more expensive than ever. But actual education and attainment of knowledge is cheaper than ever. Just YouTube alone is a massive driving factor. Or Kahn Academy. But to benefit from things like these, you have to have a culture that values education and actively seeks it out.
- metadat 4y agoIsn't this to be expected with any similarly weighted network? Guess who private sector loves to promote to executive positions like VP and SVP? Harvard and ivy grads. Even in engineering, where it's supposed to be more of a meritocracy, you can see this at every bigco. Human idiosyncrasies lead to branding pedigree consistently being selected over pure skill and / or superior experience in favor of an abstract perception.
- Hydraulix989 4y agoNobody cares where you graduate from school in engineering. It's all about what you can do, and in larger corporations, also how politically savvy you are. Most of middle and upper management (VP / SVP) also has degrees from no-name schools. If anything, they'll have degrees from worker bee / nerd schools like CMU, Caltech, and UC Berkeley, not Ivy degrees (except for Cornell, which is basically a public school). Upwardly mobile engineers are usually immigrants with high IQs who don't have connections and so have to work 60-80 hour weeks to make up for what they normally could have gotten "for free" with a more privileged upbringing. The C-suite is a different story: The Ivy Grads are either joining their parents' companies, going into VC, or starting their own companies (YC), not working as lowly "senior" ICs at say Amazon. Chances are the company you work for was founded by a Harvard or Stanford grad who spent their school years partying and networking in social clubs instead of studying... You might further split Ivy into HYPS and others (Stanford is much more like the other Ivies than Cornell). The others like Brown and Dartmouth are more like a Northwestern / U-Chicago, for people who didn't quite make the cut or for good test takers from upper middle class rather than upper class backgrounds. UPenn and Columbia lean in the middle. Sure, Elon Musk and Donald Trump went to UPenn, but the school itself still mainly graduates "just" worker bees in finance / investment banking. Your coworkers at Google didn't go there, though. There are always outliers at all of these schools, but by definition, they are the exception rather than the rule...
- metadat 4y ago> Chances are the company you work for was founded by a Harvard or Stanford grad... Thankfully not at the moment, but I get your point. My original point stands- looking at the social network connections, nothing these days is a surprise with regard to general composition. Is it the best? No, I think it is elitist and pointlessly or harmfully exclusionary. These are fundamental divisions in society, a glass ceiling that is hard to break through.
- tehsauce 4y agoFor a person that isn’t from a wealthy background already, it’s hard to justify the path of academia when a more lucrative path has much more potential to be life changing for them and their family.
- iratewizard 4y agoSame. The best decision I could have made was skipping 4+ years of adult daycare. When my peers were getting out of college I was already in senior positions and 6 years of experience on my resume.
- ethav0 4y agoMy working class zip code public schooling presented a narrative that academics make low wages. Later I realize the wages of STEM PhDs in industry. I known this does not generalize among discipline but I regret not taking an academic path.
- anon291 4y agoSTEM PhDs in industry are not really in 'academia', as their research is typically not arbitrary.
- ethav0 4y agoCan you elaborate slightly? I don't want to misinterpret you.
- UncleMeat 4y ago"Academics" usually means "university faculty or people working in research labs." These people tend to make low wages compared to typical industry positions. PhDs also don't tend to open too many doors in industry. At the major tech companies, they are roughly equivalent to 3-6 years of industry experience. They might make a resume more attractive, but you end up going through the same hiring process and largely working on the same stuff.
- mk81 4y ago
- AinderS 4y agoInteresting. Although US graduate students are only 53% white [1] (while the US is 57.8% white [2]) and women account for 53% of doctoral degrees [3], all 5 of the people in the generic stock photos in the article are white males, despite making up only an estimated 25% of graduates. A striking deviation from the photographic trend if one e.g. google image searches for "phd graduate". [1] https://www.equityinhighered.org/indicators/enrollment-in-graduate-education/race-and-ethnicity-of-u-s-graduate-students/ https://www.equityinhighered.org/indicators/enrollment-in-gr... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_the_United_States#Race https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_the_United_Sta... [3] https://www.statista.com/chart/15685/doctoral-degrees-awarded-by-broad-field-and-gender-in-the-us/ https://www.statista.com/chart/15685/doctoral-degrees-awarde...
- muglug 4y agoYou could go further and observe that all of the article's pictured students are graduating from Oxford, whereas the article discusses students at US universities. But that's grasping at straws — it really has no bearing on the article itself.
- AinderS 4y agoA search for "uk phd graduate" or "uk university students" likewise yields exceedingly diverse results.
- muglug 4y agoPresumably a bored photo editor, trying to think of "elite" images, typed in "oxford university graduation" into Getty Images and got these results: https://www.gettyimages.com/photos/oxford-university-graduation?family=editorial&assettype=image&phrase=oxford%20university%20graduation https://www.gettyimages.com/photos/oxford-university-graduat...
- pmyteh 4y agoThis is especially true of PhD/DPhil programmes at places like Oxford: their intake is massively international, unlike their undergraduate provision which hews to (a small slice of) England.
- routerl 4y agoThese studies are lagging behind reality by about a quarter century. Academia was obviously starting to become dominated by financial elites as early as 30 years ago. The non-lagging metric is: how many high-performing students, from non-elite backgrounds, are refusing to pursue academic vocations? This number has been decreasing steadily since the late 80's, and this has been very well documented in the Chronicle of Higher Education.
- kwatsonafter 4y ago
- mudrockbestgirl 4y agoFrom my own experience in academia I was surprised by how many of my peers went into academia because they were expected to do so by their parents, who were also academics. It's a smallish sample, but ~90% of the people I talked to never considered other careers paths. Their parents were academics, so it's just natural that they become one too. They already knew this ever since high school. As someone who got into academia "by chance" this was quite a shock to me.
- forum_ghost 4y agonot at all uncommon with other highly specialized professions either. MD's kids are 24x more likely to become MDs as well.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoI wonder if that will maintain going forward. All the doctors I am business partners/friends with advise their kids to go into commercial real estate/tech/law/finance/engineering. They say declining pay and difficulties negotiating with bigger players such as governments and larger and larger healthcare employers in combination with the bad quality of life at work no longer make the costs of becoming a doctor worth it.
- maegul 4y agoNot unheard for me too: it seemed for some that having both parents with PhDs, and a partner too, basically made them feel like they needed one. Plenty going on in such a phenomenon I feel. There’s the relative directionless-ness that can plague smart people coming out of unchallenging high school environments; the often accompanying “prestige for the sake of prestige” logic that you can get in middle-upper class culture, and, IMO, the inflated value and prestige of actually having a PhD in the modern (ie production-line) education system. A healthy dose of cynicism about the corporate world is often involved too I’d say. I personally find it unfortunate how classist and stupid Grad school would feel at times.
- ProjectArcturis 4y agoThat was me, 20 years ago. Going to grad school after college was just automatically assumed, like going to college after high school. And why not? My parents had made a nice life for themselves, going from farms to a secure upper-middle-class existence. Seemed like a relatively low-stress occupation that provided a lot of intellectual variety. Of course, the level of competition changed dramatically between their generation and mine. Then you could go directly from grad school to a tenure-track position and generally expect lifetime employment. Now, in the sciences, you're expected to live a nomadic life as you go from postdoc to postdoc, making less than $50k, perhaps eventually landing that coveted tenure-track. In the humanities it's even worse, where you work adjunct jobs that pay less than minimum wage. It's no surprise that people with family money are most likely to win these contests of endurance. If you need to earn your own money, it's simply irrational to persist in the academic rat race.
- boberoni 4y agoHigher education is the most socially acceptable form of capitalism. You invest in large upfront costs with the hopes that the multipliers of your capital will make it all worth it. Here, capital includes skills, knowledge, relationships, and human networks.
- downboots 4y agoHow to determine if this is attributable to economic inequality and not just overproduction of degrees ?
- legalcorrection 4y agoCriteria for becoming an academic: - Above-average IQ - Intellectual upbringing - PhD, i.e. spending five years of your life in your mid to late 20s getting your union card - During those five years, at least one of: no other mouths to feed, a working spouse, independent wealth, or well-off parents willing to support you - Willingness to get a PhD for a less than <30% chance of ever getting a tenure-track job (though much higher if you are black or hispanic) - Left-wing cosmopolitan social and political views
- frognumber 4y agoI think all of that is accurate except for "PhD, i.e. spending five years of your life in your mid to late 20s getting your union card" A lot of this depends on your advisor, but some programs are a lot more than that.
- georgia_peach 4y ago"Intellectual upbringing" is huge: correctly pronouncing the shibboleths, hearing all of the dog-whistles, yet never whistling the wrong one. Saying the right thing, but in the wrong way, has ended many an academic career. Ex-wife is an English professor. Department-wide "purges" were not unheard of. She was spared, though this was probably because she was a lowly adjunct.
- cm2187 4y ago> In 1970, just 1 in 5 U.S.-born PhD graduates in economics had a parent with a graduate degree. Now? Two-thirds of them do, according to a new analysis from the Peterson Institute for International Economics. The trends are similar for other fields (and for foreign-born students), but economics is off the charts. > This partly reflects population trends: Over that same period, the share of parents with graduate degrees and college-age children rose 10 percentage points, to 14 percent, our analysis of Census Bureau data shows. But compared with the typical American, a typical new economist is about five times more likely to have a parent with a graduate degree. So % of parents with college degree increased by 3.5x (from 4% to 14%) and % of students coming from parents with college degree increased 3.3x (from 1/5 to 2/3). That more than explains it, doesn't it? Also there should be a high correlation between kids being college-material and parents being college-material. Whether you believe in nature (genetics) or nurture (good parenting, high standards, role model, access to education, etc), or a mix of both, either way, you should not expect the % of college students from graduate families to match the % of graduate families in the country. So not sure what point the article makes.
- gnicholas 4y agoI think your analysis mixes up college degrees and graduate degrees. 'College degree' refers to a 4-year BA/BS, whereas 'graduate degree' typically refers to a PhD, Master's degree, or professional degree (JD/MD/MBA).
- robocat 4y agoPostgraduate education in UK etcetera means graduate education in North America - as per https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Postgraduate_education https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Postgraduate_education The quotes from the article seem to be using graduate in the US sense, which is what would be called post-grad in NZ. FYI, AFAIK college degree or professional degree means little in New Zealand, and probably not the UK either. Also see https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Undergraduate_degree https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Undergraduate_degree I'm just saying that to people outside the US, the article is unclear because the words mean different things in different countries, which could affect some commenters. Disclaimer: I only know what we call degrees in NZ so I am just trying to say why people from different countries could be confused. And this comment probably is confused itself, sorry.
- foolinaround 4y agoaround paywall : https://archive.ph/ivXCE https://archive.ph/ivXCE
- frognumber 4y agoElite schools want people from the power class. A lot of this is explicitly baked into admissions. Over 40% of white students at Harvard are side-door admissions (legacy, donors, children of faculty, etc.). This is especially true for minority admissions. For the most part, Harvard won't admit lower-class African Americans; they'll select from a much smaller pool who have already moved into the power networks. That's important for maintaining power networks now that the DEI movement means minorities will likely e.g. serve on corporate boards. There is some amount of meritocratic admissions as well, but you can't look at this as an accident.
- usednet 4y agoAnd all of this contributes to extremely low intellectual diversity at Ivy Leagues. I have the pleasure of frequently interacting with Harvard students and it is consistently true that they are always unremarkable individuals. These schools simply breed a managerial class that is capable of grinding hard and following orders.
- frognumber 4y agoI've been affiliated with MIT in one way or another for more than a quarter-century. What's been astounding is the change in faculty. Historically, MIT faculty were nerds into neat tech problems. New MIT faculty are slick politicians with an increasing sleazy Enron-style vibe. That's true of MIT leadership as well.
- sudosysgen 4y agoDo you know of some place where there are still nerds into neat tech problems?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- slt2021 4y agoLess popular but still hardcore places like Carnegie Mellon, Caltech, some state schools like Ohio State, UMich come to mind. Just stay away from woke ivy league
- Lanz 4y agoIt's almost as if the move away from merit-based acceptance (purely driven by test scores) in the name of equity has led to increased nepotism. Who could have saw that coming?
- jordan_curve 4y agoThis makes sense as graduate school gets more and more competitive. Getting a tenure track position nowadays often requires being among the best students of a top graduate program. Even just getting into a PhD program can be difficult depending on the subject. If your parents have graduate degrees or are professors its likely that graduate school was on your radar much earlier in life. You probably had more time to consider what steps you'd need to take to get there. You're also probably more likely to be interested in graduate school at all, since many people don't even view it as an option for themselves at all.
- oxff 4y ago> People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate academia Even if your system was pure Meritocracy that'd make 16th century Anglos proud, you'd still expect it to eventually come to this (smart people have smart kids, dumb people have dumb kids)
- smeagull 4y agoYou don't just have to be "smart" to pick academia, you have to care about reputation a whole bunch, and you need to be able to not care about money.
- blobbers 4y agoI can't believe this comment hasn't been downvoted into oblivion, but I tend to agree. It's a markov model. Educated people care about educating their children. Uneducated either a) want their kid to be the first to reach higher education (but struggle to do so or b) don't value education. Pretty rare to find a well educated person who places no value on education. Guys like Peter Thiel (educated, but promote non-traditional routes) are outliers on that spectrum, in my experience.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoParents also provide pretty bad advice if they don’t have experience in your path. My parents aren’t really uneducated, but they didn’t go to 4 year schools, and so I was pretty much on my own from high school on in figuring out how to go about getting into university and such. I got lucky, but I always feel like I could have done better with some better advice.
- ethav0 4y agoMillennials who entered college in 2010-2015 -- prior to the deep learning era -- are more subject to placing less value on education. Attention was turned to business, not education.
- TrackerFF 4y agoWhile this is a very inflamed area of discussion, there's a considerable portion of right-wing politicians - even some with degrees from prestigious school - that are becoming more and more hostile against education. It is current day anti-intellectualism. Nothing new, but unfortunately not dead either.
- kepler1 4y agoLet's play it forward where in some alternate reality we were able to reset the current "inequity" and give lots more people from non-elite backgrounds a good shot at proving their capabilities. Or even have that as an ongoing policy in a very fair way. ("Fair" being the problematic word which will constantly be debated.) Do you imagine that a new elite of some new type of class would not emerge? Would that new elite be more acceptable? Is the problem that we just don't like our current kind of elite? That it doesn't provide for "fair" resetting of the system periodically? (or within each generation) Does it unfairly give children of the elite access to things they wouldn't otherwise be qualified for, compared to some other better system? What is that system? Some kind of setup where every kid gets to have equal access to showing his/her value -- yet you don't like having tests to do that? I am not against the idea of an elite class. There will always emerge people who succeed and pass on their success. The question is, what is the outcome we're trying to achieve?
- kmeisthax 4y agoSince elite classes are probably inevitable without significantly reengineering the human condition, we at least want elite social structures that... 1. Do not stifle the well-being of lower classes 2. Allow upwards mobility into the elite class from lower classes Today's elite caste fails both criteria: the current elites have architected the US, if not the world, to the detriment of the working class. Upwards mobility is very low - which drives resentment and distrust. The elite tends to select for its children moreso than any hypothetical notion of "merit", which gives the feeling that they are less "the best our country has to offer" and more "space aliens that happen to run everything".
- avgcorrection 4y agoA dominating class that > 1. Do not stifle the well-being of lower classes > 2. Allow upwards mobility into the elite class from lower classes is not possible without significantly reingeneering the human condition.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- WesternWind 4y agoIt's interesting that it starts off talking about elite backgrounds by discussing graduate degrees, and only later talks about wealth as an influence. Wealth seems like such a huge factor in who is successful in this country. Whereas I know quite a few people with college degrees, even graduate degrees, that aren't using that knowledge in their work.
- httpz 4y agoGoing into academia is usually not the best way to maximize your financial earning potential. So usually people who go into academia value pursuit of knowledge over money. Academics tend to raise children with those values.
- beezlebroxxxxxx 4y agoIt's also well known that connections are extremely important for academic positions, especially so in humanities academia where TT positions are so rare and hyper competitive. The name appeal of the Ivy's can have huge sway, and it leads to a flattening of intellectual diversity in scholarship as whole fields are shaped by certain "schools" or movements that are more often just former fellow students mutually citing each other and their former supervisors. A lot of brilliant research gets passed over because it's not coming from the right school.
- 93po 4y agoMost of the people I know that get into academia do it because traditional work sounds awful to them but they're really good at school, so they stick with what they know. My ex got a PhD just so she didn't have to work for 5 years in a traditional office style job in finance.
- sicp-enjoyer 4y ago> value pursuit of knowledge over money Or status over money, similar to upper-class careers in journalism.
- truly 4y agoI would like to draw the attention to the precise wording around the statistics: """ In 1970, just 1 in 5 U.S.-born PhD graduates in economics had a parent with a graduate degree. Now? Two-thirds of them do, [...] """ These numbers (1/5, 2/3) refer to US-born PhD graduates (in economics). But the number of US-born PhD students is very small. The vast majority of PhD students are immigrants.
- AlbertCory 4y agoMany big tech companies are indeed led by people from Worker Bee schools (Midwestern state schools, SEC, ACC, etc.) Except for Google, famously founded by Stanford students. Or Microsoft & Facebook: Harvard dropouts. It's quite a different story when you get to the people who really consider themselves Elite: big consulting firms, white shoe law firms, large media companies, and top echelons of the government. For those people, an Ivy League degree or equivalent is money, if not mandatory. I think, in addition to the percentage of incoming students who are historically marginalized, those schools should track "percentage of students whose parents did NOT go to college." If they really cared about providing opportunity for upward mobility, those are the people they'd go after.
- corncob15 4y agoMost colleges actually do track this metric - generally it's reported as "first-generation students." (Generally defined as parents without a four-year degree, not parents with zero college education, but same concept.) Here's Harvard's press release for the class of 2026, saying "Students who will be in the first generation of their family to graduate from a four-year college or the equivalent represent 20.3 percent of this year’s admitted class." https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2022/03/harvard-to-expand-financial-aid-starting-with-class-of-26/ https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2022/03/harvard-to-ex... Yale doesn't report this statistic as far as I could find, although I found a blurb that says "more than one out of every six" (https://admissions.yale.edu/advice-first-generation-college-applicants https://admissions.yale.edu/advice-first-generation-college-...). Princeton's class of 2025 was 22% first-generation (https://www.princeton.edu/news/2021/04/06/extraordinary-year-princeton-offers-admission-1498-students-class-2025 https://www.princeton.edu/news/2021/04/06/extraordinary-year...).
- adamsmith143 4y agoHarvard has more students from the top 20% income percentile than the bottom 80%.
- corncob15 4y ago
- davesque 4y agoIf anything, I think this just goes to show again how much of a scam higher education is. The demographic of those seeking a better education wouldn't have changed as much if the availability of those services hadn't been made artificially scarce. I think we have a combination of greedy businesses practices by university administrations and the weird culture of ivy league worship to thank for this.
- crhulls 4y agoI reject the assumption that someone is “elite” based on having a graduate degree.
- rob_c 4y agoHah, theres a thing called a bubble and unfortunately yours might be about to burst.
- aj7 4y agoAcademia does not equal economics, a field where a Nobel Prize winner ran a multibillion dollar hedge fund into the ground, and economists can’t agree on whether a person deserves healthcare.
- brutusborn 4y agoThe company in question if anyone is as interested as I was: https://www.investopedia.com/terms/l/longtermcapital.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/l/longtermcapital.asp https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long-Term_Capital_Management https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long-Term_Capital_Management Interestingly the Nobel Prize winners' advice was ignored in some cases: "As a result, LTCM began investing in emerging-market debt and foreign currencies. Some of the major partners, particularly Myron Scholes, had their doubts about these new investments. For example, when LTCM took a major position in the Norwegian kroner, Scholes warned that they had no "informational advantage" in this area"
- barry-cotter 4y ago> economists can’t agree on whether a person deserves healthcare. Economists have no special insight into deserts, any more than philosophers. Is does not imply ought and all that.
- aj7 4y agoHealthcare is 20% of the U.S. econ-omy.
- galdosdi 4y agoYou're talking about macroeconomics, the exciting and unscientific field of how interest rates, markets, etc interact and the whole big world of wealth works. Obviously very difficult to get any real experimental data that isn't unrepeatable or biased. You can argue one position, or just as easily find data to argue the opposite position, and nobody will ever know which one is right. Microeconomics on the other hand is much more a real science that helps answer boring practical questions like "How much capital should I invest in each product line? How much should I price this good at?" or my personal favorite because it is relevant to everyone, not just managers: "How elastic is the demand at firm X or in industry Y for laborers with skills like mine, and how elastic is the supply of such laborers?" Thinking about that question can really help anyone make choices about where to apply for work if you want your career to do well. And since it happens at a small level there is lots of data so correspondingly more scientific certainty.
- vishnugupta 4y agoThere's a (vicious?) feedback spiral at work here too. Most of the policies, bills etc., are authored by back office workers who are either themselves academics or are heavily influenced by them. Same with lobbyists. Academics (primarily economists) are also at work to produce all those white papers, op-ed articles that shape public opinion. Academics pays less compared to industry (tech, finance etc.,) so it's mostly those with elite backgrounds with big inheritance wealth who can afford to spend a long time in academia in return for a chance to keep elite's hold in the government.
- oofnik 4y agoWhy is this at all surprising? In any status-conscious society (read: any human society), given enough time, the people who make it to the top will invariably maximize opportunity afforded to their affinity group (i.e. offspring) at the expense of everyone else. This process manifests itself regardless of the role merit plays in the sorting algorithm. If the rules are relatively meritocratic (and relatively stable), and merit broadly defined is largely a heritable trait either via genetics or culture, it follows that given enough iterations, a structure will eventually emerge that exhibits strong nepotistic tendencies. The growing call for greater diversity and equity among high-status occupations is a reaction to this phenomenon. Alternatively, many long-lasting power structures throughout history attempted to mitigate the phenomenon of hereditary nepotism via the policy of enforced celibacy among the elite class: eunuch advisors in many classical near-Eastern empires, Catholic clergymen, etc.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> many long-lasting power structures throughout history attempted to mitigate the phenomenon of hereditary nepotism via the policy of enforced celibacy among the elite class: eunuch advisors in many classical near-Eastern empires That is not a goal of having eunuchs around. Eunuchs usually don't have children, but they pretty much always have family members.
- raducu 4y ago> attempted to mitigate the phenomenon of hereditary nepotism via the policy of enforced celibacy among the elite class That just tells us nepotism is bad. We have much better ways of dealing with it -- strong independent institutions, transparent rules, free education, social programs for the poor and so on.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- klqp 4y agoThis is an excellent explanation, but I have one small remark: Diversity and equity is taught at elite cadre schools and used as a distinguishing marker from the proletariat. This gives elite children a wedge to get into Ive League institutions without high test scores. Think of it as the new "extracurricular activity" on steroids. Diversity and equity have been co-opted by the elites and are a powerful tool (smoke screen).
- winReInstall 4y agoThe bad of caste appearing is a symptom of technology strangulation & stagnation. Meaning: new technology empowers the new comer, allowing them to excell in moments of meritocracy - if the economic circumstances give them the chance. But they do no longer, creating the families of old, who own all the things and prevent a change of all the things. The ugly truth is, the more oligarch a country is, the more the number of disruptions reduces. All that remains is "allowed" disruption, which are basically take over of internal guilds by the oligarchs consolidating power. Think of Rockefeller taking over the stage coach guild with ueber. The good thing is though, this consensus of oligarchs is not global. In chaotic countries, were the hold of the oligarchs is not total, the new might still bloom and overthrow them. There lies hope, supressed by the tendrils of the oligarchs to the extern in a empire that sanctions experiments.
- tippytippytango 4y agoI was almost a first generation academic. But, my family needed me to make money to handle chronic medical issues so I quit and took my skills to big tech.
- Kenneth21 4y ago[dead]
- nostromo 4y agoThey’re defining having an elite background as having a parent with a post-graduate degree… which seems like a stretch to me. Post graduate degrees are not that special anymore and they often don’t earn you much additional money, let alone power.
- barry-cotter 4y agoTwenty or thirty years ago a graduate degree was very unusual. Now it’s clearly not a marker of elite status. Things have changed.
- tgv 4y agoThat by itself totally explains the trend. There were enough intelligent people back then, but they just didn't go to college. This is alarmist, virtue-signalling, click and rage bait journalism.
- mkl95 4y agoIs it a recent phenomenon in the US? My country has a pretty straightforward pay-to-win scheme, which leads to degrees with a higher barrier of entry (mostly STEM) having a disproportionate amount of middle-upper class students. Even university is partially pay-to-win since well-off students usually spend thousands a year on private lessons that are the uni equivalent of cheat codes. Even if it weren't dominated by the elite, it would still be a fundamentally elitist system.
- schnitzelstoat 4y agoThe biggest difference I noticed at University was not that wealthier students would pay for private lessons, but rather that wealthier students didn't need to do part-time work to get by. This gave them much more time to study.
- desmosxxx 4y ago+1. I also saw some wealthier students go part-time during particularly hard semesters (and/or to have extra time to study for gre) and just add an extra semester or two.
- beardyw 4y agoIt was ever thus. Look back on history - academia was always dominated or even the exclusive preserve of those from wealthy backgrounds. It is wrong, but it is in no way new.
- achenet 4y agoThis is true. As an optimist, however, I believe that it doesn't have to be. Looking back on history, slavery was the dominant method of production for several thousand years - until we industrialized. Looking back on history, human flight was the preserve of fools - until the Wright brothers.
- verisimi 4y agoI object to the use of the word elite! Someone with a degree is not elite! (Even if that term flatters my educational level.) Elite is someone who's parents have ever increasing amounts of money through the holdings they already have, who do things like take degrees, etc as a lifestyle choice not because they need a job, and have aspirations over the job they get. Typically elite families would be billionaires, political leaders, bankers, etc.
- roel_v 4y ago"PhD programs tend to require a hidden curriculum of classes in subjects such as mathematics that are not technically required for economics majors." <record scratch> "subjects such as mathematics that are not technically required for economics majors" Eh? Who lets clueless writers like this near a keyboard?
- barry-cotter 4y agoReal Analysis, Linear Algebra and Calc I-III are not required to get an Economics degree but they will help enormously if you want to go to MIT(number one programme), Harvard (two) or even someplace like Penn(somewhere in the top 20). You do not need to get a Math minor to get an Economics major.
- galdosdi 4y agoWhy would Calc I-II not be required to get an Econ degree? Derivatives are used all over basic microeconomics. Anytime you see the word "marginal" you're taking a derivative.
- roel_v 4y ago"You do not need to get a Math minor to get an Economics major." That wasn't the claim. The claim was that it's somehow surprising that economics is math heavy. Yes there are 'policy' or 'international business' degrees camouflaging as 'economics' degrees, but how can it be a surprise to any but the most uninformed that 'economics' (at least the prestigious degrees, which are the ones that will produce the majority of future academics) are math heavy? And I'm not even talking about just the pure math courses. Courses like Operations Research are notorious 'filter courses' for economics students, good luck passing those without math fundamentals.
- barry-cotter 4y agoEconomics is very unusual in that even doing extremely well in the undergraduate major is not going to prepare you all that well for graduate study. Knowing things like that is part of the hidden curriculum the article is talking about. See also doing undergraduate research assistantships in other disciplines. The author may not have been as clear as they could have been.
- listenallyall 4y agoHey WaPo, they increasingly dominate journalism, too. Perhaps you should hold a mirror up to yourself.
- NoGravitas 4y agoIndeed. Big-name journalism outfits run on unpaid internships. Who can afford to do the unpaid internships and eventually land a staff position? Bingo. (As an aside, this is why blue checks on Twitter always have the worst takes.)
- nabla9 4y agoUS centered studies like this are so myopic that they are useless taken individually. https://www.piie.com/sites/default/files/documents/wp22-4.pdf https://www.piie.com/sites/default/files/documents/wp22-4.pd... When Europeans make these studies–especially from smaller countries–they make cross country comparisons as a rule. These comparisons makes it possible to separate national policy from other effects. Almost everything is multicausal in social sciences, separating the possible effect of different factors makes studies worthwhile.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 4y agoEveryone is for social justice but somehow it always works best at the expense of someone else's children.
- KoftaBob 4y agoHasn't it been this way in most of the world for most of human history? Has it ever not been this way? Genuinely asking.
- honkler 4y agoexactly my thoughts, but no one else pointed this out.
- Proven 4y ago[dead]
- georgia_peach 4y agoThe one-millionth-and-one article to fan petit bourgeois striver angst over maybe possibly not getting-in on the grift of mainstream academia--like economics. Churchill's famous quote: If you put two economists in a room, you get two opinions, unless one of them is Lord Keynes, in which case you get three opinions. If it's a choice between "inequality", or reducing it by minting more parasites, I think I prefer inequality.
- lapcat 4y agoThe article totally fails to mention the elephant in the room: graduate school costs! Moreover, the public debate over student loan forgiveness typically fails to mention that graduate students owe 50% of all student loan debt, despite being only 25% of all student loan debtors. Getting a PhD often takes many years, and the PhD completion rate for incoming graduate students is very low. Even after you get a PhD, it can be difficult to get a tenure track job. For those who get on the tenure track, you'll probably be fine financially, but for everyone else... going graduate school can ruin your life. You may waste the best years of your life while accumulating a debt you can never pay off, without even an official graduation certificate to show for it. College, including graduate school, is so much more expensive now than it was decades ago. And people forget that the post-WWII generation could use the GI Bill to pay for both undergraduate and graduate school.
- RickJWagner 4y agoThat's one of the reasons I oppose taxpayer-funded debt dismissal. It's just not right to ask low-income taxpayers (including those who didn't go to college) to pay off the debts of those who did go-- and have a higher earnings potential. It's also a great dis-service to those who have paid into Social Security for decades and now face a looming shortfall. Those people actually paid in and are going to have to deal with a benefit reduction, while the student borrowers took out and may potentially have their debts funded by the same taxpayers!
- lapcat 4y ago> It's just not right to ask low-income taxpayers (including those who didn't go to college) Low-income people don't actually pay much taxes. In fact their primary tax payment may be the fixed-rate Social Security FICA that you mention, not the progressive income taxes after deductions and credits. Moreover, what about the low-income student who have to go into debt to go to school, while the rich kids have their parents pay for everything? This is my point in relation to the article: who can afford to even get a PhD nowadays except the kids of financially well-off parents? That's one of the reason richer kids are coming to dominate academia. > a higher earnings potential My point is that the difference between actual and potential is the difference between a comfortable life and a lifetime of debt that may follow you to old age and death. There's basically no return whatsoever on your investment if you spend years in a PhD program but don't finish. It's all money down the drain. Meanwhile, graduate students are exploited by universities for very cheap teaching labor.
- charlescearl 4y agoElite Capture https://www.haymarketbooks.org/books/1867-elite-capture https://www.haymarketbooks.org/books/1867-elite-capture is a short book but gives some good ways of thinking about these and other processes as a systems problem. Also addresses how “elite” can span multiple dimensions: belonging to a socially dominant class, caste, having higher levels of education, being an “influencer” etc.
- NoGravitas 4y agoExcellent link. I can't recommend this book highly enough.
- jackcosgrove 4y agoWhat was the situation in the 1920s? The US created another higher education system in the postwar era to handle the demand created by the GI Bill. The number of open professor slots at these new schools could not have been filled just by the children of existing academics, so there was a window when newcomers could enter academia much more easily than what would come after, and probably even more easily than what came before. Now we have children and grandchildren of the gigantic cohort of PhD holders from the GI Bill era competing for jobs when the student population is stagnant or declining. Given that we won't be doubling the size of higher education anytime soon, I don't foresee opportunities like what we witnessed in the 70s returning.
- nathias 4y agoUS seems to have all its institutions set up in a way to increase the class divide.
- alexpotato 4y agoThis story is decidedly anecdata, even personal, but I think it's illustrative of what's going on in certain fields. - Had a friend who has multiple graduate level degrees in architecture related sub-specialties e.g. architecture criticism etc - HN being what it is, I will mention that the pay for most of the jobs you would get with the above is zero or near zero. - There is also a dramatic oversupply of candidates for available positions - That being said, certain jobs can be prestigious e.g. curator at a museum etc - Most places that would hire someone with these degrees will ONLY hire the children of very wealthy individuals - Why? The thought is that a museum hires the child of a hedge fund manager, there is a non-zero chance the wealthy parent will give or leave money to the institution when they die - This means a steady stream of unpaid internships for everyone else for, essentially, the rest of their lives It's therefore not surprising that only wealthy/elites would go into these particular fields and, in turn, causes people to not even enter the academic subjects to begin with. This isn't necessarily a criticism since everyone here is acting rationally from an economics perspective. I do wonder about the poor kid from a bad neighborhood who could have become the next great museum curator if not for the fact that his parents aren't wealthy.
- hourago 4y ago> Why? The thought is that a museum hires the child of a hedge fund manager, there is a non-zero chance the wealthy parent will give or leave money to the institution when they die Another way that inequality damages society. When your best bet for your future is to appeal to the super rich instead of serving society and getting money from the government society losses its power. As you say, it is rational to work for the one that can pay you. It's a catastrophe that there general public in aggregation has less power than very rich individuals by themselves.
- marcinzm 4y ago>best bet for your future The best bet for the future is to pick a career path that is not massively over supplied with candidates. Once you get to that situation there's no system that will not cause most everyone to be unhappy.
- rr888 4y agoMy father was a professor, so saw a lot of University people and politics. I just dont understand how anyone can talk about Academia as "elite". They are mostly a bunch of poorly paid, navel gazing bureaucrats who do a little interesting exploring but mostly spend time with annoying students. Its a terrible career, esp compared to tech or business world. To say poorer students are "locked out" makes me lol. There is also the fact that many more people have undergrad & graduate degrees now so the fact that the number of educated parents has increased is what you'd expect.
- the_lonely_road 4y agoThe state of Florida publishes professor salaries, likely other states do too. Your assessment of “poorly paid” falls on deaf ears for most Americans not making tech salaries.
- rr888 4y agoIn other news, we've found that athletes often have parents that are athletes, and musicians often come from muscial families.
- PaulHoule 4y agoI started grad school in 1993 and felt completely lost as a child of working class parents.
- pessimizer 4y agoThis is actually nothing to worry about, because people from elite backgrounds increasingly think this is a consequence of meritocracy.
- the_only_law 4y agoWho else can afford the time and money associated with all that.
- z9znz 4y agoHere, let me fix the title: People from elite backgrounds increasingly dominate, data shows
- at_a_remove 4y agoI noted that, when I worked at the university, the admin tier seemed to have a lot of wealth not attached to their jobs, although they did do a decent job of hiding it. One might have a father who did Everest (not cheap), or you might hear about multiple "family homes." Others seemed to take incredible amounts of vacations to exotic locales. Meritocracy was largely a sham, especially if you tracked careers of those who came and went.
- historyteaches 4y agoAnd in Controverse: "But while they want to be known and keep been famous, they stored 'history' to an extend, still some people learning -not?" P-:
- hitovst 4y agoLiars who wish to divide us use lie about "priviledge", etc. to confuse us, their enemies, and turn us against each other. 99.9% of the time, "deserve" applies to that which one has. Kind of like people who are confused about "respect".. they believe that when an ally tells them a truth they don't like, it is "disrespectful", and when a liar lies to them in a way they find pleasant, it's "respectful", when in both cases, the opposite is true. A newborn hasn't "earned" what they have, but they deserve it because it is, and because their ancestors earned it for them. The wealthiest/healthiest people aren't people who at some point in their life learned a healthy diet, how to exercise, and to earn a high wage.. The healthiest/wealthiest people are those who had ancestors who sacrificed to earn, preserve, and teach, health/wealth to their descendants. There are some people who spend money before they get it, and there are others who earn and save for their great grandkids who they don't expect to meet. The great grandkids don't earn their place when they're born, but their parents, grandparents, and great grandparents earned that place for them. When people understand that IQ is inherited, and can't really be permanently increased (but can be permanently decreased through abuse, malnutrition, etc.), and that children require growing up in a family with married parents all living together to be healthy, their children will be far better off than those of people who don't realize those two things. If one lives their life accordingly, they will earn the several advantages for their children. It will be their child's to build from for future generations, or squander. TL/DR; Elite backgrounds are "elite" for a reason. It is deserved, and based in merit.
- systemBuilder 4y agoI got an engineering job at a top-30 EE dept (UBC). By the pay was really poor - i once had an elite dad but he died when i was 13. So I quit the job, as I was no longer elite. An elite family can backstop you when you are taking a low-paying academic job in an expensive city. The thought that poor people would go for a professor job is no true. I believe most poor people would much rather have money to help their family, money to bank for security, money to pay back their student loans, money to start a family life, etc. Also it's worth pointing out that academia is a huge pyramid scheme and jumping to the next rung of the pyramid can be made much much easier if your mentors (ie your parents) know which tricks to use to make the greatest leap possible.
- systemBuilder 4y agoru kidding me I saw a top-10 school give a professor offer to a stanford grad. She did a shitty interview talk about a PhD topic that didn't matter. All the grad stuents who heard her talk agreed. But as it was explained to me by a member of the faculty recruiting committee, "She's a woman and the bad PhD could have been the advisor's fault". She turned down the offer for something better. Academic recruitment is a total crock of shit. You just need to tick the boxes, "woman, top-3 school" and THEY have to justify NOT hiring you ...
- systemBuilder 4y agoThis is one of the stupidest articles I have seen in a long time. I could just as easily write an article about "The number of professors today with US citizen parents is at an all-time low" based on Figure #1 of this article but it wouldn't be politically correct so it would never be published by the washington post. https://www.aip.org/statistics/reports/trends-physics-phds-171819 https://www.aip.org/statistics/reports/trends-physics-phds-1... Note that public funding for grad students really exploded in the 1960's so there are just a hell of a lot more PhDs running around today because their degrees were paid for by the US government. In the 1950's and earlier, PhDs were paid for with something called CASH (not credit), from the POCKET of the parents of the PhD - a concept that we just don't have any more today ...
- armenarmen 4y agoJohn Adams, the 2nd President of the United States, once said "I must study politics and war that my sons may have liberty to study mathematics and philosophy. My sons ought to study mathematics and philosophy, geography, natural history, naval architecture, navigation, commerce and agriculture in order to give their children a right to study painting, poetry, music, architecture, statuary, tapestry, and porcelain."