8 ms·
Most employees say IT issues decrease workplace productivity, morale
- indymike 4y agoIT problems make people feel powerless, and people rage about it, just like they do when they get cut off by a texting driver on the way home.
- jka 4y agoDigital experience ('DEX') issues reported by employees, from the original report: - 37% : Security/regulatory policies - 37% : IT overwhelmed by number of issues that need resolving - 35% : Lack of training for IT personnel - 34% : Handling the shift to hybrid/remote work - 32% : Increasing number of endpoints to manage - 31% : Technology in place is not appropriate for supporting DEX - 27% : Lack of knowledge around DEX - 25% : Lack of budget to support DEX efforts - 19% : Lack of buy-in from leadership around importance of DEX - 2% : No challenges being faced (with some snark: statistics on signup/login requirements before viewing published reports, and presenting statistics in images instead of tabular data formats were not reported)
- jqpabc123 4y agoSo in other words, 95% of employees have unrealistic expectations with regard to IT? Anything less than PFM (pure friggin magic) will likely come up short in their view.
- viraptor 4y agoI take it you don't deal with enterprise environments much? The bar to clear for avoiding daily annoyance is really not that high. Yet, here's a list i can still remember after a decade: - outbound http proxies sometimes falling for a few specific URLs but the issue was never debugged - employee portal logging you out after a couple minutes of inactivity - expenses claiming Web app which could've been 2 plain HTML forms but somehow required IE and was so bad I had "calm down after doing expenses" breaks The bar is really around: don't actively make people angry.
- vidanay 4y ago90 password expiration policy (which is actively recommended against by security experts).
- nmstoker 4y agoSomeone told me about one that's a level worse than that: 90 day password expiration notices that tell the user to do the wrong thing!
- aperson_hello 4y agoAdding some more: -Web policies that actively prevent you from doing research in key company technologies (edit: fake example, but effectively it was on the level of a gun maker blocking searches on firearms) -No budget for replacing/upgrading outdated computers that get absolutely crushed by memory hogging corporate nannyware. It's amazing how little you get done when it takes five minutes to open Excel -Computers not arriving until well after the start date of new hires -Outdated database access prograns that won't run on x64 systems (or better yet, are still run on terminals and the only viable means of export was printing...and yes I ran into that only a couple years ago in a Fortune 100) I get a lot of this is outside the hands of IT to actually fix, but they're still "IT Problems" even if the root cause is shitty management
- test6554 4y agoThere are some really good expense reporting tools out there now.
- pxeger1 4y ago95% of employees say problems cause problems? Do the remaining 5% enjoy dealing with IT issues? Seems like a rather useless survey.
- cassianoleal 4y agoNo. 95% have gone through IT problems that impacted their work. The other 5% have either not have had to deal with such problems, or the ones they did had no significant impact on their work. This means that too many people are going through hurdles with IT, not that problems cause problems. It shows that companies need to streamline and improve their IT processes so that fewer employees are impacted.
- nyreed 4y ago5% is roughly the amount of people who will answer nonsensically in any survey. The so-called 'Lizardman constant'. We're in agreement what exactly was the purpose of the survey... See: https://slatestarcodex.com/2013/04/12/noisy-poll-results-and-reptilian-muslim-climatologists-from-mars/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2013/04/12/noisy-poll-results-and...
- wildrhythms 4y agoI wonder how many employees know when their employer outsources their IT operations to another company/country? Where you used to have experienced sysadmins and IT folks on-site maintaining systems and helping people out, now you have a catch-all call center for a dozen companies with a runbook that starts and stops at "please restart your computer."
- celeritascelery 4y agoI had a recent indecent where I needed a new screw for my work laptop. I walked up to the IT building on site and asked for one. They said they couldn’t get one unless I had a ticket. So I went back to my desk and opened a ticket with IT. It took almost an hour to talk to the person and then they wanted pictures of the missing screw hole. So I had to use my phone to take pictures and upload them to the support website. More waiting. Then I get a report back saying they recommended a complete clamshell replacement (for a screw!). I told them just give me a freaking ticket please. They finally did and I went to the on-site IT building and they put in a new screw in 2 minutes. But the whole process took almost 4 hours. Half a day wasted for a screw.
- ls15 4y agoThe IT guys would have loved to just fix it for you in two minutes, but unfortunately HR or someone else forces them to stick to the sticky process.
- raspyberr 4y agoThis was my experience too when working in IT for a little bit. Many were happy to just sort problems out there and then but I could clearly see they were being reprimanded by HR for fixing issues without tickets. However, there was one callous and jaded printer technician who basically wouldn't even speak to someone unless they had a ticket opened.
- lordnacho 4y agoThe one that I've seen a few times is when a new employee comes, and they literally cannot work due to a variety of IT issues: - Nobody has ordered a new machine, takes up to a month to sort out - Their name is spelled wrong in the email system, takes weeks to fix. Especially bad if your role is external facing. - Subscriptions have not been made for necessary services eg Bloomberg - Access is denied due to the initial password being unknown. It takes a week to sort out. I've even heard of people quitting their new job due to one of these issues. It makes the place look really amateur when a new joiner isn't set up to start when they arrive.
- aperson_hello 4y agoI've had this happen to me. Ended up with three work computers after waiting a week after my start date to get one. It was a temporary gig and they were paying me regardless, so no skin off of my back...but it was endlessly frustrating for my boss and I had multiple IT people tied up for hours trying to resolve everything. Edit: I also left another position at another company (to move to a different position at the same company) mostly because it meant I would get a new computer instead of one that would take 20 minutes to boot (and required mid-day reboots as well)
- dzdt 4y agoI think you might work the same place I work lol.
- synu 4y agoI am intensely curious about the 5% who believe IT issues increase workplace productivity and morale.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- philipov 4y agoDon't exclude the middle. Those people probably think it doesn't decrease productivity and morale, because those are already garbage regardless of what IT does.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sdflhasjd 4y agoThe 5% are IT managers with no technical knowledge who don't know how to use a computer.
- Agamus 4y agoThese are probably the people who work in IT, who love to fix things and solve problems. Their workplace productivity and morale may be enhanced by the inevitable IT problems that befall others.
- protomyth 4y agoThey are the accountants that do not want to go back to the green ledgers.
- ThePadawan 4y agoIf I tried really hard to devil's advocate that position: "If my boss can't start this 90 min Zoom call that could be an email because his headset is broken, that is some sweet blessed relief from this drudgery."
- sdflhasjd 4y agoI saw IT policy cause the near-downfall of a software company after it was absorbed by a bank. As you would guess, overbearing security policies came in nearly overnight. Development had to be done on machines with (practically) no internet connection, approved devices were crappy laptops with no memory, developers couldn't access systems to diagnose issues, looking away from your machine for more than 5 minutes had it locked. Everything just took five to ten times longer. You hear people say "the company still pays you for your time", but of course job satisfaction is important, and the company just hemorrhaged developers.
- vips7L 4y agoMy startup was bought by a large corporation late last year. My laptop finally died a month ago and I was issued a new one from corporate IT and they really messed Windows up. Our desktop app that we develop won’t even run on it. I have to change my password every 2 months, I can’t change power settings without an admin account (it’s locked on balanced), ssh wasn’t working because I needed admin to start the service, I can’t change which programs run at startup, I can’t uninstall programs that they’ve preinstalled even if I don’t use them, they automatically install/reinstall Java 8 which messes up my JAVA_HOME environment variable and I’ll randomly have to fix it so I can compile my Java 11 code base, everything in my home folder automatically goes to One Drive (rip node_modules), the fan runs at 100% no matter what because of some shitty corporate back ground processes. It’s absolutely maddening. I’m going to reinstall my own copy of Windows or buy my own machine soon.
- joezydeco 4y agoMy company thankfully allows engineers to be admins on their machine with the right amount of begging and persistence. But it still sucks. And now my corp Win10 machine is so clogged up with firewalls, antivirals, ZScaler and CarbonBlack whatever the fuck that is that the machine regularly stalls and just sits there for seconds at a time. In the middle of typing. It's put a dragchute on my productivity but they're paying me so fuck it.
- semicolon_storm 4y ago
- DoneWithAllThat 4y agoI went from working at a company that offered “tech lounge” style IT where there was a place on site you could go to get your problems addressed, to one where they use more standard big company IT and the new one is so, so much worse for getting anything fixed. It’s incredible. Waiting on hold for an hour or more to just report your problem is totally the norm. Getting hardware is a massive pain and requires tons of approvals and weeks long wait times. Getting help for more subtle issues is virtually impossible. Just things like replacement cables or dongles are like trying to do a moon landing. It’s awful.
- QuarterReptile 4y agoI work in the government. I know people who have worked at my office for years and don't yet have access to the classified systems required to do their jobs.
- hn_version_0023 4y agoHere’s a fun one from a couple gigs ago: I was working as a DC tech at a small collocation provider, roughly 120 people company-wide. It was a standard shop these days: O365 apps, Chrome on Windows 10, Slack, etc., totally managed and locked down. The IT staff were completely unable to control the Windows patching process. They made a lot of noise about gathering office hours for people so they could do OS & app updates when you weren’t working. Except it never, not one time worked. It was company folklore all the times the Windows patching process took down engineering devices that were actively in use performing upgrades or changes to core routing and switching devices. So because IT couldn’t control patching, core network services were repeatedly lost during maintenance windows. Because the host performing the work would suddenly reboot to patch itself. Now, I don’t know what lack of competence led to this situation. Maybe Windows Update is truly a horror story. But I’ll tell you one thing for certain: IT didn’t give one shit about the impact their mistakes had on production, on morale, or frankly about much of anything. Like the rest of the workforce, IT is overwhelmed, overworked, under appreciated, and fed up with the BS. But it sure seems like they go out of their way to screw people over.
- BrandoElFollito 4y agoI work in IT security, so I am probably one of those people who screw other people over by pushing patches to be installed no matter what. Behind the scene, it is a never ending war between me who says "if your want your data to be safe, we need to patch", and the business that says "no, those is quarter rend (or stuff like this)'. So I say" on, sign this paper what you start that you do not want your data to be secure" And it goes on forever. This is exhausting for everyone, but IT is zero the very bottom of thefood chain, we cannot claim sales or new products and provide z utility like water or trash collection. So this is not always that someone is trying to screw you over, out is just that technology works the way it works, with the money that is invested in it.
- hn_version_0023 4y agoYour comment exemplifies the attitude I'm talking about. You've presented a scenario that's false in it's premise: either your data is safe or it isn't. But really, whether a thing is protected isn't quite so zero or one. Whether your production environment is actually at risk for the exploit being patched is a reasonable thing to ask in all scenarios. "What's our exposure here? Can it wait a few days?" would be a reasonable thing to ask. But in my experience that isn't how it goes. It goes how you suggested: ITSecOps presents an easy-to-decide case based on a false premise, and then immediately asks for CYA if the company says no. Over time, this becomes a rubber stamp from management, who are also demoralized by the process. The solution is to not present every security patch as a sky-is-falling event, but rather to be reasonable about the threats one faces and the impact to the business of forcing updates.
- korlja 4y agoBack in the day, if your pencil was dull, you sharpened it with your own personal workplace sharpener. You could replace your pencil or maybe even typewriter by just going to the supplies closet and get a new one. Security was done by cleaning your desk and locking the file closet in the evening. Also, the friendly security guy at the main entrance greeted you nicely and knew your face. Nowadays, if there is a problem with your pencil-equivalent computer plus word-processor, you have to get support from hardly available technicians. You cannot just take the next computer out of a nearby supplies closet. Even worse, after an update, all computers company-wide break at the same time in the same way, no chance for a quick fix. Security is done by weird processes that must be followed to the letter, including learning a new "key profile" by heart every 8 weeks instead of just taking along the company-provided file-closet-key on a keychain. If you use the company provided email client like it is built to be used, e.g. click on attachments, you are at fault for breaking policy and endangering security. If you fail to use obscure processes that said email client doesn't actually want you to use to check for the originator address of an email, you are endangering security. Same for the fancy new phone-replacement-software that needs you to download and execute arbitrary executables which you aren't supposed to do. And the guard at the door has been replaced by an RFID badge that any kid in the subway standing next to you can clone with his phone. Of course you are supposed to know this and wrap that badge in tinfoil outside company premises. IT issues are so debilitating because users are powerless to fix them. They are blamed for problems that arise just because of the mandated software being unsuitable and insecure. All this gets papered over by heavy processes such that even the people in IT who are trying to help are powerless, bogged down in ticket-pushing busywork, and tons and tons of policies that actually do nothing useful.
- BrandoElFollito 4y ago> RFID badge that any kid in the subway standing next to you can clone with his phone Please do not spread FUD. Except for antique technologies. (MCF-1, ...) you can't clone RFID devices.
- blueflow 4y agoMany "security" tokens are just... tokens. Literally an ID that is writable and readable to any close device. If you think its antique... like, its still widely in use today, i think you are wrong.
- iasay 4y agoYep. I would be 3x as productive if I was given hardware and software which was fit for purpose. I have actually been unable to work at all for 17 days this year so far due to stupid issues caused by poorly tested changes or having to wait for tickets to be cleared. But I give less of a fuck these days. I can do other things and still be paid.
- sudden_dystopia 4y agoI mean yea but in my experience, what really decreases my morale and burns me out is terrible user experience. I understand that there are bugs in code and systems crash so I don’t really let IT issues bother me. But it bothers me to no end to have to use user hostile software day in and day out at work. Death by a million clicks.
- protomyth 4y agoBasically, you can run your IT department one of two ways. You can be a statistic driven group that ultimately will fail to serve the company because the act of taking those statistics will corrupt you. You can just serve your customers and take note of what you do and then try to figure out the stats afterwords. Maybe its premature optimization that gets you. I would bet you can figure out how bad IT is going to be by the CFO's attitude towards IT. Doesn't really matter what the CIO thinks because the justification for budget makes you do stupid things.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- daper 4y agoI had brief experience managing such IT team after which I've gained big respect for them. I've never seen such low budget to amount of work ratio in my IT career. Everybody expects them to fix the "trivial" problems immediately but reality in my case was: - 2 "IT guys" for > 500 headcount company - If you look at IT guy instant messaging app you will see many unread notifications all the time. Without tickets it's impossible to properly prioritize and divide work. "Tickets" for everything" was one of my first change. - They are responsible for the broadest set of technologies / vendors I've ever seen. That includes: networking (including cabling, switched, wireless routing, VPN, firewalls), laptops, office apps, conferencing hardware (and software), IT security, accounting and warehouse software (including their MS SQL databases,) windows servers, virtualization, managing email accounts and maaaany more. - without tickets they can't show real amount of work they are doing so justifying adjustment budget and staffing for the need is a big challenge. On the other hand everybody expects to fix trivial problems without forms (so most of their work!). - Upper management don't perceive the as value but only as a cost - trivial problems could be fixed faster but that would require supplies for spare parts. This is bigger than you may think: few generations of laptops in use, office hardware, spare monitors, docking stations etc. That require office space for a small "warehouse" which is not free. How to justify this need considering the previous points? - many people fix "trivial problems" themselves: replacing cable, "borrowing" cable/mouse/monitor from a different desks. That creates more work for the IT guys: more issues because of incomplete office hardware.
- ohCh6zos 4y agoI worked at a place where IT was obsessed with moving everyone to thin clients. The executives loved it, HR loved it, and it took almost 3 years to get most developer work kind of working.
- TheOtherHobbes 4y agoAre these issues with IT or with corporate bureaucracy? Is there anything about IT that specifically amplifies these issues, or are there similar issues in other contexts which aren't IT-related? IMO it's easy to blame the technology. But when virtually all individual corporate tooling relies on IT, there's no real control group to provide an alternative. A lot of the problems listed below sound like they could be solved relatively easily - if the will was there, and if the corporate relationships around them didn't promote bureaucratic non-solutions because of turf wars, irrational policy, lack of effective oversight, and so on.
- jaclaz 4y agoThank goodness it's a lot of years that I do not have to deal with corporate IT support, but at the time (in various firms) they tended to be a lot similar to the procurement office (Bob the dinosaur) in Dilbert: https://dilbert.com/strip/1995-07-29 https://dilbert.com/strip/1995-07-29
- hestefisk 4y agoCase of stating the obvious much?
- throwaway787544 4y agoThis is the thing that infuriates me most about any job. At any business, everyone needs to work as a team to accomplish the business's goals and make the customer happy. If anyone decides they're not going to care about their team mates, they are working against the best interests of the people who pay their salary. They're taking a dump on the rug of the person giving them a meal. It might be the IT person doesn't have time to work on new issues. Or it might be the middle manager doesn't want to fight for what we really need. Or the executive doesn't want to spend money on what they don't personally care about. Or the engineer doesn't want to work with operations on how the product should work. Or human resources doesn't care how painful it is to onboard in the company. Or the company as a whole doesn't care how difficult it is to just find some information, or communicate across teams. It's usually never just one person or group at fault. The culture sets the tone for how well people listen for problems, how willing they are to jump in and fix them, and whether they even think it's OK to try to fix them. Apathy, fear, and jadedness will drive everyone to stop making things better. If you find yourself in such an environment, my advice is to quit immediately, because changing culture is just about the hardest thing there is.
- chrisseaton 4y agoDo 5% of people get a morale boost from IT issues?
- karaterobot 4y agoWhat's the alternative? That IT issues increased workplace productivity? I'm not going to give 1E my contact information to read the full report, but this does not sound insightful to me.
- dqpb 4y agoAre there any category of workplace issues that do not decrease productivity and morale?
- mkoubaa 4y agoSecurity breaches are bad for business, so IT can impose draconian measures to prevent them. Right now we're bad at measuring the cost to business of IT making developers work harder. Maybe eventually they'll be an insurance policy against lost revenue from security breaches and we stop getting in developers way. One can only hope
- rr808 4y agoYeah this is the truth. My old company once lost several mil because of sketchy employee doing something they shouldn't. We now have severe controls which makes the problem less likely to happen, but the hidden costs means it costs several mil every year - but much harder to measure.
- cebert 4y ago> Maybe eventually they'll be an insurance policy against lost revenue from security breaches and we stop getting in developers way. There are polices like this, but with the prevalence of ransomeware attacks, insurers demand proof that IT departments adopt safeguards that help mitigate risk. This is in conflict with providing productive work environments to developers.
- Cupertino95014 4y ago> digital employee experience (DEX) A handy rule for deciding when someone is worth reading: when they invent a TLA for something obvious, to make it sound like they've actually done something, they are not worth reading.
- test6554 4y agoSounds like adequate IT staffing is a common thread/problem here. Companies need to staff their IT departments proportional to the number of users, devices, and applications supported. They need to staff their IT department proportional to the amount of organizational knowledge their company needs to store. Also extra people are needed to manage change. Changing operating systems, new hardware, new policies, system updates, etc. If you can't change quickly enough, technical debt and costs pile up.
- cebert 4y agoMy employer got hit by ransomeware attack, and to stay insurable, our IT department clamped down all computers to the point of harming productivity and morale. Instead of adopting trust no one security models, things are limited to the point that it’s tempting to use personal devices to complete work. Developers cannot have local admin privileges, making many task much more cumbersome. Machines run multiple AV products including Fireeye’s xAgent, Windows Defender, and BitDefender. They use Netspoke to inspect all traffic including HTTPS traffic. If that wasn’t enough, Thycotic is used to selectively allow processes to launch and is single threaded. Thycotic is extremely slow, especially for git operations and tools that tend to spawn multiple processes.