15 ms·
Making IRC better
- throwaway71271 4y agoi love IRC, without bncs you close it, and you are not there :) its amazing you connect and the history is empty, like every day is fresh slack/discord/whatsapp/etc are just invasive, everybody somehow expects immediate answer to their request.
- shp0ngle 4y agoin reality, everyone use some kind of irssi or whatever, to replicate slack etc, so everyone is there and “active” but nobody really is. Hugely annoying.
- nequo 4y ago> to replicate slack IRC replicating slack. The irony. old-person grumble
- lmm 4y agoYes IRC came first. The point is that every sufficiently experienced IRC user is running an ad-hoc, informally-specified, bug-ridden implementation of half of slack, via their bouncers/bots/etc.
- nequo 4y agoI hear you. IRC is a mess for anything other than ephemeral text-based communication. (Which I only say because I'm sticking to running irssi in a terminal window. I imagine there are clients that work better for other use cases, like inlining gifs, etc.) But bouncers and bots have been around since the 1990s. There's nothing particularly ad hoc, informally specified, or bug-ridden about them. They are open source and they've been around for longer than some of their users. Slack, by contrast, is proprietary software used for corporate communication, which comes with its upsides and downsides. IRC is just a different tool to solve a different problem.
- lmm 4y ago> But bouncers and bots have been around since the 1990s. There's nothing particularly ad hoc, informally specified, or bug-ridden about them. The protocol for actually controlling the bouncer or bot is always ad-hoc. Whether client X will have support for bouncer Y or bot Z is a crapshoot, and whether such integration will keep working is even more so (of course you can generally fall back to doing it manually, but that's a serious downgrade in usability). As for bug-ridden, well, all I can say is that that's been my experience.
- eterps 4y agoELI5 what is an irc bouncer? An irc bouncer is a middleman between you and an irc network. It connects to a network like a normal client and instead of connecting directly to an irc network you connect to it. Usually you would set it up to log for you and show you some or all of the messages it received while you were disconnected. In this way your nick is always present in your channels and you can see what was talked about while you were away. source: https://www.reddit.com/r/irc/comments/35vcth/comment/cr86hcs/ https://www.reddit.com/r/irc/comments/35vcth/comment/cr86hcs...
- dizhn 4y agoIn addition to the above. Both matrix and discord can provide IRC bridges which provide the same "always-on with history" functionality. I have been using the matrix.org bridge to libera.chat for a few weeks. One can join any libera.chat channel this way. Other matrix server might configure a more limited room-to-channel setup where not all channels are bridged.
- snarfy 4y agoI always found the ephemeral nature of IRC chat to be a feature, not a bug.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- usrn 4y agoExactly. You don't want to know everything that's ever happened in the history of the channel, there's way too much. Even on Discord the client can't handle it so you won't know anyway.
- eterps 4y agoIt doesn't work very well for low traffic channels.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 4y agoEmail does. Right tool for right job.
- dopa42365 4y agoJust use Matrix. Can run an IRC bridge if you need it.
- overlisted 4y agoLast time I checked, Synapse was the only usable homeserver implementation. Has this changed yet? It's not that big of an issue, but it doesn't seem much of an open protocol if everyone is just running the same implementation.
- miloignis 4y agoYes, depending on your needs Dendrite (Go impl, written by Element team (mostly Neil?)) works well (I've heard) and some people are even running Conduit (Rust impl, independent) as their main.
- Klonoar 4y agoI run Conduit as my main. It’s still behind on features but is active and very usable. No complaints.
- zaik 4y agoThe real standards are IRC and XMPP. Matrix is more a product / custom protocol.
- kitkat_new 4y agoMatrix isn't more or less real than IRC or XMPP, see https://spec.matrix.org/latest/ https://spec.matrix.org/latest/
- EmilyHughes 4y agoReminds me of the short time when everyone used trillian or miranda to have ICQ, MSN and whatever else at once. Guess what, these protocols are all gone know, along with these multi-clients. Why keep stuff alive that's on the way out? Just move on.
- c7DJTLrn 4y agoI can understand not wanting to use a proprietary platform for communications about a FOSS project, but why does it have to be IRC? The world is moving on. I like being able to paste code into chat and have it syntax highlighted. I like being able to ping people so that they get a notification on their phone, and likewise, I like people to be able to ping me. Occasionally, I like to send a GIF. I imagine IRC people will just call all of these distractions. They are in a shrinking minority of people.
- tsujp 4y ago> I like being able to paste code into chat and have it syntax highlighted. Use a pastebin, there are plenty out there. See: https://paste.sr.ht/ https://paste.sr.ht/ or http://ix.io/ http://ix.io/ or https://paste.rs/ https://paste.rs/ or https://bpa.st/ https://bpa.st/ or https://gist.github.com/ https://gist.github.com/ or https://paste.ubuntu.com/ https://paste.ubuntu.com/ and many, many more. Regardless of there being a better tool for syntax highlighting and holding small linkable snippets of code (so that logic doesn't need to be more to download when opening your chat) it also keeps it _out_ of the chat so it's not polluted. People not being able to instantly insert 20 lines of text is a _good_ thing. So, link to the resource don't embed it. > I like being able to ping people so that they get a notification on their phone, and likewise, I like people to be able to ping me In the article you're responding to Drew directly mentions their suggestions for Push Notifications. I don't mean to sound facetious but, did you read this (article) in it's entirety? > Occasionally, I like to send a GIF See above: link to the resource, don't embed it.
- proto_lambda 4y ago> Use a pastebin That's not a solution, that's a bad and inconvenient workaround. Having to use an external service just to share a couple lines of code is horrible for usability. Funnily enough, its also exactly the thing that IRC users complain about when the matrix bridge converts multi-line messages to links.
- Arnavion 4y ago
- tsujp 4y agoI think Drew and Simon represent a good case for IRC modernisation _without_ it devolving into Slack or Discord. Notification fatigue, endless automated bots, and the expectation to read channel history _sucks_ and IRC keeps the opt-in liveness and culture that fosters jump-in and jump-out chats which is kind of how it works face-to-face in the real world anyway. There are absolutely others doing good work here too but Simon and Drew are the most visible (to me). With (good) forums non-existent now I spend almost all of my tech/programming/misc talking on IRC and have since 2011. I'm 27, this isn't technology for "boomers" or "die hard oldies" which is the general tone against "just use Discord or Slack" I see in response to any kind of IRC discussion online.
- way2freedom 4y agoOT but wanted to share (quoting some of the people here ^^): 'In public conversations, there's no expectation that everyone will be present and no expectation that those "not there" should view the things they missed.' -Not even with the same eye. P-: Freedom!? It certainly gets around some of the privacy concerns. (-: regards,
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hericium 4y agoWanting to have a "session" on IRC 24/7 in order to stop missing messages and conversations, introduced me to UNIX-like systems. In the late 90s I've purchased a "shell account" from a guy who was working for a local uni. Had some trouble understanding how the hell `screen` makes programs like ircII stay alive when I'm logging out. Good times.
- newbieuser 4y agowhat exactly is the purpose of this site? what alternative?
- sys_64738 4y agoWasn’t this what Slack was all about?
- AndyKelley 4y agoNo, Slack was about making a return on VC investments, same as what every startup is all about.
- korse 4y agoIRC is extremely accessible. Sure, you can't send gifs without modifying your client... but you can modify your client (or write your own)! Confused about how something works? Read the RFC! Quit selling pre-packaged experiences; your opsec sucks regardless of your use of Matrix/Telegram/Signal and it doesn't hurt to shepherd people into an environment where knowing a bit about how the underlying technology functions in necessary for participation.
- ArrayBoundCheck 4y agoAlso who wants to run IRC on their phone? I rather not have my battery zapped by having an active internet connection
- lobocinza 4y agoIRC sucks for async work.
- dewey 4y agoEven when I'm not a heavy IRC user any more I'm excited that they are pushing IRCv3. It's a smaller spec where a two people team can already make a dent.
- bitwize 4y ago
- xibo9 4y agoI genuinely cannot tell if you're being sarcastic or not, and I'd rather not listen to a long rambling podcast to find out. Could you elaborate or summarize?
- bitwize 4y agoOne of the points that Aurynn Shaw makes is that federation hampers the addition of protocol features because new features have to be agreed upon by all participants in the federated network. This adds friction to the evolution of protocols, and results in the phenomenon wherein Slack runs halfway around the world while IRC is still putting on its shoes. She also makes some excellent points about the social characteristics of federated networks. In a federated environment, each node sets their own policy, which meant there was no single point of responsibility for onboarding new users, setting standards of behavior, or filtering out trolling and harassment. Often, as on USENET and IRC, it is the user's own responsibility to filter out content and users they don't want to see -- and there was no authoritative source for new users to determine who/what should be filtered. Some USENET groups were moderated, and on IRC, channel ops can monitor and ban users for in-channel behavior, but if someone is harassing you in PRIVMSG there's often nothing you can do -- and channel bans can be circumvented and enforcement bots subverted fairly easily. And no one takes responsibility to communicate which instance of a federated network to join if they don't want to see particular kinds of content. So federated networks quickly become cesspools of the worst forms of communication because they're optimized to promote all forms of communication -- "freedom of speech at all costs" as Aurynn says (and, as she points out, is actually a US-chauvinistic perspective on speech and runs contrary to the laws on speech even in most democratic countries -- hate speech being an offense is the norm). This tends to make them grognard-friendly, but hostile to new users and to users of marginalized communities, as well as potentially illegal to participate in in countries not called the USA. And that was accepted in the 90s internet because that's how the 90s internet was. But standards have changed and this is no longer acceptable. "Me too" has gone from the mark of a clueless n00b to a rallying cry against harassment. And people like Aurynn Shaw and Coraline Ada Ehmke have been leading the way in terms of calling out and removing the negativity, exclusion, and sometimes outright hate, from open source development communities with things like Coraline's code of conduct and Aurynn's efforts to highlight contempt culture -- the "PHP sucks" and "Micro$oft sucks" culture that prevailed in technical circles in the 90s and early 00s whose toxicity is something we still deal with today. Times have changed since federation came out and was promoted as a wonderful thing. Back in the 90s, we thought that building the technology itself was sufficient to change the world for the better. Today we understand better the social costs that mentality has unleashed. We optimize for creating safe, welcoming communities and promoting voices that are usually silenced, rather than allowing everyone to communicate anything at any time. Unfortunately, federated technologies as we understand them today still come from that 90s mentality, and without broader conversations about the social impacts -- as well as establishing some sort of standards for mitigating those impacts -- it's simply better to not federate. Slack and Discord are easier to get started with, offer more features, and promote a safer and more welcoming environment than does IRC.
- ArrayBoundCheck 4y agoThe 80's called, they want their technology back
- zaik 4y agoWhat are you doing on this TCP/IP based website?
- ArrayBoundCheck 4y agoWaiting for QUIC
- account42 4y agoThat's still UDP/IP.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kodah 4y agoI used to be a big fan of IRC, but I'm not so much anymore. The reason IRC tends to suck is channel operators and network operators that enable them. No amount of technical advancement will solve that problem. Channels on IRC are unique, and much like domains, so there's not much community competition to sack bad channel operators while network operators are very hands off. What I'd love to see is an open source version of discord take off. Especially if there's a discovery mechanism built in.
- welterde 4y agoThat very much depends on the network and the channels how well things work or not. And other than having no moderators/channel operators at all, I don't see how it can be a problem that can even be solved? People can always get drunk on power and go completely crazy. What would be your proposal to solve this?
- kodah 4y agoIt can be, but not in a place like IRC. The problem is that if a channel operator over a large channel gets to tripping your only option is to move networks if you'd like to chat on the same topic with less abusive operators, which ignores the value that people add to communities. On Discord, all communities are created equal, and are discoverable. When you go to the discovery mechanism you can search for many similarly purposed communities.
- welterde 4y agoFair point (especially for super generic things like "#science" or similar) - that could sometimes be handled better. However sometimes there are multiple rooms discussing the same thing on the same network, so it's not always necessary to jump ship completely. But not sure I buy that the communities are that different. I would rather view them as different networks in IRC terms. You'll have a completely different set of people from one to the next, so how is it any different to joining a different network on IRC?
- 4y ago
- lobocinza 4y agoI'm glad that Sourcehut exists but still a long way from Github or Gitlab.
- encryptluks2 4y agoI don't think it is their goal to become another GitHub or Gitlab. Both of those are bloated and focus on centralization. I like that Sourcehut takes a more traditional approach to Git SCM, like mailing lists. I think Sourcehut has a ways to go to really compete directly, but I also believe they are targeting a different audience that have different values.
- qudat 4y agoI disagree, it's feature complete for the core use case of collaborating on and sharing code.
- dpedu 4y agoAm I the only person that doesn't want IRCv3? I don't find the new features important or compelling (telling others when I am typing is creepy!) and I see v3's rise as only leading to some sort of schism.
- MaxLeiter 4y agoOne beauty of IRC is you can easily opt out or in to the typing spec
- ddevault 4y agoThere are some good ideas and some bad ones. Part of our work is to argue against the bad ones. I don't think that the contentious ones are likely to get much traction, but some of the more obvious ones, like account-registration, are making their way into the ecosystem.
- mjevans 4y agoMy _opinion_ is that whatever really replaces / evolves existing commonly used communications protocols already has an uphill battle. Further, as Gchat / XMPP based chats showed (opinion observations): federation without a sufficiently rich baseline to ensure a basic user experience leads to fragmentation, silo-ing, and eventual death. It has to fulfill the need of a common space for public discourse. The specification must be open and free for all to use. There should be no artificial restrictions on who is able to develop tools including servers, clients, intermediary or subsystems, or provide a service to host any of them. Federation also introduces a higher risk of spam and bad actors; it's part of the price of freedom so the protocol should have an intended use pattern that addresses that type of issue; ideally without forcing the association of a 'real identity' to all use of the system. That won't solve all of the problems, and it adds a bunch of other problems. However a system of the commons may see users such as government organizations or heavily regulated industries where endpoints agree to use such an identity in some way.
- Eupraxias 4y agoYou're not alone - IRC is precious as one of the last places where one can still avoid exactly these kind of features! It looks/fits/feels more or less the same today as it was when I started using it in 1996, and I have never felt it needs improvement. "Weechat in a terminal on my other monitor" feels like home to me. I'm hoping we can opt-out, but in my opinion it will be a dark and dogless day when we cannot.
- olliej 4y agoI didn’t find this article super useful, I ended up going over to the specs themselves and I was kind of disappointed. The default non-TLS with whatever that standard is to say “always use TLS in future” is boneheaded. Not supporting TLS at this point is inexcusable for any client or server. I couldn’t work out whether they’d actually made DMs private yet or whether it was still plain text. Those are things I’d consider baseline expectations for a specification 10 years ago, let alone today.
- foxes 4y agoAverage IRC experience: >blub has connected >blub has changed nickname to glub >Hello anyone here? (* 10 hours later no replies, 10 hours of random connect/disconnect spam *)
- ayushnix 4y agoTo be fair, https://dontasktoask.com/ https://dontasktoask.com/ should be basic etiquette on any chat platform at this point. I understand that some people may not be familiar with this etiquette but I won't be surprised if someone doesn't receive a response to "Hello anyone here?". What does one expect in this case? If there are 13 people online, all of them should reply "Yes, I'm here"?
- foxes 4y agoI think you missed the point. Irc is basically a ghost town apart from random noise compared to other popular communication channels.
- ayushnix 4y agoAh, yes, smaller channels can certainly seem that way and the join leave logs are basically spam. For what it's worth, I've been active on three channels in the past few months — #openwrt on OFTC, #vim and #neovim on Libera. I've always got responses fairly quickly on #openwrt and #vim.
- Gigachad 4y agoLow volume irc channels are useless because of all the join quit spam. As well as username spam where bouncers will auto change the username based on away status.
- foxes 4y agoIt felt like basically all of them even 5 years ago. I can only imagine by now it’s a completely barren wasteland apart from a few scattered private survivors at this point.
- josephd79 4y agoIRC already has these features, if the USER wants them.