13 ms·
Why nobody ever wins the car at the mall (2018)
- quattrofan 4y ago
- 0xC0ncord 4y agoPrevious discussion (2018): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17392995 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17392995
- lostgame 4y ago“I understand my permission herein overrides my listing on any state of(sic) federal do not call list and any prior listing on the do not call lists of the companies listed above.” That’s disturbing. There is no way that’s possibly legally binding? Surely there can’t be a loophole this ridiculous in the Do Not Call law?
- MichaelBurge 4y agoIf it's legal, it seems like every business would do this. Your bank, the local McDonalds when you install their app, Uber & Lyft, every e-commerce site would bury in the terms & conditions, etc.
- alexb_ 4y agoYou really think that they aren't?
- Rebelgecko 4y agoYes. I've never gotten a phone call from McDonald's.
- alexb_ 4y agoOf course you've never gotten a phone call from McDonald's, but EVERYONE has gotten a scam phone call.
- Rebelgecko 4y agoI have, but I assume they were just wardialing. I don't think I've ever gotten a scam call where they actually knew my name or DOB or anything else that could be associated with the info I put into the McDonald's app (presumably that's what they would be selling... just the existence of a phone # isn't particularly interesting I'd guess)
- drdec 4y agoPlaces you do business with (like your bank) are already allowed to call you regardless of your Do Not Call registry status.
- IncRnd 4y agoIt is legal, and that is exactly what businesses do. The statement was just a notification. Any company you do business with and provide your info can contact you, because you overrode the DNC by giving out your contact information.
- joe_guy 4y agoBeing on the DNC making it so no business ever can call you is a monkey paw wish. Your bank is absolutely permitted to call you regardless of you being on the DNC. You have an existing business relationship with them.
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoWhoopsie you said yes once upon a time, looks like you've irrevocably consented to any and all futures interactions!
- Hnrobert42 4y agoIf there is no way to decline after viewing the terms, then it is not legal. It would be considered a contract of adhesion.
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoProblem is that you can decline after but if they've sold your data, now you have to chase down everyone in the chain afterwards.
- _ea1k 4y agoI’m pretty sure filling out a form with your phone number and a granted permission with that wording does override dnc lists, but you can reverse it again when they call.
- gnicholas 4y agoYou can reverse it for whatever subsidiary called you, but I doubt your opt-out will be shared with all of their affiliates.
- jcranmer 4y agoThe general rule of thumb is that consent to be called overrides the Do-Not-Call stuff. Although, that said, you also have to be able to later withdraw that consent, I believe (I know this is true as far as anti-spam laws go, but I'm not specifically familiar with the telephony rules).
- labster 4y agoWaiving rights is a normal part of American life.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- United857 4y agoIt's unbelievable that showing a car when it's not being awarded doesn't fall under any sort of false advertising law.
- JohnJamesRambo 4y agoThis is a car!
- kukx 4y agoYeah, like those ads with "I am a doctor and I recommend ...", where the speaker is just an actor.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- winternett 4y agoDon't worry, they've mostly moved on to selling crypto and NFTs for the most part... I haven't seen a car parked in my local mall for ages, there's a bitcoin ATM parked in that space now. There's a certain breed of huckster that even if they designated a prize winner, it would be one of their family members. The most important part of managing scams is to expose them, and cite the names involved so that they need to pick a different line of work.
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoWell that's just disappointing. There is no car and it's all just smoke and mirrors to subject you to things like a timeshare promo and harvest your data? That's not even a good scam! It's just like countless others. The only creativity is the car and its not even theirs its just a loaner from some random dealership.
- audozeawayy 4y agoI wonder how much money these scams net. Even if this outfit is fully owned and operated by a scuzzy timeshare company, do they really make enough money to justify the $1500/~=22 marks? The article only mentions people being contacted by the timeshare company, but I wonder if they might sell the info as a secondary revenue stream, especially given the waiver which claims to override federal do-not-call lists. How much would one packet of contact info+metadata sell for, if the subject has signed on to be contacted by advertisers?
- aninteger 4y ago> How much would one packet of contact info+metadata sell for, if the subject has signed on to be contacted by advertisers? LendingTree.com was charging $70 per "lead", this was 2018 or so, not sure how prices have changed since then. However this was on the high end, zillow.com, also sold leads but for quite a bit lower (although you got what you paid for).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- urbandw311er 4y agoThe 22 marks was in an hour and the $1.5k was rental for a whole day.
- audozeawayy 4y agoOh, I misread. Sounds like a good scam, if aninteger's $70/lead number is accurate.
- paulgb 4y ago> do they really make enough money to justify the $1500/~=22 marks I was wondering the same, but one thing that helps the math in their favor a bit was that the 22 was in one hour on a weekday afternoon. I imagine it’s higher on weekends and evenings.
- deleted 4y ago
- paulgb 4y agoHow did timeshares become so deeply associated with slimy sales tactics?
- Hnrobert42 4y agoI’m not sure, but here’s one more data point. I have some acquaintances in Vietnam who sell timeshares there. Their practices are equally shady.
- lisper 4y agoBecause the fundamental economics of time shares are a scam. They are pitched as "ownership" but what they really are are perpetual rental contracts with no way out. (The rent is called "maintenance fees" but it doesn't matter what label you attach to it. It's a sum of money that you are obligated to pay year after year after year. If it quacks like rent...) And you even have to pay a hefty sum up front for the privilege of being obligated to rent a place once a year forever.
- gruez 4y agoMost of what you've described can also be applied to condominiums. The only difference is that you can occupy them year round, but I don't think that's a relevant difference. Are the "fundamental economics" of those also "a scam"?
- moomoo11 4y agoI have no idea what a timeshare is (sorry) but aren’t condos something you fully own? Like some of my friends live in condos, some lived in a condo for a few years and then sold them before moving into a house or some other city. Where I live the condos are usually similar in appearance to apartments (bed bath living room kitchen all on same floor) and there are townhomes which are a bit fancier and you might get an attached garage.
- grzm 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeshare https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeshare > A timeshare (sometimes called vacation ownership) is a property with a divided form of ownership or use rights. These properties are typically resort condominium units, in which multiple parties hold rights to use the property, and each owner of the same accommodation is allotted their period of time. Units may be sold as a partial ownership, lease, or "right to use", in which case the latter holds no claim to ownership of the property. The ownership of timeshare programs is varied, and has been changing over the decades.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- philistine 4y agoPeople complain that Safari is a terrible web citizen. Here I go to this website, with Safari and my trusty ad blocker extension, and the page keeps reloading endlessly. Who’s to blame? The crappy website, Safari, or its extension?
- Angostura 4y agoWell,loading the page on Safari Mac with 1Blocker has no problems at all.
- armchairhacker 4y agopage keeps reloading likely means the webpage is crashing, which is Safari’s fault
- jeromegv 4y agoNo problem with Safari Version 15.5 (16613.2.7.1.9, 16613)
- egypturnash 4y agoIt's working fine on Safari (OSX) for me. Possibly with a different ad blocker.
- travisgriggs 4y agoIs this /s? I mean—-tongue in cheek—-are you trying to illustrate that Safari actually goes above and beyond here by looping infinitely on a page that is about a scam that is essentially about an ad technique that loops you endlessly?
- philistine 4y agoI had not thought of it that way !
- IncRnd 4y agoThe issue is somewhere in there. I loaded the site without JavaScript, and there were no issues.
- bink 4y agoThere are other equally shady fronts for this activity. I made the mistake of giving my name and number a person running one of those "raffles" at an NHL arena. I was deluged with time share spam calls for weeks afterwards. I should've known better as the team owner made his money marketing for AOL.
- c3534l 4y agoTimeshares are implicated in so many unethical scams and schemes that at this point I think we should just outlaw them entirely.
- quickthrower2 4y agoOr at least they should require US accredited investor as a minimum.
- everyone 4y agoI'm suprised they go to so much effort to get peoples info in 2022. Surely u can scrape as much of that as you want from social media or just buy it en-mass? Then u can spam people to your hearts content.
- xyst 4y agoI think the source of the information might be useful. If they truly think they are going to win a car, then the chances of a successful scam are higher. The more gullible. The more vulnerable. Thus an easier target. If you ever watch scam baiting videos, those Indian scammers share and sell the numbers the collect. If they can fall for the "Microsoft tech support" scam once, then they are likely to fall for the "Amazon refund" scam as well.
- sigstoat 4y agoif you’re still giving your contact info to folks giving away cars in 2022, you probably go on the list of suckers, which are more valuable.
- paulpauper 4y agoBuying leads is usually a waste of money. Fresh leads for easy marks is way better. Social media companies have really clamped down over the past 5 years on any form of contact info scraping
- IncRnd 4y agoThey are looking for qualified leads, 28 years or older, hopefully in a couple, mobile number, where you like to go on vacation, and what type of credit card(s) you own. Scraping social media will absolutely not generate leads that a salesperson can contact.
- projektfu 4y agoEspecially people who might think they can get vacations cheaper through one weird trick.
- rkagerer 4y agoHmm would it be wrong to fill the information in with the contact info of the local District Attorney?
- saghm 4y ago> Patrick collects a rolodex of her (fake) data — full name, age, marital status — then tells her she has to be at least 28 to enter the drawing. “Tell your parent to call me,” he says, and hangs up. > Her “dad” (our writer, Conor) gives it one last try. Patrick tells Conor that in order to win the car, he has to go to a local Great Destinations office and attend a 90-minute timeshare presentation. This is the only part I still don't understand after reading the article. Why do they limit this to people at least 28? Is this just a way of filtering out people unlikely to have enough money to scam into spending on a timeshare, or are they avoiding some esoteric regulation that somehow blocks them from marketing to younger people?
- Railsify 4y agoWouldn't people over 28 be more likely to have money for a timeshare?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- brailsafe 4y agoIn this economy!? Anecdotally, I had 20000x more money at 22 than 28. If I remain employed for the rest of the year I might be on par by the end of it. Graphing my income over the last 10 years would look like a memory leak
- fancy_hammer 4y agoHa, what did you do right or wrong to end up with declining income?
- atlasunshrugged 4y agoReally hope that they meant disposable income and they're just maxing out 401k contributions and have kids and the like!
- quickthrower2 4y ago> [You have to attend a] 90-minute timeshare presentation Yeah that fact is worse than there being no car.
- andrewstuart 4y agoA friend of the family recently won a million dollar house in the hospital raffle. It was a house on the Gold Coast in Queensland, which he immediately sold. I think he might also have won $20,000 of gold bullion in another hospital raffle. And off topic but my brother won a years supply of Kentucky Friend Chicken in the footy tipping..... and he is a vegetarian. Imagine that - you win the sacrifice of 365 chickens for your skill in picking footy teams. KFC gave him 50 x $50 vouchers. And I once spent two full days entering every possible online competition I could find. You can guess how much I won. Here is Australia in the 1980's it was common to find free competition tickets that you could enter in fish and chip shops. For a joke, a friend entered another friend, who won an all expenses paid trip for two to Europe, without knowing they had been entered. I personally during the source of my many years, have won precisely nothing ever.
- ungamedplayer 4y agoWhen you say 'footie' that makes me think you are Australian. "Raffles" in australia have very specific legal requirements.
- fy20 4y ago'Footie' is often used in the UK to refer to foo^H^H^Hsoccer.
- sejje 4y ago> Here is Australia in the 1980's I think it's safe to say he's in Australia.
- lizknope 4y agoHe also mentions Queensland
- InCityDreams 4y agoNo mention of spiders? I'm calling bs.
- thebeanogamer 4y ago
- ungamedplayer 4y agoWe all did buddy.. we all did.
- SilasX 4y agoKinda funny how that comment is flag-killed, but an equally unverifiable anecdote is the top comment on the previous discussion, and it claims the same thing: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17400832 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17400832
- ungamedplayer 4y agoThe hive mind is a fickle beast. I think that it needs to contribute to the narative for it not be flagged.
- Chris2048 4y agoPerhaps because one provides no further detail, or context to add relevance?
- SilasX 4y agoBut since it’s all unverifiable anyway, it’s really just fluff that it ads. Maybe if the poster had personal information in their profile…
- Chris2048 4y agoa lot of things are, I don't think it matters if it's verifiable true, it's a single n=1 anecdote anyway. The meaning comes from the reason it was mentioned, which I don't think is fluff.
- 4y ago
- shrubble 4y agoWonder if the company owned by David Siegal , profiled in the movie The Queen of Versailles, uses these leads? A fascinating movie... https://www.magpictures.com/thequeenofversailles/ https://www.magpictures.com/thequeenofversailles/
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- chiph 4y ago> There are other types of car giveaways run by more legitimate parties (charity raffles, event promotions) that do deliver the goods — but if you win, you’re liable to pay a hefty gift tax. I don't think it's a gift tax, but ordinary income tax. A coworker won a living room sofa set on a game show, and the staff were waiting with a 1099 for her as soon as she stepped off the stage. The IRS says you need to pay tax based on the fair market value, but the shows will list the prize at it's full retail price. So if you should happen to (and you won't) win the Acura, you'll owe 25% or more on it. Plus any state income tax. I'm not sure when the IRS actually wants their money, but a safe assumption would be "soon". Perhaps by the next quarterly estimated-tax date.
- ggm 4y agoIn Australia, the thing called an "art union" used to be how to raise money for charity, and the prize was often a home, and they really exist, and people did win and live in them, and some of them were classics of the low spot of the 60s and 70s, shag-pile carpet, sunken entertainment pit, volcano-stone fireplace... They still take place. I suspect the buildings have moved with the (architectural) times.
- michaelhoney 4y agoI think you mean the apogee of architectural refinement. I would love an entertainment pit.
- ggm 4y agohttps://www.imdb.com/title/tt5473090/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt5473090/ (swingin' safari: 2018) is a coming-of-age film set in Australia, which includes an exploding whale, Guy Pearce, Kylie Minogue, and a beautiful shag-pile den with sunken pit. It was shot on the GC.
- bombcar 4y agoIn the US there is (was) some way of using the home raffle thing to bypass capital gains tax but I’m unclear on the details.
- ezekiel11 4y agoreally hate these vulture like slime tactics to go after desperate and gullible people. it just brings tears to my eyes thinking of how shameless people are and how little they think about the after math of their actions. ex) crypto
- normac2 4y agoIt sounds like they're raking in a lot from this, so you'd kinda think they'd be best off actually giving away a car like, once every 5 years. To literally never give out the thing they're advertising seems like playing with fire. (The actual supposed big prize—after you jump through a lot of other hoops—is $100k, but same deal.)
- sys_64738 4y agoProblem is that upon winning then you’re liable for sales tax when you go to register at the DMV.
- nulbyte 4y agoHow does this work, given there is no sale? Sales tax applies to the sale price paid, but there is no payment. I think the same is true for use tax, too.
- sys_64738 4y agoJust like if somebody gifts you a car and you try to register. You need to pay the estimated value sales tax.
- nulbyte 4y agoI don't think this is universal among all states. After a quick search, I found sales tax does not apply to gifted vehicles in a number of states: Kentucky, Tennessee, New York, Minnesota (between immediate family members). In Texas, it's a $10 gift tax in lieu of sales tax.
- digitcatphd 4y ago> Then, they handed over her “prize:” a $25 restaurant voucher that required a $100 minimum spend to redeem. I really don't understand what people are complaining about, seems like a good deal to me...
- shon 4y agoI actually gave away a Porsche 911. This was not a mall giveaway but a marketing experiment for my new startup: Flat 6 Club. Yes, we wanted something in return, in this case, we wanted you to buy a t-shirt or start a subscription (merch+content+events), which gives us essentially all the same info, which would enter you in a sweepstakes to win the car. We also wanted to promote the club, which we did. We researched it and contracted a sweepstakes company who helped us run the sweepstakes legally. In the end, we gave away the car to a very nice man and his wife, who we flew in from Minnesota to San Diego for the giveaway event. Some people did think it was a scam. But there are several operations that actually do give cars away such a Omaze, Diesel Brothers and many more. There’s a model there based on the new post-search world we live in that has to do with high engagement increasing Return On Ad Spend and other AdTech voodoo. No doubt there are lots of scams but there are also real winners out there. We’ve only given away 1 car. We learned a ton. I decided to kill the monthly subscription after we gave away the car because we grossly underestimated the amount of up-front ad spend required to achieve a good ROAS and I knew we wouldn’t be giving away another car for a long time. The biggest surprise to me was hearing from people that were sad that we killed the paid membership/giveaway program. This was $9.11/mo for membership and occasional swag drops and automatic entry into our next giveaway —whenever that might be. I communicated personally with some of these folks. The gist of what I learned was that for $9.11/mo, people enjoyed the hope that they may one day win a 911. We literally had people beg us to bring it back. This is probably the same happiness that a lottery ticket brings to many people. It’s not really that they expect to win. As long as someone wins, they’re buying some hope, some excitement… a dream.
- TehCorwiz 4y agoIn a world where the deck is stacked against most people regardless whether they "do the right things" like go to college hope of a chance windfall may be the only way to reach beyond their economic situation. $9.11 saved per month isn't going to ever buy a car, but it might win one and that's an easy value proposition to some people.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jimjimjim 4y agothese people are scum. no that isn't too harsh. maybe it's not a detailed enough description? Is the world a better place without these sorts of people? probably.
- dengjiuhong 4y ago
- brightball 4y agoThat reminds me, did anybody win the Coinbase money from the Super Bowl ad?
- stevenjgarner 4y ago"Coinbase reportedly spent $14 million on a commercial with a flashing QR code that encouraged viewers to sign up for an account; new users will receive $15 in BTC until February 15. The strategy was so successful, in fact, that it caused the app to briefly crash during the Super Bowl broadcast." - https://www.vox.com/the-goods/22925225/super-bowl-ads-money-crypto-sports-betting https://www.vox.com/the-goods/22925225/super-bowl-ads-money-...
- brightball 4y agoI thought there was supposed to be $3 million in BTC split between 3 winners too?
- dhosek 4y agoWhen my wife and I first got married, we went to a timeshare promo (they promised a gas card and lunch for our time). I sat in the back of the presentation room with a complex analysis textbook working through some problems. The presenter saw me there, looked at what I was doing and sent us out of the room before I could damage his prospects. We did manage to talk a couple people out of buying during the free lunch (which was, as I recall, some kind of lame hamburgers and hotdogs).
- Joel_Mckay 4y agoWelcome to the ecosystem of lead-generation, and the specialized marketing campaigns which drive business sales. One of my earliest technical jobs was writing the middle-ware systems that handled lead data, and tracked the sales conversion rates of the companies we served. As an aside, it is the worst job I ever had in any of my careers… In general, you are never dealing with a single company: 1. An advertiser operating on Radio/TV/Web/Email to drive specific consumers to a company sales lead funnel 2. A marketer running a consumer data collection form (Web/1-800-Call-center/SMS/IVR) to sort which campaign is best suited for the potential consumers 3. A marketing data-broker cross-referencing and scrubbing user data to filter bogus/old/duplicate customer leads, and ascertain the time critical nature of which campaigns to deploy new leads into 4. A company sales campaign manager monitoring lead conversion rates between the data-broker and the company sales platform (often another web-form/call-center/IVR/spammer/SMS). In general, most professional firms will drop campaigns under a 17% success rate, but spammers are happy even under 0.056% terrible rates (where old lead data goes after everyone else gave it a hard pass). 5. A sales conversion success rate lead price adjustment by push back from the company campaign to the data-broker (higher % sales per lead pool mean higher prices). The data-broker also cross checks the conversion rate for a given lead pool, and will adjust the quality/price per lead by comparing many company campaigns to keep everyone honest. While many firms will honor a Do Not Call record flag by law, once a lead is in the ecosystem it can be resold to dozens of firms all over the world. It was also common for call-centers to leech call lists to resell to other data brokers, which would predictably have terrible conversion rates equivalent to spam email. I should probably mention the data-broker was also a social networking site owner, and this was the primary fiscal motivation behind running the platform. ;-)
- lelanthran 4y agoI do the same thing with every cold-call power-sales phone call I get. I try to keep them on the line as long as possible, while paying as little attention as possible. Put the phone on speaker, turn down the volume a little, and carry on working on my computer. I feel that the only way to end spam (email and phone), is to take up as much time of the spammer as possible. If all 25m recipients of an email scam replied with the intention to drag it out as long as possible, the scammer will never identify those who actually fell for it. If all 25m recipients of a phishing email responded with poisoned data, the target bank would quickly realise what was happening. If everyone who ever receives a spam phone call kept the person on for 30m instead of dismissing the call in 5s, it would be unprofitable to make these calls. In general, dropping the ROI on these techniques to negative would stop them.
- WesolyKubeczek 4y agoIn Slovakia, there was a sweepstakes of sorts (required some skills) where the main prize was a car. Which in fact turned out to be a loan of the said car for three months. On the other hand, my first laptop ever was a sweepstakes win in 2007. It wasn't a very good laptop, but it was an honest win.
- walrus01 4y agoIt seems like this could be weaponized if you filled out a lot of these with the names, emails, phone numbers and other details of people you particularly dislike. They'll never get out of those shady grey market crm systems..
- koolba 4y agoThis idea has existed for decades with magazine and tape/CD subscriptions. Bonus points were given if you picked hard core pornography or new age as the subscription of choice.
- walrus01 4y agoon the other hand, if you created a few hundred plausible but fake people and filled out many of these, you could collect an excellent data set of "shady grey market lead generation services that sell peoples' data in aggregate", for the purpose of examining what sort of emails and phone calls they make to the contacts, and then training an anti-spam / call-blocking data set on it.
- yayitswei 4y agoI have a friend who's actually won a car in a mall sweepstakes.
- theotherplanb 4y agoMe too! My friend's daughter had just turned 18, just got her driver's license, and was at the mall with a younger buddy. She entered and then cajoled her friend, who was ready to go, to wait for the drawing. She won a four-year lease on an Audi A4 and she loved every minute of driving it until the end of the term.
- ifelsethenyeah 4y ago1. Vehicle marketing and 2. personal information and demographics collection for resale preying on the magical thinking of people who play the lottery as wishful thinking in order to better their circumstances.
- 752963e64 4y ago" “[When I declined], they proceeded to tell our 12 year old daughter, ‘I guess your parents won’t take you on your dream vacation!’” she says. Then, they handed over her “prize:” a $25 restaurant voucher that required a $100 minimum spend to redeem. " Muricans are insane... Do this to me in françe I WRECK you in middle the mall in public taking some free palms in face :)
- fortran77 4y agoPeople should sue the car dealer and the mall. Even if they don’t have a leg to stand on, a few nuisance lawsuits would cause the mall not to want this business
- projektfu 4y agoWhat would you sue for? The time spent listening to the pitch? Your dashed hopes of owning a new car? What are the damages? This is why there's usually either a criminal fine for false advertising or a class action lawsuit. It's probably better to find someone at the California AG who's interested in shutting down false advertising.
- fortran77 4y agoYou would sue because there's a sign that says "win this car" and nobody will win that car. As I said, it will get thrown out, but if a few people would do that, it wouldn't be worth the mall's time to deal with them.
- hennell 4y agoI used to enter a lot of competitions in my Uni days. Won a few DVDs/CDs, a years worth of coffee, public WiFi for a year, a Sony laptop, an iPad mini and a trip to Florida with car hire and a meet an astronaut meal at Kennedy space center! I stopped entering comps though because it started to change from "give us your email for some marketing you can opt out of" to "enter with Facebook account where we can see everything about you and you have to share our post on your feed etc". Pretty sure the UK / EU is better on making sure prizes are what they say they are, but the small print on competitions has got so much worse.
- MrBuddyCasino 4y agoI was really wondering who the general manager at great destinations was, but his LI page seems to be inaccessible: https://www.linkedin.com/search/results/people/?currentCompany=%5B3967389%5D&sid=ZTj https://www.linkedin.com/search/results/people/?currentCompa...
- crikeyjoe 4y agoIt's about collecting data. But now we have other ways, don't we?
- rmeertens 4y agoA while ago I gave a presentation at the chaos computer conference looking into this topic for those spinners you encounter everywhere. Turns out, you can't win anything: https://youtu.be/DstR4mdG2MU https://youtu.be/DstR4mdG2MU
- lapser 4y agoI recall as a younger child (teens, in the early to mid 2000s) there were these websites that allowed you to get all kinds of free stuff as long as you gave them your details. I, as someone who had only just discovered the internet (i.e. clueless) after emigrating to the Netherlands only a few years earlier and being in a relatively poor household, decided it was the most awesomest thing. I was signing up for all of these websites. "Who cares!" I thought to myself. "What can they even do?! As long as I don't pay them anything it's fine!" I naively told my parents, who were just as naive around these issues. I got told off a few times, not because I was giving out my data to every company under the sun, but because random things were coming through the door. I remember once a prominent pet food company sent out a sample cat food package. I didn't even like cats. Pets were frowned upon in our culture. Needless to say, I'm some 15 years older now, and I regret every single form I was filling out back then. I realise that everything has vastly changed and systems change, but I can't help but feel somewhere some system still has my data, and it's only a matter of time before something wrong happens with it, if it hasn't already. This kind of thing probably targets similar households. Poor people who are generally uneducated on these matters. It's sad that such thing isn't outlawed.
- jeromegv 4y agoRealistically.. they have your name, date of birth, and where you lived as a kid. What's the worse that could happen? I don't think there's enough there to open a credit card under your name.
- vondro 4y agoGave me smile because I have a little anecdote that happened recently. My friend showed up for a B-day party, and after some time invited me and few other friends to have a look at his new car. I was thinking he must have gotten a raise at work, because the car was brand new Volvo V40, which is above average expensive in my country and also our income bracket. Then it turned out he bought a new collar for his dog, and that the producer of the collar organized a prize lottery, where you could win a really nice backpack, and a car. And that my friend won the main prize, which was the brand new Volvo. Now I know someone who won something really valuable, and also that these prize lotteries can sometime work.