8 ms·
The Bullshit Web (2018)
- esprehn 4y agoShould be tagged (2018)
- metadat 4y agoThanks, fixed.
- andrewvc 4y agoWhat’s the point of loading a page in 500ms if the real problem people are dealing with is a glut of content and fierce competition for our attention. I wonder if a slower web might be a better web in many ways. Reduced page load speeds increase engagement. What if I want to decrease engagement with the internet?
- AussieWog93 4y agoJust did a quick Google, looks like plugins for this exist on both Firefox and Chrome!
- shrimp_emoji 4y agoWhat if I want to shop for my groceries without waiting 10 seconds for Costco's app to load and then NOT have the "Grocery" button jump up half a page just as I'm about to tap it because a deals section below it just got finished dynamically loading?
- mistersquid 4y ago> What if I want to shop for my groceries without waiting 10 seconds for Costco's app to load and then NOT have the "Grocery" button jump up half a page just as I'm about to tap it because a deals section below it just got finished dynamically loading? Drive to Costco?
- shrimp_emoji 4y agoNever again.
- LinuxBender 4y agoThat's easy enough to simulate on Linux if you want to try. Replace eth0 with your wan interface. Re-paste the "del" lines to clear the added latency. If testing this on a remote host I would suggest adding a cron job to run the "del" lines every 10 minutes. I am typing this from memory so it may not work quite right. Use "tc -s -p qdisc" to get the packet statistics. All of these commands need to be run as root or with sudo. # outbound qdisc tc qdisc del dev eth0 root > /dev/null 2>&1 tc qdisc del dev eth0 ingress > /dev/null 2>&1 tc qdisc add dev eth0 root netem delay 250ms 20ms # inbound qdisc modprobe ifb numifbs=1 && ip link set dev ifb0 up tc qdisc del dev ifb0 root > /dev/null 2>&1 tc qdisc del dev ifb0 ingress > /dev/null 2>&1 tc qdisc add dev ifb0 root netem delay 250ms 20ms 250ms 20ms means add a latency of 250ms with a variability of 20ms. This test will break at some point but one could test the impact of this using a speed test [1][2] [1] - https://www.dslreports.com/speedtest# https://www.dslreports.com/speedtest# [2] - https://fast.com/ https://fast.com/
- thekingofrome 4y agoLoading a webpage slower isn't going to do anybody any good, especially not when someone is trying to complete important tasks. If someone wants to decrease engagement with the internet then they should use it less. If your problem is with the attention economy and media overload, then your problem is more likely with apps and sites that are specifically tailored to addict the user, rather than the fast speeds that admittedly enable them.
- gennarro 4y agoI don’t really understand the complaint. If you don’t like the CNN website, don’t go to CNN or use CNN lite, which has been well documented on HN. No one is forcing you to visit the site. Also, blocking webfonts is trivially easy at this stage so if you have specific complaints then you can take matters into your own hands with little more than a flip of a setting.
- thekingofrome 4y agoThe complaint is more about the general direction that the web is taking. It's all well and good saying "just don't use X website", but most news sites have plenty of features that are either annoying or outright disrespectful to the user. That aside though, somebody who likes articles published by CNN has good reason to complain, because the things they like are being filled with bloat/are annoying to access.
- sacrosanct 4y agoCNN has a ‘lite’ version: https://lite.cnn.com/en https://lite.cnn.com/en
- allarm 4y agoIdk, in my case I just stopped using web at all, with some exceptions like hn and some messengers. I’ve passed the point where I missed “the old web”, I don’t really care anymore. I’m back to reading books, that’s what I had been doing before the Internet, so that’s just getting back to roots. I don’t read news, I haven’t been using social networks for at least a decade, and I feel good. Modern web is a shit show I just can’t stand.
- remram 4y agoI don't understand the complaint. If you don't have a problem with the web or don't experience those problems, don't comment on this HN thread. No one is forcing you to like it or engage with this post.
- mynameishere 4y agoEverybody has to put something in their weekly report, and so the website gets a couple KBs larger every week.
- Cyberdog 4y agoIt's an old, old argument, but very true. My first Internet-capable computer had a 14.4k modem - that's a theoretical speed of 14,000 kilobits per second. But on the whole I don't really remember the web being slower or less usable than it is now, and that was before ad blockers were really a thing. And some of the technologies that we have now but not then could theoretically have made sites load even faster; PNG instead of GIF, MozJPEG compression for JPEGs, SVG for vector graphics, CSS for reducing repeated code and getting rid of table-based layouts, etc. But, obviously, the web hasn't gotten faster, because the increased bandwidth has been filled with increased nonsense, and browsers now download 2MB of nonsense to show a 200-character text post. It's this sort of nonsense that is partly the genesis for ideas like Gemini, a return to Gopher, or my own KyuWeb; limit the capabilities of the medium to vastly improve its speed and legibility. This sort of thing isn't exclusive to the web, either. Is an old late-'90s version of Microsoft Word that could run on a machine with 4MB of RAM really a thousand times better than one from today that requires 4GB? I really love the web, but sometimes it does piss me off a bit.
- tracerbulletx 4y agoI truly wish I had the data to back this up, but in my memory the web is WAY WAY faster than it was back then even with all of the extra "bullshit". I mean the images were like 16 colors and 200X300, and even just text based sites were slower and latency was worse too. Am I crazy here?
- 121789 4y agoYeah I agree. Lots more bloat now, but I'm not often waiting for images to render or sites to load in general
- gonehome 4y agoYeah - I think people forget, things were really slow back then.
- PaulKeeble 4y agoNo doubt the modern web is faster even on moderate xDSL connections. I remember web pages taking half a minute to load, even relatively basic ones. The 56k v90 was quite a bit quicker than 14.4k too. Its not even close to similar I remember watching JPG images gradually progress through their low quality versions upwards. Pages were a lot lighter back then but still much much slower than today.
- UIUC_06 4y agotl;dr which ironically is a good summary of all the bullshit on the Web. Ages ago, I got tired of having these discussions with a certain class of programmer: me: it really sucks that X does Y by default. certain class: yeah, it does, but there's a switch you can set to turn that off. me: I don't want to spend time learning how to configure X. certain class: (puzzlement)
- nocman 4y agoJust because someone suggests a way to work around a problem doesn't mean that they aren't also annoyed by the problem. There are some problems you do not have a viable way to attack at the root, and you just have to deal with them. Often other people control the thing you would have to change, and will not be persuaded to do it your way. I understand the desire to not have to learn something just to be able to remove an annoyance, but isn't having that option better than not being able to remove the annoyance at all?
- DonHopkins 4y agoThis is why 25 years ago in 1997 I proposed BSML: https://web.archive.org/web/19970113025507/http://www.art.net/studios/hackers/hopkins/Don/text/bsml.html https://web.archive.org/web/19970113025507/http://www.art.ne... And also AIML (Artificial Intelligence Marketing Language), an obvious application of BSML: https://web.archive.org/web/19970112152156/http://art.net/Studios/Hackers/Hopkins/Don/text/aiml.html https://web.archive.org/web/19970112152156/http://art.net/St... (Actually a parody of VRML, which I did by copying articles hyping VRML, and replacing VR with AI): https://web.archive.org/web/19970113025339/http://art.net/Studios/Hackers/Hopkins/Don/text/SupportForAIML.html https://web.archive.org/web/19970113025339/http://art.net/St...
- tannhaeuser 4y agoIronically, as I read TFA, that post about the newest React state mgmt fad appears just below it on the front page lol
- ineedasername 4y ago>A story at the Hill took over nine seconds to load The Hill is what finally pushed me to install an ad blocker. Before that it didn't bother me too much to get served ads etc that I filtered out of my awareness anyway, but The Hill was unusable. So, I installed an ad blocker and immediately realized how negligent I had been-- in terms of quality of web browsing experience-- in not doing so earlier. The Hill loaded near instantly. Massive improvements all around on other sites as well. As in the article, It felt similar to upgrading from dialup to a Cable modem. Unfortunately it seems sites have upped their game in adblocker arms races and the gains I achieved when I first installed it are incrementally being chipped away as things become ever so slightly slower, tick.. tick.. tick... tick... As time goes by. Suggestions? Is there something more I can do? Besides simply disabling JavaScript which breaks many site from usability.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoInstall the Steven Black hosts.txt or equivalent. Possibly tailor to your own needs (e.g. I allow Twitter, but absolutely no other social media site).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Cyberdog 4y agoFor what it's worth, AdGuard still seems to be holding its own against ad blocker blockers. Unlike other blockers, AdGuard is a paid service, but well worth it in my opinion and I'd recommend it in an instant. The only place where AdGuard has been failing recently is blocking Twitch ads, unfortunately.
- ineedasername 4y agoI really don't like paid services, not the cost but the mental friction and the fact that you can easily accumulate so many of them... Anyway, I'll at least check them out during the trial they offer to see how much of an improvement it is over UblockOrigin.
- tonymet 4y agoGoogle made a solid attempt at improving web performance and usability with AMP and offering preferred ranking - and hacker news mostly skewered them for it. Publishers need to be compelled to improve performance but the current model encourages bloat
- kristopolous 4y ago> solid attempt Nope. A compromised attempt. This is Google's problem; they smuggle in invasiveness and control in an attempt to conquer the web wearing a costume of benevolence and reasonability. It's cyber-imperialism. The professed virtues are honorable but they have to be instrumented without the power grab
- metadat 4y agoAmp is the worst, and now Google has reneged and rolled back on it, yet many sites still have it integrated because it's more work to undo all the work that's already been done to migrate to amp to begin with. A solid, first-class, grade-HIV+ clusterfuck.
- sacrosanct 4y agoWorth browsing the web with Lynx for a week just to see how convoluted the modern web has become. Roughly 10% of sites are viewable in Lynx and have a simple enough layout. Lynx due to it being text based also filters out all the AD-Tech, trackers, and JS bloat. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lynx_(web_browser) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lynx_(web_browser)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- javajosh 4y agoMaybe if you paid for your content it would suck less. The problem is no-one wants to pay for content, so they have to pay for it with ads, which means satisfying the true customer, the advertiser. Google tried, for a while, non-cruft ads, but eventually the demand for more sensational advertising is what drives most of this cruft. Another driver, which is something front-end devs can do something about, is to stop shipping 20MB bundles to the browser, stop using 10MB of fonts, and stop front-loading 200MB of images. Ignorant use of powerful tools that make adding more and more resources to your project feel basically free are a big contributor, at least in the webapp space. (Classic CMS software also accretes cruft, but generally more slowly over time.)
- mountainb 4y agoI pay for a lot of content nowadays, less and less of it on the web. I spend far less time on the web than I used to, and life has become better. The web is just not a very good medium in general and unfortunately the promise of web search has turned out to be just a chimera. Conventional methods of research or specialized search engines are more time efficient. The only thing the web is good for is cheap stimulation, and even for that it isn’t very good.
- mandmandam 4y ago> Maybe if you paid for your content it would suck less Haha, maybe, but I really don't think so. People pay for cable and still get ads; people pay for Netflix and still get ads, I still got ads when on Youtube Premium, etc. Even outside of media consumption, there are countless similar examples. Perhaps, if content was paid for in juicy frictionless micropayments, the bullshit web would suck less - for a time. But it would begin to suck more and more, until we have the same situation or worse (while still paying, more and more). The companies pumping out these trackers and selling our data couldn't care less whether people are subscribing to a service or not. They'll offer cash and buy our data until the day that shit is illegal.
- tunap 4y agoThe host of a podcast I enjoy held an AMA recently added an anecdote to your, and my, opinion. While He readily appreciated the Patreon subscribers & tailored special features for their contributions, he admitted the funds from the subscribers were eclipsed by several(?) factors by the ad revenues.
- nickdothutton 4y agoMy first modem was a 2400bps MNP5, before the revelation that was the 14.4 HST (sysop discount, naturally). I first used the Internet in the early 90s, “pre-Netscape” and for a couple of years even “pre-Mosaic”. Precisely because so few people had good connections, web site owners were economical with their use of images, and information was structured so that it loaded quickly. Presentation took a back-seat to accessibility.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dang 4y agoDiscussed at the time: The Bullshit Web - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17655089 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17655089 - July 2018 (550 comments)
- pluijzer 4y agoFor me the web, granted with an ad blocker, nowadays feels snappy. Some pages are indeed bloated but ironically these sites are more often than not the types with nothing but regurgitated blog spam. Even with my first broadband connection I remember the web to be a lot slower in the past. Actually sitting and waiting for images to be loaded in line by line for example. I do agree that webpages could go on a diet making our current situation even better I do believe the feeling of a faster web is an false memory out of a nostalgia of a simpler time.
- tomrod 4y agoWhat a great article. I wish I had a scalpel I could use to cut away the webcruft that comes from every direction. Setting up a pihole and turning off JS can help, I reckon, but there is still tons of cruft that simply doesn't belong.
- wildrhythms 4y agoI wish browsers universally established a hard resource budget for webpages. Cap it at 2MB runtime memory usage and let's see what happens.
- dredmorbius 4y agoThis. Unless limits are imposed, page size will increase without limit. It's a Jevons Paradox / Parkinson's Law phenomenon.
- aimor 4y agoIt doesn't stop there. There's still no good way to validate information on the internet. The internet, much like the real world, is full of untrue information, bad advice, and outright lies. Things that don't overcome this: Trusted experts, Wikipedia type citations, comment sections. Of those I think comment sections are the closest to being successful because they at least provide an open platform to raise doubt about any info.
- ocdtrekkie 4y agoA lot of similarity here to roads: The more lanes you add, the more cars drive on that road, but it never gets faster to drive on.
- tijuco 4y agoVery good reading. I always say that when people say "hey, remember when we had 10G hard drives. They were so small". People don't realize that today we have bigger drives but we also have bigger files. Of course our pictures today have better quality, but proportionately we have similar storage capacity as we had in the early 2000's
- moffkalast 4y agoThat's true of course to some extent, but I don't think the trend will continue on quite as drastically. Like sure, you have games nowadays like RDR2, CoD, that have inflated to absurd file sizes of up to like 200 GB, compared to only a few gigs for AAA games maybe 10 years ago, but you also for examplehave more powerful hardware and more advanced compression like x265 which can store vastly more video in a lot less space than it was ever possible before since it can be decoded and unpacked in real time. It used to take 4.7 GB of a DVD to hold a single movie at an abysmal 480p resolution, whereas nowadays you can pack a full HD one in easily a quarter of that size. I'm sure this will get even more extreme as processing power increases.
- gusbremm 4y agoBack in 2008 I was doing a lot of flash banners. Some clients would request the swf file to be as small as 9kb for a multi-scene banner.. It was a pain in the ass but we managed it most of the time with no design changes. We would spend a lot of time tunning image compression params to get the smallest swf possible. Sometimes the image quality would get awful. Today, my clients just don't care at all if the frontpage is 10MB as long they can have a multi banner hero with a video running in the background. Side note: I worked on a chatbot widget project where the tech PO was pushing us to move from react to preact to save 8kb on a 60kb script. I said, why bother? There is a 1.2MB image on the front page. Just give me access to the front page assets and I can save 800kb alone on that image.
- wildrhythms 4y agoHow the hell have we managed to relegate every step of our application design and decisionmaking to people whose technical expertise starts and stops at "it works on my machine" ... we are doomed
- everyone 4y agoI think engineers can sometimes become hyper-focused on a single metric eg. speed. A webpage in 1992 or today just needs to load fast enough. Theres a whole rake of other factors that may be more important than speed.
- anovikov 4y agoHow will the web make money if all this "bullshit" stuff is removed? Unless you put all of it behind a paywall (which may be not a bad idea, in fact i'm waiting for a startup that will provide a "paywall to everything" service which you can plug your site in and get a cut)
- marttt 4y agoSame here, kind of. I'm reading this thread in Linux framebuffer mode and w3m, a text-mode browser. You can see images with this setup, but only by hovering a particular image link and launching an external viewer. This has been my main computing setup for about half a year now, and it works surprisingly well (I'm neither a coder nor a web dev, though). Majority of the sites I visit are definitely bearable in text-only mode. It's a flexible setup, too, since I can seee the images if I need to. For more inspiration, see Ali G Rudi's framebuffer tools [1] and a great site on w3m [2]. 1: https://litcave.rudi.ir https://litcave.rudi.ir 2: http://w3m.rocks http://w3m.rocks
- vmoore 4y agoAside from bullshit, a few other adjectives could be used to describe the modern web: - Obtrusive - Bloated - Unnecessary - Distracting - Orwellian - Pushy - Intrusive - Resource intensive - Bandwidth intensive - Tacky - Hyped up
- ksec 4y agoIt is sad I thought this was submitted on HN not that long ago, but it turns out COVID somehow makes 4 years of life span felt like a year. The summary of my comment from previous discussions remains the same. >My biggest problem is with the idea of extending the Web via Javascript and everything should be Javascript only. Rather than extending the Web Browser native function. But no one wants to tackle this problem. Google isn't interested, Mozilla were the first to want everything on the web to be Javascript. Apple wants everything to be an App. Even the Government wants everything to be an App so they could police Apple and Google only. The web is dying not because it cant be made better or competitions are driving them out. It is dying because no one in power gives a fuck about it.
- milky2028 4y agoA point made before, a little whinier this time. What are you doing about it?
- mgraczyk 4y agoThe web is only bullshit if you use bullshit websites. I get nearly all my news from wikipedia or twitter. Neither of them take more than 1s to load for me.