14 ms·
Detecting unauthorized physical access with beans, lentils and colored rice (2021)
- csours 4y agoIf preventing covert entry and modification is important to you, consider this unpickable lock to go with your tamper evident glitter https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31880108 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31880108
- nl 4y agoI think this is an interesting but my immediate question is how much are the color matrices affected by normal shipping? If your intention is to be able to detect tampering during shipping but shipping always causes some disturbance then it probably deserves some discussion?
- ars 4y agoIf I were tasked with dealing with this I would disturb the rice every single shipment, and then let the item continue to its destination. When every single shipment shows sign of tampering I would expect them to give up on this method.
- kragen 4y agoThe shippers would probably find a different way to ship things.
- ungamedplayer 4y agoNegative, do not change. While you are incurring a cost to the attacker keep it as is. Ship nulls regularly AND find another method.
- daenz 4y agoIf you were disturbing every single shipment, I would assume someone was tampering. Once I find a shipping route where none of the items were disturbed, I would know it is secure.
- 8organicbits 4y agoRight, if you are worried about covert tampering and every shipment shows up tampered, you have proven that someone along the shipping route is tampering. You react by distrusting any packages that were previously shipped without anti-tamper protection. And you find a different shipping route. This is costly, but it's a reaction to a threat you can prove to be targeting you. The tamperer is probably better off not tampering with packages, unless they can do so in a plausibly deniable way.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- walterbell 4y ago> I would disturb the rice every single shipment Increasing attacker costs = success.
- pmoriarty 4y agoIt would also increase defender costs, if the defender has to throw out our re-ship some perfectly good hardware every time some of the rice it was packed in was disturbed.
- walterbell 4y agoDecoys are a tried and true response to surveillance, with decades if not centuries of best practices.
- batch12 4y agoI believe they attempted to address this via vacuum sealing and cascading bags (if I understood the article).
- layer8 4y agoThe vacuum packing is tight enough to prevent any significant motion.
- nl 4y agoIs it? I'm doubtful. I regularly vacuum pack clothing when I travel and things move enough to change creases even in my carry-on luggage. I'm skeptical that it won't be disturbed in regular shipping unless specific measures are taken.
- layer8 4y agoI used to buy vacuum packed peanuts, there was practically zero chance that they would move around. I also remember that when vacuum packing beddings the result was hard like a brick.
- lysium 4y agoThe authors should test if this is actually the case or not.
- zxexz 4y agoI think it would be fun to test this with a few people. Let’s vacuum pack some beans and ship them between each other. Sisterhood of the Shipped Legumes. Email in profile.
- jerzyt 4y agoI can confirm it. I have a commercial vacuum packing machine, and a bag of rice sealed in it becomes a brick. You can't displace a grain of rice without damaging the vacuum. I doubt that a laptop inside this bag would survive it.
- 8organicbits 4y agoA commercial vacuum packing machine may be stronger than a normal home vacuum cleaner, which the article mentions. Fewer people have access to a commercial machine.
- cowvin 4y agoExactly. I would imagine any sort of substantial impact (common in shipping) would shift around some of the pieces.
- p1necone 4y agoVacuum packing small grain-like things like coffee beans/grounds or rice creates a surprisingly sturdy result. I'd be surprised if you could actually move much around without also piercing the plastic. I've bought products packaged like this before and it's a really odd sensation feeling the bag go from effectively a single solid object to a bag of mush as soon as you release the vacuum.
- Xylakant 4y agoThis effect is used in adjustable casts (these modern plastic ones that you get when you break your foot) and vacuum stretchers for people with a suspected spine injury(+). They’re essentially a bag filled with tiny foam pellets that adjusts to your foot/body shape and turn rock solid once you pump out the air. (+) https://www.rusunsafety.com/VacuumMattressStretcher/ https://www.rusunsafety.com/VacuumMattressStretcher/
- dredmorbius 4y agoI'd run across a demonstration of this somewhat recently. I believe it was a video explaining transitions between free-flowing and locked particles, though I don't recall specifically where, and was unable to find it looking for a few minutes just now. That said: yes, vacuum-sealing good such as beans or coffee grounds provides a surprisingly solid chunk. Releasing the vacuum instantly changes the properties of the mass.
- ars 4y agoI wonder if it would be possible to fill the bag with CO2 and then freeze it, so nothing moves. (Use two tiny needles, and carefully inject CO2 on one side and remove the air from the other.) Then open it inside of a room kept at dry ice temperatures, do what's needed, and then put everything back. Let the dry ice sublimate (slowly so nothing moves) and resume the shipment.
- walterbell 4y agoCold (un)pack.
- jfim 4y agoConsidering dry ice sublimates at -78°C, this is likely to cause cracks or other damage to the equipment being shipped.
- dane-pgp 4y ago> Use two tiny needles I'm wondering if it would be possible to manufacture some sort of clear plastic sandwich-like material that contains two separate chemical "fillings", kept apart by a central barrier which, if punctured, would allow the chemicals to mix together, triggering a colour-changing chemical reaction. I guess the problem would be wrapping the target object in a way that couldn't just be unwrapped afterwards, but maybe a glue could be used which creates a chemical bond that is tamper-evident.
- hyperdimension 4y agoThat's basically how Polaroid pictures work(ed). The developer/fixer was in the bottom edge, and this container was punctured and the chemicals squeezed out by the rollers as it came out. The only thing left would be to distribute it along the back of the photograph, so you, you know, shake it.
- 2bitencryption 4y agofascinating. exactly the type of content I love about Hacker News.
- hackernewds 4y agoabsolutely stunning research and commitment to publishing a free article
- owenfi 4y agoMy wife (shameless plug: https://messyplaykits.com https://messyplaykits.com) recommends liquid water colors instead of food coloring (cheaper and better color). Colorations brand from discount school supply or amazon works well for her and she makes a lot of colorful rice!
- arthurcolle 4y agoThis is a cool site. Definitely bringing back memories of playing with arts & crafts kits in kindergarten lol
- harrisi 4y agoIf I may ask, how successful is this? I feel like this is in a similar space to kiwico (not exactly, but it's similar enough I imagine both that they could quickly take over, and the average person is probably more aware of kiwico even if it's not the same offering(s)). I have had an idea for awhile that's also somewhat similar to kiwico's model, although different enough I'm still tempted to pursue it, and this is the first comparable company other than some popular YouTube channels that I've found. Has your wife had any discussion with kiwico? Is kiwico a threat to success? Are there noticeable advantages/disadvantages to subscription vs á la carte sales?
- owenfi 4y agoIt’s a small home based business, but that’s allowed her to keep control and grow sustainably-I’m not quitting my tech job any time soon, but we are also expecting our first baby in October so might look into more effort on advertising once we know how much growth we can handle. Definitely very similar to kiwico, no direct conversations, not that worried as there is a fair amount of overlap as well as differences. She’s done lots of approaches over the years (eg selling at festivals pre-Covid) and life is a lot easier now that the focus is mainly subscriptions. Phone number is on the site and she says she’d be happy to chat if you want to give a call.
- fhsm 4y agoThanks for plugging. I wish I had known about this during the various lockdowns of the past 2 years. It never occurred to me to look. (Aside ... reflective moment on the possible value of ads and failure of ad tech) It's great to see someone packaging what look like Reggio style provocations. I hope she is as successful (or more) as Love Every has been with aesthetic Montessori objects.
- javajosh 4y agoLove these kinds of problems. I've always felt for very critical equipment you'd be better off designing a PCB to be physically cracked in two, such that you need both specific halves for it to operate at all, and then ship each half separately. E.g. the electronics version of tearing a dollar bill in half and matching the two halves to verify the identity of the holder (something I've seen in spy movies). You'd probably want to make sure the recipient got the first part before shipping the second, just to make sure.
- dlgeek 4y agoWouldn't help if the chips on the PCB could be replaced.
- poyu 4y agoAll modern credit card terminals have this built in. It has a mainboard/sub-board design. In case one or more contacts has been apart, the contents (assuming some kind of keys) on the sub-board are erased, something like a SRAM. Downside is it needs constant power source to keep the content, thus a rechargeable cell is on the board.
- wildzzz 4y agoCrypto devices used by the government and military have this same sort of tamper identification design. I've seen limit switches hidden behind the front lip of a server so if you pull it out, it triggers the tamper alarm. There are also panels with multiple switches behind so if the panel is opened, alarm triggers. There's layered mesh inside the walls of the devices that will trip the alarm if the layers touch (like with a drill) or if the voltage going through the mesh layer changes (like if you cut through it). Once any seals are broken, the keys inside are wiped and the device is possibly bricked if it really was never meant to be opened. Additionally, screws are JB welded in place so only way you can get in is to either go through the access panel or drill a hole. These things are tempest rated so no one is getting in and nothing is coming out, unless of course you manage to hack it without ever touching it.
- noodlesUK 4y agoIf I were actually going to use a method like this in real life especially for international shipping etc, I’d probably avoid using rice or beans or other plant material to avoid unnecessary inspections at customs. I feel like this would definitely get stopped and inspected, where a block of multicoloured plastic or resin might not be.
- akehrer 4y agoMaybe use injection mold resin pellets instead. They’re not as convenient as rice or lentils, but there are a lot of color choices.
- jschulenklopper 4y agoI'd think that a block of resin would be equally suspicious, warranting an inspection immediately, but IANACBPO. Otherwise, a block of (say) white icing sugar, encapsulated in a block of (opaque) resin, would pass a machine inspection and icing sugar-sniffing dogs at the border... and a lot of icing sugar would enter the country in a resin mold.
- ezoe 4y agoI guess the point is detecting the inspection, not avoiding it.
- dredmorbius 4y agoThere are customs regulations against importing foodstuffs in many areas. For international travel or shipping, this might prove problematic on those grounds. Rice, for example, is not allowed or might require specific permission to import into Australia. Coffee, noodles, pasta, pepper, and wheat might be restricted. https://www.abf.gov.au/entering-and-leaving-australia/can-you-bring-it-in/categories/food https://www.abf.gov.au/entering-and-leaving-australia/can-yo...
- advisedwang 4y agoIf you are just getting package disturbed 100% of the time by TSA, that makes it useless to detect whether or not somebody else also tampers with it.
- walterbell 4y agoIf buying tamper-tempting devices online (e.g. powered USB/Thunderbolt docks with access to keyboard/mouse/video), you can order several devices from multiple vendors and look for unexpected delays or routes in shipment progress. Requires some experiments to determine baseline "normal" routes and latency. For post-delivery tamper deterrence, ship via package receiver and audit home door/window locks, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31856444 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31856444
- varenc 4y agoIf you’re worried about package interception I’d recommend just trying to buy your electronics at a local retailer. Decide which one you’re going to right as you walk out the door so there’s no reasonable way someone can even predict where you’re going. Though if that’s a legitimate part of your threat model, you’re in a very difficult situation.
- walterbell 4y agoWFH has likely expanded the number of developers subject to such threats, e.g. those whose enterprise device access-from-home can be leveraged to compromise software supply chains.
- lawl 4y ago> Though if that’s a legitimate part of your threat model, you’re in a very difficult situation. Its probably (close to) impossible to establish a trust anchor in that situation. That trust anchor being the untampered image. How do you secure that? Yes you can send it to trusted friends, but at that point that just means they're now fair game too. Its definitely not safe on your phone because 0days now definitely are part of your threat model too. I think maybe if you make it your full time job, you might have a slim chance. But realistically you'd probably only manage that for a limited time.
- QuadmasterXLII 4y agopolaroid?
- happyopossum 4y agoI wouldn’t want to rely on the vacuum bag method, otherwise you’d be writing off otherwise good devices regularly due to random failure, bag punctures, etc.
- marcosdumay 4y agoThose photos on the article, it's hard to imagine something changing the patterns on those bags not being strong enough to destroy the item inside too. Puncturing those things is quite hard too.
- pmoriarty 4y agoIf punctures were a concern, you could seal the inner tamper-evident, vacuum-sealed bag in a second, outer bag (with more rice and beans or perhaps colored styrofoam peanuts if you wanted). This process could be repeated as many times as you wanted, adding extra layers until the desired level of protection was achieved. Another approach would be to encase the tamper-evident packaging in wood or metal before putting it in a shipping container.
- voxadam 4y agoIsn't this pretty much exactly what the 'Cascading' section of the post already, at least partially, addresses?
- jacobsenscott 4y agoThis is cool, but a manufacturer isn't going to vacuum pack your router with rice and beans. So how do you know the thing you are packaging up before sending to someone else wasn't already intercepted before you received it?
- walterbell 4y agoPurism charges $300 for their service of tamper-discouraging shipment of a laptop, in an industry where profit margins are historically very low, https://www.cnx-software.com/2020/05/21/purism-anti-interdiction-services-popular/ https://www.cnx-software.com/2020/05/21/purism-anti-interdic... Other manufacturers may be interested in increasing their slim profit margins via optional packaging services.
- leetbulb 4y agoAt a certain scale, sure, some will, or they'll work with you to setup your own integration process.
- leetbulb 4y agoThis is one of the coolest anti-tamper mechanisms imho: https://spectrum.ieee.org/the-unhackable-envelope https://spectrum.ieee.org/the-unhackable-envelope TLDR: HSM housed within an envelope composed of layered electrodes having a unique capacitive signature used to derive its secret material.
- ntbnt 4y agoWow that is super cool! What an elegant solution.
- walterbell 4y agoSimilar work from another German team. https://www.hardwear.io/netherlands-2019/presentation/Enclosure-PUF-hardwear-io-nl-2019.pdf https://www.hardwear.io/netherlands-2019/presentation/Enclos... https://media.ccc.de/v/35c3-9611-enclosure-puf https://media.ccc.de/v/35c3-9611-enclosure-puf > verifying the authenticity, integrity and/or the physical state of an item by employing the propagation behaviour of electromagnetic waves. In particular, it enables to check for any tamper attempts for larger structures, such as off-the-shelf computers and their periphery. The technology extends existing tamper proof approaches from the chip/PCB to a system level and is easily retrofittable. In this presentation, we are demonstrating exemplary tamper proofing in order to protect secret information without an attack-detection or data-deletion circuit (!), which is a known difficult problem and an imperfect undertaking. Therefore, we demonstrate the simplicity and effectiveness using a very cheap self-made testbed (using alumium foil) to protect standard hardware against invasive attacks, such as needle probing through the case. Cyber-physical systems are ubiquitous and are often located in non-trustworthy environments, in which data is processed that is both sensitive and worth protecting.
- tyingq 4y agoThat is really cool. I'm surprised, though, something at the femtofarad level doesn't suffer from big swings in behavior/signature based on ambient temperature, moisture, general surroundings, and so on.
- amelius 4y ago
- thematrixturtle 4y agoAm I the only one who's totally unable to spot the apparently-obvious difference in the comparison photo GIF at the end?
- HanClinto 4y agoUsed SIFT and OpenCV to align the images a bit better: https://imgur.com/a/vGORFxX https://imgur.com/a/vGORFxX
- xarope 4y agoLook at around 8.45-9pm (clock dial direction) in the photo, you should see it readily now.
- moioci 4y agoLook at about 8 o'clock roughly 2/3 of the way from the center to the edge.
- teraflop 4y agoIt's not as obvious as it could be, because the images were taken from slightly different angles and with slightly different exposure settings, causing a lot of visual distraction. I was able to clean up the animation a little bit: https://i.imgur.com/cgKSA7H.gif https://i.imgur.com/cgKSA7H.gif
- jerzyt 4y agoI'm with you - I noticed that little pac-man, but it's not an optimal way to see the difference. Seems like scaling both images and doing an image diff would be much more effective. That's a standard tool in semiconductor manufacturing.
- eternauta3k 4y agoMaybe even do a perspective transformation + brightness/contrast/hue adjustment and optimize for the parameters which minimize the image difference.
- Someone 4y ago
- mNovak 4y agoWould be interesting to use black and white rice, then convince your phone to read it as a QR code. That'd vastly simplify the before/after comparison.
- NobodyNada 4y ago> An alternative to sealing is embedding the whole object in a substance whose surface forms a mosaic that is difficult to reproduce and changes when manipulated. The problem with a QR code is the “difficult to reproduce” part —- if you can organize the rice in such a way that it’s recognized as a valid QR code, surely the attacker can recreate the same QR code (or an equivalent, since QR codes have redundancy/ECC).
- rhplus 4y agoRather than vacuum pack, embedding the device in an expanding foam (mixed with one of these embedded signatures) would serve dual purpose of anti tampering and anti shock.
- mc32 4y agoThis seems pretty good if you can randomly embed these signature materials as it expands and then have a record of how they are dispersed in 3D. It’d be hard to duplicate unless the packing foam is repairable and does not leave a trace of reparation if any occurred.
- dredmorbius 4y agoThe pattern can be applied to (and sealed onto) the foam after-the-fact. That said, the loose-bagged option is reusable. Sealed foam would be an option for initial shipment. The loose-bagged option is more effective against Evil Maid attackes --- frequent periods in which devices or records are left unobserved.
- wgrover 4y agoLovely work. Here's a similar project where I showed that randomly-placed multicolored candy particles (nonpareils) can be used to confirm the authenticity of pharmaceuticals: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-022-11234-4 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-022-11234-4
- seventytwo 4y agoVery cool work! Speckles could be added to the pill itself to eliminate the possibility of shipping damage, though it was good to see you tested that. I know explosives are often laced with statistical chemical properties that identify them. I was wondering if that could be done to limit ammunition purchases as a way to get around gun control.
- jarenmf 4y agoThat's really a cool study! Do you think this will be adopted at some point? are there currently any efforts to solve this problem?
- Crespyl 4y agoThank you for sharing that, I really enjoyed reading your work, it looked like a fun project. In addition to authentication, I imagine they could also be used to double-check expiration dates or as a last-ditch effort to notify consumers in the event of a recall. Being able to precisely identify exactly which factory and batch any given pill or other edible item came from could be very useful in some cases.
- tgbugs 4y agoAs a giant identifier nerd, this is incredibly cool. Any insights/thoughts on tamper resistance/non-duplication? I realize that this is a bit outside the original use case/threat model, but would it be possible to ensure that any physical injury to the coating would ensure that the code would no longer match? Seems like a challenge because you want robust matching but not robust enough to allow someone to substitute or reproduce the exact pattern. I'm fairly certain that this cannot defend against a determined adversary buying up a bunch of pills, reading out the ids, and then reproducing the patterns (which would already be in the database) or similar enough patterns via a non-random process. Only useful for substitution attacks where someone trusts a pill because it is in a database without realizing that its contents could have been substituted for e.g. poison. This may be obvious, but it also seems critical for any database that might use these to have expiration dates, otherwise expired pills could be bought in bulk and resold or have their codes reused.
- ta988 4y agoAccess to cheap x-ray sensors would be great.
- FateOfNations 4y agoThe sensors aren't the issue, it's the X-ray generator that's needed to create the patterns for the sensor to detect.
- ta988 4y agoLooks like you can find $600 dental x-ray machines (probably low quality but that's a low price too) on eBay (source+sensor). That would do a great device for small electronics (assuming you know how to shield, don't be that guy)
- praptak 4y agoCan't find the article but I read that during the cold war US used translucent resin with pieces of aluminium foil to seal high-security rooms, with multiple photos from different angles to capture the 3d arrangement of the foil. A similar technique exists for non-replicable unique tokens. The token is multiple translucent microspheres pressed together and its authenticity verified by shining a laser on it from different directions and capturing the output.
- intended 4y agoInstead of blink comparison, look at the image the same way you do for stereoscopic images. The difference pop up immediately.
- toast0 4y ago> Instead of blink comparison, look at the image the same way you do for stereoscopic images. Stare at it for a while, and the sigh frustrated and say whatever, it's the same? Clearly you had more luck with magic eye than I did.
- dredmorbius 4y agoYes and no. The cross-eyed (or wide-eyed) option tends to reveal visual discontinuities. Our eyes / visual cortex may register this but it's somewhat inconsistent. The blink comparison shows an apparent motion, which is a signal our eyes are primed to detect. I use both methods myself, and find the blink option is far more reliable.
- zeristor 4y agoAt primary school we had a lid as a desk, and I used to place rulers and a protractor in a certain combination that would be dislodged if open. OK it could probably be reproduced, and I don’t think I recorded what the position was, but I was only 10 at the time.
- xpe 4y agoSounds like a fun 3D bin-packing algorithm.
- fit2rule 4y ago
- pressurefree 4y ago
- tgbugs 4y agoI wonder whether it would be possible to use isotopic ratios of gases in negative pressure containers or something like that to ensure that any puncture will disrupt the mixture before it can be measured. Hardly foolproof, but anything that an adversary can measure you have to assume that they can reproduce unless you have some way to prove that the process required to reproduce that physical state _must_ take longer than the transit duration. The other thing that comes to mind would be quantum systems that can only be measured once. Unfortunately I think that practically you would need a system that is "only twice" so that it can be compared, but I have this sense that anything that can be measured twice can be measured 3 times. Lots of great links here to people working on practical solutions, but in the limit I wonder whether for many of the "black box in enemy territory" models you just have to go with self destruction as the only safe solution because anything less than a fully trusted human being is at risk for being tampered and pwnd (and even then you might still worry).
- codesections 4y ago> The other thing that comes to mind would be quantum systems that can only be measured once. Unfortunately I think that practically you would need a system that is "only twice" so that it can be compared, but I have this sense that anything that can be measured twice can be measured 3 times. Just spitballing, but you could do it with a "once only" system if you could generate it reliabilly/deterministically enough that you don't need to measure it post-generation
- tgbugs 4y agoThis thought crossed my mind, but I couldn't figure out quite how to get it to work. I think the fundamental flaw with using a deterministic process to create the state is that an adversary can immediately reproduce a matching system if they make the measurement, and then we are back to needing a deterministic process that takes longer to occur than transit time. After a bit of tangentially related thinking (see below), here is one possible way, and why I don't think it works. One could deterministically create a metastable state in a quantum system, e.g. by pumping a certain specific amount of energy into it. Then to figure out how much energy there was present, any additional amount of energy from by the measurement would cause the state to collapse. Unfortunately having the measured value in hand an adversary could now reproduce that state because the original process is deterministic. For example, a classic "easy to produce hard(er) to measure" is creating aqueous solutions, where a bunch of different solutes are mixed together (I always think of ACSF, artificial cerebrospinal fluid, because I used to have to make it all the time). The creation of these can be entirely deterministic. Unfortunately all you need is a good analytical chemist to get an approximation. Even if you used specific ratios of different isotopically pure salts they could probably reproduce it, and you would want something that would cause an irreversible change on physical tampering, such as an oxidation, cleaving, or isomerization so that you couldn't just dump the contents and put them back. All of these are tactics that delay an adversary by presenting them with a measurement and combinatorial problem, but doesn't provide the "measure once" property we need.
- amelius 4y agoWrap your box with thin copper wire (e.g. as used in transformers). Add tape over the wire. Use a circuit that monitors the resistance of the wire.
- CodeBeater 4y agoThat's so simple that it could actually become a product.
- 4gotunameagain 4y agogreat idea. Transformer wire has an enamel coating, so for a resistance based system it wouldn't work. Also I wonder what effect will corrosion/shock have on the resistance ? Maybe an impedance or inductance based system with enameled wire would be more robust. So many questions, interesting :)
- grapeskin 4y agoJust the wording makes it seem like something TSA would be glad to see as a bomb.
- elzbardico 4y agoReading it put me on some Persons of Interest list from the TSA.
- xpe 4y agoYes, also make sure the wires are visible and suspicious looking. For extra credit, include some mysterious oozing stuff so it looks like battery acid is leaking.
- BrandoElFollito 4y agoWhen flying I often lock my suitcase with a zip (the plastic strip you buckle up on its own, works one way). I got red and green zips because they are less common. I do this to detect obvious attempts at opening the suitcase (to have a look what is inside, or to plant nuclear weapons for me to transport them). When the suitcase is on the reception belt, I inspect the zips and if they are broken (or missing) i immediately go to the police/customs agents for them to inspect my suitcase because I see it was tempered with. It happened twice that the zips were missing. There was no problem for the agents to inspect my luggage. Nothing was found or missing, the zips were probably broken during transport (or someone had a look inside but did not find anything interesting.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- capableweb 4y ago> with a zip (the plastic strip you buckle up on its own, works one way) Just in case you didn't know, unless you buy ones that are specifically hard to open (like if you instead use ones from a random hardware store), they are trivial to open without breaking it by lifting the flap inside the lock-mechanism with something thin and sharp, roll it back out and inserting it again once you've done your deed.
- BrandoElFollito 4y agoI used the ones that are specifically hard to open (you basically force a blade into a part and if you want to remove it it is destructive). It will not protect le against everything, and this is the reason i do not go for anything fancy. I just hope that the ones who would like to put something in would be deterred by the zips. Anything that breaks visibly (a seal for instance) would do, but this leaves traces on the suitcase.
- O__________O 4y agoGlue, most likely super glue (cyanoacrylate) would likely counter that vulnerability. There are also tamper evident zip ties.
- daneel_w 4y agoMy first impression is that a weird shrink-wrapped pack of colored rice'n'beans is gonna trigger any customs agent.
- CTDOCodebases 4y agoI agree. Anything organic looking that is vac sealed is bound to look suspicious.
- londons_explore 4y agoVacuum bagging this stuff seems risky... I could imagine a technique could be developed to keep all the coloured beads in place while getting the item out. For example, heating the bag so the beads stick to it? Or flushing through a glue followed by a solvent.
- londons_explore 4y agoVacuum sealing something often leaves wrinkles in the bag material, especially when sealing soft items. Those wrinkles are very hard to reproduce if the seal is broken. That effect could be used to be less 'obvious' that the package is protected.
- zcw100 4y agoPerhaps use two stacked meshes and allow it to create a moiré pattern. I'd imagine that would be fairly unique and difficult to reproduce.
- RandomLensman 4y agoI might misremember, but wasn't there something about the use of aluminum flakes in resin for verification in disarmaments, i.e., use a blob of flakes in resin to mark and then check the pattern when about to be scrapped? Could have been just a concept many years back, though. Certainly powerful stuff as very difficult to reproduce at any kind of scale.
- elheffe80 4y agoCan we get a warning to those of us with a clearance so that we don't have to self report? Thanks. This turned my day right the hell upside down. Still cool article. Author- portion markings like that are cool and all, but fml.
- injidup 4y agoCan you explain please.
- SturgeonsLaw 4y agoThere's an image at the start of the post (I want to say from the Snowden leaks) that's classified TS/SI/NF (top secret, sensitive information, not for release to foreign nationals). Not a problem for civilians to view actually, but those with government clearance are prohibited from viewing that material unless they are in the allowed categories.
- xpe 4y agoOk, I see what you mean. I wonder if you can use a custom Hacker News site/reader that might help somehow?
- superkuh 4y agoNo one else is responsible for your bad life decisions.
- cto_of_antifa 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tomxor 4y agoI was expecting more stealthy techniques, like the old sticking a hair and tape on a door or carbon shoe prints under the carpet type tricks. I was imagining people spraying invisible coatings on USB sockets or something. The problem with doing something as elaborate as wrapping stuff in vacuum packed beans is that it draws attention and provides an adversary plausible deniability due to customs inspections etc, "Oh sorry the DEA had to inspect your package but it's fine, here's your beans too".
- bad416f1f5a2 4y agoIs that really a problem? I think you’ve described a valuable signal, and you may have a different threat model in your mind. If my use case for this device is so sensitive that I’m taking these steps to avoid it being intercepted, any evidence of tampering, even slight, means the device is compromised, /full stop/. In your scenario when the government hands me three bags of lentils & my device I thank them, walk to the nearest dumpster, and pitch the whole lot in because I have to assume it’s been bugged.
- tomxor 4y agoTrue, my point is only that it's far from free and therefore has limited purpose... You gain highly reliable interception signalling at the cost of significantly increasing the probability of interception. As you suggest, if your use case is so sensitive or critical that you can afford to send 10 laptops and only use the ones that arrive in tact then fair enough - however for the more common scenario of just being a privacy conscious individual who would like some degree of ability to determine tampering in transit - this is a non-starter. It's not unthinkable that a method exists with as much resilience without attracting unwanted attention.
- Buttons840 4y agoGood point, but if my package contained illegal material, I'd know I'm being played. Of course, they'd just arrest me instead in that case, but maybe that's preferable?
- skrap 4y agoI was wondering if you could defeat the beans/lentils by injecting some water vapor in there (while maintaining the vacuum & placement of the items), and freezing the whole thing. Then cut it open under hard freeze and maybe everything sticks together.
- thehappypm 4y agoMight even be doable without water vapor at cold enough temperatures. Vapor could damage or cause the rice/beans to start to rot later on, dead giveaway of tampering. Maybe the plastic beads are better in general because of their lack of moisture and general lack of organic weirdness.
- pvillano 4y agoplastic beads are also infinitely reusable, although probably have a much higher environmental impact than grains. Gravel could work.
- eric4smith 4y agoRecently I went to visit my old property and was told of some intrusions. A simple leaf stuck in the gate made it seem completely natural and at the same time was clear to show it someone opened it. And it was completely natural to pluck the leaf and stick it in the gate as I was leaving each day.