5 ms·
Recent versions of the health monitoring app on the Apple Watch looks at how much time you spend with a foot completely off the ground while walking. Which is r
by hinkley 4y ago
Recent versions of the health monitoring app on the Apple Watch looks at how much time you spend with a foot completely off the ground while walking. Which is related to this.
I think a yoga instructor said this, but it’s the reason I do tai chi. Death certificates don’t say “died from a fall” but many many people do. Breaking a hip is the beginning of the end for most people. The wound takes so long to heal and you are immobilized for so long that secondary health issues become primary. Many people with a broken hip die from pneumonia. So if you can avoid a broken hip by improving your balance you are better off. If improving your balance improves leg bone density, then you are saved twice over.
We’ve circled around this discovery a number of times. Those exercise programs for retirement homes know this. Water aerobics is just an arthritis- and obesity-friendly way to accomplish the same.
- jeffbee 4y agoThere must be at least some death certificates that say fall, because CDC WISQARS shows falls as the 2nd-most-common mechanism of unintentional death - after drug overdose, and before motor vehicle crash - with over 42000 in 2020.
- xwdv 4y agoUnfortunately I think if you haven’t internalized fitness as a thing you have to maintain all your life, your chances of suddenly become motivated late in life when your survival depends on fitness related activities are slim. Many people who break a hip simply lose the will to live much more. They don’t really take the rehab seriously, they don’t focus on prevention, they make half hearted efforts. Because they are not used to the pain that comes with exercise, they resist it. They simply shut down slowly until they pass away from whatever cause they become vulnerable to.
- hinkley 4y agoHonestly I suspect that the success of exercise classes in retirement homes speaks more to a lack of other pass times. This makes me feel better and it kills three hours a week.
- anjel 4y agoAnecdotally: after being sedentary for 35-40 years and having both hips replaced in their early 70s, health quality in one of my parents had degraded such by the time they were 85 that I suggested a mild fitness program of walking 3/4 of a mile each day. Exercise regimes get no milder than that. Improvements in day to day energy and balance, A1c, frailty and sleep quality were so markedly improved after just one month that it became the source of motivation. 7 years later, when weather prevents their daily walk, the difference is obvious to them. Advanced aging is learned helplessness. Exercise can make a difference at any age and is the natural offset to that depressive, learned helplessness of aging. As the saying goes: Exercise is its own reward.
- planarhobbit 4y agoWould decades of squats, deadlifts, free weights/kettlebells and a plethora of compound exercises build up enough hip/femoral bone density and muscle to withstand most chances of hip breaks occurring? Or most bone breakages, period? I’m assuming most of the population does not engage in serious exercise regiments, but we rarely have studies performed solely on a highly athletic/strong cohort, so I have to be the glib one and ask if bodybuilders are exempt from these “frail in old age” studies. One great study we’ve had done recently is how the heart is sculpted as pertaining to exercises that are done, namely cycling, swimming, lifting heavy weights, and rowing all exhibit their own reconfiguration of heart walls/chambers.
- gkop 4y agoI'd love to see a simple infographic that tells us the most important stuff to pay attention (eg. strength vs flexibility) to at different ages and for both genders..
- hinkley 4y agoThey are linked. Tai chi and yoga both work on hip flexibility, and without that flexibility I don’t think my hams would be as strong as they are. I was always unbalanced to quads, even before I got into cycling which made that worse. And that’s a quick route to chronic knee pain, which makes everything else harder.
- aristophenes 4y agoCould you expound? Are you saying strong quads + weak hamstrings == knee pain? I recently started using an exercise bike in addition to squats and climbs in order to get in shape and found that I started having chronic knee pain for the first time in my life, which persisted for months even after I stopped using the bike. I don't use clip on shoes, which I would imagine would allow hamstrings to be utilized more. Very few datapoints right now, but my knees seem to feel better, not worse, after sprinting exercises. I've been very athletic my whole life and never had knee problems before.
- btilly 4y agoDeath certificates don’t say “died from a fall” but many many people do. Breaking a hip is the beginning of the end for most people. My sister is a nurse and told me that we SAY "fell and broke a hip" but ACTUALLY it was "broke a hip and then fell". You can tell that from where the break was, and once the hip breaks you are guaranteed to fall. The cause of hearing this was that my mother had exactly this accident, broke her hip them fell. In the hospital she got some serious drugs, and this triggered severe dementia for the rest of her life.
- andruby 4y agoDrugs triggered dementia. That's interesting. Is that something that has been thoroughly researched or is it still a hypothesis?
- btilly 4y agohttps://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10459729/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10459729/ Actually in her case it WAS more delirium. At first she had a sense of humor about it - the floating cake she was seeing looked quite delicious and she regretted that she couldn't eat it. But later, well, she honestly believed she was sleeping outside under the stars even though she emphatically wasn't.
- causi 4y agoIt happens. My grandfather fell off his roof onto concrete and suffered a bad broken arm. His subsequent prescription and continued use of opiate painkillers exactly coincide with the onset of his dementia, one he didn't recover from even after getting off the drugs. My grandmother was prescribed Wellbutrin for a few months after my grandfather died. A decade later she suffered a fall and was hospitalized. In the hospital the doctors for whatever reason started giving her Wellbutrin again. She spent the next month subject to intense psychosis, not knowing where she was or who was in the room with her, thinking she was being attacked, thinking there was a party going on in the hallway. We were probably less than a week from institutionalizing her when my aunt noticed the unneeded medicine she was being given. After they stopped giving it to her she was back to normal in less than 48 hours.
- morninglight 4y agoHow many people will fall and break a hip while attempting a 10-sec 1-leg stance? .
- themitigating 4y agoI'm assuming that people will put their other leg down if they sense they are going to fall.
- nkurz 4y agoThe paper gives us reason to believe the maximum rate is probably something less than 1 in 1000: "Anthropometric, clinical and vital status and 10-s OLS data were assessed in 1702 individuals (68% men) aged 51–75 years between 2008 and 2020." "No adverse medical events or accidents occurred during the 10-s OLS testing."
- ihaveajob 4y agoMy understanding is that in the typical hip-breaking fall, the fall is the consequence of the bone-breaking, and not the cause. In other words, osteoporosis causes brittle bones that break at odd times, and that makes you fall. If that's the case, bone-strengthening exercises and diet would be more effective at preventing this catastrophic scenario. But I'm not a medical doctor.
- hinkley 4y agoThat's certainly possible, but if you can also just have a leg buckle on you. Sometimes the signals just get lost, especially with certain medications.
- throwaway0a5e 4y agoThe broken hip is more of a symptom of being very frail than it is a cause of death. Nobody who isn't so frail that a bone break is the final straw is breaking their hip. You don't need an app to tell you someone is frail.