9 ms·
Bitcoin drops below $18,300 as sell-off accelerates
- rinze 4y agoStill $18,300 to go. Getting closer, at least.
- fny 4y agoI'm a huge bear, but thinking its going to zero is crazy. Even beanie babies retain some value. And crypto still has utility as a transaction medium for illicit exchanges.
- Ekaros 4y agoI think 0 is eventual end result. Unlike beanie babies or sports card. The operating costs of bitcoin is rather high. You can throw those in a box and then leave it at back of cupboard... But to do anything with bitcoin you need a network.
- unicornmama 4y agohttps://www.fooledbyrandomness.com/BTC-QF.pdf https://www.fooledbyrandomness.com/BTC-QF.pdf "Comment 1: Why BTC is worth exactly Gold and other precious metals are largely maintenance free, do not degrade over an historical horizon, and do not require maintenance to refresh their physical properties over time. Cryptocurrencies require a sustained amount of inter- est in them"
- _0w8t 4y agoIn Russia 200 years ago the was a spike in interests in platinum. Gold melts at temperature of wooden house fire and substantial amount of it was lost this way. Platinum melts at much higher point.
- fny 4y agoYou know, this is actually raises a good point. If the marginal cost of producing Bitcoin exceeds the sale price, Bitcoin is toast and one of the proof of stake coins will win out.
- gsliepen 4y agoThat's a good point. What if enough miners quit such that suddenly one of the big mining groups gets a majority?
- HyprMusic 4y agoCrypto still has value, but bitcoin itself has shown little value in any of the things it's supposed to be a solution for. It's not really that decentralised (in as far as most people trade through exchanges, and the miners have pooled their power to elicit control), the transaction fees are too high to be good for commerce, it's too volatile to be a store of money, and it's not anonymous enough to be used on illicit markets (the majority of them have moved to Monero). In my opinion, for crypto to flourish bitcoin needs to die. That said, I also don't believe it will go to zero because there's one thing it's great at.. speculation. It's an ingenious bit of technology that the general public doesn't really understand and so the greater fool theory will continue to prove true.
- stevenalowe 4y agoBeanie Babies actually exist IRL.
- nathanaldensr 4y agoYep, as did tulips. And tulips smell good and look pretty! That's more than Bitcoin can say.
- oleganza 4y agoI like the sound of "this time it's different" from the bitcoin doomsayers.
- 609venezia 4y agoThis is the first time since inception it has traded below its previous bull market high. This time is different.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 4y agoThanks for your work :).
- graeme 4y agoIt is different, it’s bitcoin’s first recession. The “ultrahard” currency has always depended on cheap money to grow, especially from Tether
- nivenkos 4y agoThere is unfortunately a fair amount of intrinsic exchange value in its use for illegal trades (drugs, CP, etc.) and tax evasion. So it won't ever drop to 0. Unless governments actually start to do their job and stop all transactions to the fiat-crypto exchanges. They are literally being used to bypass international sanctions and fund all sorts of trafficking and cartels.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- czbond 4y agoLots of support in $11-$12k range. Be hard to break that.
- rsrx 4y agoBitcoin is here to stay. You're mixing up shitcoins and other ponzi-like schemes. As with any new & emerging technology, blockchain ecosystem hosts various (intentional or unintentional) FUD and malicious coins that are backed by nothing and often run in a ponzi scheme manner. These coins will eventually crash and disappear. Bitcoin's intrinsic values are similar to other asset classes, plus, its also decentralized and censorship resistant.
- anon2020dot00 4y agoNothing wrong with Bitcoin itself but the rampant speculation is what draws the proponents and critics alike. If Bitcoin just worked like a peer-to-peer neutral currency and had no speculative element, most people would have no issue with it. The annoying element is when it is used as a get-rich quick pyramid scheme.
- rsrx 4y agoI'm really curious why that annoys you? As I mentioned earlier, almost any emerging technology will go through period of instability, and with bitcoin and its speculative nature this is certainly the case. And there are people that are ready to ride that wave.
- gigatexal 4y agoI am dying laughing right now. Sitting here with popcorn watching all the ponzi-coin bs burn
- haswell 4y agoWhy is this funny? I'm no crypto apologist, but a significant number of innocent bystanders are being absolutely ruined right now. I understand the pull of schadenfreude when thinking about a certain subset of the crypto ecosystem, but that is also tampered a bit by the tragedy that comes with it. The life savings lost, inevitable suicides, relationships shattered. Laughing about this seems like an odd response.
- gsibble 4y agoBecause a lot of those people acted like they were smarter than everyone else and shoved their gains in our faces for years. I'm happy to see crypto bros losing their shirts.
- haswell 4y agoI'd imagine that majority of the people impacted by this crash are not crypto bros. They're people who saw a super bowl commercial, or heard about it from a friend. Hell, my mid-70s parents hold crypto, and crypto bros they are not. As I said in the parent comment, I get the sentiment towards the shills/scammers/pumpers/etc, but the reality is that this is not really about them.
- jacquesm 4y agoYou should probably have a chat with them regarding the stuff they put their retirement money into then. For their sake I hope it was only a very small fraction of their total holdings.
- haswell 4y agoOh I’ve definitely had this conversation with them. Whatever version of the truth they’ve been sold is apparently quite convincing, which does make me angry.
- yellowbanana 4y agoThe store of value argument is now dead.
- pvg 4y agoIt's an everdupe at this point, turning the front page into a bitcoin price tracker which is not particularly interesting https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=bitcoin%20below%20comments%3E5&sort=byDate&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- cozzyd 4y agoDouble entendre of dupe here? :)
- graeme 4y agoIt’s plausibly the collapse of the largest ponzi the world has ever known, by lrders of magnitude. Madoff was $60 billion. Crypto was $2.6 trillion at its peak. This article itself doesn’t add much but having the ones with analysis pop up frequently seems valid. Very interesting to watch this in real time, as in 2008. Ponzi doesn’t quite fit and my hope is some day crypto will be known as a Nakamoto Scheme.
- pvg 4y agopop up frequently seems valid It's not HN-valid on a daily, never mind hourly basis which is where we're at. That's just how the site functions and maintains its own interestingness, irrespective of the interestingness of any individual topic or article.
- robga 4y ago> my hope is some day crypto will be known as a Nakamoto Scheme It’s called this in various places. See https://salbayat.org/the-strange-case-of-nakamotos-bitcoin/ https://salbayat.org/the-strange-case-of-nakamotos-bitcoin/
- rsrx 4y agoControversial take, but the amount of salty comments on crypto here always amuses me.
- monkeybutton 4y agoYou're only going to see the salty and bullish takes, the truly neutral have nothing to say about it.
- rsrx 4y agoComments on other internet sources I follow are mostly mixed bag of beans, however here they are prevalently salty when it comes to crypto and every time I stumble upon topic like this I wonder why. I was expecting that HN audience sees blockchain tech and bitcoin for what it is, and unique capabilities it offers, beyond "omg its a ponzi scheme!!11!" narrative.
- mekster 4y agoPossibly people are richer than in Reddit and got burned more heavily in the past buying at the wrong time?
- jacquesm 4y agoI've used bitcoin for short term transactions to get some money to people that needed it, but in spite of that I have no illusions about that being the exception and not the rule. At some point tech needs to prove itself through utility and economic viability. This is going to be a difficult to achieve thing for all these coins (BTC and others), and in the bulk of the cases they are money grabs or Ponzi schemes. That does not help, if the money grabs and the Ponzi schemes (which happen in the 'real world' as well) were a very insignificant minority I suspect the sentiment would be entirely different.
- kanonieer 4y agoWhere's the take? As it stands it's a silly flame-bait.
- 4y ago
- pcdoodle 4y agoAnti bitcoin people are pretty toxic. What an amazing invention to have the absolute truth published every 10 minutes. Back in the day before naval armies, merchant ships used to have to carry their own cannons and couldn't max out their payload with goods. Bitcoin has a neat feature of not requiring armies or vaults to protect itself. Is it a currency? I think not but it is many things all the same. The people who focus on the price haven't seen the forest for the trees.
- isatty 4y agoIdk if it’s about btc or eth but it really started leaving a foul taste with hundreds of garbage Ponzi scams and NFTs - combined with non tech and older folks getting scammed. The moment someone brings up crypto (coins) not cryptography I just don’t entertain them anymore.
- d_watt 4y agoRelatively few people are against the blockchain as an interesting technology for creating distributed truth in areas that can actually benefit from that. I think if we're extending your age of sail metaphor, I think people are against it being used for the modern version of tulip mania. Personally, I'm now more excited now about blockchain than I have been in the past. I think the the rush to extract money from people via btc, nfts, etc. is what has overshadowed it's ability for interesting/novel use cases.
- 988747 4y agoSo far the only real use of blockchain technology is Git. Cryptocurrencies are misuse of it :-D
- layer8 4y agoIf you count Git, then “blockchain technology” is also used for Evidence Records: https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc4998 https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc4998 There’s probably a number of further Merkle-tree-based technologies in current use.
- 4y ago
- eterm 4y agoMaybe HN should incorporate a price ticker? /s I appreciate that we get to look down upon the "fools" losing their shirt but there probably more appropriate places to do so. Yes, we warned them. Yes, we told them that it was all greater fool theory, but remember it's usually the average punter who got in just before* peak hype that loses everything. And they don't really deserve it. Those who fooled them do, but they're often the ones offloading their bags to the next. * Just before because they're the ones who hit 60% gains and didn't sell, and risk chasing that high all the way down.
- twiceaday 4y agoMaybe these waves of new lows stories will counter-balance the fomo-harvesting 'new all time highs' that were suspiciously absolutely everywhere.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- radu_floricica 4y agoI really really don't understand how anybody can look at a long term graph of bitcoin price and still think people were "tricked" into anything. It's... I don't know, I firmly believe there a lower limit of due diligence needed for something after which "tricking" just isn't a right word. You google "btc price" and you get a nice graph with all the info you need. They could be mistaken - or not. Right now odds are maybe 4:1 for each price peak to be surpassed in about three years. Even if it won't and it turns out to be a bad investment, the odds make it a pretty legitimate decision, right or wrong.
- jacquesm 4y agoSo does that translate for you into "I'm buying BTC"?
- radu_floricica 4y agoshrug I haven't touched the right/wrong part, and I did it on purpose. All I said is that it's a legitimate decision. When an Alzheimer grandma gets a call with a great business opportunity and loses all her savings, that's a scam. When somebody invests maybe too much in bitcoin because his gym buddy told him so, that's at worst a bad decision (or a great one, depending on when he did the investment).
- hmate9 4y agoI have no horse in this race but it seems like a lot of people are rooting for as much pain as possible for Bitcoin as that justifies/makes people feel good for missing its bull run. Also it’s not just Bitcoin falling in a vacuum. The entire US and European stock market is absolute garbage too (housing showing cracks as well) so it’s hard to blame Bitcoin alone although it has undeniable failed as an inflation hedge.
- francoi8 4y agoA lot of people are rooting for Bitcoin to crash so it will stop pumping carbon in the atmosphere like a middle sized country.
- Imnimo 4y agoI think it depends on your perspective. If you believe the options are bitcoin goes down or bitcoin goes up, then you're rooting for more pain if you're rooting for bitcoin to go down. But if you believe the options are bitcoin goes down now or bitcoin goes down later, then bitcoin going down now is minimizing pain.
- jmyeet 4y agoI disagree. Bitcoin is hugely wasteful. Estimates on the power usage of the Bitcoin network have it using more energy than Sweden. Now that might be fine if it provided more than a modicum of utility but it doesn't. The only use case I've seen is to bypass laws on where money can be moved. Some of this is moral (eg totalitarian governments with capital controls on the poor) but most of it isn't (eg scams, ransomware, otherwise illegal gambling, drugs, child abuse material and so on). I'll agree there's probably a little schadenfreude here because of how many Crypto Andys have pumping crypto so hard for many years pretty much for no other reason than their own gain. Most don't believe in any utility here. It's just a get rich quick scheme. AGain, that would be fine if it wasn't so horribly wasteful.
- hmate9 4y agoIt’s energy usage is indeed terrible. I’d love to see it move to a proof of stake model.
- Geee 4y agoThis is a very good buying opportunity, because this is mostly caused by overleveraged people and institutions having to liquidate into thin markets. Too greedy people are now wiped out. This gives an opportunity for those who have been wiser and have spare cash around. If you decide to buy, buy only the amount which you wouldn't need in a couple of years, taking into account increasing living costs and coming recession. Obviously, buy bitcoin only. Other coins can have their few months of fame but then fade away. The price can still go lower, but I think we're quite close to the bottom of this cycle.
- hmate9 4y agoIf you are investing here please dollar cost average over the next ~6 months (likely recession/bear market duration) as opposed to buying in one go. Sell ~4 years from now as Bitcoin tends to be cyclical and peaks 2 years after a halving event.
- timeon 4y ago> as Bitcoin tends to be cyclical and peaks 2 years after a halving event. Watch out for cargo culting.
- hwers 4y agoIt’s silly that you’re being downvoted because this is absolutely true. The idea that it would go to zero is mad, it will without a doubt go back up to similar numbers again. This is just a little gift
- raesene9 4y agoI'd say the problem is that no-one can easily predict where the bottom lies right now. We have Celcius with frozen withdrawals and in an undetermined state having called in restructuring specialists. We have 3ac apparently not talking to their partners with a lot of loans outstanding and margin calls due, then we have all of the other people who were partners/customers of those organizations, who at the moment either can't access their funds temporarily, or may not be able to access their funds ever, so are essentially schrodingers companies right now, until they can get accurate information about what's happening Once all the companies that go down have gone down, then there's a reasonable chance that a bottom can be called, but at the moment I don't think there's enough information to know.
- pid-1 4y agoIf I understand correctly, the actual cryptography in cryptocurrencies isn't terribly interesting. Blockchains are, however, trying (or claim to be trying) to solve the Byzantine Fault Tolerance problem, which has no known efficient solution. Is that correct? Are blockchains an actual area of research for folks studying distributed systems in CS Departments?
- yata69420 4y agoIt is an actual area of research, mostly around scalability. I don't know what happens in computer science departments, but you can watch Ethereum be developed in the open. They cite the research they're implementing. For example: https://notes.ethereum.org/@vbuterin/proto_danksharding_faq#How-%E2%80%9Ccomplicated%E2%80%9D-and-%E2%80%9Cnew%E2%80%9D-is-KZG https://notes.ethereum.org/@vbuterin/proto_danksharding_faq#... I'm not quite smart enough to follow all the cryptography, but there are a lot of unsolved problems being worked on. It seems that doing trust and accounting at global decentralized scale is trickier than chaining blocks together.
- xtracto 4y agoThere are a couple of blockchain projects doing BFT development n the first one I read about was AntShares (now Neo) doing delegated BFT. There IS some interesting R&D happening, but most if it is lost in the get-rich-quick noise. Also Zk-SNARK research is interesting . Monero and Zcash technology is also quite interesting ,and can go beyond cryptocurrencies. I'm very pro blockchain tech, and I'm glad this "winter" is coming so that all that noise is reduced and good interesting projects get more visibility. There's a little known project called selfkey who have been developing some interesting "Sovereign digital id" stuff. Pretty early but interesting. Just get away from the "money money money" stuff and you can find some interesting projects.
- xtracto 4y agoAlso , the basic cryptocurrency stuff is basic PKI with signing. Plus a version of Kademilla plus a database linking records with hashed previous records and the infamous PoW. Nothing really fancy computationally. The "genious" of Nakamoto was to put all the existing parts together. But hashcash was there, kad/BitTorrent were there, chained append only DBs were there, etc.
- DantesKite 4y agoWhat I'm most curious about is what the knock-on effect this will be to crypto businesses. From what I hear, a few pension funds invested into Bitcoin. Wondering how that'll turn out...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jpgvm 4y agoMost pension funds probably had an exposure somewhere on the order of 0.05% AUM or less so it should have no significant impact. It's the crypto hedge funds and other businesses that were holding huge chunks of BTC/ETH that are in trouble.
- jacquesm 4y agoA pension fund with significant Bitcoin exposure is not 'investing' they are recklessly endangering the funds they have been entrusted with and the fund managers ought to be held personally liable.
- valdiorn 4y agoDude, you have absolutely no idea what you're talking about. I fucking loathe crypto but to say fund managers are "recklessly endangering the funds" shows you have no knowledge of how a hedge fund works. Source: I work risk management for a large UK fund.
- jacquesm 4y ago> I work risk management for a large UK fund. Oh, that's ok then, carry on, user 'valdiorn' has spoken and it's ok for funds to invest a significant amount of their holdings into BTC. Or did you miss the word 'significant'?
- czbond 4y agoGenerally a pension would put 1% or less to such investments. So while the absolute value of the loss may be large, the percentage of portfolio loss will be little. The loss of S&P and equities at large impacts them much more greatly.
- jacquesm 4y agoThe thing to watch is the hashrate, once the bigger miners start pulling out it will get interesting. https://www.blockchain.com/charts/hash-rate https://www.blockchain.com/charts/hash-rate
- Overtonwindow 4y agoIf larger miners pull out, what will that mean for the smaller miners?
- jacquesm 4y agoThe bitcoin algorithm that determines when to double/halve is well tested in one direction, but the halving suffers from some problems if the hashrate drops too quickly. I would imagine that suddenly the number of transactions that can be processed will rapidly decrease as well simply because not enough blocks would be mined. This might cause a massive increase in the interval between two subsequent blocks and that in turn may cause more people to lose faith in bitcoin because transactions would slow down significantly. Which in turn would put more downward pressure on price and eventually again on the hashrate. And halving are just that: they are halvings, you can't skip multiple halvings in one go. So in short: it may cause a downward feedback loop.
- Zopieux 4y agooh no! anyway.
- rossdavidh 4y agoHypothesis: if, as some have asserted, the BTC market is driven by the Tether market, then BTC dropping might be related to the recent wobbling of Tether USDT, which never quite regained $1 peg. If Tether is about to go the way of Luna and Celsius, then it may be that one of the major remaining purchasers of (heavily discounted) Chinese property bonds is about to go away. We have already seen a couple small runs on the bank in China in recent weeks. Perhaps we are about to see more? Whether the above hypothesis is true or not (and I am not attached to it, as I own no BTC nor USDT), I suspect that one way or another, the crash of BTC is going to have knock-on effects on the rest of the global economy. Remember, at the beginning of the GFC not many people in Greece or Iceland or Spain probably thought that American housing bonds had anything to do with them...
- jacquesm 4y ago> I suspect that one way or another, the crash of BTC is going to have knock-on effects on the rest of the global economy. I highly doubt that because there just isn't enough volume in BTC compared to what the rest of the world transacts in other currencies. It may affect the price of drugs for a while.
- eltradero 4y agoConsidering that you're pricing it against a spreadsheet stored in a DC basement, maybe backupped in some Jersey data center, it's indeed doing poorly. Cheap USD and free (i.e., unregulated) derivative markets are doing the rest. Speculation is the lifeblood of commerce. There are some who rejoice at the sight of it.