10 ms·
If anyone hasn’t tried using System Settings yet on macOS Ventura, overall it’s…pretty bad. On iOS the canonical way to display a bunch of settings is a table v
by saagarjha 4y ago
If anyone hasn’t tried using System Settings yet on macOS Ventura, overall it’s…pretty bad. On iOS the canonical way to display a bunch of settings is a table view, because there really aren’t that many controls available to be used on a touch-first device. In Ventura they brought this over to macOS, trying to cram all the old settings into lists of options (which used to be nice little checkboxes, but are now tiny little switches that look pretty bad). In many cases the thoughtful, if somewhat dated, layout of some preference panes are completely lost and bulldozed over with the list of switches. In other places it’s clear that the team was forced to do the redesign and keep all the old options available somewhere, but couldn’t really figure out where to put the stuff, so there’s little push button on the bottom that will show a sheet with the UI that didn’t fit in the list. Of course, any settings that don’t really make sense to share with iOS are now lumped together and hidden from sight-in this case, under the “General” tab.
If you remember how everyone moaned about iTunes and begged Apple to rewrite it, then got Music in macOS Catalina, you can kind of see how the new System Settings app is.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoThere are a lot of pref panes owned by a lot of different teams/owners. I suspect the rough edges will get ironed out in future updates as other teams have time to come in and do a re-think/re-write. I have to say though, iOS does not seem like the best model of Settings that I would emulate. Rather than the years-long, pile-on model that iOS Settings seems to be the result of, someone needs to step back and reevaluate where every setting ought to belong — how best to organize them. Also, speaking of iOS Settings — Mail setting should be in the Mail app, Safari settings in the Safari app. I have always loathed that iOS 1.0 idea that you had to go to a different place to find the settings for the apps.
- egypturnash 4y agoI have always loathed that iOS 1.0 idea that you had to go to a different place to find the settings for the apps. You are not alone, it drives me nuts to have to scroll through the settings for every dumb joke app I have when I'm looking for something.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mrweasel 4y agoThat's really annoying, because the settings in iOS is terrible enough on the phone. Tons of stuff doesn't make sense, naming is bad, many settings are, in my opinion, placed under the wrong menu item.
- harha 4y agoAlso: it used to be ok-ish to have all settings in one place when apps were rather simple and few. Now it's super annoying to be in an app, want to change something, go to settings, scroll forever to find the app settings and make the change.
- azinman2 4y agoCould you give examples?
- vetinari 4y agoAs someone who normally doesn't use iOS, it is always a chore to find what I'm looking for. That means that the logic of the hierarchy is not intuitive and to use it, you need learned behaviour.
- ghaff 4y agoMore and more options have certainly been added over time, often for good reason. But it means that someone who hasn't lived with iOS for a while, when suddenly presented with it out of the box, can be overwhelmed and a lot isn't intuitively discoverable.
- jclardy 4y agoI’ve used iOS since the first iPod touch. Basically everything dumped into “General” is misplaced and hard to find, you only find it because it has been there for 10 years now.
- KORraN 4y agoMy recent example when I needed to set up a proxy - Certificate Trust Settings are under General -> About, at the same time there is VPN & Device Management.
- GekkePrutser 4y agoI don't think it's too bad, it just needs a bit more discoverability. I use KDE now as main driver which has a ton of options compared to macOS and they use the same format. What I do find myself using a lot more is the search. Part of the reason I didn't have to do this with the old macOS preferences was just my muscle memory (only slightly thwarted by Apple's changing of the icons). And the other part was that there's simply less to find there. But essentially I think the scrolling left and right panes are not a bad idea. The old format consisted of a non-scrolling and non-resizable(!) window that would be replaced, and this caused some issues on really low-res screens in the past, at 800x600 pixels (or even 800x480 like the eeePC) it was impossible to reach all the settings on the old preferences. At least this is now fixed to a format where more controls don't need to be crammed into the same space, it can simply expand. And the number of "menu" options is now also dynamic and no longer constrained by screen space. But it's going to mess up decades of muscle memory which is not fun :)
- alxlaz 4y ago> I use KDE now as main driver which has a ton of options compared to macOS and they use the same format. Those of us who remember the old tree-based layout from before Kirigami took over were about as happy about the change as macOS users are about the new Preferences layout in Ventura. It used to look like this a long time ago: https://fedoranews.org/krishnan/review/kde3.2/fullsize/controlcenter.png https://fedoranews.org/krishnan/review/kde3.2/fullsize/contr... -- it was a lot more space-efficient and going into one sub-section didn't automatically hide all other sections, so it was a lot easier to look for things. I don't recall if the window in Plasma-era releases was resizable but it certainly replaced one that was both scrolling and resizable. Early 5.x releases still supported the tree-based layout IIRC but it hadn't been the default since the 4.x days, which used that awkward icon-based layout, eek!
- GekkePrutser 4y agoI only started using KDE recently so I didn't know that one. It does look very useful indeed.
- necovek 4y ago
- jamil7 4y agoWith the whole Safari debacle, maybe they learned a little and will improve the design before the release based on feedback.
- arrrg 4y agoThey massively iterated on Safari after receiving bad feedback. I really like the version that shipped: I love the much more reachable address bar and use the quick tab switching by swiping (and also the quick tab creation) all the time. I also like it much more visually – but even if you don’t, it‘s clear that the design is different for functional reasons, not visual appeal. There is a clear purpose behind the changes (moving the address bar to the bottom is the obvious change, making the address bar look draggable and providing the hint of the other tabs to the left or right is also quite important and very much function first. I didn’t care for the first iteration. I do like the final design. The only thing that‘s weird is that they kept the old variant around as an option. Maybe because the discussion turned toxic and people became unable to evaluate the design based on its merits?
- mihaaly 4y agoI do not want to relearn how to configure my OS, waste of time! I want something that make life easier, not harder!! : ((
- kcplate 4y agoHow often are you in system preferences? Literally I am in there maybe once/twice a month. I guess I don’t see the outrage over minor UI tweaks for a feature I rarely use
- pilsetnieks 4y agoFrom what I've seen, there's not much to re-learn. Everything is in the same place as it was before, it's just that the layout is clunky and does not look that good.
- eevilspock 4y agoIt's easier, not harder. You can find settings easily using the search box. Seems to me like your reaction is rather out of proportion.
- mulmen 4y agoMy 2014 MacBook is no longer getting major updates. Apple is still popping up ads for the latest MacOS, even though I can’t install it. I considered buying a new Mac with Apple silicon but the last three MacOS releases have been enormous regressions. At this point a Framework seems to make a lot more sense. I hated everything about the UX on Big Sur and they seem to have doubled down on their poor decisions. This news destroys the final bit of hope I had that they’d correct the MacOS path the way they did with MacBook hardware.
- neurostimulant 4y agoI actually just upgraded my late 2012 MBP to Monterey last week using OpenCore Legacy Patcher [1]. Everything works great so far. Your 2014 MBP should be supported as well. Made me wonder how part-time hobbyist with minimal resources can continue supporting old hardwares while a trillion dollar company cannot. [1] https://dortania.github.io/OpenCore-Legacy-Patcher/START.html#how-do-i-get-started https://dortania.github.io/OpenCore-Legacy-Patcher/START.htm...
- saagarjha 4y ago> Apple is still popping up ads for the latest MacOS, even though I can’t install it. This seems like a bug they might actually fix? As opposed to the "bug" of showing you those at all, which is pretty annoying but unlikely to get looked at.
- plufz 4y ago
- Phurist 4y agoThey are just moving on with the industry standard. I am quite happy with this layout on Gnome for a long time already. Get with the times
- saagarjha 4y agoWhat industry standard? There's no industry standard for this stuff, it's just each OS doing what it wants. As it stands System Settings now looks different from every other preference panel on the system. I helped ship a sidebar+search design in IINA and we do a far better job that System Settings does. Go take a peek if you'd like to see how this could've been done. (Personally, I think most apps should stick with top tabs, but we–and Apple–are constrained by how many preferences we can show on screen at once.)
- hnlmorg 4y agoThere is no industry norm. KDE, for example, follows the approach described in the article. In fact even Windows has some control panels designed that way too (though Microsoft still cocked it up be creating multiple different settings applications each with overlapping utility yet somehow differing support for configurability thus leaving left to Google how to make even some of the simplest of changes).
- yjftsjthsd-h 4y agoI struggle to credit the idea that GNOME did something and that it's a standard; their whole thing ever since 3 is "innovation" (i.e. NIH).
- pjmlp 4y agoYou forgot the cherry on top of the cake, if I understood correctly it is now written in Catalyst and based on the iPad OS one.
- saagarjha 4y agoNah it's just SwiftUI
- madeofpalk 4y agoI don't think that would actually make sense. I'm sure the backend/business logic/functionality of settings has extremely little in common with iOS, so that cannot be reused with catalyst. And the UI is tweaked and "improved" for macOS (compared to iPad UI). So you don't actually gain anything from using the iPad settings app on macOS through catalyst.
- sk0g 4y agoI was trying to figure out how to do a factory reset, which they call "erase all content and settings". It's available through settings, but not in settings. You have to open the settings app, then in the menu bar click the app name, and click the erase all content and settings button. Searching for "erase", "reset", "clear", "empty", etc in settings returns no results. Of course, I couldn't tell if it was indeed a factory reset or not - what even is content? Does it include non-user scoped files and folders? Why not just use normal language people are accustomed to?!
- mproud 4y agoIt’s almost the same as erasing a phone. There’s a read-only partition that contains system files and default applications, and a read-write partition that contains files and apps you’ve added. The second gets erased, keeping the first.
- mcculley 4y agoWould “factory reset” mean reverting to the version of the OS installed at the factory? That is no longer a viable option. “Erase all content and settings” is clumsier language but more accurate.
- Isthatablackgsd 4y agoFactory Reset does not mean to reset the phone back to the original version it came with. Factory Reset is basically erase everything and load the protected partition to "reinstall" the OS (if you upgrade your OS several times, it will use the current OS version.) Factory Reset term been around for so long and everyone already know the term meaning. Even I remember that term 25 years ago. Apple chose to change the language and this cause confusion. "Factory Reset" and "Erase all content and settings" didn't implies the same meaning. Apple should add a subtitle or a tooltip to indicate that it is factory reset or additional context for us to understand what it does. So why change the term if it isn't broken?
- mcculley 4y ago
- shotta 4y agoTook me forever just to find sharing to rename my machine. Trying to step people through this convoluted app over the phone or text is really going to be a chore. I had the old System Panes memorized.
- eevilspock 4y agoTook me one second to type "name" in the search box. Results: Computer Name Network Name Login Name and Password VLAN ...
- mikepurvis 4y agoSounds comparable to the Windows metro rewrite of control panel— an attempt to modernize and make it tablet friendly, but only 80% of the way there, so the old UI had to still be maintained behind the scenes. Didn't expect a mess like that from Apple.
- lathiat 4y agoCraig says in John Gruber’s “The Talk Show” chat that the developer beta for this is early and they have a much better touchpad experience in the works already but wasn’t ready yet and hopefully the rest will get improved also https://youtu.be/WfnvsepVJC0 https://youtu.be/WfnvsepVJC0
- wodenokoto 4y agoOh, wow, that does look pretty bad. https://photos5.appleinsider.com/gallery/48776-95249-001-System-Settings-comparison-xl.jpg https://photos5.appleinsider.com/gallery/48776-95249-001-Sys...
- r00fus 4y agoI don't know about you - but the "shelves" UI that current System Preferences uses is - hard to navigate. There's no real rhyme or reason for the shelf location. At least the Ventura/iOS multiple menus has a hierarchy. Ultimately I use "search" for such large settings to find stuff like 90% the time.
- 2Gkashmiri 4y agowhy is wifi/bluetooth/network/vpn separately laid out instead of being in a single "network" like i assume was in the old ui?
- wodenokoto 4y agoI think the sidebar is a big improvement and I think it is nice that you can quickly get to the network items you need. It's the right hand side that is awful.