9 ms·
The low energy density of batteries favors large planes and short distances. The only reason you are seeing them in small planes is that electric propulsion ma
by marcosdumay 4y ago
The low energy density of batteries favors large planes and short distances.
The only reason you are seeing them in small planes is that electric propulsion makes VTOL viable, and VTOL favors small planes. There is just this niche in aviation that can't be filled at all by fossil fuel engines, so it's the first to adopt electric ones.
And yes, regulations will be the most important factor for those. I imagine it all depends on how silent those planes can be. But I doubt safety will be the limiting factor.
- closedloop129 4y agoIn that niche, why are batteries needed? Couldn't those planes be constructed with gas turbines that generate the necessary electricity?
- t0mas88 4y agoVTOL works fine with turbines, nearly all large helicopters use turbine engines. They don't use the turbines as generators but instead connect both engines to the rotor via a gearbox.
- marcosdumay 4y agoIt's a matter of the weight/power relation. While batteries suck on weight/energy, their weight/power is great. The lower that relation, the smaller you can make your VTOL vehicles, and the smaller the vehicles, the cheapest and more economical they are on total.
- dr_dshiv 4y ago> I imagine it all depends on how silent those planes can be. I agree. I’d say, though, not just how silent, but how pleasant sounding. Aesthetics of sound could make or break this industry.
- inb4_cancelled 4y agoYou either get a chop-chop-chop, or a bzzzt, both incredibly loud. It's not the engine that makes the noise, it's mostly the propeller/rotor. The only advantage of electric VTOLs is easier manufacturing and better control.
- dr_dshiv 4y ago> You either get a chop-chop-chop, or a bzzzt Well, for instance, if they could line up the harmonics to create a missing fundamental (eg with the addition of external sounds), they could make propellers present an artificially lower pitch.
- Judgmentality 4y agoYour solution to them being too loud and annoying is to make them louder and hopefully less annoying?
- dr_dshiv 4y agoYes. It’s possible that louder but less annoying is more viable, wouldn’t you say?
- vkou 4y agoI would say the most viable solution is to not subject hundreds of thousands of people to an incredible amount of noise pollution, so that a couple of playboys get to skip a taxi ride to the airport. Private-transport helicopters or equivalents have no place in cities. The gain is in no way worth the cost.
- savingsPossible 4y agoTo complement that: they are only viable because they are heavily subsidized by the suffering of city dwellers. If you placed the cost of air pollution on the bill, they'd be much more expensive. Its not just unreasonable because the person flying gets less utility that is otherwise lost. It is also an unfair form of theft.
- aliswe 4y agodo you have any references to back these statements up? I am not an expert but I did read in a hacker News comment that the energy density of gasoline is about 14 (reading that article, its 50) times higher than a "normal" battery. if that is true (I do not think that he left references either) then I would think that your statements seem less plausible. a replier who later deleted their comment left a reference saying the energy density is 50 to 1, comparing lithium-ion battery to diesel: https://www.batterypowertips.com/comparing-ev-battery-and-fuel-cell-energy-density-faq/ https://www.batterypowertips.com/comparing-ev-battery-and-fu...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoCombustion aircraft also benefit from the weight reduction as fuel is consumed.
- repiret 4y agoWhile that’s true, and makes a huge difference for rockets, it only makes a relatively small difference for airplanes. In cruise, most of an airplane’s energy is spent overcoming air resistance to move forward through the air mass (parasitic drag) rather than to create lift (induced drag).
- Deritio 4y agoWhenever I hear air taxi, I think about water bottles and airport security. I don't want some rich dude flying over my house just because he/she can afford to take a airtaxi from the airport to city center while everyone else uses car or train. For other use cases they can do what they want. Australian outback perhaps. But airspace pollution and a potential small airplane crashing down in a city? No way.
- nostromo 4y agoThey do this already. They're called helicopters.
- ben_w 4y agoOn the one hand, yes. On the other hand, making it cheap enough that mono-millionaires can do it regularly is going to make a big difference compared to the status quo.
- wildmanx 4y ago> mono-millionaires Ah right, moving it from 0.1%-ers to 1%-ers is really going to make a big difference.
- brrrrrm 4y agoAbout 10x, right?
- jxf 4y agoRoughly 10% of Americans are millionaires, for reference (though I doubt all of that is liquid).
- wildmanx 4y agoAlright, the actual figure is $1,2M for the 90-percentile household net worth. For the individual that's to be divided by 3 (since there are about 120M households in the U.S.). We are at the 96-percentile for $3M household net worth. So yeah, 4%-ers then. Really makes a big difference to my point. This is totally gonna change everybody's life. (I.e. those who can afford it, while the majority is scraping by from paycheck to paycheck.)
- swarnie 4y agoDid the Harrier just get skipped by the rest of the world? fossil fuel VTOL was cracked in the late 60s.
- alluro2 4y agoWhen talking about practical small plane with relatively acceptable noise levels and fuel efficiency, I don't think Harrier counts as it "being cracked". 125dB at 100 feet from the plane, very limited time it can spend on vertical takeoff while loaded, limited situations (fuel/weight/thrust ratio) in which it can hover at all...If it was cracked, the newer iteration of the "same thing" - F-35B - wouldn't be so complex and take so many billions to develop...
- nradov 4y agoAnd the Harrier only barely worked at all. For most operational missions, they couldn't really make true vertical take-offs and landings. Instead they usually had to make short ground rolls to get some lift from the wings, or have a carrier ship sail into the wind. And the mishap rate was appalling.
- ScalaFan 4y agoAny idea how reliable electric motors/systems are compared to fossil fuel systems (primarily piston driven as opposed to jets)?
- aidenn0 4y agoMy understanding is that electric motors are generally more reliable than piston engines. I'm not sure how that compares to jets (which are also considered generally more reliable than piston engines). Nearly all modern helicopters are jet powered.