10 ms·
New CRISPR-based map ties every human gene to its function
- jmyeet 4y agoThis is really amazing. Of course I was aware of the Human Genome Project and mapping DNA in general. I was also aware that figuring out all the proteins in a cell and what they do is a whole other problem. I didn't realize they'd made this much progress. It's not complete obviously but being able to figure out gene expression is a massive step forward. The ability to switch off genes (this is where the CRISPR editing comes in) and seeing what changes is just astounding (there was an example of chromosome segregation). It's known that certain proteins mediate certain processes where the presence of that protein or the absence of it can lead to a condition or disease. The potential impact here for treating genetic disorders I think cannot be overstated. Between this an the technology behind mRNA vaccines, I really wonder if the 21st century will lead to the effective elimination of many diseases.
- jjtheblunt 4y ago> The ability to switch off genes (this is where the CRISPR editing comes in) i think your wording is ambiguous : CRISPR can edit the sequence, but "switch off" has an association with methylation of items in the sequence, orthogonal to the sequence itself.
- Filligree 4y ago> I didn't realize they'd made this much progress. It's not complete obviously but being able to figure out gene expression is a massive step forward. The ability to switch off genes (this is where the CRISPR editing comes in) and seeing what changes is just astounding (there was an example of chromosome segregation). The protein folding problem was solved earlier this year. You can expect a lot more coming in this vein... interesting times.
- dekhn 4y agothe protein structure prediction problem was solved, not protein folding. Different field. Also, it wasn't really much "solved", so much as prediction got as good as the metric used to compare the predictions to reality, so we can't really say for sure whether the predictions are better than golden labels or not.
- hirako2000 4y agoThe 21st centry may lead to the definitive elimination of humans, of desease i can only imagine their numbers going up, not down. "that's where CRISPR editing comes in". To edit the DNA of congeniality diseased people? I doubt the business will focus primarily on this category of patients, unfortunately. but I still hope the worst will be avoided when/if using this tech kind of tech.
- BurningFrog 4y agoI suspect FDA regulations will have to be redesigned a lot to make most DNA editing treatments economically possible.
- hirako2000 4y agoIf they approved the sort of recent treatment they approved, for that scale of deployment (billions of individuals within a year) it wouldn't surprise me they will approve anything, given enough lobbying. No worry to have with FDA becoming an obstacle.
- tandr 4y ago> Between this an the technology behind mRNA vaccines, I really wonder if the 21st century will lead to the effective elimination of many diseases. And, due to errors and human mistakes, possible creation of some new, or old-but-improved ones...
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 4y agoYou misunderstand. We've being doing genetics for decades. Molecular biology without mutant studies wouldn't exist. It's the foundation of the field. All this is is a difference in scale. But it is a very crude tool; really understanding gene function involves studying it in relevant contexts. Looking at cells in tissue culture can give you some ideas or hints about how it functions, but the critical insight might require certain cell types or gene regulatory environments. What data like these do is inform hypothesis generation and refine the interpretation of genomic data. It is important work, but does not replace doing actual biology. What you're talking about is essentially saying we just invented molecular biology. Which is obviously not the case.
- mdaniel 4y ago> New CRISPR-based map(ping process) ties every human gene to its function Maybe it's because I'm not in that industry, but I was looking for a graphical gizmo that I could click on a gene and see functions but they mean "map" in its functional programming term Although clicking through the first link does say "Interactive Website under construction..." so maybe this was just submitted too early or something
- caycep 4y agoit seems like that is a whole other skillset vs. biology graduate students...I know the Allen Institute employs data vis people to write visualisation tools like this in d3/react or whatever the web api du jour is, but they are separate from the science folks
- dekhn 4y agoHere's a link to the gene they mention: C7orf26 https://genome.ucsc.edu/cgi-bin/hgTracks?db=hg38&lastVirtModeType=default&lastVirtModeExtraState=&virtModeType=default&virtMode=0&nonVirtPosition=&position=chr7%3A6593761%2D6612466&hgsid=1375192377_nrQXzaDA44NJQx2z41IdMAi7nNRU https://genome.ucsc.edu/cgi-bin/hgTracks?db=hg38&lastVirtMod... To understand its function, it has its own wikipedia page(!) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/C7orf26 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/C7orf26 It's one of the remaining proteins whose "function" (to the extent that proteins can be said to have a "function") has not been reliably determined. There are sites for protein function, my favorite is Uniprot: https://www.uniprot.org/uniprot/Q96N11 https://www.uniprot.org/uniprot/Q96N11 as you can see, they don't really know what it does: "Probable component of the Integrator (INT) complex, a complex involved in the small nuclear RNAs (snRNA) U1 and U2 transcription and in their 3'-box-dependent processing.". The integrator complex is an important bit of machinery that helps transcript DNA to RNA on its path to protein expression: https://www.embl.org/news/science/at-the-core-of-the-integrator-complex https://www.embl.org/news/science/at-the-core-of-the-integra... In general, data presentation in biology is a pretty mixed bag. The field never attracted the level of UX investment that you see at ad-driven companies.
- lysozyme 4y agoThat’s true, software for biology tends to be terribly, almost comically bad, with one-off file formats, brittle data interchange, and impossible-to-maintain code being the norm. With user interface and ergonomics being the most neglected aspect. Why do you think that is? Surely there is plenty of money in biology these days to hire a good designers to design good user experiences. Surely better user experience for biology software would lead to better understanding of biological systems and better outcomes in bioengineering. Where are the polished, powerful design tools for biology like those that exist for other fields like online advertising that routinely process and distill huge amounts of lightly-structured data?
- cauthon 4y agoNever underestimate MIT’s ability to oversell itself. (EDIT: see below, this is directed at the press release, which I perceive to be overstating the achievements presented in the paper, not the quality of the paper itself)
- warent 4y agoCare to elaborate? This just seems like an empty criticism without any value or substance
- cauthon 4y agoSure. A genome-wide perturb-seq experiment is a huge (and expensive) technical accomplishment, but the authors did not "map every human gene to its function". (Nor did they claim to, it's press release hyperbole.) One, there's ~20k protein-coding genes in the human genome, and they screened ~10k, analyzing about 2k (fig 2a). Two, all the functional annotation is based off transcription profiles. They essentially looked for clusters of genes with correlated expression, and assigned function based on genes with previous annotations (fig 2d, S4). It's a good resource, but there's a lot more molecular work to be done to validate the function of these genes.
- timy2shoes 4y ago> Two, all the functional annotation is based off transcription profiles. They essentially looked for clusters of genes with correlated expression, and assigned function based on genes with previous annotations This is an important point, because if you've ever worked with single cell data you'll know that the transcriptional profile is extremely noisy and your transcriptional profile to cell type map has many researcher degrees of freedom. I heard a story about a paper early in the single cell work that started with 53 cell types and after review ended up with 37 cell types. Are those true cell types? Did the experimenters validate that those cell types all performed different functions? Well, of course not. That's way too much work. Then add on technological biases, which make mapping between technologies difficult. I say this because they used a new sequencing technology that appears to have homopolymer bias (https://twitter.com/lpachter/status/1533875723995185153 https://twitter.com/lpachter/status/1533875723995185153), which will bias the gene quantification.
- geysersam 4y agoI'm not a biologist. Still, do genes really have "functions"? Guess some have, such as producing an enzyme to break down a particular kind of suger. But that this would be the case for every human gene sounds unlikely to me.
- eurasiantiger 4y agoAll human proteins are encoded in genes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Human_proteins https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Human_proteins
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- projektfu 4y agoA gene is a DNA (or RNA) sequence that codes for some protein or RNA product. There are other functional sequences in DNA but they're not called genes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gene?wprov=sfti1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gene?wprov=sfti1
- dekhn 4y agoFor your last sentence: that's right, to get any press attention today you have to basically say you've solved all cancer or done something pan-genomic, in a way that massively overstates the importance of the specific result and its impact on health care delivery. That said, Jonathan Weissman is a great guy who has pushed the field forward and the techniques they are using really are powerful.
- panabee 4y agothanks for all your comments and insights. can you recommend other people to follow on the leading edge of integrating technology and biology?
- david_l_lin 4y agoAll genes have a function. This paper helps us understand genes of unknown function (which is a LOT of them). Some of these functions are not intuitive: maybe they regulate the function of another protein, maybe they only function in the context of a particular stressor, etc. You can think of nearly unlimited scenarios to apply and you start to understand the complexity of understanding how a gene functions.
- throwawayarnty 4y agoOne model of how science progresses is a few pioneers breaking new ground and then everyone else rushing in to pick up low hanging fruit in the new field. Looks like Weissman lab has consistently been breaking new ground over and over again. Extremely impressive and very few labs in the world have such a track record.
- jazzyjackson 4y agoThis is basically chaos engineering applied the the genome It doesn't say "this gene has this outcome" so much as it says "this outcome fails when this byte of data is missing"
- david_l_lin 4y agoNot really? It says that some genes result in the same outcome when knocked out as other genes, and identifies novel genes that putatively participate in the same pathways as others. This helps get at the potential function of genes without known functions.
- dekhn 4y agoSo, people do this a lot and frequently make mistakes. For example, when you knock out a gene, you also damage any overlapping genes (yes, genes can overlap). most studies don't pay attention to the damage they do to overlapping genes. The underlying physical model for how gene products interact to make phenotypes ends up being so hopelessly complex and latent that most conclusions in this area end up being "sufficient, but not necessary" instead of "necessary, but not sufficient"
- jazzyjackson 4y ago> It says that some genes result in the same outcome when knocked out as other genes a very useful map to make, but I don't see that this contradicts my comment - both genes in this case are dependencies to the outcome, without either of them, the outcome fails this does not sound to me like we know the "function" of these genes, only that they're nessary for each phenotype not to knock the research, just trying to make sense of what they're really mapping, in my own language of computer code (i suppose "function" has a different connotation in genetics)
- timy2shoes 4y ago> this does not sound to me like we know the "function" of these genes, only that they're nessary for each phenotype But they're not even measuring the phenotype. They're using the transciptional signature as a substitute for phenotype/cell function (i.e. the bag of RNA model). This is a poor substitute if you try to apply this to practical applications such as cell engineering. Let's say I perturb a cell to match it's transcriptional signature to that of a neuron. Does that make it a neuron? Not if it doesn't function like a neuron.
- achenet 4y agoThere's an interview with Ken Thompson from about 2008 where he says that most of the work in CS has already been done, and he's advising his son to go into biology. I feel like CRISPR is the transistor of the 21st century.
- jazzyjackson 4y agoI'm still holding out for photonics and other optical-analog computers (where are my instantaneous trig co-processors?) but that does sound like good advice
- Invictus0 4y agoAI?
- JKCalhoun 4y agoPerhaps also future biology?
- shimon 4y agoI studied CS and now work in software systems for biomedical research. It's difficult to overstate how different the fields are, so I don't entirely agree with this statement. But I do agree there are going to be lots and lots of huge discoveries in biology in the 21st century. The main difference is that CS attempts to generate and study complex systems built from well-understood components, whereas biology attempts to understand and manipulate systems that evolved naturally over eons. Imagine dropping a fully functional internet-connected Google Home Hub into 1960-era humanity and asking them to figure out how it works so they modify it to sound like Walter Cronkite. There are thousands of problems on this order of complexity in biology. It's wild.
- tyre 4y agothink of the tech debt in our legacy codebase
- 4y ago
- coryfklein 4y agoWait do we even know that every human gene has a 1:1 mapping to a function in the body? I think the code analogy to this would be trying to map "C++ if statements" to a particular feature in your product. I'd expect something as complicated as the genome would have a much richer and complicated interaction with biological feature expression. I'm probably simply misunderstanding; maybe Weissman's data is a 1:N mapping?
- astrange 4y agoThis kind of shallow presentation is common for genetics; compare reporting genetic traits by SNPs and implying the SNPs "cause" them, which is like diffing two versions of a program and saying X new feature happens because there's a letter 'n' in one program and not the other.
- shpongled 4y agoWe already know that many genes have more than one function (especially when you consider that one gene can produce many protein products)
- elif 4y agoI think mpeg encoding would be a better demonstrative than code... Where data is lost, details are lost, but the end result still typically renders into something recognizable. If you lose an iframe, you end up with a more serious deformity. Whereas code either does exactly what it says or does nothing at all, and knocking out a single statement is almost certain to break everything.
- axg11 4y agoThere’s not any type of mapping and this is what makes biology so difficult to study and understand. One gene can affect anywhere from zero other genes to every single gene. We also need to account for effects at every level of the central dogma of biology. Knockout of a gene can affect genetics, RNA, protein, and much more we don’t even know about yet. The other underestimated complicating factor is that biology is very nonlinear. A 10% increase in gene expression could lead to no resulting effect, whereas an 11% increase in expression could upregulate downstream genes by 1000x.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- atlasunshrugged 4y agoAnyone know where the state of the art is happening in applied 'designer baby' tech? I feel like there hasn't been much news since the arrest of the scientist who claimed to be the first to change the genes of live kids but I'm shocked there aren't some people out there pushing the envelope on this (and/or commercializing it).
- loxias 4y ago> New CRISPR-based map ties every human gene to its function The title would be so much better if s/its/a/. There is no way we'll have an operative map from "all" genes to function anytime soon. Sometimes hundreds of genes work together, interact with other microbiomes we contain or our environment to produce what might seem to be a "simple" quality like height.
- grej 4y agoAnother cool thing, their paper mentions that, "The specific implementation is based on the python package torch-two-sample, modified to use numba for improved performance." ( https://www.cell.com/action/showPdf?pii=S0092-8674%2822%2900597-9 https://www.cell.com/action/showPdf?pii=S0092-8674%2822%2900... ) If you haven't checked out the numba package, definitely worth a look for custom numerical computing in Python! disclosure - have made a small contribution to the package.
- cvccvroomvroom 4y agoNot in the field. Q: How can the human genome be "mapped" without sampling and sequencing genetic material from millions of individuals? Is it a sequencing of one individual?
- eibhinn 4y agoWe have thousands of human genomes sequenced now.
- cvccvroomvroom 4y agoWho is "we"? How many? How are the SNPs and larger differences in genes and unique genes placed into an ontology?
- imchillyb 4y agoThis is akin to taking an automobile apart piece-by-piece, not to determine its function but just to figure out if the automobile fails substantially by removing say a taillight, dome light, dash light, or wiper delay fuse. The car's not gonna fail for each piece, it'll take forever to determine what pieces are absolutely necessary, and it doesn't tell ya shit about what the pieces functions are. Neat, but ultimately inefficient and exceedingly limited in necessary detail to make the claim in the article's title.
- bryans 4y agoAn article from MIT:TR in the early 2000s always stuck with me as an example of how intricate and interconnected genes really are. Researchers using fruit flies found one born with white eyes, and they narrowed the mutation to a specific gene. They were able to modify it in vivo to reliably produce white eyes, but the change had an unexpected second outcome, which was that white-eyed males would only attempt to mate with other males. Years later, there was a group who cited that fruit fly paper when they proposed the same methodology to control mosquito populations, but I'm not sure if they ever recreated the male preference. The mosquito gene editing did pan out, but the method is different in that it doesn't allow females to survive, while males will go on to mate with other non-edited populations and spread the female-killing gene.
- rootsudo 4y agoThis is cool, so in laymans terms - you can disable the bad "genes" and just express/enable/push the "good ones." So how do we define what is a bad gene? If we use crispr, can we turn it off on an actual, live, aging human being or only before they're "born" or such? Is there a good resource/book that gets someone from zero to a basic biological understanding and background of this and above? I really have no idea, nor do I know who to ask. :(
- moron4hire 4y agoSo, like... I'm pretty ignorant on biology, genetics, gene editing, and such. But... could one alter their genetics for, say, poor eyesight and eventually have better eyes? I mean, I imagine that there is a shelf life for cells already in the body and they don't just go away right away. But they are also constantly being replaced, right? So... can I just... rewrite my genome to replace my eye cells with "better" eye cells? And--hypothetically speaking, for sure, certainly, I assure you--who might be capable of such a thing, and what might they like as remuneration?
- jzer0cool 4y agoWould love to dive in looking into the data, but I don't understand it. Could someone share how to "read" the data file both from non-technical and technical perspective. Right now not sure how to interpret the data and I also do not have a biology/gene background.
- balsam 4y agoDo you have a direct link to the data you mention? Something more specific than a general “help! I am lost!” would go a long way. I dont really see it in the article. OTOH, here is the wikipage of the one gene mentioned https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/C7orf26 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/C7orf26 EDIT: dekhn below expands on this
- ngcc_hk 4y agoVery frightening … good to know relativity but then we have nuclear bomb. Not sure the negative side to this. Just hope the good side out win any bad use of information about all of us.