9 ms·
Colombia shares unprecedented images of treasure-laden wreck
- kurupt213 4y agoI think we are just scratching the surface. There should be 4,000+ years of these cultural time capsules. This one looks amazing. I hope they are able to raise the wreck and preserve the structure
- dpeck 4y agoIt is so good to see an archeological announcement article that includes photos of the actual find! Great that they shared them.
- belval 4y ago> When that happens, though, Colombia will face a challenge from Spain and an indigenous group in Bolivia to determine who keeps the bounty. I understand the Colombian and Bolivian claims, but Spain trying to get their blood gold 300 years after enslaving and murdering the natives is a bit rich.
- yesenadam 4y agoI know, right - "Spain insists that the bounty is theirs since it was aboard a Spanish ship" - I couldn't believe that! Like if you catch someone stealing stuff from your house and loading it into a truck, and they say "It's mine because it's it my truck". Not just saying it, but insisting on it in court. Shameful.
- frozenlettuce 4y agoIt's interesting because because former colonial powers argue that they acted by the moral standards of that time - and thus can't be judged today for that. And on the first opportunity they demonstrate that we didn't improved much as a species.
- adastra22 4y agoThat is absolutely standard legal practice though. Laws generally aren’t retroactive for good reason.
- FpUser 4y agoI understand non retroactive part. But claiming stolen gold now - I do not think it should ever be legal. On top of that it is simple disgusting. Really shows what their values are. Enlightened society my ass. They should be shown middle finger.
- seoaeu 4y agoI think the claim is that back then the law was “finders keepers” so it shouldn’t retroactively be called theft. Personally I don’t find that argument very compelling.
- adastra22 4y agoIt was never stolen though. Wars of conquest and slavery were perfectly legal under international law at the time. I agree it’s a dick move by Spain and really tarnishes their reputation today. But that’s not a legal argument.
- happy_path 4y agoAnother example: Is UK going to pay reparations to its old colonies? Don't think so.
- ajmurmann 4y agoWhose moral standards at the time? Seems like there was no agreement between indigenous South Americans' government and Spanish invaders at the time either.
- AlotOfReading 4y agoMore specifically, the Brussels convention that underlies modern marine salvage law carves out military ships as exempt from salvage rules. Spain insists on being tone deaf and maintains that their treasure ships were in fact military vessels and that the cargo is therefore still the property of Spain.
- happy_path 4y agoIs the US government going to return their lands to Native American peoples?
- galactus 4y agoTheir statement was something like “hey, thanks for finding our stuff. Please let us know when we can have it back.”. You gotta admire the chutzpah.
- pacetherace 4y agoLot of colonial claims become bogus if they don’t continue to keep that stance
- escapecharacter 4y agoYou know, it would certainly lighten my mood if we had a lil pirate gold war in 2022. I think it would be good for us all.
- siod 4y agoHonestly by that logic the British have a stronger claim, they sunk the ship. (Both claims would be/are farcical)
- elnatro 4y agoNot according to the law of the sea.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pestatije 4y agoAs a Catalan... that's standard behaviour for Spain since more than 300 years. No surprises there. If the Colombians don't give the treasure willingly the Spanish will start calling them tight arses.
- nsbk 4y agoHow is "As a Catalan..." relevant in this context?
- AlotOfReading 4y agoThe costs of putting down catalonian rebellions were one of the major fiscal issues of the 17th century Spanish Empire and a substantial portion of the gold on this ship would have gone towards the war of Spanish Succession, which itself resulted in the Nueva Planta Decrees that contributed to modern Catalan nationalism. It's certainly not irrelevant here, plus you know... centuries of conflict with Spain.
- TexasBall 4y agoI've always thought the Spanish succession war involved Spain, France, Great Britain, Netherlands and Germany[1]. Today I learnt it was about a catalonian rebellion. [1]https://militarymaps.rct.uk/war-of-the-spanish-succession-1701-14#:~:text=The%20war%20was%20fought%20between,support%20of%20Philip%20of%20Anjou https://militarymaps.rct.uk/war-of-the-spanish-succession-17....
- happy_path 4y agoHowever, Catalonia was not a kingdom but a region inside the Kingdom of Aragon, like Valencia, for example.
- AlotOfReading 4y agoThe "Catalonian rebellion" I was mentioned was the Reaper's War, which was hugely expensive for Spain and the payments for which involved what would become a long series of currency devaluations. The war of Spanish Succession was between the countries you mentioned, as well as Catalonia as a part of both Spain and France. One important event in that war was the formation of an army of Habsburg loyalists by Catalonia to dispute the treaties of Utrecht. This in turn led to the Nueva Planta decrees and the end of Catalonia as an autonomous principality within Spain. If you have any more questions about imperial Spain (particularly the colonies) or you'd like me to go into more depth, feel free to ask. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reapers%27_War https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reapers%27_War
- frozenlettuce 4y ago200t is more than many country gold reserves https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/gold-reserves-by-country https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/gold-rese...
- kingcharles 4y agoAt the time it must have represented a sizeable proportion of the world's gold. There was significantly less gold mined in the early 18th century when this vessel was sunk.
- xref 4y ago200t is “gold, silver, and emeralds”
- bogota 4y agoFrom the article it’s believed a large portion of the 200t is gold. In the 150t range.
- dotancohen 4y ago> In the 150t range. For context, that's more than the Saturn V payload to orbit. The Galleon San José must have been the Saturn V of its time, literally traveling to what was to Europeans a strange new world.
- JoBrad 4y agoSide rant: What a crappy color scheme.
- dr_dshiv 4y agoThis will be the century of underwater archaeology. We will learn so much that we thought was lost for good.
- the42thdoctor 4y ago> When that happens, though, Colombia will face a challenge from Spain and an indigenous group in Bolivia to determine who keeps the bounty. They should de divide the gold between all the natives (indigenous) of the region. I don't think the gold should go to Colombia simply because that country did exist back then, the Spanish were stealing from natives. At the very least they should give all the gold to some branch of government concerned with indigenous rights.
- FpUser 4y ago>"They should de divide the gold between all the natives" I wish. But in practice I'd say when the hell freezes over.
- dylan604 4y ago>when the hell freezes over as if there is only one. i live at least 3 different hells per day
- oh_sigh 4y agoTo be fair, the natives who would receive the money didn't exist either back then.
- smt88 4y ago> To be fair There's no way to be fair with this. There is no "rightful owner" of this gold, so anything that's done with it is unfair in some way. It's true that the descendants of the people who were harmed in the collection (stealing, mining, or both) of that gold were not alive then, but their current conditions were determined by the behavior of the colonists who collected the gold. They would have inherited a very different (likely better) life if the colonists had not arrived.
- dotancohen 4y ago> They would have inherited a very different (likely better) life if the colonists had not arrived. This presents a very rosy-glasses version of history, likely based on the noble savage myth. Do you have any idea how the standard of living has changed in the past 600 years? Malnutrition, disease, lifespan, hours of leisure, infant mortality, are all far better today than they were in Precolumbian south america, even among the poor.
- Reason077 4y agoBackground on the Galleon San José: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_galleon_San_José https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_galleon_San_José It's believed that the gold, silver, and emeralds on board could be worth up to $17 billion at today's values.
- lesgobrandon 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- thrwy_meta 4y agoI wonder how well the Colombian Navy patrols this area. I doubt they have a 24/7/365 presence. This is begging for a pitch deck to a shady bank like HSBC: angel fund my startup to rapidly design/deploy some sonar-equipped unmanned submersibles to locate and snatch as much of this gold as possible from under everyone's noses. I know a guy who works robotics, a guy who studied underwater comms, a geologist interested in undersea mining....I can probably dig up a retired submariner through some Navy contacts....Hmmmm... You don't need a sub with the crush depth of a Triton 36000/2[1] (price: $50 million), but you do need something with a large carry capacity to reduce the number of trips needed to exploit the site. Maybe something like Boeing's Orca would suffice. [2][3] Even if you spent $100 mil on the sub, $100 mil on the surface ship and staff, maybe even a few million bribing some Colombian Navy/Coast Guard officers.....for a chance to make off with $12 billion in gold (at the current spot price)? Seems like a no-brainer for somebody to fund such an endeavor. [1] https://tritonsubs.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/Datasheet-Triton-36000-2-March-2020.pdf https://tritonsubs.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/Datasheet-... [2] https://www.naval-technology.com/analysis/boeing-orca-xluuv-unmanned-submarine/ https://www.naval-technology.com/analysis/boeing-orca-xluuv-... [3] https://www.popularmechanics.com/military/navy-ships/a26344025/navy-extra-large-unmanned-submarines-boeing/ https://www.popularmechanics.com/military/navy-ships/a263440...
- boomboomsubban 4y agoHow exactly did they give away the location? I struggle to imagine how those pictures would help, unless they left the exif data. And if knowing it was in Columbian waters was enough to find it with publicly available tools it'd likely have already been discovered.
- thrwy_meta 4y ago>>>How exactly did they give away the location? They didn't, not with sufficient detail. Hence the need for the sonar on the submersibles, probably need to do some undersea mapping to pinpoint the wreck. I only know it is "near" Islas del Rosario. It's in water 950 meters deep, so the average concerned citizen can't exactly strap on a wetsuit and go poking around the ocean floor for it. This site [1] from 2015 claimed it was in 300 meter waters, ~25km from Cartagena. Some of the infographics suggest it is NW of Isla del Tesoro. Maybe best to look at nautical charts of the area, and plot a course from west of Isla Rosario to northwest of Isla del Tesoro, along the part of the sea floor that is ~900m deep (course runs roughly NE). Map/scan that with the sonar on the submersibles, focus on major "outcroppings" that are possibly the San Jose (or the other two nearby shipwrecks). For a second pass, go straight to those outcroppings with a higher-resolution scan, plus visual cameras (use the released photos as reference for visual confirmation). Once pinpointed, send in the bigger cargo-carrier sub with robotic arms, excavator shovel, etc. and start scooping up the treasure. Split it 60/40 with HSBC, and your team still gets to keep ~$4.7 BILLION. That's a better unicorn offramp than building yet another BS SaaS cloud app. [1] https://blog.geogarage.com/2015/12/spanish-galleon-may-contain-biggest.html https://blog.geogarage.com/2015/12/spanish-galleon-may-conta...
- tjbiddle 4y agoFinders Keepers.
- bobhutfghh 4y agoTg
- jl6 4y agoDetermining the owner of this treasure will be fascinating. By modern standards, the treasures are ill-gotten gains, extracted by force from an occupied territory. But it was so long ago that the countries and populations involved have only passing resemblance to their modern descendants. Spain does appear to have recognized law on their side - it was a Spanish flagged ship, and modern Spain is the recognized successor of historical imperial Spain. But giving the treasure to Spain would be tantamount to endorsing colonial looting. On the other hand, giving it to anyone else sets a precedent for distributing colonial-era wealth as some form of reparations, and trying to unpick hundreds of years of history and population mixing to work out exactly who should be a beneficiary seems an impossibility. Maybe it should stay sunken until we have matured a little more as a species.
- zivkovicp 4y agoI think it's a clear cut case of "finders keepers" :)
- MikePlacid 4y ago> trying to unpick hundreds of years of history and population mixing to work out exactly who should be a beneficiary seems an impossibility. That’s definitely interesting. Consider: - Stalin paid for American war supplies with gold during WWII (see HMS Edinburgh e.g.); - This gold was obtained via forced labor; - My relatives were made part of the forced labor force; Not yet a hundred of years of history, not much of population mixing yet - I am here and not mixed with anyone except my wife, not much to unpick. So just tell me: which part of the US Treasury should be mine, if you do not want to endorse imperialistic looting?
- RobertoG 4y agoIronically, part of that gold came from Spain. History is complicated. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moscow_gold_(Spain) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moscow_gold_(Spain)
- towaway15463 4y agoExactly, if we attempt to adjudicate crimes committed by people long dead by using their descendants as stand ins then we will be quickly overcome by madness. Its just nonsensical, you can’t come to a just conclusion with no evidence, no witnesses and no suspects remaining. You might as well write a fantasy story and call it truth.
- happy_path 4y agoFor other similar case (this time the shipwreck was found in Portugal) see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuestra_Se%C3%B1ora_de_las_Mercedes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuestra_Se%C3%B1ora_de_las_Mer... A private company (Odyssey Marine Exploration) salvaged the wreck illegally: > On February 17, 2012, it was reported that U.S. Magistrate Judge Mark Pizzo ordered Odyssey to return the coins to Spain by February 24, 2012, where they will be dispersed to museums, not to heirs. The Supreme Court declined to stay this order and Odyssey will abide by the decision.[23] On February 24, 2012, two C-130 Hercules aircraft from the Spanish Air Force picked up the treasure in Florida and transported it to Spain.[24] Odyssey petitioned the Supreme Court to reconsider the issues in the case but on May 14, 2012, the court declined to take up the appeal.[25] The coins have been returned to Spain, whereby Spanish law dictates that they can never be sold to the public. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Swan_Project https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Swan_Project The treasure can be visited at the Museno Nacional de Arqueología Subacuática in Cartagena (Murcia, Spain) https://www.culturaydeporte.gob.es/mnarqua/colecciones/piezas-seleccionadas/edad-moderna/nsm.html https://www.culturaydeporte.gob.es/mnarqua/colecciones/pieza... Some maps an information about the ship https://www.elmundo.es/cultura/laesferadepapel/2021/11/26/6172f755fc6c83b9478b4748.html https://www.elmundo.es/cultura/laesferadepapel/2021/11/26/61...
- happy_path 4y agoLegally the treasure of shipwrecks belongs to the nation whose flag was flying on her mast. However, as a good faith, a portion of the treasure could (and should) be given to Colombia. Spain and Colombia are brother countries, I'm sure we can find some agreement (I hope!).
- dvh1990 4y ago"Colombia found the wreck of a Spanish treasure ship, sunk in 1708. Experts believe it contains at least 200 tons of gold, silver and emeralds. Colombia considers wrecks found in its territorial waters to be part of its cultural heritage, meaning the contents cannot be sold. Spain insists that the bounty is theirs since it was aboard a Spanish ship, while Bolivia's Qhara Qhara nation says it should get the treasures as the Spanish forced the community's people to mine the precious metals." Sounds like a Star Trek TNG episode. Where's Picard?
- musikele 4y agoThe least thing I'd do is to give the treasure to Spain. For the number of deaths and for the consequent slavery, I don't think the "occupation" and the sack of primary goods can be considered peaceful. Comparing to modern times, it's like giving back to Germans some treasure that Hitler found somewhere else...
- elzbardico 4y agoI can’t believe colonial Spain thinks it has a claim on it. Simply unbelievable! They should be paying reparations instead, for all the colonial exploitation