20 ms·
Norway to track all supermarket purchases?
- kzrdude 4y agoIt's ok that the government wants this data, but the data protection agency needs to tell them no, that's not possible, and maybe work with them to make something similar possible - but that respects privacy. Due to the database leak effect, I hope they do a good job.
- SnowHill9902 4y agoCan you pay cash?
- binz120 4y agoYeah you could haha I think the majority of the public wouldn't care about their food purchases being tracked.
- TedDoesntTalk 4y agoReally? What if it includes alcohol sales? Do you want the state to know how much alcohol you consume?
- SnowHill9902 4y agoYou can’t buy alcohol at the supermarket in Norway.
- samstave 4y ago"How many villages does a Man need to Pillage to get a drink in this place?!"
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- m-s 4y agoYes, you can. But only drinks with up to 4.7% abv
- Tor3 4y agoYou can buy alcohol at the supermarket in Norway, it's just that it's limited to alcohol of 4.5%vol. or lower (i.e. the supermarkets sell beer and alcohol cider and the like).
- charlieyu1 4y ago4.5%, no thanks. Easier to get water intoxication than feel anything about alcohol.
- gyaru 4y agoThe state owns the only alcohol store.
- Tor3 4y agoSee my comment above - you can buy beer elsewhere, unless it's stronger than the typical lager.
- jerzyt 4y agoAnd what will stop them from monitoring the alcohol sales?
- Tor3 4y agoI replied to the statement "The state owns the only alcohol store." - the only text in the comment I replied to. And as it's factually wrong, I replied with a comment stating just that. There was nothing about monitoring in the comment I replied to, nor in my reply. As for monitoring - as said elsewhere, if monitoring of supermarket sales will happen or not depends not only on what that particular office wants (SSB - central statistics bureau), but what politicians decide on. And, despite many comments here believing otherwise, it is actually quite common for Norwegian politicians to listen to massive resistance from the people, particularly when the reasoning behind the whole suggestion is quite questionable, as in this case. In any case, whether alcohol is sold here or there it wouldn't make any difference to the monitoring. And cash is still legal tender in Norway, even if there are some that don't like that fact. As for myself I believe only Mastercard really know how much money I use on wine. I don't think they know my preferences though (Italian, as it were)
- neither_color 4y agoSounds like Virginia. A lot of states have a similar system in place: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alcoholic_beverage_control_state https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alcoholic_beverage_control_sta...
- ekianjo 4y ago> The state owns the only alcohol store. How do they feel about being responsible of delivering poison to people then? Somehow I can rationalize it if it's a transaction between private parties, but if the government acts as the drug dealer it's no better than a cartel.
- admash 4y agoIn case you were unaware, all liquor stores in Norway are run by the government — “vinmonopolet” as they are called. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vinmonopolet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vinmonopolet
- TedDoesntTalk 4y agoThat misses the point.
- marcc 4y agoSarcasm? I think most people should care about this.
- binz120 4y agoYes. They start with food and then god knows what else they will track. Give them an inch and they will take a mile.
- Zigurd 4y agoWhat do you think happens to online food delivery orders? That all gets sold to data brokers.
- convolvatron 4y agobecause I used the same credit card at Whole Foods as linked to my amazon account my last shopping trip there showed up in 'recently purchased' and 'suggestions'. are we upset because the Norwegian government is getting the same information that Amazon is clearly mining?
- rglullis 4y agoYou don't pay taxes (yet?) to Amazon.
- guerrilla 4y agoThey pay profit instead. What's it matter though?
- rglullis 4y agoThe ability to collect taxes was shorthand for "the right to use force to compel you to do things as they see fit". Amazon can not compel you to buy from them, and Amazon can not throw you in jail if they don't like you as a customer. Mining personal data and using it against the interests of the individual is bad in both cases, but it is far more dangerous when done by the State.
- nine_k 4y agoThis assumes that the scope of tracking is somehow naturally limited to grocery, and can't extend. Also, the technically easiest way to track grocery purchases can be by tracking all purchases, and then filtering out the non-grocery. Let's generalize the question: what makes you uncomfortable about the government tracking all your (non-cash) purchases? They already know your income for tax purposes, and much of your large purchases, also for tax purposes. And if you need a pinch of stuff that's illegal, you're not going to swipe your debit card anyway. I suppose a court order will show all your bank operations history, should the government need it for lawful purposes. So, if there's still anything left to preserve, we need to clearly articulated first, what that is.
- digitallyfree 4y agoI feel it's similar to people "not caring" about corporate tracking (e.g. browser tracking, or cell phone companies selling location data) - i.e. by turning a blind eye to it as long as their services work and so on. They accept it as the norm and do not push back against these measures. They know that it's happening and don't like it, like how they won't like the Norweigan government's decision. But they'll likely put up little resistance and move on to other things.
- ekianjo 4y ago> wouldn't care about their food purchases being tracked You dont buy only food in supermarkets these days.
- reaperducer 4y agothe majority of the public wouldn't care about their food purchases being tracked. Citizen #83238201: You have exceeded your yearly purchasing quota for condoms and thrush medication. Please report to your nearest moral re-education camp.
- Svip 4y agoThere is still a receipt even if you pay cash. It's just that in that case, _only_ the supermarket and the buyer know of the transaction.
- Enginerrrd 4y agoOstensibly... But if you ever pay with a card, it's quite likely those with the data will be able to correlate your cash purchases with the card purchase and thus identify you.
- finnh 4y agoHow? Unless you input a form of ID (like a telephone number in a loyalty program) I don't see how a cash transaction can be linked to you at all. It's not like your cash purchase of 58.32kr has a match 578.32 kr withdrawal; that cash was taken from an ATM in a large, round-number bundle.
- lkschubert8 4y agoI think they are more likely referring to being able to create a fingerprint of what you purchase. If you purchase via card enough times its not unreasonable that a model could be created to link your cash transactions back to you.
- Enginerrrd 4y agoYes that's exactly what I was referring to. Papers have been written on this subject. When you're buying quite a few items, it's quite hard not to be relatively unique.
- InvaderFizz 4y agoI believe the reference is to utilizing pattern matching in the items and quantities purchased. We are creatures of habit and tend to repeat the same activities and purchases.
- Karellen 4y ago
- ekianjo 4y agoNow you know why governments want you to move away from cash transactions. Cash is evil anyway because it can be used to evade taxes, finance terrorism and purchase drugs! Think about the children!
- zmgsabst 4y agoThe Stasi would be jealous.
- dasil003 4y agoSure, they would have loved to have Norwegian levels of government trust, but that's antithetical to the way the Soviet Union was set up.
- DeathArrow 4y agoStasi was the secret police in East Germany.
- dasil003 4y agoYes I'm aware of that. Do you believe the GDR could have established meaningful trust with the populace independent of Soviet policy?
- tloriato 4y ago“Hello #3576. You have reached your 1kg monthly limit of natural meat. Please consult the official list for alternatives.”
- baisq 4y ago
- ekianjo 4y ago> Please consult the official list for alternatives.” More likely a new way to tax stuff that the government does not like. Eating too much red-meat from methane-producing cows? Extra climate change tax for you!
- fullshark 4y agoCan’t they just add a meat sales tax to accomplish that?
- klipt 4y agoOr just measure the methane output and charge the farmers a tax on that directly. That would give them incentive to feed their cows that methane reducing seaweed.
- MontyCarloHall 4y ago
- verisimi 4y agoTell me again how we're not moving into technocracy, with everything micromanaged, every purchase accounted for (by the government). 'Its perfectly fine for governments to know this info'. The end of banks, and central bank digital currency and social credit systems are just around the corner.
- rvz 4y agoAll of what you have just said is totally correct. Will be made worse if not is already worse with closed-source software, zero privacy, internet-of-things, artificial intelligence and blockchains as I said before. [0] Anyone standing in the way of this have failed to stop it entirely and we will end up co-existing with these things in a few years or so. So it is not a surprise at all to see Norway do this. A new world order of CBDCs, IoT and more invasive tracking, etc led by members of the World Government Summit. Oh dear. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31617042 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31617042
- jacooper 4y agoBlockchains ? If anything, blockchains mighg be the things that end government control over finance. And not all cryptocurrencies are public, monero and zcash exist.
- Havoc 4y agoOpen to abuse & certainly not privacy friendly, but in a hypothetical world where governments can be trusted on that it seems very plausible that it could be a social plus. i.e. You can probably spot trends like person X spends a huge amount of their pay on nappies and babyfood...probably could do with some additional social help. Nordic countries probably come closest to said hypothetical but still seems kinda dicey
- cuteboy19 4y agoOr people can just ask for help if they need it
- axg11 4y agoThe people in society who need help the most often have the least trust in government and don't have the means to understand and navigate programmes that could help them.
- californical 4y agoHow does surveilling them and then coming to them with assistance increase their trust? Seems like it would decrease trust. I mean I distrust a lot of government functions, and would trust them less in that case.
- hutzlibu 4y agoThis might be, because the programs are often not helpful. Here in germany I know stories of how asking for help mainly resulted in the children taken away (and cared for badly). It depends on the area and the people working on it, I also know of good institutions, but I can see, why the so called underclass is sceptical of the common state institutions. Most help that comes, comes with hard obligations, that mainly keep them down. Give a struggeling person a bunch of paperwork to fill out and he or she will just struggle more. And only once they are down enough, they get a certain label and then they get a more or less competent government helper, putting them totally into dependent state. Most have accepted their state as retarded by then and rarely make it up again.
- giantg2 4y ago"SSB claims they want a less time-consuming way of collecting and analysing household consumption statistics in order to inform tax policy, social assistance and child allowance." Aka the more we know about you, the more efficiently we can create policies to control your behavior to our liking.
- tylerdurden91 4y agoThey state they're only interested in group level data, isnt there a way to collect data that is not able to link purchases to any individual. Theoretically, it seems possible, if the data is never stored against the SSB, but only stored pre-aggregated against demographic markers such as location, age, etc. If so, wouldn't it be a net win that the government has data to better plan import/export or anything else and maybe make this data public so people can use this data to come up with new businesses in the right locations without compromising individual privacy.
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoOr to tax you more efficiently.
- rglullis 4y agoDistinction without a difference
- data-ottawa 4y agoIsn’t that just what sales tax is for? Another comment mentioned increasing your tax bracket if you bought too much meat, but trivially they could just add a sales tax on meat instead to the same effect.
- rglullis 4y agoWith this they can make a progressive sales tax. "Oh, if you buy meat according to the national average, you pay the standard tax. But if you are eating more than that, you pay double."
- andreshb 4y agoMore the reason to not feed your guests
- daniel-cussen 4y agoGestapo's dream. I think they did in fact track purchases--not very efficiently--to find who was hiding Jews in their basement. Though maybe at least if it's government-tracked that's better than only being corporate-tracked. And there have to be escape-hatches.
- FpUser 4y agoThis is insanity and will definitely lead to abuse.
- mateo1 4y agoPeople seem to suddenly forget that these transactions are already tracked and individually linked to you. Should we allow anyone to collect that data except democratically elected governments? What's the logic behind this?
- mdmglr 4y ago> People seem to suddenly forget that these transactions are already tracked and individually linked to you. Is this true? I thought only if you joined a rewards program.
- charlieyu1 4y agoIn most countries, paying in cash is a thing. And I try to avoid paying with cards or e-payment as much as I can
- JohnJamesRambo 4y agoYou must have hella change laying around.
- charlieyu1 4y agoNot much, because I also pay in coins in exact amounts.
- AlbertCory 4y agoI don't know about him, but my Safeway has a change machine up front. You can either get the total in cash, minus commission, or store credit for the whole amount.
- hutzlibu 4y agoMy bank in germany has a machine, where I can put them in to be transfered to my account. (but I think I only ever did that once)
- somehnacct3757 4y agoIf you always carry your change with you and spend it whenever possible, your coin quantity will remain pocketable. You gotta be committed enough to hand over a twenty dollar bill alongside a quarter, when paying a $19.17 bill for example. Rather than take in 83 cents you take in 8 (and score a dollar.)
- Tor3 4y agoI went and checked various online papers with comment sections, and the comments have been massively negative to this. This is apparently not something people will easily accept, so it remains to be seen what happens.
- ekianjo 4y agoSince when do governments care about what people think? Even with mass demonstrations they typically hardly move an inch.
- jacooper 4y agoI mean, Norway should be one of the most Democratic countries, so it should have an effect, but it will probably not since its protests against giving them more power.
- guruz 4y agoPlease check rank of https://www.statista.com/statistics/679796/democracy-index-most-democratic-countries/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/679796/democracy-index-m... :-)
- guerrilla 4y agoThat is a joke. Sweden is 4th on that list. Despite the fact that the vast majority voted for anti-NATO parties, they just refused to have a referendum or wait until the election (in 90 days) to make a decision and explicitly stated they will not consult us. (No, polls aren't elections. Don't even start.) This isn't exactly unique either. They regularly do things people don't want and can't stop. On top of that, we have powerful lobbyists and shittons of propaganda too, just like everyone else.
- baal80spam 4y ago> I went and checked various online papers with comment sections, and the comments have been massively negative to this Thank God.
- lordnacho 4y agoWorth remembering the whole reason this can even be suggested is that Scandies tend to have high trust. Not saying there won't be similar voices to what is in this comment section, but plenty of Norwegians will take this at face value, an honest attempt to gather socially useful information, part of a tradition that has historically functioned reasonably well.
- MontyCarloHall 4y agoThen why explicitly link the data to people’s national ID numbers? If analyzing societal trends were the only purpose of this initiative, anonymized (or for some applications, aggregated) data would work equally well.
- Beltalowda 4y agoThe article already answers this: "When the purchases are linked to a household, it will be possible in the consumption statistics to analyze socio-economic and regional differences in consumption, and link it to variables such as income, education and place of residence."
- MontyCarloHall 4y agoThat can still be done with anonymized data. It is not necessary to associate purchasing habits with national ID numbers to perform the analyses you listed.
- Beltalowda 4y agoI fail to see how you can get this kind of data from anonymized supermarket receipts? Entirely different data collection methods: sure. But the entire point of this is that was too difficult ("time-consuming and error-prone", according to the SSB).
- MontyCarloHall 4y ago
- DeathArrow 4y agoWelcome to the Brave New World.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- MontyCarloHall 4y agoGiven that this is Norway, the cynic in me thinks this is not about getting better demographic data as claimed, but rather to lay the groundwork for progressive sales taxes: your sales tax rate (potentially only for certain items) increases relative to your income and/or consumption habits. If this were just about demographics, it would be relatively straightforward to anonymize purchase records. (Massive privacy implications aside, I don't necessarily disagree with progressive sales taxation.)
- elephantum 4y agoRussia does that already country-wise. Every receipt is sent to federal taxes office instantly, every cash register is connected to the internet.
- el-salvador 4y agoEl Salvador does this too for business to business receipts. It doesn't include item descriptions though, only totals.
- jacooper 4y agoSome Arab gulf countries do this too
- kzrdude 4y agoOne of the big grocery stores in sweden (coop) closed all their shops for a week last year due to a ransomware attack. So yeah, all those cash registers were and are connected to the internet.
- axg11 4y agoThere's a general reaction that big government is bad, more tracking is bad. Norway ranks highly in most metrics of development and quality of life. Perhaps in a high trust society this type of data collection is a positive.
- mdmglr 4y agoWhat do you mean by “high trust society”? The people trust the government agencies? I agree data collection can be positive. I think next they should start collecting any tweet, comment, or text file citizens write so they can see how good the public education system is doing. Actually the state should run an SSO service. Every computer, phone, tv and device must use the states SSO so that the person behind the device is tracked. State should also run an MDM solution. Every Smart watch should send all vitals to see how good nutrition is. Add microphones and camera everywhere to see if any crime is happening. (If you can’t tell by now I’m not being serious.)
- axg11 4y agoHigh trust society, as in: there is a high degree of trust between any two random people that they are likely to act in each other’s benefit when it comes to societal issues. That is fundamentally how I view taxes. We’re contributing to a common fund for common good.
- DeathArrow 4y agoThe ideological left push us more and more towards a dystopic future. Which doesn't seem very distant.
- Elinvynia 4y agoThe ideological left of neoliberalism, which has only been gaining ground everywhere since the 70's :)
- zmgsabst 4y agoCollectivist authoritarians will always cause totalitarianism as a “step toward Utopia”. The logical conclusion of their beliefs is to enslave people “for their own good”.
- Iv 4y agoYeah, fuck the leftist ideology that gave us the PATRIOT act, the legalization of torture, that wages wars on lies with no long term plans, who made the Echelon network a mass surveillance network. Fuck these neocon hippies.
- dane-pgp 4y agoAh yes, mass surveillance is well known to be only supported by left-wing ideologues, such as Viktor Orbán: https://www.connectontech.com/2016-2-19-hungary-condemned-for-its-mass-surveillance-program/ https://www.connectontech.com/2016-2-19-hungary-condemned-fo...
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- PartiallyTyped 4y agoIt isn't the left that keeps pushing authoritarianism around the world, see Orban, Putin, Trump, DeSantis, Abbott and the likes. Touch some grass.
- samstave 4y agoOne of the things I have long wanted in the USA: An app/website/whatever-service which allows the scanning of a receipt/UPC code - which takes the scan data and the price for ITEM.' Then allows me to track ITEM $ over time, and between vendors / stores. Ideally I also want to be able to track ORIGIN, thus if I am tracking the cost of an ITEM which has an ORIGIN of non-US-country, I can track over time the cost of a product that was made over-seas. The reason this is of interest to me - is I like to see where the inlfation of costs is occurring. As an example, there is a juice that I like to buy which was $1.34 per half-gallon. It quickly became $1.50 during the pandemic, pre-gas price hikes etc. It was a product that was standard stock forever, its made in the US, and I am convinced that this item was just price lifted, but not because of economies of delivery... As compared to a product which , say, comes from Thailand - which is shipped over-the-sea, and there are no price hikes. This can give you insight into where profits are being harvested. Additionally, one would do well to know ImportYeti ; a service to examine the source ORIGIN of products that you find which are made in China, in order to get the actual mfr for a product - such that if you want to cut out all middle men, you can contact the factories directly.
- forgot_user1234 4y agoNAV is an Extremely well run org. I believe in the system and I believe Norwegian state will do the right thing Case in point - look at the tech platform docs for NAVs tech teams - https://nais.io/ https://nais.io/
- rhn_mk1 4y agoThat's a reasonable stance as long as you believe that no change will ever happen. Neither peaceful change from within, nor violent from outside.
- dane-pgp 4y agoThe dynamics of such a system are rarely considered, which is why it's such an easy trap for societies to fall into, especially societies with high regard for their institutions. It starts with the voices of reason ("Isn't there a danger this data could be abused?") being slowly pushed out, through lack of promotions or being transferred to other departments where they are a "better fit". Then this government body starts to attract the naive zealots ("Just think of all the good we can do! How could anyone see a problem with us collecting more data?") which becomes self-reinforcing. The final step is when the ambitious and malicious take notice ("This data must be worth a lot of money to the right people, and I could make sure my political party never loses another election") at which point the entire process is captured and corrupted from the top down. Avoiding building these systems in the first place is good civic hygiene, and societies need to develop an instinct that if you allow data and power to accumulate in one place for too long, it will start to attract pests.
- jonahbenton 4y agoNo. Variations of the slippery slope argument fail to engage with the actual concrete issues, the actual social trajectory, and anything specific and contextual. Not engaging is not engaging. It is weak and solves nothing. The Norweigian government has specific plans for this data. Engage those plans. Concrete adversarial scenarios are in fact helpful from a policy and planning perspective. Generic narratives are not. Cheers.
- jonahbenton 4y agoThe comments objecting to this are bizarre. In the predatory capitalist US, the number of private companies- not subject to any real regulation, or supervision, or action on the part of citizens- that have exactly this data and more numbers literally in the thousands. And while a lot of attention is paid to government data collection, it is very hard for various parts of the government in the US to get this information for administrative purposes- as distinct from criminal investigations- and even if government could, it would serve no purpose because except for policing, education, highway maintenance, delivery of mail and healthcare for military veterans, US government entities perform virtually no services. In Norway, which has extremely high quality of life and a very competent government that runs things like a sovereign wealth fund to the express and explicit benefit of citizens, where the goals of data collection are further improvement of quality of life, the intent and capacity of delivery for which by the government is proven over and over again- IOW, to be concerned about data collection by an entity that over and over again has demonstrated its competence, especially in the context of alternatives like the US- WTF are people thinking.
- dane-pgp 4y agoKnowledge is power, and power corrupts, so what you're saying is "I don't mind giving the Norwegian government absolute power, because they aren't absolutely corrupt (yet)".
- cerol 4y agoAlthough I understand and agree with what people are pointing to here, it's too easy to get carried away with the "welcome to 1984" fatalism. Life does not have a "last page", like in a book. In a story, the last page lasts forever, but in the real world it does not. In the real world we get to see things get really bad, and then we see them get better, then bad again, ad infinitum. When people have nothing left to loose, that's where real change happens.
- leonardinius 4y agoWow. That seems to be a succession / resurrection of 2015-2016 projekt I was involved with Norwegian Consumer Council forbrukerrådet and some of major groceries chains(Coop, Rema, NG..) The moment I left we were receiving soft real-time Pos log data (anonymized) and we’re building some consumer groceries basket stats.
- karencarits 4y agoOne should be aware that Norway already has very comprehensive registers and databases about the population. Currently, it has only been a benefit, I think, as it enables detailed quality control of say health care services and high-quality register studies. For example, all health/hospital records of deceased Norwegians are digitalized ten years after death and added to a national register. No way to refuse. In my opinion, that is much more invasive, yet it hasn't been discussed at all by the public https://helsedata.no/en/about-helsedata.no/ https://helsedata.no/en/about-helsedata.no/ https://www.digitalarkivet.no/en/ https://www.digitalarkivet.no/en/
- nostromo95 4y agoInvasive to whom? I'm certainly not going to be feeling outraged by medical records disclosure when I'm dead. Do with me what you will when I'm gone--I care more about my experience when I'm alive.
- amenghra 4y agoHypothetical situation: how would you feel if your medical records and used to calculate health risks for your children/other family members and refuse specific insurances (or make them more expensive)?
- peoplefromibiza 4y agoNon hypothetically, if your parents have a genetic condition that can be passed onto their offspring, in my country you are checked against them to try prevent them or catch them in the early stages. For free (payed by the taxes)
- nostromo95 4y agoThat’s a good point. I was imagining some sort of anonymized records database—turns out you can look up specific names which I agree yields some undesirable outcomes.
- ceejayoz 4y ago
- tiffanyh 4y agoAre the actual basket item details being sent, or just the total basket price? Advertisers would pay insane money to get ahold of data to link exactly what a consumer bought (basket item details).
- androa 4y agoStores already has that data, and shares it with their suppliers.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoFuture conversation with government bureaucrat: “I see that you are made of approximately 23% cheese. That is above the state limits for health reimbursement, so I am sorry we cannot support you at the moment until your diet fits within government guidelines.”
- guerrilla 4y agoNonsense, healthcare already covers smokers, alcoholics, obese and all kinds of other things.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoDepends on who _is_ the government. Once you have the data exactly on how unhealthy someone’s choices are, you can lean their behavior towards better behavior(according to those that want government to help people behave better).
- guerrilla 4y agoI'm saying it does now in Norway and Sweden and they already have all of our medical records.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoWe can’t predict how future humans will use this data, especially considering human’s desire to control the behavior of others.
- guerrilla 4y agoAgree, for sure, but that's a different claim.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoThat’s why I keep using the word future :) cheers!
- mikkergp 4y agoI’m not totally insensitive to libertarian arguments about a free society and limitations on government, but I also wonder given all the constraints on a government and societal pressures, what tools does a government really have if they want to offset climate change or reduce public health costs, or ration limited resources. I guess I think most of us, if we were actually in that position and wanted to stay in that position would have to choose interventions that are less than ideal.
- nomilk 4y agoIn the same week we see one government (Canadian) fining a company for unnecessarily storing data on users, and another government obtaining masses of data just for the hell of it. EDIT > SSB claims they want a less time-consuming way of collecting and analysing household consumption statistics in order to inform tax policy, social assistance and child allowance. That does seem plausible. Inflation statistics, for example, are notoriously vulnerable to arbitrary changes in the "basket of goods" economists define. If economists could access the entire shopping list, including volumes, then there'd be no need to try to guess what a representative basket looks like.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 4y agoCan't you just pay in cash, without leaving digital trail?
- kwhitefoot 4y agoOf course you can pay in cash. Most of us in Norway simply choose not to most of the time.
- ortusdux 4y agoI'm still surprised that the major credit card companies and banks in the US have not started transitioning to digital receipts. Several retailers and smart POS systems link your credit card number to your email and send you receipts automatically. It could be a dual edged sword for the banks, as a more informed consumer might budget more carefully and spend less, but the data collected would be quite valuable. It would not be a hard sell to consumers - "Shop with blank and you never need to worry about paper receipts again!". On a separate note, thermal receipt paper is a terrible source of BPA/BPS plastics. There are alternatives that use vitamin C, but they are rare. https://www.pca.state.mn.us/green-chemistry/bpa-thermal-paper https://www.pca.state.mn.us/green-chemistry/bpa-thermal-pape...
- NiceWayToDoIT 4y agoTwo years ago when they moved to cashless payments, question was what can go wrong. Well now we know...
- apienx 4y agoCoincidentally, the WEF's individual carbon footprint tracker initiative was recently announced. https://youtu.be/_j1d_2yTRRA https://youtu.be/_j1d_2yTRRA
- Krasnol 4y ago...and than there are People who wonder why Germany is so reluctant with their personal data, leaving cash behind, having a general ID, and so on. Sometimes it is wise to look at the past and learn from it. Datensparsamkeit ftw!
- paganel 4y agoFuck it, not even Ceausescu was doing this (or something similar to this) in communist Romania, and I grew up under Ceausescu as a kid, I should know. The worst that was happening from this point of view was maybe an older neighbor lady stopping you on your way back from the grocery store and literally going through your purchases (yes, kids were sent to the grocery store to do small purchases), but nothing more than that (and, even then, we, as kids, knew that what those old ladies were doing was wrong) Which begs the question: how come today’s Norwegians are ok with this? How is this normal in a liberal democracy? Is this what modern liberal democracy was all along? I.e. a dystopian State infringing more and more on one’s basic liberties, all in the name of the “greater good”? That’s nuts.
- Jenz 4y agoI am confounded as to why I have not heard of this. I'd appreciate it if someone could link me the official statement.
- c_--vote_win 4y ago
- c_--vote_win 4y ago
- greatgib 4y agoWhat is very scary, is the normalization of the surveillance society with crazy things like that being accepted/ignored by most citizens. It is getting worse and worse all the time. Curiously, 20 or 30 years ago people would have being angry and governments would have had to resign as even suggesting such privacy killer things would be offensive. Now most people would not even care... Just to let you imagine the future, in France, with the current 'ecological bullshit', some idiots suggested that households could have a quota of consumption of everything to save the planet: that much water, electricity, food... That will be more easy with shops transmitting all your shopping info directly to the gov...
- hexo 4y agoHope they won't ban cash payment.
- t_mann 4y agoIt's happening in China, it's happening in arguably the most 'well-mannered' 'Western' country - at this point it's naive to assume mass data collection won't be coming to your country (and they might not always be as well-mannered as Norway currently is). Some might say 'I don't care' or 'only those who have something to hide have anything to worry about', but I respectfully disagree. For the same reason that I have curtains in my bedroom I want to have agency over my data. What baffles me is that I'm fairly sure that similar views are shared by many in the HN community, yet the 'crypto/web3' communities receive almost undivided scorn. Yes, it's ridden with scams, but those are still the communities that do the most overall to push zero knowledge and similar privacy-preserving technologies (and contrary to the popular claim here that 'web3 doesn't do anything innovative', some of the zk stuff like STARK/SNARK/PLONK... they already put in production are pretty cutting edge).
- cuteboy19 4y agoCrypto/web3 as it is practiced offers absolutely zero protection against any of this. In fact, unless you use privacy chains (of which only few actually work) your Entire Transaction History is Public (!!). This is already a reality in most of cryptoland. Even if you trade on exchanges your entire order flow is immediately sold to the highest bidder, or if you're unlucky the exchange itself is trading against you. It's pretty horrible for privacy.
- t_mann 4y ago'of which few actually work' could also have been phrased as 'several are already working' - how many do you need? Even if the current offering isn't enough for your needs, how can 'there's not enough of it yet' be an argument against building more of it?
- stjohnswarts 4y agoI hope the people in Norway are smart enough to fight this tooth and nail. This is how everything you purchase or ever will purchase will be scrutinized by bureaucrats to be used against you. Sure the initial version might be anonymized but you can be sure some government official will say "well we have the data anyway and they don't seem to really care..."
- mark_l_watson 4y agoI have been following the World Economic Forum articles and talks about smart money: a digital currency that knows how it is used and by whom, can be 'turned off' for some types of purchases, etc. What Norway may do is just a small precursor to what the WEF crowd wants. Sadly, I think regular people have lost the class war. As a libertarian this should drive me nuts, but as a practical matter I tend to accept the world as it is, and plan my life accordingly. In other words, 'play the current position on the chessboard.'