14 ms·
A lot has been said about the dealership model in the last few years, and the almost universal consensus is that it is an unnecessary and predatory industry and
by paxys 4y ago
A lot has been said about the dealership model in the last few years, and the almost universal consensus is that it is an unnecessary and predatory industry and all auto makers should just sell cars directly like Tesla does.
That being said, is there any counterpoint to this view? Are there any benefits that dealerships offer today over direct sales? What would we lose if we got rid of every dealership? If there is truly little or no advantage, why has this obvious disruption never come up in the last ~100+ years of car sales in this country and all over the world?
- PainfullyNormal 4y agoFortNine made a case for it. They're Canadian, though. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=meHYBhcpdvQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=meHYBhcpdvQ
- guerrilla 4y ago> Are there any benefits that dealerships offer today over direct sales? Proximity and diversity. How are you going to have direct sales depots in every random town in the world? And which towns get which brands? Makes no sense.
- erichocean 4y ago> How are you going to have direct sales depots in every random town in the world? How about The Internet? Might work…
- guerrilla 4y agoThe Internet is terrible for such things. You want to see it and feel it, test drive it, kick the tires. .
- FpUser 4y agoThey could sell used vehicles, hence provide some value
- boardwaalk 4y agoBut, we already have (exclusively) used car dealerships and private car sales. Once you break it down, dealerships not a combination of businesses that really needs to be together, IMO.
- taeric 4y agoLocal profit? That is, in many towns, my understanding is that the local dealerships are relatively well off. Which implies that a bit more of the money is kept local to where the cars are being sold. I'm guessing this is less true today than in years past.
- naravara 4y agoThe owners of those local dealerships also tend to have a big hand in driving town politics as they’re often the richest people around.
- ABeeSea 4y agoThe other side of that is the dealership owner is often the richest person in a small town and has extremely outsized impact on local politics.
- taeric 4y agoI think that is precisely why the laws have largely not allowed direct sales. :)
- walrus01 4y agoIn many small to medium size towns if you find the family who owns the local ($BRANDNAME) dealership they are often among the wealthiest people in the entire county. edit: I can see from the two other comments here alongside mine that this is a common observation.
- qbasic_forever 4y agoThe only argument for it I've read is that it indirectly forces auto manufacturers to have local service centers to handle repairs, warranty work, etc.
- ianai 4y agoThis. And localities outlawing direct sales due to eons of local lobbying.
- kbrackbill 4y agoMany states have laws that explicitly prohibit direct sales. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Car_dealerships_in_the_United_States#cite_ref-dealerlaw_1-0 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Car_dealerships_in_the_United_...
- mjevans 4y agoThat's just a racket for the dealerships though.
- kbrackbill 4y agoRight, this is just an answer for "why has this obvious disruption never come up in the last ~100+ years"
- thrill 4y agoAnd thoroughly defended for a measly $10MM per year. https://www.opensecrets.org/industries/summary.php?cycle=2020&ind=T2300 https://www.opensecrets.org/industries/summary.php?cycle=202...
- vkou 4y ago> That being said, is there any counterpoint to this view? 1. A national dealership network is at minimum, a soft-guarantee that your car can be maintained/recalled/fixed without you jumping through hoops. Unfortunately, that soft-guarantee is saddled with all the other baggage of car dealerships. Pushy sales-people, extended warranties, predatory loans, etc. 2. It forces you to buy local, so not all the money flows out of your community, and into Detroit - some of it stays to circulate in your town. 3. People want to sell/trade their cars in, and Craigslist can be a pain in the ass. 4. People like to test-drive cars. People really like to test-drive used cars. See point #3. By the time Tesla starts holding used car inventories[1], and lets local buyers test-drive them[2], their 'showroom' starts looking less like an innovation, and more like a non-franchised dealership, where instead of the franchise owner skimming profit off the top, it just goes up the food chain, directly to corporate. [1] Which they are. [2] Which they do.
- booi 4y agoLooking at Detroit.. I don’t think a lot of money is flowing there.
- cebert 4y agoI live in Detroit. We have tech positions and several employers that are doing fine. If you haven’t checked out the city in a while, I’d encourage you to. It’s really starting to rebound.
- bobthepanda 4y agoDetroit the metropolitan area is doing pretty well. The executives live in the suburbs.
- PNWChris 4y agoThat’s a consequence of suburbanization and divestiture from the major auto cities (Detroit, Pontiac, etc) in Michigan. In recent years there has been meaningful investment and growth in Detroit [0], but a lot of auto money is in surrounding areas like Grosse Pointe [2] and Oakland county [1]. [0]: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/DETR826PCPI https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/DETR826PCPI [1]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Michigan_locations_by_per_capita_income https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Michigan_locations_b... [2]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grosse_Pointe,_Michigan https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grosse_Pointe,_Michigan Edit: mentioned Grosse Pointe
- pishpash 4y agoIt's a big purchase, so you'd want to at least test it out in person?
- paxys 4y agoNo dealerships doesn't mean no test drives. Tesla offers them today.
- pishpash 4y agoYeah but you'd have to set each one up separately, or buy/return in serial order (unless you have a great deal of capital). This vs. walking into some auto mall with like 5 dealers on the same day.
- eastbayjake 4y agoIt has meant no test drives in practice. I was shocked when I tried to test drive a Ford Mach-E that no dealership within a 100 mile radius had any inventory on hand -- when I called individual dealerships to ask, they said not only was the entire inventory already promised to individual customers and the only way you could test drive was if someone bailed on their order. I got a few emails that inventory had popped up, by the time I called (even within a few hours!) the vehicle had already sold. I'm genuinely shocked that consumers are buying first production run vehicles entirely online without a test drive.
- qbasic_forever 4y agoEven with dealer car sales there's usually a 48 hour or so grace period where if you realize you made a mistake, etc. they'll take it back and annul the sale. I imagine for a purely online sale there'd be a similar agreement and they just pick the car back up.
- bombcar 4y agoThat’s often a side effect of lemon laws and similar requirements.
- 4y ago
- serf 4y ago>That being said, is there any counterpoint to this view? Are there any benefits that dealerships offer today over direct sales? the only thing I can think to say is that they are still a convenient repair facility, Tesla is fairly notorious for slow turn-around for repair.[0] I think a nice middle-ground would be the conversion of dealerships into showrooms/receiving-centers/repair facilities -- oust the sales portion and highly regulate the repair pricing. Faster repair times while getting rid of most of the scummy parts of the car dealership experience. [0]: https://www.teslaownersonline.com/threads/model-3-significant-repair-times-5-months-and-counting.20044/ https://www.teslaownersonline.com/threads/model-3-significan...
- themitigating 4y agoTesla's wait times could be because they are scaling up and part delays.
- jethro_tell 4y agoWell, and becuse they don't have a dealership in every city. You can get a ford serviced anywhere and they have a waiting room for you to wait if needed. Even in rural areas, a very small percentage of the country is not going to be close to a dealer. if your driving a newer car, theyll handle warrenty work, recalls, service packages that your car came with. Everyone is having parts Problems, it's the scaling that Tesla still needs to do.
- FireBeyond 4y agoTesla's wait times are because every part that sits on a shelf for warranty/service/accident repairs is a part that can't go on a vehicle coming off the assembly line, and we all know that Tesla / Elon has a raging hard on for "deliveries, deliveries, deliveries". "Because they're scaling up". They've been making vehicles for 14 years, how much more time do they get to realize they should have a parts network?
- vkou 4y ago> Tesla's wait times are because every part that sits on a shelf for warranty/service/accident repairs is a part that can't go on a vehicle coming off the assembly line, and we all know that Tesla / Elon has a raging hard on for "deliveries, deliveries, deliveries". The Soviet Union's automotive industry operated in this exact manner. It's why, when by some miracle you got your hands on a car, sourcing replacement parts was nigh-impossible. > ... how much more time do they get to realize they should have a parts network? It took them ~60 years, give or take.
- SnowHill9902 4y agoTry the car. Pay cash. Negotiate. Sell yours. Choose from different brands. Chat with the owner. Get serviced.
- wumpus 4y agoPeople who like negotiations generally think they're good at it. Guess what? The dealer sells multiple cars per day. You don't know enough to be a good negotiator against them. Same thing as venture capital vs company founders. Founders found a couple of companies which do a couple of rounds each. VCs make way more investments.
- Alupis 4y ago> Guess what? The dealer sells multiple cars per day. You don't know enough to be a good negotiator against them. Right - so let's get rid of negotiations all together and everyone pays whatever absurd price the sales team at Ford can think of without laughing out loud. This isn't a box of cookies folks... besides your house, it's likely the most expensive thing you'll ever buy. There is no "one" price for the asset... unless we remove all the competition that drives down prices (dealerships) and put all the assets into a single basket owned by one of a small handful of manufacturers in the world. What could go wrong?
- wumpus 4y agoWait what? If there are no negotiations, and Ford's price is too high compared to the market, Ford is going to lose sales. That's micro-economics. > besides your house, it's likely the most expensive thing you'll ever buy. This is Hacker News, and I've spent 10s of millions on servers, colo, and cloud.
- Alupis 4y agoThe problem is Ford will be the market. They are only offering these EV's direct from their website. There will be no dealerships to compete with on price and service. > This is Hacker News, and I've spent 10s of millions on servers, colo, and cloud. I'd bet you negotiated those contracts too.
- c4wrd 4y agoIn my opinion, we lose a lot, some things practical and others societal. Practically first, when I’m in the market for a new vehicle, I’m not sure which I honestly want. I like being able to go to a dealership and find something that convinced me otherwise from what I came to originally look at it. In the most recent case, I was really wanting a truck and being able to see them in person, how I fit, etc, was what sold me over one make versus another. Second, how does a future where there’s X car dealerships with different sites that I can’t easily compare across makes sound? Now it’s much harder for the average consumer to find a new vehicle. This will lead to aggregators, which will initially not be allowed up front because the manufacturer wants the full cut, but they’ll eventually concede. Now societal. Sure, car dealerships may be “predatory” (I argue against that, some may be but most I’ve dealt with are opposite of that because they want your business), but at the end of the day it allows for more people to have jobs and participate in the economy. At some point we, technologists, are going to remove everyone’s job from them and we’ll act surprised societal uprisings happen because there’s no jobs available to the average Joe. Now I’m not arguing against automation, but car dealerships employ millions across the country, I don’t think removing those jobs from our fellow citizens who may or may not be able to do much more than sell cars, to no fault of their own, just to make a few more dollars for the manufacturer at “ease of the consumer”. Once again these are my opinions, I’d love to hear from people who think this could be a good model for selling vehicles and will take them into full consideration.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dghlsakjg 4y agoJust a note, If you want to go sit in a Tesla or test drive one, you can still do that despite a complete lack of dealerships. In my experience, a Tesla is the only showroom experience where there was 0 pressure, and no-one trying to get my info or photocopy my driver license just to see the inside of a car. A lack of dealerships does not mean that there are no showrooms or test drives. There's nothing stopping Ford, BMW, Mercedes or whoever from putting in a showroom next to a Tesla showroom. In actuality it makes it easier since a showroom doesn't have to have inventory; you can put them in places where a normal car dealership couldn't exist (this is exactly what Tesla is doing). I saw a Genesis showroom in an airport once...
- smsm42 4y agoI am not sure what Tesla does, but I think there's a value in having somebody local which can show me the car, give explanations, provide maintenance services and add-on sales, etc. It doesn't have to be independently owned, in theory, but in practice I think it'd be hard for one company to manage so many local shops at US scale. Some kind of franchise model would work much better. Does it have to be the same as dealership today? Maybe not. But I think there's value in having something like that, even if not exactly what we have now.
- rootusrootus 4y agoI think your mistake here is to look at dealers simply as sales outlets. Dealers would deny that. You sell a car once, but you work on it multiple times throughout its life. IMO the problem with comparing to other retail channels is that most things we buy aren't expensive enough to warrant the same level of upkeep as a $30,000 car. Tesla has made fixed-price online sales work so far, but notice that they're scrambling to build the support network. They're re-creating most of the dealership model but bringing the ownership in-house. That's only good if their customer service is good, because now you don't really have any good alternatives. > why has this obvious disruption never come up in the last ~100+ years of car sales in this country and all over the world? This is important. We can try to point to laws, but the more likely answer is that the current model is the best we've invented yet. There have been attempts to change, and more often than not it's the consumers that reject it, not lawmakers.
- jethro_tell 4y agoBefore recent markups because of parts shortages, dealers mostly made almost nothing on new cars. Even now I'd assume most of their money comes from service and used car sales.
- jasomill 4y agoMostly true in terms of margins, at least if you consider finance and insurance separately from vehicle sales (as all dealerships do). Nevertheless, new vehicle sales including F&I is a non-negligible factor in most dealerships' bottom line, and new vehicle sales can also be a significant driver of service volume (both organically and as a result of loyalty incentives). You're also correct in assuming COVID has been good for new vehicle sales profitability. Here are the per-segment breakdowns reported by the three largest dealership groups in the US, before and after COVID: 1. AutoNation (AN) 2019 Rv: 52.3% New, 25.6% Used, 16.7% S&P, 4.8% F&I, 0.6% Other 2019 GP: 14.3% New, 10.4% Used, 46.1% S&P, 29.0% F&I 2021 Rv: 46.7% New, 33.4% Used, 14.3% S&P, 5.4% F&I, 0.2% Other 2021 GP: 24.3% New, 13.9% Used, 33.8% S&P, 28.0% F&I 2. Penske Automotive (PAG) (excluding non-retail auto dealership businesses) 2019 Rv: 45% New, 35% Used, 6% Fleet, 11% S&P, 3% F&I 2019 GP: 23% New, 12% Used, 1% Fleet, 43% S&P, 21% F&I 2021 Rv: 44% New, 38% Used, 5% Fleet, 10% S&P, 3% F&I 2021 GP: 27% New, 17% Used, 2% Fleet, 34% S&P, 20% F&I 3. Sonic Automotive (SAH) 2019 Rv: 47.0% New, 35.0% Used, 13.0% S&P, 5.0% F&I and Other 2019 GP: 15.0% New, 10.0% Used, 44.0% S&P, 31.0% F&I and Other 2021 Rv: 41.3% New, 39.3% Used, 11.3% S&P, 8.1% F&I and Other 2021 GP: 24.1% New, 6.9% Used, 35.2% S&P, 33.8% F&I and Other (Rv = revenue as percentage of total, GP = gross profit as percentage of total, New, Used, Fleet = vehicle sales, S&P = Service and Parts, F&I = Finance and Insurance) (source: SEC filings) N.B.: Gross profit may be a misleading figure in this comparison, as it excludes major expenses (notably, salaries and commissions for non-administrative staff) directly attributable to particular business segments. Alas, I'm lazy, and these are the only per-segment percentages immediately available in all dealership 10-Ks. With all that said, I imagine many, possibly most, dealerships would remain comfortably profitable even if net (non-F&I!) profit on new vehicle sales were zero. Finally, note that fixed vehicle pricing is not exactly a new idea: GM famously introduced the Saturn marque with a similar tactic. And as with this older example, I assume Ford isn't planning to mandate fixed pricing on financing, insurance, trade-in allowances, third-party extended warranties, dealership-installed options, or anything else beyond the selling price of the vehicle itself and possibly certain minor fees related to the sale.
- SamuelAdams 4y agoThe way I've heard it explained before, feel free to correct me if my facts are wrong: State sales taxes. The big 3 auto makers are all located in Michigan, USA. If they sold a vehicle direct, the sales tax dollars goes to the State of Michigan. Which means all the other states are missing out on *significant* tax dollars. To force each state to get tax dollars, local dealerships were established. That way tax dollars go to the state the vehicle is sold in, rather than the state the vehicle manufacturer is located in. I'm curious if this has changed at all over the last 20 years with the rise of e-commerce. For example, when I order a product on Amazon, do I pay taxes on that product for where I live (where the product is "purchased"?), or where Amazon is headquartered?
- cdash 4y agoIt used to be you could avoid taxes for things purchased online even though you had a responsibility to report it yourself. To answer your question though, you pay tax to the state it is delivered to when ordering from Amazon.
- wumpus 4y agoYou pay sales taxes in the state you register the car in, period. Doesn't matter where the seller is. I lived in Virginia, bought a car in Delaware... no sales tax in DE. Wohoo? No, had to pay Virginia sales tax when registering the car.
- favorited 4y agoStates already account for this. For example, in Massachusetts, if you purchase a vehicle in a different state, you are subject to a "use-tax" which is equal to the Commonwealth's sales-tax. Otherwise, car dealerships would be non-viable in MA – everyone would take a quick jaunt over to NH to buy their cars.
- pinot 4y agoIME car sales tax are captured by the registering arm (DMV). You absolutely pay local sales tax on amazon, not Washington salestax. Taxation is about nexus of transaction.
- 4y ago
- Alupis 4y agoWhen I see "No Haggle, Fixed-Price, Online Only", I think "Rip Off", and I can't be the only one. It's not that I enjoy haggling with car salesmen, walking out the door and getting hunted down in the parking lot like an animal... I don't... in fact I hate it. But at the end of the day I get a deal I'm satisfied and comfortable with - and it's always below MSRP - far below. I think what we're seeing here is a combination of the younger generation's fear of conflict (a negotiation is an adversarial conflict), coupled with car manufacturers realizing a lot of people are totally OK paying $10,000+ over MSRP... almost "bidding" for a car. I fully expect prices to increase, while overhead decreases (no sales staff, no stale inventory, no loss of inventory, rent payments, etc). But the younger generation will feel great because they got to click a button and a grossly overpriced car shows up the next day - just like "Amazon but for Cars!". I can't see any positive coming out of this. You don't buy anything over a few thousand bucks without negotiating. Even the photo copier at your office was negotiated for days or weeks... how can someone buy a $50,000 vehicle at MSRP/Invoice price and claim they didn't throw away money? It used to be only suckers walked into a dealership and paid sticker price... bigger suckers payed more than sticker price (gotta have that undercarriage coating), and everyone else paid closer to the true price having researched what similar vehicles sold for etc.
- raz32dust 4y agoWhy would a fixed, online price end up being higher on average than what someone paid after haggling at a dealership. If anything, it should be lower because of (1) Reduced overhead, and (2) It is more closer to a free-market due to more transparency. Yes, there might be outliers where an extremely good haggler paid less, but that would be outweighed by a novice who paid way more, and the average has to be higher because of the higher overhead.
- Alupis 4y agoWhy would Ford (or any manufacturer) offer cars on their website for cheaper than MSRP? What is their incentive? MSRP is a suggested retail price, which is based off the manufacturer's costs + what they believe is a reasonable margin for their vendor (dealership in this case). Ford cutting out the middle man means they can offer cars at the same exact price (MSRP in this case), but not have all the expenses dealerships have... meaning massive profit for them. There is literally no incentive for Ford to offer the cars for less money. Plenty of people have eagerly paid $10,000+ over MSRP already - indicating they could even raise prices if they desired. Look at Carmax as an example. Their entire business is built around the "no haggle" model - and if you know anything about the cars you are looking at, you will not find any good deals there. Everything is overpriced - but they will tell you it's their "rock bottom price" and any defects or problems have already been factored in. It's just a sales tactic. Plenty of folks walk into a Carmax believing they're getting the best possible price without any of the hassle... just like their commercials tell you.
- dharmab 4y agoThis recent video on motorcycle dealerships argues that dealerships are beneficial for the financial arms of manufacturers and also manage risk due to warranty/recall work and sales flops. https://youtu.be/meHYBhcpdvQ https://youtu.be/meHYBhcpdvQ
- TreyS 4y agoDealerships are major job providers in small towns and provide some of the better jobs. Salespeople, loan officers, etc. Think replacing local grocery stores with Walmart. Low end jobs stay, high end jobs go away. Further hurts small towns. My guess is that a good chunk of the efficiencies from this model will go to Ford corporate so it’s a wealth transfer from small towns to big co managers / stockholders.
- qgin 4y agoSemi-counterpoint: Walmart pays hourly workers more than any of the mom-and-pop retail in my hometown.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- wumpus 4y agoOne commonly said counterpoint is that having independent dealers means you get better warranty service. Here's how it works. I had a Subaru, and Subaru had a problem for a decade+ that their head gaskets were tissue paper and frequently failed. So I had one free replacement mid-warranty. I went in just after the warranty expired for a normal service and lo and behold, the head gasket was bad again. The dealer replaced it for free. What happened? They defrauded Subaru. So sure, there's an advantage. Not only will a dealer happily be aggressive at any warranty repair, they'll even commit fraud doing it.
- bombcar 4y agoOften companies have leeway on warranties - when I did warranty work we had a five year warranty but could give a replacement up to six months “out of warranty” if needed.
- imroot 4y agoDealers have almost wide latitude about submitting and getting paid for "good will" warranty claims, as long as they don't abuse it. Sometimes manufactures will direct dealers to fix things that are long out of warranty when weird things happen (like in Seattle when that radio station sent out a bug that bricked the radios over RDS -- the manufacture directed the dealerships via a service memo to replace the radios and bill the manufacture). Service is a decent part of most dealerships these days, and a good amount of that income is driven from warranty claims.
- wumpus 4y agoAll car companies have "service memos". It has nothing to do with dealers.
- argonaut 4y ago1. Service centers. Others comments have talked about this. 2. Trade-ins. Most new car dealers also sell used cars (in fact many make more profit on used cars than with new cars). Because of this they can usually give you much better trade-in valuations than Tesla, which I believe just sends cars to auction. Obviously you could also just sell to CarMax/Carvana/etc. or sometimes sell a car to a dealership without buying a car. But this is an added bit of hassle.
- SoftTalker 4y agoThe worst price you will get for a used car is trading it in. The best thing to do is sell it privately, after researching what it is worth.
- faangiq 4y agoThe main benefit is it allows some absurd accounting gimmicks that paper pushers have optimized over decades. It’s also a jobs program for all sorts of useless middlemen.
- didibus 4y agoWell, for a customer, I think you want the luxury to try before you buy, easy returns, fast delivery, easy upkeep and repair, good warranty and finally you want the lowest prices. Dealerships are very good for "try before you buy", "easy returns", "fast delivery", and "easy upkeep and repair". They don't change anything for warranty, and they don't necessarily provide the biggest selection. So I think best price is the only dimension that dealers could be worse at, but at the same time, you can often negotiate paying below MSRP with a dealer. I guess we're assuming most of the time they take a premium, but it's hard to predict what the prices would be if dealers didn't exist, would they be lower? By how much? Maybe they'd be higher? The only thing about online orders that is pretty sure is convenience, you can buy a car in your bed and pyjamas, no need to talk to anyone, browse online and purchase, car arrives at your door.
- qgin 4y agoSeems similar to the franchise model. Local people in local markets find the opportunities and take on the risk while the cost of the arrangement is passed on to the consumer.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jfb 4y agoThere really isn't one. The laws about manufactures not owning dealers are left over from a very different era, and the existing model is a product of pure rent-seeking from the very powerful dealership lobby.
- topspin 4y ago> is there any counterpoint to this view? I don't think the counterpoint has changed since it was codified in the laws of US states: limit the power of large corporations and their influence over sovereign states. Our ancestors were rather circumspect about corporate power within the US and created mechanisms to insulate themselves from that power. The emergence of multinational corporations has naturally produced a similar model at the nation-state level: the ability of a global private enterprise to operate in some nation frequently depends on the existence of a domestic component, often in the form of a subsidiary with an obligation to retain executive staff that are citizens subject to the laws of the host nation. My experience with dealers has been good. They've arranged financing competently, dealt with recall work, honored warranties and supplied OEM quality parts when needed. Nothing as complex as a passenger vehicle and all that goes into realizing one is ever perfect, but the dealers I've dealt with have met all of the expectations I've had of them. I suspect that much of the enmity towards dealers arises from unreasonable expectations. That's a suspicion. This isn't: the same people bitching about dealers today will be bitching at least as much about manufacturers when the dealers are gone. At some point in this discussion someone speculated that the delegation of EV service to dealers is not viable due to the nature of EVs; the manufacturer must be directly involved or Bad Things will happen. That may be true. I don't know. I do know that, short of some form of mortal danger, I can't imagine a better argument to avoid EVs than that; I will never, ever own a vehicle that can't be properly serviced without the manufacturer's direct involvement. That would be deeply stupid.
- bombcar 4y agoA huge percentage of people who bitch about dealers have never bought a new car from one - and the majority of those who do, continue to go to the same dealer thereafter.
- hackernewds 4y agoEasier to see multiple cars from multiple different manufacturers in person in one lot through an informed salesperson. Ford showrooms will not have Toyota cars.
- bombcar 4y agoThey usually will in the used lot (if any used cars were available anymore). And many dealer families run multiple brands under one name. Eg: https://www.walser.com/new-vehicles/minnesota/ https://www.walser.com/new-vehicles/minnesota/
- rawgabbit 4y agoThe dealership model has never benefited the consumer financially. The majority of dealers view auto sales as one time transactions where their goal is squeeze money from the customer using morally dubious tactics if not outright lies. You have to place the dealership model in historical context. They were created in an era where the Detroit automakers monopolized the industry. And they created mostly shoddy cars. They created “choice” by rebadging one car and passing it off as another. There are good dealerships who want a relationship with the customer. But in my experience they usually end up selling to a larger dealership who only care about gouging the customer. Plus with cars basically becoming high tech batteries on wheels with dozens of minicomputers. When an EV really breaks down, I doubt your local mechanic can do much about it. At the most, he can swap out one module with another (if he has it). More likely the only thing the dealer can do, is give you a loaner car while the manufacturer ships the modules and components you need. Ford and Tesla are probably better off giving you a loaner car directly and when the parts are available instruct you to go to the nearest repair facility or in the worst case, the technician will come to you.
- krrrh 4y agoA decent service and warranty experience is the point a lot of people make, and this has obviously become less important with EVs which require less ongoing maintenance. Beyond that dealers provide distributed and localized inventory management. Modern car plants basically have to run at full capacity year round, but sales are much more seasonal and unpredictable given effects of gas prices and other economic factors, many of which can be regional. The dealers find underused land all over the country and have huge lots that allow for cars to be delivered on a consistent year round basis which provides efficiencies in the logistics operations since the trucking, shipping, and rail contracts can have permanent workforces and long term predictable contracts. When inventories pile up for specific models the manufacturer can provide incentives and dealers can innovate and adapt to take advantage of these using local knowledge of the conditions in their community in a way that manufacturers would have a harder time doing. Dealers can finance their floorplan using independent and local sources of capital for inventory and buildings which allows the manufacturers to extend operations without taking on additional debt, or putting their own finances at risk. Some of these factors played more of a role in the past, when new car companies were building out their dealership networks and benefitted more from offloading risks to dealer partners. Tesla was able to innovate with their small showrooms in malls largely because they went for a long time with only a small handful of models, and because the buzz around the brand and vision meant that there has always been a waiting line (still the case), so they’ve never tried to compete for the “car broke down, need something new this week” market, which has had no choice but to head to well-inventoried lot.
- Aspos 4y agoBack in 2001 GM hired my university professor to study what could be done with the dealer network. Even then it was clear dealers were of no use in the long run, but there were no practical ways of getting rid of them. Forcing dealers to do repairs only effectively meant risking that best dealers would switch to other brands, other dealers would have to charge more for the service and these two factors could potentially kill any brand. No single manufacturer could pull it off, and even if they could find a way to work together to change legislation, it would be way too costly and way too risky.
- fomine3 4y agoSo much hate for car dealership is seems to US specific problem. I don't see so much complains from other country.
- throwaway5752 4y agoYou can test drive multiple vehicles at the same location.
- whoomp12342 4y agofor obscene and obscure issues, their overpriced repairs are great. E.g. something weird happened with just your model and you need just that right part/repair but your local repairsperson doesnt have the specialized knowledge
- giarc 4y ago>Are there any benefits that dealerships offer today over direct sales? Competition. In a decent sized city you will get multiple dealers for the big names (Toyota, GM, Ford etc) and they will compete against each other. Because of this, you won't pay over MSRP, winter tires at cost, discounted warranties, free oil changes for life and they generally try really hard to keep your business through good customer service.
- rossdavidh 4y agoWow is that not my experience. Even for cars that I liked, the dealerships never impressed. I always ended up going to other mechanics. I also have discussed the issue with several friends in the past, and heard way more bad experiences than good ones.