8 ms·
My Mega65 has arrived
- miguel_cordeiro 4y agoMaybe it's nostalgia but for me it makes computing look fun again. Amazing attention to detail... kudos to the makers.
- kloch 4y agoI love that the box and form factor are retro 80's but the keyboard is fully modern. Very good design decisions.
- layer8 4y agoIt’s based on the C65 prototypes (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commodore_65 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commodore_65) from 1990/1991. Not sure about “modern”, the modern keyboard layout was arguably established by the IBM Enhanced Keyboard (https://deskthority.net/wiki/IBM_Enhanced_Keyboard https://deskthority.net/wiki/IBM_Enhanced_Keyboard) introduced in 1985/1986, so roughly at the same time the now-retro C128 and the Amiga were introduced (who had vaguely similar keyboards).
- mindcrime 4y agoThe first question that comes to my mind is, "where did they get the floppy drives?" Surely the original manufacturer of those drives isn't still making them??? And having a batch manufactured as a one-off seems like it would be prohibitively expensive. So I'd be really curious to know how they managed that part of the whole thing. Anyway, looks like a great project. I wasn't a C64 fanboy as a kid or anything, but I'm still tempted to look into getting one of these. OTOH, I still have an Atari 800 I bought last year that I haven't touched yet, a half-started Z80 retrocomputer project to finish, and a desire to get an Atari 1040 "one of these days". So maybe I don't need yet another retrocomputer "thing" to play with... :p
- dfxm12 4y agoSo I'd be really curious to know how they managed that part of the whole thing. Searching the linked development blog yields this: https://c65gs.blogspot.com/2019/03/floppys-floppys-everywhere.html https://c65gs.blogspot.com/2019/03/floppys-floppys-everywher... After some searching, we found what we were after: A local supplier here in Germany who has some quantity of different models, including a large number of ALPS 3.5" 1.44MB drives.
- mindcrime 4y agoWow, so it sounds like they actually had to go with used drives. I was thinking maybe they got lucky and found some unsold NOS ones in an old warehouse or something. No such luck. But at least they found something to let them move forward with the project. It does lead me to wonder though: How many floppy drives would one have to commit to ordering, and how much would it cost, to get a company to manufacture a run of such devices?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- salgernon 4y agoThere’s some interesting reading from the creator of a Mac Floppy emulator on sourcing the obscure (DB19) connector it uses - and his setting out I do a new production run. This [1] is kind of in the middle of the thread - but still interesting reading: [1] https://www.bigmessowires.com/2015/03/20/finding-a-db-19-angering-the-internet/ https://www.bigmessowires.com/2015/03/20/finding-a-db-19-ang... Better[2] link: [2] https://www.bigmessowires.com/2016/06/04/db-19-resurrecting-an-obsolete-connector/ https://www.bigmessowires.com/2016/06/04/db-19-resurrecting-...
- MegaDeKay 4y agoThe article actually states that the drives are not new.
- forinti 4y agoThe last time I bought a real brand new floppy drive at a shop was in 2010 and they were really cheap (about US$5). They must have been trying to get rid of old inventory already.
- 300bps 4y agoI have quite a number of Commodore 64s lying around by virtue of developing a hobby of learning component level repair on them. I'm tempted to buy one of these Mega65s to play around with it but at $832.50 including shipping to the US, it's a bit much. The main reason I am interested in old computers is because I used those old computers back in the day! Really have to hand it to them on the engineering of it though - looks like an amazing machine.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoYou might be interested in my good friend Randy's labour of love: https://accentual.com/vicii-kawari/ https://accentual.com/vicii-kawari/ FPGA replacement for the VIC-II.
- 300bps 4y agoConsidering I just bought 10 NOS NTSC VIC-II chips, yes I’m interested. I’ve been following that project for some time but it seems to be On hold for months and counting due to chip shortage. Is it being resumed at some point soon?
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoHe's constantly working on it. We both quit our Google jobs back in January (on the same day) and frankly, the VIC is how he seems to be spending most of his time since. The problem remains chip shortages. He had to rework the board a couple times because of lack of FPGA supply. I've seen his latest boards and they are impressive.
- dfxm12 4y agoConsider checking out the mister project. The Mister is one FPGA board that lets you emulate many old computers, like the C64, Atari ST, Amiga 500, Macintosh plus, 486 based systems, even Japanese computers like the Sharp x68k, PC-88, MSX, etc. It's a great piece of kit, with some level of floppy support and more affordable (although you have to bring your own fancy case!).
- 4y ago
- DeathArrow 4y agoSince the CPU is emulated by an FPGA, FDD is emulated, then why not save all the money and just use a software emulator?
- markus_zhang 4y agoMaybe holding some real hardware gives much joy? I'm thinking about maybe emulating it using a Pi and buy some peripherals such as external floppy. Not sure if it's doable though.
- Koshkin 4y agoThe real real hardware - sure, but emulated on a FPGA… not so much. But that’s just me. Emulation in software (and the virtual space in general), on the other hand, is close to perfect these days. In fact, material things get boring pretty fast (and tend to end up in the attic) whereas virtual reality (like games) remain a source of perpetual joy.
- markus_zhang 4y agoAfter some thoughts I believe I agree with you on both points. A replicate but with new board and new chips for buyers to solder their own hardware would be really interesting and educational. On the other side, I already have some retro hardware collecting dust so tonight I'm going to get one out to play CD music I just bought. Only vintage laptops have CD players installed.
- jason-phillips 4y agoBecause the journey is more rewarding than the destination? Extending your thought, what if the journey of building/acquiring/configuring the meatspace thing was also emulated?
- antiverse 4y agoWouldn't use this analogy - it might be an emulation of some sort.
- SeanLuke 4y ago> Back in the 1980's, Commodore released the famous Commodore 64 (8 bit computer), and then followed it up with the Commodore 128, and Amiga (16 bit computers). ??? Pretty sure the 128 was an 8-bit computer.
- glonq 4y agoDoes the mega65 shipping put a nail in the coffin of the commander x16, which seems to be stumbling?
- the_af 4y agoHow is it stumbling? Do you mean "slow going"? Because according to Wikipedia, the MEGA65 project was started in 2015, so Mega itself was slow. These are essentially hobbyist projects, I don't think there's any nails to be placed on any coffins. They get done when they get done, and are not expected to become huge commercial successes.
- glonq 4y agoBy stumbling I mean 'founders and influencers abandoning the project'. Well hopefully by scaling back ambitions they'll be able to get something out.
- the_af 4y agoI'm really enjoying the current retrocomputer craze. I bought the "TheC64" myself (full size with working keyboard, wouldn't have it any other way), which is just a C64 lookalike case with a tiny ARM computer running VICE inside. I know it's not a real C64, but it sure looks like one! The Mega65 in particular is not for me though: it's way too expensive and it's not an actual computer I owned as a kid, so the nostalgia factor is lower. It does look extremely nice, though.
- FullyFunctional 4y agoMy only interest in this is as an FPGA dev kit. It was surprisingly hard to find details on the actual hardware but it appears to be a Xilinx™ Artix A7 200T according to https://shop.trenz-electronic.de/en/TE0765-03-S001-MEGA65-highly-advanced-C64-and-C65-compatible-8-bit-computer?c=564 https://shop.trenz-electronic.de/en/TE0765-03-S001-MEGA65-hi... That page curiously doesn't specify the amount of external DRAM, but various hints suggests it might be 8 MiB of HyperRAM (that's DRAM with a simpler protocol). Cute.
- hedora 4y agoI was wondering the same thing. I wonder if they could produce a "lite" version without some of the physical components (like the floppy disk and "expansion port"), and maybe some of the retro stuff swapped for cheap modern bits, like USB. Does anyone know if the FPGA code that makes this thing work is open source? It might be a nice starting point for some other hobby project / processor architecture experiments / etc.
- everslick 4y agoIt's on GitHub.
- Keyframe 4y agoNexys 100T was recommended as a stand-in until you get the real mega65, that it's pretty much the same thing once set up. So, one could view it as a lite version: https://shop.trenz-electronic.de/en/29376-Nexys-A7-100T-FPGA-Trainer-Board-Recommended-for-ECE-Curriculum https://shop.trenz-electronic.de/en/29376-Nexys-A7-100T-FPGA...
- bpye 4y agoIs a high performance HyperRAM controller really simpler than a normal DRAM controller? It's serial rather than parallel so you need higher frequency signals for the same bandwidth.
- thrtythreeforty 4y ago
- Arrath 4y agoI'd never heard of the Mega 65 before, I love the aesthetic of it fully contained in the keyboard and for some reason the floppy drive being molded right into it just tickles my fancy in all the right ways.
- mlindner 4y agoI really don't understand the love people have for the commodore 64. It wasn't especially advanced for it's time nor was it especially good. Finally it basically required the use of a horrible language like Basic to use. There's like zero reason to re-create it as a retro computer. Then you compare it to things like the Amiga which was incredibly advanced for it's time with amazing graphics and sound that even today are very playable modern-feeling experiences. For an example of what I'm talking about here's two clips (the whole video is good): https://youtu.be/kjapiUQOi2s?t=834 https://youtu.be/kjapiUQOi2s?t=834 https://youtu.be/kjapiUQOi2s?t=1502 https://youtu.be/kjapiUQOi2s?t=1502
- guyzero 4y agoI really don't understand the love people have for ${literally anything}. Nostalgia is a hell of a drug.
- yakz 4y agoMy family couldn’t afford an Amiga when I was a kid, but we could afford a C64 so that’s what we had.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pvg 4y agoIt's heartwarming to see some people still enjoy the old breadbox and others still enjoy telling everyone everything was better on the Amiga.
- tenebrisalietum 4y agoThe SID chip in the c64 is very unique, it's specifically designed for music versus the PSG-like square wave generators in other systems at the time. (I will say the Atari POKEY is magical though.) Comparing c64 to Amiga isn't fair, the Amiga was a generation later. What the c64 should be compared with is the Atari 8-bit systems (400, 800, 65XE, 130XE), Apple II, Colecovision. Having the 64k RAM, plus sprites, plus a sound chip that implemented ADSR and different waveforms other than square did introduce a lot of possibilities and excitement in 1982 though, even if you tried your best to use them from the absolutely shitty BASIC and/or had to wait minutes for things to load from disk or cassette.
- Linda703 4y ago[dead]
- com2kid 4y ago> In my view the ongoing race to the bottom of slave labour to make cheaper systems is not sustainable. As someone who has worked in consumer electronics, and worked closely with the people who were on the factory line, employees on electronics manufacturing lines are not slave labor. They are often times well paid, with pay that would make for a good living in more rural parts of the US. After having worked on a production line for a year, they are in a good bargaining position to up their pay for the next year[1], sometime I got to witness as my team had to basically pay a bonus to get people to come back to work after the spring festival. Do some employers suck? Of course[2]. It is important for the companies placing these orders to ensure workers are treated well, I know when I was at MSFT we had guidelines in place for worker treatment, including an increase minimum age for workers vs what the local law allowed. I also don't think a lot of people realize that for any production line in China making complicated American designed electronics, that there are likely Americans also on the factory floor helping things out! Especially at the beginning of the production run. None of the people I know who were on the factory floor would have been silent if they had seen abuses, abuses of the people they worked day in and day out with for weeks and sometimes months. I'm not saying horrible abuses don't happen, but I am saying that it is possible, and not some insanely difficult task, to responsibly manufacture goods in China, or any other country for that matter. BTW, everything is made in China because China has a ton of local expertise, engineering talent, and ease of sourcing parts. For complicated to make products, the labor savings really isn't the big driver. [1] Yield rates go up significantly with experienced employees. [2] There is a lot of pressure to make release dates for consumer electronics, missing certain holidays for release means an entire product may not sell enough units to be profitable anymore. Does this mean crap tons of stress for everyone involved? Unfortunately yes, if you work in higher end consumer electronics you will see people fall apart all around you, it is a very high stress environment. It sucks that the stress is also put on the lowest paid workers in the chain, and more needs to be done to stop that from happening.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- imiric 4y ago> They are often times well paid, with pay that would make for a good living in more rural parts of the US. That might be the case now, but manufacturing moved to China decades ago partly because of cheap labor and as a cost saving measure for companies building elsewhere. > BTW, everything is made in China because China has a ton of local expertise, engineering talent, and ease of sourcing parts. Everything is made in China because everything else is made in China. I.e. the momentum is already built for everything to be cheaply made there, so no external manufacturing can compete on prices or equipment. The issue is that in the race to the bottom to build everything cheaply, quickly and in large quantities, is that you get a ton of low quality products that become junk soon after purchase. And given the total disregard for intellectual property, any company sharing any manufacturing details with Chinese manufacturers must either have strong on-site control and oversight of the process, or deal with the fact that the market will soon be flooded with counterfeit products of their design.
- imiric 4y ago> So nice to see electronics made somewhere other than China. Hope we can see this done more often. Indeed. Is there an online store that specializes in products not made in China? Or at least allows me to filter products by country of design and manufacture? I'd give anything to have that filter on Amazon. It would get rid of most of the scams and shoddy products that end up in landfills shortly after purchase. I really don't mind paying a premium for products built elsewhere. I'd rather pay extra for quality than buy another cheap Chinese knockoff.
- ffhhj 4y agoWhich store!?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ckz 4y agoFor some countries (Japan comes to mind), there -are- dedicated stores to a degree. Usually for luxury goods though where it's tough to gauge real-world quality/value vs aesthetic strengths. Also, this doesn't directly address your question, but the interim solution I've used is to build a research habit with each successive purchase for the home. With time, it gets a lot easier and more intuitive to track down vendors. Vendors is actually a key word--typically you're looking for one of a small number of authorized importers for a given brand. Often they'll be B2B focused, e.g. buying EU power tools or USA-made N95s from industrial supply companies. This strategy has netted out a (simplified) distribution like this in my home: * Home Appliances: German, French * Food Storage: French (lunchboxes even!) or vintage US * Whet Stones: Japanese * Wooden Goods: Local, Canadian, or Eastern European * Food: Local mills, garden, area farms; preserve seasonal foods * Health & Beauty: Canadian * Safety Gear: Canadian, US * Garden: German, Italian, US; seeds from open-source genetics You still have to be intentional, since plenty of foreign stores have global supply chains like the US does, so just because you're bringing it from Canada doesn't mean it's Canadian-origin, etc. Also note: I'm absolutely cherry-picking what I listed. I still buy plenty of arbitrary things from big-box stores. In general, the research LOE scales with how important the purchase is to me, and you really need the research to become something of a hobby since you'll be spending hours on it. :)
- charles_f 4y agoThe fact that it has a manual proves that it's poor UI. Also the setup for sd card is way too complex, and it does not support Bluetooth. I doubt it will have any success. Note that they're building this in Germany, no way they'll manage to recover their cost of manufacturing.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- AYoung010 4y agoI believe that the point of this project is not to have a simple UI, but an authentic one. UI in the 1980s was not known for being friction-free, so I would actually argue that its "poor" UI is a design success. Although I understand that the SD card setup is complex, but I really think the target audience won't have too much trouble with it...this isn't intended to be a raspi competitor, after all... Was this comment a joke that just flew completely over my head?
- wvenable 4y agoThe Commodore 64 manual literally taught people how to program -- it was as important as the machine itself.
- charles_f 4y ago(was meant to be satire but I guess it failed)