10 ms·
California Right to Repair Bill Dies in Senate Committee
- spicyusername 4y ago> The policy had broad, bipartisan support, with 75% of Californians and majorities of both parties supporting Right to Repair. > “Sadly, the powerful tech manufacturers won out over the everyday Californians and small businesses that would benefit from Right to Repair..." Can someone elaborate specifically on how something like this failed with, apparently, so much support?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nness 4y agoI don't know how relevant this point is specifically for this bill — but I've always wondered if politicans simply "supported" a bill or otherwise did not speak out in favour/against because they know it'll be a quiter death if they say one thing/vote another. Rather then begin a drawn-out and public campaign in support/against. Easier to be disingenious than "make it my issue."
- sjburt 4y ago
- pm90 4y agoI would like to see them actually follow through on this absurd threat.
- black_puppydog 4y agoLol yes, after years of actual water shortage and housing shortage being "not great, but you know, we manage" this would certainly push the state over the edge into full-on Mad Max thunderdome mood. :D
- lokar 4y agoThere is only a water shortage if you insist on irrigation by flooding fields in vast inland desert
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- busterarm 4y agoThen you're trading a water shortage for a food shortage. Rock. Hard place. There's a long list of fruits and vegetables where California growing is the source of nearly 100% of the nation's consumption. Celery, Garlic, Walnuts...Spinach is up near 80%...Lemons 50%.
- lokar 4y agoAnd yet they use vast amount water to grow nut trees in a desert, rice as well as alfalfa for export to feed dairy herds in China. There is plenty of water to grow all of the veggies needed, if it was done responsibly
- rcpt 4y agoBeef and dairy use more water than nuts. We only deflect attention to almonds because the meat industry is excellent at influencing public opinion
- Dylan16807 4y agoAccording to what estimates? I'm seeing various numbers but they're suggesting a bit under 2000 gallons of water to make a pound of both almonds and beef. The almonds do have more calories, but that's a really unimpressive number for both. The reason we talk about almonds is because both of those are wasteful, and both of those are enormous uses of california water, but california has 6% of the country's cattle and 80% of the entire world's almonds. I can't find a good estimate for milk.
- idontwantthis 4y agoThere's no way they made that threat. California is the 5th largest economy in the world.
- ksec 4y agoI dont know if they made that threat to California, probably not for Apple, since they could get what they want without doing so. But they did made similar threat to the UK and EU. Possibly hinted in AUS. So it is not the first time Apple did this.
- TrackerFF 4y agoWith almost 90% of the population in California being over age 10, that would be quite that market to ignore. It's more people than almost all of Scandinavia combined.
- bluescrn 4y ago
- throwingrocks 4y ago> Can someone elaborate specifically on how
- rtkwe 4y agoThe lobbies only have to focus on swaying the committee members because all bills have to make it through the relevant committees before being voted on widely. There are ways for bills in some legislatures to skip the committee process but usually by unanimous votes or large percentages.
- guerrilla 4y agoOops, I meant to answer you but someone asked the same question [1]. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31559612 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31559612
- KerrAvon 4y agoYou know, sometimes bills intended to do something good are actually really bad. I don’t know if that’s the case here, but two things strike me as red flags on a quick read: - There are references to specific dollar amounts in the bill with no provision for automatic adjustment due to inflation. - There is the following passage. “(2) For products with a wholesale price to the retailer of not less than fifty dollars ($50) and not more than ninety-nine dollars and ninety-nine cents ($99.99), that contains an electronic security lock or other security-related function, the manufacturer shall also make available to owners of the product, service and repair facilities, and service dealers, on fair and reasonable terms, any documentation, tools, software and parts needed to disable the lock or function, and to reset the lock or function when disabled, during the course of the inspection, diagnosis, maintenance, or repair of a product for at least three years after the date a product model or type was manufactured, regardless of whether the three-year period exceeds the warranty period for the product.” That sure seems like a requirement for a secure enclave backdoor.
- Zhenya 4y agoSo they will sell the dumb lock for $75 and the security insert for $25. See ya later, legislator!!
- bcrosby95 4y ago> That sure seems like a requirement for a secure enclave backdoor. Apple uses hardware pairing. Without such a tool you couldn't even swap two genuine parts with eachother.
- Dylan16807 4y agoA reset isn't a backdoor.
- KennyBlanken 4y agoWhat the hell is their reasoning for only having a rule that applies to devices that cost $50-$99.99, aside from likely ruling out every cell phone? > the manufacturer shall also make available [...] for at least three years after the date a product model or type was manufactured How much you want to bet that was put in to allow manufacturers to supply software tools that the manufacturer can either remote-disable, or have time-bombs built in, or both? Watch a cell manufacturer shrug and come out with the "YZ 5 Pro", manufacture it for a year, and then come out with the YZ 5 Pro A" the next year, etc. Seems like this got poison-pilled just like a lot of gun legislation which is written to focus on things easily changed so they're not effective. "Guns over 14 inches with a vented barrel grip installed during manufacture" write the lobbyists, and then they send a memo to gun manufacturers to plan on adjusting their tooling to make 13.95 inch barrels, or leave off the barrel grip, easily installed by dealers or buyers.)
- FollowingTheDao 4y ago
- spicyusername 4y agoI'm trying to understand the specifics of what happened in this particular case. Was it corporate influence? Was it bad policy design? Was it a failure of process? None of the above? All of the above? Something else? It's all too easy to cynically handwave and parrot platitudes like "politicians are corrupt", "capitalism is bad", etc. Reality is far more complicated than those overly simplistic platitudes let-on and parroting them doesn't meaningfully contribute to the discussion of what to do better next time. If we want to understand how to implement lasting change through government policy, the context and details matter when seemingly good policies fail.
- TrackerFF 4y agoCan anyone familiar with the process, explain exactly how these industry lobbyists win these cases? With a 75% of Californians being pro-right to repair, and with bipartisan support - you'd think this would be an easy case to argue. Do the lobbyists have some incredibly legitimate insider information they share with the senators? Do they just throw cash/donations at them?
- lolinder 4y ago75% of Californians are pro-right to repair when asked, but that doesn't mean that 75% really know what it means much less care about it. The legislature is probably assuming that the campaign money from the lobbyists will more than make up for the lost votes from the tiny minority that truly cares.
- whoopdedo 4y agoIt also depends on who is asking the question. A right-to-repair advocate would ask "Do you support this law that will lower the cost of repairing old phones?" and most people will agree. Then an industry group asks the same people "Do you support this law that will raise the cost of making new phones?" and get a different answer.
- Wowfunhappy 4y agoI realize you’re making a hypothetical point about the importance of question phrasing, but I really don’t see how this law would raise the cost of making new phones.
- 41b696ef1113 4y agoI think it is reasonable to imagine some manufacturing processes that are single shot construction. Gluing pieces together rather than screws/fasteners comes to mind.
- Wowfunhappy 4y ago
- mijoharas 4y agoAs someone that doesn't have a strong understanding of american politics, can I check my understanding? This means that a majority of senators voted to oppose the bill, (after it had been approved by the house). Is that correct? Are there common websites where you can see exactly how individual senators vote on specific issues? (in the UK we have publicwhip.org.uk where you can search anything that you care about and see if your mp voted in a way you agree with). What method do americans tend to use to check that their politicians are voting in their interest?
- Avshalom 4y agoBefore a bill goes before the full Senate it gets debated/edited in a relevant committee, if the committee votes against the bill it never goes up for the full vote.
- wiz21c 4y agoDoes it mean that whoever selects (controls) the committee pretty much selects the fate of the bill ?
- Avshalom 4y agoThe committees are generally permanent, not instantiated per bill, and the senators on the committee doesn't change often (the majority party does get to have a majority membership in all the committees) but yeah, committee membership can be really powerful and gets used as a reward/threat by party leadership.
- glowingly 4y agoNot really. In CA, if h/a really wanted something, they could gut and amend an existing bill that did make it out of committee. Or use the proposition system (public vote), but that system is just as captured, IMO.
- mijoharas 4y agosorry, what is h/a?
- diebeforei485 4y agoCollect signatures and put it on the ballot.
- 88j88 4y agoSo if I am reading this correctly, a majority of votes (unanimous) were cast to pass the bill, but this was held in some subcommittee instead of moving to senate floor? Who is this subcommittee, and why do they have more power than the people, plus the senators who voted unanimously?
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> why do they have more power than the people How did you conclude this?
- tigen 4y agoThis committee is the following seven people: Senator Anthony J. Portantino (Chair) Senator Patricia C. Bates (Vice Chair) Senator Steven Bradford Senator Brian W. Jones Senator Sydney Kamlager Senator John Laird Senator Bob Wieckowski
- Drunk_Engineer 4y agoYou would think if anyone understood the problem of eWaste it would be Sen Laird. From his Bio: "Laird served as a member of the State Integrated Waste Management Board from 2008 to 2009 and taught state environmental policy at University of California Santa Cruz."
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- abledon 4y agoThrong of GPT-3 powered complaint emails coming in 3...2...1...
- wyrm 4y agoThank you. Exactly the info I was looking for. Now, where did you find it, so I can look there next time?
- tigen 4y agolisted on https://sapro.senate.ca.gov https://sapro.senate.ca.gov
- onphonenow 4y agoMassachusetts already did a limited form of right to repair. I know at least Subaru and Kia now don't sell with certain features in MA as a result.
- KennyBlanken 4y agoMA passed a right to repair bill requiring tools be made available to third party mechanics. So car companies shifted all the functionality of those tools into "telematics" (so for example, instead of a Subaru tech plugging in a scan tool, now he logs into a Subaru website which talks to the car over its cellular based telematics link) and said "neener neener, you didn't say telematics in your law, HAW HAW!" So MA passed a second right to repair bill specifying telematics is included, and slapped back harder by speccing that they had to establish various systems to grant third parties access, etc. A couple of automakers responded by petulantly disabling telematics functions for any vehicles sold in MA. Of note: both bills were general ballot measures, because the Right To Repair folks knew that they'd never get a bill like it through the MA legislature due to lobbyists and legislative corruption (aided by much of the MA legislature's activities not being public record; the executive branch has also declared itself exempt from public record/meeting laws, as has the judiciary.) The other thing of note: automakers ran a massive advertising campaign including videos strongly implying that women would get stalked and sexually assaulted/murdered, presumably by third parties given access to their vehicle's telematics. They basically called independent mechanics rapists and murderers. Worse, they claimed that a sexual assault victim's NPO (RAINN I think? I forget) was against the bill. Turns out it was a bald-faced lie and the org wasted no time reaching out to press to inform them of that. It really tells you how much was at stake here profits-wise, and how important right to repair is, that automakers were willing to shout "YOU'LL BE RAPED BY YOUR MECHANIC!" and lie so blatantly about NPOs supporting them
- baskethead 4y agoAnytime anyone says that Democrats are on the right side of morality, please point to things like this. California has been strongly Democrat for decades and this is how things are. They are "progressive" on hot button issues like abortion and gun laws, but for the most part, they don't give a shit about regular people just like Republicans. We need a third party to disrupt the two party oligopoly that has tricked most Americans into thinking we have a choice. We currently have no choice because both parties don't give a shit about citizens, just how can they perpetuate the ruling class to continue to feed off us.
- cosmiccatnap 4y agoThere are a lot of non Americans asking how a bill that was universally condoned was killed and the answer is sad but not particularly complicated. American politics primarily works based off of what people see on TV or read in the news and what a politician says and what they do are entirely disconnected. So these politicians publically say whatever is the popular openion which in this case is that right to repair is good but then they placate to companies who don't want right to repair to succeed. This allows them to have their cake and eat it too. They get to say they tried to push for it but there wasn't support even when you can search and find that they in fact voted against it and are even often on the payroll of many of these companies in a round about way. How is this possible? Well you don't have too fool every American just most Americans and the overwhelming majority of Americans don't care about any issues that do not effect abortion, gun control, taxation, or jobs. This doesn't directly effect those things in a significant for Californians so it becomes quick forgotten in a month when some other hot topic becomes the news of the week. If a conservative politician is pro abortion and pro gun control they can do anything else they want legislatively and get the votes they need for reelection so they pass laws on the side in which they are sure to get financial kick backs for. It's basically a mr.smith goes to Washington but nobody ever has to deal with the consequences of corruption they just get upset when they are caught. Rinse and repeat.
- gcoguiec 4y agoIt's sad, but not only because it means people are forced to buy new too often or because of the atrocious increasing e-waste associated with it. It's sad because folks will be less and less interested in fixing their things or simply opening their devices to understand how they work. It'll be general knowledge that it's "dangerous" to attempt a repair, and they're impossible to fix anyway. Attempting a repair is one of those sparks that nurture curiosity. It's the same spark that ultimately gave us Apple and many other great businesses. Why are we indirectly undermining ingenuity and inventiveness? Is it a false perception? Or maybe Hanlon's razor? On the other side, China has relatively affordable access to parts (low-level components included), schematics, extensive tooling and a growing hacker/maker culture. Sometimes, I feel we (occidentals) are going into reverse.
- drdeadringer 4y agoA large part of my tinkering hobbies include fixing, not just making -- often a mix of both. A lack of "right to repair" seems to kill some aspect of both if not one of these.
- gruez 4y ago>It's sad because folks will be less and less interested in fixing their things or simply opening their devices to understand how they work those days are long gone. you might be able to disassemble a turntable to figure out how it works, but disassembling a phone isn't going to tell you much when all the magic is in the silicon. all you get from disassembling it is a circuit board with random bumps.
- okr 4y agoHm, these markets in Shenzhen seem to offer different stories. Youtube is full of those, you can replace/upgrade displays, memory, storage of your phone or even assemble your own. And in my country you have these little shops as well, where you pay a premium, but you dont have to buy a new phone. So, unless you really want to fix something very integrated, i am rather positive about the situation. And from my own history, mainboard was never really a problem, it was always something attached or plugged or solded onto it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kepler1 4y agoSometimes legislation being worked out dies because the details really can't be squared with reality or practicality. I have not seen an example proposal of language for such a bill that didn't invite many, many questions about how it would apply to certain manufacturers or products, and raise all sorts of issues about how it would be implemented, both now and in the future. Remember that legislation, if it is to be sensible, is necessarily a snapshot in time of some set of principles to govern the future. If those principles are sound, they can be stated in some finite and non-specialist text that an agency can go implement (which is their role to do the technical implementation of). If the legislation is 1000+ pages, something is being legislated at the wrong level, and something has been designed with too many exceptions, special cases, and opportunities for something to slip through a loophole. Or if it's just one page, how will someone figure out from that ambiguity whether something applies to their product? Some noteworthy fraction of people are in support (although... a certain minority if asked say they are in support of it, while many others have no idea what the issue is), but when it comes to their purchasing behavior it doesn't seem so. If you were to state the principles by which such legislation should be designed, what would they be? And if you then look at that language objectively, how many times would you have to ask "but what about...<xyz> issue/consideration"? If you, or the industry, have to ask that enough of a proposed bill, it will not work. You can say, well we'll have an agency responsible for working out these details. Ok, well that's how California has 200+ agencies, all paid government employees. Not everything is corruption and "influence of big money". Sometimes it is, yes. But sometimes it's that it can't be made a sensible law (for the moment). --------- I quote some notable passages from the bill that are examples of the above (https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtml?bill_id=202120220SB983 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtm...): Every manufacturer of an electronic or appliance product with a wholesale price to the retailer of not less than fifty dollars ($50) and not more than ninety-nine dollars and ninety-nine cents ($99.99), shall make available to owners of the product, service and repair facilities, and service dealers, sufficient service literature, at no charge, and functional parts and tools, inclusive of any updates, on fair and reasonable terms, to effect the diagnosis, maintenance, or repair of a product for at least three years after the date a product model or type was manufactured, regardless of whether the three-year period exceeds the warranty period for the product. To be made available at no $ charge? Why? What other publication or service do we mandate people do for no compensation? This section does not require a manufacturer to divulge a trade secret, except as may be necessary to provide service literature, documentation, tools, software, and parts on fair and reasonable terms. What constitutes a trade secret? Is it simply up to the manufacturer to declare that something is a trade secret and thus cannot be revealed? This section shall not be construed to require the distribution of a product’s source code. What is that defined as? What if the ability to repair is tied very closely to something about the source code which should not be revealed for security considerations? How about if the parts cost such a price as to make repair uneconomical? How about if the repair requires specialized equipment and training that the general public cannot receive feasibly? The list of questions goes on and on.
- squarefoot 4y agoWhat if FOSS an Open Hardware related pages would show links to the pages of those opposing the law, whether politicians or companies, along with "don't vote" or "don't buy" alerts? Sometimes, just sometimes, they fear bad advertising.
- franczesko 4y agoWhat does it mean "it dies in Senate Committee"? What's the process here? Does lack of "right to repair" essentially block someone from repairing his/her device or is it simply lack of legislation in regard to this matter?
- hoppyhoppy2 4y agoIt's referring to a bill (a proposed law) in California "which would have significantly expanded Californians’ access to the parts, tools, and service information needed to fix consumer electronics and appliances." So California state law remains the same as it has been. No changes (other than less hope for improvement via California state law in the near future).
- knowmad 4y agoWhat is the easiest way to find out who voted against this bill so I can put them in my "don't vote for these people" list?
- goldstone43 4y agoIt’s required by California state law to post all bills online along with associated vote tallies in committee and floor votes. The vote types are as follows: - Ayes (in favor), - Noes (against), - and No Vote Recorded (NVR; the equivalent of abstaining). Looks like the [most recent committee vote referred in the article for SB 8](https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billVotesClient.xhtml?bill_id=202120220SB983 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billVotesClient.xht...) is not online but will likely be by mid week.
- KennyBlanken 4y agoStrange how those votes take so long to tabulate and get online, so complex. Totally not to let things get out of the news cycle /s
- hungrigekatze 4y agoI found this site which is for nation-wide tallies of how (state) representatives voted: https://openstates.org/about/subscriptions/ https://openstates.org/about/subscriptions/ It's free to subscribe. But - IMO - it is likely that the OpenStates.org site monetizes the subscriber data somehow. As far as CA-specific 'follow what a piece of legislation is doing' there's this site from the California state government: https://www.assembly.ca.gov/informationtohelpyoufollowtheprocess https://www.assembly.ca.gov/informationtohelpyoufollowthepro...
- ChrisArchitect 4y agoMay 19th? Surprised it took this long for a post/story about this to make its way here. Didn't see anyone really talking about it around then either, though I see there were a number of Bay-area news stories about it.
- ChrisArchitect 4y agoRelated SF Chronicle story: Broken laptop? How California’s right-to-repair movement is trying to make it easier to fix your electronics https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31565827 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31565827
- aiscapehumanity 4y agoIt's not just "billionaires bad", there's a whole population of people in govt on both sides who are not impartial, and who have made the govt itself implicit in backing monopolous behavior here. No one took control of politicians mind to make them shills, they shilled out themselves
- wiseleo 4y agoInteresting. Susan Eggman is my local senator. I'll contact her office to work on the next attempt.