5 ms·
This is really good advice - for externalizers. For internalizers however, it is perfectly terrible. Before deciding to go all in on advice like this, it's cruc
by kelseyfrog 4y ago
This is really good advice - for externalizers. For internalizers however, it is perfectly terrible. Before deciding to go all in on advice like this, it's crucial to know where you fall along that spectrum[1].
Externalizers tend to place the locus of control outside of themselves which symbolically castrates them to fantasize about the objet petit a[2]. When it negatively impacts your life, you become the friend who likes to complain about everything but does nothing. Or worse, you're a person against the world who owes no one and impotently rages against everything.
Internalizers do the opposite. They will place immense burdens upon themselves to unrealistically adapt and change when most people would confront the challenge directly. An example is the Missing Stair[3] metaphor. An internalizer works around everything, always pushing the problem inward and never forcing the world to change. Internalizers can be harder to identify as they silently suffer in an absence of self-kindness.
What the article glosses over is knowing yourself[4] well enough to understand which tendencies you have. Maybe you tend to be an externalizer with your career and an internalizer with social relations or vice-versa or some other mixture entirely. It can be hard to be honest with yourself and ask, "Is this truly working for me?" But, those questions are hard precisely because they are the first step towards personal growth.
1. https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-theater-the-brain/201408/the-nature-nurture-question-nature https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-theater-the-brai...
2. http://cahiers.kingston.ac.uk/concepts/castration.html http://cahiers.kingston.ac.uk/concepts/castration.html
3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missing_stair https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missing_stair
4. γνῶθι σεαυτόν - which everyone should practice before blindly taking advice
- amelius 4y agoWhat does modern science say about these theories? E.g. wasn't most of Freud's psychosexual work debunked?
- kelseyfrog 4y agoI framed it psychoanalytically, but locus of control was coined by Rotter so its probably grounded more in behaviorism and social learning traditions.
- UmbertoNoEco 4y ago
- philosopher1234 4y ago> wasn't most of Freud's psychosexual work debunked? No, it wasn’t.
- fartcannon 4y agoHas anyone tried to replicate his results? Psychology got a lot of shit thrown at it during the ongoing replication crisis.
- andi999 4y agoI thought he didnt have results in the modern sense, more like personal interpretations and generalisation of individual patients. There is nothing to replicate.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- shrimp_emoji 4y agoNot debunked in the same way that religion was never debunked :p
- Dracophoenix 4y agoIs it possible for an internalizer to snap and become an externalizer? In which case would the advice apply?
- swayvil 4y agoThat's what's known as a "halfternalizer". They've got their own special way of doing things. Totally different nomenclature.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoIt's my personal belief that people have the capacity for change and it is largely dependent on desire and willingness. Having the words to conceptualize one's self can catalyze the process of self transformation and that's why it's important to talk about it. No one can snap change nor is a willing person's mind immutable. Maybe they find it possible to change one aspect of their life more than others. There's also therapy.
- Dracophoenix 4y agoPerhaps I wasn't clear enough before, but what I'm trying to ask is whether or not being an internalizer that acknowledges oneself as a victim (through burnout or a shocking epiphany) could lead to becoming a pessimistic externalizer. That because this ex-internalizer has recognized he has been victimized, he will try to study how he's been wronged and come to the conclusion that he had little control over his life. Or perhaps that staying quiet was what made one a victim in the first place, so that one should do the opposite. At that point, would "don't be a victim" be useful advice or an empty platitude?
- kelseyfrog 4y agoThat's certainly possible. Someone who has tried every possible way to direct their agency inward without results can simply burn out and feel helpless to affect change. By process of elimination, they've shifted their locus of control outward. This isn't a given though. I know plenty of people who overinternalize to the point of burnout and don't become cynical externalizes[1]. In my experience "dont be a victim" means "please stop complaining" more than anything else. A friend who truly does wish to help might start with getting curious about why the externalizing victim feels like they cannot affect change, but this is tricky. Often people don't want to be offered unsolicited advice or be made to feel like they have to prove that they have exhausted their options before being offered sympathy. It's a fine line. 1. Before someone else chimes in with it being a useless model because it does not make predictions - that's not the point. It's a mode of interpretation/critical lens, not a predictive model.
- goodpoint 4y ago> This is really good advice - for externalizers. For internalizers however, it is perfectly terrible I wish I could upvote you 10 times. The "don't feel like a victim" advice is a very dangerous when a person really is a victim and needs to get away from an aggressor. Besides, advice that works very well for 50% (or even 90%) of the population and harm the others is terrible advice. We need nuance.
- em-bee 4y agofeeling like a victim and being a victim are different concepts. the latter is reality, the former is a feeling, and how you deal with it. to me feeling like a victim implies that i can't change my situation. which exactly means that i feel that i can't get away from the aggressor. in order to get away from that i need to not feel like a victim, but take responsibility to better my situation by getting away. at least that is how i read the article.
- grammarnazzzi 4y ago> The "don't feel like a victim" advice is a very dangerous when a person really is a victim and needs to get away from an aggressor. Did you even read the article? By not feeling like a victim, you own your problem, and this enables you to solve it. In this case, by getting away from the aggressor.
- em-bee 4y agocould you clarify the difference between externalizing and internalizing please? isn't feeling like a victim the very definition of externalizing? wouldn't internalizing mean to blame yourself instead? doesn't accept personal responsibility translate (crudely) to: don't blame others, it's your own fault. (i realize that this is not the intent, i actually understand the article to mean that i should take responsibility for changing the situation, not just for getting into the situation in the first place. so this is just exaggerated to draw out the point) so yes, i agree this is for externalizers, but that's because internalizers would never see themselves as victims. (well maybe one can see oneself as a victim of ones past self) sorry, if i sound confused, i am trying to work this out as i write. so basically, the advice to not feel as a victim is a no-op for internalizers because they don't do that already. but what follows still applies: take responsibility to get yourself out of that situation likewise internalizers are also not immune to self-pity. externalizers feel they can't do anything because everyone else prevents them. internalizers feel they can't do anything because they themselves are lacking the necessary capacity. but the article says that neither is true. you can take responsibility and make your situation better. i think that applies equally to both. an externalizer can say: yes, that happened to me, but i can fix it, even though it's not my fault. and the internalizer can say, yes, i got myself into that situation, but i can also get myself out of it. so i don't really see much of a difference there, and why the advice would be terrible for internalizers.
- Delk 4y agoI think GP's point might be that, if you tell an internalizer who is miserable -- and thus seeing the fault in themselves -- that it's bad to feel victimhood or a fault in others or in their circumstances, you might push them further into self-blame even if their misery was brought by bad luck, or if they're disproportionately seeing a failure in themselves already. What you say makes sense from a solutions point of view that assumes people presently have the mental capacity to improve their lives and circumstances. Sometimes it works, and it's always attractive to think of and offer solutions, but it can be a two-edged sword. If you say that to someone who's burned out (for lack of a better expression; doesn't have to be burnout), out of capacity and miserable and disproportionately blaming themselves for that, you might just increase their self-blame rather than positively encouraging them towards solutions even if your intention is the latter.
- 0x20cowboy 4y ago> Internalizers do the opposite. They will place immense burdens upon themselves to unrealistically adapt and change when most people would confront the challenge directly. [...] An internalizer works around everything, always pushing the problem inward and never forcing the world to change. Internalizers can be harder to identify as they silently suffer in an absence of self-kindness. This blew my mind. Thank you for that.
- nradov 4y agoNah. That's just nonsense pop psychology with no real scientific basis. Avoiding seeing yourself as a victim is good advice for everyone, regardless of their perceived locus of control.
- Bakersfield 4y agoRape victims would vehemently disagree.
- barrysteve 4y agoRape victims dont like falling into a black hole where they are 'marked' as victims. They dont like when most people in their life relate to the rape event as the primary subject and not the person who was raped.
- grammarnazzzi 4y agoYour distinction is irrelevant. Owning your problem will always result in a better outcome than focusing on victimhood and blame. Blame places control and solutions outside yourself.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoI'm getting at the difference between people that give up because they feel they have no control and people who feel like they can only change themselves. Both of those are maladaptive in their extremes. Figuring out which sort of tendencies one has and adjusting that is a step toward owning your problems. The steps toward ownership looks different for these two types.
- barrysteve 4y agoInternalizers shouldn't work around things, they should turn away from evil. The Missing Stair metaphor was started from talking about a rapist in a bdsm community. Sexual immorality should be removed from the communion. Generalizing the Missing Stair metaphor to any given Challenge, opens the user up to studying evil and spreading the fire by challenging it. Turning away from evil "missing stairs" works better as a generalized concept as it works better in most cases and gives the missing stair person, a chance of redemption by turning to the good by following the internalizer.
- zozbot234 4y agoIt seems like in both cases, the relevant portion of the advice is just fixing that missing stair step in the most effective way. Work on what's broken inside your house, before complaining about the world.