9 ms·
A city fights back against heavyweight cars
- jimmaswell 4y agoPeople with such vehicles already naturally pay more in fuel taxes. An actual productive solution to any safety concerns would be mandating some kind of sensor or camera retrofit, optimally with a tax credit for anyone who has to do it.
- pmyteh 4y agoIt's not just safety concerns in general (though it could be in DC): the other problem is that road damage is approximately proportional to the fourth power of axle weight. So doubling the weight of a car causes 16 times the road wear. And a car twice the size takes up twice as much road room and parking area too. So there are externalities with bigger vehicles that are beyond that of mangled pedestrians and which their owners could reasonably be required to pay for. Of course, these are even more true of large trucks, which we would find much more difficult to eliminate, even if we wanted to. So it's always going to be a matter of judgement how to proceed.
- abeppu 4y ago> road damage is approximately proportional to the fourth power of axle weight It sounds like there must be some good and interesting physical reason for this. Do you have an intuitive explanation for it?
- rektide 4y agoA person having to pay the intrinsic cost of usage does not affect whether they are adequately paying the extrinsic cost of their usage. There was some minor fuel tax benefit to the state, but with ultra-heavy electric vehicles like a electric Hummer, there's not really any penalty/paying of dues for having obnoxiously sized, dangerous vehicles.
- corrral 4y agoRoad wear and risk to other cars and pedestrians don't scale the same way fuel consumption does.
- ruddct 4y agoThe electric Hummer’s battery weighs more than my first car. It has a curb weight over 9000 pounds. Heavy cars do more damage when they hit things, emit more brake dust, and cause more damage to roads. Exploring ways to reduce (or appropriately tax) their use should be celebrated.
- rfiat 4y agoIt should be noted that it's possible for electric (~heavy) vehicles to emit less brake dust than conventional vehicles due to regenerative braking
- 1970-01-01 4y agoCheaper economy vehicles will use metallic brake pads that emit lots of dust. More expensive luxury vehicles (SUVs and trucks) use premium ceramic pads that wear much less per mile. EVs and hybrids add regen and don't need brakes to stop unless it's under emergency braking. It's absolutely not apples to apples, and people need to understand that fact.
- 1970-01-01 4y ago>emit more brake dust This is false.
- 1970-01-01 4y agoDid you just downvote a fact?
- gkop 4y agoTop result for “do heavier vehicles emit more brake dust?” is https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2590162121000216 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S259016212... > Heavier vehicles emit higher levels of brake and tire particles
- 1970-01-01 4y ago
- kube-system 4y agoSome EVs are close to or exceed 6000lb
- stefan_ 4y agoExcept things don't cost what they used to in 1970 anymore, which is about the point in time fuel taxes are stuck. And of course once moving, fuel consumption is surprisingly insensitive to weight.
- kube-system 4y agoWhen I think of cities where people drive F250s, DC is the last place I think of.
- pseudo0 4y agoIt's definitely uncommon, and the ones you do see around typically have out of state plates. Some are people commuting in from VA and MD, and others are just slow in registering their vehicle, or have a second residence elsewhere and keep the registration there. As the article notes, DC is expensive already when it comes to vehicle registration, so people avoid it when possible.
- yohannparis 4y agoTrue, DC should have a fee to drive in the city, like London. Execpt for vehicles registered in the city. Simple and effective!
- andlarry 4y agoAn appropriate way to welcome visitors to the city they fund.
- munk-a 4y agoI think if you asked DC whether they'd rather continue to be funded by federal income and burdened by the national politics that constantly dictate what they can and can't do - or whether they'd prefer to enjoy the same level of freedom that other US cities enjoy they'd choose the former. In fact I don't think - I know - DC statehood has been a hugely locally popular movement for quite some time. Just because you bought someone a coffee after punching them in the gut doesn't mean they appreciate your patronage.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 4y ago
- mig39 4y agoI don't think this will work. People who want to drive these vehicles will just register them somewhere other than DC.
- 0x53 4y agoDon't you need to prove residence to register the vehicle?
- chucksta 4y agoNot exactly https://wallethub.com/answers/ci/can-i-register-a-car-in-a-different-state-than-my-license-2140693858/ https://wallethub.com/answers/ci/can-i-register-a-car-in-a-d...
- kube-system 4y agoYes, you must be a DC resident to register a vehicle in DC. https://dmv.dc.gov/node/1118861 https://dmv.dc.gov/node/1118861 Even if you didn't, nobody would want to register a vehicle in DC unless you absolutely have to. It is not cheap or convenient.
- munk-a 4y agoAnd given that most of "DC" is actually just Arlington - this cost increase is going to have a minimal effect on heavy weight cars... especially since I'd assume a higher proportion of people owning these cars would be frou-frou suburbanites that likely don't reside in DC proper anyways.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Terry_Roll 4y agoYou dont own a fleet of container ships by any chance? What you have highlighted is known as a flag of convenience (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flag_of_convenience https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flag_of_convenience)
- kspacewalk2 4y agoYou can also tax based on engine volume, in order to penalize gas-powered vehicles more and still penalize curb weight indirectly. Probably a formula combining the two would be ideal.
- wizee 4y agoDisplacement taxes are terrible. There are many instances of large displacement engines (e.g. modern GM LS/LT series engines) that are lighter and more efficient than comparably performing smaller turbocharged engines. Penalize heavy vehicles that damage pavement, or vehicles with poor pedestrian safety, or gas guzzlers, but don't penalize one aspect of engine design (displacement) that isn't directly harmful.
- throwaway0a5e 4y agoI propose we tax vehicles based on their 0-60 time. Soft tire compounds and abundant wheel torque and available power are directly correlated with tire wear and tire wear directly translates into particulate pollution. This tax would also have the side effect of being slightly more burdensome on particular demographics that are most likely to come up with half baked "let's tax X" ideas that fail to pass even the most cursory analysis as these demographics tend to drive fast high performance sedans. Edit: Just to be clear, lower number = more tax. Work vans pay little, high performance toys pay a lot. This is a semi-satirical proposal.
- appleiigs 4y agoSo you want to tax the lightest cars and give a pass to large trucks which have a poor 0-60 time? Just like the comment you are replying to, you're taxing the wrong metric. Need to be more direct in taxing the problem.
- mattlondon 4y agoHigher taxes on fuel would do this too. Larger heavier vehicles need more energy to get around.
- 4y ago
- Tiktaalik 4y agoI think the regulatory approach of making these sort of vehicles more expensive is a good one. I'd love to see this approach be adopted at the provincial level where I live. There's going to be businesses that need this sort of vehicle and particular hobby enthusiasts will be willing to pay much more to have one, but regular people doing typical activities absolutely do not need these and we should dissuade them from buying vehicles that are so much more dangerous and polluting than others.
- ensignavenger 4y agoIf one can afford an F250 just for fun, $500/year ain't gonna affect nothing.
- bpye 4y agoMake the tax higher then.
- supertrope 4y agoA driver license endorsement for heavy vehicles would do more for safety than a tax.
- toss1 4y agoYup. I was definitely surprised at the puny suggested increases. If they are goint to increase registration costs, it should also not be merely "if >6000 Lbs, increase $500", but a formula steadily increasing the cost so that mfgrs don't merely post the 'official' curb weight 10Lbs under the threshold. So, something more like $10/year for every 100 Lbs over one ton curb weight. It'd be even better to do this via fees combined with a congestion tax system. This has worked very well for many cities to charge road use tolls higher in congested times, therefore motivating people to not use vehicles if they can avoid it. In this case, just increase the costs based also on vehicle weight, so the heavy vehicles have higher fees even at 3AM. Plus, this will avoid people avoiding it by registering their beast at their out-of-city home, or their brother's address or something.
- 4y ago
- tengbretson 4y agoWith any luck they will prevent the people that keep the lights on and the sewage flowing from ever setting foot in their city at all.
- munk-a 4y agoThat seems unlikely considering that businesses are much more rational at costing things out than hobbyists.
- tengbretson 4y agoIn a skilled labor market that is supply-constrained the rational thing to do might be to just go elsewhere.
- munk-a 4y agoPotentially - the truly rational response is to incorporate the additional fees into your operating costs and if you're running a plumbing business those costs are going to be amortized across a whole lot of clients and might end up being pretty negligible. You'd likely see more stratification between the DC and adjacent markets though - some proportion of the plumbers based in Arlington might refuse to serve DC proper to avoid the fee (if it were somehow enforced on them, which seems difficult given they're relying on registration) - but that'd lower supply and possibly give plumbers who do remain in the DC market more command over their price. Either way, when you're talking about running a business, if a 500$ expense is going to break the bank you're probably teetering on the edge of insolvency anyways.
- kube-system 4y agoNobody is choosing whether they live in DC or not based on a $500/year fee to register a 6000lb vehicle.
- hahaxdxd123 4y agoI distinctly remember seeing one day in Palo Alto, a pristine pearl-white lifted F250 alongside a battered old Ford Ranger that was actually carrying tools in its bed. The Ford Ranger was no larger or heavier than my sedan.
- SwetDrems 4y agoCars were a mistake. Cities would be much better without them.
- HeyLaughingBoy 4y agoMaybe cities were the mistake.
- imtringued 4y agoSuburban sprawl is financially bankrupt. It can't finance itself. It is like rural areas but rural areas are essential and deserve the subsidies.
- HonestOp001 4y agoAbsolutely not. Cars allowed people to access areas they would not be able to. Look at why sprawl occurred, it was not started by cars, it started with trains. The trolleys would allow for undeveloped land to be used, reducing rents that had been increased by demand. Then came the car. Instead of being dependent on the trolley to get you from place to place, you could allocate resources to get there. Economic activity boomed after that. There may be some difference on the implementation of automotive vehicles, but they are not a mistake.
- imtringued 4y agoSprawl is a symptom. You are fleeing from the city core because there are uncooperative individuals owning land and real estate. You cannot improve the city without their consent, so you flee and run away from the corrupt rent seekers.
- munk-a 4y agoIf cars had been kept as an additive to public transit then I might buy your position but a lot of public transit systems were specifically destroyed at the direction (and with subsidies from) car manufacturers. Trains and trolleys did allow for some suburban growth - but the sprawl didn't come into being until cars became the norm for transport... specifically, commuting by train and using cars for leisure could have been the world we live in, rather than this hellish landscape where cars are the norm for getting to the work or picking up groceries. This may differ from your world view but please just compare the west to east coast where most of the eastern cities were built first without cars in mind and only later expanded - vs. a lot of west coast cities that have always been car first. The difference is extremely stark.
- baby-yoda 4y agoa couple other comments have touched on something ive thought about alot recently; as ev adoption continues we are going to observe more asymmetry between older cars which are lightweight and relatively lower to the ground, and massive EVs with giant battery packs and high hood lines [0][1] a hummer EV's battery weighs 3000 lbs and the entire vehicle weighs 9,000 lbs. a 2005 Honda Civic coupe, which is generally very reliable and likely to still be in operation 17 years later, is 2,600 lbs. the civic doesn't stand a chance in a collision with the Hummer. of course the hummer might be a relatively lower volume vehicle but the f-150 and silverado are #1 and #3 respectively in volume; their ev counterparts are going to be all over the roads in short time. and they have similar increases in weight over their ice counterparts, 6000-7000 lbs each. i hope i'm wrong but i don't see how the number and severity of traffic fatalities go anywhere but up for the next 5-10 years. [0] - https://twitter.com/ajlatrace/status/1495124630868213764 https://twitter.com/ajlatrace/status/1495124630868213764 [1] - https://twitter.com/DrTCombs/status/1528853211582455814 https://twitter.com/DrTCombs/status/1528853211582455814
- Ekaros 4y agoThose are rare here but it will get fun in some European countries. Your regular license is not enough if mass is over 3500kg
- foepys 4y agoTo clarify for non-EU readers, that's 3,500kg fully loaded (gross vehicle weight), not just curb weight. Everything over 3,500kg requires you to get a special license and regular medical tests by a physician.
- supertrope 4y agoMany USA states allow up to 26000 lbs (11800 kg) on a regular driver license. (Which is awarded after one casual road test when you were 16 and each state thereafter accepts your prior license as proof of skill). Commercial operations like Amazon delivery intentionally order trucks right up to this 26K limit to avoid having to hire CDL holders (commercial driver license) and follow DOT regulations.
- teakettle42 4y agoEverything I don’t like should be illegal. If we cannot make it illegal, it should be inordinately inconvenient. If we cannot make it inordinately inconvenient, we should at least do something so that we can feel better about ourselves having done something. Whether or not it actually solves the problem - or if there’s even a problem in the first place - barely registers as a concern. I doubt DC has a lot of 6,000lb personal vehicles on the road, and I doubt a $500/year tax will dissuade anyone from buying one. Reminds me of how Boulder instituted a steep sugar tax despite being one of the healthiest cities in the country.
- tomohawk 4y agoIn DC, a lot of the luxury vehicles are provided by corporations, almost all of whom are sited in/around DC to exert influence on the government. So the people making these sorts of rules will not be affected by them, and they are just making a moat around the luxuries that they want to enjoy so that they have status over the common folk. Kind of like politically connected and wealthy people wanting to get rid of gun ownership. They will still have armed body guards provided by the state or that they pay for.
- imtringued 4y agoHeavy vehicles cause significant road damage, scaling the tax based on vehicle weight is actually very reasonable. I personally would rather turn your comment around. "Paying for the road damage I caused is something I don't like, it should be illegal" That is how capitalism works. Just make doing the right thing illegal. People complain about the homeless problem but don't talk about how they made it illegal to not have homeless people. They spend insane amounts of resources, like $60k per year per tent, because that is the best option that is still legal.
- hahaxdxd123 4y agoExternalities on others should be taxed, yes.
- robocat 4y agoYour comment deeply upsets me. Perhaps you need to be taxed for your comments that upset others. We should also tax low-quality off-topic comments as well?
- kkfx 4y agoI do not know in USA, but in UE norms demand roads to be able to normally operate ad SEVENTH time the expected mean load, so I doubt than an "oversize" car (not big truck) would made significant wearing to public roads. IMVHO the issue is another: we can't sustain cars in cities anymore because there are too much cars for roads and parking infra. There is no "classic" solution for that: cities can only be just public-transport + only needed vehicles (emergency/work-related etc) to work and being NOT designed for such usage they can't easily be adapted => cities are dead end, we can only rebuild them and we already know that since anything change at a certain speed doing such enormous challenge will be pointless, for when it end we will end up in the similar issues for newer/mutated needs and gears. Long story short IMVHO we need some "hub", where people live nearby, BUT little kind an on-purpose only like "this is a place where only students and teachers live for their relative active 'duty', here is just a metallurgic area there are a residential part for workers, but just for their working times and all have relatives and homes elsewhere" etc. Tough to achieve but I see no over evolvable option. So far only moderately dense Rivieras have shown life and sustainability. Low density areas became too expensive, high density untenable. Aside we probably can't sustain anymore entertaining a modern country-wide road network, some countries like Finland here and there have barely admitted something alike, witch means we need something else to move. Small flying drones can be ok for private travel, no I'm not joking, actually a small flying car can cost as a road-born car, on similar scale, the far reduced infra costs compensate extra energy costs BUT that's can work for low weight transports. For logistic is a bit of a nightmare and for that so far I hardly see solutions behind a disperse economy where most of heavy and abundant stuff are local and local only witch is not much achievable. Another is waterways but they are usable only on the sea and large-enough rivers, witch means in too limited spot.
- vinyl7 4y agoThese kinds of threads give me the impression that HN is comprised of gargoyles who never travel more than 1 mile from their home
- halffaday 4y agoIf you’re designing a pavement structure based on the AASHTO Guide For the Design of Pavement Structures (1993), then you wouldn’t include anything other than trucks (semi-trailers, single-units, and buses) because passenger vehicles produce negligible wear. Even the devil’s own ride, the Ford F-250, produces 1/1350th the wear of one loaded semi-trailer. Given this is D.C., I would assume this is just a manifestation of petty malice toward symbols their council associates with people on the “wrong” side of righteous causes.
- Someone 4y agoI see that differently. Ballpark, that car causes 16 times the road wear of a car half its weight. Assuming comparable road usage, why wouldn’t its owner pay more to the government? And that ignores other externalities such as pollution, risk to pedestrians, etc. I think city councils should even seriously consider banning such cars from busy city centers, like quite a few cities (mainly in Europe) do with older Diesel engines (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Low-emission_zone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Low-emission_zone)
- halffaday 4y agoAn empty bus weighs 20,000lb or more. That’s around 80X the wear the trucks this bill targets causes, and you probably can’t put 80x more people on the bus. Why not axe the public transportation nobody with a choice actually uses?
- Someone 4y agoBecause we are civilized. Why not axe the unemployment benefits/wheelchair ramps/etc nobody with a choice actually uses? Those also incur large costs.
- Kon-Peki 4y ago> Other state and local leaders alarmed by “truck bloat” would be wise to study the D.C. law, which represents a first-of-its-kind effort to address the negative externalities — or costs borne by others — associated with larger, heavier SUVs and trucks First-of-its-kind? OK https://www.chicityclerk.com/sticker https://www.chicityclerk.com/sticker: > Vehicle with curb weight of 4,500 lbs or less with a payload capacity of 2,499 lbs or less - $90.88 > Vehicle with curb weight of 4,501 lbs or more with a payload capacity of 2,499 lbs or less - $144.33 > Vehicle, Truck, pickup truck with closed or open bed, or van with a gross weight of 16,000 lbs or less or with a payload capacity of 2,500 lbs or more - $213.82 > Truck or vehicle with a gross weight of 16,001 lbs or more with a payload capacity of 2,500 lbs or more - $481.10 This has been around for as long as I can remember, and there are a number of vehicles (especially minivans) where the lower trim levels pay one fee but the top trim level pays more.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gwbas1c 4y ago> Notably, no exception is available for residents claiming that they need a heavy-duty truck or SUV for their work This only vaguely alludes to why some people drive ginormous SUVs. If you "own your own business" you can deduct a truck from your taxes. My wife works with a doctor who "owns his own business." His family drives giant SUVs because it's cheaper than driving a normal car. The family across the street from me owns a franchise, and both parents drive giant vehicles. One of them is a truck that they use to tow large boats as part of their business; the other is never used for actual business purposes. (But it does have a commercial plate.) They have two kids.
- HeyLaughingBoy 4y agoYou can always deduct the vehicle if you own a business. I have a small business that generally grosses only a few thousand per year, but I deduct all business use of my personal car. The difference, IIRC, is that instead of amortizing the cost over years, IRS Section 179 allows you to expense the entire cost of a 6,000+ lb. vehicle in a single year. So if you own an Escalade like my neighbor, that's an $80,000 tax deduction in one year. It's certainly tempting and I'll probably do exactly the same thing once my business makes enough income for it to make sense. The tax code is a thing: use it to your advantage.