7 ms·
Practical power beaming gets real
- h2odragon 4y agoCool stuff! I wonder what will be left after the bitter bites of reality for consumer products: consider that we still have actual engineering troubles with things like aluminum in house wiring, which we've been doing for >100 years now. "battery free cordless" desktop peripherals will be nice, tho. Wonder what bandwidths the data overlays will be. If you're steering and modulating a beam for power, why not use it for signal at the same time?
- csours 4y agoWhen is this better than solar panels and batteries?
- Ancapistani 4y agoWhen your power source is a solar satellite in geosynchronous orbit, for starters :)
- elihu 4y agoPowering/charging aircraft without them having to land.
- synicalx 4y agoI could see that working from the top down - ie. something in space beaming power "down" to a plane. Going from the ground up seems like it could be a little risky, nuking other planes, passing birds etc. Having said that, a Goldeneye-type setup is also a little risky I guess.
- elihu 4y agoI would think it's the other way around: beaming power up, you're less likely to hit people and buildings and terrestrial animals. You'd just hit birds and potentially planes and satellites, but planes and satellites can be tracked so you can shut off power if they're too close.
- jhgb 4y agoI imagine that even just powering one receiver from many different transmitters would help you here, since only the receiver would be at the intersection of the numerous beams.
- willcipriano 4y agoIf you want to construct a underground chamber that is electrically isolated from another chamber but still has power. Say for running very sensitive experiments with RF.
- jotm 4y agoWifi is practical, too. But I prefer wired Ethernet whenever possible, even if it's hard.
- SemanticStrengh 4y agoHow much energy loss has the system? And what complexity curve fit its efficiency over length?
- c54 4y agoOne of the big problems with the current power grid is transmission loss, resistance in electrical wires over long distances eat ~5% of the generated power. This makes it infeasible for example to have large solar installations in the American southwest transmit power to the Northeast. Does anyone know about theoretical minimum losses from this kind of power transmission?
- kurthr 4y agoVery roughly minimum loss is 50% for a far-field optical or RF system (near-field can be better), excluding the energy cost of building the transmitter/receiver systems themselves. Losses due to impedance mismatch make this difficult to improve. The most efficient light emitters are ~50% and the best optical photo-voltaics are also ~40%, which would get you to an 80% loss, ignoring atmospheric losses.
- jhgb 4y ago> The most efficient light emitters are ~50% and the best optical photo-voltaics are also ~40%, which would get you to an 80% loss, ignoring atmospheric losses. Unless you have matched emitters and PV cells? For example [1] cites 53.4% conversion efficiency for monochromatic light. (The 40% figure was presumably sunlight conversion efficiency?) [1] https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/4922910 https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/4922910
- droopyEyelids 4y agoa current induction charger for a phone, that operates over about a millimeter of distance, is at best 70% as efficient as charging with a wire. The fact that this article omitted all details about efficiency, and omitted any numbers that we could use to calculate it, say it's probably not beating the standard induction charger's efficiency. I think this technology is more in the stage of "It's possible to do this!" rather than "it's practical to do this"
- hinkley 4y agoWord games are common in advertising and that has spread to journalism as well. “it’s impractical to shop for a house in a war zone” and “it’s impractical to buy a house in San Francisco” are two very different definitions of “practical”. It feels like that’s what’s going on here.
- sandworm101 4y agoNote that in all the pictures the receiver seems to be on a tower or at least above the emitter. No doubt this is a safety consideration. Nobody would dare test one of these things horizontally. And good luck with this anywhere near an airport. If they are worried about 1w handheld lasers, a 400w one aimed skyward will require a NOTAM every time you want to turn it on. The boiling tea thing goes back long before the Japanese team working on this tech. That is a reference to pre-WWII request from the British government for tech that could boil a few liters of water a distance: a death ray. That request eventually resulted in what we now today call radar. https://www.bbc.com/news/business-41188464 https://www.bbc.com/news/business-41188464 >> "Suppose, just suppose," said Watson Watt to Wilkins, "that you had eight pints of water, 1km [3,000ft] above the ground.
- TameAntelope 4y agoJust put them underground.
- bialpio 4y agoAt this point you might as well just put cables in the hole that you had to dig up, right?
- minsc_and_boo 4y agoWired cables still have electrical resistence. Better to beam power over buried vacuum tubes.
- ben_w 4y agoThese systems are less efficient than even mediocre cables. But if you could affordably construct a continental scale vacuum tube, you could do much better than even a good existing industry standard cable: Vacuum is a good insulator, so you can put any superconducting cable you like in the middle of the vacuum tube and keep it cold with minimal cost. In principle you could even do away with the cable, by shooting electrons down the tube and collect them at the other end. No resistance so this is a room-temperature superconductor (non-quantum, I believe the term is "ballistic superconductor").
- rektide 4y agoHighly tuned wavelength-specific photovoltaic sounds interesting. > The receivers for optical power transmission are specialized photovoltaic cells designed to convert a single wavelength of light into electric power with very high efficiency. Indeed, efficiencies can exceed 70 percent, more than double that of a typical solar cell. I'm still thinking of the last power-beaming example, a Navy microwave-based one, which showed up a month ago (and in this article) & was hyped up but ended up being pretty crazy low end-to-end efficiency if you read the fine fine print. If these folks really can do real 50% end-to-end efficiency- major congrats to them. At some point, I think solar concentrators probably do make great sense. We already have some pretty big scale solar-thermal plants. These can have nice thermal storage capacity, for off-peak usage. The idea of launching some satellites & trying to point lasers or concentrators down at an on-the-ground collector seems more promising than microwaves, given what lukewarm at best efficiencies we've seen out of attempts to leverage microwaves. That said, the article itself contra-indicates: > But there have been improvements in efficiency and increased availability of devices that operate at much higher frequencies. Because of limitations imposed by the atmosphere on the effective transmission of energy within certain sections of the electromagnetic spectrum, researchers have focused on microwave, millimeter-wave, and optical frequencies. While microwave frequencies have a slight edge when it comes to efficiency, they require larger antennas. So, for many applications, millimeter-wave or optical links work better. [1] https://newatlas.com/energy/us-navy-beams-1-6-kw-power-kilometer-microwaves/ https://newatlas.com/energy/us-navy-beams-1-6-kw-power-kilom... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31128267 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31128267 (245 points, 33 days ago, 194 comments)
- gigel82 4y agoIt starts interestingly enough talking about optical (which is proven possible though horrendously inefficient), but then goes into snake oil territory talking about charging mobile phones at a distance. I'm not an expert, so here's one explaining why wireless power is mostly bullshit: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MCyLO-1grEk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MCyLO-1grEk
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoI imagine beaming power to space (for powering space devices) and from space (from orbital solar power stations) would be pretty useful.
- petschge 4y agoIf you are doing solar anyway and need a decently transparent atmosphere to get power through, why not leave the solar panels on the ground?
- DennisP 4y agoBecause from a geostationary satellite, you'll collect power all through the night for most of the year. It's like having noon sun for 24 hours a day.
- jiveturkey 4y agoHow so? A geostationary satellite sees night time.
- DennisP 4y agoNot on most days, because the Earth is a lot smaller in the satellite's sky than it is from LEO, and the equator is tilted with respect to the Earth's orbit. So there's a 44-day period around each equinox, during which there will be shadow for a few minutes per day, up to 72 minutes at the equinox itself. The rest of the time, the satellite gets full sun for 24 hours. https://www.viasat.com/about/newsroom/blog/how-satellites-are-affected-by-the-spring-and-autumn-equinoxes/ https://www.viasat.com/about/newsroom/blog/how-satellites-ar...
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoRight-of-way, transmission lines running through expensive real estate, cooling towers heating up rivers, limits to size (you can run out of ground, but you'll never run out of space). And on the ground you get this annoying eclipse phenomenon called 'night'. Takes away half your potential collecting time. Also solar flux is like 9X more dense outside the atmosphere. So it takes far smaller surface to collect the same energy.
- mNovak 4y agoThe article jumps between multiple experiments (some laser some microwave), but if you're interested in the the recent 10 GHz microwave experiment the authors were a part of (and which was on the HN frontpage recently) -- 1.6kW delivered over 1km -- the details were published in [1]. Very relevant datapoint: the transmitter source was 100kW, fed into a 5.4m dish. The receiver array was 2x2m. The end to end efficiency, which this article pointedly avoids, is on the order of 1-2%, over 1km. [1] https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/stamp/stamp.jsp?tp=&arnumber=9662403 https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/stamp/stamp.jsp?tp=&arnumber=966...
- exmadscientist 4y agoThe laser system shown in the top photo is similar in efficiency. And, trust me, the engineers are very aware of it. It's also frighteningly expensive, with a large number of exotic things. (Source: I work with the guy who designed a big chunk of the receiver circuitry, among other things.)
- walrus01 4y ago100kW turning into 1.6kW is just gross, go buy ten 380W STC rated 72 cell monocrystalline Si photovoltaic panels, a really good charge controller and 10kWh of good quality battery storage instead.
- teleforce 4y agoForget about about wireless power transfer efficiency, the normal wireless power amplifier (PA) efficiency for cellular wireless applications (or any wireless systems) is probably just around 10 - 20%. This inefficiency is terrible not only because the use of modern linear wireless power amplifier but also due to other factors. For starter, there is a significant distance of wired connection between PA and the antenna that resides on the tower (yes wireless PA still need wires to function). This distance create delay effect on the signal and suddenly this unaccounted impedance mismatched (because delay is phase), and changing phase results in totally different impedance on the Smith Chart even for exactly the same signal amplitude. Secondly, wideband signal impedance matching (tens to few hundreds of MHz that are now the norm rather the exception) is impossible to do in analog domain as practiced by the industry and putting anything and everything not working as the mythical "memory effect". Can't wait until the climate change people get into the matter and realize that about half of the wireless systems power budget is due to the inefficiency of the freaking PA and all hell breaks loose.
- kubami 4y agoThe article mentions that in the 1975 they beamed 34kW but it doesn't say why this thread of research was not pursued further.
- grumbler348 4y agoWireless power over radio waves is a dead end. Radio waves go everywhere, great for your cellphone. But completely useless for power beaming. Most of that lost energy doesn't go into heat, but into your body. Lasers are the way to go.
- ben_w 4y agoRadio waves, like laser light, can be directed fairly easily. However, laser light is absorbed by far more things than is radio, which causes them to rapidly heat objects up much more effectively. Some of these things will catch fire, but if the things are water-filled, the effect is much the same for both radio and laser: the water boils until the steam pressure makes them explode. For example, eyeballs. No, if you really want safe beamed power, you probably want something that generally doesn’t interact with normal matter at all, but will act with some specific rare thing that isn’t in your body. Neutrinos would be great from a safety POV, if only we knew of anything that could absorb them usefully so we could turn them into useful energy at the receiving end.
- grumbler348 4y agoTake a look at the diffraction formula and plug in realistic radio frequencies. Even tens of GHz get all over the place very quickly, not to mention the more common place single digit GHz frequencies.
- ben_w 4y agoIt’s also reflected off many surfaces, which is how radar works. And IR and visible light bounces off most non-black surfaces (the latter by definition of the word 'black'). UV is also (with strength varying by frequency) diffused by the atmosphere. But RF needs higher power to become dangerous: Even mere diffuse reflection of 0.5 watt laser light is considered a blinding hazard.
- grumbler348 4y agoReflection is not so scary once you have a wave that doesn't go everywhere but really approximates a point source. And if you go high enough with RF frequencies, you'll get significant attenuation when passing through objects just like with light.