8 ms·
Behind the Pretty Frames: Elden Ring
- weltensturm 4y agoSo that's why my 1600X was not good enough
- wincy 4y agoMy GTX 970 on medium was fine. This whole thing is a little confusing to me, why would my slower card be faster?
- gamblor956 4y agoCertain advanced graphics features are enabled or utilized if you have a graphics card that supports them. Unfortunately, the implementation of some of those features was poorly ported or implemented, so you end up with performance issues. Ironically, because the older cards can't support those features, they don't have the performance issues related to the bad implementations.
- weltensturm 4y agoI meant the Ryzen CPU (is there a GPU with that name?), should have been more specific. My GPU is a GTX 1080 and it was unenjoyable to me with that CPU, now I have a 12600KF and it runs pretty well. The OP article shows quite well how CPU bound this game is.
- thrwyoilarticle 4y agoAny time I saw some pretty new vista in Elden Ring, I felt guilty that I wasn't appreciating it. My suspicion is that the FOV is fixed and small for balance reasons & this detracts from the landscape, making it hard to take it all in. For example, the first reveal of Leyndell with the [spoiler] draped on the right of the screen would be more impressive if you could see more of the city to the left.
- djtango 4y agoI often used the telescope from high vantage points to take in the view The game I feel struggled most with this was FFXII - that camera was so bad, wanted you staring at the floor at all times. I remember peeking up inside the airship station and noticing how detailed the ceiling was and what a waste the world had been because of a poor camera
- FridgeSeal 4y agoThe game also desperately needs widescreen monitor support-wpuld definitely help in admiring more of the landscape.
- SECProto 4y agoI also had issues with it, not so much for the fixed camera FOV, but because the weird momentum/camera mechanics (it always felt like it was pulling and shifting in non-linear ways I couldn't control) made me feel motion sick within a half hour of getting in game. Googling at that time, it seemed like a common enough issue that people had hacks or add-ons or workarounds to address it, but I ended up just returning it for a refund as I had less than the steam hours limit.
- myfavoritedog 4y ago
- flohofwoe 4y agoReading the first few paragraphs (mainly the 25k descriptor copy and CBV creation calls) I really wonder if the game would perform better on PC if they had just gone with a traditional D3D11 renderer (assuming the team is more familiar with D3D11 than D3D12). At least it explains why the game stutters on my PC with a 2070RTX even at 1080p and medium graphics settings (so the performance problems are most likely not caused by too complex shaders).
- AHTERIX5000 4y agoProbably. It's funny that the game at least used to run better on Proton due to bad DX12 API usage workarounds implemented in the translation layer. Enabled mitigations can be tracked from https://github.com/HansKristian-Work/vkd3d-proton/blob/master/libs/vkd3d/device.c#L504 https://github.com/HansKristian-Work/vkd3d-proton/blob/maste...
- revolvingocelot 4y agoYeah, I laughed heartily at my Windows-bound friends as my shitbox 3400g iGPU linux machine put out a smoother experience than their Actual GPU'd rigs. I stopped laughing when day-two (or so) patches resulted in most enemies turning invisible for me thanks to rendering pipeline priorities. 1.4 has fixed that, but I learned a lot about regulation.bin and the various things it controls. [0] [0] https://www.nexusmods.com/eldenring/mods/109?tab=description https://www.nexusmods.com/eldenring/mods/109?tab=description
- tomrod 4y agoI've found my game stutters when game files become invalid. Revalidating through steam (apologies, don't remember the specific term) fixes the issue. EDIT: I stand corrected, the more common stutter issue the article describes is different altogether.
- wincy 4y agoI was confused when the game came out because I was running a GTX 970 and never had any stuttering issues with medium settings. Not sure why, but everyone I knew with a newer nicer card had the stuttering issues.
- WithinReason 4y agohttps://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:194vKfEg_GUJ:www.mamoniem.com/behind-the-pretty-frames-elden-ring/ https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:194vKf...
- havblue 4y agoIs it going to be worth waiting for the pc port to finally get patched sufficiently, maybe with ultrawide, or should we just enjoy it now? I get the sense from digital foundry that if you're perceptive about performance problems then maybe it's worth waiting. I suppose another option would be to just enjoy it on steam deck because that version already runs in a state that's closer to optimal.
- jpeter 4y agoYea the pc patch will be released just after bloodborne next gen version. So never
- mizzack 4y agohttps://github.com/gurrgur/er-patcher https://github.com/gurrgur/er-patcher Been playing ultrawide and 144hz for a while. Mostly offline, but haven't been banned online, either.
- ARandumGuy 4y agoFor general performance, the game is perfectly playable. It's capped at 60 fps, and there is still the occasional stutter (like, once an hour max for me). But if performance is what's been keeping you from picking up Elden Ring, I would say jump right in. The worst performance issues have been fixed, and it's easy to look past any other issues. Regarding ultrawide: as far as I know, there's no official plan to add ultrawide support. So if you're waiting for ultrawide support, you may be waiting a long time.
- dudeman13 4y agoMy gear is better than the recommended specs. I have to turn off anti-cheating (i.e. https://www.nexusmods.com/eldenring/mods/90 https://www.nexusmods.com/eldenring/mods/90) to make it run smoothly, which disables online interaction. Seems like it's down to luck whether EasyAntiCheat will wreck your performance or not. I can run it at almost max settings without EAC, but even with minimum resolution and minimum everything else it runs like crap with EAC.
- whelming_wave 4y ago
- boringg 4y agoWas going to try this game out based on reviews i was hearing and people swearing this is a “masterpiece” game but ive also read its unplayable in PC even with top of the line gaming rigs. How does a company do such a Poor job on a port like that?
- Dobbs 4y agoBugs in the anti-cheating software, who knows if it was enabled or not on the testers computers.
- pawelduda 4y agoI was delaying my decision to play Elden Ring on PS5 due to numerous reports that it has pretty noticeable FPS drops, even in 'performance mode'. Finally decided to give it a chance and have zero regrets when it comes to it. Yes, it's far from perfect but good enough for me to not be annoyed with it. Times I have been upset because of FPS is close to 0, which is like 1000 times less than because of yet another death. My point is, people talk about FPS drops, stutters, etc., but everyone has different tolerance to these things. So it's better to check it out yourself if this is the main reason holding you back. Make sure you can get a refund/sell the copy if you're unsatisfied. Will likely play it again in my lifetime.
- ohgodplsno 4y agoUnplayable is exaggerating it. There are frame pacing issues, and dips are common, no matter the hardware. (Possibly due to them binding 25000 resources at every single frame). It is perfectly playable on PC.
- sdwr 4y agoPlayable maybe, but very painful. It said I was getting 60 down to 40 frames, but it always felt like it was running at 20fps. Im glad someone is investigating, its a good game held back by terrible optimization.
- lc9er 4y agoI've had almost no problems with the game. In about 110 hours of play time, it has crashed once, and had two minor slowups in game play. Both lasted a just a second or two. I'm very happy I took a chance on it.
- andy_ppp 4y agoNo chance of an Apple Silicon port of Elden Ring is there? Looks like a really fun game...
- wincy 4y agoJudging from the modus operandi of most Japanese game developers, I would give this a 0% chance of happening, unless you're planning to buy Bandai Namco and make them do it. Which because this is HN, for fun I looked up, is worth about 100 billion USD.
- brootstrap 4y agoThe game owns and article makes a great point. These games around about high resolution graphics and densely packed pixels. It's about the atmosphere, story, setting, your personal struggle against seemingly impossible odds. The fact people care about graphic quality is pretty funny to me. Go play the latest FPS online loot shooter if you want "triple A" graphics. The game is a masterpiece in it's own right. Its like taking a dark souls game and making it bigger and bigger. Then just when you thought you were nearing the end. Oops sorry you are only 30% done with the game! I'm at 100 hours on PC , getting close to finishing. Some graphic stutters near release but since then i've had no issues at all. Medium level rig.
- oneoff786 4y agoI wish elden ring was smaller. I thought the open world concept was very poorly executed. I didn’t know where to go at first so I explored pretty much the entire open world unable to do much other than run past everything. The remainder of the game was just teleporting around so the open world was irrelevant. The bosses were good. The legacy dungeons were good. But the open world was largely a one time early game tax to find flak upgrades. I felt frustrated that I was not clearly shown where level appropriate content was. I don’t mind the option of seeking inappropriate content, but it should have been more transparent. I spent the game picking up herbs. Never used any. I picked up loads of weapons, but couldn’t use any them effectively without respeccing or farming weapon upgrades. I found very few of the mini dungeons organically and had to look up where to find them but they tended to be pretty dull and reuse the same bosses. The quests were equally inscrutable without a guide. Finding bosses that are just way too strong for you sucks. Leyndell and onward aren’t really open world. They’re mostly just linear areas, which I liked more but I also suspected was mostly due to budget and scope cuts. I would have gladly traded the vast open world and mini dungeons for a few more well designed legacy dungeons and bosses. I played with no summons and beat malenia with two whips and no skills for reference if it matters
- arkaic 4y agoSounds like you would love the Dark Souls games. They're Elden Ring without open world, and all legacy dungeons.
- corysama 4y agoFor more articles like this, check out https://www.reddit.com/r/TheMakingOfGames/search?q=frame&restrict_sr=on https://www.reddit.com/r/TheMakingOfGames/search?q=frame&res...
- doodlebugging 4y agoThis sounds like an awesome game. I wasted hours yesterday trying to get past the white screen of death so my son could play. We have worked through every "fix" documented online on several forums with no joy and still the game will not start. I believe it fails in the Easy Anti-Cheat at start-up. I will get the machine in hand this afternoon at some point so I can personally troubleshoot the issues since doing the phone tech support thing for a couple of hours after midnight with someone who has already run through all the documented fixes can be frustrating (and funny) itself.
- LanternLight83 4y agoIdk if you're on Linux, but what worked for me with Linux+Nvidia was enabling CONFIG_SGI_GRU
- doodlebugging 4y agoThanks for the linux nudge. For anyone who is thinking about Elden Ring on Linux I was able to dual boot linux using Pop-OS! and install the Steam client, download the game and it played perfectly straight out of the box. I borked the Windows installation in the process when I disabled Secure Boot, Fast Boot, and Intel RST. I'll work on repairing all that later. I initially attempted installing Ubuntu since I have recently messed with that on another machine. I ran into the Intel RST problem and in the process of investigating that I discovered Pop-OS!. Reviews claimed it was quick to install, came with NVidia drivers (if you select that version on download), and was tuned for gaming. I did install Pop-OS! to a separate SSD drive since they're cheap enough nowadays and, after finding the upgrade info for this machine, it was simple to install. I have it all running on an MSI Aegis 3 Plus with 1080Ti. I have had an NZXT rig sitting in a box for months waiting be set up and this whole exercise was just what I needed to compel me to open it all up and set it up. It's still a Win10 box but I plan to dual boot it too.
- doodlebugging 4y agoThanks for the reply. Unfortunately this is a Win10box from MSI trying to run Elden Ring thru Steam. It exceeds the specs to run the game, everything is updated, etc but it hilariously white screens within seconds of starting the game. We have so far managed to optimize the thing to the point where the white screen that had taken 15-20 seconds now occurs in less than 5. Saves a lot of time when your crashes happen faster so you can move on to the next potential issue without losing those valuable seconds. It's gonna be a real treat dinking around with this later since I only know the sequence of the troubleshooting that I walked him through so I may need to unwind some of the stuff he did before he broke down and asked for help.
- boringg 4y agoUnrelated, but related. Is Elden Ring a game of the year kind of game, game of a decade kind of game or game of a quarter century kind of game / GOAT?
- brnaftr361 4y agoI would and have said it's the best game I've ever played.
- boringg 4y agoWhat makes it that good?
- brnaftr361 4y agoI think they just acknowledged what they were doing was making a video game. Like they weren't pretentious at all about it. There's not a bunch of long winded dialogue I don't care about. They didn't try to make it hyper-real. You don't need to pay attention to the stats on anything except for requirements. There isn't some narrow line of progression. With just a handful of exceptions, the loot is just openly available and not subject to luck, meaning grinding is almost entirely voluntary. It just feels like a game, a lot of other games feel like work. But I've also been playing FS games since Demon's Souls so maybe I put in the hard work already.
- coldpie 4y agoAt least decade, and it definitely belongs in the conversation for all-time.
- boringg 4y agoWhat makes it that good? I cant tell its more hype then reality.
- coldpie 4y agoI'm not a games review person so sorry if this comes across as clumsy. But they just made a really good video-game, you know? What really blows me away about it is how much of it there is. Yes, the world is big and full of interesting stuff, but other games have done that. What stands out here is the quantity and variety of mechanics. I'm still on my first playthrough and I'm doing a pure melee-focused build. There are dozens (hundreds?) of special skills that can be applied to hundreds of different weapons. Many weapons have their own special skills. Ditto all that for shields, and the armor you can equip. And since my character is melee-focused, I haven't even touched any of the huge amount of magic stuff that is in the game, nor ranged weapons, nor even most melee options that are better served by different stat progression choices. This is just a huge variety of playstyle approaches. I've been playing the game for three months and I'm looking forward to beating it so I can go back and try again from the start with a completely different approach. And it has such a pure focus on gameplay. Other games try to be movies or HBO miniseries. There's story and lore in Elden Ring if you want to dig for it, but personally I don't care about that, I'm here to play a game. It respects your time by respawning you immediately outside boss doors when you die. If you enjoy the challenge, you can tackle bosses immediately when you come across them. Or if you're struggling, you can go do something else in the world and come back later after you've built up your skills and weapons, and have an easier time of it. There's loads of optional content to find, for people who want additional challenge. It's just a really jaw-dropping, video-game experience that isn't trying to be something else. It's definitely a masterpiece video game.
- txsoftwaredev 4y agoHow does this play on the Steam Deck? I received mine recently and was thinking of giving that game a try.
- __david__ 4y agoCrazily, it plays better on the Steam Deck on than on many gaming PCs. Valve did some special optimizations for it specifically in the translation layer. Since all Steam Decks have the same hardware, they were also able to ship out precompiled shaders, avoiding all shader compilation related hitches. Digital Foundry made a nice video about it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o1HuX2_Hhss https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o1HuX2_Hhss