5 ms·
Large vessels, aircraft carriers are sitting ducks for rockets. Even with some anti rocket defense. It costs large amounts of money to build big ships and it c
by DeathArrow 4y ago
Large vessels, aircraft carriers are sitting ducks for rockets. Even with some anti rocket defense.
It costs large amounts of money to build big ships and it costs little to sink them.
- ghaff 4y agoWhich is why aircraft carriers aren’t tooling around the ocean on their lonesome.
- lumost 4y agoAn aircraft carrier can operate 400-1000km from a target, while moving at 40 kph. Much more time to mount an adequate defense compared to the Moskva 50km distance from the coast while sitting idle.
- caycep 4y agothe issue is - what is the D21 (and brethren) capability? I think the war gaming w/ the late USSR and now China as the opposing force worried re theater-capable ICBMs. It's not like the carrier can hide these days...
- ckozlowski 4y agoCan it not? I'd reverse the question: Can China find it? That's the part that I find missing from these discussions. Missiles like the D21 sound really deadly, but the information and communications needed to successfully target a carrier hundreds or thousands of miles away and deliver the weapon successfully is the much more difficult part of the equation. As the U.S. Navy (paraphrasing) said themselves, "The D21 has a long kill chain, and plenty of places to disrupt that kill-chain." Likewise, the carrier goes around with much more than it's planes and escorts. It has the information being fed to it from ISR elsewhere, from satellites overhead to pre-mission information, communications eavesdropping, etc to know what they're up against and when and where they might encounter it. That, in my opinion is far more important than the specifics and specs of such and such weapon. The success or defeat of a carrier battle group I think is going to depend far more on who knows what and when, and therefor, what's going on in the electromagnetic spectrum, than any singular missile.
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago'Can it not? I'd reverse the question: Can China find it?' You can find it yourself on free satellite imagery collected by the european sentinel satellites, provided globally free of charge. All ships are really easy to see from space, especially giant carriers. Ofcourse sentinel takes images once every few days, and how that compares to spy satellites and how you target a missile from there i dunno
- nradov 4y agoShips move around. Those satellites don't provide the real-time target tracks needed by ballistic missiles. Reconnaissance satellites are themselves no longer survivable.
- ckozlowski 4y agoSpot on. To add to this, the Navy knows those satellite tracks. It's one thing to spot a carrier in port from a days old image. It's another to find it actively evading you in wartime. And regarding the satellites themselves, also agreed. I really believe that success at sea is going to depend a large part on success in space, and many countries know it.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoWhat possible action can a carrier take to evade satellite that can take daily photographs? Its not a plane, it cant travel a thousand kilometers in a day. It can only be withing a limited radius of it's initial position I would expect that every major nation keeps track of every carrier on a daily basis
- lumost 4y agoPrecision targeting of hypersonic ballistic projectiles is very difficult. While landing ballistic missile within 100 miles of a carrier is trivial, direct hits with conventional weapons require high precision measurements of carrier velocity, and position. The inbound weapon has very little time to correct its trajectory, and few sensors which will be effective at hypersonic velocity at the ranges required.
- baq 4y agokhinzals are supposed to be carrier killers.
- trasz 4y agoSame way Russia is supposed to have a 2nd army in the world. AFAIK at this point Kinzhal was successfully used only once, against a barn.
- cpursley 4y agoKinzhal has been used multiple times according to western sources. Once against an underground weapons store where it's kinetic energy acted as a bunker buster. And a few other times against high level targets like foreign weapon stores and mercenaries.
- trasz 4y agoThis "underground weapons store" sounds exactly like how Russian sources described what later turned out to be a barn.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dariusj18 4y agoThis is the whole reason carriers move in groups. Plus in modern naval warfare, if you can see the enemy on the horizon, they are already too close.
- MomoXenosaga 4y agoAfter WW2 European countries came to this conclusion that war between technologically advanced industrial nations no longer makes economic sense. Obviously it all predicates on politicians making somewhat rational decisions.
- troon-lover 4y ago
- Zigurd 4y agoThis is true-ish but the eleven US supercarriers and their accompanying carrier battle groups are vastly different from any other navy on the planet. Other nations do not have ships of a comparable size. Two UK carriers come closest to the way the US Navy works, but are smaller. Russia's lone, damaged carrier is 25% smaller and may travel with a roughly comparable escort, if and when it becomes operational again. Many other nations' carriers are one half to one fifth the size of a supercarrier. They exist to provide STOL/helicopter platforms.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoFrench carrier has proper catapult launch capability and seemingly so does the new chinese carrier. They sorties are smaller, but that's another matter
- ckozlowski 4y agoSome of the costs are hidden. The Neptune missile was cheap. The hidden, often unaccounted for part of that system however are the ISR (Intelligence, Surveillance, and Reconnaissance) capabilities to find the target. Anti-Ship missiles (AShMs) like the Neptune and practically any others have a limited ability to see what's around them because of the altitude they fly at and the overall small frame for radar power. This means the operator has to identify where the ship is, where it's going, and then fire their missiles to intercept. There's practically no communication afterwards (certainly not in Neptune's case) so the further away the ship it, the greater the chances it will move in that time and the missiles will fail to acquire it. (Firing closer as you can imagine brings its own risks.) So you need a system or system of systems to find your target, relay that information down to your launchers (securely, quietly, and timely!) so you can launch your relatively cheap weapon. That's where all of the investment in communications, radars, overhead platforms (drones, aircraft, satellites) comes into play. The GlobalHawk that had been flying over the Black Sea for weeks at 40,000 feet isn't cheap, but without one, one's firing missiles blind. The further out you get, the more eyes and links you need to find and track your target, and that's where it gets expensive. It also becomes less of a sure bet.