12 ms·
Guns, Privacy, and Crime
- WallyFunk 5y ago> We find that burglaries ... decreased in those with more gun permits Interesting find. Although this doesn't mean guns prevent burglaries just by mere presence. And if anything it ends in bloodshed because thieves get shot at upon a breach and it's not necessarily a safer scenario.
- theurerjohn3 5y agothe important thing is that it was: > after the database was publicized It seems they couldn't confirm if burglaries were prevented or merely moved the burglaries to low gun zipcodes, but they felt they had weak evidence for a drop in burglaries in total
- MaxLeiter 5y agoThis reminds me of one of my favorite (due to its uniqueness) local laws in the US: > In Kennesaw, Georgia, local law says that “every head of household residing in the city limits is required to maintain a firearm.” “If you're going to commit a crime in Kennesaw and you're the criminal – are you going to take a chance that that homeowner is a law-abiding citizen?” asked Kennesaw Mayor Derek Easterling https://www.cnn.com/2018/03/06/us/kennesaw-georgia-gun-ownership/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2018/03/06/us/kennesaw-georgia-gun-owner...
- 13of40 5y agoGun question not withstanding, am I the head of my household or is my wife?
- jagged-chisel 5y agoYes.
- teakettle42 5y agoI’m not sure how they define it, but it’s also moot; the law was meant to be a political statement, and doesn’t actually mandate ownership of a gun: Further exempt from the effect of this section are those heads of households who are paupers or who conscientiously oppose maintaining firearms as a result of beliefs or religious doctrine, or persons convicted of a felony.
- josephcsible 5y agoWhy does that matter? If one of you buys something, doesn't the other one of you own it too?
- 13of40 5y agoI think the question is which one of us needs to clean the damned thing.
- prepend 5y agoYou’re married, decide amongst yourselves. Who owns the weapon wouldn’t matter who has a responsibility to clean. Since you’re married, in Georgia, it’s community property and you both own it and both have the responsibility to clean. Who would you like to help you decide this issue of who cleans the weapon?
- twothamendment 5y agoJust declare it to be a joint partnership and you'll both have to have one. Problem solved!
- joey_bob 5y agoAlmost every time I've heard this mentioned it's framed as "I live in such a backward place, they have a law that requires everyone to own guns."
- teakettle42 5y ago> And if anything it ends in bloodshed because thieves get shot at upon a breach and it's not necessarily a safer scenario. It’s safer overall if it means there are fewer people willing to rob a home, whether it’s because (1) they’ve seen what happens to other people when they try, or (2) they themselves tried, and now cannot try again.
- kcplate 5y agoWhere I live many households own firearms (likely around 50%+). B&E is nearly non-existent in homes, but we get a fair share of overnight car break ins though. These are usually opportunistic where the cars are unlocked and the theft can be achieved quietly and quickly. Porch pirates as well. I definitely attribute the lack of household break ins to be a correlated to the number of gun households. Areas with a high degree of gun ownership and castle laws, there is a pretty big deterrent to the criminal to find their prey elsewhere. Just too much risk for the minimal rewards you find in most homes.
- nyolfen 5y agonot sure most people are put off by their community being unsafe for burglars
- throwaway0x7E6 5y agogive this thread half an hour or so
- marcosdumay 5y agoIf it reduces the amount of violence, it reduces the amount of violence. You don't get to take a measured reduction and conclude that it increased. You can still claim a lot of things, but not that.
- GravitasFailure 5y agoConsidering that about 266,000[1] people are injured by burglars per year, deaths included, I'm not seeing how the resident being able to shoot back is making anything "less safe" for anyone except for the burglar, which I'm pretty sure anyone getting burgled is usually ok with. Though as to why burglaries went down, I wonder if people got more alarm systems or took other deterrent countermeasures after the database was published? [1] A DOJ special report PDF https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/vdhb.pdf https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/vdhb.pdf
- eftychis 5y agoThere is the point of correct close combat training. Shooting in an enclosed proximity is vastly different. For instance you don't want the gun to blind, deafen or grabbed and used against you. That can be alleviated with the right training and choices. You need more information beyond that to assess -- e.g. are people living in remote areas or next to a police officer?
- yeetawayhn 5y ago>For instance you don't want the gun to blind, deafen or grabbed and used against you Sounds like we need to make it easier to obtain suppressors so that the victim's guns do not blind or deafen them as much.
- vorpalhex 5y ago> And if anything it ends in bloodshed because thieves get shot at upon a breach If you break into my obviously occupied house, then you aren't doing it to steal $100 of shitty electronics. Put another way, you saw that my dwelling was occupied and felt that made it more of a good target than any of the other houses around me. I don't use lethal force to protect stuff. I use lethal force to protect my family.
- philjohn 5y agoHave these zip codes been normalised for socioeconomic factors, otherwise this could very well be correlation and not causality.
- prepend 5y agoIt could still be correlation and jot causality if normalized. I think you may mean that a socioeconomic factor could be responsible for the correlation.
- Glyptodon 5y agoI'm a bit surprised, I would have guessed publishing permit holder locations would have lead to organized and targeted attempts to monitor and steal guns from the households listed. (In the same sort of way I'd expect people to smash and grab a truck with an NRA sticker to maybe find a gun in the glove box.) Edit: Would it be different if the publication didn't bin by zip code?
- nostromo 5y agoTargeting and burglarizing homes of known gun-owners seems like a great way to have a very short criminal career.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoPretty sure they break in when no one is home. Guns are second to cash in terms of desirability for robbers.
- stevenicr 5y agoPretty sure you are right, and many will knock / ring the door to ask if you want some tree service or if you are selling a car or something if someone answers. If no one answers and no dog barks..
- jasonwatkinspdx 5y agoHappens all the time. Guns are almost as easy as drugs to sell/fence. Also, folks doing cat burglar stuff obviously don't have good risk estimation going on in the first place. But on top of that, most home robberies happen during daylight work hours, when the person breaking in has already identified the house is empty. The movie/tv scenario of a dude in all black breaking in at night with a flashlight is more exceptional.
- queuebert 5y agoI don't know about homes, but I suspect there is a reason that Nashville is #1 in thefts of guns from cars.
- Simon_O_Rourke 5y agoI lived out in Berlin where basically nobody except the police and the (really) bad guys are armed. Sure, there's burglary, but much more likely was bicycle theft... I had three stolen in one calendar year. To be honest, I was more comfortable that none of my a-hole neighbors were armed, because they would have pulled a gun on you for leaving out the rubbish an hour too early or talking to loudly after 8pm.
- burner556 5y agoIf you were armed too they probably would think twice.
- andrewstuart2 5y agoI really doubt the narrative that someone who would pull out a gun over trash would spare the time to think twice.
- menacingly 5y agoso we can speculate far enough to imagine this person into existence, but no further
- prepend 5y agoThe pull a gun over trash scenario is kind of ridiculous because the gun puller would be arrested. And it just doesn’t happen. It would go like this: 1) I leave trash out 2) Neighbor yells and pulls out gun 3) I put up trash 4) I call police, neighbor is arrested and gun is taken away forever. I think there’s a perception of “crazy people owning guns” means they are just randomly doing things. Gun owners are typically pretty responsible or self-destructive. Half the US owns guns and there aren’t many crimes percentage wise. So the vast, vast majority just never do stuff with their gun. The actual argument is about the extreme outliers who murder people and commit mass shootings. There’s 20M firearm homicides [0] so that’s still super rare as a rate but the impact of each event is super impactful. [0] https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/homicide.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/homicide.htm
- nradov 5y agoHome burglaries in general have been trending down regardless of gun ownership. Burglary just isn't as profitable anymore. Common target items like consumer electronics and small appliances have gotten so cheap that they're not worth the hassle. It seems like the burglars have moved on to stealing catalytic converters from parked cars. https://ucr.fbi.gov/crime-in-the-u.s/2019/crime-in-the-u.s.-2019/topic-pages/burglary https://ucr.fbi.gov/crime-in-the-u.s/2019/crime-in-the-u.s.-...
- josephcsible 5y agoThe article says "burglaries increased in zip codes with fewer gun permits".
- verdverm 5y agoDo you mean the abstract says?
- ourmandave 5y agoWe use detailed crime and handgun carry permit data for the city of Memphis to estimate the impact of publicity about the database on burglaries. We find that burglaries increased in zip codes with fewer gun permits, and decreased in those with more gun permits, after the database was publicized. So to reduce my chances of house robbery just get a gun permit. You don't even need to own a gun and all the hazards that come with it. Or if you're looking where to live, move to a zipcode with fewer gun permits so you can worry less about a stray round coming from a neighbor's house.
- denton-scratch 5y agoYeah, you can read that statistic more than one way. For example, my reaction was that you should move to an area with lots of permits, because the robbers are clearly working over the low-permit neighbourhoods. I mean, if you're going to rob someone, it's often better if they're not armed. [Edit] I forgot about the "good and bad neighbourhood" thing that is present in some US cities. I mean, all cities everywhere have rough neighbourhoods or estates; but I was shocked when I first arrived as a guest, to be advised: "Don't cross the road at the end of the block, that's a bad neighbourhood". I wonder how permit levels correlate with the "good/bad" ranking of a neigbourhood.
- mwint 5y ago> a stray round coming from a neighbor's house Any statistics on how often this happens? Feels like a “shot by a swimming dog” scenario.
- denton-scratch 5y agoI simply assumed it must happen often enough to be quantified. So I searched for /"stray round" "neighbour's house"/. I got: About 48 results (0.32 seconds) It looks like there aren't many great matches for your search And none of those results matched the scenario under discussion. I imagine it would be a newsworthy event, so perhaps it just doesn't happen?
- rascul 5y ago
- ourmandave 5y agoGetting a gun permit in TN is actually rather restrictive compared to say, Iowa, where they approve them for blind people. https://www.tn.gov/safety/tnhp/handgun/eligibilityrequirements.html https://www.tn.gov/safety/tnhp/handgun/eligibilityrequiremen...
- User23 5y agoTN is a constitutional carry state now. Even so I recommend getting a permit because carrying a lethal weapon is an awesome responsibility and needs to be treated with respect. The classes teach much useful knowledge.
- outgunned 5y agoAlso, state reciprocity for travel.
- nostromo 5y agoThat sounds like an interesting legal case. On one hand, the state shouldn’t block one’s civil rights because one is disabled. On the other hand, blind gun-owner.
- User23 5y agoAre you implying that blind people are somehow irresponsible on account of their disability?
- nostromo 5y agoI suppose I am, yes. Not of all blind people of course, but of one that owns and fires a gun. How can a blind person shoot a gun in a responsible way?
- User23 5y ago> How can a blind person shoot a gun in a responsible way? Don’t be simple-minded. Blind people can shoot a gun responsibly the same as anyone else: be sure of your target and what’s behind it. Yes, that’s more difficult for persons that have impaired or even no usable vision, but knowing many legally blind persons I can assure you that they are responsible firearms owners.
- spicyramen_ 5y ago
- sirmike_ 5y agoAn armed society is a polite society. -- RAH
- watwut 5y agoAnd that sentence is made up. It is sentence from fictional story. It does not accurately describes how real world works. Many cultures full of gun are super rude - macho dudes proving masculinity and low level criminals are more likely to have guns and are way less polite then average person.
- ourmandave 5y agoPoliteness grounded in fear and the threat of violence. Arguments and differences escalating to shoot outs. Sounds like Utopia... in the 5th circle of hell.
- outgunned 5y ago
- res0nat0r 5y agoI'd expect if this were true, then the USA which has the highest per capita concentration of guns anywhere in the world, should also have the least amount of crime, but this isn't the case.
- stevenicr 5y agoper capita when you average that way sure - but i think it's more like the average gun owner has several and it still leaves millions of people unarmed and are easy victims. I also do not think lethal force is the primary reducer of crime for a country, I think it has more to do with social safety net available and income inequality and things like that - and guns won't help with those factors. Then of course you have to add El Salvodor, Honduras and their neighbors being a free train ride away to the mix. One thing to reduce violent crimes is not going to stop all crime anywhere, especially here.
- 5y ago
- diego_moita 5y agoIt is so weird to see Americans talking about guns... When you live in a society without guns everywhere, the notion that law-abiding citizens don't need and don't want guns is just plain obvious, like "water is wet and the wind blows". Civilized life is life with low crime so you don't need guns. They're far more trouble than solution. But talk an American talk about gun control and they go full crazy on "socialist tyranny" and "from my cold dead hands!". They just can't grasp it.
- verisimi 5y agoI'm not American and resent that individuals cannot arm themselves, if they choose to. We have no defence against the government and its agents. You may think the government is benign - I do not. I could ignore government a lot easier, and its abilities to write special laws to sanction it doing whatever it likes, if I had the ability to defend myself. So, you and I had better convince ourselves that the government really does have our interests at heart, because we have no other options.
- diego_moita 5y ago> We have no defence against the government and its agents. Oh, I am sorry to hear that. In both my native (Portugal) and adoptive (Canada) country we do have defences: votes, freedom of assembly and speech, passports,... They're far more effective than guns.
- verisimi 5y agoYou can choose red or blue and someone to represent you for 4-5 years (this is not democracy, its 'representative democracy' - the people choose nothing); you can't choose not to follow government edicts - eg shutting down schools, the economy; you do not have freedom of assembly (in Canada you can have your bank account frozen); in Canada you cannot travel by plane or train if you are not vaccinated; passports are a government id - not sure why this is a benefit to you; etc. But, as long as the governance system has you convinced its a good thing, it's all fine.