16 ms·
.01% of Bitcoin holders hold 27% of all Bitcoin
- camjohnson26 5y agoHow many of those are exchanges or dead accounts?
- zaik 5y ago* addresses
- TomK32 5y agowhich means it could be even worse.
- bufferoverflow 5y agoIt's probably not. Exchange hot and cold wallets hold insane amounts, but most of that money doesn't belong to them, it's their clients'.
- dosenbrot 5y agoOr maybe better. In the first days of bitcoin nobody cared about a lost key. A few thousand bitcoin on an account nobody has access to? These bitcoin shouldn’t count, but it’s hard to count them. Maybe declare all bitcoins that didn’t move since eight years as lost?
- randomhodler84 5y agoAnd this is a stupid metric too. I have utxos that old that will be unspent for another 5y+ I don’t care about Bcash and other worthless forks and I could tell it was an attack to unmask old utxos.
- drexlspivey 5y agoCoinbase cold storage holds billions of dollars for millions of people. Do you understand how bad this metric is now?
- ShamelessC 5y agohttps://fortune.com/2022/05/11/coinbase-bankruptcy-crypto-assets-safe-private-key-earnings-stock/ https://fortune.com/2022/05/11/coinbase-bankruptcy-crypto-as...
- joshcryer 5y agoNot your keys, not your coins.
- jazzyjackson 5y agoIs there a benefit to consolidating all those coins into bulk wallets? Why not have an address associated with each user?
- drexlspivey 5y agoYes consolidating outputs significantly reduces transaction fees
- manquer 5y agoThe study excluded all the exchange wallets [1], that makes the metric if anything more conservative than it is actually. [1] https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w29396/w29396.pdf https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w29396/w293...
- tshaddox 5y agoOr less worse.
- adnzzzzZ 5y agoThis analysis I saw says something else? https://twitter.com/woonomic/status/1512433154875101198 https://twitter.com/woonomic/status/1512433154875101198 Which one is right? I haven't looked into it carefully.
- manquer 5y agoHere is the paper https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w29396/w29396.pdf https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w29396/w293...
- bko 5y agoDoesn't this include large cold storage wallets of exchanges and mining pools? I don't know what the "appropriate" number is
- nightski 5y agoExcept wealth isn't power with Bitcoin. That's the entire point of PoW. PoS is a little different.
- Closi 5y agoOf course with bitcoin wealth is power - you can use your bitcoin to influence people to do what you want, or to give you access to goods and services that people with less bitcoin / wealth can't access.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- alphabettsy 5y agoSomeone buying or selling 5% of all Bitcoin wouldn’t have any impact on its exchange value?
- nightski 5y agoOf course it would, even if a little. It looks like that is typically less than the daily traded volume. But if you added another 5% on top of it surely it would affect prices. But my point is the ability to affect the price a bit doesn't equal power in terms of control over Bitcoin itself.
- audleman 5y agoIf they made a bad investment and lost that 5% they couldn't ask their friends in the Bitcoin corporation for a bailout. No politician could write a few lines of code and grant them a one-time issuance of new coins. No matter what percentage of coins one person, corporation, or government holds they have gained zero control over the network. Equality of rules, not equality of wealth.
- iownzerobtc 5y agoIn PoW you can purchase miners. In PoS you can purchase validators. But PoS is easier than PoW to defend against a 51% attack as the offending validator set can be targeted.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- iownzerobtc 5y agoSeveral issues with using this metric to measure wealth inequality for crypto currencies, especially those with smart contracts like Ethereum. - A single address might be a contract like WETH, which can hold tens of billions of dollars worth of tokens despite all users in the network having access to it. Similar with centralized exchanges holding many tokens. Addresses are not users. - This metric often confuses “inequality of interest” with “inequality of wealth.” A user holding $10,000 of ETH and another user holding $100 of ETH may be in similar fiat-wealth brackets, but one is more interested & invested in crypto than the other. - It is very easy to spin up a new wallet as it’s effectively just a random unique number. A single user might have 10-20 wallets with almost-zero tokens leftover, and all of their assets concentrated on one or two accounts, which further skews this stat. - A number of tokens in the network are inaccessible due to being locked in a contract or sent to a burn address. The standard ETH burn address has $250M worth of tokens. There is a lot of crypto disparity and inequality but this stat at face value is fairly meaningless.
- salawat 5y ago>Addresses are not users. Mmmmhmmmm. Welcome to the User-Agent problem. Unfortunately, Society will take your idea and massage it until the rest of society "safely" (to their thinking) can make that assumption.
- jwilber 5y agoNone of these make this stay meaningless at face value. Almost all of your points apply to non-crypto as well, but nobody is denying wealth inequality there.
- plsbenice34 5y agoAn invalid statistical argument that appears to support the truth is still invalid. Just like a proof for a mathematical theorem can be invalid even if the statement turns out to be provably true by other means.
- hihihihi1234 5y agoNobody is "denying wealth inequality" here either, the point is just that the headline statistic may be a bad way to measure wealth inequality in crypto.
- SemanticStrengh 5y agohow does this compare to dollar? > That’s 100x the wealth concentration of the regular economy sauce?
- oblak 5y agoFor starters, what "regular economy"? The global one? The one on the books, or the real thing?
- donkarma 5y agobut that doesn't matter to Bitcoin?
- lvl102 5y agoAssets more concentrated than even diamond mines but it’s going to democratize finance for humanity. Notice concepts such as PoS would make it even more concentrated.
- dosenbrot 5y agoIf you have enough bitcoin you could also buy and run many bitcoin miner, it’s PoS with extra steps.
- arcticbull 5y agoYep, folks dont realize that proof of work and proof of stake converge at the limit. The only difference is quantity of environmental externalities.
- lvl102 5y agoWhy would it converge when we are already starting with concentration? PoS would only work if we all started with nothing from t=0 which NO ONE in the crypto space would concede to because they don’t want to give up their wealth. So in the end, you end up with something even worse than current state of capitalism.
- arcticbull 5y agoYeah, I agree with that assessment. I'm just saying that 'staking' in proof of stake isn't materially different than taking your Bitcoin and purchasing a share of a company that mines Bitcoin. [edit] you can always un-stake by selling your share.
- atweiden 5y agoStaking is similar to buying lottery tickets at the store, except you need never leave your home or pay any money for the tickets. It’s all about passive income generation. Mining is a business, with real costs and logistics to fret about. People should really stop doing the mental gymnastics to make push-button passive income generation seem extraordinarily challenging and, even more egregious, extremely equitable (“it’s _at least_ as fair as Bitcoin”).
- deeviant 5y agoMmmhmm, I just can't wait until proof of stake. That's going to fix everything. /s
- tasubotadas 5y agoDid somebody just discover the power law?
- 323 5y agoVery misleading. The fact that Binance or Coinbase holds 10% of bitcoin doesn't mean that it owns 10% of bitcoin. You can say something similar about any fiat currency, because almost all USD for example lives on the balance sheet of the big banks - JPM, Chase, BoA, ...
- gitfan86 5y agoAt one point crypto was about decentralization, and having advantages over the current banking system. But to your point it seems like it is no longer for most people, for most people crypto is about the price going up, regardless of centralization or usefulness.
- 323 5y agoThe internet is decentralized. At the same time, 99% of the internet traffic passes through 15 or so tier 1 networks. Being decentralized doesn't mean that there are not huge entities which control most of the system.
- gitfan86 5y agoBut the internet was never promoted as having value due to a large number of tier 1 networks. Bitcoin was created specifically as a way to counteract centralize control of money. The fact that many people store their crypto in central exchanges implies that they don't actually care about the advantage of decentralized money.
- 323 5y agoIt doesn't matter what the internet was promoted for. Do you believe it's decentralization has value or not? Despite the fact that the vast majority of people use it just for Facebook and Instagram.
- gitfan86 5y agoThe internet is valuable even though most of the traffic goes to a few sites. But that has nothing to do with decentralization. No one ever promoted the internet as useful because no site would ever be super popular. The value Bitcoin provides is that it allows you to bypass government controls and other monopolies on transferring money. If you put that Bitcoin on an exchange you no longer have that ability to bypass government controls because Coinbase will lock your account if the government tells them to do so.
- togaen 5y agoKinda like a pyramid scheme.
- TekMol 5y ago"Holders" is defined how? I have the feeling by address? If you add assets under management for all banks in the USA, you will probably get to an even more extreme distribution. Bank of America alone has $1.55 trillion under management.
- secondcoming 5y agoIt's time for me to unveil my Bitcoin0x11, where instead of hashes having to have a certain amount of leading zeros, it needs ones.
- nayuki 5y agoIt would be 0xFF.
- thisisfalse 5y agoThat's not how it works.
- rhacker 5y agoI'm surprised it's not 99% considering I figured most of it is in exchanges or coinbase.
- betwixthewires 5y agoI'd like to see the methodology. I guarantee you they can't actually determine the claim. Beyond that, bitcoin wasn't designed to "decentralize wealth and power", it is a disingenuous claim made by an agenda poster. Bitcoin was created to take a step towards a future where economic power is not synonymous with political power. The natural distribution of wealth is not at issue, so long as it's just that: natural.
- FabHK 5y ago> I'd like to see the methodology. https://www.nber.org/papers/w29396 https://www.nber.org/papers/w29396
- betwixthewires 5y agoIs that the research cited in the tweet?
- FabHK 5y agoThe video in the tweet is based (at least partially) on a WSJ article that is based on that paper.
- abrichr 5y agoInteresting. Can you please clarify what is meant by "natural" in this context?
- betwixthewires 5y agoFrom a birds eye view, a Pareto distribution. From the ground, so long as nobody with political power influences the distribution of wealth and it flows with the market it is a natural distribution.
- abrichr 5y agoIf I understand correctly, this means that a natural distribution of wealth should have exactly zero correlation with distribution of political power, is that right?
- slickrick216 5y agoSo much effort put into FUDing Bitcoin. Just don’t buy it.
- randomhodler84 5y agoOr do, and ignore the same people that said it was stupid for the last decade and will probably say the same for the next. Meanwhile, those that understand the internet know that protocols are extremely long lived and might even outlast them.
- slickrick216 5y agoDon’t tell the rest of them that. More for the rest of us.
- darawk 5y agoThe only way you could possibly measure this is just to look at the distribution of coins among wallets. This is obviously going to count crypto exchanges as single entities, which is absurd. It'd be like counting JPMorgan as a single person when computing wealth inequality in the US. Analyses like these are a total joke.
- id 5y agoIn the world of crypto, where people keep repeating the "not your keys, not your coins" mantra, crypto exchanges are very much the owners of all the coins they hold. But I agree, it's absurd.
- netsharc 5y agoIronically their customers trust them because just like other businesses around the world, the customers rely on the jurisdictions of where the exchanges are incorporated to uphold the law and make sure the exchanges don't rob them. The same jurisdictions many crypto-diehards think need to disappear... Would you trust an exchange name "Uncle Vlad's Russki Crypto Exchange"? Probably not, right? Because if they take your money, and you call the Russian version of the FBI, they'll just laugh at you. So you think your money is safer in a crypto exchange where the founders would be arrested if they blatantly stole your money...
- shuntress 5y agoThis is the main thing that has always seemed odd to my about much of enthusiasm for crypto. People seem to conflate "it works like physical cash but it's electronic" with "no banks no laws no regulation" when its very obvious that banks and governance are still necessary.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bogota 5y agoNot to mention how to determine what coins are lost forever. I know of several addresses that are mine but the keys are unfortunately lost forever. And additionally you might have coins that haven’t moved in 8 years that is considered lost but i just haven’t had a reason to move them. Im sure someone could come up with a decent methodology for figuring this out but this isn’t it.
- ideamotor 5y agoComparing this to other assets misses the point. Dollars have (imperfect) democratic governance. Whereas the entire ideology of crypto is to throw away what little feedback loop we do have.
- OsintOtter69 5y agoOccupy the blockchain
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jsiaajdsdaa 5y ago
- vmception 5y agoPeople that already have money can buy a bunch of bitcoin Along with early miners How is that controversial? There is zero mechanism to change that reality and not an issue bitcoin was claiming to solve. Whichever frothing at the mouth enthusiast told you otherwise can just be ignored. This is only news because people never made their own analysis after hearing someone else be excited for the wrong reasons.
- throwoutway 5y agoBecause shills say that it will democratize finance better than banks/USD/WTO/ and make a more equitable future. Which of course is bogus, and data like this is needed to contradict the lies
- vmception 5y agoI think it already has, I could never get a flash loan elsewhere, or trade in some ways that I like. The closest I could get was access to some favorable margin systems. I don't think that has anything to do with bitcoin or any cryptocurrency’s distribution. Its a boon, to me, that it functions like any other asset class, no reason to hold it up to fictional higher standards to discredit it.
- majormajor 5y agoMy main takeaway from concentration is that it indicates potential price volatility if a whale makes a move.
- vmception 5y agoWe can judge market depth in fairly real time though so we know what size of order can and does move
- MomoXenosaga 5y agoThe funny thing is that none of those whales can cash out without tanking the price.
- keybored 5y agoWho’s the Bernie Sanders of Bitcoin?
- f6v 5y agoMethodology aside, would it be surprising if most of Bitcoin belonged to 1%? How would this asset be fundamentally different from other assets?
- curiousgeorgio 5y agoThank goodness Bitcoin wealth isn't distributed evenly among everyone who holds it. Show me a system where that's true (or even close to true), and I'll show you a system controlled by tyrants. Wealth equality != fairness. Effort, sacrifice, and contribution to the well-being of society is not – and never will be – equal for everyone, so rewarding everyone equally would be inherently unfair.
- tonguez 5y ago“Thank goodness Bitcoin wealth isn't distributed evenly among everyone who holds it. Show me a system where that's true (or even close to true), and I'll show you a system controlled by tyrants.” yeah that makes a lot of sense
- Barrera 5y agoThat statement is not the focus of the video, which is an overview of the history of Bitcoin. Also, these estimates of wealth distribution all suffer from the same flaw: addresses do not correspond to users. A single address might lock the funds of thousands of people. For example, this is how exchanges operate. A single user can control thousands of addresses or more. It's extremely difficult to nail down how addresses relate to users. And that's by design.
- Terry_Roll 5y agoSaw this earlier https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u1_gAgDBnOo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u1_gAgDBnOo and my immediate thought was the crypto tumblers are not working which then made me wonder if this is an in-plain-sight money laundering exercise using the power of celebrity!?! Elon Musk is definitely in market moving territory and sailing close to the window for things like buying Twitter and then pulling out, I wonder how many puts and shorts existed in dark pools? LOL
- iownzerobtc 5y agoIt is a scam, you send tokens and they send you nothing back in return.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoSounds like our traditional economy then.
- benjaminwootton 5y ago.01% of USD holders probably own 27% of USD
- birthday 5y agoWait, so Bitcoin isn't being handed out equally to every person on earth? I thought the rule is we each will be given same amount? /s.
- tromp 5y agoThe best Bitcoin could hope to achieve is mirror the wealth inequality in fiat. But the nature of the emission, with half of all supply emitted in the first 4 years, has exacerbated the inequality. One cannot imagine one person holding several percent of all fiat.
- npc12345 5y agoThis is fine. The point of Bitcoin is "they" cannot print more of it, they have to earn it fair and square.
- majormajor 5y ago"They" (for even wider values of "they") can just make a new token instead of printing more of BTC. If people accept that that second one has value, that's gonna inflate prices since it's more money sloshing around.
- kayamon 4y agoNot if it's a PoW crypto. You can't mine Bitcoin and Ethereum at the same time. You can't use electricity for two tasks at once. Conservation of energy --> conservation of money.
- Smithalicious 5y agoDoes this really matter? Bitcoin is freely available on the market, there's is nothing stopping someone with enough money from acquiring an arbitrary share of the existing bitcoins.
- missedthecue 5y agoNo it doesn't really matter. Inequality by itself does not make anyone else worse off.
- niemal_dev 5y agoWealth distribution, with the bigger part owned by an extremely small percentile is like the history of human kind. We should take into account properties and any kind of ownership, such as national territory as well. Humans like to own as much as they can -- this is why wars happen. Regarding to bitcoin as a currency, as I read in some comment here: 1) You can't demand your money from your bank at any time given. This gives the banks the leverage to maintain and/or invest your money however they seem possible, rendering them a complete "Ponzi" machine (lending all the time in order to invest and make more money while paying out whatever you want to withdraw within calculated timelines). 2) Bitcoin can't print money as it is designed to have a fixed number of distribution. You can't inflate it. You have the capability to become your own autonomous, independent bank. With a fiat such as USD, job wages do not increase in correlation to the USD volume. This promotes poverty, inequality and is completely unethical -- regardless if that effect is intended or not. There must be a public mathematically proven metric that constitutes as a stable currency, this is what Bitcoin is trying to solve. A so-called mathematical gold. 3) Different problems arise, such as: (a) incapability for consistent day-to-day payments due to processing inefficiency, (b) early birds get the bag, (c) global warming (hi tesla).
- anothernewdude 5y agoThis actually wonderful news. It means bitcoin is close to the point where it can easily be declared worthless since as a "currency" that isn't backed by anything there's no inherent value. Once a few players have the majority of the coin, there's no reason to play with them.
- alliao 5y agofor all we know, 99% could be in one guys hand.
- hitovst 5y agoPeople think there are 21M Bitcoin, but they have no idea how many millions have been lost forever already, and how many will continue to be lost going forward. I wonder how many of those 27% are lost.
- karmakaze 5y agoEven if this were accurate, is it meaningful? Can we infer how close we are to X% of holders having 50._% and what is X% is as an absolute number?
- tamrix 5y agoThere's better break downs videos on YouTube which go into far more detail including over time. The top 9/10 are exchanges so it's not too surprisingly.
- butterisgood 5y agoCool. Let them sink with it
- senectus1 5y agoThis has long been one of the top 5 issues with bitcoin and cryptocurrencies as a whole. the gene pool is too shallow. It makes them too brittle and way too susceptible to co-ordinated abuse.
- SkipperCat 5y agoI'm amazed anyone is actually surprised by this factoid. Wealth has always wound up concentrated into a small minority of the populous. Why would it be any different with Bitcoin? Bitcoin did not start out being distributed to "the masses" in an even manner. It was mostly picked up by folks in the tech world who typically have excess wealth to engage in speculation. Then when it went big, you had the investor class (ie: Winklevoss types) jump into the fray. Bitcoin, stocks, SPACs, 2nd homes... It's all the same. Stuff owned by rich people.
- daniel-cussen 4y agoThat's the exact right amount they idealists should own. Exactly .01% owning 27%. But tell me, what is the value for which x% own (100-x)%? That is the figure of merit. It actually has mathematical meaning. For instance, if you take a single example at exactly the x percentile, that particular person gets a fair share. For instance, if there's 100 people and it's 80-20, 20% of the people get 80% of the wealth, then the person at exactly the 80th percentile gets 1% of the total. For him specifically, it might as well be shared equally. Tell me where that x percent gets 100-x percent equilibrium is!
- timcavel 4y ago
- h43z 4y ago"Crypto, which was supposed to decentralize wealth and power, has just made it worse." Crypto was never about an equitable distribution of wealth. And Bitcoin uses Proof of Work so wealth does not equal to power. You can have as many bitcoin as you want you still can't issue new ones or change the consensus algorithm.
- jmartin2683 4y agoSeems kinda centralized?