10 ms·
Before Ships Used GPS, There Was the Fresnel Lens
- wbl 4y agoThe article is incorrect about the obsolescence of lighthouses. GPS is an adjunct to navaids and charting, particularly when near shore. Some small boats won't have a chart plotter. You don't want electrical problem to become a navigational issue also.
- gabereiser 4y agoExactly. Fancy electronics are secondary to the Mark I Eyeball. Lighthouses are still incredibly useful in low visibility situations such as heavy fog.
- sandworm101 4y agoSo which do you go with when they disagree? If your eyeball sees a landmark that you believe puts you at point X, but the GPS says you are at point Y, which do you believe? For me, absent any other facts, I default to trusting the instrument over the human. I think the risk that the is human misidentifying a landmark is greater than the risk that a ship's GPS is malfunctioning. Again, absent any knowledge of hacking/spoofing in the area.
- gabereiser 4y agoIf it’s a matter of a landmark, I trust GPS. If it’s a matter of where the rocks and shoals are, I trust a human. From the cockpit you can only see what’s above the waterline. Currents and seas can shift sand bars and reefs. For that you need a person on the bow.
- can16358p 4y agoBut doesn't virtually anyone have a smartphone now? A phone + powerbank should suffice. And most likely there would be additional people on board in case someone's phone stops working (e.g. dropped into the sea). And if I were to navigate in a foggy/stormy day by myself, I'd at least carry an additional phone. And if there was so much fog that would affect GPS signals, how can lighthouse lights be seen anyway? I'm not a sailor or anything, just trying to understand why this can't be done and why lighthouses are still needed.
- throwaway0a5e 4y agoThere are a lot of sea states and weather conditions in which it's inappropriate and somewhat futile to whip out a smart phone on anything that doesn't have a fully enclosed bridge. Marker buoys are your friend in those situations.
- TameAntelope 4y agoAnd what signal to download the updated weather data?
- can16358p 4y agoYour comment is completely irrelevant to my comment as I'm not commenting anything related to getting weather data.
- TameAntelope 4y agoThen your comment is incomplete! You would need accurate weather data to use your cell phone successfully to navigate in the night time during weather where a lighthouse is of most importance.
- _moof 4y agoFog doesn't affect GPS. GPS is just not 100% reliable (ask me how I know) or necessarily even the best navaid for every situation. Even aircraft go visual for the last few hundred feet. (Or if they're doing autoland, it's with a purpose-built ground-based system, not GPS.) Speaking more generally it's just very risky to put all your eggs into one basket when it comes to navigation. It's so difficult to impress upon the new generation of navigators that they are guaranteed to be completely screwed at least once in their lives if they don't learn something other than GPS.
- mortenlarsen 4y ago> GPS is just not 100% reliable (ask me how I know) How to you know?
- sccxy 4y agolighthouse != all kind of physical navigation aids Lightvessels, classical big lighthouses are obsolescence. There are a lot of other physical navigation aids which are improved. Old unlit marks are replaced with lit and AIS capable ones. New safe waterways and danger areas are marked every year. Nobody said these are obsolete.
- Ekaros 4y agoLighted buoys and sector lights are still common and useful aids for navigation, both in dark and light. And you really don't some times go outside those specially with deeper drafts.
- sandworm101 4y ago>> classical big lighthouses are obsolescence. Nope. To see something in daylight it needs to be big. That big white pole is visible for miles and identifies the location in exactly the same way as the light does at night. Towers guided ships long before anyone started putting lights on them.
- sccxy 4y agoNope. For that there are daymarks. [1] Clover Island Light (2010) is the first lighthouse to be built in the United States since 1962. [2] If they are not obsolescence why they have built only one lighthouse in last 50 years in USA? [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daymark https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daymark [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clover_Island_Light https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clover_Island_Light
- traceroute66 4y ago> GPS is an adjunct to navaids and charting. Indeed. For all the millennial kids on here, there's a famous American Airlines lecture called "Children of the Magenta Line", it's doing the rounds on YouTube[1]. Boaters should adopt the same mentality. [1]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WITLR_qSPXk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WITLR_qSPXk
- sandworm101 4y ago>> GPS is an adjunct to navaids and charting Maybe 15 years ago. Today, GPS is the primary and charting comes slower/later to confirm positions. GPS isn't done intermittently. It is just on 24/7. Then occasionally (on the order of minutes to hours) a ship's position is confirmed by other means if possible. Near land the crew will sight landmarks to confirm the GPS track is accurate. But go onboard a ship in bad weather at night. You won't see the captain out there with a sextant trying to track stars. The GPS is basically it until there is good reason to second guess or confirm its accuracy. If the GPS fails, the ship's insurer might just tell the ship to hold position until it gets fixed. Ships are not planes. They can actually stay away from land/danger for days/weeks while repairs happen.
- ggm 4y agoYea. So maybe the french say Fray-nel but I have yet to meet an anglo who didn't say Fres-nell
- joe-collins 4y agoI would not have guessed the name was French.
- dotancohen 4y agoFrench words should be written with an asterisk to designate that no matter how they're spelled, you have no idea how to pronounce it. I'm exaggerating of course, but I say that as someone reasonably fluent in four languages with four different alphabets.
- orwin 4y agoI think this is ironic writing this in English. In Portuguese, Deutsch or Italian, even Spanish why not, but in a language with like 10 diphthong and 5 triphthong, 15 ways to pronounce the letter 'a', that even native speaker can't really pronounce (at least Scotts and Irish, but I wouldn't be surprised if it's the same for blue collar English workers) should not be used to make fun of another idiotic language. At least we have the excuse that a conservative, non elected body is keeping our language difficult and dumb for conservative reasons.
- ggm 4y agoFew native English speakers learn grammar formally these days. Partner is a retired proofreader and these last 20 years has killed her, watching teachers and lecturers fail to understand their mother tongue. Also, the Spanish equivalent of academie francais is at least talking about ending gender for inanimate objects I believe. In english, lack of a definitional body makes this very hard (actor/actress chairman &c, not having gendered inanimate objects makes it hard to find a direct equivalent)
- dotancohen 4y ago
- londons_explore 4y agoFresnels final design used mercury (as in the liquid metal) to float the lenses on and allow them to move easily, which allowed the lenses to turn with just clockwork and make the light appear to be flashing from afar. Mercury had to be used because the lenses were very heavy, so the way to support them was to float them on a heavy liquid. Wheels or bearings would have been too much friction for clockwork. Mercury vapour is poisonous, especially over time, which is why lighthouse keepers were said to go crazy. At the time people thought it was from being isolated for long periods, but it was probably the mercury in the Fresnel lens support that made them crazy.
- winrid 4y agoThe wheels and various types of bearings were used for some time right? They switched to floating the whole assembly on mercury because it was more reliable with less maintenance (and simpler drive mechanism).
- null_object 4y agoLarge format film cameras use Fresnel lenses to overcome the problem of darkened corners when viewing the ground-glass image - the frosted glass on which the inverted image is focussed - redirecting the light rays that enter the lens around the edges and which would otherwise exit the back of the camera at the same angle, making the image appear increasingly dim towards the edges when the photographer looks directly at the back when focussing. The Fresnel re-orients these light rays so they are parallel to each other, pointing towards the photographer's eye [0] [0] Some example images here: https://www.onlandscape.co.uk/2017/08/large-format-camera-accessories/ https://www.onlandscape.co.uk/2017/08/large-format-camera-ac...
- aksss 4y agoBefore ships used GPS, there was LORAN. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/LORAN https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/LORAN
- xattt 4y agoMy introduction to LORAN was in high school discussing hyperbolic functions.
- dmix 4y agoThis is the best explanation of the innovation of Fresnel lenses I've come across: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VyQAg4j-7K4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VyQAg4j-7K4
- kuu 4y agoIt's a pity that there isn't an schema explaining the working of the lens...
- Loic 4y agoHere you have: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fresnel_lens https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fresnel_lens
- MasterYoda 4y agoFun facts!? The Swedish inventor Gustaf Dalén (1869-1937) invented many revolutionary systems for beacon lightning for lighthouses [1]. In Sweden those lighthouses was called "AGA-fyr" (AGA-lighthouse) after his company AGA and abroad Dalén-lights. Some of the inventions was the: - "Dalén Flasher" that made the beacon flash and that conserved 90% of the acetylene gas, and the timing between flashes also made so observers could differentiate between beacons. - "Dalén Mixer" that gave lighthouses greater luminosity where acetylene and oxygen was mixed in specific proportions. - "Sun valve" made so the lighthouse only was on during the night to preserve gas. It was a black body rod that was connected to a membrane and tree shiny rods. So when the sun shined, the black expanded and turned off the gas. When the Blockhusudden beacon in Stockholm, the first sun valve beacon in the world, was electrified in 1980, it was discovered that the sun valve had never needed to be repaired! For this, he also got the Nobel Prize in Physics 1912 “for his invention of automatic regulators for use in conjunction with gas accumulators for illuminating lighthouses and buoys.” [1] https://www.tekniskamuseet.se/en/learn-more/swedish-inventors/gustaf-dalen/ https://www.tekniskamuseet.se/en/learn-more/swedish-inventor...
- Laforet 4y ago>his company AGA and abroad Dalén-lights... TIL the AGA cooker was also invented in Sweden. Somehow I have always assumed that it is a British peculiarity.
- daneel_w 4y agoTo anyone who doesn't know what a lighthouse is used for, comparing them with a GPS wrongly alludes that they are used to directly convey the ship's position. This isn't true, though you can sometimes deduce your position if there are enough lighthouses on your horizon. The main function of a lighthouse is to let the crew know that the vessel is inside a safe fairway when calling port or for example when navigating an archipelago or a coastline. It's been over a decade since I last did any sailing, but I believe it's still mandatory to verify safe bearing with the lighthouse (when present).
- sandworm101 4y ago>> With the invention of modern navigational tools, the lighthouse has become largely obsolete for maritime safety. But the lens invented for it lives on in side mirrors used on trucks, solar panels, and photographic lighting equipment No. Just no. GPS has serious limitations. Lights of various sizes, lighthouses being the biggest, are still essential. A light not only provides a bearing to a known/fixed point but also gives you weather and visibility information. And since they do not rely on any on-ship equipment, they keep working during onboard power failures. Go tell a pilot that runway lights are irrelevant now that they can follow GPS down to a runway at night.