12 ms·

Narcissism is rampant, so how do we address it?

108 points by binnacle 4y ago

jjtheblunt 4y ago
being addressed is what narcissism wants. oh the irony
- cirrus3 4y ago
  OP sounds like a classic narcissist
eismcc 4y ago
Only you can stop narcissism.
- brentirwin 4y ago
  Only I can stop narcissism.
tonguez 4y ago
what’s rampant is billionaires ”amplifying” vapid narcissism because they want a disempowered population with no good role models or values other than the worship of money, and the path to money is being a cog in the western MCI/global supply chain/the great satan. people don’t want to build the surveillance state for google if it means they are going to be shamed and looked at as creeps. but if you give them enough money, they can film the crispest videos with their most expensive phones of their most expensive houses, making them de-facto cool, because everyone else is poor/a loser.
ButterWashed 4y ago
"Unfortunately, there is no cure for narcissism" I can't imagine this will ever change. How do you encourage someone who seeks the admiration of others at all costs to simply stop? Without a shred of evidence, I'm sure the increased use of social media is at least partially to blame.
- Melatonic 4y ago
  On the other hand labelling these people in some completely "other" group probably is not helpful either - what about those who are on the border? What about those who might display what appears to be very narcissistic qualities but only in very specific niches?
  - robonerd 4y ago
    > On the other hand labelling these people in some completely "other" group probably is not helpful either I'm inclined to agree. Recognizing and accounting for harmful traits in others is important, but some of the rhetoric in this discussion borders dangerously close to dehumanization.
- apostacy 4y ago
  I am really confused about this. It does not make sense to me. Do you mean that it is difficult to cure? Because that is not the same thing as incurable. If people can be socialized into it, why can't they be socialized out of it? 15% of the population is incurably emotionally broken? And most of them were made, not born, because they spent too much time on Instagram, and now they are part of the 15% of the population that is cursed to a life of narcissism, no matter how much effort is put into curing them? Isn't it possible that you can just mature and become less solipsistic? Aren't these behaviors situational? What if you were put in an environment where someone got negative feedback for narcissistic behavior? There must be something I am missing, because those claims do not seem realistic.
  - zozbot234 4y ago
    Of course it's possible to mature, but only if people want to. People who actively want to become less self-centered are not narcissists, by definition.
    - apostacy 4y ago
      So it is possible to cure narcissism, if only the narcissist wants to be cured? That is a very far cry from being described as 'incurable', which I have seen used a lot. Again, I am not saying that narcissism doesn't exist, but the language that is being used to describe it is unhelpful. A lot of people go through phases in their teens or 20s that could be described as narcissistic, and then they develop out of it.
daenz 4y ago
>A week later, I received a few ambiguous and regretful messages from her, which escalated to a phone call in which she sought guidance on her next date The author needs to spend time identifying how people use tactics to assert and obtain power. Even if you don't want to use those tactics yourself, which is fine, your whole life will be better served by knowing how to deflect tactics others use to submit you (lowering your perceived value to others). For some people, all they have is power games. They can't rely on abilities or genuine personality traits, so they have to rely on manipulating perceptions of themselves and others. Other people have the privilege of not needing to do that, so they never develop those manipulation instincts through practice. They get taken advantage of because they don't even see the games being played. Imo, the sweet spot is not needing to manipulate others in order to have your intended effect on the world, but being able to do so to when it's required.
- bGl2YW5j 4y ago
  Both this article and your comment sum-up what I have really been struggling with lately at work. I’ve never experienced such a narcissistic person and have had a hard time not only dealing with their behaviour, but identifying it for what it is in the first place. Thanks for the insight.
  - prometheus76 4y ago
    Some tips from someone who has dealt with a few classic narcissists: don't argue with them. They do not reason the way you do. One-word answers are best. Pretend you are a very dull, boring person with no opinions when you are talking to them. Never raise your voice or get angry. They will try to use the silent treatment on you: ignore it. But it works very well on them too. They will never, in a million years, apologize. But if they apologize, they are only trying to manipulate you further because their fear of abandonment has been triggered by your body language and tone. Always remember they lie constantly. They don't know what the truth is anymore. These are strategies and perspectives I've learned from having narcissistic family members. I hope it helps. The best thing you can do is just not deal with them at all, but sometimes it's unavoidable.
hitovst 4y ago
End the dysgenic forced redistribution of wealth, and people will be forced to adapt to reality. If we continue to tolerate forced redistribution of wealth, it only goes one way, and it's the opposite of "addressing it".
- farzatv 4y ago
drewcoo 4y ago
Dig more lacunae? The impulse to "help" other people is noble. Except for those quotes around "help." This isn't about helping others so much as dealing with them. And that's toxic in itself. Narcissus liked to stare into his lacuna. So harm reduction might be digging more lacunae. With enough reflective surfaces, Narcissus might have a "normal" life. I've experienced environments where everyone constantly gets praise for the least little aspect of existing.
givemeethekeys 4y ago
It's simple but not easy. Reward people who take orders more than those that give them.
29athrowaway 4y ago
If narcissism (and psychopathy) is prevailing is because it is favored by society. - Marketing and advertising - Social media and entertainment industry - Employers - Dating scene Everyone nowadays seems to love charismatic selfish people that do not have time for empathy. Noone wants to be the "loser" that contributes to society, but rather the jerk that takes everything from others. We glorify parasitic people like Bezos and the Waltons that can exist only because they have the majority of their workforce on welfare benefits.
- brewdad 4y ago
  I don't mind being the "loser" that contributes to society. I hate feeling like the "sucker" that gets left holding the bag when the selfish jerks continue to take.
- Melatonic 4y ago
  I think what you are describing is distinctly more American than anything else - in many countries it would probably not be seen as a huge positive to be super gregarious in a business setting for example.
- rendang 4y ago
  The Waltons are glorified? I barely hear much about them at all.
  - 29athrowaway 4y ago
    Every time you shop at Walmart.
greatpostman 4y ago
Generally there’s huge rewards for being a narcissist. Refusing to ever admit your wrong and instead gaslighting people around you works really well. People figure out the pattern, just shuffle them out of your life and add new people. I noticed that a few friends I grew up with developed this approach when they found it worked extremely well with women.
- BlargMcLarg 4y ago
  It works well as long as there is an abundance of people willing to stick around, which is when these people will develop this mindset. With a bit of luck they'll grow out of it once the environment no longer makes it beneficial, but many are too far gone by then. It's part of why PUA circles (to stick with the dating example in the article) hammer "abundance mentality" so much. You don't have to deal with a person having a problem with you when, as you say, you can shuffle them out for someone else.
- blacksignal 4y ago
  Unfortunately this means there's no incentive for them to change. Becoming a better person and having healthier relationships takes a lot of effort, and to them, they are giving up power (and becoming vulnerable) -- so why bother? And empathy for others will never be a motivator, here.
  - greatpostman 4y ago
    Yeah I mean as a general human strategy, narcissism works. Not everyone is equipped for it though
- fudged71 4y ago
  The show "Inventing Anna" is a perfect example of this. Charismatic narcissist gaslights everyone around her and anyone who doesn't plan along gets replaced with someone who will.
- heavyset_go 4y ago
  Depends on how deep they are into it. Some people with such traits can't keep down a job or even familial relationships without their ego getting in the way.
kadenwolff 4y ago
You cannot solve your narcissism through introspection. Introspection will only lead you to thinking you've found the answer, and stopping there so you don't have to change. "I've figured it out, I know why I'm a narcissist," and then stopping there. People can't tell you how to stop being a narcissist. If someone tells you exactly what to do, you'll do that thing, and then stop. "I'm doing that thing now, so I'm not a narcissist!" Your mind will simulate the most awful pain imaginable just to protect against changing your behaviour. You think your suffering is making you a good person, that by looking at the painful parts of your mind you are no longer a narcissist, but you're at the same place as you were before. You haven't changed your behaviour at all.
- gtirloni 4y ago
  I didnt get what you're trying to say. What's one to do then?
  - careersuicide 4y ago
    > What's one to do then? GP gives a hint: > You haven't changed your behaviour at all. TLP[1] said it best: > There you go again, thinking about yourself. Your impulse wasn't to say, "am I doing this to my kids?" or "how will I act differently?" It was to wonder about your own nature. 1: https://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2012/10/the_story_of_narcissus.html https://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2012/10/the_story_of_narciss...
    - yes_i_can 4y ago
      Worthy of note, TLP did often harp on the fact that his view of 'narcissism' as a cultural phenomenon (I think he called it a "generational pathology") is NOT the same as the DSM definition. People are fooled into thinking every narcissist is the person with a self-inflated ego (I inferred the same from the OP, "Some of them are good enough to fool Jersey Shore candidates, while others can reach high executive positions and, in some cases, potentially win a presidential election..."). But TLP's definition was closer to someone who is completely focused on controlling others' perception of them. This could include a person who projects himself as a meek victim, but hyper-focused on relaying that image to others. Although, this does fit quite well too: "I don't want to be with someone who doesn't care to drink tap water." Anyway, not saying you said it was the same as the DSM definition, just adding some perspective since I read a lot of TLP and naturally compared what I read in the OP to what I remember from TLP's blog.
wonderwonder 4y ago
Author appears to be bleeding friends and relationships and blaming it on the narcissism of the other person. Some people are narcissistic to a certain degree, for some of them it drives them to great accomplishments. See Trump, Elon, and many other billionaires and politicians. Some others it cripples them. People are complicated.
- IG_Semmelweiss 4y ago
  Agree re: trump, its textbook case... But what makes you say elon meets the criteria? He's definitely aloof, and probably on the spectrum of autistic. But that does make him a narcissist?
rogerclark 4y ago
Guy Posting On Substack Blog Complains About Narcissists
- waiseristy 4y ago
  > Following that dramedy, I packed my belongings and embarked on a nomadic lifestyle in which I lived in multiple co-living spaces and met a wide and authentic group of people Nomadic Goober Shocked That He Is The Perfect Prey For Narcissist Personality Types. More at 11
- cirrus3 4y ago
  ^ "poor me, and had to resort to living nomadic lifestyle in which I lived in multiple co-living spaces" cry me a river. OP needs to think harder about "am I the baddie?"
recursivedoubts 4y ago
we live in a culture of narccissism, as christopher lasch pointed out[1]. social media and online dating has ramped this exponentially, amplifying appearances and social positioning beyond anything humans have ever experienced, and the sociopaths are thriving, in their own way my solution to this is the same as my solution all other social ills: raise good children yes, that is hard [1] - https://thezeitgeistmovement.se/files/Lasch_Christopher_The_Culture_of_Narcissism.pdf https://thezeitgeistmovement.se/files/Lasch_Christopher_The_...
ristlane 4y ago
It's entirely possible to have rewarding & meaningful interactions with narcissistic people. Here's my process. First, realize you're not so much better. Don't expect too much. Next, don't insult them. Be aware of power games; don't get confused. Be straightforward. Generally avoid putting yourself in a situation where you need something from them. If they offer a favor, accept it (if you want) and say "thank you". Finally, don't try to fix them. Be simple. Offer them your time, and not much else. You'd be surprised at how many narcissists are relieved and happy to meet someone who behaves in this way.
- twelve40 4y ago
  I appreciate the tips (really) but the gist of it sounds awfully close to "just treat them like a baby and pamper them". Could work if you _really_ need this person, but doesn't sound... healthy?
  - ed_elliott_asc 4y ago
    and pay them lots of attention to keep them happy.
  - __s 4y ago
    No. The point is to have clear boundaries. In fact, "treat them like a baby and pamper them" is quite the opposite of the advice Don't offer to help them. If they ask for help, only agree if not expecting anything in return. Or be clear about what you'll want in return. Everyone is different: they may react negatively to rejection, which is it's own problem, others may not hold a grudge Be straightforward: call them out on their behavior, preferably privately to avoid power games. Let them know the boundaries which if crossed you'll disengage from them over
  - pseudosavant 4y ago
    It isn't healthy. It takes some serious honesty with yourself to decide who you really need.
  - IG_Semmelweiss 4y ago
    I think that is more part of your personal growth. People wont change. Some never grow up. Some never get past baby stage. Its up to you to accept how they are, or step aside and forge your own path
jalino23 4y ago
I recommend looking into into spiral dynamics for the framework of human behavior's
jl6 4y ago
Narcissism is an excess of identity. The self runneth over. Image empuppets the person.
- zeptonix 4y ago
  That's a social media motivated definition. It's actually a lot more than that.
  - swagasaurus-rex 4y ago
    In collectivist cultures, a narcissist is one who makes the appearance of caring very much about others/society/the nation, when in fact they're really doing so because of appearances.
    - mbakke 4y ago
      Or a feeling of self-worth, for the kinds of narcissist who loathe themselves (the "victim" type). They need to set a higher goal in order to bring meaning into their life because they are unable to nourish healthy relationships and enjoy the small things in life.
sam_goody 4y ago
1. A great many narcissistic children will label a classmate / neighbor an enemy somewhere between grades 6-8, and do everything in their power to destroy him. Their popularity and talent for molding public opinion will help them, as will the understanding that no one else wants to be his next victim. Unfortunately, I have seen this too often (the school psych told me it is a common trait for narcissists), and the effects on the victim are catastrophic. 2. As someone who runs a youth group, I know a family which is highly narcissist. It is very painful for me to watch them (they are children, so it is not personal, nor is it a threat). By the first kid, I mentioned something to the father, who turned on me personally and caused some days of heartache. By now, I just feel bad for them - and everyone who will ever be in contact with them. The school psychologist said that he cannot provide help without the parents OK, and the parents will never say OK. I know of no solution.
- malwarebytess 4y ago
  I know of one. Many won't like it, though, because it involves flexing the muscles of the state. And at the end, I'm not sure the potential benefits outweigh the real risks.
  - throwawaylinux 4y ago
    Criminalize mental deviancy, as defined and adjudicated by some state-employed panel of "experts"? You're really on the fence about the cost/benefit of this one?
    - malwarebytess 4y ago
      Yes I am. In my view people with NPD probably should be isolated from society in the same way an irredeemable criminal should be; that is because narcissists will never stop harming people if left to their own devices. If it's possible to do this without causing too much harm to society or our concept of justice, then it should be done. Thing is we already do this. The only step that would be novel would be allowing new inputs into the system. We already institutionalize millions of people with mental disorders. When there's no focus on mental disorders and treatment that's where prisons come in, when there is a focus on mental disorder and treatment then mental hospitals come into the picture. The sorting already happens. The differences would be in where do we begin intake, and where do we place people.
tempnow987 4y ago
I'm slightly curious about the author's ability to form solid peer relationships. This person dated someone who was "emotionally abusive, hypersensitive, and disrespectful". Umm, it IS possible to just say, hey, I don't think this is going to work out. Then just move on. Back in the craigslist dating days dates could be seriously wild for those old enough to remember that. I never felt the urge to post a substack blog about any of it. Every time I read these things I'm so thankful for my partner who is practical and grounded and I've never heard talk like this. We have 2 kids and it's a job and I can't even imagine doing it with someone who was constantly evaluating the other person for deficiencies. We both cut each other a lot of slack and it really works out for us. When you find yourself diagnosing the world with various problems, a bit of introspection might be helpful. You may be projecting some internal dysfunction, and even if not, it's MUCH easier to address things with respect to yourself then to "address rampant narcissism". "toxic behaviors repeatedly observed over an extended period with no apparent willingness for the perpetrator to change, lead to legitimate questioning." - Just the language here - "perpetrator" etc. Most people are just trying to make it through life in one piece. The language in this is throwing up my own pink and red flags.
Barrin92 4y ago
I think our narcissism is largely a product of a culture obsessed with individual identity, individual success and ego. One of the best pieces I ever read on HN was by a Shopify engineer just a month ago about why he serves in the British Yeomanry. (https://chrisseaton.com/army/ https://chrisseaton.com/army/) "Being in the Army also grounds me in reality and in my community. The tech world can be a relatively narrow cross-section of society. When I spend time with the Army I interact with the full spectrum of my local community. My squadron has nurses, carpenters, architects, police officers, unemployed people, veterinarians, warehouse workers, tree surgeons, railway engineers, pilots, firefighters. I get to interact with people from a variety of backgrounds, a variety of economic situations, with a variety of outlooks[...] More than just interacting with a cross-section of society, it means building a very high level of trust and depending on each other. When we’re in the field there’s absolutely nowhere to hide, with no privacy and no time-off, and you’ll need to manage to get along. There’s a big taboo of being ‘jack’ and not looking after each other or serving yourself before others." I had a similar experience when I had to do military service. I don't think there's a better cure for narcissism than getting out of your head and comfort zone, doing something for and with other people in the real world. We should remember where the word 'narcissism' comes from. From Narcissus staring into his own reflection. So sitting in your room, reflecting on how totally not narcissistic you are is never going to be a solution.
- bladegash 4y ago
  Think there is also a certain level of self-policing that happens in the military as well, which does not exactly reward those high in ego/self-centered behavior. One thing I appreciate about my friends from the military, over a decade later even, is I can trust they’ll call me out when I deserve it (and vice versa).
- heavyset_go 4y ago
  I hate pathologizing, I whine a lot about it on HN, but for some people, narcissism is pathological and no amount of service towards others will give them perspective. I once knew a self-described narcissist who was proud of the fact. At one point, doing volunteer work benefited them, possibly for college credit or something, I forget. Their lesson from serving in a soup kitchen? "The homeless people didn't thank me enough, they're all so greedy and should be more thankful that I'm giving them food instead of doing something better with my time."
Melatonic 4y ago
The problem I have with articles like these (and discussions about narcissism in general) is that they often fail to classify or recognize that like many aspects of our psyche it is a spectrum of behaviours and beliefs. The extreme examples are of course shocking and easily derided - but on some level we need a healthy amount of narcissism in our lives.
jancsika 4y ago
> In my experience, there are a few pink flags that attract my attention: I try to be careful with people who continually credit themselves – this can be done indirectly by using false humility; they don't demonstrate a genuine interest in their peers; their words are inconsistent with their actions – sometimes for many small details; they rarely express guilt and, in most cases, make insincere apologies; they can be very sensitive in the face of unwitting criticism. Be careful-- you quoted a number like 15% of the population, in which case-- the narcissists are among us! And aside from inconsistent words/deeds, someone who is being calm but firm in the face of narcissists may wave these same pink flags: 1. They may take credit explicitly and precisely for the actual work they do. This avoids the pitfall of one of the narcissists seizing on ambiguities and lack of communication to claim credit for this same work (which they didn't actually do). 2. Narcissists seem like they constantly leave room for little dramas and use manipulative tactics to try to gain "points" with those around them. In the face of that, even the author's professed stoicism would be interpreted as a problem by such a narcissist-- after all, if you don't follow them down their rabbit hole of manipulation then how could you possibly register as "genuinely interested" in their view? 3. Maybe I'm weird in that I am fascinated by narcissists and try to interact with them when possible. I mean, a guy walks up to me talking on his cell and puts his finger up, as if to say, "Hold on, I have something to say to you after I'm done with this very important conversation." It's like smelling the elephant shit outside a circus tent-- it's bad, but it a sign of an impending spectacle. I'm getting a tiny shot of adrenaline just thinking about it... Now, do you think I'm going to express any degree of vulnerability whatsoever to this asshole? Doing that can only cause problems-- like asking the ring toss guy at the carnival if he will take a check... 4. Outside of cranks on HN, everybody is sensitive in the face of unwitting criticism. We've all got different tolerances for it, but we all can only take a finite amount in a given day. If there's a flag here, perhaps it has to do with the way we deal with that sensitivity. In my experience, normies commiserate and tend to feel better for it. Oh, you hit that obstacle and you're a professional obstacle avoider? Thanks, I don't feel as bad now. Perhaps that doesn't work for narcissists because they are Greek Gods with the highest standards? Dunno, just speculating. Epilogue: the finger-guy walked off without finishing his very important phone call. I haven't heard from him since. :(
UnpossibleJim 4y ago
"Dr. Ramani give numbers around 15% of the population, while my therapist believes it's considerably higher, but I assume she's biased since she lives in Paris." This might be my favorite quote I've ever read. It reads of pulp fiction and I love it. I know I'll get downvoted, but I can't believe that Paris can be worse than any other major urban center like New York, L.A., Milan or Quebec.
- TameAntelope 4y ago
  I'm not a writer, but I cannot right now come up with a less self-aware sentence. It's absolutely brilliant, I also love it.
  - ikr678 4y ago
    I did giggle, but the handful of narcissistic personality types I have encountered in my life have be hugely concerned with status, so it doesnt seem a huge stretch to believe they'd concentrate in cities.
- zik 4y ago
  I just took it as straight up racist / xenophobic. I feel sad for any Parisians who read this article. But on the other hand maybe it's just a narcissistic attempt at dropping that he's so important that he has a therapist in Paris?
prepend 4y ago
> I don't want to be with someone who doesn't care to drink tap water I don’t know if it’s ultimatum worthy, but this is a really curious behavior to me. Tap water in almost all of the US is healthy and fine. So not drinking tap water is as queer to me as not wearing any clothes that weren’t professionally cleaned. I’ve heard from people that they don’t like the taste of tap water. But if one lives in an area for a few weeks the taste is acquired.
- robonerd 4y ago
  In some areas, the tap water is perfectly safe but tastes foul. For instance in many parts of Florida the tap water tastes like rotten eggs because it has a lot of sulfur in it. Safe, but not very tasty (or an acquired taste?)
- rendang 4y ago
  Lots of people don't drink water much at all, tap or not. As for the flavor, I disagree that one just gets accustomed to the taste of high chlorine or sulfur levels the way that one gets used to the bitterness of coffee or whiskey.
voidhorse 4y ago
There’s something a bit ironic in the attitude of this essay. By the conclusion it seems to suggest the only thing one should do in a relationship is continually verify that it isn’t toxic and to find tools to protect oneself over all else…which is when you become the very thing the article decries. America, and slowly global society thanks to the success and pervasiveness of American media and technology, has always been on a hyper-individualistic trend. Nearly all long-standing communal institutions have at best become shadows of their formers selves at this point or have pretty much dissolved entirely. It’s the natural outcome of a society that idolizes individuals through rampant celebrity fixations and continually perpetuates the lie of meritocracy by permitting a wildly unbalanced late-stage capitalism to persist and prop up entrepreneur-celebrity types, which are pretty much the manifest fusion of America’s worst aspects: praising individuals because of their entertainment value and praising individuals because of their capital gains. Unfortunately, social media has devolved into a means for extending this possibility of celebrity to the masses. You too can become successful and wealthy not on any significant merit that actually improves society, but just by being a “fun” personality that posts “content” on social media. No need to be an inventor or do anything significant, everyone gets their little kingdom of “followers”. In America, people who perform selfless, society-serving feats are generally sentenced to becoming footnotes in the public consciousness, maybe being remembered and celebrated for a holiday or so, while the rest of our mental space is occupied by nonsense pretty much 24/7.
- chasd00 4y ago
  if you're doing selfless acts only to be remembered then it's not very selfless is it? The thing i like about individualism is if you're into being selfless then that's great and more power to you. If you're not, well then that's great as well and more power to you too. You're free to pursue what you value.
atq2119 4y ago
> impressive accomplishments: a dozen academic degrees in various fields Having a dozen academic degrees is not impressive even if true. If true, it would be a warning sign that the person isn't able to move on to something deeper and more meaningful than degrees.
robonerd 4y ago
Does anybody else feel the hair on their neck rise when they hear accusations of narcissism? A few times in my life I've known people who tried to control me by accusing all of my other friends of being narcissists, telling me that I should stop being around them. I now believe that accusing other people of narcissism is one method employed by narcissists, so these sort of accusations now make me very nervous about the person making them. Also it reminds me of the 'asshole' theory; that if you meet an asshole one day, you've simply met an asshole. But if you meet many assholes every day, it's probably you who's the asshole. Somebody who perceives many narcissists all over the place is somebody I'm wary of.
- blacksignal 4y ago
  Yes. Abusers often claim to be the victim and turn people against their target. And abusers will often provoke victims, complicating the situation. > A few times in my life I've known people who tried to control me And you are aware of a red flag. Another good tool -- narcissists (other manipulators, abusers) will use fear, obligation, and guilt to control people -- FOG. If you find yourself feeling those emotions around / because of certain people, investigate carefully as to why.
- anm89 4y ago
  Yeah this is my first thought when I read this. Calling others narcissists is more often a red flag for the accuser than the accusee in my opinion. Narcissism is a spectrum just like every other personality trait, not some binary thing that some people are and some people aren't. And you don't really want to be on either extreme of that spectrum in my opinion. I think the term is often used to mean "someone who isn't giving me what I want so I'm going to pathologize my not liking them". That being said, there are certainly people who are subjectively obnoxiously narcissistic and I'm sure in a clinical setting you find true outliers who are deeply pathological.
- FooBarBizBazz 4y ago
  I feel the same. Because whenever I hear these accusations, part of me goes, "oh no, am I a narcissist? Am I one of those horrible people?" But then I take a step back and go, "wait. It feels like someone is trying to control the people around them with guilt." So then I reject the concept entirely and instead ask another set of questions: - Do you hurt people? - Do you insist on dominating people's conversations? - Do you take things from people? - Do you steal credit? - Are you mean? - Do you display physical violence? - Do you throw tantrums? - Do you lie about other people? No? Well, fine, that doesn't mean you're perfect -- we all sin -- but... is it really likely that you have some terrible behavioral pathology? I don't think so. The problem is, this gets mixed with a bunch of other things that, as far as I can tell, are universal: - Do you like to feel appreciated? - Do you enjoy positive attention? (Well, only so much, actually.) - Do you try to keep up appearances? Dress better when you're going out? Worry about embarrassment when public speaking? Isn't all that just normal? I'd think it is! In fact, what happens if you reverse these? A person who gives no shit what other people think -- what motivates them? I just don't understand it. It's like considering a reptile. We're social creatures. At some level -- Do you attack other people? If the answer is no, you're probably ok. And if you're throwing the word "narcissist" at people... doesn't that make you an attacker? Something about it all just makes my skin crawl.
jrm4 4y ago
This article feels slightly closer to parody than genuine; does the author not see that they are the common denominator?
- cirrus3 4y ago
  this
mbakke 4y ago
As someone with several narcissistic traits, the book "The Subtle Art Of Not Giving A Fuck" by Mark Manson was an eye-opener. It succinctly describes detrimental thought patterns that you might even not know you have, and gives examples of more productive mindsets. Can recommend for anyone dealing with insecurities.
quadcore 4y ago
Ive thought a lot about that lately and found an explanation (about why do narcicism and psychopathy seem to be more trendy) which satisfies me. Farms and factories used to employ a lot of people. It was the default job back in the day. So we have two things, 1) it was difficult to get out, especially when you do things superficially and 2), well then, being a "body person" (think muscles) was more trendy than being a "brain person" (think nerd). I dont think the nerds are mocked at schools anymore, I think they are the stars (though its actually conjecture, Id love to verify that). So yeah, more people out of guetto lives (one might say not the best on average, if you'd forgive me the shortcut here) and the need to look smart socially. Boom psycho crisis. As a sidenote, same thing happened with the web, it used to be a nerd-with-glass thing (many wouldn't even want to be seen with a computer), you had to have a computer which was expensive and useless for your say, average factory worker. Now what can we do? Teach children basic psychology, yoga and buddhism maybe? We got to do something because thats a lot of people on the brain market now and thats not gonna end well :)
TameAntelope 4y ago
> Following that dramedy, I packed my belongings and embarked on a nomadic lifestyle in which I lived in multiple co-living spaces and met a wide and authentic group of people. Oookay, feels a bit "pot calling the kettle black" here, not really sure what the point of this article really was, other than to exclaim, "Narcissism exists!"
- RyJones 4y ago
  People need affirmation. I am people; therefore, affirm me? I don’t know. It was a slog to read.
- notahacker 4y ago
  Yeah, reading through the first few paragraphs made me think: this is the sort of thing a clever writer puts together before revealing at the end the only narcissist is the person who believes their relationship broke down because of irredeeemable flaws in the other person alone, responded to encountering an impressive individual by furiously searching for gaps in their resume, and maintained an "almost-healthy" transactional relationship with a formerly popular friend as all that person's other relationships soured by constantly letting them have the "credit" for stuff until that person eventually confronted them... But tbf to the author, who is presumably a real person and not a narcissist, I thought the second part was quite well written without that twist :) The general point seems to be that "narcissism exists and is more common and a less clearly defined than the mirror-watching psychopath of popular perception", although perhaps that's a bit too nuanced for parts of the HN audience now furiously insisting that people exhibiting narcissistic traits, unlike people with other spectrum disorders, must be regarded as irredeemable and avoided at all costs...
- cirrus3 4y ago
  yep, this person has bigger issues with themselves that others. Millions (Billions?) of other people seem to navigate the world without having to go to a "nomadic lifestyle in which I lived in multiple co-living spaces"... as if that is even a remotely possible option the vast amount of people out there in similar situations. OP has problems, blames other, is entitled, needs to grow TF up
farzatv 4y ago
davesque 4y ago
Doesn't seem like a very serious article on the topic. Seems to essentially say, "I had some difficulty getting along with certain people in my life whom I would call narcissists. Therefore, narcissism is rampant."
bsedlm 4y ago
it's also important to understand the difference between narcissistic traits, and a narcissistic pathology. i.e. being narcissistic is not inherently bad nor evil, and unless there are other negative consequences that elevate the traits into pathology, I don't see why should we strive to eradicate narcissism
CPLX 4y ago
This says there’s no cure for narcissism but that’s clearly and demonstrably not true. Narcissism is when someone has excessive self regard, like they have a vastly over-inflated image of themselves. Most people focus on making people revise that high self-regard but it’s much more straightforward to just actually become more and more and more awesome until your perception comes into line with reality. If you’re really one of the greatest or most important people in the world, and you believe that you are, you’re just a realist. This has been my preferred approach to solving the problem so far.
- dralley 4y ago
  Ok, Elon.
mhmmbt 4y ago
apengwin 4y ago
Build a bunch of clear, deep ponds everywhere so they get stuck staring at themselves
mdoms 4y ago
happythebob 4y ago
Narciasism has to be a spectrum, no?
cjbgkagh 4y ago
Instilling a culture of narcissism was done intentionally in order to sell us stuff. It works and it makes a lot of money, I don’t know how you’d stop something like that.
vcryan 4y ago
I am sad to say that I have had a significant dealings with a narcissist for years without being familiar with the term. From my experience, the narcissist suffered some traumatic event, probably in ~early childhood, and somehow it caused them to become maladapted in the way they perceive the world and their role in it. I don't believe narcissism is caused by culture/society. Although, it anecdotally, I wonder if there is also a genetic factor. Regardless of the cause, the person and their behavior are irrevocably damaged and the only way of dealing with them is not feeding them. Maintain extreme neutrality and disinterest and stay as far away as you can. All they do is harm, and they have no capability of ever taking accountability, it is simply beyond their comprehension. If you suggest that there is an issue, you will quickly find out that you are the issue, and the narcissist will get hard at work taking you apart, piece by piece, until there is nothing left of you.
jimkleiber 4y ago
When people label humans as narcissists or their behaviors as narcissistic (or socialist/fascist/sexist/etc), I mostly feel confused at what they mean and wish they would describe more specific behaviors, and ideally, how they themselves were feeling in response to those behaviors. I think we sometimes use such labels as shortcuts and assume others know what we mean, and yet by abstracting so much, we can create more distance and less understanding. I believe these terms can become buckets into which we throw all sorts of "they did something evil / that hurt me" actions that may or may not relate to the theory of narcissism. In lieu of that, when I hear someone claim someone else is a narcissist, I mostly just assume the person claiming that feels very hurt or angry by something that other person did.
mdotk 4y ago
Simple, shut down social media.
TwoNineFive 4y ago
lol is this intentional parody or unintentional parody, I just can't tell.

108 points by binnacle 4y ago

jjtheblunt 4y ago

being addressed is what narcissism wants. oh the irony

cirrus3 4y ago
OP sounds like a classic narcissist

eismcc 4y ago

Only you can stop narcissism.

brentirwin 4y ago
Only I can stop narcissism.

tonguez 4y ago

what’s rampant is billionaires ”amplifying” vapid narcissism because they want a disempowered population with no good role models or values other than the worship of money, and the path to money is being a cog in the western MCI/global supply chain/the great satan. people don’t want to build the surveillance state for google if it means they are going to be shamed and looked at as creeps. but if you give them enough money, they can film the crispest videos with their most expensive phones of their most expensive houses, making them de-facto cool, because everyone else is poor/a loser.

ButterWashed 4y ago

"Unfortunately, there is no cure for narcissism" I can't imagine this will ever change. How do you encourage someone who seeks the admiration of others at all costs to simply stop? Without a shred of evidence, I'm sure the increased use of social media is at least partially to blame.

Melatonic 4y ago
On the other hand labelling these people in some completely "other" group probably is not helpful either - what about those who are on the border? What about those who might display what appears to be very narcissistic qualities but only in very specific niches?
- robonerd 4y ago
  > On the other hand labelling these people in some completely "other" group probably is not helpful either I'm inclined to agree. Recognizing and accounting for harmful traits in others is important, but some of the rhetoric in this discussion borders dangerously close to dehumanization.
apostacy 4y ago
I am really confused about this. It does not make sense to me. Do you mean that it is difficult to cure? Because that is not the same thing as incurable. If people can be socialized into it, why can't they be socialized out of it? 15% of the population is incurably emotionally broken? And most of them were made, not born, because they spent too much time on Instagram, and now they are part of the 15% of the population that is cursed to a life of narcissism, no matter how much effort is put into curing them? Isn't it possible that you can just mature and become less solipsistic? Aren't these behaviors situational? What if you were put in an environment where someone got negative feedback for narcissistic behavior? There must be something I am missing, because those claims do not seem realistic.
- zozbot234 4y ago
  Of course it's possible to mature, but only if people want to. People who actively want to become less self-centered are not narcissists, by definition.
  - apostacy 4y ago
    So it is possible to cure narcissism, if only the narcissist wants to be cured? That is a very far cry from being described as 'incurable', which I have seen used a lot. Again, I am not saying that narcissism doesn't exist, but the language that is being used to describe it is unhelpful. A lot of people go through phases in their teens or 20s that could be described as narcissistic, and then they develop out of it.

daenz 4y ago

>A week later, I received a few ambiguous and regretful messages from her, which escalated to a phone call in which she sought guidance on her next date The author needs to spend time identifying how people use tactics to assert and obtain power. Even if you don't want to use those tactics yourself, which is fine, your whole life will be better served by knowing how to deflect tactics others use to submit you (lowering your perceived value to others). For some people, all they have is power games. They can't rely on abilities or genuine personality traits, so they have to rely on manipulating perceptions of themselves and others. Other people have the privilege of not needing to do that, so they never develop those manipulation instincts through practice. They get taken advantage of because they don't even see the games being played. Imo, the sweet spot is not needing to manipulate others in order to have your intended effect on the world, but being able to do so to when it's required.

bGl2YW5j 4y ago
Both this article and your comment sum-up what I have really been struggling with lately at work. I’ve never experienced such a narcissistic person and have had a hard time not only dealing with their behaviour, but identifying it for what it is in the first place. Thanks for the insight.
- prometheus76 4y ago
  Some tips from someone who has dealt with a few classic narcissists: don't argue with them. They do not reason the way you do. One-word answers are best. Pretend you are a very dull, boring person with no opinions when you are talking to them. Never raise your voice or get angry. They will try to use the silent treatment on you: ignore it. But it works very well on them too. They will never, in a million years, apologize. But if they apologize, they are only trying to manipulate you further because their fear of abandonment has been triggered by your body language and tone. Always remember they lie constantly. They don't know what the truth is anymore. These are strategies and perspectives I've learned from having narcissistic family members. I hope it helps. The best thing you can do is just not deal with them at all, but sometimes it's unavoidable.

hitovst 4y ago

End the dysgenic forced redistribution of wealth, and people will be forced to adapt to reality. If we continue to tolerate forced redistribution of wealth, it only goes one way, and it's the opposite of "addressing it".

farzatv 4y ago

drewcoo 4y ago

Dig more lacunae? The impulse to "help" other people is noble. Except for those quotes around "help." This isn't about helping others so much as dealing with them. And that's toxic in itself. Narcissus liked to stare into his lacuna. So harm reduction might be digging more lacunae. With enough reflective surfaces, Narcissus might have a "normal" life. I've experienced environments where everyone constantly gets praise for the least little aspect of existing.

givemeethekeys 4y ago

It's simple but not easy. Reward people who take orders more than those that give them.

29athrowaway 4y ago

If narcissism (and psychopathy) is prevailing is because it is favored by society. - Marketing and advertising - Social media and entertainment industry - Employers - Dating scene Everyone nowadays seems to love charismatic selfish people that do not have time for empathy. Noone wants to be the "loser" that contributes to society, but rather the jerk that takes everything from others. We glorify parasitic people like Bezos and the Waltons that can exist only because they have the majority of their workforce on welfare benefits.

brewdad 4y ago
I don't mind being the "loser" that contributes to society. I hate feeling like the "sucker" that gets left holding the bag when the selfish jerks continue to take.
Melatonic 4y ago
I think what you are describing is distinctly more American than anything else - in many countries it would probably not be seen as a huge positive to be super gregarious in a business setting for example.
rendang 4y ago
The Waltons are glorified? I barely hear much about them at all.
- 29athrowaway 4y ago
  Every time you shop at Walmart.

greatpostman 4y ago

Generally there’s huge rewards for being a narcissist. Refusing to ever admit your wrong and instead gaslighting people around you works really well. People figure out the pattern, just shuffle them out of your life and add new people. I noticed that a few friends I grew up with developed this approach when they found it worked extremely well with women.

BlargMcLarg 4y ago
It works well as long as there is an abundance of people willing to stick around, which is when these people will develop this mindset. With a bit of luck they'll grow out of it once the environment no longer makes it beneficial, but many are too far gone by then. It's part of why PUA circles (to stick with the dating example in the article) hammer "abundance mentality" so much. You don't have to deal with a person having a problem with you when, as you say, you can shuffle them out for someone else.
blacksignal 4y ago
Unfortunately this means there's no incentive for them to change. Becoming a better person and having healthier relationships takes a lot of effort, and to them, they are giving up power (and becoming vulnerable) -- so why bother? And empathy for others will never be a motivator, here.
- greatpostman 4y ago
  Yeah I mean as a general human strategy, narcissism works. Not everyone is equipped for it though
fudged71 4y ago
The show "Inventing Anna" is a perfect example of this. Charismatic narcissist gaslights everyone around her and anyone who doesn't plan along gets replaced with someone who will.
heavyset_go 4y ago
Depends on how deep they are into it. Some people with such traits can't keep down a job or even familial relationships without their ego getting in the way.

kadenwolff 4y ago

You cannot solve your narcissism through introspection. Introspection will only lead you to thinking you've found the answer, and stopping there so you don't have to change. "I've figured it out, I know why I'm a narcissist," and then stopping there. People can't tell you how to stop being a narcissist. If someone tells you exactly what to do, you'll do that thing, and then stop. "I'm doing that thing now, so I'm not a narcissist!" Your mind will simulate the most awful pain imaginable just to protect against changing your behaviour. You think your suffering is making you a good person, that by looking at the painful parts of your mind you are no longer a narcissist, but you're at the same place as you were before. You haven't changed your behaviour at all.

gtirloni 4y ago
I didnt get what you're trying to say. What's one to do then?
- careersuicide 4y ago
  > What's one to do then? GP gives a hint: > You haven't changed your behaviour at all. TLP[1] said it best: > There you go again, thinking about yourself. Your impulse wasn't to say, "am I doing this to my kids?" or "how will I act differently?" It was to wonder about your own nature. 1: https://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2012/10/the_story_of_narcissus.html https://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2012/10/the_story_of_narciss...
  - yes_i_can 4y ago
    Worthy of note, TLP did often harp on the fact that his view of 'narcissism' as a cultural phenomenon (I think he called it a "generational pathology") is NOT the same as the DSM definition. People are fooled into thinking every narcissist is the person with a self-inflated ego (I inferred the same from the OP, "Some of them are good enough to fool Jersey Shore candidates, while others can reach high executive positions and, in some cases, potentially win a presidential election..."). But TLP's definition was closer to someone who is completely focused on controlling others' perception of them. This could include a person who projects himself as a meek victim, but hyper-focused on relaying that image to others. Although, this does fit quite well too: "I don't want to be with someone who doesn't care to drink tap water." Anyway, not saying you said it was the same as the DSM definition, just adding some perspective since I read a lot of TLP and naturally compared what I read in the OP to what I remember from TLP's blog.

wonderwonder 4y ago

Author appears to be bleeding friends and relationships and blaming it on the narcissism of the other person. Some people are narcissistic to a certain degree, for some of them it drives them to great accomplishments. See Trump, Elon, and many other billionaires and politicians. Some others it cripples them. People are complicated.

IG_Semmelweiss 4y ago
Agree re: trump, its textbook case... But what makes you say elon meets the criteria? He's definitely aloof, and probably on the spectrum of autistic. But that does make him a narcissist?

rogerclark 4y ago

Guy Posting On Substack Blog Complains About Narcissists

waiseristy 4y ago
> Following that dramedy, I packed my belongings and embarked on a nomadic lifestyle in which I lived in multiple co-living spaces and met a wide and authentic group of people Nomadic Goober Shocked That He Is The Perfect Prey For Narcissist Personality Types. More at 11
cirrus3 4y ago
^ "poor me, and had to resort to living nomadic lifestyle in which I lived in multiple co-living spaces" cry me a river. OP needs to think harder about "am I the baddie?"

recursivedoubts 4y ago

we live in a culture of narccissism, as christopher lasch pointed out[1]. social media and online dating has ramped this exponentially, amplifying appearances and social positioning beyond anything humans have ever experienced, and the sociopaths are thriving, in their own way my solution to this is the same as my solution all other social ills: raise good children yes, that is hard [1] - https://thezeitgeistmovement.se/files/Lasch_Christopher_The_Culture_of_Narcissism.pdf https://thezeitgeistmovement.se/files/Lasch_Christopher_The_...

ristlane 4y ago

It's entirely possible to have rewarding & meaningful interactions with narcissistic people. Here's my process. First, realize you're not so much better. Don't expect too much. Next, don't insult them. Be aware of power games; don't get confused. Be straightforward. Generally avoid putting yourself in a situation where you need something from them. If they offer a favor, accept it (if you want) and say "thank you". Finally, don't try to fix them. Be simple. Offer them your time, and not much else. You'd be surprised at how many narcissists are relieved and happy to meet someone who behaves in this way.

twelve40 4y ago
I appreciate the tips (really) but the gist of it sounds awfully close to "just treat them like a baby and pamper them". Could work if you _really_ need this person, but doesn't sound... healthy?
- ed_elliott_asc 4y ago
  and pay them lots of attention to keep them happy.
- __s 4y ago
  No. The point is to have clear boundaries. In fact, "treat them like a baby and pamper them" is quite the opposite of the advice Don't offer to help them. If they ask for help, only agree if not expecting anything in return. Or be clear about what you'll want in return. Everyone is different: they may react negatively to rejection, which is it's own problem, others may not hold a grudge Be straightforward: call them out on their behavior, preferably privately to avoid power games. Let them know the boundaries which if crossed you'll disengage from them over
- pseudosavant 4y ago
  It isn't healthy. It takes some serious honesty with yourself to decide who you really need.
- IG_Semmelweiss 4y ago
  I think that is more part of your personal growth. People wont change. Some never grow up. Some never get past baby stage. Its up to you to accept how they are, or step aside and forge your own path

jalino23 4y ago

I recommend looking into into spiral dynamics for the framework of human behavior's

jl6 4y ago

Narcissism is an excess of identity. The self runneth over. Image empuppets the person.

zeptonix 4y ago
That's a social media motivated definition. It's actually a lot more than that.
- swagasaurus-rex 4y ago
  In collectivist cultures, a narcissist is one who makes the appearance of caring very much about others/society/the nation, when in fact they're really doing so because of appearances.
  - mbakke 4y ago
    Or a feeling of self-worth, for the kinds of narcissist who loathe themselves (the "victim" type). They need to set a higher goal in order to bring meaning into their life because they are unable to nourish healthy relationships and enjoy the small things in life.

sam_goody 4y ago

1. A great many narcissistic children will label a classmate / neighbor an enemy somewhere between grades 6-8, and do everything in their power to destroy him. Their popularity and talent for molding public opinion will help them, as will the understanding that no one else wants to be his next victim. Unfortunately, I have seen this too often (the school psych told me it is a common trait for narcissists), and the effects on the victim are catastrophic. 2. As someone who runs a youth group, I know a family which is highly narcissist. It is very painful for me to watch them (they are children, so it is not personal, nor is it a threat). By the first kid, I mentioned something to the father, who turned on me personally and caused some days of heartache. By now, I just feel bad for them - and everyone who will ever be in contact with them. The school psychologist said that he cannot provide help without the parents OK, and the parents will never say OK. I know of no solution.

malwarebytess 4y ago
I know of one. Many won't like it, though, because it involves flexing the muscles of the state. And at the end, I'm not sure the potential benefits outweigh the real risks.
- throwawaylinux 4y ago
  Criminalize mental deviancy, as defined and adjudicated by some state-employed panel of "experts"? You're really on the fence about the cost/benefit of this one?
  - malwarebytess 4y ago
    Yes I am. In my view people with NPD probably should be isolated from society in the same way an irredeemable criminal should be; that is because narcissists will never stop harming people if left to their own devices. If it's possible to do this without causing too much harm to society or our concept of justice, then it should be done. Thing is we already do this. The only step that would be novel would be allowing new inputs into the system. We already institutionalize millions of people with mental disorders. When there's no focus on mental disorders and treatment that's where prisons come in, when there is a focus on mental disorder and treatment then mental hospitals come into the picture. The sorting already happens. The differences would be in where do we begin intake, and where do we place people.

tempnow987 4y ago

I'm slightly curious about the author's ability to form solid peer relationships. This person dated someone who was "emotionally abusive, hypersensitive, and disrespectful". Umm, it IS possible to just say, hey, I don't think this is going to work out. Then just move on. Back in the craigslist dating days dates could be seriously wild for those old enough to remember that. I never felt the urge to post a substack blog about any of it. Every time I read these things I'm so thankful for my partner who is practical and grounded and I've never heard talk like this. We have 2 kids and it's a job and I can't even imagine doing it with someone who was constantly evaluating the other person for deficiencies. We both cut each other a lot of slack and it really works out for us. When you find yourself diagnosing the world with various problems, a bit of introspection might be helpful. You may be projecting some internal dysfunction, and even if not, it's MUCH easier to address things with respect to yourself then to "address rampant narcissism". "toxic behaviors repeatedly observed over an extended period with no apparent willingness for the perpetrator to change, lead to legitimate questioning." - Just the language here - "perpetrator" etc. Most people are just trying to make it through life in one piece. The language in this is throwing up my own pink and red flags.

Barrin92 4y ago

I think our narcissism is largely a product of a culture obsessed with individual identity, individual success and ego. One of the best pieces I ever read on HN was by a Shopify engineer just a month ago about why he serves in the British Yeomanry. (https://chrisseaton.com/army/ https://chrisseaton.com/army/) "Being in the Army also grounds me in reality and in my community. The tech world can be a relatively narrow cross-section of society. When I spend time with the Army I interact with the full spectrum of my local community. My squadron has nurses, carpenters, architects, police officers, unemployed people, veterinarians, warehouse workers, tree surgeons, railway engineers, pilots, firefighters. I get to interact with people from a variety of backgrounds, a variety of economic situations, with a variety of outlooks[...] More than just interacting with a cross-section of society, it means building a very high level of trust and depending on each other. When we’re in the field there’s absolutely nowhere to hide, with no privacy and no time-off, and you’ll need to manage to get along. There’s a big taboo of being ‘jack’ and not looking after each other or serving yourself before others." I had a similar experience when I had to do military service. I don't think there's a better cure for narcissism than getting out of your head and comfort zone, doing something for and with other people in the real world. We should remember where the word 'narcissism' comes from. From Narcissus staring into his own reflection. So sitting in your room, reflecting on how totally not narcissistic you are is never going to be a solution.

bladegash 4y ago
Think there is also a certain level of self-policing that happens in the military as well, which does not exactly reward those high in ego/self-centered behavior. One thing I appreciate about my friends from the military, over a decade later even, is I can trust they’ll call me out when I deserve it (and vice versa).
heavyset_go 4y ago
I hate pathologizing, I whine a lot about it on HN, but for some people, narcissism is pathological and no amount of service towards others will give them perspective. I once knew a self-described narcissist who was proud of the fact. At one point, doing volunteer work benefited them, possibly for college credit or something, I forget. Their lesson from serving in a soup kitchen? "The homeless people didn't thank me enough, they're all so greedy and should be more thankful that I'm giving them food instead of doing something better with my time."

Melatonic 4y ago

The problem I have with articles like these (and discussions about narcissism in general) is that they often fail to classify or recognize that like many aspects of our psyche it is a spectrum of behaviours and beliefs. The extreme examples are of course shocking and easily derided - but on some level we need a healthy amount of narcissism in our lives.

jancsika 4y ago

> In my experience, there are a few pink flags that attract my attention: I try to be careful with people who continually credit themselves – this can be done indirectly by using false humility; they don't demonstrate a genuine interest in their peers; their words are inconsistent with their actions – sometimes for many small details; they rarely express guilt and, in most cases, make insincere apologies; they can be very sensitive in the face of unwitting criticism. Be careful-- you quoted a number like 15% of the population, in which case-- the narcissists are among us! And aside from inconsistent words/deeds, someone who is being calm but firm in the face of narcissists may wave these same pink flags: 1. They may take credit explicitly and precisely for the actual work they do. This avoids the pitfall of one of the narcissists seizing on ambiguities and lack of communication to claim credit for this same work (which they didn't actually do). 2. Narcissists seem like they constantly leave room for little dramas and use manipulative tactics to try to gain "points" with those around them. In the face of that, even the author's professed stoicism would be interpreted as a problem by such a narcissist-- after all, if you don't follow them down their rabbit hole of manipulation then how could you possibly register as "genuinely interested" in their view? 3. Maybe I'm weird in that I am fascinated by narcissists and try to interact with them when possible. I mean, a guy walks up to me talking on his cell and puts his finger up, as if to say, "Hold on, I have something to say to you after I'm done with this very important conversation." It's like smelling the elephant shit outside a circus tent-- it's bad, but it a sign of an impending spectacle. I'm getting a tiny shot of adrenaline just thinking about it... Now, do you think I'm going to express any degree of vulnerability whatsoever to this asshole? Doing that can only cause problems-- like asking the ring toss guy at the carnival if he will take a check... 4. Outside of cranks on HN, everybody is sensitive in the face of unwitting criticism. We've all got different tolerances for it, but we all can only take a finite amount in a given day. If there's a flag here, perhaps it has to do with the way we deal with that sensitivity. In my experience, normies commiserate and tend to feel better for it. Oh, you hit that obstacle and you're a professional obstacle avoider? Thanks, I don't feel as bad now. Perhaps that doesn't work for narcissists because they are Greek Gods with the highest standards? Dunno, just speculating. Epilogue: the finger-guy walked off without finishing his very important phone call. I haven't heard from him since. :(

UnpossibleJim 4y ago

"Dr. Ramani give numbers around 15% of the population, while my therapist believes it's considerably higher, but I assume she's biased since she lives in Paris." This might be my favorite quote I've ever read. It reads of pulp fiction and I love it. I know I'll get downvoted, but I can't believe that Paris can be worse than any other major urban center like New York, L.A., Milan or Quebec.

TameAntelope 4y ago
I'm not a writer, but I cannot right now come up with a less self-aware sentence. It's absolutely brilliant, I also love it.
- ikr678 4y ago
  I did giggle, but the handful of narcissistic personality types I have encountered in my life have be hugely concerned with status, so it doesnt seem a huge stretch to believe they'd concentrate in cities.
zik 4y ago
I just took it as straight up racist / xenophobic. I feel sad for any Parisians who read this article. But on the other hand maybe it's just a narcissistic attempt at dropping that he's so important that he has a therapist in Paris?

prepend 4y ago

> I don't want to be with someone who doesn't care to drink tap water I don’t know if it’s ultimatum worthy, but this is a really curious behavior to me. Tap water in almost all of the US is healthy and fine. So not drinking tap water is as queer to me as not wearing any clothes that weren’t professionally cleaned. I’ve heard from people that they don’t like the taste of tap water. But if one lives in an area for a few weeks the taste is acquired.

robonerd 4y ago
In some areas, the tap water is perfectly safe but tastes foul. For instance in many parts of Florida the tap water tastes like rotten eggs because it has a lot of sulfur in it. Safe, but not very tasty (or an acquired taste?)
rendang 4y ago
Lots of people don't drink water much at all, tap or not. As for the flavor, I disagree that one just gets accustomed to the taste of high chlorine or sulfur levels the way that one gets used to the bitterness of coffee or whiskey.

voidhorse 4y ago

There’s something a bit ironic in the attitude of this essay. By the conclusion it seems to suggest the only thing one should do in a relationship is continually verify that it isn’t toxic and to find tools to protect oneself over all else…which is when you become the very thing the article decries. America, and slowly global society thanks to the success and pervasiveness of American media and technology, has always been on a hyper-individualistic trend. Nearly all long-standing communal institutions have at best become shadows of their formers selves at this point or have pretty much dissolved entirely. It’s the natural outcome of a society that idolizes individuals through rampant celebrity fixations and continually perpetuates the lie of meritocracy by permitting a wildly unbalanced late-stage capitalism to persist and prop up entrepreneur-celebrity types, which are pretty much the manifest fusion of America’s worst aspects: praising individuals because of their entertainment value and praising individuals because of their capital gains. Unfortunately, social media has devolved into a means for extending this possibility of celebrity to the masses. You too can become successful and wealthy not on any significant merit that actually improves society, but just by being a “fun” personality that posts “content” on social media. No need to be an inventor or do anything significant, everyone gets their little kingdom of “followers”. In America, people who perform selfless, society-serving feats are generally sentenced to becoming footnotes in the public consciousness, maybe being remembered and celebrated for a holiday or so, while the rest of our mental space is occupied by nonsense pretty much 24/7.

chasd00 4y ago
if you're doing selfless acts only to be remembered then it's not very selfless is it? The thing i like about individualism is if you're into being selfless then that's great and more power to you. If you're not, well then that's great as well and more power to you too. You're free to pursue what you value.

atq2119 4y ago

> impressive accomplishments: a dozen academic degrees in various fields Having a dozen academic degrees is not impressive even if true. If true, it would be a warning sign that the person isn't able to move on to something deeper and more meaningful than degrees.

robonerd 4y ago

Does anybody else feel the hair on their neck rise when they hear accusations of narcissism? A few times in my life I've known people who tried to control me by accusing all of my other friends of being narcissists, telling me that I should stop being around them. I now believe that accusing other people of narcissism is one method employed by narcissists, so these sort of accusations now make me very nervous about the person making them. Also it reminds me of the 'asshole' theory; that if you meet an asshole one day, you've simply met an asshole. But if you meet many assholes every day, it's probably you who's the asshole. Somebody who perceives many narcissists all over the place is somebody I'm wary of.

blacksignal 4y ago
Yes. Abusers often claim to be the victim and turn people against their target. And abusers will often provoke victims, complicating the situation. > A few times in my life I've known people who tried to control me And you are aware of a red flag. Another good tool -- narcissists (other manipulators, abusers) will use fear, obligation, and guilt to control people -- FOG. If you find yourself feeling those emotions around / because of certain people, investigate carefully as to why.
anm89 4y ago
Yeah this is my first thought when I read this. Calling others narcissists is more often a red flag for the accuser than the accusee in my opinion. Narcissism is a spectrum just like every other personality trait, not some binary thing that some people are and some people aren't. And you don't really want to be on either extreme of that spectrum in my opinion. I think the term is often used to mean "someone who isn't giving me what I want so I'm going to pathologize my not liking them". That being said, there are certainly people who are subjectively obnoxiously narcissistic and I'm sure in a clinical setting you find true outliers who are deeply pathological.
FooBarBizBazz 4y ago
I feel the same. Because whenever I hear these accusations, part of me goes, "oh no, am I a narcissist? Am I one of those horrible people?" But then I take a step back and go, "wait. It feels like someone is trying to control the people around them with guilt." So then I reject the concept entirely and instead ask another set of questions: - Do you hurt people? - Do you insist on dominating people's conversations? - Do you take things from people? - Do you steal credit? - Are you mean? - Do you display physical violence? - Do you throw tantrums? - Do you lie about other people? No? Well, fine, that doesn't mean you're perfect -- we all sin -- but... is it really likely that you have some terrible behavioral pathology? I don't think so. The problem is, this gets mixed with a bunch of other things that, as far as I can tell, are universal: - Do you like to feel appreciated? - Do you enjoy positive attention? (Well, only so much, actually.) - Do you try to keep up appearances? Dress better when you're going out? Worry about embarrassment when public speaking? Isn't all that just normal? I'd think it is! In fact, what happens if you reverse these? A person who gives no shit what other people think -- what motivates them? I just don't understand it. It's like considering a reptile. We're social creatures. At some level -- Do you attack other people? If the answer is no, you're probably ok. And if you're throwing the word "narcissist" at people... doesn't that make you an attacker? Something about it all just makes my skin crawl.

jrm4 4y ago

This article feels slightly closer to parody than genuine; does the author not see that they are the common denominator?

cirrus3 4y ago
this

mbakke 4y ago

As someone with several narcissistic traits, the book "The Subtle Art Of Not Giving A Fuck" by Mark Manson was an eye-opener. It succinctly describes detrimental thought patterns that you might even not know you have, and gives examples of more productive mindsets. Can recommend for anyone dealing with insecurities.

quadcore 4y ago

Ive thought a lot about that lately and found an explanation (about why do narcicism and psychopathy seem to be more trendy) which satisfies me. Farms and factories used to employ a lot of people. It was the default job back in the day. So we have two things, 1) it was difficult to get out, especially when you do things superficially and 2), well then, being a "body person" (think muscles) was more trendy than being a "brain person" (think nerd). I dont think the nerds are mocked at schools anymore, I think they are the stars (though its actually conjecture, Id love to verify that). So yeah, more people out of guetto lives (one might say not the best on average, if you'd forgive me the shortcut here) and the need to look smart socially. Boom psycho crisis. As a sidenote, same thing happened with the web, it used to be a nerd-with-glass thing (many wouldn't even want to be seen with a computer), you had to have a computer which was expensive and useless for your say, average factory worker. Now what can we do? Teach children basic psychology, yoga and buddhism maybe? We got to do something because thats a lot of people on the brain market now and thats not gonna end well :)

TameAntelope 4y ago

> Following that dramedy, I packed my belongings and embarked on a nomadic lifestyle in which I lived in multiple co-living spaces and met a wide and authentic group of people. Oookay, feels a bit "pot calling the kettle black" here, not really sure what the point of this article really was, other than to exclaim, "Narcissism exists!"

RyJones 4y ago
People need affirmation. I am people; therefore, affirm me? I don’t know. It was a slog to read.
notahacker 4y ago
Yeah, reading through the first few paragraphs made me think: this is the sort of thing a clever writer puts together before revealing at the end the only narcissist is the person who believes their relationship broke down because of irredeeemable flaws in the other person alone, responded to encountering an impressive individual by furiously searching for gaps in their resume, and maintained an "almost-healthy" transactional relationship with a formerly popular friend as all that person's other relationships soured by constantly letting them have the "credit" for stuff until that person eventually confronted them... But tbf to the author, who is presumably a real person and not a narcissist, I thought the second part was quite well written without that twist :) The general point seems to be that "narcissism exists and is more common and a less clearly defined than the mirror-watching psychopath of popular perception", although perhaps that's a bit too nuanced for parts of the HN audience now furiously insisting that people exhibiting narcissistic traits, unlike people with other spectrum disorders, must be regarded as irredeemable and avoided at all costs...
cirrus3 4y ago
yep, this person has bigger issues with themselves that others. Millions (Billions?) of other people seem to navigate the world without having to go to a "nomadic lifestyle in which I lived in multiple co-living spaces"... as if that is even a remotely possible option the vast amount of people out there in similar situations. OP has problems, blames other, is entitled, needs to grow TF up

farzatv 4y ago

davesque 4y ago

Doesn't seem like a very serious article on the topic. Seems to essentially say, "I had some difficulty getting along with certain people in my life whom I would call narcissists. Therefore, narcissism is rampant."

bsedlm 4y ago

it's also important to understand the difference between narcissistic traits, and a narcissistic pathology. i.e. being narcissistic is not inherently bad nor evil, and unless there are other negative consequences that elevate the traits into pathology, I don't see why should we strive to eradicate narcissism

CPLX 4y ago

This says there’s no cure for narcissism but that’s clearly and demonstrably not true. Narcissism is when someone has excessive self regard, like they have a vastly over-inflated image of themselves. Most people focus on making people revise that high self-regard but it’s much more straightforward to just actually become more and more and more awesome until your perception comes into line with reality. If you’re really one of the greatest or most important people in the world, and you believe that you are, you’re just a realist. This has been my preferred approach to solving the problem so far.

dralley 4y ago
Ok, Elon.

mhmmbt 4y ago

apengwin 4y ago

Build a bunch of clear, deep ponds everywhere so they get stuck staring at themselves

mdoms 4y ago

happythebob 4y ago

Narciasism has to be a spectrum, no?

cjbgkagh 4y ago

Instilling a culture of narcissism was done intentionally in order to sell us stuff. It works and it makes a lot of money, I don’t know how you’d stop something like that.

vcryan 4y ago

I am sad to say that I have had a significant dealings with a narcissist for years without being familiar with the term. From my experience, the narcissist suffered some traumatic event, probably in ~early childhood, and somehow it caused them to become maladapted in the way they perceive the world and their role in it. I don't believe narcissism is caused by culture/society. Although, it anecdotally, I wonder if there is also a genetic factor. Regardless of the cause, the person and their behavior are irrevocably damaged and the only way of dealing with them is not feeding them. Maintain extreme neutrality and disinterest and stay as far away as you can. All they do is harm, and they have no capability of ever taking accountability, it is simply beyond their comprehension. If you suggest that there is an issue, you will quickly find out that you are the issue, and the narcissist will get hard at work taking you apart, piece by piece, until there is nothing left of you.

jimkleiber 4y ago

When people label humans as narcissists or their behaviors as narcissistic (or socialist/fascist/sexist/etc), I mostly feel confused at what they mean and wish they would describe more specific behaviors, and ideally, how they themselves were feeling in response to those behaviors. I think we sometimes use such labels as shortcuts and assume others know what we mean, and yet by abstracting so much, we can create more distance and less understanding. I believe these terms can become buckets into which we throw all sorts of "they did something evil / that hurt me" actions that may or may not relate to the theory of narcissism. In lieu of that, when I hear someone claim someone else is a narcissist, I mostly just assume the person claiming that feels very hurt or angry by something that other person did.

mdotk 4y ago

Simple, shut down social media.

TwoNineFive 4y ago

lol is this intentional parody or unintentional parody, I just can't tell.