9 ms·
Long-Term Building in Japan
- pcurve 5y agoFor those wondering about the cost... I found it elsewhere: "The most recent rebuilding required 14,000 cypress timbers, 25,000 sheaves of reeds, took 9 years to complete, and cost over $500 million." "Obtaining large enough timber posts, for instance, requires trees 300 to 500 years old" I seriously hope they can give it a rest for a while.
- earleybird 5y agoThere are 300+ yr old timber frame barns etc in Europe, so it seems to be plausibly a net zero impact.
- pcurve 5y agoHrm, I figured Japanese is doing this in a sustainable way, but I can't help but wonder about the half a billion dollar price tag. It's a massive public works project since it's partly tax funded that benefits particular sectors. Since they've been doing it for 1400 years, superstitiously inclined people will be adamantly against making changes to the interval.
- shagie 5y agoFrom the Long Now post: > As we walked from arch to arch, Maholo explained that the forest here had historically been used exclusively to harvest timbers for all the shrines, but over the last millennia they had been harvested too heavily for various war efforts, or lost in fire. Since the beginning of this century the shrines’ caretakers have been bringing these forests back, and expect them to be self-sustaining again within the next two or three rebuilding periods — 40 to 60 years from now. Part of this is also a preservation of skills. It ensures that the artisans who work on it have a consistent demand for their skills.
- henearkr 5y agoForestry in Japan is a disaster nowadays. Both driven by the lack of wood on the market and by the bad habit of "accounting fraud" in Japan -- the count of cut trees is systematically under-reported by the timber corporations. This was revealed in particular after the huge landslides of 2021, as a forest holding together the soil had been silently harvested much more than what was reported.
- ricardobeat 5y agoIs that for all 80000 shrines? That’s 6k per unit. I’m sure the USA builds more backyard sheds than that, at a higher price tag, every year.
- denkmoon 5y agoOn the other hand, most backyard sheds don't use materials that take 300-500 years to produce. Well, except the petro-plastics...
- masklinn 5y agoAs the article notes, but for the war the surrounding forest is tended and maintained just for that purpose.
- pcurve 5y agono, it's just that particular shrine... Ise Shrine. https://theprepared.org/features-feed/ise-jingu-and-the-pyramid-of-enabling-technologies#:~:text=The%20most%20recent%20rebuilding%20required,and%20cost%20over%20%24500%20million https://theprepared.org/features-feed/ise-jingu-and-the-pyra.... 80,000 is number of shrine in the entire region.
- morninglight 5y agoThe cost is minuscule compared to the ROI. Religion in Japan is big business, just like your home country. Rest assured that when you visit a shrine in Japan, the first thing to greet you will be an offering box. .
- pcurve 5y agoOh yeah tell me about it. Every single shrine I hit in Kyoto... it was 500-600 yen.. and this was when exchange rate was 90 yen per dollar!
- alephnan 5y agoYou're confusing temples with shrines.
- SapporoChris 5y agoshrines can be happy with an offering as little as 5 yen. https://guidable.co/culture/japanese-shrines-how-much-donation-money-should-we-offer/ https://guidable.co/culture/japanese-shrines-how-much-donati... https://japantoday.com/category/features/lifestyle/busting-one-of-the-biggest-myths-about-the-%C2%A55-coin-and-shrine-offerings-in-japan https://japantoday.com/category/features/lifestyle/busting-o...
- pcurve 5y agoOffering is optional. Entrance fee is not. Most major temples have mandatory entrance fee
- alephnan 5y ago> The cost is minuscule compared to the ROI. Religion in Japan is big business, just like your home country. That's a very western way of looking at things. Alternatively, it can be viewed as a community crowdsourcing and preserving culture.
- tinco 5y ago
- Aeolun 5y agoThis makes it sound like that $500 million is just the cost of reconstruction of one shrine. > Every 20 years exact copies of Naiku, Geku, and 14 other shrines are built on empty sites next to the existing structures > the rebuilding also includes creating exact copies of thousands of ceremonial treasures and artifacts But the real value in this whole deal is that the entire reconstruction happens using traditional techniques, passing them on to the next generation. $500 million feels like a steal for preserving your cultural heritage like that.
- throw0101a 5y agoContrast with Japanese residential housing: > An unusual feature of Japanese housing is that houses are presumed to have a limited lifespan, and are generally torn down and rebuilt after a few decades, generally twenty years for wooden buildings and thirty years for concrete buildings – see (§) regulations for details. Refurbishing properties, rather than rebuilding them, is a relatively uncommon practice in Japan, though its prevalence is increasing, indicating that attitudes towards older houses may be changing.[1] * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Housing_in_Japan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Housing_in_Japan > Raze, rebuild, repeat: why Japan knocks down its houses after 30 years * https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2017/nov/16/japan-reusable-housing-revolution https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2017/nov/16/japan-reusabl... > Japanese Homes Aren’t Built to Last—and That’s the Point * https://robbreport.com/shelter/home-design/japanese-homes-are-ephemeral-facing-demolition-just-22-years-in-heres-why-1234608438/ https://robbreport.com/shelter/home-design/japanese-homes-ar...
- gamegoblin 5y agoThe main subject of the post is a temple that has been torn down and rebuilt every 20 years for over a thousand years. It’s an example of continual, dynamic renewal rather than static permanence.
- donw 5y agoIt is fantastically frustrating, as it makes wealth-building through home ownership impossible. The land will nominally hold its value, but the $300k+ you spend to build a house literally just... vanishes. This might have made sense back when houses were cheap to build, but now, houses in Japan are probably twice as expensive per unit area compared to the US. Salaries are low as well, so building a house here is basically a one-way ticket to 35 years of wage-slavery. Don't even think about a used house, because they were built to a level of cheapness that defies logic, along with a complete disregard for utility. A 1970s rubber-stamp development home in the US has better design, no joke. Windows, light switches, and walls will be allocated by a pseudo-random algorithm that somehow maximizes inconvenience: "Hmm... what could we do on this wall? I know, a gigantic off-center window that looks directly out upon the wall of the neighbor's house! Let's also make sure the kitchen sink underneath it is also off-center, but differently. That 'sketched by a drunken, retarded misanthrope' effect doesn't just happen on its own: you gotta work for it." "We've got this other wall over here, how can we make it even more useless? We've already sketched in a massive off-center window that looks right into the neighbor's lavatory, but I dunno. Something's missing. I think we left some utility... ah, that's it, we need to drop the window below countertop height." "Remember, electricity is a fad. One 20A circuit is plenty to cover an entire six-meter wall. In the kitchen." Did I also mention that a "big" housing lot is 1/20 of an acre? Usually no yard, just concrete. (You are correct in observing that I have spent way too much time on this over the past year, as I very much would like to buy a home)
- thematrixturtle 5y ago(02019)
- hoseja 5y agoHonestly I like the +10k (12019) better.
- diebeforei485 5y agoI think getting rid of (or renovating) old structures is a good thing. 100 year old houses are not generally fun to live in, unless they have been very very well maintained to the point that it would have been cheaper to rebuild.
- soperj 5y agoI've been in 200+ year old structures in the Netherlands that are nicer than the majority of houses I've been to in NA.
- ajmurmann 5y agoHow high-end and affordable were these buildings when they got constructed? I remodeled a ~300 year olds house in rural Germany. The building used to house at least two families till the first half of the 20th century. We had to in essence redo everything except for maybe 70% of the oak beams, totally change the layout, dig up and lower the floors to accommodate anyone but tiny people and build out the attic to make the building attractive at all. This building was at the equivalent of the village square when it was constructed. Had the village grown and turned into Al even a town, I'd hoped it would have been replaced a long time ago. I'm proud I got to take part in this work and will in all likelihood own it myself some day. If it wasn't a under heritage protection we'd likely not have preserved it though because it makes little economic sense.
- robswc 5y agoWhat sort of structures? And how are you deciding "nice" ? I do believe you, its just when I think of a nice structure to live in, good HVAC is a must and lots of place in Europe simply don't have AC... can't speak as to why that's the case but its one of those things you take for granted lol
- bowsamic 5y agoEuropeans do not consider AC a must. I live in an attic conversion on a very well to do street in Germany, and there is not a single AC unit in sight. It's not common at all, we do not care about it. We would rather get extremely hot and sweaty for a few days a year than make the investment for AC
- ghostly_s 5y ago(2019), though details in the article seem to indicate this trip took place in 2013.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rootos 5y agoWhat do they do with the old wood? Do they recycle it? Can someone buy it?
- wodenokoto 5y agoThe article buries the lead. What’s the other structure?
- robswc 5y agoVery respectable. On a side note though, I often see people complain about how things aren't "built to last" anymore and sometimes I wonder (as a person naive to construction) is that even a good thing? I've lived in a few places over the years and it seems the older houses were consistently not great while the newer ones might have felt cheaper, but all the while felt "designed" for modern life. Perhaps since my family was never really well off growing up, I'm used to "cheap, old houses" and now that things have gotten a bit better, I find myself in newer, more expensive houses... idk, just seems like any house built now wouldn't really suit most people 100 years from now, no matter the quality. A "simple" example, we do have a vacation cottage that was built in the 1800s, passed down each generation, with very few changes. It's holding up well but it feels like it was made for elves and "fixing" that would be next to impossible without redoing most of the building. Again nice to visit but you would have to make a ton of changes to make it more livable...
- hparadiz 5y ago100 years ago no one would have imagined that a couple in their 20s would want a room dedicated to their desktop computers.... or even that each of them might want a separate "office". And I say "office" in quotes cause it's really a nerd cave that I might work in as well. I imagine some folks on HN would even want a dedicated VR space with a cleared out 10x10 square. What is considered luxury housing changes overtime.
- Bayart 5y ago> 100 years ago no one would have imagined that a couple in their 20s would want a room dedicated to their desktop computers.... or even that each of them might want a separate "office". And I say "office" in quotes cause it's really a nerd cave that I might work in as well. They were refered to as smoking rooms and boudoirs, but they very much existed.
- masklinn 5y agoAs well as cabinets, drawing rooms, parlours (possibly multiple), solars, sunrooms, studies, recreation rooms (billiard rooms), …
- Freak_NL 5y agoThe pedant in me is slightly miffed by the very conscious use of that five-digit year notation (e.g., 02033) in the article (this being the home of that jarring monstrosity), the neat use of macrons (the dashes over long vowels in transcribed Japanese, as in 'Jingū'), and then oddly referring to a Long Now member from the Netherlands as “a […] member in Holland” (which many Dutch perceive as like being called English when you are born in Edinburgh). The no-smoking sign at Hōryū-ji mentioned in the article doesn't just prohibit smoking, but open flame of any kind as well as taking combustibles inside (think contractors doing some job). That last bit got dropped by whoever put the English translation on the sign. It makes a little more sense that way.
- andyjohnson0 5y ago> The pedant in me is slightly miffed by the very conscious use of that five-digit year notation (e.g., 02033) in the article (this being the home of that jarring monstrosity) Yes its a bit of an affectation, and it does seem to annoy some people, but I do think it has some value as a subtle hint that "there is more after that". That observation by Danny Hillis: "When I was a child, people used to talk about what would happen by the year 2000. For the next thirty years they kept talking about what would happen by the year 2000, and now no one mentions a future date at all." [1] ...is still pretty true. There is very little mention of the future that isn't either gadget-focussed or terrifying (ie the climate crisis). We just don't have any signifiers that people want to use. I'd like to be able to say that Long Now has had some influence regarding this, but sadly (outside of a smallish bubble) I don't think it has. At least they're trying though and doing interesting stuff, I guess. (Disclosure: Long Now charter member fwiw) [1] https://longnow.org/about/ https://longnow.org/about/ (I removed the leading zeroes because I'm pretty sure they weren't in the original quote)
- smikhanov 5y ago> and now no one mentions a future date at all It might be that works of Mark Fisher (aka k-punk) hold an answer to that. He convincingly argues that somewhere around 1990s the humanity lost the ability to conjure alternative futures, or having ideas about the future at all, because capitalism now sets the limit of what is thinkable. According to Fisher, any future without capitalism doesn’t appear to be thinkable, so all humanity is left to do is infinitely rehashing ideas of last 50-60 years (post-WWII period, coinciding with emergence of the late capitalism).
- helsinkiandrew 5y agoReminds me of "Raze, rebuild, repeat: why Japan knocks down its houses after 30 years": https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2017/nov/16/japan-reusable-housing-revolution https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2017/nov/16/japan-reusabl... Discussed here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15736734 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15736734
- anon2020dot00 5y agoFive-digit year notation seems more like a gimmick instead of something useful given that four-digit notation (2022) will suffice for at least 5000 more years. Future generations will probably come-up with something more clever than a Five-digit year notation.