21 ms·
Judge: California’s women on boards law is unconstitutional
- fortran77 5y agoCan all the women who have been added to boards because of this illegal law be kicked off with no liability?
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoDefine "liability". Without legal consequences? Probably (if the decision is not reversed on appeal). Without horribly negative PR consequences? No way.
- metabagel 5y agoWhy would you want to do that?
- DocTomoe 5y agoTo state the obvious: You may have been forced to hire a less desireable candidate because of their genitals.
- varnaud 5y ago
- ralusek 5y agoBecause any modification to criteria other than optimizing for competency in the specific role for which you were hiring will be necessarily, mathematically, suboptimal.
- wombatpm 5y agoWe are talking board seats - which has nothing to do with competence and everything to do with being connected.
- yladiz 5y agoYou’re assuming that humans can be perfectly, mathematically, optimal, and this is basically never the case. Humans will always have biases, such as preferring those similar to themselves.
- simion314 5y ago>mathematically The problem with reality is there is no mathematical metric function where you can plug as input a human and you get as output a number and then you can sort this humans out so you can hire the best. Even for small domains like programming with language X and framework Y is not possible to create a good such metric function, someone could be good at memorizing APIs, someone could be fast at creating good solution but others might be slow but their solutions are even better and others are good at debugging issues.
- colordrops 5y agoI think the term "mathematically" is used here broadly and metaphorically, and not literally meaning a symbolic formula. Perhaps "measurably" would have been a better term. No doubt you measure people on various skills during an engineering interview rather than the shape and color of their body, right? Board of Director positions also have measurable skills.
- boolemancer 5y agoAre you really going to claim that there is some objective way to choose the best candidate during an engineering interview?
- colordrops 5y agoNo, I'm going to claim that there is at least something better than judging on physical characteristics. In fact most companies agree. It's not a strange or unique opinion.
- simion314 5y agoMost company want to meet and see you, why is that? why are so incompetent and not just give you a test and have someone check the results without meeting you and having a bias ?
- simion314 5y ago
- 7952 5y agoYou are just optimising for different things. One side is optimising for gender equality and statistical diversity. You are trying to optimise for competency. But outside of a perfect mathematical universe competency is multi dimensional and difficult to measure. Bias does creep in. Treating it as a scientific process seems just as reductive as reducing a person to just their gender.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- WaxedChewbacca 5y ago
- kstenerud 5y agoThe crux of the matter: "The law voided Friday was on shaky ground from the get-go, with a legislative analysis saying it could be difficult to defend. Then-Gov. Jerry Brown signed it despite the potential for it to be overturned because he wanted to send a message during the #MeToo era." The true purpose of this law was political career boosting, not actual change.
- mikeyouse 5y agoThat doesn’t even make sense - Jerry Brown was 79 years old when he signed that law and had already signaled his intent to retire.
- kstenerud 5y agoPushing through a law that requires discrimination based on race/gender/etc in a state that constitutionally forbids discrimination based on race/gender/etc does not make any sense (at least not on the surface). Brown is not stupid, nor is the legal team that worked for him. Just because you're retired doesn't mean you're out of politics and no back scratchers are beholden to you or you can't act as kingmaker or whatnot. There's a lot more to politics than the office itself. California is famously corrupt in this regard.
- epgui 5y ago> a law that requires discrimination based on race/gender/etc This is a semantic matter that largely depends on context, but more typically, it is not considered "discrimination" in the legal or usual common sense when it's in reality a form of "affirmative action". I'm just pointing this out to distinguish the case where "discrimination" can have positive meaning with that where it has pejorative meaning. When making value judgments either way, overloaded word choices can cause more harm than good. Edit: for those who are taking issue with my comment, please see #7 before you downvote: https://www.usf.edu/compliance-ethics/equal-opportunity/ten-myths-about-affirmative-action.aspx https://www.usf.edu/compliance-ethics/equal-opportunity/ten-...
- DoreenMichele 5y agoGood. European women generally sought help with carrying the burden of child bearing and child rearing and gains in terms of employment followed. American women generally took the very American position of "Don't tread on me!" and it hasn't been as effective. There are better ways to address such issues.
- Loic 5y agoIn Germany and France, the women are fighting to get such laws going through. My very personal take on the issue is that one needs such law to "change the habits" and then hope that the new normality later reduces the need for such laws.
- DoreenMichele 5y agoWell, I am skeptical that such an approach is really a good idea. So I personally hope they aren't throwing the baby out with the bathwater.
- epgui 5y agoAre you skeptical of whether the approach is morally good, or of whether it's effective? Because it is often very effective over time.
- DoreenMichele 5y agoMy concern would be that it could lead to women getting positions for which they aren't really qualified and this undermining corporate health over time, among other things. Having a smaller slice of a larger pie can be a better deal than a larger slice of a dying economy because people are being stupid in the name of ethics and equality.
- epgui 5y agoThat is more of a short-term concern: over the longer term, it is widely understood that establishing more equitable opportunities has the effect of redressing systematic inequities that are preventing full participation & competition of traditionally marginalized groups. The classic illustration is that the increased prevalence of women/black/hispanic/indigenous role models in STEM, for example, encourages a higher degree of participation and competition from these traditionally marginalized groups in the field. If there is no good reason to think these marginalized groups are inherently less suited for the role, then over time, they should be selected on the basis of merit in roughly demographic proportion.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tlb 5y agoIt’s frustrating how the courts can take 4 years to decide such an apparently straightforward question. During which time people had to make important decisions under uncertainty.
- antisthenes 5y agoIt may seem so from our perspective, but the people who were in charge of rebuttal probably wanted to make sure their case is bulletproof. I'd rather it take a little bit longer if it assures that procedure is followed and laws like these are legitimately struck down and set a strong precedent for the future.
- temp8964 4y agoActually it’s the purpose of the side pushing for this. They want this to be put in practice before it’s officially shut down by the court.
- ars 5y ago“More women on corporate boards means better decisions and businesses that outperform the competition,” Atkins said This is an odd way to defend a law. If he actually believed this were true, why would he need to mandate it? Just let the better companies outcompete.
- epgui 5y agoThis "natural selection" argument presupposes that women are sufficiently prevalent on boards that the competitive advantage they provide is apparent and obvious to all other companies. This assumption is problematic in a context of low prevalence.
- fyrn- 5y agoArticle says 26% met the criteria already, so it's not that out there to expect to see an effect
- twelve40 5y agoThe way State Senate leader Toni Atkins stated it - direct reference by the OP - "better decisions and businesses outperform the competition" means she believes that this is a 100% fact, and the competitive advantage is apparent to everyone but the foolish judges (quote: "legalities don’t match our realities"). She doesn't seem fazed by this assumption being problematic in a context of low prevalence.
- Veen 5y agoIf they aren't sufficiently prevalent to demonstrate the advantage, then on what basis is the claim being made?
- epgui 5y agoWhen you do research, you select your sample judiciously, and you never really sample the whole population. Depending on the research question, you sometimes want to select a sampling technique that is not representative of the population.
- radu_floricica 5y agoWinds are finally blowing the other way? The other completely unconstitutional but widely practiced things in US are "the employer has to prove its innocence" when it comes to hiring discriminations - which is not only blatantly unjust, but eats up enormous resources and potential. And affirmative action in education.
- supernova87a 5y agoHere is the text of the opinion: https://s.wsj.net/public/resources/documents/Crest-et-al-v-Padilla-05-13-2022.pdf https://s.wsj.net/public/resources/documents/Crest-et-al-v-P...
- kepler1 5y agoI found these points of the court's judgement noteworthy: -- If a California government action contains discriminatory classifications with the intent to reverse or compensate for discrimination, that original discrimination must be concrete, tangible, and a product of that government's other action. -- The defendant (California government) could not / did not produce any case of an identifiable woman who was discriminated against in board seat selection (according to the definitions of illegal discrimination) which would have been justification for creating legislative discrimination to reverse the harm. -- The history and debate about the Senate bill showed that the goal was not to reverse specific cases of discrimination, but to achieve the broad goal of gender parity on boards -- which is not a compelling state interest enough to justify creating discrimination. -- The state was not able to (or did not) present compelling evidence either that lack of women representation on boards is a result of discrimination, or that having women on boards is a causal factor in improved corporate performance or positive benefit to the state, which would have been necessary to claim that the legislation is constitutional. During the bill's debate and passage, none of the expert testimony or contribution to its passage was able to cite compelling research linking female board members causally to such. ---- Let me just say I am all for all for women to have more representation on boards of companies -- by each individual's interest and merit (and equally, connections) to do so. I am not in favor of legislators passing such shoddy discriminatory legislation to force it to happen because they want to see a symbol of something achieved regardless of how it happens, and glossing over what it contorts others to have to do to make it so.
- benmmurphy 5y agoI suspect if they had worded the law as boards must have a minimum number of both sexes then it would have been less likely to run into legal trouble. Such a law would have had a similar effect so it puzzles me as to why they chose the explicit discrimination option.
- robertlagrant 5y ago> “More women on corporate boards means better decisions and businesses that outperform the competition,” Atkins said in a statement. “We believe this law remains important, despite the disheartening ruling.” I don't understand this. Something being a competitive advantage is not a reason for a law.
- kennywinker 5y agoInequality is a reason for a law. The fact that it's a competitive advantage just means it's not a law that has to harm anyone in order to decrease inequality.
- chacham15 5y ago[flagged]
- kennywinker 5y ago[flagged]
- danuker 5y agoThere is a difference between equality of opportunity and equality of outcome.
- kennywinker 5y ago
- Ekaros 5y agoHmm, should we just take everyone's wealth every few years and split it evenly? After all wealth is opportunity. Hmm, or maybe set inheritance tax and gift tax to 100%. After all that is also equal opportunity.
- cm2187 5y ago> “More women on corporate boards means better decisions and businesses that outperform the competition,” Atkins said in a statement. “We believe this law remains important, despite the disheartening ruling.” If they really believe that they would let the market make it happen. It is because they don’t really believe it that they are trying to enforce it by law.
- flipbrad 5y agoPerhaps they also believe markets are imperfect, especially over the short to medium term timescales that the current and incoming generation of women (and other people who care about these things) actually care about?
- kepler1 5y agoJust because someone says that they believe in something, does that mean that they're right, and that they get to force others to do anything they want based on that belief? Including discriminating against yet others?
- kennywinker 5y agoIf you arrived at the snack table early and grabbed 10 juice boxes, and the teacher comes and takes five of them away from you and gives them to the other kids, you're not being discriminated against.
- kepler1 5y agoThank god this kind of lazy and intellectually dishonest thinking (I hesitate to call it logic) gets checked by courts in the end.
- taylorius 5y agoYes, a teacher, and the children that are in their charge. That's exactly the attitude these politicians have. How lucky we are that they know best!
- einarfd 5y agoThat's unfortunate, we've had a similar law on the books here in Norway since 2006. There where some noise about it at the beginning. But the consensus now seem to be that it is a positive.
- native_samples 5y agoBy "the consensus" you mean the press stopped reporting on objections and now tell you there's consensus? There's obviously no consensus that it's positive. It's clearly, very obviously and very badly negative. It's blatantly sexist discrimination against men who have done nothing wrong, which is deeply immoral. It also many other subtle negative effects. It degrades the language and confidence in the rule of law because these laws that make people unequal are invariably presented as "equality" laws. It also makes it impossible to respect women on boards! Everyone knows they might be there only to satisfy a legal quota, not because anyone actually respected their abilities. I've actually heard quite a few women opine that they start out suspicious of women in powerful positions these days, because they know directly how easy it is to get there on the back of feminism, but they need competent services in that moment and not a job. If you want to create anti-female sexism where none should exist, forcibly replacing men for sexist reasons is a great way to do it across the board.
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoThis sounds like you don't actually live here. I'm not a native in Norway, and what you describe isn't what I see at all. Is there a small part of the population that is against it? Sure, and there probably always will be. There is also a small population of xenophobes and racists, but they definitely aren't the majority. I've actually heard quite a few women opine that they start out suspicious of women in powerful positions these days, because they know directly how easy it is to get there on the back of feminism, but they need competent services in that moment and not a job. Just to fill you in, people are suspicious of people in powerful positions. Right now, folks that agree with you blame feminism. Previously, they'd say it was obvious that she sexed her way to the top. I'd not take any of this seriously.
- diebeforei485 5y agoShouldn't be surprising to anyone. Also it makes no sense. Why should, say, a men's health startup be forced to have women on the board?
- taylorius 5y agoThe law is to force companies to let women onto boards. That's the aim. Claiming that some study says it's better for business is just something to fire back at the "leave it to the free market" people, in case of opposition.
- SemanticStrengh 5y agoHow about we get parity quotas for enforcing the ratio of men attending university, which is crushing? The fascinating thing about those "protections" is that they mandate a ratio for women without mandating a symmetric ratio for men, which means a world where men become very underepresented would be perfectly fine according to the law. And given that neither masculinism nor egalitarianism have a sufficient number of vocal proponents, those situations will happen as they are already happening in Education. Males issues such as suicide rate, egodepletion and loneliness are skyrocketing and it will only lead to more suffering and conflict in our society. Don't be a retard, be an egalitarianist.
- taylorius 5y agoThe thing to realize is that all the "fairness logic" is made up after the fact, to rationalize the whole endeavour, and sell it to the population at large. Women want to do what men are doing, they want to be there in every vaguely high-status space, always on the scene. That's it. If a load of men get driven out of some place as a result, that's of comparatively little import.
- krageon 5y ago
- SemanticStrengh 5y ago
- honkdaddy 5y ago
- krageon 5y ago
- diebeforei485 5y agoIf California was not a one-party state, the legislature wouldn't have wasted time on passing these unconstitutional virtue-signaling laws. Good thing we have a court system and a constitution.
- SpEd3Y 5y agoCan someone help me understand why a law that mandates women on company boards (arguably the best position in the market) would be more beneficial than women being mandated into all jobs, including lower level men dominated jobs (like brick laying, plumbing, construction, metal working, etc)?
- Veen 5y agoBecause more female plumbers isn't something that middle-class college-educated women in the media and industry care about—and those are the women in a position to be heard and to influence policy.
- fortran77 5y agoAnd women don’t want these dangerous or dirty jobs.
- CJefferson 5y agoSerious answer? Because boards of companies have control over many parts of those companies. Ensuring companies have a variety of people on their boards ensure a variety of viewpoints, and make sure female issues are represented. Are there are a wide range of other viewpoints still not represented? Yes, but let's try to make progress where we can. Can men represent female issues? Of course in principle, but in my experience they often don't do well at it. There are plenty of policies, including ones where governments spend chunks of money, to get women into (as you call them) "lower level men dominated jobs", these often involve advertising, and helping people get qualified to do the job. As there are no qualifications for company boards, that type of thing wouldn't help there.
- SpEd3Y 5y agoInteresting insight. I see your point and I agree that more points of view can definitely be an asset to a company. But my concern in about mandating these jobs. I tend to disagree with you that company boards have no qualifications. I think you need a pretty impressive resume to even be considered in a company board. So programs for less prestigious jobs that can help women gain the experience and build an resume where they get the job in a non mandated way could be more viable (IMHO). I think if you start mandating these kind of jobs in the name of equality and diversity you: 1. Should mandate blue collar jobs in the name of equality and diversity as well 2. Should really make sure you have qualified and competent people to fill the jobs. Otherwise you risk filling those positions with unqualified people who, despite their best intentions, will not help the cause by under performing.
- nxm 5y agoCan it be true that the companies that have women directors do better only because they promoted the qualified ones organically and due to permit? Those that would be forced to due to quotas may not do better
- cft 5y agoAfter many years of living in San Francisco I came to the couclusion that for most CA lawmakers US constitution is a pesky nuisance. Thus both CA and the rest of the country would greatly benefit in the long term, if CA secedes.