16 ms·
Jack Dorsey says he agrees with reversing Trump's Twitter ban
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Bud 5y ago
- Eddy_Viscosity2 5y agoJack is a just another super-rich guy protecting his interests. He sees the political climate shifting hard right and is acting accordingly. Should there be another mob, he doesn't want to be on the wrong side of it.
- unsupp0rted 5y agoI don't see the political climate shifting hard right. Twitter un-banning Trump isn't an indicator of a political climate shift, although perhaps a social shift, or perhaps simply a one-off random Elon shift.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 5y ago> I don't see the political climate shifting hard right. Supreme court repealing Roe v. Wade, Don't say gay bill, restrictions of voter rights, denial of 2020 election loss among top leaders in the GOP, the list goes on... Not to even to mention the likelihood of conservatives gaining control of the senate and perhaps house in the midterms. This is what a hard right political climate shift looks like. So, the unbanning is a response to this perceived shift - to get in good with the guys will soon be in power.
- Veen 5y agoConservatism isn't a hard-right ideology.
- MacsHeadroom 5y agoHaven't you heard? The center is the right now and the right is "hard right." Clearly this indicates a political shift to the right. /s
- Eddy_Viscosity2 5y agoI agree with that. But what is happening now isn't the traditional conservatism of 'low taxes, small government'. Look what happened to Liz Chenney, a traditional conservative if anybody can be called one, when she dared to claim Biden won the election.
- lp0_on_fire 5y agoLiz Cheney belongs to the neoconservative wing of the GOP just like her father and both of the Presidents Bush. All had no compunction with growing the size of government when it came to their policy of regime change abroad.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 5y agoShe didn't get censured for her spending or foreign policies, but because she dared to say out loud that Biden won the election and that the Jan.6 insurrection was a bad thing.
- q3 5y agoTo me it seems like the opposite of a collective political shift. It's more like one individual opposing the status quo.
- mccorrinall 5y agoInnocent until proven guilty. AFAIK Trump has not been convicted of any "illegal activity" in that regard.
- Bud 5y agoHe's been proven guilty. He did it on live tv. The fact that he still has enough political power to avoid execution for sedition, or any responsibility whatsoever for this crime, does not have any effect on the truth value of my statement.
- BuyMyBitcoins 5y ago>”He's been proven guilty. He did it on live tv.” Proven guilty in the court of public perception, perhaps, but certainly not in a court of law.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lenkite 5y agoproven guilty of what ? Any evidence ?
- LightG 5y agoWe could get into the detail but I won't, it's a waste of time here. But the very denial of the election result, and all that stems from that, is enough. If you can't see that, then you're a bigger fool than most of us.
- _-david-_ 5y agoLots of people deny the 2000 election. Lots of people deny the 2016 election. Lots of people deny the 2020 election. Why is denial of 2020 worse than any of the others? Stacy Abrams is still claiming her election was stolen. Denial of elections is quite common in the US.
- theandrewbailey 5y agoI think that mob incitement is an excuse used for selective enforcement of the rules. If you're on the left, you're clearly operating under different rules: https://twitter.com/LoriLightfoot/status/1523844510735908864 https://twitter.com/LoriLightfoot/status/1523844510735908864
- ece 5y agoYeah, that's equivalent to "stand back, and stand by" /s
- gadders 5y ago
- ece 5y agoShe is talking about defending her rights in court.
- antiterra 5y agoWhere are you exactly where people say ‘call to arms’ as anything other than idiomatic call to action?
- gadders 5y agoWell I think to be fair-minded if "call to arms" is idiomatic, then you have to assume that "stand back, and stand by" is as well. You can't arbitrarily take one literally and one not. If they both idiomatic, then they are both equally harmless.
- notreallyserio 5y agoOne of those phrases is told to groups of people that regularly worships guns in public. The other is not. Context counts for a lot.
- luciusdomitius 5y agohttps://nypost.com/2022/05/10/chicagos-lori-lightfoot-urges-call-to-arms-against-supreme-court/ https://nypost.com/2022/05/10/chicagos-lori-lightfoot-urges-... One rules for me, others for thee, no? Disclaimer: Trump also made a massive mistake by suggesting what he suggested.
- originalvichy 5y agoWe have had years of these social media "who deserves to get banned" discussions. Not once has it been a good counter-argument to post someone else seemingly breaking rules getting away with it. It rarely, extremely rarely, is a response to someone who actually has power to perform moderation. It implies that the person you are replying to is somehow biased towards something or someone when in reality a) it's likely they have never heard of this counter-argument case you are linking, and b) even if they have heard about it they are not a member of SocialMediaSite's content moderation team.
- luciusdomitius 5y agoIt doesn't imply anything like that. And in case someone takes everything personally, then they must be an extremely dysfunctional person. I am an average guy looking for truth through discussion, not a clinical psychiatrist.
- h2odragon 5y agoThere's tweets calling for harming Supreme Court justices now; are those OK?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- frosted-flakes 5y agoNo, of course not, but if President Biden was making those tweets he'd fall under the same criticism as Trump, and if they continued he'd likely be banned too (sans Musk, I mean).
- cloutchaser 5y agoMayor of chicago said yesterday overturning roe vs wade is a call to arms. Still on twitter.
- kingkawn 5y agoEveryone in American politics uses fight metaphors. Not every political movement erects a gallows outside the Capitol and then breaks and enters to look for legislators and the Vice President to hang.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- belorn 5y agoNot every cause has the same effect, which is one reason why the law often looks into intent. If the speaker intend to incite violence then it's a call for violence, and if it is not then it's a metaphor. It is only by going through the context and the environment of a statement that intent can be subjectively judged.
- kingkawn 5y agoYes, we all know Trump knows how to weasel his way out of anything.
- belorn 5y agoIt goes both way. If we assume intent behind a given action that has occurred, then we apply some form of competence to the person in their ability to turn intent into action. If an action is unintentional then there is some level of incompetence in play. The bigger the outcome and the more obvious we view the action is, the bigger the incompetence from a successful defense of non-intent.
- kingkawn 5y agoIf this word salad is what we’re reduced to when trying to justify why Trump ain’t in prison…
- kyrra 5y agoThey problem is that Trump also said he wanted the protestors to be peaceful. We don't know what he intended. For you to pretend you do is nonsense. Now, where Trump is guilt is his actions after the events started. He should have within minutes been calling for it to stop and doing all he could to get police or national guard there to help. This is where I wish the impeachment investigation would have gone, sadly that was a rushed mess.
- ece 5y agoThe missing call logs say everything here don't they? To be on the phone with the police or national guard isn't going to happen on Signal.
- _-david-_ 5y agoThe lack of proof is now considered proof?
- ece 5y agoWell, Trump likely knew what he'd be culpable for, and acted accordingly. I'm not the judge though, the DOJ and it's actions will be.
- kyrra 5y agoI think you're story is outdated? See: https://www.nytimes.com/2022/02/10/us/politics/jan-6-trump-calls.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/02/10/us/politics/jan-6-trump-c... > Investigators have not uncovered evidence that any official records were tampered with or deleted, and it is well known that Mr. Trump routinely used his personal cellphone, and those of his aides, to talk with other aides, congressional allies and outside confidants, bypassing the normal channels of presidential communication. So the J6 committee just hasnt' gotten his personal phone records yet, they only had the official Whitehouse call-logs.
- ece 5y agoThe next few paragraphs hint at his culpability, the DOJ should act based on all of the evidence: > Some of the records that the Jan. 6 committee has received had been ripped to shreds and taped back together, reflecting the former president’s habit of tearing up documents. In addition, he removed more than a dozen boxes of presidential records from the White House when he left office, which the National Archives believes contained classified material, according to a person briefed on the matter.
- dwringer 5y agoI fully support suspensions, particularly in this case. However, I don't believe a permanent ban for illegal activity is ever warranted, and particularly not in cases where (unfortunately) no guilty verdict was ever given. I think it's fundamentally not an issue with right/left politics but of subtle philosophical differences over speech, society, and technology. If twitter has a certain form of monopoly on some aspect of public discourse then it's (arguably) in the public good to keep people on it by default. "Keep your friends close, and your enemies closer" kind of thinking.
- Bubble_Pop_22 5y ago
- belter 5y agoOfficial company statement at the time: "Permanent suspension of @realDonaldTrump": https://blog.twitter.com/en_us/topics/company/2020/suspension https://blog.twitter.com/en_us/topics/company/2020/suspensio... Jack Dorsey at the time: "Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey Calls Trump Ban After Deadly Riot 'the Right Decision'": https://people.com/politics/twitter-ceo-jack-dorsey-addresses-donald-trump-ban/ https://people.com/politics/twitter-ceo-jack-dorsey-addresse...
- dncornholio 5y agoPeople can't change mind?
- floatinglotus 5y agoSure. I used to respect Jack, now I’ve changed my mind.
- teekert 5y agoSo you're pro censorship? I'm more on the "I Disapprove of What You Say, But I Will Defend to the Death Your Right to Say It" -boat. Actually I though most people here would be, I'm a bit disappointed tbh.
- cosmiccatnap 5y agoThey can it's just typically called hypocrisy.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 5y agoTrump said he wouldn't go ever go back to Twitter. So this is a moot point because Trump is always honest and true to his word. /s
- dhuk_2018 5y agoWonder if they're trying to bait him away from Truth Social (his failing competitor platform)
- swores 5y agoI'd be surprised if they were remotely worried about that, seems much more likely they either believe it to be the right thing to do on principle (as claimed) - of course, whether it's the free speech principle they claim, or a pro-Trump principle, is another question - or believe that the views/engagements they get from having him on Twitter outweigh the negatives.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 5y agoNo bait is needed, Trump just needs the right excuse to backpedal and not lose face.
- Brometheus 5y agoNot even. Just ignore that you said you won't come back.
- lalos 5y agoIt is interesting how much influence Peter Thiel has on the main players of social media: via Facebook as an early investor and ex-board member and via Twitter with his ex-coworker from Paypal days Musk. He’s very explicit in his book about the power of monopolies and now you see this consolidation of social media companies under a specific group of closed people. WSJ reported Thiel being involved with Musk on this twitter deal, that plus his recent political investments in certain figures, did he figure out that they are not getting the same bang for buck with this ban in play? Dorsey has a financial interest of this deal going through, last I heard was at least 1 billion. So he’ll start saying yes to whatever pops up to let this go through and even more incentive with the recent downturn of tech stocks that are not profitable.
- natly 5y agoI doubt Thiel is some kind of central master mind behind all this. Musk seems quite independently driven and probably found this a necessary move with only minor chats with thiel (if any). I'm not sure Thiel has any more or less influence than Sam Altman or Paul Graham.
- lalos 5y agoIf someone makes you rich and successful with their business advice and you work with them for multiple years, would you ignore their phone call in the future and ignore their other suggestions? It’s not about being a master mind, there is soft power in play, humans are social animals.
- melony 5y agoIf somebody truly creates value out of thin air, then they deserve to be heard.
- throwmeariver1 5y ago
- 5y ago
- spicyusername 5y ago
- haolez 5y agoYour tone is not much different from his from my perspective (citizen of another country and I don't care about US elections).
- spicyusername 5y agoWhat does it say about the state of our ability to assess what is right or wrong that a requirement for something to be morally right is that it is said in a friendly way?
- Ensorceled 5y agoI don't think you have read much of the former president's writings or heard any of his speeches if you think this tone is "not much different".
- belter 5y agoWhat happens in the US elections, is more likely to have a bigger impact in your own country than your own country elections. Think of the major strategic implications of a pro-Russia or anti-democratic US administration for example...
- haolez 5y agoI care about US policies, of course. I just don't think that Biden is different from Trump in any way that matters in the big picture.
- hadrien01 5y agoMy anxiety when reading news online or listening to radio went noticeably down when Donald Trump was banned from Twitter, and I don't live in the US. I entirely agree with you.
- 5y ago
- lesgobrandon 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- importantmsg 5y ago
- fsloth 5y agoBefore this turns into a culture-war-fest consider this: if Twitter is to be a global platform, it probably should NOT take political sides and if it is to censor anyone permanently, it should mostly adhere to local courts and similar entities. It's not about Trump or United States. It's about everyone else. World is a really messy place. It's not very easy generally to decided if in a political conflict one or other party has moral high ground. For instance we have several Nobel peace price winners now participating in plausible genocide (Aung Sang Suu Kyi and Abiy Ahmed). Who has the moral high ground? I have no frigging idea, but I don't think an unelected corporation should decide either. If Twitter takes the side Trump is a crook and should be perma-banned, this creates a precedent for silencing the voices of opposition voices around the globe. Edit: I mean in the context if Twitter is designed to be a fair medium for anyone to express themselves. Of course it does not have to be like that and can block anyone without infringing anyones rights as such.
- lkxijlewlf 5y agoTwitter should enforce their ToS no matter who breaks them.
- dahfizz 5y agoShould twitter maintain all it's old bans if it changes it's ToS, which Musk wants to do?
- lkxijlewlf 5y agoShould twitter update it's ToS so that it doesn't have to?
- choko 5y agoTheir TOS and policies are vague enough to allow selective enforcement, which is a complaint that I've seen many times. Fewer people would take issue with Twitter (and all social media) if they were more transparent.
- ModernMech 5y ago
- ricardoplouis 5y agoIs there just a different set of free speech rules for the rich and powerful? If I incited violence on the platform, I doubt Elon or Dorsey would be letting me come back after a ban.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lkxijlewlf 5y agoYes. The rich have a different set of rules everywhere.
- haunter 5y agoYes, different rules and privileges.
- arundi2 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- einpoklum 5y ago> Is there just a different set of free speech rules for the rich and powerful? Of course there is. Twitter's owner appoint managers who hire people to oversee censorship on the platform. These choices themselves are already biased towards the owners' interests and points of view. If you add to this ability of rich and powerful people/organizations to harass or influence Twitter, the bias is even stronger. Having said that - the tweet Trump was suspended for: https://blog.twitter.com/en_us/topics/company/2020/suspension https://blog.twitter.com/en_us/topics/company/2020/suspensio... does not seem like an incitement of violence.
- hbosch 5y agoIf the president is publicly instigating toward North Korea on your platform, arguably you have the responsibility to allow people to witness what's being said. In the same way, CNN arguably has the responsibility to broadcast it if he was recorded by their cameras. It's probably not in the public interest to broadcast every person's incitations of violence or bigotry, but the president? Yes. Certainly you're not implying you should be treated exactly the same as the president of the United States...
- originalvichy 5y agoIt's not surprising that someone who sounds like a sort of free speech absolutist agrees that permanent bans are bad for the idea of free and accessible speech. The problem I have with some free speech purists is that they give me a feeling that they are persons who are more often than not unaffected by speech that can be categorised as inciting hatred towards a people, and thus they see little to no problem with being able to spread harmful bad faith speech freely on an algorithmic social media site - or any place for that matter. It's a tricky thing for which there are no real correct answers. What I do know is that socially and politically we have several unwritten rules about what, where and how to speak about things because not abiding by those rules results in things as minor as slight embarrassment to as severe as physical violence. That is to say, things can spiral out of hand and the usefulness of speech deteriorates if some standards are not kept. Twitter shouldn't be the judge of what an American president can say, because the American people should have already filtered out a person of such low integrity from gaining a position in such a high public office. All this time I've felt amused by how much our American friends can talk about what should or shouldn't Twitter do, but seemingly never discuss how they can as a society make sure that the executive office doesn't get filled by someone who brought their entire democratic process to disrepute. To conclude, I think if you aren't scared of what another Trump can do to your country or its societal fabric or your personal freedoms then I see no reason why a Dorsey doesn't think Trump should be allowed to come back. The women of his country already saw what one term of Trump did to the rights they thought they had. Not all political turmoil is scary for those who are safe from politics.
- chmod600 5y ago"The problem I have with some free speech purists is that they give me a feeling that they are persons who are more often than not unaffected by speech" There's a mirror image problem though: people in favor of regulations on speech have little reason to fear that their speech will be limited, at least in the short term. Regulators are politically-correct, so if you are politically-correct, what's the problem? (Obviously: bad things can become politically-correct, too.)
- dnissley 5y ago
- phphphphp 5y agoJack is showing that he’s unprincipled. He doesn’t shape his decisions around principles, he shapes his ostensible “principles” around his decisions. The question they (Jack, but also Elon) ask themselves is not “what’s the principled decision to make?” but “What’s best for me in this moment?” and in the moment Trump was banned, banning Trump was the best decision for Jack. And now the best decision for Jack is not to ban trump… A person without principles is a bad leader.
- nh23423fefe 5y agoImagining there exist platonic principles to be adhered to is fundamentalism, not virtue. Principles are compressed representations pointing to virtue, not things in an of themselves to be reified and held.
- phphphphp 5y agoPrinciples are not absolutes, principles can evolve. Principles are not mandatory, people can operate without principles. I am arguing that Jack (and Elon) profess to be principled people (in this case, free speech) yet Jack is clearly demonstrating a radical shift in perspective without an accompanying radical shift in principles, which must only be the sign of someone who doesn’t follow principles. How can Jack hold the same principled view today that he held 2 years ago but disavow the choices he made 2 years ago? If you compress radically different virtues you don’t get the same principles.
- causi 5y agoI don't agree with government regulation of what should or should not be in a site's code of conduct. Requiring codes of conduct to be enforced equally on all users, however, merits some thought.
- sascha_sl 5y agoBut then the entire business model becomes even less viable than it already is. Twitter and other social media have to rely on outsourced overworked and underpaid reviewers who will never have the time or training understand context (regularly receiving veiled threats[1] and not having anyone act on them made me quit twitter) and make thousands of decisions per hour. It doesn't scale any other way. [1]: https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=join%20the%2041%25 https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=join%20the%2...
- Gigachad 5y agoI think the other side of the argument has value though. If Twitter is large enough that it has such huge social impact rivalling that of governments, why should a single ceo or board be able to make these decisions. We shouldn’t be expecting or perhaps even allowing twitter to make these calls at this scale. Twitter is beyond just a private company offering a product. It’s now a serious utility.
- sc90 5y agoShould there be a Penal/Criminal Code for Social Media violations rather than indefinite bans? Edit: By the respective tech companies not something enforced by any branch of government.
- a3w 5y agoIn germany, there is. What the courts will make of those laws is still TBD. Regimes do copy these laws to put anti state opinions behind bars, though. It's hard to find a middle ground, mostly depending on culture and acceptable offenses by both believers in a message and feelings of people hurt by offensive proposals or hateful speech.
- sc90 5y agoNot government/court enforced but by the respective companies.
- a3w 5y agoSo I guess Hitler would not have been banned from Twitter under Elon Musks rule? Because inciting violence is free speech as long as someone else does the bad deeds.
- NDizzle 5y agoTake a look at the two tweets that twitter used to justify the perma ban of Trump. It's weak, at absolute best. https://blog.twitter.com/en_us/topics/company/2020/suspension https://blog.twitter.com/en_us/topics/company/2020/suspensio... On January 8, 2021, President Donald J. Trump Tweeted: “The 75,000,000 great American Patriots who voted for me, AMERICA FIRST, and MAKE AMERICA GREAT AGAIN, will have a GIANT VOICE long into the future. They will not be disrespected or treated unfairly in any way, shape or form!!!” Shortly thereafter, the President Tweeted: “To all of those who have asked, I will not be going to the Inauguration on January 20th.” Those two tweets are perma-ban worthy? I'm glad nobody has paid attention to what I typed into region chat in MMOs for the past 20 years...
- jwond 5y agoWow, I didn’t realize those were the tweets he was banned for. That blog post includes some pretty twisted mental gymnastics to try and explain how those tweets justify their decision.
- NDizzle 5y agoCorrect. I'm glad I reached at least one person before I am downvoted to flagged for pasting twitter's own reasoning. Again.
- ModernMech 5y agoYou're leaving out the fact that those tweets were sent two days after an insurrection in which Trump used Twitter to target the Vice President with a mob. In the days thereafter, Trump was being urged to cool things down because tensions were still red hot. Instead, he refused to back off the very narrative that got people fired up enough to literally assault our democratic process. There was a legitimate worry that he was still using Twitter to signal to his supporters (who again, had just sacked the capitol) that they should attack the inauguration of Joe Biden next. That was the real and legitimate concern at the time. How many insurrections are you willing to let Trump coordinate on your platform? Two? More?
- 5y ago
- stillbourne 5y agoI think moderation is at the discretion of the content provider. I endorse banning Trump and I also endorse unbanning Trump. That's how the first amendment works.
- titzer 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bonestamp2 5y ago> There is no need for Twitter to signal-boost the idiotic shit this person says. This is an important point. They could let him back without boosting his voice. In general, whether it's Trump or not, if the algorithm could boost fact checked statements only, that would be a win. I think both sides need better exposure to the facts that are typically not seen in their echo-chambers. We need to separate politics and facts if we want to sew this country back together. Facts are apolitical.
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoFirst thing when i open the webpage, is them asking me for my email address Seriously, web developers, stop it!
- tomlin 5y agoYou mean marketers. Marketers have become developer's bosses in a lot of agencies.
- vlunkr 5y agoSeems like they're making slightly different arguments. Dorsey is saying it was wrong to permenantly ban, rather than suspend Trump. He's also saying it was a business decision, and it shouldn't have been. Honestly I don't know what that means. Every decision Twitter makes is a business decision. He violated the rules repeatedly and got away with it, I think it was absolutely the right choice.
- s1artibartfast 5y ago>He's also saying it was a business decision, and it shouldn't have been. Honestly I don't know what that means. It means the decision was driven by which option drives higher profit, and not a moral position.
- tomlin 5y agoHonestly, this whole "Elon Musk is the enemy" narrative has to take a self-reflection. "Current Twitter" – the one that is supposingly the angel of protecting the will of the people – got Trump elected. Full stop. Trump's tweets were promoted by Twitter. So in the life time of Twitter, "Current Twitter" wants to take credit for the last 5 seconds? Good luck with that.
- mattbrewsbytes 5y agoA ban on a web site is usually driven by one or more violations of Terms of Service. Some of those Terms of Service are linked to criminal laws and the company wants to protect itself from being prosecuted, liable to damages, etc. I dislike the use of the words "freedom of speech" when it comes to social media/web sites because uneducated people seem to think a ban is a violation of the 1st US amendment. Which is even sillier when a website allows users globally. I doubt the conversations will suddenly change to "freedom to violate ToS" but I feel like there is a better wording than "freedom of speech". If a camping website banned content about Bigfoot because they wanted to and you posted something about Bigfoot and got banned, its not a freedom of speech issue, its more like a "No Shirt, No, Shoes = No Service" issue.
- sascha_sl 5y agoLet's be completely honest. Twitter bans people based on metrics and 1-2 seconds of review per report (possibly by a human!). Trump got the white glove treatment of actually evaluating his compliance with the TOS, likely with an actual lawyer involved too.
- Gigachad 5y agoFreedom of speech is just a loose concept. The first amendment is an implementation of freedom of speech. It’s still accurate for a business to say they support and implement freedom of speech even if they are not legally obligated to.
- SilverBirch 5y agoHonestly, this entire thing is ridiculous. The logic behind Dorsey's comment on this is essentially "I don't think Trump should've been banned for his actions but I didn't feel comfortable saying so at the time. So I banned him, waited for the fuss to die down, and now I'm going to change my mind because I've got political cover". The only good thing I think that will come from this deal is that Musk will be direct about his absurd position where Dorsey was two-faced. It's absolutely wild to see Dorsey essentially publicly admit that he disagreed with most of his own decisions running twitter.
- ece 5y agoHe's getting a billion dollars out of this, maybe that's playing a part too, to lend Musk some additional cover. Look, even the guy who banned him thinks differently now.
- ck2 5y agoI mean that was the whole reason Musk bought twitter, you will never convince me otherwise. But are there things that can get you banned on the "new" twitter? Because then any concern about unbanning him and similar is a moot point because they will be banned again within a month or two as long as rules are enforced. However I am dubious rules will be enforced. I think everything is going to be "nudge nudge wink wink".
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- thunkshift1 5y agoTell him to focus on square.. looks like he isn’t happy being out of the limelight and wants back at twitter
- ljw1001 5y agoTwitter is in the outrage business. What’s not to like?
- ddingus 5y agoI agree with reversing the ban.[1] Right along with many others. Frankly, permabans really need thinking through. At a minimum, multiple bans, or feature limits should precede them, and there should be required process associated with a permanent ban, including appeals. That may seem excessive and or burdensome. I agree. Small venues that do not come with considerable life implications can and should be exempt. Big venues are making plenty of money, or have the means to do that, and are interwoven with society to a degree worth the effort. In general, the cancel moves we see rising in prominence are not answers in themselves. Trump sucks. Alex Jones sucks, and arguably more! Banning them was not helpful. It does feel good to those who dislike their speech, but it had near zero impact on others who value and seek more of their speech. Closing the door hard luke that hardens those people, who then present notable resolve to follow a favored speaker and or act on their behalf.[0] What is does not do is open them up to receive remedial speech of any kind. Having the media then attack these people, often speaking for them, is not a good look particularly given the level of error (and I am being charitable) in their own speech, often labeled authoritative. Again, despite considerable error. Finally, we have and will continue to see this abused to silence both critics and competing speech. This speech is both necessary and prior to massive media consolidation, considered normal, healthy behavior in a functioning democracy. I should also mention there is a shared burden related to speech we do not like and that burden lies with any of us and how we choose to respond to speech we do not like. That offense can be gamed is a problem too. People are as offended as they think they are and the basis for said offence varies widely. A claim of profound offence can be made and others have very little to validate it with. At a minimum, responding to speech we do not like with righteous indignation generally escalates the dialog into unproductive meta. Almost any other response will fare better. Other responses include: humor, questions, rebuttals, redirects, reconsideration... any of which can take a conversation t9 a productive, far less harmful place. Emphasis on how we all manage incoming speech would do a lot of good, rather than the ongoing harm being used to cast the idea of free speech aside and or solidify some entities as authorities, sans meaningful checks on their speech, which also gets abused. The most common abuse is manufacturing consent. [0] Source is behavior observed in a fair number of people who fall into one or more categories implied by my comment. [1] That is not an endorsement of any kind.
- upsidesinclude 5y agoIt is baffling that people think a person should be permanently banned from access to any "public forum", which Twitter has become. To the people deriding Trump, you do recognize that no actual criminals are prevented from excersing speech? Even if you believe he is a criminal, the law of this country does not agree. You dislike him, great. You don't get to remove everything that you disagree with from a public forum. To the ideologues believing that Republicans are destroying 'democracy', recall that this country is a constutional republic and the reason is because pure democracy, or majority rule, degrades to mob rule. To not make the mistake of equating freedom with democracy. Not all votes are equal! What blasphemy! Not all people are engaged, informed and care about preserving the sovereignty of the nation. We have a system designed to keep those people from destroying our liberty. The system allows the people to pick representatives who are sworn by oath to act as an informed and engaged agent on their behalf. Our duty is to try our best to pick those agents that will put aside their interests and live by their oath.
- LightG 5y agoOh Lord ... The last couple of years have been a breath of fresh air ... The only time I notice Trump now is from his loser supporters posting Shorts on Youtube believing he'll make a come back. Anyone who believes that taking him off twitter didn't stabilise the political temperature is in la la land.