14 ms·
Neoliberalism has resulted in preference for greater income inequality
- mindvirus 5y agoThat may be, but the other side of this is that global poverty has never been lower [1]. I think both absolute and relative poverty are important to consider, but generally the direction the world is going with respect to poverty is good. The example questions they ask reflect a pretty superficial and biased view in my opinion: “We need larger income differences as incentives for individual effort” and “Incomes should be made more equal." Versus perhaps the neoliberal framing (also biased) of "we should incentive people to take risks" and "fewer people living in poverty is more important than income distribution". 1. https://ourworldindata.org/extreme-poverty https://ourworldindata.org/extreme-poverty
- next_xibalba 5y ago> I think both absolute and relative poverty are important to consider I would be interested to learn your (or others) thoughts on why relative poverty is important. I've thought frequently, but probably superficially, about this quite a bit over the years. Many people who are considered impoverished in the U.S. are: obese (AKA not hungry), housed, and have a smart phone and cable TV. It is very hard to wrap my mind around their "hardship" when we have real world examples of people in other places who lack all of these things. My mind, likely due to my own biases, tends to conclude that it is a function of a country that has become too wealthy and thus abstracted away from the resources and efforts that created and sustain that wealth–natural resources, rule of law and due process, hard work, training and experience, risk taking, innovation and creativity, etc etc. Is relative poverty important simply as a system feature that elevates political risk? Or is there something more tangible in terms of human need that I miss?
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoThat's really applying stereotypes to a huge swathe of people and I think you should seriously review your biases and stereotypes. You are saying a lot of people are obese and not hungry; what about the ones that can only manage to afford shit like dry pasta? Housed, what about the over half a million homeless? What about the ones that aren't technically homeless but live couch to couch, in a van, or with family even though they have a family of their own? And what about the ones that can hardly make rent every month, let alone never have a chance at home ownership? The smartphone thing is moot; they can be cheap, and they cost a fraction of, say, a month of rent. The "you have a smartphone so you can't be poor" line is just dumb. There's a lot of whataboutism as well, i.e. "what about these other people who have it worse"; it's not like it's one or the other. There's wealth inequality, and there's poverty in many forms - poverty that seems intentional and avoidable. The solution? It's not easy, but raise the minimum wage, tackle the housing crisis; fix the health care system and make it affordable for everyone; tax the rich and do a Robin Hood, or at least fix the infrastructure, reduce the decades long exorbitant spending on the army in favor of health care, public health and education. And I think all of these can be made to work together with this neoliberalism thing. It just requires some people to give up some of their privileges.
- next_xibalba 5y agoMy greater point is about the definition of poverty and perceptions therof. In the past, poverty was defined as lack of access to the basic necessities of life: food, water, and shelter. That definition has expanded in scope quite dramatically. You say there are 500k in the U.S. that are unsheltered, and I would agree that, yes, those people most certainly fit the classic definition of poverty. But the U.S., according the U.S. Census Bureau, has 38 million people living under the poverty line. > can only manage to afford shit like dry pasta Go tell someone who is starving to death in Yemen or South Sudan how having access to dry pasta is the equivalent of real poverty. I'm sure they would correct you had they the energy. > The smartphone thing is moot; You only underscore my point. You take having a smartphone (a product of the Neoliberal system) so for granted that you believe it is "dumb" to point it out. A smartphone would have appeared as God's Real Magic 100 years ago. It is one of the most powerful tools ever built by mankind. > There's a lot of whataboutism as well, You literally "what about" multiple times in your own reply. Raising the minimum wage will result in fewer people getting jobs. This is accepted as fact by economists. As for your other prescriptions, they amount to, "Just do it." In other words, they are equally naive or uninformed. These are intractable problems in ultra complex systems that do not have easy or obvious solutions. For example, you write, "fix the health care system and make it affordable for everyone". Please do explain how to do this. But in your reply, please make sure to show your work. For instance, what are the trade-offs to a single payer healthcare system? Talk to any Briton over a pint and they will enumerate a long list of cons to their healthcare system, some of them very serious. When it comes to ultra complex systems, when one pulls one lever, a thousand others move, often in unexpected ways.
- mindvirus 5y agoYes, I think both are important. On fixing absolute poverty - it means children and adults don't starve to death or die of treatable diseases. Hopefully it's self evident why it's important to solve. On relative poverty - it means equal opportunity. The gap in life expectancy between the richest and the poorest is like 10 years. The lowest quartile has the least income mobility, and still struggles to have more access to quality food, health care, education. And that lack of mobility concentrates wealth and reduces generating wealth which leaves society as a whole poorer.
- ricardobeat 5y agoAre global averages meaningful to look at, though? You could have millions lifted out of poverty in countries that are becoming more developed, counterbalancing changes elsewhere, without neoliberal policies being correlated. In Brazil, extreme poverty was reduced by 75% during a decade of a left-wing, welfare focused government, and then promptly went up again as soon as neoliberal (not exactly, but close enough for the purpose of this argument) politicians came back to power. And the averages didn’t improve either - quality of life has deteriorated for everyone else too.
- kanduri 5y ago75% of global poverty reduction has been due to China lifting over 800 million people. The real number is even higher if you account for Vietnam, Laos and Cuba. Then there are also many nations that don't classify themselves explicitly as government-planned economies where the public sector plays a huge role in providing a wide breadth of basic services to the people, rather than the private markets doing so. So virtually all of the poverty alleviation has happened when governments have prioritized access to basics (housing, education, healthcare, public transport, pensions, wage regulations, utilities like power/water/sewerage, etc) to the common people rather than leave it up to "market forces". Institutions that represent the interests of people using state budgets for inclusive policy have a much bigger role in poverty alleviation, by creating an environment of fair opportunity for the poor, than explicit deregulation/privatization. Source: https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2022/04/01/lifting-800-million-people-out-of-poverty-new-report-looks-at-lessons-from-china-s-experience https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2022/04/01/l...
- gruez 5y ago>75% of global poverty reduction has been due to China lifting over 800 million people. The real number is even higher if you account for Vietnam, Laos and Cuba. Then there are also many nations that don't classify themselves explicitly as government-planned economies where the public sector plays a huge role in providing a wide breadth of basic services to the people, rather than the private markets doing so. You can also make the opposite argument by pointing out China's growth only really got started with Deng's market liberalization reforms, which did the opposite of what you described.
- kanduri 5y agoThe government guaranteed access to the basics to the masses. It made money via the market liberalization policies. I was talking about how governments using their budgets for inclusive policies can have a much more impactful role in poverty reduction. In other nations where the governments don't take these proactive role, people are at the mercy of market forces for everything, including basics needed for survival. Topic on how governments can make money via global trade is a different thread of discussion. This one pertains on how the public sector can/should use their power to empower the underprivileged.
- BirAdam 5y agoNeoliberalism hasn’t actually been the world order at all, but rather soft fascism in which government and corporation walk hand in hand. If you add to this the cartelization of global banking, the situation starts to look more like neo-feudalism. I would hasten to say that there has never and will likely never be a “neoliberal” world order; people in power don’t typically just give up their power. Also, don’t start an article with words like “findings” and then use the article to spout your own moral values.
- VictorPath 5y agoYes, this idea of neoliberalism and free market reforms has meant corporations getting more government involvement in the economy. Eliminating market barriers to promote competition is mythical, it has been the opposite - most industries are oligopolies. Look at the 40 billion that Congress just pushed to give to US military contractors en route of some of the output to Ukraine (supported by the Squad, opposed by some Trump friendly Republicans). This has been modus operandi of US pumping taxpayer money into corporations since World War II. Biden had diplomats go to Venezuela to get oil and pull back Monroe Doctrine US military operations down there as its shifting military operations from around Venezuela to the western border of Russia.
- VictorPath 5y agoA lot of the framework is tautological. Income for work, that he receives more money for an hour of labor than him, has always been of minor concern to people who have not bought into the neoliberal system. It's a concern for some at the top of the system. Social relations between those who work and the heirs who expropriate surplus labor time from those who work might be more of a concern. I don't know what market friendly psychological tendencies are or free-market reforms. Large corporations have instituted reforms to quash the market. Don't rely on me, Warren Buffett, Peter Thiel and others have said the same thing. Industries are oligopolies from music (Universal controls more than half of US music) to breakfast cereals. I am not sure what a free market is, in the Soviet Union people were free to go to a small market owned by the proprietor and buy potatoes or radishes with rubles, just like in the UK (with pounds) or US (dollars). So what is a free market? Or are they talking about control of the commanding heights of the forces of production? But that is not a market. Also a country can be run by FDR and he says a New Deal economy is good and this idea is promoted from the top. It can be run by Reagan, with control of the media becoming consolidated and corporatized, and promoting another view if the economy. It is no surprise if all people hear 24/7 from people from Bush to the Clinton's how great so called free trade agreements etc. are that more will echo that sentiment. The reality is working people have been and are resistant to these economic agreements which harm them, relative to the opinion of the decision makers.
- cameronh90 5y agoProbably true but "preference" almost feels like a loaded word. I suspect few people want inequality directly, but it's a means to an end. Looking throughout history, extreme inequality, while unfair for most people, still achieves some useful progress. All attempts for a perfectly equal economy, that I'm aware of, have ended in disaster. Sometimes horrifically. For that reason, I think it's fair to see some level of income inequality as a necessary evil until someone can convincingly demonstrate otherwise.
- mola 5y agoI would go further than the article and say neoliberalism is optimizing for income inequality. I would also point out that the dichotomy you talk about: neoliberalism vs equal economy is false . Modern Social democracies don't optimize for perfect equality, they try to strike a balance between market forces and humane values. They reject the neoliberal idea that perfect markets are morally correct.
- cameronh90 5y agoI'm not sure any economy is fully behind what you describe as neoliberalism though? Even the USA has welfare, tax and many other not purely Laissez-faire institutions. You'll note that I never even actually argued for neoliberalism. I think social democracies are far better than unfettered neoliberal capitalism. However, I think the way that people answered those questions is completely compatible with social democracy too. They never asked do you want inequality and perfect markets above all else. Modern social democracy is much closer to neoliberalism than it is to communism or even 70s style socialism. One way or interpreting these poll results is that living under a neoliberal world order has increased support for inequality because people are, on the whole, happy with how it changed their lives. Sure, some rich people are absurdly, unfairly rich, but in many ways the average person's life drastically improved from the 70s to now at far quicker rate than ever before in history. Perhaps many people accept that increased inequality is a fair price to pay for the way they feel life has improved? Certainly speaking for myself, I don't particularly care that Elon Musk is so rich that he could buy every superyacht in the world, provided that I have all my basic needs met and the economic resources to try and achieve what makes me happy. I'm not jealous of the wealth of others. Looking at what happened to my family under the economic policies of the 70s in the UK, I am pretty glad to have grown up in the 90s. I'm aware that not everyone is as lucky as me to have all their basic needs met. I think that's a great shame and as far as inequality goes, I think it's fine if someone is 100000x as wealthy as someone else PROVIDED THAT person on the bottom has a house, food, heating, healthcare etc. which certainly is not the case right now. Ultimately, I'd prefer to be the poorest well fed person in Britain rather than starving in the same boat with everyone else.
- posix86 5y agoIsn't... isn't that the core idea of liberalism? Letting people do their thing? Which, naturally, leads to some people getting more than others? What am I missing?
- andrepd 5y agoMe grabbing a gun and a baseball bat and terrorising the neighbourhood into paying me protection money is "me doing my thing" which "leads to some people getting more than others". Yet it's hardly Liberalism (at least as understood in the classical sense of the term, not sure about current "neoliberalism" :))
- LatteLazy 5y agoMETA I'm seeing more and more political pieces like this here. There was a similar piece yesterday about privilege and inequality. What's the limit here before we just turn into Reddit?
- andrepd 5y agoI'd say economics is inside the purview of hn.
- moolcool 5y agoI think that it's really important for knowledge workers to think about these kinds of things. We (the HN target audience) are in one of the most lucrative professions in the world, and I think it's easy to lose perspective as a result.
- refurb 5y agoIncome inequality decreases significantly during recessions. Check out the wealth owned by by the top 1% during the latest recessions. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WFRBST01134 https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WFRBST01134 Would anyone argue that the situation of the poor got better during this time?
- 1ncorrect 5y agoNeoliberalism overwhelmingly rewards self interested behaviour, explicitly at the expense of cooperative and altruistic counterparts, which iteratively nurtures disproportionate sociopathic tendencies in those who thrive in the system. It’s often posited that the solution is to replace it wholesale with something else entirely, but I’ve argued for some time that it’s best to be subjected to a counterbalance in the form of a competing system that rewards cooperation and altruism at least equally. My thesis is neoliberalism, in the way it rewards self interested behaviour closely aligns with valuing optimisation, which in turn requires quantifiable resources with which to precisely measure performance, namely those intrinsically finite. Long story short, this boils down to basically energy and time, a lay explanation I’ve used is anything that intersects with E=mc^2. An example of a resource that’s abundant, or at least not intrinsically finite, is information. The way this is currently incorporated into our value systems is through artificial scarcity constructs, namely copyright and patents. These mechanisms incentivise locking them up as tightly as possible, manifesting as greater sociopathy. An alternate would directly value the breadth and depth of an idea’s use, the scarce component being the links between the ideas, and amplify the incentive for the idea to be used and made as widely available as possible, rewarding collaboration and altruism. I see it as basically Page Rank applied to the current scope of copyright and patents. Funding for payments would be an additional or modified source currently used by entities who hold sovereignty over their currency, and I’d argue would require much less abstraction from the realised value than existing debt and interest mechanisms.
- lobocinza 5y agoThe issue is with cronyism and not liberalism. I read this preference for inequality as: in countries with rampant cronyism and social divisions economical freedom isn't able to lift everyone but just a few that have connections to the people in power. That isn't to say that economical freedom makes the poorest more poor. Look at this list of countries by equality. https://inequality.org/facts/global-inequality/ https://inequality.org/facts/global-inequality/
- fedeb95 5y agothe study is interesting, but it's wrong to infer causation. you don't have data about what people thought back in the 70s, so it may as well be that economy got shaped in order to reflect what people were already thinking in term of values
- randomcarbloke 5y agoincome inequality isn't necessarily bad, "neoliberalism" has lifted millions out of poverty, and poverty as an absolute value is what actually matters.
- modo_mario 5y agoWould you consider China (which has done a great deal of padding that poverty statistic) neoliberal? I'd say they have a mix of market practices that both benefit from free global trade and at the same time is quite protectionist in a number of ways and i wouldn't exactly define it as neoliberal.
- randomcarbloke 5y agoactually global poverty without china follows the exact same trend. But China's adoption of market practices absolutely has a bearing on their own poverty reduction, then again, I doubt china's figures can be trusted since they've consistently misrepresented economic data for at least two and a half decades.
- motohagiography 5y agoWhat if we just decline income equality as a meaningful or valuable ideal at all? Full income equality is not a viable or desirable outcome, and it seems like a distraction from solvable problems like political and institutional corruption - paid for out of funds collected under the pretext of policies to combat said inequality. The word and concept is even a second order artifact of the belief in a zero-sum human economy, and an idea whose goal is to centralize power and resources into the very institutions whose corruption it moralizes. The Gini coefficient is no better than a horoscope, and arguably, "income inequality" isn't meaningful as a thing. What is more plausible? That most of the people who take risks to build businesses do so from an exploitative and evil urge, or that a few performers like Piketty, Varafoukis, Krugman and the Greek chorus of lazy ideologues who talk, write, and flatter for a living are self dealing? The word itself is a begged question, and accepting its negative definition as a premise makes any logic built on that idea seem internally consistent because it will always sound "good" because it is "against bad." Merely being anti-bad is not even rationally ethical, it just means one has been folded into a mob that doesn't actually believe anything - they're just against the representation of a bad thing. It's easier to believe than accepting we've been tricked, but please, enough.
- BlargMcLarg 5y agoThe fundamental problem is wealth having a high correlation or even causation with power. At any point in time, very little keeps a neutral or even benevolent elite from turning malevolent. At that point, you're stuck with the populace willing to shed sweat, tears and blood to fight back. We also tend to select on relative fitness, and both wealth and power contribute pretty strongly towards fitness. You can educate people to look past this, but it's pretty difficult to get individuals to look past their basic instincts even after training them to do so their entire childhood. You can change society to minimize the negative effects, but society can lose knowledge and trend the other way over time. If it was just "well more income for everyone means less people in poverty", yes, it would be useless. But that's not what is happening.
- pclmulqdq 5y agoWhy don't we attempt to strip the power from wealth rather than attempting to take people's wealth away? The fact that wealth and power are correlated has a lot to do with the fact that we have these hugely complicated legal systems with a lot of gray areas. The wealthier you are, the more you can afford to look for loopholes. What if we took an axe to the codes of laws and closed the loopholes? What if we stripped certain offices of power so that there wasn't much benefit to corruption? Humanity has built systems that give the wealthy power, but we don't have to design them this way.
- chiefalchemist 5y ago> Neoliberalism, which also calls for greater privatization and deregulation, has become the predominant global socioeconomic framework since the late 1970s. Why should the results be of any surprise. If these are the rules, those most able to play the game are going to benefit most from those rules. I believe that's the intention. Fair enough. The failure comes from greed. It not the collecting of resources per se. It's the lack of fair and equitable sharing. Oddly enough, for the most part, the proles idolize, if not worship the winners (as opposed to challenging their greed and demanding fairness).
- zephrx1111 5y agoIs neoliberalism just an alias of conservatism?
- eternalban 5y ago> Overall, the analysis showed that in countries in which there was a higher-than-average level of neoliberalism, as measured by the “Economic Freedom Index,” there were also subsequent higher-than-average levels of preference for income inequality. > “Our results suggest that a few years is sufficient for—as Thatcher put it—systems to change ‘souls,’ ” concludes Goudarzi. You thought that the "system" may have the side effect of concentrating mass media (aka the mechanism to 'grab souls') in a few monied hands, which in turn after decades of directed media assault on values would shift them, but no, it is in fact "the neo-liberal free market" that magically shifts values.
- emteycz 5y agoNeoliberalism calls for elimination of social services? I know it as the exact opposite! Who defines these terms? Who defines what is canonical?
- baisq 5y agoLiberalism and neoliberalism have always been about the rights of the individual above everything else. But the concept of "liberal" has been perverted in America.
- usrn 5y agoThe idea of a "political compass" helps. The left has two groups: authoritarians who want to replace culture with something secular and have strong social services and government regulation, and the liberals who want to reject culture and let people do what they want. The right also has two groups: the conservatives who want the government to enforce our culture and the libertarians who want to be left alone. For the past ~100 years we've found consensus between the liberals and libertarians but everyone is radicalizing away from that. So we still think of liberals as being the leftward movement and libertarians as being the rightward one.
- nicoburns 5y agoDoesn't the political compass usually use the label "authoritarian" and "libertarian" for both the left and right? There's nothing about being libertarian that is inherently right-wing (in particular if you generalise the logic of "big government bad" to "any large powerful organisation including governments, corporations, and individuals bad" then you end up with a very much left-wing position).
- robertlagrant 5y agoI've never heard government bad being described as left wing. Which left wing organisation would say that?
- throwaway787544 5y agoWhen you suggest that reducing taxes and eliminating regulations might hurt the most vulnerable, they have two responses: 1) no way, it would only help them because the market is perfect!, 2) who cares? the poor need to get a job! People like neoliberalism for the same reason they like fascism: people want to believe in a utopia that mirrors their values. Belief is a hell of a drug.
- alfor 5y agoWe know there are problem on both sides: Too big and powerful government = corruption and inefficiencies Too big and powerful corporation = corruption and inefficiencies I prefer going more toward the free market as corporation are in competition and that force some accountability that we don’t see in the government. Keep the government small and nimble, mostly as a control mechanism for corporation that become corrupt and monopolistic. Read Atlas Shrugged if you want to see the opposite of your point of view.
- throwaway787544 5y agoCorporations are accountable to their bank statements and Governments are accountable to people. Except when the opposite is true. The real world is complicated and generalizations don't pan out. Neither do philosophies rooted on generalizations.
- baisq 5y agoLower taxes is not a utopia, it's perfectly feasible, unless you think that you owe something to the poor just for existing.
- mcv 5y agoYour taxes could go to help the poor, or to police them. Both cost money.
- throwaway787544 5y agoSo you're a #2 :)
- christophilus 5y ago> Institutions can promote well-being and solidarity, or they can encourage competition, individualism, and hierarchy. Why is this presented as an either / or?
- go13 5y agoAs if 'competition, individualism, and hierarchy' is bad. Well, somebody has to work hard, compete and provide to those who want to enjoy well-being and solidarity. In the meantime, the left wants to use this as a selling point to abuse the power and be the one in control without paying the hard price of working hard and taking risk.
- ixtli 5y agoThey are mutually exclusive. Solidarity is the opposite of individualism.
- mordae 5y agoBecause they are mutually exclusive. Competition, individualism and hierarchy will make sure that the ruthless will end up on top of the hierarchy, caring only about their individual needs, squashing attempts at solidarity and squandering opportunities to have any kind of well-being for others.
- christophilus 5y agoCompetition is like eating. It’s an important part of everything that life touches. Whether or not it’s healthy is entirely contextual. A study which puts competition into the category “bad” is starting off with a highly questionable assumption. Same for individualism. I’m not a fan of hierarchy, and tend to see it as more bad than good, but even hierarchy isn’t one or the other. It’s contextual.
- carschno 5y agoThe assumption that "competition [...] is an important part of everything that life touches" seems at least as questionable.
- lr4444lr 5y agoPeople throw around that word "Neoliberalism" as if its meaning is self-evidently clear. The author cites three elements of it, only one of which (free market capitalism) I've seen consistently used, but that isn't even something that began in the era most commonly ascribed to the ascendency of this doctrine. Just what preceded "Neoliberalism" so that we can distinguish its full defining feature set?
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoIt is a defined economic term and has scientific papers detailing its inadequacy
- goatlover 5y agoAs opposed to some alternative economics which doesn't have inadequacies?
- noelsusman 5y agoSuch as? There are half a dozen definitions being used in this thread already, none of which really overlap with each other.
- luciusdomitius 5y agoBefore that was Classical Liberalism. At least in US and Western Europe. In Eastern Europe it was something officially called "Unimplemented Communism/Developed Socialism".
- School-Cotton 5y agoWhat is the main difference between classical liberalism and neoliberalism?
- AstralStorm 5y agoRegressive taxation and pro-corporate rather than pro-small business stance. Classical liberalism also is fine with public spending.
- ramblerman 5y agoThe question on the survey was "We need larger income differences as incentives for individual effort" vs “Incomes should be made more equal.” But the ridiculously biased title pretends that people who picked the first option just want income inequality for no good reason, and are somehow brainwashed by neoliberal institutions.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoHeadline: nazis want to kill minorities Comment: the actual question was: 'We need to kill minorities to make more living space for our people' But the ridicilously biased title pretends thay people who picked the first option just want death for no good reason, and are somehow brainwashed by nazi institutions! Every action ever has some reasoning behind it, from you buying coffee to Russia's invasion to Hitler's genocide - Lebensraum. The propaganda succeeds when false reasoning has been accepted without questioning it
- ramblerman 5y agoStraight to Nazis huh... Context matters. People might support a free market where they can excel and see their hard work rewarded. That isn't quite the same as wanting income equality. It's a 2nd order effect of the first desire.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoThats the point i was illustrating - the argument 'people have their reasons' is not a good one. Also is hard work rewarded when top 3 predictora of sucess are family wealth, school and connections? You want a real free market, set 100% inheritance tax. You could probably abolish all other taxes with it.
- Dracophoenix 5y agoHow does a 100% inheritance tax create a free market?
- 5y ago
- yyy888sss 5y agoLiberalism means freedom in all spheres (including economically and socially), no need to add the neo- prefix. When you have freedom in a global economy there will be massive income inequality (think about Lebron James or Elon Musk vs the average person) but everyone is better off. Technology allows the best athletes to entertain millions, and the best entrepreneurs to serve billions.
- orta 5y ago"Neoliberalism" is a specific term for the conceptual forms of capitalism the west has been under since the 70-80s: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neoliberalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neoliberalism
- yyy888sss 5y agoBut the 'neo' refers to the resurgence of basic ideas of freedom, not a big change in philosophy over the original liberal ideas.
- lupire 5y agoSpecifically, neoliberalism was a created to return to the Roaring 20s to rollback the post-Great Depression attempts at economic stability. Less sardonically, neoliberalism is classical liberalism in the 20th Century but with an 18th Century perspective that ignores the oppressive potential of corporations that are more powerful than nations. Neoliberals have a hard time figuring how to hold "corporate persons" accountable for their violence against humanity and our environment, because they never cared to solve the problem of dilution of responsibility.
- noworld 5y agoInteresting, freedom to do what?
- yyy888sss 5y agoFreedom to do whatever you want as long as it does not infringe the rights/freedoms of anyone else.
- incomingpain 5y agoThe phase of politics we have entered is the post-culture wars. It's no longer red vs blue. It's wealth redistribution vs not. "Pay my college tuition loans!" or "give me $ for a new ev car" But break down what that means? The predominantly rich are who get into those ivy league schools and rack up giant student loans. You're planning to pay off rich kids loans? Anyone who already paid off the loans gets nothing? People who didn't go to university gets nothing? Also how's that money printing going? 8.5% inflation and still rising... You want more of that? Lets go further. Let's just imagine we decide to reset. They print a million $ per person and everyone gets it. Everyone is back to equality. Inflation will obviously blow up and find some equilibrium eventually. We eliminate all debt. What happens? The poor will burn that million so fast. It's the mentality of the psyche, no different than a dog who eats their food as fast as possible fearing they might lose it. The rich take the million and buy as much investments as possible right away. In a couple years we go check on how things are doing... the rich are rich. the poor are poor. Nothing changes. People need to understand that money doesn't work this way. Want to eliminate inequality? Teach people to not be poor, teach them to bust their butt doing something useful to society.
- hamter 5y ago> The predominantly rich are who get into those ivy league schools and rack up giant student loans. You're planning to pay off rich kids loans? that one's gonna need a citation lol. > Also how's that money printing going? 8.5% inflation and still rising... You want more of that? ask the corporations that are posting record profits in spite of this inflation > The poor will burn that million so fast. It's the mentality of the psyche, no different than a dog who eats their food as fast as possible fearing they might lose it. break out the calipers boys > The rich take the million and buy as much investments as possible right away. wait i thought we were getting inflation that makes the million meaningless > In a couple years we go check on how things are doing... the rich are rich. the poor are poor. Nothing changes. People need to understand that money doesn't work this way. Want to eliminate inequality? Teach people to not be poor, teach them to bust their butt doing something useful to society. real rich dad / poor dad hours here
- 5y ago
- jdthedisciple 5y ago> Neoliberalism has resulted in preference for greater income equality is I think a misguided conclusion from what the survey actually asked. Just because one of the side effects of having more freedom is that many people will choose not to use that freedom - while a few will totally successfully use it - doesn't mean that that is my preferred outcome. I could prefer to have freedom and also prefer to have everyone use that freedom to their best benefit so that everyone is better off. It's just that that isn't what usually happens (mostly due to human nature). In other words I could just as well say this (don't even need a survey for that): Socialism results in preference for less freedom.
- m000 5y ago"Everyone": Go tell the homeless sleeping under the bridge to praise the Lord we don't have socialism, or they would end up in those nasty Khrushchyovkas.
- mrep 5y agoDidn't the soviets send people who didn't work to prison and then forced them to do hard labor?
- mordae 5y ago> mostly due to human nature Citation needed. Seriously, are you sure you are not mixing up free market conditioning with nature? Check out Dawn of Everything.
- jdthedisciple 5y agoOkay I didn't wanna go into that discussion: I don't think the true reasons are crucial for my argument here.
- imapeopleperson 5y agoFree markets will always remain the most fair system of resource allocation. Any other system requires an uninvolved power, likely a govt, to decide. Who gets to live in the 56 Leonard PH?
- ixtli 5y agoThis is the neoliberal ideology they are talking about, yes :)
- kuschku 5y agoA free market necessarily requires government involvement. A free market is industry-specific. For it to work, a company in one industry may not influence the market in a different industry, or that market won’t be free anymore. To prevent this, government involvement is required to ensure fair start conditions for all companies within of the free market
- cameronh90 5y agoWhile a free market economy requires government involvement, one must admit it requires less than an economy that tries to ensure equality. I also suspect the more you leave an economy to its own devices, the more unequal it becomes.
- maxerickson 5y agoThis is incoherent, industrial categories are a convenience, not a natural component of economic activity. Is automation an industry? Because an automation innovator might be built on the assumption that it can influence another industry. Can a manufacturer of one thing decide that they have the internal capacity to manufacture something at a lower cost than the existing competitors and then not share that methodology with the existing competitors?
- moolcool 5y ago> Free markets will always remain the most fair system of resource allocation. First, I think there's a lot of different angles from which you can challenge that claim. In a truly "free market", things like nepotism, bribery, and inherited wealth still exist (and by definition they'd exist in higher levels than in regulated markets). Does some random millionaire trust fund kid in a free market really create value? Is it fair that Bezos is a billionaire when low-paid workers are the ones actually creating value at Amazon? I would argue that without some restriction, free markets almost guarantee _unfair_ resource allocation. Like without antitrust regulation, for example, it would become a winner-take-all game where a single megacorporation could absorb all competitors and value labour however the hell they want. That is all besides the point though. I would argue that the "most fair system of resource allocation" is not a desirable outcome at all. If a true meritocracy were possible, swaths of people would just starve to death.
- mypastself 5y agoThe conclusion seems to be that citizens of economically free countries tend to value income increase as incentive for making a greater individual effort, which makes sense. The rest of the article seems to pass judgment on this view, and implies the alternative is preferable.
- jrsj 5y agoVery hard for me not to have this opinion now after working in a few different companies where half my coworkers seem to not be doing much more than jerking off all day and at best accomplishing a days worth of work in a week. How could anyone who has had this experience NOT want greater variation in pay that’s at least somewhat correlated to effort/performance? This stands out more to me in an office environment but the dynamic existed even when I worked at McDonald’s. Nobody wants to have to carry dead weight.
- goatlover 5y agoReminds me of the old Soviet saying, "We pretend to work and they pretend to pay us". But there seems to be a rise in popularity of the idea that meritocracy and competition is bad and everyone should be paid the same. Killing incentive seems like a bad economic policy to me that's already been tried.
- andrepd 5y agoIt's not that meritocracy in abstract is bad, it's that it is a fiction which does not really exist, certainly not in our capital-skewed status quo.
- bostik 5y agoI tend to be mostly supportive of meritocracy as a driver, but with a pretty wide carve-out. When you declare something to be a meritocracy, you also have to answer one fundamental question: who gets to define merit? Taken to its (il)logical extreme, unchecked meritocracy is a route to a mix of mercenary rule and nepotism.
- nlangy 5y agoOf course. Since at least Clinton the Democratic neoliberals have been the party of the 1% and the welfare recipients. The rest are screwed. Most of the Covid "relief funds" ended up in the hands of cronies, enabling them to buy private airplanes (there is a severe shortage right now), drive up the stock markets to ridiculous heights and use the gains to buy up even more real estate. (The Republicans are of course also doing all of this, but neoliberalism refers more to Democrats betraying their original interest groups.)
- newsclues 5y agoIf you understand that you realize why they fool everyone with the equality and diversity slogans. Gotta convinces the fools you aren’t robbing them blind!
- happythebob 5y agoBoth Sides is quite the global, age-old narrative that most people are vulnerable to. The two sides couldn't be more different than ever, if you'd care to see what Biden and Democrats have actually passed in the last 16 months. There's been more fury over Pelosi buying shares of US companies than there was over Trump pumping stocks on national TV, or about the leadup to Roe vs Wade, or about the right's attack on democracy. Which is what both sides fallacies has always done, always, by default it serves the shittier of two sides and makes people disinterested or impractical. And now it's louder and more exploited than ever thanks to social media. Thanks to you. If you are a proponent of the Both Sides Fallacy in the year 2022, you need a hard look at reality of the last 100+ years and the last 16+ months. You're helping the red wade and helping to move the Overton Window further right, learning nothing from the protest and non-voters of 2016, paying no attention to the reality of how many positive things have been done in the past 16 months, and things that have been 180 different from the previous four years, but you just see the Both Sides headlines.
- Dracophoenix 5y ago>If you are a proponent of the Both Sides Fallacy in the year 2022, you need a hard look at reality of the last 100+ years and the last 16+ months. You're helping the red wade and helping to move the Overton Window further right, learning nothing from the protest and non-voters of 2016, paying no attention to the reality of how many positive things have been done in the past 16 months, and things that have been 180 different from the previous four years, but you just see the Both Sides headlines. If you're going to criticize over-simplistic narratives, consider the flaws of your own. "Both sides are the same" is not a fallacy when both parties have regularly voted to increase the power of the state, cater and pander to their chosen special interest groups at the expense of the average citizen, and continue to punch holes into enumerated rights of the constitution. If you are of the view that the ends justify the means so long as you get your favored party into power, then your methods are no better than those of the elephant men. There is nothing remotely logical about voting for either of the parties, even as a buffer against the excesses of the other. If you can only conceive of politics in terms of binary spectra, you've already lost.
- epistasis 5y agoI appreciate that they defined neoliberalism. In Northern California over the last five to ten years, it has been so misused that people who are not very neoliberal, but have been called neoliberal a lot, started adopting the term to describe themselves. And these people would never agre with Thatcher or Reagan on much.
- gadders 5y ago>>Neoliberalism, which calls for free-market capitalism, regressive taxation, and the elimination of social services, That first sentence, where neoliberalism is described in a deliberatively pejorative way, doesn't do much for the credibility of the report. Margaret Thatcher (for instance) never called for the elimination of social services. She and the Conservative Party were always in favour of some form of social "safety net".