5 ms·
Disney Copyrights Targeted in Bill Proposed by Sen. Josh Hawley
- spacemanmatt 5y agoDisney was one of the champions and remains one of the biggest beneficiaries of the DMCA, a roundly-hated law. As much as I'd like to stick it to them, it's not enough to stick it to ONLY Disney, and it's certainly not good if it helps a national traitor like Josh Hawley.
- ladyattis 5y agoThere's a right way and a wrong way to enact copyright reform. This particular bill is the wrong way. First, the US government signed onto the Berne Convention in the 1980s, so we'd have to have another bill to leave it. Second, we're also signatories to NAFTA and it's updated treaty which also have similar IP language that conforms to the Berne Convention. Third, the back-dating of the copyright to specific companies that make 150 billion dollars a year is definitely not going to pass muster since the government would have to offer something place of the lost asset meeting the market rate which I'm going to assume the section of the Disney catalog that's affected by this bill would be an astronomical sum of cash. So if this ever got passed by Congress and signed by a President, there would be mayhem over this bill. Like kiss goodbye the US economy considering how many other entertainment companies that aren't Disney would get smacked hard by this. Seriously, Josh Hawley is like that douche from high school that use to bully the nerds for playing D&D but only joined one tabletop session because one cute girl was interested in it so he magically got interested too. It's that kind of thinking that goes through Josh's pinhead.
- Finnucane 5y agoI guess we know where their priorities lie. I mean, for years, republicans have championed corporate-friendly agendas like privatization of public resources and copyright maximalism, and now they are willing to undo it in order to stick it to LGBT& folks.
- nyokodo 5y ago> for years, republicans have championed corporate-friendly agendas The Republicans used to be the party of big business but that stopped being true around 2016. They’re now squarely populist which is why you’ve noticed a change in behavior. However, it’s not that anti-woke is more important than big business it’s that big business isn’t a constituency of the populists in the first place.
- cafard 5y ago2016: Have you looked at the Trump cabinet? It sure looks like big business to me.
- smoldesu 5y agoI don't know why this has to be polarized, of all things. There's nothing crazy about people coming to an agreement on copyright limitations. Hell, even if this was a contrived revenge plot, I don't think it detracts from it's legitimacy. IP legislation is insane and everyone knows it, Disney won't catch any empathy from me for virtue-signalling to distract from systematic exploitation.
- MBCook 5y agoNormally you’d be right. But in this case it only seems to be in progress because one party got mad at Disney and is now just looking for ways to hurt Disney’s interests in revenge. If a the school bully beats up a kid who torments you for a terribly unfair reason… should you root for them?
- xkcd-sucks 5y ago"A thief robs a thief, and God smiles" or whatever it is It would be pearl-clutchingly terrible if 50+1% of the country/state thought a cabal of (gays, nazis, woke commies, abortionists, pedophiles, etc.) were in the NSA using surveillance tech + weak encryption to accomplish their goals
- car_analogy 5y agoIt's unrealistically optimistic to expect the government to do the right thing for the right reasons, so I'm more than willing to settle for doing the right thing for the wrong reasons.
- klyrs 5y agoI've been railing against Disney's power over copyright law for over 2 decades, but I'm still inclined to look this gift horse in the mouth. > Hawley, employing DeSantis’ playbook, said in a statement, "Thanks to special copyright protections from Congress, woke corporations like Disney have earned billions while increasingly pandering to woke activists." Is it okay for the government to enact targeted legislation to punish the exercise of legitimate political speech? I'm very wary of the precedent that's set by this. When the ends justify the means, the entire constitution goes out the window.
- sieabahlpark 5y agoAnything that kills the copyright law industry is a win for literally everyone.
- spacemanmatt 5y agoExcept when it helps quislings like Hawley.
- _carbyau_ 5y agoThat's the thing though. How does it help Hawley to have copyright law curtailed, thus enabling even more free expression? Or does this law somehow only apply to Disney and no other copyright holding entity?
- klyrs 5y agoThe particulars don't help or harm Hawley. The value to him is in virtue signalling to his voter base. Not for any principled stance on free expression, but for fighting "wokeness."
- joshjob42 5y agohttps://clickhole.com/heartbreaking-the-worst-person-you-know-just-made-a-gr-1825121606/ https://clickhole.com/heartbreaking-the-worst-person-you-kno... Me right now. Copyrights should be much shorter but also it's Hawley so :shrug:
- ece 5y agoHonestly, finding some common ground seems good, but when someone is just doing things out of spite and without any rhyme or reason, it makes you think twice.
- PoignardAzur 5y ago> “Thanks to special copyright protections from Congress, woke corporations like Disney have earned billions while increasingly pandering to woke activists.” You know, "woke" has really become the new "commie". It doesn't refer to an ideology anymore, it's just a buzzword that has to be placed in as many sentences as possible to remind your base of all the awful people out there who want to destroy everything that is good and holy. (That aside, I don't have much sympathy for Disney. They had no business commenting on that Florida law, no matter how much shit their progressive fans and creators gave them.)
- kadoban 5y ago> They had no business commenting on that Florida law, no matter how much shit their progressive fans and creators gave them. The Republican party has spent the past couple of decades arguing that corporations have free speech, and expanding what "speech" means in that case. Does that only apply when they say Republican things?
- klyrs 5y agoThe draft ruling on Dobbs v. Jackson spells out very clearly that the "freedom of religion" is the freedom for Christians to impose their beliefs through legal stricture.
- tsol 5y agoHonestly I think woke just means leftist or progressive most of the time
- mrtweetyhack 5y ago
- yarg 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_Term_Extension_Act#/media/File:Tom_Bell's_graph_showing_extension_of_U.S._copyright_term_over_time.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_Term_Extension_Act#/... The Disney Lobby is partially responsible for this - and something really does need to be done about it. But let's not pretend that this is anything but sabre-rattling by the Republican - they have no interest in sane copyright limits.