23 ms·
Equality is prevented by the misperception that it harms advantaged groups
- nathias 5y agoit harms only the poorest, because above all equality means societal stability
- vmception 5y agoOk this one is long and has many many dimensions to try to understand the veracity of (without assuming you know what its referring to). The conclusion though is something I’ve noticed as well and matches the title. This is exacerbated by the very people arguing for equality, they lose support of would-be supporters in the majority groups by misdefining privilege. Causing resentment by would-be supporters who feel their valid struggles are neglected and invalidated.
- kingkawn 5y agoThe thing preventing equality is the people who horde everything. Blaming the people asking for not asking right is a joke.
- sidlls 5y agoIf you tell someone who grew up homeless or borderline homeless with a single parent who occasionally starved themselves for several days in a row so the kids could eat that they’re privileged because they’re white don’t be surprised if they’re less inclined to be your ally.
- vmception 5y agothe misdefined version of privilege is meant as “lack of some additional distractions” but the word is ambiguously paraded around as “everything handed out to people who are guided to use it all perfectly” and that latter usage definitely loses supporters from the voting bloc that could do anything about it
- dijit 5y agoFWIW privilege as defined in the English language is very firmly fitting the latter. https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/privilege https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/privileg... > an advantage that only one person or group of people has, usually because of their position or because they are rich: eg. > * Healthcare should be a right, not a privilege. > * Senior management enjoy certain privileges, such as company cars and health insurance. Privilege means special advantage. Not “default” behaviour. Which is why it’s very difficult to be told a person is advantaged when they do not feel that they are.
- vmception 5y agoright, which is why its the wrong word to describe the former. I guess the sad part here is that many influential people promulgating the term "privilege" actually believe(d) that was relevant amorphously to all white people, who as a class theoretically enjoy(ed) some certain privileges (such as moving to Oregon, not being conscripted as a slave, access to credit), but as individuals did not necessarily become beneficiaries of them. And as the relevance of those extreme explicitly codified exclusions disintegrated, it moved to hyperbole - an exaggerated reality that ignores class based inequality. But with such heavy segregation many people believe the exaggerations. and finally, some academics are trying to retcon what the word "privilege" means by incorporating additional information that imposes a different interpretation on previously described events, retconning is typically used to facilitate a dramatic plot shift or account for an inconsistency. how do we make this more obvious to people? I think there is a wide degree of support for programs that would disproportionately support disenfranchised people, as long as they are acknowledging its more of a class system now (and includes people of all race/ethnicities/colors in the program). And that's not the direction things currently are going, with the wrong words being used. Many would-be supporters are instead believing that there is an organized movement and threat to exclude them, as a form of payback, which is such an ironic and huge distraction, all from a failure to communicate. To that, I would just say its not organized. Its just such a large potential population of support. "disproportionately affecting minorities" still leaves extremely large numbers of white people affected. whether its poverty, university admissions, dubious assaults and killings by law enforcement, domestic violence.
- epicureanideal 5y agoAbsolutely. “Privilege” and “guilt” based on inherited characteristics is a horrible thing regardless of who it’s applied to. We should’ve learned this lesson several times last century.
- sidlls 5y agoEh, there's no doubt that white people in America enjoy a certain privilege, all other things being equal when compared to non-whites. However, that privileges diminishes substantially as one descends the economic ladder, until at the bottom most rungs whatever "white privilege" exists is almost entirely washed out by all the other variables causing misery and suffering, in general.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Arainach 5y agoPrivileged doesn't mean easy. Even if you're poor and white, you will never be judged by a potential landlord, store security employee, or taxi driver on the basis of your skin. You may have a tough life for all sorts of other reasons, but that won't be one of your problems, and that is a form of privilege.
- vmception 5y agoAgreed, this is an obtuse non-consensus definition that is conflated by disenfranchised, the beneficiaries of this phenomenon, activists, and casual onlookers. Is there another word to convey this concept more universally?
- sidlls 5y agoThat abuses the word "privilege" to the point of making it useless to communicate the point you're (likely) trying to make (which I agree with, if it's what I think it is) effectively in general.
- HideousKojima 5y agoThat's assuming, despite mountains of evidence to the contrary (exhibit 1 is all of blue check Twitter), that there are no people out there who discriminate against white people.
- vmception 5y agoYou have to get supporters for consensus to shift. If an approach isn't working then you have to know why and acknowledge it. It doesnt matter how you feel about acknowledging it, consensus wont shift if the approach doesnt change.
- oblak 5y agoIt's amazing how quickly you got downvoted. Feelings will be hurt. In any case, the abstract reads funny to me: "Nine preregistered studies (n = 4197) demonstrate that advantaged group members misperceive equality as necessarily harming their access to resources and inequality as necessarily benefitting them." Can we really blame exceptionally selfish people for not wanting to give up anything in a world where not everyone can live like a king at the expense of the vast majority? We only have one planet and they know it.
- wvh 5y agoYet asking while spitting someone in the face is not going to work well either. If your base principle is that the other person is privileged scum (even though there might be some truth to that in some cases), there's not really anywhere to go from there. Unless you're willing to go for violent revolution of course, but it should be fairly easy to understand that is not generally going to make the other sympathetic to your cause. Fair enough, some defenestration needs to happen every once in a while, but being divisive and going for open war might not be the best long-term strategy from a societal context, as opposed to some consensus and common goals.
- endisneigh 5y agoDoesn’t it though, necessarily? If you have three people, one who has almost everything, one who has almost nothing and another who has nothing. How can you make things more equal without harming the relative standing of the person who has almost everything? It could be positive sum in the long run but if you consider life to be a series of snapshots I’m not convinced that equalizing measures don’t hurt those who are, fairly or unfairly, advantaged at least momentarily.
- vlovich123 5y agoThat seems like splitting hairs. Are all investments then zero sum? I lose $100, the other person gets $100. At that moment in time it’s win/lose but clearly if that were actually the case all game theory would be useless for anything involving time between action and reward/penalty.
- endisneigh 5y agoIn the short term investments are zero sum though.
- vlovich123 5y agoWikipedia disagrees with that: > Nevertheless, the situation like the stock market etc. is not a zero-sum game because investors could gain profit or loss from share price influences by profit forecasts or economic outlooks rather than gain profit from other investors' losses.
- csa 5y ago> If you have three people, one who has almost everything, one who has almost nothing and another who has nothing. How can you make things more equal without harming the relative standing of the person who has almost everything? This assumes zero-sum. Many issues are not zero-sum issues.
- endisneigh 5y ago
- teakettle42 5y agoYou can’t simply declare a zero-sum situation to not be, and then expect your study participants to believe you. That’s what this study did: > In studies 1 to 5, participants read various equality-enhancing policies that would provide additional resources (e.g., salary and jobs) to a disadvantaged group (e.g., Latino Americans, people with a disability, women, and ex-felons) without changing the resources provided to the advantaged ingroup (e.g., white Americans, people without a disability, men, and non-felons). Where, exactly, does the money to pay for their additional salary and jobs come from?
- blacksqr 5y agoFrom a magical castle called the Federal Reserve, which creates it out of nothing.
- pas 5y agoThe Fed and Congress are still beholden to the actual economy, the gods of prices will ruthlessly sprinkle inflation all over if there is too much fairy dust in the hands of people.
- blacksqr 5y agoIn the actual actual economy, the magic castle buys almost half of the Treasury bonds issued by the government; and when you give free money to people who can't meet all their basic needs, they spend all of it, which causes a cascade throughout the economy of taxable transactions, which reimburses the government for most if not all of the money it laid out.
- pas 5y agoYes, that's why people who harp about debt-to-GDP ratio are usually ignorant of the fiscal multiplier. That said not all spending is the same. Spending on reforms or infrastructure that people benefit from (so things that help to make structural changes in the economy eg. by decreasing income inequality) has a large fiscal multiplier, spending on yet another useless thing (let's say paying Amazon - by giving it a tax break - to move its HQ from A to B) does nothing.
- indymike 5y agoPeople really struggle with how the logical or works here's a sentence: I get money or you get money Most people read that as: Either I get money and you get nothing, or you get money in I get nothing... which is wrong. That's why equality is so hard. People read or as xor.
- dudeinjapan 5y agoIn common speech "or" in the context of a choice is typically an "xor". "We can go to the beach or we can go to a movie."
- donatj 5y agoThere are certainly those who promote equality by knocking people down rather than raising people up at least in their choice of language. It's ingrained in the entire idea of "privilege". A privilege is you get but don't intrinsically deserve. Fair treatment under the law isn't a privilege, it's something everyone deserves.
- j_walter 5y agoI would say some extremely liberal cities giving contracts to specific minorities (female or black owned businesses) to promote equality...that is not fair treatment. Equality is making sure everyone has the same opportunities to succeed.
- jdkee 5y ago"For each inequality, participants first read a description of the disparity between an advantaged and disadvantaged group (e.g., “According to a recent report, in 2018, White homebuyers received roughly $386.4 billion in mortgage loans from banks, while Latino homebuyers only received around $12.6 billion in mortgage loans overall”). In the equality-enhancing policy condition, participants read proposals to increase resource access for the disadvantaged group and not change resource access for the advantaged group (e.g., “Several banks propose increasing the total amount of mortgage loans to Latino homebuyers by $7.3 billion and not changing the total amount of mortgage loan funding to White homebuyers”). The policy would thereby increase proportional equality in access to a given resource between the two groups. In the inequality-enhancing policy condition, participants read proposals to decrease resource access for the disadvantaged group and not change resource access for the advantaged group (e.g., “Several banks propose decreasing the total amount of mortgage loans to Latino homebuyers by $7.3 billion and not changing the total amount of mortgage loan funding to White homebuyers”). " . . . "As predicted, participants misperceived equality-enhancing policies as more harmful to their advantaged ingroup’s resource access than policies that maintained the status quo [b = 0.75, SE = 0.087, t(590.68) = 8.62, P < 0.001, 95% confidence interval (CI) [0.58, 0.93]] or worsened inequality" But do the participants really "misperceive" the hypothetical policies as "more harmful" if one doesn't agree with the study's framing, and conclude that increasing lending to a purported subset of the population results in higher housing costs for all due to market forces?
- rectang 5y ago> advantaged group members misperceive equality as necessarily harming their access to resources Equality may not harm advantaged groups materially (more likely equality brings material benefits), but the sense of your group's place at the top of a social hierarchy being challenged is surely psychologically distressing.
- drewcoo 5y agoIt's as if they're pretending we're not a social species.
- rectang 5y agoMy sense from reading the article is that they're not "pretending" so much as "not addressing". I'm persuaded that in terms of access to resources, equality brings benefits — for example, integrating women into the US workforce unlocked massive economic potential, benefiting men as well as women. This article reinforces that conclusion. But as to why misperceptions exist that access to resources is always a zero-sum game, this article doesn't say (from what I've seen, haven't read the whole article yet). It just observes that such misperceptions exist and have policy consequences. From the abstract: > This misperception that equality is necessarily zero-sum may explain why inequality prevails even as it incurs societal costs that harm everyone. EDIT: ah, here's their theory: > Building upon this research, we propose a new explanation for this phenomenon — that people fundamentally misperceive losses of relative advantage as losses in absolute terms.
- HideousKojima 5y agoOr people are used to being lied to about "equality" initiatives and their effects. There's a finite number of spots at any given university, company, etc. Favoring one demographic inherently means disfavoring another, no matter what lying advocates claim to the contrary.
- kevingadd 5y agoIf there are 8 demographics and you boost one, you're not "disfavoring another". You've raised one and the other 7 are all even with each other (theoretically) like they were before. If things were originally skewed unintentionally, you may have actually evened things out. "Finite number of spots" is also kind of a faulty assumption. There are many cases where you can adjust how many spots you have available if you make more intelligent decisions about resource allocation or are willing to make junior hires that cost less than senior ones and train them up.
- HideousKojima 5y ago>If there are 8 demographics and you boost one, you're not "disfavoring another". If the situation is zero-sum, then you absolutely have. Your post is exhibit #254,689,472,096,776 of people lying about this, and other people have caught on. >There are many cases where you can adjust how many spots you have available if you make more intelligent decisions about resource allocation or are willing to make junior hires that cost less than senior ones and train them up. So let's say instead of an Asian senior dev making $180k a year, you now have a (different) Asian junior dev and a Black junior dev making $90k. That doesn't disadvantage the Asian who would have been a senior dev making $180k? Preposterous.
- kevingadd 5y agoYou're presuming a zero-sum situation without specifying that. Plenty of situations are not zero-sum and it's disingenuous to pretend otherwise. > So let's say instead of an Asian senior dev making $180k a year, you now have a (different) Asian junior dev and a Black junior dev making $90k. That doesn't disadvantage the Asian who would have been a senior dev making $180k? Preposterous. Why are you presuming the Asian developer has to take a pay cut? I never specified that.
- j_walter 5y agoDepends on what type of equality you are referring to. I see equality as everyone have equal chances of succeeding...equal opportunity and not necessarily equal outcome. If you push equality as equal outcome...then yes the person who is "advantaged" because they did better (maybe worked harder or had a better idea) will feel like it harms them to force equal outcomes. When you look at the recent nomination of Ketanji Brown did it harm the 97% of federal judge candidates who were excluded from the process because the intended outcome was to have a black woman on the SCOTUS?
- dudeinjapan 5y agoAnd uh... if we are playing diversity bingo, where are the Asians, Native Americans, etc. on the Supreme Court?
- DoreenMichele 5y agoThis is no doubt compounded by the very justified anger of disadvantaged groups. It means women, people of color et al often make enemies unnecessarily from people who might well be inclined to be their allies. And the beat goes on. Same as it ever was.
- lnxg33k1 5y agoI've also been felt alienated a lot of times by women fighting for feminism and what some of them has come up with, like womxn, all men are dicks etc. but then I think it takes a bit of mental resilience to understand that it's the most noisy part of a group of people who suffer and is exploited and needs to be supported. On the other hand I think most of the battle might even be shared in terms of interests, I got today a good example about it as in Italy today have made news the words of female stylist saying something along the lines of "I won't hire women younger than 40 as they won't be available 24/7 and would need time off to enjoy friends and family, build families and they would also maybe need time off if they get pregnant, sometimes we forget that the battles are between business owners and workers, properties owners and tenants... and that increasing the salary of one doesn't necessarily means lowering it for another as I think business owners don't reditribute the value created by workers bust most of it is stolen, pocketed and results in yacht, luxury and properties, like business owners are the common enemy we need to fight not each other
- krona 5y agoI can't imagine anyone disagreeing with 'equality-enhancing policies' which leads me to believe the entire article has confused equality with equity, an entirely different (and incompatible) concept.
- golemotron 5y agoIt is an interesting article but it completely glosses over the fact that not everything is non-zero sum and that differential costs can and do exist. The basis of this is entity-hood, and it applies not only to groups but also to individuals, corporations, etc. In fact, it applies to plants and animals also. As this is all evolved, it's nearly impossible to separate the inclination from its effects. When humans have equal access to physical resources, they seek status and status as resources because it is a way of assuring physical and other resources in an uncertain environment. All entities that persist have some process which enables that persistence: self and group interest are long-term evolved responses. We can see them as problematic, but it's actually very important that they exist. Since entities can defect in a game-theoretic sense, existence is not assured. It's nice when you are Ukraine, for instance, to be able to have the urge to promote unequal access to arms (a resource) or international attention to ensure your survival. Without this urge, there is trouble. Carrying this back to something more local, in a family, attention-envy can happen among siblings because parental attention is not infinite. The non-zero sum model ignores these realities.
- ianbicking 5y agoRelated, I've seen a lot of commentary on Roe that takes the form "men should stop telling women what to do with their bodies." On it's face, sure, but men support choice almost as much as women, and while abolishing abortion hurts women much more it doesn't help men one bit, and even hurts men who are also very much a part of the hard parts of family planning. It's the same fallacy in the opposite direction: the idea that because something hurts one group it must help another group, when really pro-lifers just hurt everyone, even themselves. I don't really know what this stance does to an ideology... it feels like it's unnecessarily constructing enemies, or misplacing anger in ways that dilute the meaning of that anger. I know in most ways these expressions are just ways to release anger, maybe the form doesn't matter that much, but...
- Izkata 5y ago> Related, I've seen a lot of commentary on Roe Unrelated. This study is mostly financial (loans and bonuses, without mentioning where the extra money would come from), they included the questions under "materials and methods".
- MrStonedOne 5y ago
- Izkata 5y ago> A longitudinal survey of the 2020 U.S. voters reveals that harm perceptions predict voting against actual equality-enhancing policies, more so than voters’ political and egalitarian beliefs. Doublespeak. These policies are equality of outcome, not equality of opportunity, so those voters are siding with their egalitarian beliefs, not against. Waaaaay down in "Materials and Methods", here's the first study: > In the equality-enhancing policy condition, participants read about policies that proposed to increase the disadvantaged group’s resource access and not change the advantaged group’s resource access, which would therefore reduce the disparity: > “Several banks propose increasing the total amount of mortgage loans to Latino homebuyers by $7.3 billion and not changing the total amount of mortgage loan funding to White homebuyers. Ultimately, these banks predict that this proposal will narrow the gap in mortgage loans between Latino and White homebuyers over the next year.” > In the status quo condition, participants read that no policy was proposed to address the disparity: > “However, several banks propose not changing mortgage loan funding over the next year.” > In the inequality-enhancing condition, participants read about policies that proposed to decrease the disadvantaged group’s resource access and not change the advantaged group’s resource access, which would therefore worsen the disparity: > “Several banks propose decreasing the total amount of mortgage loans to Latino homebuyers by $7.3 billion and not changing the total amount of mortgage loan funding to White homebuyers. Ultimately, these banks predict that this proposal will widen the gap in mortgage loans between Latino and White homebuyers over the next year.” > Participants indicated how each policy proposal would affect the advantaged ingroup’s resource access [“How do you think the proposed changes will affect [advantaged groups’] chances of [receiving resources]?”; 7-point Likert-scale with meaningful anchors: −3 (greatly harm), 0 (no effect), and +3 (greatly improve)]. On top of the opportunity/outcome distinction, there's a something the voters might be thinking of that they didn't account for (this is huge and I went looking for these questions, so it could easily be in there somewhere, but the word "confound" doesn't appear on the page): Where does the extra money for the loans come from? Banks can't create it out of thin air, it has to come from somewhere, so the "and not changing the total amount of mortgage loan funding to White homebuyers" can easily be read as a lie, making the premise of this section ("and not change the advantaged group’s resource access") incorrect.
- azornathogron 5y ago
- roody15 5y agoThe problem is using outcomes to describe equality. This in and of itself is controversial and not agreed upon (IMO). I suggest that most humans would agree striving for equal opportunity is a universal goal (although hard to measure and perhaps impossible to fully achieve) I suggest that many humans see equalized outcomes as more a dystopian nightmare. In todays world it seems equal opportunity, equity.. and equalized outcomes often conflated with one another.
- hemreldop 5y ago
- ethbr0 5y agoThe issue is that outcomes are easier to measure, and so are. Consequently, the policy eventually targets the measured metric, and we get policies intended to increase opportunity that instead directly target outcomes. At which point, policy wonks pat themselves on the back for hitting their metrics.
- eastbound 5y agoCan it happen that the two groups reach the same outcome, but one group able to achieve the same place without much work? Isn’t that what happens with women and causes misogyny?
- thfuran 5y ago>Isn’t that what happens with women and causes misogyny? I'm not sure what you mean.
- themacguffinman 5y agoWell yes, it can happen. I don't know if that "causes" misogyny, but is rather the result of it. It's paradoxically the case that societies with less gender equality tend to have greater STEM equality [1], and vice versa. Because women in these unequal societies have very little broad opportunity, they rush to one of the few opportunities that's even possible for them: STEM. They'll push themselves to do it even if they don't want to, because it's their only meal ticket out of their situation. Women in more equal societies presumably have more of a voluntary choice and tend to choose STEM less as a result. [1] https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0956797617741719 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/095679761774171...
- hemreldop 5y ago
- ssalka 5y agoThe following line from the abstract: > Misperceptions persist even after an intervention to improve decision-making. echoes a finding from the CIA handbook Psychology of Intelligence Analysis, which for some reason lives rent-free in my head: > Initial exposure to blurred or ambiguous stimuli interferes with accurate perception even after more and better information becomes available.
- SuperCuber 5y agoWTF is "an intervention to improve decision-making"? On what basis do they think that their decision making is better than the participants'?
- eastbound 5y ago> “Misperception that it harms advantaged groups” They literally put it in the title. The scientists have this prejudice that some groups are advantaged, and that if they complain it’s caused by a misperception. What people complain about is unfairness. Promoting an entire group based on skin or ethnicity is racism. One can’t assume that groups must be equal in the way they work. There are only two ways we can solve racism: - Give people equal opportunity and accept that groups will have different averages, on average, - Pile up on whites, they’re basically only 10% of humanity so they will end up representing a smaller voting group in the long term, especially if they’re divided pro/against, so we can be unfair to them and punish the ones who complain.
- Sporktacular 5y agoSome groups have advantages that others don't. Neither of those ways will solve racism, and since racism will go unsolved, in 100 years we'll still be talking about how the past has passed and that NOW is the time for a meritocracy. 100 years of some groups falling further and further behind.
- inglor_cz 5y agoLooking at the state of racial relations in 1922 and how they changed in the 100 years since then, I sort-of doubt that the situation of 2122 will be anywhere close to today. Someone will probably oppress someone else, but the overall balance of power and ideas will be totally different than today.
- Sporktacular 5y agoIn the Western context, that's probable. But no matter where you look, some groups will still lag in a bunch of metrics, xenophobia and racism will still exist in some form and will still be holding them back. That's always been the case and they certainly won't be solved with the two suggestions above.
- glerk 5y ago> The scientists have this prejudice that some groups are advantaged, and that if they complain it’s caused by a misperception. 100% correct. Calling these people "scientists" is giving them too much credit. These are propagandists using sciency sounding language to push a political agenda.
- drewcoo 5y ago> advantaged group members misperceive equality as necessarily harming their access to resources and inequality as necessarily benefitting them I don't think that's misperception. I think the article (and likely cited studies) lead with their dogma and try to "prove" it. Having privilege is beneficial. Isn't that an obvious tautology?
- smegsicle 5y ago> ctrl-f misperceive + misperception -> 75 results it's not a tautology if you repeat it enough
- isabelc 5y agoEquality will always be prevented as long as we're allowed to exercise free will. A wise man said, "Differences in habits and attitudes are differences in human capital, ...and such differences create differences in economic outcomes." Besides, the 2nd sentence of the Abstract shows they begin by labelling the perceptions of others as inaccurate. This corrupts the rest for me: >Only when equality is increased within their ingroup, instead of between groups, do advantaged group members accurately perceive it as unharmful.
- car_analogy 5y agoThis explains the refusal to set aside some Ivy League admissions for non-Jewish whites - Asian and Jewish students misperceive that they would be harmed, and so they prevent it. For reference, the non-international student body of the Ivy League, circa 2019 (source: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30338742 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30338742): Ivy League US ratio mean SAT* Jewish 17.2% 2.4% 7.16 n/a Asian 19.6% 5.3% 3.71 1216 White (incl. Jewish) 50.3% 61.5% 0.82 1148 Hispanic 11.4% 17.6% 0.65 1043 Black 7.8% 12.7% 0.61 966 White (non-Jewish) 33.1% 59.1% 0.56 ~1141 On the other hand, the study defined "advantaged group" very differently. I wonder if this would affect their results? They should do a follow-up study and compare. *Source: https://www.ednc.org/eraceing-inequities-the-influence-of-race-on-sat-scores/ https://www.ednc.org/eraceing-inequities-the-influence-of-ra... - estimate for non-Jewish white SAT calculated by assuming the Jewish score is a generous 200 points higher, and adjusting that they are only ~4% of all white students. I.e. the true value is likely closer to 1148. While Asian students benefit greatly from their 173- and 250-point leads over Hispanic and Black students, non-Jewish whites are, bizarrely, not helped at all by 98- and 175-point leads over those groups.
- shroompasta 5y agoIt isn't "misperceived", they are actually harmed when adjusting for their SAT scores and academic records.
- jedberg 5y agoWhat inequality would you be adjusting for by reserving spots for non-Jewish whites? Especially if it means taking away spots from Asians and Jewish kids, given that both of those groups have historically dealt with biases their entire lives (Asians much more-so than Jewish kids)?
- slibhb 5y agoHow on earth are they "misperceiving" anything? If Jews were considered Jews and not white they wouldn't be 17.2% of the Ivy League. They'd go back to being discriminated against as in the past and as Asians are currently. The solution to this is so simple. If you must institute affirmative action, stop considering "advantaged groups". Only consider ethnicity when it helps the application. So consider ethnicity for black, Hispanic, Native Americans, Pacific Islanders, etc. Don't consider it for Asians, whites, Jews, and so on. This strategy will still hurt non-disadvantaged people but the impact will be spread across all ethnicities that are doing fine rather than focused almost entirely on Asians.
- tracerut 5y agoWhy is this study applied only to identity groups? It would have been more interesting to see the results in terms of the genuinely disadvantaged in society: those with low income and no wealth. Those are the people who really need help.
- nomdep 5y agoAmerican society has been brainwashed to believe everything is about race and gender, so they don’t bother the wealthy and powerful
- bufferoverflow 5y agoEqaulity of outcome is a stupid target. Different people have different productivity. There are people who don't want to work at all. There are people who want to work 15 hours a day. There are people who produce 10x of work in the same time span. There are people with rare and hard to learn skills. I will never be convinced that a neurosurgeon should be paid the same as a janitor high school dropout. While both cleaning and neurosurgery are important jobs, they are not of the same value to the society.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- CoastalCoder 5y agoWho gets to pick the groupings? Who gets to define disadvantage? I would think that whoever imposes those choices on others runs afoul of his own ideology. (If there's a flaw in my thinking I'd be grateful for correction.)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kwatsonafter 5y agoThis articles seems to equating societal advantages to game theoretic advantages-- they have severe differences. Human systems don't always benefit from, "equality" and, "democratization" despite those terms being very, "friendly" in terms to the contemporary culture. It's good to democratize workspaces but by comparison it's illiberal to democratize someone's girlfriend. Inviting the public to do grown up science is an interesting idea but in terms of lofty ideals but without a workable, "human model" you get, "drown the public in dopamenic engagements and then use data-collection to develop statistical models as a socioeconomic model" to progress science and technology and I think we can mostly agree that this is not a good thing. This same reasoning has applications in other, "human" domains-- sex cultures benefit from secrecy and exclusivity, artists often benefit from the creative process not being, "democratic" and it seems that it would be unwise to let untrained people manage the greater macroeconomy through voting or popular consensus. Financial, social, and creative elites get this. That's why institutional and social gatekeeping exists. Real equality and Liberalism go along with Universal Education; Franklin and Rousseau (and others) seem to typify a progressive society as a being a kind of social arrangement where nobody is deliberately or arbitrarily held back from the process of becoming self-determining through education and for the most part, "democracy" has been considered a, "vulgar" form a government since antiquity even amongst the Founding Fathers and Enlightenment thinkers. Consider a modern society where the media system has been hijacked to, "manufacturer consent" for abolishing democratic institutions, libraries, and schools through popular consent and social degradation. It's worth noting that CPAC's having a conference in Budapest two weeks. The only silver bullet for human systems is education. Equality and democracy without universal education is worse than the forms of government it/they historically displace. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Journalism#Lippmann-Dewey https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Journalism#Lippmann-Dewey
- cato_the_elder 5y ago> Racial inequality costs the U.S. economy an estimated $16 trillion in lost gross domestic product (GDP) The entirety of US GDP is about $21 trillion. Based on that, this just looks implausible. > "According to a recent report, in 2018, White homebuyers received roughly $386.4 billion in mortgage loans from banks, while Latino homebuyers only received around $12.6 billion in mortgage loans overall" So in the "descriptions of the disparity" given to the participants, they don't even bother to normalize by population. > "Several banks propose increasing the total amount of mortgage loans to Latino homebuyers by $7.3 billion and not changing the total amount of mortgage loan funding to White homebuyers" They use this as both an example of an "equality-enhancing policy", which doesn't "harm advantaged groups". But they are misrepresenting this as a Pareto improvement. Changing the amount of loans offered obviously effects the price of homes. Inflation be damned.
- overboard2 5y agoSubprime mortgages, here we go.
- Sporktacular 5y ago"Only when equality is increased within their ingroup, instead of between groups, do advantaged group members accurately perceive it as unharmful." This is why it's critical that policies for education, city planning, economic planning etc. all maintain and encourage interaction between classes. If the advantaged are never made aware of the struggle of others, the result is runaway social stratification. Also, these studies are entirely within the US context and so correlate along common historical and geographical lines. Conclusions can't be applied broadly to other societies.
- eric4smith 5y agoIn the end we live in mostly free countries. Women are not clamoring to be brick layers. And men are not clamoring to be kindergarten teachers. And as long as we remain free - meaning, the ability to choose what we want to do, biology will remain the foremost driver of choice of occupations. People keep trying to suppress biology with various social constructs, and cry when we fail.
- gojomo 5y agoPretty weak, tendentious study mainly designed to flatter the experimenter's priors. Doesn't compare "advantaged" group (here assumed to simply be "white (non-Hispanic)") to any others. Claims to find "misperceptions" when a reasonable-person real-world interpretation of any of the questions, even if they are designed to exclude any loss to the respondents' category, will necessarily apply assumptions about resource-limitations. For example, one example given in the text is a proposed policy, “Several banks propose increasing the total amount of mortgage loans to Latino homebuyers by $7.3 billion and not changing the total amount of mortgage loan funding to White homebuyers”. People who live in the real world know such a policy might not "increase equality". Sometimes, generous loans offered due to trendy policies – like in the leadup to the 2008 crisis – trap the borrowers with unsustainable debts. Other times, they meet the ostensible targets – "more to Latinos" – without actually reaching the disadvantaged. (Only Latinos who are already well-off can work the system.) Many people of all 'advantagedness' categories will reject the idea of targeting loans by ethnicity, preferring as a matter of morality that such decisions should be ethnicity-blind. They might even choose to suffer tangible resource losses for themselves & their 'ingroup', to punish attempts to set up a resource-allocation on unfair precepts, as in 'ultimatum game' experiments. And, no matter how carefully the question-conditions are wordsmithed to suggest a 'free lunch' for the preferred-category at no cost to the respondents – "not changing the total amount of mortgage loan funding to White homebuyers" – in the real world an extra $7.3B has to come from somewhere. Reserving it for a specific ethnicity means it's taken from everyone else – not just from the study's 'advantaged' but every other (possibly-even-more-needy) program/group. (Other conditions only described in the supplementary materials are even worse in imagining free-money for pay-raises, and free-jobs that don't displace anyone else, as if magically from-the-sky.) The experimenters' childlike wishing-away of tradeoffs thus makes their desired result fall automatically out of the interaction between their fanciful scenarios & respondents' real-world familiarity with how such proposed policies truly work.
- MrPatan 5y agoYeah, if anything, this study proves people's ability to see through the experimenter's bullshit. Faith in humanity: restored
- Arubis 5y agoIf you're privileged and carrying the feeling that you need to be the provider in your family group, that facet of your life experience would be improved by greater equity in our society. The patriarchy harms everyone, including those that it privileges.
- maxbendick 5y agoThis may very well be true, but only as a post-hoc explanation. Reactionary politics (all politics, really) have their home at a subconscious level. Politics are ways of feeling and acting. It's an error to think that if the other side had more "common sense", they'd see the light. Even animals have politics. Only the most _surface-level_ politics can be affected through logical explanations.
- LatteLazy 5y agoThere are a whole bunch of bad assumptions here just in the first few paragraphs. Those include the idea that group are homogeneous (every white person is advantaged, every woman is disadvantaged) and that it is even possible to improve one person's position without worsening someone else's. It's actually so poor I am having trouble assuming good faith on the authors parts.
- chmod600 5y agoIt depends on the means to achieve equality, right? And you also have to account for the possibility that a given idea to improve equality actually reduces it. But sure, if you observe equality in a well-functioning system after the fact, I could certainly believe that everyone is better off.
- chmod600 5y ago"In studies 1 to 5, participants read various equality-enhancing policies that would provide additional resources (e.g., salary and jobs) to a disadvantaged group (e.g., Latino Americans, people with a disability, women, and ex-felons) without changing the resources provided to the advantaged ingroup (e.g., white Americans, people without a disability, men, and non-felons)." That sounds a little too magical. I understand policies might have that overall effect, at least in aggregate, but I doubt there would be widespread agreement on the "everybody wins" outcome.
- hall0ween 5y agoI have an opinion, that sort of conflicts with having an opinion itself - but hear me out. I have growing opinion that Americans (US) more often than not feel a compulsion to have an opinion. A family-member states an opinion or event, we read something in the news, etc. and, without being even _decently_ educated in the subject, choosing to hold an opinion and (pseudo) defend it. I'm outing my former self here. How much easier is life if we choose a select group of topics to be informed on and debate those. Letting the other shit go, saying to ourselves "I'm not knowledgeable enough here to have an meaningful opinion. And therefore, I will stfu." That takes a lot of where with all and, aside from myself, I have not heard a single person say words along these lines.
- DoreenMichele 5y agoMost of the time, people deciding to STFU because they don't know enough simply don't speak. On rare occasions, I have said "I don't know enough to draw a conclusion". The result is usually hell to pay.
- steve76 5y ago
- rayiner 5y ago> A longitudinal survey of the 2020 U.S. voters reveals that harm perceptions predict voting against actual equality-enhancing policies, more so than voters’ political and egalitarian beliefs The Biden administration has repeatedly enacted policies that send white people to the back of the line in receiving government benefits. The Biden USDA adopted a loan forgiveness program which whites were ineligible for: https://www.politico.com/news/2021/08/24/doj-appeal-minority-farmers-506820 https://www.politico.com/news/2021/08/24/doj-appeal-minority.... The Biden SBA also adopted a small business loan program that excluded whites: https://www.law360.com/articles/1389372/6th-circ-blocks-sba-s-covid-19-loan-priority-for-minorities https://www.law360.com/articles/1389372/6th-circ-blocks-sba-.... Left-leaning jurisdictions like Vermont, moreover, have adopted policies such as prioritizing vaccines for non-whites: https://khn.org/news/article/vermont-gives-blacks-and-other-minority-residents-vaccine-priority https://khn.org/news/article/vermont-gives-blacks-and-other-.... How can it be a "misperception" if white people conclude that policies that deprioritize them for access to limited government programs will cause them harm? The study also makes a critical assumption that supposed "equality-enhancing policies" will actually produce "non–zero-sum increases in resource equality." Some may think that small business loans from which whites are excluded will generate benefits that make everyone, including the excluded white small business owners, better off. Maybe even better off than if those white small business owners had been allowed to participate in those government programs in the first instance. But that's an assumption--the authors are assuming that the intended effect of these government programs will be the actual effect. There doesn't seem to be any scientific basis for calling that a "misperception."
- psacawa 5y ago400 years ago: "Equality is prevented by the misperception that sharing land with the Jamestown colony will harm the Algonquin tribes" I shake my head whenever I see supposed scientists assert that everybody's incentives are aligned, defying both common sense and all of human history. The reality is competition and contention are readily observed in every domain of human life. To me, articles like this are obvious political agitation.
- xputer 5y agoThe problem with grouping people into advantaged and disadvantaged groups along lines of race and ethnicity is that you will end up grouping some people that are actually from a poor background into the "advantaged" group and vice versa. No matter how you put it, that just doesn't seem fair and I find it appalling that this somehow became acceptable in modern day America.
- yes_really 5y ago> Equality is prevented by the misperception that it harms advantaged groups But what the article calls "equality" is discriminating against men, whites, asians and other groups. It's pretty obvious this discrimination harms those groups.
- kurupt213 5y ago
- CryptoPunk 5y agoThis is sophistry for social justice ideology masquarading as science: >>Racial inequality costs the U.S. economy an estimated $16 trillion in lost gross domestic product (GDP) (4), failing to hire job seekers with a criminal history results in an annual loss of $78 billion in U.S. GDP (5), and the persistent gender pay gap restrains the global economy by about $160 trillion (6). The idea that these inequalities can be addressed, in an economically net-gainful way, by government mandates or simple changes in hiring preferences, is based on the fanciful premise that such inequality is economically irrational and due to discrimination, as opposed to disparites in skills or work hours that justify pay and representation inequality. This premise - that inequality between various demographics in employment is significantly or largely due to discrimination and thus economically irrational - is not only not established, it is heavily counter-indicated against by the evidence. Policies that reduce inequality in pay or representation, without addressing inequality in skills present or value contributed that are behind the pay or representation inequality, will harm the economy, by mismatching compensation/representation and value provided, and thus causing capital to be allocated in a suboptimal way for the purposes of maximizing total productivity.
- fallingfrog 5y agoLet’s say that everyone in the country rolls 11 dice, and whoever rolls all sixes becomes dictator for life. That would be fair, wouldn’t it? In the sense that everyone has an equal chance, it is fair. In fact it’s precisely, purely fair. Everyone in the country had exactly the same chance. You don’t get much more fair than that! However, you are still left with a nation ruled by a dictator.. Let that cook in your head for a minute. I’ll solve the riddle for you: Fairness has never been the issue here. Power imbalance is. We’re asking the wrong question. The correct question is, how can we make it so nobody has unwarranted power over anyone else? That’s true equality.
- Gravyness 5y agoIt is not a misperception. It's a high probability that influencing one thing influences the other. Equality of oportunity is what we should be looking for.
- mbar84 5y agoAccumulation of capital is prevented by the misperception that equality is desirable in and of itself. Is it better that we allow the capital in society to be commanded by elected bureaucrats or by people who acquired it in a competitive process, even if that means that they will have more pieces of paper (called shares) with their name on it? Is the billionaire who only spends $100k on himself every year to be viewed the same as the billionaire who throws a party every weekend with bikini models on his mega-yacht?