5 ms·
> dissuaded capital from financing the real economy and instead encouraged herding and levering up in the financial economy for returns. i don't really agree w
by chii 5y ago
> dissuaded capital from financing the real economy and instead encouraged herding and levering up in the financial economy for returns.
i don't really agree with this - the money used to purchase financial products don't disappear, because for every product bought, there was a seller. This seller now has cash, which would be invested elsewhere.
The only concern is low interest rates, which makes the hurdle for any investment lower thus making it easy for malinvestments to occur; In hindsight is easy to make judgements on what is a malinvestment, but not so easy at the time.
- bagacrap 5y agoI've had this same thought, but everyone seems to be sitting in cash? No one wants to invest unless everyone else invests. Seems the emperor is suddenly naked.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> everyone seems to be sitting in cash? What is this based on? Every indicator suggests we’re still in a risk-on mode as an economy. It’s why we have inflation.
- EGreg 5y agoYield curve inverted and interest rates have begun to go up. Risk on?
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> curve inverted and interest rates have begun to go up. Risk on? Yes, we’re still seeing billions of dollars being deployed into start-ups [1], crypto and the like. We are less risk on than we were. But within America, there is no flight to safety. (Internationally, it’s more complicated.) [1] https://fortune.com/2022/04/08/venture-capitals-2022-slowdown-4-charts/amp/ https://fortune.com/2022/04/08/venture-capitals-2022-slowdow...
- baq 5y agoDon’t know which indicators you’re looking at, but the bond market disagrees.
- gabereiser 5y agoYou should see the volume of the last 24 hours. No one is sitting on cash unless they are hobbyists.
- zmgsabst 5y agoThat’s ironic. If you’d sold your S&P500 on Monday and bought back on Friday, you’d have gained 2.7 shares per 100 sold. If you’d sold your S&P500 a month prior and bought back on Friday, you’d have gained a 8 shares per 100 sold. If you’d sold your S&P500 six months prior and bought back on Friday, you’d have gained 14 shares per 100 sold.
- gabereiser 5y agoYou just described a hobbyist. Institutions don’t sit on cash for that long, nor do they buy S&P in any significance. [0] Berkshire Hathaway - https://www.dataroma.com/m/holdings.php?m=BRK https://www.dataroma.com/m/holdings.php?m=BRK
- carnitine 5y agoInteresting that you cite BRK, who famously have been sitting on ~150bn in cash recently. Professional investors absolutely sit on cash all the time.
- gabereiser 5y agoYeah, they did, and within a month or two it was reinvested elsewhere. Whether it was pulling out of American Airlines in favor of more shares of Chevron, or doubling down on tech stocks. BRK doesn’t just sit on 150bn in cash for longer than they have to. Not saying they don’t sit on cash but they definitely don’t sit on it for a year or more.
- gabereiser 5y agoShow me a hedge fund that sat on more than 1% of their holdings for more than a year. I’ll wait.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y ago> i don't really agree with this - the money used to purchase financial products don't disappear, because for every product bought, there was a seller. This seller now has cash, which would be invested elsewhere. But just look at housing, which has exploded well beyond the rate of inflation since the Great Recession bottomed out, and especially in the past couple years. Yes, if money is plowed into housing, the homeowner has more cash when they sell. But presumably they have to live somewhere, and with housing skyrocketing in basically any halfway desirable place, it means they're just going to spend that cash on another expensive house.
- chii 5y ago> if money is plowed into housing, the homeowner has more cash when they sell. but it's not expensive _everywhere_. It's expensive in some of the most desirable places. And housing has some issues unrelated to the market - such as NIMBYs stopping new constructions.
- mach1ne 5y ago>but it's not expensive _everywhere_. It's expensive in some of the most desirable places. The fact that the median and average house prices have exploded signifies that the housing market is in a bubble. It's not relevant that house prices have not increased equally everywhere. Ultimately, after the bubble eventually bursts, it will leave a lot of people indebted to banks with their real ownings not matching the debt. This translates to a decrease in consumer consumption, meaning slower economic growth. Resources of the society will be more directed towards customers who have more wealth, meaning those who weren't part of the housing crash. Likely customers from abroad. Obviously we're talking about percentages, but that's how economy works and that translates to very real changes in a many people's lives.
- lottin 5y agoSince the mid-2000s house prices have risen less, on average, than disposable income in the US. https://twitter.com/MPelletierCIO/status/1522704947556483073/photo/1 https://twitter.com/MPelletierCIO/status/1522704947556483073...
- arrosenberg 5y agoCouldn’t there be an issue if the buyer is paying with margin that’s backed by an overvalued asset? Maybe not for the seller, but eventually someone will be left holding the bag.
- adg001 5y ago> i don't really agree with this - the money used to purchase financial products don't disappear, because for every product bought, there was a seller. This seller now has cash, which would be invested elsewhere. Make no confusion, please. Quantitative easing was intended to give credit institutions greater ability to lend money to entrepreneurs, so as to boost real economy. When capitals are invested in financial products the entities closing their positions (e.g., selling stocks) and, in turn, getting the cash are not necessarily credit institutions (i.e., they are typically fund managers and private investors) – which is to say they pocket the money.
- jseban 5y ago> i don't really agree with this - the money used to purchase financial products don't disappear, because for every product bought, there was a seller. This seller now has cash, which would be invested elsewhere. And buying stocks is financing real projects, and you only get those returns if they manage to do something actually useful, this is helping to finance and promote economic activity, how is that taking money away from the "real" economy?
- PretzelPirate 5y agoIf someone buys stocks from a third party in the open market, are they financing real projects? It really feels like it’s all speculation since the value of my shares doesn’t actually entitle me to that portion of the company’s profits, unless I can sell back directly to the company.
- qgin 5y agoThe value of stocks is pinned to two events that you often don’t directly participate in but are absolutely connected to in a real way. 1. The IPO. While it’s true that only the people who buy at the IPO directly finance the company, if there wasn’t the promise of someone else in the future to sell the shares to, nobody would buy at the IPO. The existence of future second-hand buyers makes the direct funding at the IPO possible. 2. Dividends and buybacks. All stocks get their value from either the current existence or future promise of dividends and buybacks. While from time to time people get lost in “greater fool” trading, the reason a stock doesn’t go to zero is because there is either currently a dividend/buyback or people believe that eventually when the company matures, they will offer a dividend/buyback to shareholders and a future buyer will want to buy this shares for the cash returned by the company. (As a tangent, this is something most crypto investors don’t understand… cryto is almost exclusively “greater fool” trading with no basis in the promise of future real cash return)
- MisterMower 5y agoPoint 2 is false: shares of stock derive their value from the fact that they represent ownership in a company. If the company is profitable or owns valuable assets beyond their liabilities, then the shares themselves are valuable. Their value does not depend on current or future dividends, but on the company’s current assets and the market’s estimation of the value of the company’s future cash flows. Your point about crypto still stands: there are no future cash flows to consider with crypto, only the current value of the asset, although the comparison is really apples to oranges.