15 ms·
Amazon abruptly fires senior managers tied to unionized warehouse
- faangiq 5y agoThey’re reaching a market cap where it would make sense to fire everyone but AWS.
- Mountain_Skies 5y agoIt's confusing why investors haven't pushed harder for AWS to be spun-off into its own entity.
- hiddencost 5y agoThe largest customer of AWS is Amazon. AWS would not be profitable without Amazon.
- franczesko 5y agoI don't see any benefits for Amazon as a whole of doing so.
- Bilal_io 5y agoWhy would they do that when one entity's losses can be used as a tax write-off for the other entity's profits.
- di4na 5y agobecause an option on a basket is worth less that a basket of options
- devoutsalsa 5y agoInvestors like profit and they like growth. The moment a business unit isn’t growing or profitable, you need to start justifying why you’re keeping it around. On the topic of write offs, losing money isn’t great unless it’s used to fuel obscene growth. You don’t spend $2 to save $1. The “we lose money on every sale, but make up for it on volume” model doesn’t work in the long run. More simply, a business is worth the value of all future cash flow, and it’s that simple.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Why would they do that when one entity's losses can be used as a tax write-off for the other entity's profits. Because it's better to not have losses than to use them as tax write-offs (also, because basically every use of funds other than retaining profits is already a tax write-off for business, and the ones that aren't losses contribute to future profits.)
- Ekaros 5y agoLosing and investing money are different things. It's all fine for future to spend money on new warehouses, distribution hubs and better software. But there is expectation that this will at least increase revenue if not the profits. If it does not it is just waste that any company is better off with.
- tyrfing 5y agoMassive company, so an activist would need a lot of capital for any noticeable stake. Overall reasonable and relatively consistently increasing valuation, so there is little incentive. If the stock does very poorly while AWS keeps growing, so the company value diverges further from the value of individual divisions added together (sum of the parts value), you could expect pressure on this.
- syshum 5y agoElon should buy it and take it Private ;)
- idiotsecant 5y agoFor real. Amazon's retail side is nothing but bad pr and other messy human entanglements. AWS is clean, profitable, and nearly ubiquitous. I definitely know which business I would rather be in
- thinkling 5y agoThe guy who used to run AWS now runs the whole show, so maybe it'll get better on the retail side over time?
- robertlagrant 5y agoIt's not about management. One business has many low paid workers as part of how things have to work; the other has fewer, high skilled workers.
- Dreako 5y agoAs they should!
- humanistbot 5y agoSo you think corporations should break the law? Workers have the right to organize a union, firing workers in retaliation for organizing has long been illegal: https://www.nlrb.gov/about-nlrb/rights-we-protect/the-law/employees/your-rights-during-union-organizing https://www.nlrb.gov/about-nlrb/rights-we-protect/the-law/em...
- noncoml 5y agoNot the OP and not supporting his opinion, but these where not workers they fired, they were senior managers, and I believe it's not illegal. I guess the OP means that they should be fired for failing to do their job, ie. "convince" the workers to not unionize.
- peoplefromibiza 5y agothat's an old argument though, where does it stops? If someone put those managers in charge of "convincing" workers to not unionize, aren't they responsible as well? And who gave the order to put someone to "convince" them, haven't they failed too?
- Aperocky 5y agoI don't think senior managers of the warehouse are the ones organizing..
- 650REDHAIR 5y agoCare to explain your reasoning?
- dylan604 5y agoIn Amazon's view, they woefully performed in their functions. They failed in a very high profile task. Their (in)actions are going to cost the company lots of money. Leaving aside the exact task, these sound like typical reasons for dismissal.
- sitkack 5y agoIf only those managers had joined the union.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hammock 5y agoProbably were ineligible
- advisedwang 5y agoUnfortunately those in a " supervisor" role are explicitly excluded from the main US labor protection [1]. Amazon could fire them anyway. [1] https://www.nlrb.gov/about-nlrb/rights-we-protect/your-rights/employee-rights https://www.nlrb.gov/about-nlrb/rights-we-protect/your-right...
- kwhitefoot 5y agoSounds like US labour legislation needs to be scrapped and restarted.
- klyrs 5y agoProblem being that the ones interested in scrapping them aren't interested in replacing them.
- fallingknife 5y agoWhy do we need legislation? Formation of unions is protected by freedom of association in the 1st amendment. Not sure why we need another federal bureaucracy to intervene in the negotiating process. Not sure why we need the whole all or nothing union voting process. What if 33% of employees want to join the union? What if managers want to join? Why can't they just join?
- 5y ago
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y ago> Several were veterans of the company, with more than six years of experience I think it's sad that we have an industry, where someone with six years' experience, is considered a "veteran." But it sounds like Amazon is sending a message to managers of other warehouses, to go as low as possible, to fight unionization. Expect things to get ugly.
- whycombagator 5y agoWell the line you quoted says company not industry. Ecommerce is a relatively young industry anyway. And Amazon has been around since what, 94? So 6 years is over 20% of the time Amazon has existed.
- k__ 5y agoSo, if a company exist 1 year and someone worked there for 6 months, they're a veteran?
- zoover2020 5y agoRelative to the company, yes
- MobiusHorizons 5y agoIt’s not a technical term, so it’s always going to be somewhat of a matter of opinion. If I had to guess, you could only really be described as a veteran at some company if you had been there longer than most other employees. It seems like at least 60 or 70% of the employees should be newer.
- baitedandrated 5y ago
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoFair point. I just found it to be an interesting choice of words. Whenever they use the same term, in other industries, they are talking about double-digit tenures. The main point is that this is a fairly unambiguous message to other managers, that allowing unionization to happen under their watch would be a careericidal offense. That means that they can expect the warehouse managers to get pretty desperate, and probably break all kinds of laws and whatnot. It's just that the message is being sent in a way that allows the company to keep their hands clean, from the almost certain results. The managers will certainly get fired, if unionization happens, and might get fired, if they get caught, spiking the trees. Guess which path the managers are likely to take?
- tyingq 5y agoMy guess is that they didn't fire them for "letting it happen" exactly. They probably fired them because the employees would view those managers as someone they recently defeated over a major issue. Which changes the power dynamic in a way that's distinct from the presence of the union itself. It's a weak attempt to get some of that back.
- mola 5y agoOr maybe as an example for other managers? Basically it's "no union" or your head... Disgusting anyway.
- tyingq 5y agoI'm skeptical, because it seems like most of the anti-union activities are either dictated or run from HDQ. It doesn't feel like something where the local leadership was free to make their own plays.
- bostonsre 5y agoThe fact that a unionization vote was happening would have been more than enough to start an investigation into management and firing management before the vote due to bad practices could have prevented the unionization vote from being passed. I'm not sure it matters much how much leeway the managers actually had in preventing unionization from happening. Amazon has been extremely cold hearted and calculating with the management of their logistics infrastructure. They are managing (ruling) by fear, not love. They could easily have prevented unionization by treating their employees like human beings and not robots, but they chose to go the dystopian route of extreme monitoring and pushing their employees to work as hard as possible. It almost feels like a move that Putin and other dictators would pull. They shift blame to those that are relatively powerless in middle management and make an example of them even though the fault lies with those at the top.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> It doesn't feel like something where the local leadership was free to make their own plays. Firing managers where unionization happens encourages managers where unionization efforts are under way to make their own plays, whether this is formally allowed or not, whether by company policy or the law. Obviously, getting caught on independent, policy/law-forbidden, efforts would also have adverse consequences, so the incentive also is to not get caught.
- someweirdperson 5y ago"fired"? don't they have time limited contracts, that include a golden parachute in case of early termination? Does Amazon manage to even treat senior managers badly?
- blamazon 5y agoSenior warehouse manager =\= Senior corporate manager
- Ekaros 5y agoPart of middle-management with very little power outside following corporate policies. Might be able to do something not outright sanctioned, but the position really isn't much different from the workers in grand scheme of things.
- rootusrootus 5y agoI don't think any manager at the warehouse level is senior enough to have a golden parachute.
- bostonsre 5y agoThey are just another set of expendable cogs in the logistics machine of Amazon. They are incentivized to enact and enforce harsh management practices on those cogs further down the line while being subject to similar constraints coming from above them. Shit rolls down hill so they don't get the worst of it, but they are nowhere near the top of the hill and they still have to handle a miserable amount of it.
- joshe 5y agoTo me a more reasonable explanation than any in the article is that after losing the vote, Amazon looked into the warehouse and decided part of the problem was that the managers were making the situation worse. This could have been that the rsi injury complaints were true and unaddressed promptly. Or that the managers came off as cold in communications. Or 5 other things they could have done better.
- jollybean 5y agoIn Amazon's purview, 'the problem' is that the 'union was formed'. It's a signal to the managers of the other warehouses that if a union is formed on their watch, they are toast.
- rolandog 5y agoWouldn't it be ironic that this makes Senior Managers realize it's in their best interest to join a union?
- stormbrew 5y agoMost unions don’t allow managers to join, as they’re generally considered to be part of capital’s collective bargaining side, if not part of capital themselves. I think most modern labor theory includes a “professional-managerial class” to account for this. There’s an argument to be had about where this line makes sense in modern megacorps but local managers in blue collar work tend to hold a lot of power over their employees in particular regardless of the shape of the corporation they’re under, so it would be surprising if they could. Edit: fair points in the replies about management unions and that I was focused on a North American perspective. I was interpreting the post I replied to as saying the managers would join the union (as in the same one), but they didn't actually say that. I can definitely believe that things would be different in a less union-adversarial environment. But it's still pretty unlikely that warehouse bosses at amazon would be welcome in the same union as the workers, or be likely to manage to unionize themselves successfully. The incentives just don't really align well in this context: corporate has too many carrots and sticks.
- fyrn- 5y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20220506173540/https://www.nytimes.com/2022/05/06/technology/amazon-fires-managers-union-staten-island.html/ https://web.archive.org/web/20220506173540/https://www.nytim...
- GeorgeTirebiter 5y agoThe correct answer to the Amazon Problem is to create an alternate organization that starts as a unionized workplace, and goes from there. E.g. Spain's https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mondragon_Corporation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mondragon_Corporation These problems mentioned in this thread are due to the greed of Capitalists. Period. Once the 'age of the Capitalist' is put behind us, and we move towards post-capitalism, then bs like OP mentions will be history.
- egypturnash 5y agoWhy is “spending 70 years growing a collective workplace to huge scale” more correct than “unionizing a huge ultra-capitalist workplace that exists right now”? Both are laudable goals IMHO.
- GeorgeTirebiter 5y agoThey are, except one is actively being viciously suppressed, and the other already exists and is working great.
- egypturnash 5y agoGuess we'd better hop in the time machine and go back to 1950 to start the American equivalent of Mondragon to preemptively destroy Amazon before Bezos is even born, then.
- Mountain_Skies 5y agoWhat system follows capitalism?
- GeorgeTirebiter 5y agoThat's why I provided the Wikipedia URL. Here's a useful quote: "In 2012 Richard D. Wolff, an American professor of economics, hailed the Mondragon set of enterprises, including the good wages it provides for employees, the empowerment of ordinary workers in decision making, and the measure of equality for female workers, as a major success and cited it as a working model of an alternative to the capitalist mode of production." The other standard source for a critique of Capitalism is in the early works of Marx, especially https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Das_Kapital https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Das_Kapital . In Marx' later works, he gets a little cranky for my taste.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- newaccount2021 5y ago
- pkaler 5y agoIsn't this a good thing? If the workers were fed up enough with conditions that they formed a union, doesn't that imply the managers were terrible? Shouldn't terrible managers be fired? For example, my wife is a unionized nurse. The best thing that could happen at her work is for her manager to be fired. The union has no power in that. I'm an engineering manager at a software company. I get performance reviews twice per year. It's well understood that if I'm doing a terrible job that I will be fired.
- GoodJokes 5y ago
- vmception 5y agothat's an assumption. union existence should be tied to the perseverance of labor rights and collective bargaining power, not dissatisfaction. its mere coincidence that there is a correlation to workplace/compensation satisfaction and interest in a union.
- thaumaturgy 5y agoCounter-anecdotally, a friend of mine is one of the leaders of the Starbucks unionization efforts in Oregon, and they adore their store manager. The complaints that are driving those union efforts are the result of corporate policies and in no way related to specific stores. I can't say anything well-informed about Amazon specifically, but mega-corps tend to build lots of layers of middle management, then apply high-pressure incentive structures from the top that force middle management to do things that are unpopular with lower-level employees. When these policies inevitably backfire, it's the middle-management that gets axed for it.
- pessimizer 5y agoYou don't need a terrible manager to have a union. A union isn't an attack, it's a bunch of peers caucusing. That's anti-union rhetoric, the idea that if there's good management you don't need a union, and that having a union is some kind of insult.
- 5y ago
- linuxhansl 5y ago> The managers were told they were being fired as part of an “organizational change,” Nit: That language implies that they were laid off, not fired. The timing is a stupid move from Amazon, and these employees will likely be able to make a good case in court. Being from Europe I have mixed feelings about unions here in the US... On the one hand I think they are essential to tilt the uneven power dynamic between employer and employee towards the employee, and are thus dearly needed! On the other hand, unions seem to often go overboard with impractical demands and are more political than in Europe, which damaged their reputation - I think - and contributed to their demise over the past few decades. Which is truly a shame! (I'm reminded of alleged cases where only a union worker is allow to plug a power plug into an outlet at exorbitant prices. But this might a rumor too.) Any opinions here?
- bontaq 5y ago...What case in court?
- Kab1r 5y agoUnlawful Termination?
- lalaland1125 5y agoUnlawful termination for what?
- Kab1r 5y agoThe National Labor Relations Act prohibits employers from firing employees for participating in union activities.
- ganoushoreilly 5y agoI don’t believe they were a part of forming or attempting to form the union, but we’re the management of the facility. Maybe I misread it. Maybe they have a claim because it’s highly likely they were let go because they did squash the attempts at forming a union?
- jeffrallen 5y agoIt's time for the corporate death penalty. God, Amazon is so evil.